Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF
%
DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on : 24th September 2026
Pronounced on : 05th October 2026
Uploaded on : 06th October 2026
#
CNR No. DLHC012505452015
+
MAC.APP. 440/2015
USHA GUPTA & ANR
Through:
versus
.....Appellant
Mr. Kartik Shankar, Adv with Ms.
Kanchan Shankar, Mr. Tungesh and
Ms. Manisha, Advocates.
YOGENDRA PAL SINGH & ANR (RELIANCE GENERAL
INSURANCE LTD)
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. A.K. Soni, Advocate for
Insurance Company.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANISH DAYAL
JUDGMENT
ANISH DAYAL, J.
1.
This appeal has been filed by the claimant seeking setting aside of
impugned judgment dated 26 th February 2015 passed by the Motor Accident
Claims
Tribunal,
East
District,
Karkardooma
Courts,
Delhi
(‘Tribunal/MACT’) in MAC Petition No.267/2011, whereby the claim of the
appellant/claimant was dismissed on the ground that claimant have not been
able to prove the involvement of the offending vehicle.
The Incident
2.
The accident occurred on 28 th April 2011 at about 11.30 p.m., when
Digitally Signed
MAC.APP.440/2015
By:MANISH KUMAR
14:39:57
the deceased going to his house at Vivek Vihar on his two-wheeler scooter
from Surya Nagar, reached near Vivekanand Mahila College. As per the
claim, a Maruti SX4 car bearing registration No. DL-3CBC-4399 (offending
vehicle), driven by Yogendra Pal Singh, hit the scooter. As a result of the
impact, he fell down and sustained injuries and subsequently succumbed to
his injuries on 04 th May 2011. FIR No. 142/2011 was registered at PS Vivek
Vihar.
Submissions of Counsels
3.
Mr. Kartik Shankar, counsel for claimant/appellant, in support of his
appeal, stated that there were certain undisputed facts viz. that Satish Kumar
Gupta did die in an accident which took place on 28 th April 2011, Yogendra
Pal Singh is the owner of the offending vehicle, and that the offending
vehicle was insured with respondent no.2.
4.
The Insurance Company raised an issue that the offending vehicle had
actually met with an accident on 28 th April 2011, but the accident was in a
different place. They presented the claim form from the insured, which
mentioned that the accident had happened with a tractor trolley and another
vehicle had hit them from behind.
5.
Mr. Kartik Shankar, counsel for claimant/appellant, drew attention of
this Court to order dated 20 th August 2011 passed during the MACT
proceedings where it was recorded that ‘since there is no dispute to the
involvement of the offending vehicle and to the fact that the offending vehicle
was covered with the insurance policy of respondent no.2 and deceased
Satish Kumar Gupta had suffered a fatal road accident by the involvement
of vehicle insured with respondent no.2/Insurance Company, an order under
Digitally Signed
MAC.APP.440/2015
By:MANISH KUMAR
14:39:57
Section 140 MV Act of a sum of Rs. 50,000/- for interim relief is separately
passed’. Counsel focused on the admission by the Insurance Company.
6.
It was further submitted that the owner the offending vehicle had
admitted that he was driving the vehicle and the notice under Section 133 of
the MV Act was given by the Investigating Officer (I.O.).
7.
Mr. A.K. Soni, counsel for the Insurance Company, essentially stated
that the impugned award had, however, proceeded to assess the testimony of
the alleged eyewitness PW2 and PW4 and then discarded the same due to
their being unreliable and inconsistent. It is submitted that the DD entry and
FIR did not initially disclose the registration number of the offending
vehicle, the name of its driver or the presence of any eye-witness. It is
contended that in a petition under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act,
negligence is required to be proved by the claimants.
8.
It is further contended that the testimonies of PW-2 and PW-4 suffer
from material contradictions and are rendered unreliable by the evidence of
R2W3, the General Manager of Sunshine Hotel, who stated that no
party/event had taken place at the hotel on 28 th April 2011. PW-4 admittedly
did not disclose to the police the make, colour or registration number of the
offending vehicle, despite stating that he had been informed of the same by
PW-2 at the spot and that the police had reached the hospital shortly
thereafter. PW-2 also disclosed the registration number only on 01st May
2011. The absence of any contemporaneous reference to the offending
vehicle, coupled with these material discrepancies, is therefore relied upon
to contend that its involvement in the accident was not established.
Digitally Signed
MAC.APP.440/2015
By:MANISH KUMAR
14:39:57
Analysis
9.
