Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
10.03.2026
M/L No.14
Court No.12
(gc)
FMA 1761 of 2025
CAN 1 of 2025
Utpal Mitra
Vs.
Union of India & Ors.
Mr. Raghunath Chakraborty,
Mr. Soumava Mukherjee
…..for the Appellant.
Mr. Pulakesh Bajpayee
…for the Respondents/UOI.
1. This appeal arises out of the judgment and order dated
August 8, 2025 passed by a learned Single Judge in
WPA 2293 of 2018.
The writ petition was filed for
direction
respondents/employer
upon
the
of
the
deceased husband of the writ petitioner (father of the
appellant), to pay a sum of Rs.1, Crore jointly or
severally towards compensation and/or damages for
committing
constitutional
tort.
The
arguments
advanced before the learned Single Judge were that an
ideal employer ought to have informed the family on
time about the entitlement of his wife towards death
benefits of the employee who died in harness.
petitioner
was
the
wife,
who
was
The writ
subsequently
substituted upon her death by the son.
It was
vehemently urged before the learned Judge that, at the
first instance, the authority refused to treat the death
as died in harness. The appellant had to approach the
Central Administrative Tribunal, the High Court and the
Supreme Court in order to establish the right to
extraordinary pension and compassionate appointment.
The
claim
for
extraordinary
pension
was
made
sometime in 2008. The employee expired in 1982 while
his date of superannuation was sometime in 1988.
Under such circumstances, it was urged that it was the
duty of the employer to pay the dues to the family on
the date of entitlement and grant compassionate
appointment without the family having to run from
pillar to post and having to face the harassment of
litigation.
2. It appears from the order of the learned Single Judge
that,
the
entire
background
of
the
case
was
meticulously considered. The Court recorded that, all
benefits including the extraordinary pensionary benefit
were awarded.
The Hon’ble Apex Court also awarded
interest on delayed payment of extraordinary pension at
the rate of 9% per annum on the differential amount
from the date of the application, sometime, in 2008.
Compassionate appointment was granted to the son.
The arguments before the learned Single Judge were
violation of Articles 14 and 21 of the Constitution of
India as also deprivation of the proprietary right under
Article 300A of the Constitution of India. The learned
Single Judge discussed the decision in Bhupendra
Nath Hazarika Vs. State of Assam reported at (2013)
2 SCC 516, on the point that the State, as a model
employer, was obligated to act fairly and in strict
adherence to the rules.
Similarly State of Haryana
Vs. Piara Singh reported at (1992) 4 SCC 118, was
discussed on the issue that the State, as a model
employer, must not exploit its employees, but must act
fairly, by upholding rule of law and by treating its
employees with dignity. Reference was also made to the
decision in Balram Gupta Vs. Union of India reported
at (1987) Supp SCC 228.
On the basis of these
decisions, Her Lordship proceeded to decide the claim of
the writ petitioner for compensation on the allegation
that the respondents had committed constitutional tort.
3. Reference was also made to the decision in Common
Cause Vs. Union of India reported at (1999) 6 SCC
667.
4. Her Lordship recorded that the original writ petitioner
(wife) was granted family pension in terms of Pension
Rules of 1972.
Thereafter, extraordinary pension in
terms of the Central Civil Services (Extraordinary
Pension) Rules, 1939 was also granted with effect from
the date as directed by the Court. Interest was provided
on the differential amount of pension, pursuant to the
direction of the Hon’ble Apex Court.
Her Lordship
observed that compensation could be awarded by the
Writ Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India, only when there had been a violation of the
fundamental right of a person, based on the principle of
strict liability.
granted
Her Lordship held that when Court
compensation
under
Article
of
the
Constitution of India, there had to be a public wrong,
for which the State had to be made liable. Negligence in
protecting the fundamental right of a person, was a
good ground for awarding compensation. Referring to
the decisions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court, Her
Lordship recorded that such compensation was not
akin to civil damages in private law, but was a broader
remedy, for breach of public duty, resulting in violation
of a fundamental right.
5. The Division Bench of the High Court, by the order
dated February 21, 2011, held that the Central Civil
Service (Extraordinary Pension) Rules, 1939 would be
applicable with retrospective effect from the date of
sanctioning of normal pension. Another Division Bench
allowed an interest at the rate of 12% per annum for a
period of four months.
Finally, the Hon’ble Supreme
Court by an order dated January 24, 2014 directed that
interest should be paid at the rate of 9% per annum
with effect from January 21, 2008, that is the date
when the writ petitioner first made the claim for
payment of extraordinary pension, and the amount
already received by the writ petitioner (appellant’s
mother) should be suitably adjusted. It is also a matter
of record that, the son of the deceased had been granted
compassionate appointment. Her Lordship was of the
view that, only because the authority rejected the claim
of the wife at various stages, that could not be treated
as intentional negligence and wilful inaction. The writ
petitioner would not be entitled to a public law remedy
for damages, on the principle of strict liability.
