Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of Decision: 14th September, 2026
%
#
CNR No. DLHC010746642006
+
W.P.(C) 8480/2006 & CM APPL. 10115/2012
UOI
.....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Jitesh Vikram Srivastava,
SPC, Adv.
versus
V.S. TYAGI
Through:
.....Respondent
Mr. Om Prakash, Sr. Adv. with
Ms. Samridhi Prakash, Mr.
Rajeev R. Pathak, Mr. Tushar
Bhalla & Mr. Taney Yogendra,
Advs.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT MAHAJAN
AMIT MAHAJAN, J. (Oral)
1.
The petitioner is aggrieved by order dated 16.12.2004, passed
by the learned Central Government Industrial Tribunal-cum-Labour
Court-II (‘the Labour Court’). The learned Labour Court by
impugned order, allowed the application filed by the Respondent
under Section 33-C (2) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 (‘the I.D.
Act’) and directed the petitioner to pay a sum of ₹67,296.80.
2.
Succinctly stated, Application under Section 33-C (2) was filed
by the respondent, stating that he was employed as a Pharmacist at
Delhi Division Hospital Northern Railway in the pay scale of ₹330560/- and was getting total monthly wages, including all allowances
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
19:50:22
W.P.(C) 8480/2006
amounting to ₹1,954/-. He was granted leave at half average pay for
the period from 28.07.1978 to 31.01.1979. Subsequently, a
supplementary bill was prepared in May, 1979 for the abovementioned leave period of six months and the same was sent to
Divisional Office, New Delhi for arranging the payment of ₹1972-80
to the respondent, however, the amount remained unpaid without any
justification. It was further claimed that he was also entitled to recover
inter alia, arrears of certain unpaid annual increments; compound
interest @12% on monthly basis from 1984; complete salary with
allowances for the suspension period from 03.03.1983 to 24.11.1985.
Hence, it was urged that the respondent is entitled to receive total
Rs.67,296.80 along with @12% compound interest on monthly basis.
3.
The management had refuted the claim by filing the written
statement and had essentially contended that no recoverable arrears
remain unpaid; the application has been filed only to harass the
petitioner; no such dues can be recovered under Section 33 C (2);
already proceedings had been initiated before the learned Central
Administrative Tribunal; and the claims if any are time-barred.
4.
The learned Labour Court considered all the arguments
advanced by the parties, in detail and observed as under: “It was submitted from the side of the workman that he was promoted
by the Divisional Personnel Office by order dt. 21.08.1996 on
01.01.1984 so he could not get the amount claimed. The CAT
quashed the order of the Disciplinary Authority and the Appellate
Authority dt. 30th April 1983 so he is entitled to get revised pay. The
management did not hold any enquiry as such the order dt.
20.03.1987 was again confirmed by the CAT in OA No.2126/90 on
29th May 1997. So the applicant could not claim his arrears in the
earlier LCA of 83 and 85. The management dropped the enquiry so
the order dated 20.03.1987 of CAT prevails and the order of the
Disciplinary Authority and the Appellate Authority dt. 309.04.1983
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
19:50:22
W.P.(C) 8480/2006
stands quashed.
It was submitted from the side of the workman applicant that he was
granted leave at average pay sanctioned form 28.07.1978 to
31.07.1979. He has not received the half average pay for the leave
sanctioned. The amount claimed under this head is Rs.1972.80. He
has filed the letter of sanction dt. 16.05.1979. it was submitted that
from the side of the workman that he has not received arrears of
increment since 29.07.1980 to 24.11.1985. It was further submitted
that the Hon’ble CAT in May, 1977 quashed the order of the
disciplinary authority as well as the appellate and has stated that he
is entitled to get all the benefits. The increment was also one of the
benefits and he should have been given increments but the
management despite several representations did not pay him
increment. He has claimed Rs.2173.00 as arrears of increment from
29.07.1978 to 24.11.1985. It was further submitted from the side of
the workman applicant that he has not received full pay from 32
months 22 days despite the order of the CAT. He is entitled to full
payment and order of the disciplinary authority dt. 30.04.1983 has
been quashed by the Hon’ble CAT in May, 1997. I have perused the
order. In the order, it has been written that he is entitled to get all
the benefits. The CAT also passed orders on 02.02.1992. As such,
there are two orders of CAT Order dt. 02.02.1992 and order dt.
May, 1997, the orders of the Disciplinary Authority as well as the
Appellate Authority has been quashed by the CAT and it has been
held that the applicant is entitled to get all the benefits just as
bonus, increment etc. As such, according to the order of the CAT,
the claimant is eligible to get all the consequential benefits.
