Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
$~1 & 2
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Date of decision: 28th September 2026
#
CNR No. DLHC014557912017
+
MAC.APP. 894/2017 & CM APPL. 36697/2017
UNITED INIDA INSUARCE COMPANY LTD
Through:
....Appellant
Mr. Amit Kumar Singh, Ms.
Rokosieno Meyase, Advocates.
versus
MAMRAJ & ORS
Through:
....Respondents
Mr. Varun Sarin, Ms. Parul Dutta,
Advocates for Respondent No.1.
(2)
#
CNR No. DLHC012383062018
+
MAC.APP. 762/2018, CM APPL. 28412/2024 & CM APPL.
30641/2024.
MAMRAJ
...Appellant
Through:
Mr. Varun Sarin, Ms. Parul Dutta,
Advocates.
versus
M/S UNITED INDIA INSURANCE CO LTD
Through:
....Respondent
Mr. Amit Kumar Singh, Ms.
Rokosieno Meyase, Advocates.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANISH DAYAL
MAC.APP. 894/2017 & MAC.APP. 762/2018
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
12:16:35
JUDGMENT
ANISH DAYAL, J (ORAL)
1.
These cross-appeals have been filed assailing the impugned Award
dated 18th July 2017 passed by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Patiala
House Courts, New Delhi (‘MACT/Tribunal’) in MACP No.94/2015
which awarded compensation of Rs.19,39,348/- along with interest at 9%
per annum.
2.
While MAC.APP. 894/2017 has been filed by the Insurance
Company, seeking a reduction in compensation, MAC.APP. 762/2018 has
been filed by the claimant seeking enhancement of compensation.
3.
The accident occurred on 30th December 2014, when the claimant
had parked his truck bearing registration No.HR-63B-1552 on the extreme
left side of the road with all emergency lights on and was in the process of
changing the tyre of his truck. A truck bearing registration No.HR-38T4638, driven by respondent no. 1, hit the vehicle of claimant from the rear.
As a result, the jack of the truck (No.HR-63B-1552) collapsed, and the
whole weight of the vehicle came on both his legs, resulting in grievous
injuries.
4.
As per the Disability Certificate dated 03rd March 2016, the claimant
was certified to have suffered permanent physical impairment to the extent
of 40% in relation to both lower limbs. The claimant sustained injuries
medically specified as ‘Genu Valgum of the right knee, Rocker Bottom
deformity of the right foot, and deformity of the left foot’.
5.
Thereafter, by an order of this Court dated 25th March 2022, this
Court directed Safdarjung Hospital and VMMC to constitute a Medical
MAC.APP. 894/2017 & MAC.APP. 762/2018
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
12:16:35
Board to examine the claimant's disability. As per the Medical Board’s
Report dated 05th September 2023, it was certified that injured-claimant
had suffered permanent physical impairment of 30% in relation to right
lower limb, the nature of injury being the same.
6.
In respect of the second report, AW1 (Dr. Ashish Rustagi, MS
(Ortho), DNB (Ortho) MNAMS, Associate Professor, Department of
Orthopaedics, VMMC & Safdarjung Hospital, New Delhi) was examined
on 29th July 2024. He stated that the disability was permanent, but the
amount/percentage may vary in the future.
7.
During his cross-examination, a suggestion was put to him as to
whether injured-claimant could run, climb stairs up and down, or perform
long standing duties. To which he mentioned that, in all probability, there
will be difficulty in running, performing long standing duties and climbing
on stairs. With regard to assessment of disability at 30%, he said there
would be some restrictions in performing his day-to-day activities, and it is
difficult to comment upon his ability to drive.
8.
Mr. Varun Sarin, counsel for the claimant, pointed out to the
testimony recorded before the MACT of the representative of the Medical
Board of Dr. R.M.L. Hospital, PW2, which had given the first disability
certificate. He stated that the claimant cannot drive the truck due to the
injuries suffered in the accident.
9.
Taking into consideration these circumstances, the MACT assessed
the functional disability at 50%, keeping into account that the claimant was
working as a driver of a commercial truck and would have lost his vocation
in that regard.
MAC.APP. 894/2017 & MAC.APP. 762/2018
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
12:16:35
10.
Mr. Amit Kumar Singh, counsel for the Insurance Company,
challenges the same on the ground that claimant’s license was renewed on
19th December 2016, showing that he was in a condition to drive the truck.
It was further stated that he filed an application to cancel his license on 16th
July 2018, after this ground had been raised in the appeal.
11.
This Court has taken a view on a similar issue in Manish Madan v.
Prem Pal Singh & Ors. MAC. APP. 1086/2016, wherein it was held that
merely holding a driving licence after suffering a disability cannot, by
itself, lead to the conclusion that the claimant was capable of driving a
vehicle.
12.
Though the circumstances in Manish Madan (supra) were different,
this Court reiterates the view that renewal of a driving license may occur as
a matter of routine and does not necessarily indicate that the claimant is
physically capable of driving. With a permanent disability of 30% or 40%,
it would be well-nigh impossible for a person to be entrusted with the
operation of a large or heavy vehicle such as a truck. There is no evidence
on record to suggest that the claimant continued to drive a truck after the
accident. The only circumstance relied upon is that his driving license was
renewed and continued to remain in his name.