Mr. Kartik Shankar had procured the charge-sheet along with a
translation thereof, which was placed on record before this Court. It was
submitted that the offending vehicle finds mention in the charge-sheet upon
completion of the investigation. Counsel for the appellant/claimant also drew
attention to the photographs of the car after the accident and the claim form
submitted by the insured, that show that the damage to the car was at the
front and that there was no damage at the rear of the vehicle. This assumes
significance, in context of the assertion made by the Insurance Company that
the insured vehicle met with an accident at about 11:00 p.m. while travelling
from Mohan Nagar to Sahibabad, when it was coming from Delhi, and had
hit a tractor-trolley, following which another vehicle had also hit it from
behind. Registration number of neither the tractor-trolley nor the vehicle,
which allegedly hit the insured car from behind, was disclosed in the claim
form. The claim form was exhibited as Ex. R2W2/1 and was annexed with
the repair estimate dated 03 rd May 2011.
10.
Yet another testimony which the Insurance Company relied upon was
of R2W3, Pankaj Gupta, who was working in the Hotel Sunshine Park,
Surya Nagar, Ghaziabad. This was in context of the assertion made by PW2
and PW4 that they were all coming back from a marriage anniversary
function at Hotel Sunshine Park, Surya Nagar, Ghaziabad, which had been
organised a common friend, Rajinder Singhal. Satish Kumar Gupta was
travelling on a two-wheeler and PW2 (Ramesh Panchal) was coming in his
car, followed later by PW4 (Virender Gupta), who was the cousin of the
deceased.
11.
Mr. A.K. Soni contended that that R2W3 had stated that there was no
Digitally Signed
MAC.APP.440/2015
By:MANISH KUMAR
14:39:57
record of any party held by Rajinder Singhal on 28 th April 2011 and that the
hotel maintained a register of all the parties. However, it is noted that he had
not brought the record and merely made a statement, as was evident in his
cross-examination.
12. R2W4, the Investigating Officer, testified with regard to the
investigation record, inter alia, Ex. R2W4/1, which was the notice issued
under Section 133 of the Motor Vehicles Act. The endorsement on the said
notice had been made by Yogender Pal Singh.
13.
PW2, Ramesh Panchal, in his testimony, stated that on the night of
28th April 2011, they had all gathered at the place of Rajinder Singhal, where
the party of the anniversary was being held at Chander Vihar near Surya
Vihar. He stated that they were returning to their house from the Hotel
Sunshine Park, where the function was organized, and Satish Gupta had gone
earlier and he was following him in a car. At a distance, when Satish Gupta
took a right turn from the red light of Vivekanand College towards Vivek
Vihar Phase-II, he saw a car bearing registration No.DL-3CBC-4399, driven
at speed, which hit the scooter as a result of which scooter fell down. The
driver of the car came out to see what had happened and then he fled away.
14.
PW2 stated that he chased the car but he had escaped and then he
returned to the spot of the accident. In the meantime, other family members
had returned from the same function and they stopped and Satish Gupta was
taken to the hospital in the car of his cousin (Vijender). He stated he was very
disturbed and did not accompany him to the hospital. He did not have his
mobile phone. On 01st May 2011, he went to the police station and gave a
statement. In the cross-examination, he stated that he had gone to the
hospital, but no police official contacted him and he got recorded his
Digitally Signed
MAC.APP.440/2015
By:MANISH KUMAR
14:39:57
statement on 01st May 2011. He denied all suggestions that were put forth
that he had not seen the vehicle and was deposing falsely.
15.
PW4, Virender Gupta, testified that he was also in the celebration of
the anniversary of his cousin and her husband at Hotel Sunshine Park they
were all returning back home. When they reached the point where the
accident had taken place, he took injured/Satish Gupta in his Innova car and
admitted him in Max Hospital, Patparganj for treatment. In the crossexamination, he states that he did not know whether his statement was
recorded by police but he was orally questioned in the hospital by the police.
Police came to the hospital within 1 or 2 hours of the accident.
16.
PW4 stated he did not tell the police about the offending vehicle, its
number, colour or its make as his priority was to take his brother to the
hospital immediately. He did confirm that Ramesh Panchal had told him
about the make, colour and the number of the offending vehicle, but he did
not pay attention to it as he was involved in taking care of his cousin. He
stated that he had seen the offending car hitting his cousin from a distance of
about 100 to 200 metres, but could not make note of the number or make of
the car. He denied the suggestions that he was deposing falsely.
17.
Though the MACT has considered the testimonies of these witnesses
as not credible, the same have to be viewed from a different prism and in
conjunction with the other surrounding circumstances so as to join the dots.
18.
