Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Judgment reserved on: 20.12.2025
Judgment pronounced on:16.01.2026
Judgment uploaded on:17.01.2026
+
CO.APP. 29/2023, CM APPL. 66051/2023, CM APPL.
11786/2024, CM APPL. 21188/2024, CM APPL. 33070/2024,
CM APPL. 12608/2025, CM APPL. 30563/2025, CM APPL.
56756/2025
V.K. SHARMA
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. Rajeev Bhalla, Senior
Advocate with Mr. Rakesh
Kumar, Mr. Anjaneya Mishra,
Mr. Sahil Yadav, Mr. Nidhish
Gupta, Mr. Faizeen Hussain
Khan, Mr. Shubham Bhalla,
Ms. Gauri Bedi, Ms. Neha
Verma and Mr. Aman Khatri,
Advocates.
versus
JVG FINANCE LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION)
.....Respondent
Through: Mr. Gaurav Gupta, Senior
Standing Counsel for Income
Tax Department.
Ms. Ruchi Sindwani, Senior
Standing Counsel with Ms.
Megha Bharara, Advocate for
Official Liquidator.
Mr. Ankur Mittal and Mr.
Aviraj Pandey, Advocates for
Intervenor/Applicant in CM
APPL. 21188/2024
Mr. Sandeep Sethi and Mr.
Aseem
Chawla,
Senior
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
CO.APP. 29/2023 & connected matter
15:01:52
Advocates with Mr. Rishabh
Jain, Ms. Pratishtha Chaudhary
and Mr. Saksham Arya,
Advocates for Respondent No.
2.
+
CO.APP. 11/2024
ABR EMERALD LLP
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. Mukul Gupta, Sr. Adv.
with Mr. Aayush Agarwala,
Mr. Anuj P. Agarwala, Mr.
Sumit Mishra & Mr. Vipul
Singh, Advs.
versus
THE OFFICIAL LIQUIDATOR & ANR.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Gaurav Gupta, Senior
Standing Counsel for Income
Tax Department.
Ms. Ruchi Sindwani, Senior
Standing Counsel with Ms.
Megha Bharara, Advocate for
Official Liquidator.
Mr. Sandeep Sethi and Mr.
Aseem
Chawla,
Senior
Advocates with Mr. Rishabh
Jain, Ms. Pratishtha Chaudhary
and Mr. Saksham Arya,
Advocates for Respondent No.
2.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL KSHETARPAL
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HARISH VAIDYANATHAN
SHANKAR
JUDGMENT
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.
1.
By way of this common Order/Judgment, the two Company
Appeal (Co. App.) nos. 29/2023 and 11/2024, challenging the orders
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
CO.APP. 29/2023 & connected matter
15:01:52
passed by the learned Company Judge [hereinafter referred to as
„LCJ‟] on 30.11.2023 and 29.02.2024, in the Company Petition (Co.
Pet.) Nos. 265/1998 and 113/2014, respectively, shall stand disposed
of.
2.
At the outset it is clarified that the challenge in both the
Appeals arises out of the sale of property bearing no. 51, Street No.7,
MIDC, Andheri, Mumbai [hereinafter referred to as „subject
property‟], by way of auction and its subsequent bidding thereof,
belonging to the JVG Group of Companies, which is undergoing
liquidation at the behest of Reserve Bank of India (RBI) [hereinafter
referred to as „Company in liquidation/CIL‟].
3.
Co. App. 29/2023 has been filed by the ex-director/promoter of
the CIL, challenging the impugned order dated 30.11.2023
[hereinafter referred to as „IO of 2023‟], vide which the Co. Appl. No.
829/2023 in Co. Pet. 265/1998, filed on behalf of the Official
Liquidator (OL), was allowed. The LCJ, vide the IO of 2023, allowed
the OL to take requisite steps for the sale of the subject property at the
rate of Rs. 88.90 crores on account of deficiency of funds with the OL,
alongwith a direction to sell the property by way of auction through
RailTel Corporation of India Limited [hereinafter referred to as
„RCIL‟].
4.
Co. App. 11/2024 has been filed by a subsequent bidder, who
failed to participate in the aforesaid auction, and contends that he is
willing to offer a higher amount against the sale of the subject
property. By way of this Appeal, the Appellant seeks to challenge the
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
CO.APP. 29/2023 & connected matter
15:01:52
impugned order dated 29.02.2024 [hereinafter referred to as „IO of
2024‟], whereby the LCJ dismissed the Appellant‟s application
seeking to set-aside the e-auction conducted on 09.01.2024 in respect
of the subject property.
