Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:2073
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
W.P.(S) No.5080 of 2022
-----Uttam Kumar, son of Late Ajit Bouri @ Ajit Kumar Bouri, resident of
Banberia, Palma, P.O. and P.S. Purulia, District Purulia, West Bengal.
… … Petitioner
Versus
1. M/s Bharat Coking Coal Limited, through its Chairman-cumManaging Director, office at Koyla Nagar, P.O. Koyla Nagar, P.S.
Saraidhela, District Dhanbad.
2. Chief Manager (P) MP & R, M/s Bharat Coking Coal Limited,
office at Koyla Nagar, P.O. Koyla Nagar, P.S. Saraidhela, District
Dhanbad.
3. The General Manager (Personnel), M/s Bharat Coking Coal
Limited, office at Koyla Nagar, P.O. Koyla Nagar, P.S. Saraidhela,
District Dhanbad.
4. Manager (Pers.) Bharat Coking Coal Limited, Burragarh Colliery,
P.B. Area, P.O. & P.S. Burragarh, District Dhanbad.
5. Project Officer, Bharat Coking Coal Limited, Burragarh Colliery,
P.B. Area, P.O. & P.S. Burragarh, District Dhanbad.
… … Respondents
-----CORAM
: SRI ANANDA SEN, J.
-----For the Petitioner(s) :
Ms. Moushmi Chatterjee, Advocate
For the Respondent(s):
Mr. Amit Kumar Das, Advocate
Ms. Kanishka Deo, Advocate
-----11/ 27.01.2026
By filing this writ petition, the petitioner has prayed for
the following reliefs:“for issuance of appropriate Writ or Writs,
direction or directions, order or orders to set
aside
the
Letter
No.BCCL/PBA/BGH/2022/165 dated 09-082022 (Annexure-5) issued by the Project
Officer,
Burragarh
Colliery,
P.B.
Area
whereby and whereunder Project Officer,
Burragarh Colliery, P.B. Area has withdrawn
the Compassionate Appoinment granted to
Petitioner on 04-06-2019, on the sudden
death of his father, after more than 3 years
on
the
ground
that
as
per
medical
2026:JHHC:2073
assessment of the age of the Petitioner on
25-03-2021, his age was 8 months 9 days
more than 35 years on the date of death of
employees on 03-06-2019;
AND
Petitioner further prays for issuance of
appropriate
Writ
or
Writs,
direction
or
directions, order or orders commanding the
concern Respondent to pay the Salary for the
period 04-06-2019 to till date because
petitioners have been working sincerely
under the Respondents but Respondents
have not paid any Salary/wages to the
petitioner till date.”
2.
Heard learned counsel representing the petitioner and
learned counsel representing the respondents.
3.
The facts are not disputed in this case. The father of this
petitioner namely Late Ajit Bouri @ Ajit Kumar Bouri, was an
employee of Bharat Coking Coal Limited (BCCL), who died in
harness on 03.06.2019.
3.1.
On account of death of father of this petitioner, the
petitioner was granted provisional appointment on the post of
“Trainee” vide Appointment Letter dated 04.06.2019. Thereafter the
petitioner joined and started working pursuant to the said
appointment.
3.2.
The age of the petitioner as per his Aadhar Card, Voter
Card and PAN card is 05.02.1988.
3.3.
The petitioner appeared before the Medical Board for his
Medical Examination on 18.03.2020 and 25.03.2021.
3.4.
Thereafter, the respondents vide Office Order bearing
2026:JHHC:2073
Reference No.BCCL/PBA/BGH/2022/165 dated 09.08.2022, has
withdrawn the compassionate appointment granted to the petitioner
after more than three years on the ground that as per the medical
assessment of the age of the petitioner on 25.03.2021, his age was
found to be more than 35 years on the date of death of his father.
4.
Learned counsel representing the petitioner submits that
his provisional appointment has wrongly been withdrawn by the
respondents by the impugned office order holding therein that the
petitioner was more than 35 years of age at the time of death of his
father. He further submits that the petitioner may be re-appointed
as he was less than 35 years of age as per his testimonials i.e.
Aadhar Card, Voter Card and PAN card, at the time of death of his
father as also at the time of being appointed provisionally.
5.
The issue as to what would be the age for grant of
compassionate appointment, when the midpoint is taken, as
calculated by the respondents, has been dealt with by this Court in
W.P.(S) No.2790 of 2020 (Nand Lal Soren Vs. Central
Coalfields Ltd. & Ors.). The said writ petition was allowed vide
order dated 02.04.2025. This Court while allowing the said writ
petition, referred to the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
the case of Ajay Kumar Dubey Vs. Central Coalfields Limited
& Ors. in (Civil Appeal No.(S). 908 of 2025) (decided on 21st
January, 2025), wherein it has been held that the opinion of the
Medical Board in assessing the age, cannot be said to be accurate.