According to the claim statement, he has not received the amount
under head-I of Rs.1972.80, under head-II, he has not received the
arrears of increment amount of Rs.2173.00. under head-III, he is also
entitled to get full salary for 32 months and 22 days amounting to
Rs.63,191.00. As such, the applicant has claimed in all Rs.67,296.80.
It was submitted from the side of the management that dues are time
barred. He has recovered the dues in LCA 167/85 but it was
submitted from the side of the workman that these dues were not
included in LCA No. 167/85. The management has not filed any
paper to show that these dues have been paid. The dues are not time
barred as he has filed 7 LCAS after the order of the CAT. It was
further submitted from the side of the management that he cannot get
these dues under an application under Section 33(C)(2) and the court
has no jurisdiction to decide such applications. There is order of the
CAT. The applicant may initiate contempt proceedings against the
management and he may move an application under Section 33(C)
(2) for the recovery of the dues that have become due. My attention
was drawn to the judgment of the Hon’ble High Court of Gujarat and
it has been held that in case, the Railway refused to pay back wages,
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
19:50:22
W.P.(C) 8480/2006
the employees can move an application under Section 33(C) (2) even
if the adjudication is of the CAT. The application is not illegal or
without jurisdiction. In view of the judgment, the claimant is entitled
to recover the dues that have not been paid. It was submitted from
the side of the management that the management is not an industry.
The court has no jurisdiction. All these pleas are useless. The court
has the jurisdiction and the management is an industry in view of the
judgment of the Bangalore Water Supply of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court. As such, the claimant is entitled to recover Rs.67,296.80 from
the management / respondent. There is no force in the argument of
the management. It was submitted from the side of the management
that the workman / applicant was suspended. Enquiry was held and
he was dismissed. In case, the order of the disciplinary authority
and the appellate authority has been set aside by the CAT, the
applicant is entitled to get full wages. The CAT has also held that
the applicant is entitled to get all the consequential benefits.
Consequential benefits include arrears of increment, full wages and
leave at half pay sanctioned. Authorities ought to have payment but
they have delayed the matter. The application under Section 33
(C)(2) of the ID Act deserves to be allowed.”
5.
Hence, in the opinion of this Court, the learned Labour Court
has rightly dealt with all the arguments raised by the parties and
concluded that once the learned Central Administrative Tribunal had
held the respondent entitled to all consequential benefits, the same
also included the arrears of increments/wages/leave pay, which has
been unnecessarily delayed by the petitioner. In the opinion of this
Court, a plausible view has been taken by the learned Labour Court
which ought not to be interfered while exercising the power under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India. This Court does not sit as a
Court of appeal over findings of fact rendered by the learned Labour
Court and the petitioner has failed to demonstrate any perversity in the
above findings.
6.
Another argument has been raised by the learned Counsel for
the petitioner that after the order was passed by the learned Labour
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
19:50:22
W.P.(C) 8480/2006
Court, it came to the knowledge of the petitioner department that
respondent, during the said claim period, was working with the
CGHS, due to which an FIR bearing No. 388/2009 was also registered
against the respondent.
7.
As rightly argued by the learned Senior Advocate, Mr. Om
Prakash on behalf of the respondent, that the said objection was never
taken by the petitioner before the learned Labour Court. Additionally,
it has been informed that the FIR is still stated to be pending and no
final order has been passed till today. Be that as it may, it was not the
case of the petitioner department that the amount was not paid to the
respondent for the reasons that he had joined another department. The
same could have been a separate cause of action, for initiating fresh
action, but cannot be taken into account to deny the relief to the
respondent in the present proceedings. It also remains undisputed that
no steps have been taken by the petitioner department pursuant to
being informed that the respondent had allegedly been working in
some other department during the period of suspension. Thus, no
benefit of the same can be given to the petitioner at this stage.
However, the petitioner is at liberty to take appropriate legal action if
advised and permissible in law.
8.
The same, however, cannot be formed basis for denying the
amount which has been awarded by the learned Labour Court,
specifically when the present petition had been filed more than two
decades ago and only involves a sum of ₹67,296.80, for which the
parties have been embroiled in litigation for decades now.
9.
In view of the above discussion, this Court finds no reason to
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
19:50:22
W.P.(C) 8480/2006
interfere in the impugned Award. The amount deposited by the
petitioner before this Court pursuant to the order dated 04.04.2008,
with all the accrued interest is directed to be released in favour of the
respondent, in terms of the impugned award.
10.
This Court appreciates the efforts put in by the learned Senior
Counsel for the respondent who agreed to address arguments on
behalf of the workman on being requested by the Court.
11.
Accordingly, the petition is dismissed, along with pending
applications, if any.
AMIT MAHAJAN, J
SEPTEMBER 14, 2026
“SK”
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
19:50:22
W.P.(C) 8480/2006
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review