BRIEF FACTUAL MATRIX:
5.
The genesis of the present proceedings lies in the regulatory
intervention initiated by RBI in October 1997, whereby the CIL was
restrained from accepting fresh deposits or alienating its assets.
Following which, in June 1998, filing of a compulsory winding-up
petition took place leading to appointment of a provisional OL to take
over the CIL‟s assets against the grave findings of fraudulent conduct
and large-scale financial impropriety.
6.
In January 2003, the Bombay High Court directed that the
subject property be handed to OL, Mumbai. Thereafter, the aforesaid
order was recalled in the year 2018 and the OL, Delhi was handed
over the possession of the subject property. Following the valuation of
the subject property in 2023, the LCJ vide IO of 2023 approved its
sale by public auction at a reserve price of Rs. 88.90 crores. Following
which the auction was conducted on 09.01.2024, resulting into a sole
and successful bid by M/S Beekalene Fabrics Private Limited
[hereinafter referred to as „BFPL‟] at the fixed reserve price, pursuant
to which 25% of the sale consideration stood duly deposited.
7.
Subsequently, the present two appeals came to be filed before
this Court, the Co. App. 11/2024, was dismissed by the predecessor
bench on 30.04.2024, however, the said order was challenged by the
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
CO.APP. 29/2023 & connected matter
15:01:52
Appellant before the Supreme Court by way of SLP (C) Nos. 1097910980/2024. The Supreme Court vide its Order dated 14.05.2024
restored the appeal with a direction to the LCJ to examine the
adequacy of the bid offered by BFPL, and further directed the
Appellant to deposit 30% of the offered bid amount, pursuant to
which the Appellant would be at a liberty to raise its claim. It is in this
procedural and factual continuum that the present appeals fall for
consideration of this Court.
8.
Before proceeding to examine the rival submissions made by
the parties in Co. App. 29/2023, we deem it necessary to note that,
although extensive arguments have been made by parties in Co. App.
11/2024, a perusal of the Supreme Court Order dated 14.05.2024,
shows that the question pertaining to adjudication of the adequacy of
the bid amount offered by BFPL against the sale of subject property
was left open for adjudication by the Company Court. The relevant
portion of the order dated 14.05.2024 is reproduced hereinbelow:
“It is an accepted position that the bid given by respondent no. 2Beekalene Fabrics Pvt. Ltd. has not been accepted. Respondent
no. 2 – Beekalene Fabrics Pvt. Ltd. has, however, deposited 25%
amount.
The issue whether or not the bid given by respondent no. 2Beekalene Fabrics Pvt. Ltd. should be accepted, it being adequate
bid for the property in question etc., has not yet been considered
by the Company Court.
In these circumstances, in order to balance out the equities, we set
aside the impugned judgment dated 30.04.2024, subject to the
condition that the appellant – ABR Emerald LLP will deposit 30%
of the proposed price, which they have offered, that is 10% above
the bid given by respondent no. 2 – Beekalene Fabrics Pvt. Ltd.,
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
CO.APP. 29/2023 & connected matter
15:01:52
within a period of fifteen days from today. Interim order dated
09.04.2024 passed by the High Court will also accordingly stand
set aside.
Only if the deposit is made, the appellant-ABR Emerald would be
heard by the Company Court. In case the deposit is not made, the
appellant – ABR Emerald LLP would not be entitled to any
hearing by the Company Court, In that case, it will also open to
the Company Court to impose costs on the appellant – ABR
Emerald LLP.”
In substance, the Supreme Court while noting that the bid amount
offered by BFPL, has yet not been accepted by the LCJ, granted
liberty to the Appellant to be heard by the LCJ subject to the deposit
of 30% of the offered amount. In view thereof, the Co. App. 11/2024
is disposed of, granting liberty to the parties thereof, to advance their
arguments before the LCJ.
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES IN CO.APP. 29/2023:
9.
This Court has heard learned counsels for the parties at length
and, with their able assistance, perused the paper book.
10.
At the outset, it is contended by the learned counsels for BFPL
and the OL that the present appeal is not maintainable, as the
Appellant, being an ex-director and a part of the erstwhile
management, lacks locus standi to challenge the transactions
concerning the assets of CIL. It is further argued that the Appellant
cannot assert any rights over the assets of the CIL since the same has
now been entrusted to the OL under statutory mandate.
11.