5.1.
This Court further referred to the judgment of the
Division Bench of this Court rendered on 01.01.2010 in L.P.A.
2026:JHHC:2073
No.117 of 2010 (Md. Rahim Vs. Project Officer, Kuju Colliery
of CCL), wherein it was held that the compassionate appointment
cannot be denied on the ground of variation of age. It was also held
that there is always a possibility of error of plus minus two years in
age calculation.
5.2.
This
Court
also
referred
to
the
judgment
dated
10.02.2021 passed by the Division Bench of this Court in L.P.A.
No.687 of 2019 (Lilwa Bhuiyan Vs. Central Coalfields Limited
(C.C.L) & Ors.), wherein it has been held that since the provision
of compassionate appointment is a Social Security Scheme, the
same has to be interpreted in the light of object it intends to achieve
and in case of variation of age, the age which is favourable to the
applicant, has to be considered. It is necessary to quote para-7, 8,
9 & 10 of the judgment of Nand Lal Soren (supra), which reads as
follows:“7. Recently the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the
case of Ajay Kumar Dubey vs. Central
Coalfields Limited and Others in Civil Appeal
No.(S). 908 of 2025 decided on 21st January,
2025 has held that the opinion of the medical
board regarding age does not give accurate
estimation. In paragraphs 9 and 10 it was held as
under:“9. A Medical Board by using scientific
methods can never make an accurate
estimation of the age of a human being. It
is always an estimate which can never be
accurate.
10. In the present case, the relevant date
for deciding the age of the appellant is 31st
July, 2013. We have perused the certificate
of the Medical Board dated 10th December,
2014. The Medical Board has recorded that
the recommendation is based on physical
and radiological examination of the
appellant. It is not necessary to record
2026:JHHC:2073
detailed reasons to hold that it is unsafe to
make an accurate estimation of the age on
the basis of physical examination or
radiological examination or ossification
test. These methods have their own
limitations. In fact, the opinion of the
Medical Board records that the age of the
appellant as on 31st December, 2014 was
in between 35-40 years. Going by the said
opinion, in July 2013, it is quite possible
that the age of the appellant was less than
35 years.”
8.
Further the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the
aforesaid case also has held that the statements
made by the employee in the service records
cannot be treated as conclusive and in case the
respondents do not doubt the genuineness of the
School Leaving Certificate the same can be
accepted as valid proof of age. In para 11 it was
held as follows:“11. As no dispute has been raised
regarding genuineness of the school leaving
certificate dated 15th July, 2013, we find
that on the date on which the appellant’s
father was superannuated, the appellant’s
age was less than 35 years. The statements
made by his father while stating the family
particulars of the appellant cannot be
conclusive. Moreover, in none of these
statements, the precise date of birth of the
appellant has been mentioned by his
father.”
9.
Further a Coordinate Division Bench of this
Court in L.P.A. No.117 of 2010 (Md. Rahim Vs.
Project Officer, Kuju Colliery of CCL) has held
that the compassionate appointment cannot be
denied on the ground of variation of age. It was
observed that there always remains a possibility
of error of plus-minus two years in age calculation.
The petitioner was found to be little more than 35
years of age, which is evident from the averment
made in the counter affidavit in paragraph 20,
therefore, the petitioner must be given the benefit
of possibility of error in the medical board’s
assessment of age.
10. As N.C.W.A. is a social security scheme it has
to be construed liberally. This court in L.P.A.
2026:JHHC:2073
No.687 of 2019 (Lilwa Bhuiyan Vs. CCL & Ors)
disposed of on 10.02.2021, has observed that
since the provision of compassionate appointment
is a social security scheme it has to be interpreted
in the light of object it intends to achieve and in
case of variation in age, the age which is
favourable to the applicant has to be considered.
Thus, considering the aforesaid judgments
and the facts and circumstances of the case, I am
of the view that the lower limit of age assessed by
the Board should be considered which is 35 years
in this case. A person of 35 year is entitled to be
employed in the Company.”
6.
impugned
In view of the aforesaid facts and circumstances, the
Office
Order
bearing
Reference
No.BCCL/PBA/BGH/2022/165 dated 09.08.2022 (Annexure-5 to the
writ petition), is hereby quashed and set aside.
6.1.
The respondents are directed to consider the case of the
petitioner treating his age to be less than 35 years on the date of
death of his father (deceased employee), and pass an appropriate
order within four weeks from the date of receipt of copy of this order.
6.2.
Further, the respondents are directed to re-appoint the
petitioner, by issuing a letter / order to that effect to the petitioner.
7.
Accordingly, this writ petition is allowed. No order as to
costs.
8.
Pending interlocutory application, if any, stands disposed
of.
(ANANDA SEN, J.)
27th January, 2026
Prashant. Cp-2
Uploaded on 31.01.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review