In the opinion of this Court, the following aspects would have to be
considered:
Digitally Signed
MAC.APP.440/2015
By:MANISH KUMAR
14:39:57
(i)
Both PW2 and PW4 are consistent in their testimonies as regards
where they were coming from and have furnished specific details
regarding the anniversary function at the hotel.
(ii)
Both of them were also aligned on the fact that the family and
friends were all coming back and the distance was only about half
to one kilometre and that Satish Gupta was riding ahead of them.
While PW2 was immediately following Satish Gupta, PW4 was
about 100-200 meters behind. Naturally PW2 saw the accident,
chased the vehicle and noted the offending vehicle’s number and
then told it to PW4. The same is also corroborated by the testimony
of PW4. PW2 also stated that he let PW4 take the deceased to the
hospital which PW4 also confirms in his testimony.
(iii)
PW2 thereafter stated that he did not go to the hospital and
subsequently made a statement on 01 st May 2011, two days later.
This cannot be considered unusual considering the fact that the
Satish Gupta had received grievous injuries and had to go through
immediate emergency medical procedure. As per the MLC and post
mortem report, he was admitted on 29th April 2011 at 12:10 a.m. and
was finally passed away on 04th May 2011. Therefore, there was
sense of urgency in the family to take care of him first and,
therefore, it is quite possible that they did not report it to the police.
The reporting to the police did happen on 01 st May 2011, just a day
later.
(iv)
As regards why the registration number of the offending vehicle
was not mentioned in the FIR, which may appear unusual, the same
could possibly be attributed to an omission or lapse on the part of
Digitally Signed
MAC.APP.440/2015
By:MANISH KUMAR
14:39:57
the Investigating Officer. In any event, the details of the offending
vehicle are recorded in the charge-sheet.
(v)
As regards the damage to the offending vehicle, it is pertinent to
note that the owner of the vehicle, in response to the notice under
Section 133 of the Motor Vehicles Act, admitted that he owned the
car which was involved in the accident. However, a claim form was
subsequently filed stating that the accident had occurred elsewhere,
where the vehicle had hit the rear of a tractor-trolley and was
thereafter hit by another car from behind. The photographs annexed
with the claim form, however, do not show any damage to the rear
portion of the vehicle and instead show damage only to its front
portion. The nature of the damage is consistent with a collision
involving the front of the vehicle, possibly with a two-wheeler, as
in the present case. It would, therefore, appear that the claim form
was filed to cover the involvement of the vehicle and to put forward
a different version of the accident.
19.
Counsel for appellant has relied upon the decision of Supreme Court
in Firoz Khan Akbarkhan v. State of Maharashtra 2025:INSC:387,
wherein it has been laid down that delay in recording an eye witness’s
testimony would not draw an adverse influence, if the delay is adequately
explained. Also, in Goutam Joardar v. State of W.B., (2022) 17 SCC 549,
the Supreme Court held that the mere factum of delay in recording the
testimonies of eyewitness cannot result in rejection of their testimonies.
20.
Moreover, it cannot be denied that negligence has to be proved on
preponderance of probabilities and not beyond reasonable doubt. It is not
denied that the charge sheet had been filed and there is nothing on record to
Digitally Signed
MAC.APP.440/2015
By:MANISH KUMAR
14:39:57
state that a protest petition had been filed.
21.
As regards the FIR, it is noted that it was registered on the basis of one
PCR call and the statement was finally made on 01st May 2011. Reliance is
placed on Kuncham Lavanya v. Bajaj Allianz General Insurance Co. Ltd.,
2025 SCC OnLine SC 749 where it is stated as under:
“17. The very fact that the case was registered against
an unknown vehicle initially would indicate that the
offending vehicle was not identified. However, since an
FIR is not expected to be encyclopaedic2 and is only for
the purpose of putting into motion criminal law such
that thorough and full-fledged investigation by the
police ensues, it is the duty of the investigating agency
to find out the identity of the culprit which in the present
case would be the offending car and driver and take
action in accordance with law. Thus, the mere fact that
initially the FIR records the vehicle as unknown would
not be fatal for the prosecution/claimants to later come
up with the specific identity of the vehicle/driver, with
the obvious caveat that the connection of the accident
with the said vehicle has to be based on cogent and
reliable evidence. In the present case, the factor in
favour of the Insurance company is that the conduct of
the so-called eye-witness (PW2/U.V. Atriya), who was a
consumer at a paan-shop, gives his statement to the
police about two and a half months after the accident
disclosing the registration number of the offending
vehicle. This raises serious doubts on the authenticity
thereof as he states that he had noted it on a piece of
paper and when he again visited the spot after 15 days,
he came to know that the injured had passed away but
even after lapse of the said 15 days, he neither informed
the paan-shop owner nor produced/handed over the chit
of paper to the police on which he claims the
registration number of the offended vehicle was noted .”