Per contra, it has been argued by the Appellant that, being the
ex-director and contributory of the CIL, he cannot be treated as a
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
CO.APP. 29/2023 & connected matter
15:01:52
stranger to the present dispute. Additionally, it has been argued that a
revival scheme bearing CA(M) No. 1/2023, has already been filed
before the Company Court, pursuant to which notice has been issued
vide order dated 01.06.2023. Reliance is also placed on the
observations of this Court in Co. App. No. 1/2017 titled V.K. Sharma
& Anr. v NEMO, wherein it was held that ex-directors of the
company under liquidation would have a stake in the assets of the
company being available to pay the creditors.
12.
This Court has heard the parties on the preliminary objection
regarding the maintainability of the present Appeal. In this context,
reference is made to the order dated 16.11.2018 passed by the
Division Bench of this Court in Co. App. 24/2018 titled as V.K.
Sharma v Official Liquidator & Ors., vide which the appeal,
preferred by the Appellant herein, challenging the order dated
12.10.2018 in Co. Pet. 265/1998 was dismissed. The Bench upon
considering the arguments made therein, held that the Appellant,
being an ex-management of the CIL, had failed to establish his locus
standi to maintain the appeal in his individual capacity. The relevant
paragraph of the aforesaid order is reproduced hereinbelow:
“4. Mr. Neeraj Malhotra, learned Senior Counsel, who is appearing on
behalf of the Appellant, is unable to show any provision of law, either
in the Companies Act or elsewhere permitting a former Director to
question in his individual capacity the order passed by Company
Court in winding up proceedings, dealing with the claims of creditors.
In other words, this Court is not shown what the locus standi of the
Appellant is in preferring this appeal.”
13.
In the present proceedings, this Court is of the opinion that the
objection as to the locus standi of the Appellant raises a serious and
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
CO.APP. 29/2023 & connected matter
15:01:52
arguable issue. However, this Court consciously refrains from delving
deeply into the said objection, since the merits of the present appeal
can conclusively lead to the present matter being disposed of.
Nonetheless, having regard to the aforesaid, and taking into
consideration the order dated 16.11.2018 as well as the arguments
advanced by the Appellant, this Court is of the view that the Appellant
has again failed to clearly establish his locus and, as such, does not
possess the requisite locus to maintain the present appeal.
Notwithstanding the aforestated and without expressing any final
determination on the issue of maintainability, this Bench now
proceeds to examine the arguments advanced by the parties on the
merits of the case.
14.
While controverting the findings of the IO of 2023, the
Appellant has made the following submissions on the merits of the
case:
14.1 Relying on T. Narayanan v The Official Liquidator & Ors.
[2010 (2) CTC 411], it is contended that the assets of the CIL cannot
be alienated merely to provide for contingent, speculative or yet to be
adjudicated liabilities. It is their case that liquidation of valuable
immovable assets, in the absence of crystallised liability, is contrary to
settled principles governing winding-up proceedings.
14.2 The Court‟s attention was further drawn to the additional
affidavit dated 05.01.2024 filed by the OL, to argue that even after
accounting for all admitted liabilities, a sum of Rs. 13,14,64,333/remains available with the Official Liquidator, sufficient to meet
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
CO.APP. 29/2023 & connected matter
15:01:52
security expenses and other incidental costs, thereby negating any
immediate financial exigency warranting sale of the subject property.
14.3 Further, it is contended that auctioning of the property in
question is completely unjustified and premature. It has been argued
that the LCJ failed to explore less intrusive alternatives, including the
auction of other assets of the company, particularly land admeasuring
approximately 65 acres situated at Gurgaon, valued at around Rs. 56
crores which, according to the Appellant, could have adequately met
the stated financial requirements. Additionally, it has been argued that
the LCJ has also failed to examine the chart stated to have been
produced during the course of arguments.
14.4 Lastly, reliance is placed upon the OL‟s Report dated
11.09.2023, which records that claims already adjudicated and
awaiting disbursement aggregate to only about Rs. 5,00,00,000/-,
whereas available funds with the OL stand at Rs. 7,44,97,006/-. This,
it is argued, further reinforces the submission that the impugned sale
was unnecessary and unwarranted at the relevant point in time.
15.
Per contra, BFPL while controverting the arguments advanced
by the Appellant on the merits of the case, has made the following
submissions:
15.1 It has been argued that the winding-up was necessitated by
regulatory and statutory imperatives whereas the attempts by the
Appellant to revive the company through schemes of arrangement
remain rejected or pending, opposed by multiple stakeholders
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
CO.APP. 29/2023 & connected matter
15:01:52
including the RBI, the OL, and other financial institutions. It is further
contended that no stay is operative against the ongoing liquidation.