Her
Lordship recorded that the constant stand of the
respondents was that, the death of the employee did not
occur in discharge of his official duty and also the
deceased ought not to have used the vehicle which met
with an accident. Her Lordship was of the view that the
respondents were within their right to deny the claim.
There was no violation of Articles 14 and 21 of the
Constitution of India.
There was no gross negligence
and intentional inaction on the part of the respondents.
Reliance was placed on the decision of Sube Singh Vs.
State of Haryana reported at (2006) 3 SCC 178 to
establish that, a Writ Court could award compensation
for violation of rights guaranteed under Article 21 upon
answering the following questions:(a) Whether the violation of Article 21 was patent
and incontrovertible,
(b) Whether the violation was gross and a
magnitude to shock the conscience of the
Court,
(c) Whether there was any evidence of intentional
negligence and causing the death/harm to
the person (in specific to the case ‘custodial
torture’).
6. In other cases, the Writ Court may not compensate as
a public law remedy, but relegate the parties to the
appropriate forum. Thus, Her Lordship held that before
any compensation was awarded, such questions were
required to be answered. Her Lordship was of the view
that the Court could not attribute any tort of negligence
or intentional deprivation of the right of the writ
petitioner or failure of duty of the employer towards the
family of the deceased.
The delay in grant of
extraordinary pension was due to rejection of the claim
at the first instance.
In this intra-court appeal, the
scope for interference with the order of Her Lordship is
very limited. Her Lordship held that the writ petitioner
had abused the process of Court and she should be
made liable to pay cost. However, considering her age
and ailing condition, the Court restrained itself from
issuing any such adverse order.
7. Mr. Chakraborty, learned Advocate for the appellant
relies on the Universal Declaration of Human Rights
and Article 17 thereof, to substantiate that everyone
has a right to own property and no one shall be
arbitrarily
deprived
argument
on
of
such
property.
Developing
provision,
Mr.
his
Chakraborty
submitted that pension was the property of the family,
upon the death of the employee and the respondents
could not have deprived the appellant from enjoyment
of such property. This was an intentional violation of
the
constitutional
protections
guaranteed
to
the
appellant.
8. In our view, the pensionary benefits had been paid as
per the Pension Rules of 1972.
extraordinary
pension
was
The prayer for
rejected
with
reasons.
Ultimately, it was allowed by the High Court. Interest
was also allowed by the High Court for a period of four
months and the Hon’ble Apex Court ultimately granted
9%
interest
extraordinary
from
the
pension,
date
that
of
is,
application
from
for
upon
adjustment of the differential amount. Only because the
respondents
rejected
the
prayer
for
extraordinary
pension and the appellant had to go through a series of
litigations, that could not be a sole ground for the Writ
Court to award compensation on the principle of strict
liability. This is not a case of failure of public duty
towards a citizen. Such aspect has been rightly
considered by the learned Single Judge. With regard to
the observations against the appellant we are of the
view that these observations will not affect
any
proceeding, if the appellant approaches the appropriate
forum.
9. The proper course of action would have been to
approach the competent Civil Court by filing a suit for
damages, inasmuch as, the damages suffered by the
petitioner on account of harassment, mental agony,
delay, etc. will have to be quantified and proved by
leading evidence. The jurisdiction of the Writ Court to
award compensation are limited. The records must
demonstrate patent acts of negligence or failure of duty
towards a citizen by the State, which are absent in this
case.
10. In M.C. Mehta v. Union of India reported in (1987) 1
SCC 395, the Hon’ble Apex Court held that, to justify
the award of compensation, the infringement must be
gross, patent, incontrovertible and ex facie glaring.
11. Remedy of damages is an extraordinary remedy, and is
available when there is gross violation arising out of
deliberate action or malicious action resulting in
deprivation of life and personal liberty. We do not find
any illegality in the order impugned.
12. Accordingly, the appeal and the connected application
are dismissed.
13. The dismissal of the appeal will not prevent the
appellant from approaching the appropriate forum,
strictly in accordance with law.
14. We have not entered into the issue of limitation and
leave it open to the forum to decide such issue.
15. The observations of the learned Single Judge will not
prejudice any such proceeding.
16. There shall be no order as to costs.
17. Parties are to act on the server copy of this order.
(Shampa Sarkar, J.)
(Ajay Kumar Gupta, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review