(emphasis added)
Digitally Signed
MAC.APP.440/2015
By:MANISH KUMAR
14:39:57
22.
Reliance on the testimony of R2W3, Pankaj Gupta from Hotel
Sunshine Park, may not be tenable considering he did not get any records
with himself and was only making a statement and was a witness summoned
by the Insurance Company. As against his testimony, there were testimonies
of both PW2 and PW4 with corroborating details of the function they had
attended.
23.
The MLC notes that the accompanying person, to the injured, is Mr. V.
K. Gupta. The history is of a road traffic accident at 11.30 p.m. near Mahila
College at Vivek Vihar. The Mechanical Inspection Report of Maruti SX4 car
also shows that there was a left front side windscreen glass dented and has
been painted freshly and that the car repaired and painted freshly on the front
number plate and some marks on the front grille. The mechanical inspection
was conducted on 11 th May 2011. This also dilutes and erodes the assertion
that the vehicle was involved in an accident where it collided from both the
front and the rear.
24. It is well settled by a catena of judgments of the Supreme Court that
claims under the Motor Vehicles Act are to be established on the touchstone
of preponderance of probabilities and not beyond reasonable doubt. Where
the evidence renders one version more probable than not, the claimant’s
burden stands discharged. Reliance in this regard may be be placed on the
judgment of Bimla Devi v. Himachal RTC, (2009) 13 SCC 530, which was
subsequently followed in Geeta Dubey v. United India Insurance Co. Ltd.,
2024 SCC OnLine SC 3779. The relevant paragraph of Bimla Devi (supra)
is extracted as below:
“15. In a situation of this nature, the Tribunal has rightly
taken a holistic view of the matter. It was necessary to
Digitally Signed
MAC.APP.440/2015
By:MANISH KUMAR
14:39:57
be borne in mind that strict proof of an accident caused
by a particular bus in a particular manner may not be
possible to be done by the claimants. The claimants were
merely to establish their case on the touchstone of
preponderance of probability. The standard of proof
beyond reasonable doubt could not have been applied.
For the said purpose, the High Court should have taken
into consideration the respective stories set forth by both
the parties.”
(emphasis supplied)
25.
The Supreme Court in M. Siddiq v. Suresh Das, (2020) 1 SCC 1,
discussed that preponderance is decided based on test of prudent man.
Preponderance is when, basis the evidence an event is more probable than
not, and the burden stands discharged. There is no need to reach certainty,
but must carry a high degree of probability.
26. What transpires from the testimony and evidence, assessed above, is
that the testimonies of PW2 and PW4, when read together with the MLC,
the mechanical inspection report, the notice under Section 133 of the MV
Act and the charge sheet, sufficiently corroborate the involvement of the
offending vehicle in the accident. The discrepancies regarding the initial nondisclosure of the registration number in the FIR and the subsequent recording
of the statements of the eyewitnesses do not, in the facts and circumstances
of the present case, outweigh the other corroborative evidence on record. The
version of the Insurance Company regarding the vehicle having met with an
accident at a different location is also not supported by the damage reflected
in the mechanical inspection report and the photographs forming part of the
claim form. The evidence, therefore, when considered cumulatively, makes
the claimant’s version more probable than the contrary version set up by the
Insurance Company.
Digitally Signed
MAC.APP.440/2015
By:MANISH KUMAR
14:39:57
27.
In view of the above, the involvement of the offending vehicle in
causing the accident and the negligence on the part of its driver stand
established on the touchstone of preponderance of probabilities. The only
issue that survives for consideration in the matter is the determination of the
quantum of compensation.
28.
Accordingly, the matter is remanded to the MACT for determination
of the quantum of compensation. Considering that the accident occurred in
2011 and the award was passed in 2015, the MACT is directed to decide the
issue of quantum of compensation within a period of three months from the
date of this judgment.
29.
List before the MACT on 28 th October 2026.
30.
Appeal is disposed of in the above terms.
31.
Pending applications, if any, are rendered infructuous.
32.
Copy of this judgment be sent to the concerned MACT.
33.
Judgment be uploaded on the website of this Court.
OCTOBER 5, 2026/ak/zb
(ANISH DAYAL)
JUDGE
Digitally Signed
MAC.APP.440/2015
By:MANISH KUMAR
14:39:57
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review