15.2 Further, it has been submitted that the Appellant, whose tenure
was marked by financial mismanagement, cannot circumvent the
consequences of insolvency by filing revival proposals or challenging
lawful asset realization. It has been contended that the RBI has
mandated that unclaimed investor deposits must be transferred to the
Investor Protection Fund, representing liabilities exceeding Rs. 118
crores.
15.3 Lastly, it has been argued that admittedly the total investor
claims exceed Rs. 550 crores, whereas as evidenced by the OL the
existing funds are insufficient to satisfy creditors and statutory dues
exceeding Rs. 443 crores.
ANALYSIS:
16.
Having heard the rival submissions advanced by the learned
counsel for the parties and upon careful consideration of the material
on record, this Court on the issue of financial exigencies, notes that it
is clear that outstanding liabilities, including those to statutory bodies,
financial creditors, and investor deposits, far exceed the available
funds. The auction proceeds are essential to discharge claims and
ensure protection of public deposits. The Appellant cannot obstruct
the lawful discharge of these obligations under the guise of alleged
surplus funds or delay in crystallization of claims.
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
CO.APP. 29/2023 & connected matter
15:01:52
17.
As far as the extraneous matters are concerned, any attempt by
the Appellant to traverse into unrelated schemes of revival lies outside
the scope of company law proceedings and is impermissible. The
liquidation process and asset realization must proceed unimpeded.
18.
The arguments advanced by the learned counsel for the
Appellant lacks substance, since the LCJ has merely permitted the
auction of one of the properties located in Mumbai. Notably, two
properties belonging to CIL situated at Baghpat and Mumbai, have
already been sold in order to discharge the liabilities of CIL. As per
the CM Appl. 11786/2024 filed by OL on 06.02.2024, the total
liabilities of company in liquidation exceed Rs. 470 crores. The
relevant paragraphs of the said application are reproduced
hereinbelow:
“7. That upon invitation of claims, the Official Liquidator had
received the following claimsClaimant
No.
Claims
Financial
Depositor
Secured Creditor
(State Bank of
Patiala)
Un-secured
Creditors
Preferential Creditor
Income Tax
Sales Tax
EPFO
Total
of
Amount
71677
71,91,00,365/-
Rs. 1,43,00,000 /-
Rs. 3,50,00,000/-
71702
350,51,80,581/138317270/1,81,52,455/443,00,50,671/-
8. That out of the said claims, the amount payable to the EPFO,
Income Tax and Sales Tax, being an amount of Rs. 366,16,50,306/is payable in full, since the Official Liquidator cannot adjudicate a
claim raised in pursuance of a adjudication order of a statutory
authority. However, the Official Liquidator has filed an appeal
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
CO.APP. 29/2023 & connected matter
15:01:52
against the assessment order passed by the Income Tax
Department, wherein no stay has been sought by the Official
Liquidator, since that would require a pre-deposit of 20%, in terms
of Office Memorandum dated 31.07.2017, F.No. 404/72/93-ITCC,
issued by the Central Board of Direct Taxes which amounts to
about Rs. 70 crores.
9. That the amounts payable to the financial depositors which has
already been directed to be paid is as follows a) 555 Claims for Rs.72,80,097 /b) Rs.3,78,50,382 /- being balance amount to be paid to claimants
whose claims have been admitted and had earlier received payment
The Company-in-Liqn. Has an amount of Rs. 6.56 Cr. available as
on 05.02.2024.
10. That the Official Liquidator had received 71677 claims,
amounting to Rs.71,91,00,365/-, from various depositors of the
Company-in-Liqn. Out of which 15784 claims were admitted and
against the said claims, an amount of Rs.22,24,63,702/- was
quantified as the amount payable upto the date of appointment of
the provisional liquidator. However, the said claimants are entitled
to be paid upto the date of winding up and a further sum of Rs.
17.30 crores will be payable to the said investors.
11. That the Official Liquidator had received a total of 71766
claims for a total value of Rs. 72.39 crores and out of the said
claims, about 46484 claims, for an amount of Rs. 43,31,62,372/have been technically rejected, and the Official Liquidator, by way
of the reply to Co.Appl. (M) 1 of 2023 (being the revival scheme
filed by the Appellant) and OLR 105 of 2023, has submitted that
the said amount is to be provisioned for and it is submitted that the
said amount is payable It is submitted that the Official Liquidator
has to raise the said amount and even if the said claimants are not
traceable, the said amount is to be transferred into the Companies
Liquidation Account, maintained by the Reserve Bank of India, in
terms of Section 555 of the Companies Act, 1956, It is submitted
that as per the record, the Company-in-Liqn. had deposits of Rs. 88
crores, as on 31.03.1996, and most of the claims are of small
depositors, who may not have been able to pursue their claims or
may not have informed their new address to the Official Liquidator,
and therefore, the aforesaid claims have not been adjudicated by
the committee on merits and the said claims ought to be
adjudicated on merits and a provision has to be made by the
Official Liquidator to safeguard the interests of the said creditors.
12. That further, the Reserve Bank of India, in its reply to the
scheme of revival filed by the Appellant herein, has stated that the
Company-in-Liqn and other companies, being JVG Leasing Ltd.
and JVG Securities Ltd have a liability of Rs.118.99 crores towards
public deposits. It is submitted that the Official Liquidator has
received claims for about Rs. 72.39 crores, and the balance liability
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
CO.APP. 29/2023 & connected matter
15:01:52
towards public deposits, being a sum of about Rs. 46.6 crores, is
required to be deposited into the Investor Education And Protection
Fund, in terms of Section 205C of the Companies Act, 1956 and
Section 45QA of the Reserve Bank of India Act, which has also
been stated by the RBI in its reply to the scheme. The said amount
is immediately payable to RBI.
14. That accordingly, the following sums are immediately
payable–
19.
Head under which payable
Admitted amount to admitted claimants from
05.06.1998 (PL appointment) to 29.08.2003
(OL appointment)
Amount payable to claimants whose claims
were rejected on technical grounds (This
amount will also have to calculated upto date
of winding up and will accordingly increased.
Balance liability towards public deposits,
required to be deposited into the Investor
Education And Protection Fund, in terms of
Section 205C of the Companies Act, 1956
and Section 45QA of the Reserve Bank of
India Act,
Amount payable to statutory creditors - the
EPFO, Income Tax and Sales Tax
Amount
Rs. 17.30 crores approx
TOTAL
Rs. 473.37 crores
Rs. 43,31,62,372 / -
Rs. 46.6 crores
Rs. 366,16,50,306/(Amount for stay Rs. 70
crores)
Moreover, there is no dispute with respect to the subject
property located in Mumbai. It is also pertinent to note that the sale of
the assets of the CIL has become imperative in order to discharge its
outstanding liabilities. In these circumstances, the various properties
of the CIL are required to be sold in accordance with law, and the
Appellant cannot be permitted to dictate or determine which of the
several properties is to be sold first or given priority in point of time.
20.
As far the as the argument raised by the Appellant, with respect
to the failure of the LCJ to refer to a chart produced during the course
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
CO.APP. 29/2023 & connected matter
15:01:52
of arguments, it is noted that mere failure to advert to the chart cannot,
by itself, constitute sufficient ground to set aside the IO of 2023,
particularly, when the perusal of record sufficiently establishes that
the financial requirement for meeting the liabilities of the CIL was
taken into consideration and duly examined.
21.
As is evident, the proceeding before the LCJ has remained
pending for the last 27 years. The Provisional Liquidator was
appointed as far back as in the year 1998, followed by the winding-up
order passed in 2003. Notably, the earlier scheme for revival of CIL
proposed by the former promoter has already been considered and
rejected. In view of the aforestated, this Bench is of the view that the
prolonged pendency of the matter highlights the necessity of bringing
the liquidation proceedings to its logical conclusion without any
further delay.
22.
Accordingly, this Court finds no merit in the contentions raised
by the Appellant in Co. App. 29/2023.
CONCLUSION:
23.
In view of the foregoing discussions, this Court is of the
considered view that the impugned orders need no interference.
24.
Resultantly, finding no merit, both the Appeals are dismissed.
Pending applications, if any, also stand closed.
25.
Needless to state that the observations made herein shall not be
construed as an expression of opinion on the rights of the parties to the
dispute, which are subject to examination by the Company Court
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
CO.APP. 29/2023 & connected matter
15:01:52
independently
and
uninfluenced
by
the
observations
made
hereinabove.
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.
HARISH VAIDYANATHAN SHANKAR, J.
JANUARY 16, 2026/sp/hr
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
CO.APP. 29/2023 & connected matter
15:01:52
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review