13.
The fact that he got his driving license cancelled post filing of the
appeal may be just a precautionary measure in order that this issue may not
be held against him. In the opinion of this Court, the said issue is not
germane to the question of disability. The MACT assessed the functional
disability at 50%, taking into account the claimant's occupation as a truck
driver.
MAC.APP. 894/2017 & MAC.APP. 762/2018
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
12:16:35
14.
Mr. Varun Sarin has argued that the disability ought to be considered
at a higher percentage, considering the claimant had lost his vocation.
15.
However, in light of the principles laid down in Raj Kumar v. Ajay
Kumar (2011) 1 SCC 343, it is not as if, with 30% permanent disability, he
will not be able to manage any other vocation or his whole livelihood
would be wiped out. Therefore, considerations relevant to determining
100% functional disability are not attracted in the present case. At the same
time, it is noted that the MACT treated the renewal of the driving license as
a factor in assessing the functional disability at 50% rather than 100%.
16.
Taking all these factors into consideration, this Court is of the view
that the claimant's functional disability ought to be assessed at 70%.
17.
On the issue of income, Mr. Varun Sarin has argued that the
claimant had deposed that he was earning Rs. 15,000/- per month from the
employer/M/s Rao Transport; however, no oral/documentary evidence has
been led by the claimant to substantiate this and, therefore, the MACT
assessed the claimant's income on the basis of the minimum wages
applicable to a skilled worker, i.e., Rs. 10,478/- per month.
18.
Decisions of the Supreme Court in Chandra @ Chanda @
Chandraram & Anr. v. Mukesh Kumar Yadav & Ors. (Civil Appeal
No.6152/2021), which was followed by the Supreme Court in Faridaben
Mahebub Hajiya & Anr. v. National Insurance Co. Ltd. & Ors. 2026 SCC
OnLine SC 1287 has been relied upon by counsel for claimant to state that
the notional income may be taken as more than minimum wages.
MAC.APP. 894/2017 & MAC.APP. 762/2018
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
12:16:35
19.
However, this Court is not inclined to enhance the notional income
assessed by the MACT, as there is no evidence on record to establish the
claimant's actual employment or earnings.
20.
As far as mental & physical shock, pain and suffering and loss of
amenities, the MACT, in the impugned award, clubbed these heads
together and awarded a sum of Rs. 1,10,000/- collectively.
21.
Accordingly, for pain and suffering and mental & physical shock, the
said amount of Rs.1,10,000/- is awarded, but for loss of amenities, a sum of
Rs.1,00,000/- is awarded separately.
22.
Future prospects were awarded at 50%. However, considering that
the claimant was not in permanent employment, future prospects ought to
be 40%, in light of the principles laid down in National Insurance
Company Ltd. vs. Pranay Sethi & Ors. (2017) 16 SCC 680.
23.
Sr.
No.
Accordingly, the revised computation of compensation is as under:
Heads
Awarded by the
Tribunal
Awarded by
this Court
PECUNIARY LOSS
1.
Rs. 50,000/-
Rs. 50,000/-
Rs.40,000/-
Rs.40,000/-
Rs. 10,478/-
Rs. 10,478/-
Rs.41,912/-
Rs.41,912/-
5.
Expenditure on Medical Bills
and medical treatment (A)
Expenditure on conveyance
and special diet (B)
Income of injured per
month(E)
Loss of income (L) [Rs.
10,478/-x 4]
Add: Future prospects (F)
50%
6.
7.
8.
Multiplier (G)
Functional disability (H)
Loss of future income/future
50%
Rs. 16,97,436/-
40% of Rs. 10,478 =
Rs. 4,191.20/18
70%
Rs. 22,17,983.04/-
2.
3.
MAC.APP. 894/2017 & MAC.APP. 762/2018
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
12:16:35
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
earnings [(E+F) x 12 x G x
H] = (I)
NON-PECUNIARY LOSS
Pain and suffering (J)
Rs.1,10,000/Rs.1,10,000/Loss of amenities of life (K)
Rs. 1,00,000/Compensation for mental and
NIL
physical shock (M)
Total compensation (A + B +
Rs.25,59,895.04/Rs.19,39,348/C + D + H + I+ J+ K+L+M)
(rounded to
= (N)
Rs. 25,59,895/Interest awarded
9% per annum
9% per annum
Enhanced compensation
Rs. 6,20,547/-
24.
Accordingly, the compensation is enhanced by Rs. 6,20,547/-.
25.
The enhanced amount, along with interest at 9% per annum from the
date of filing the petition, shall be deposited before the MACT within a
period of four weeks. The same shall be released to the claimant in a lump
sum within two weeks thereafter.
26.
By order dated 13th October 2017 passed in MAC.APP. 894/2017,
Insurance Company was directed to deposit the entire compensation
amount along with accrued interest and release 20% amount in favour of
claimant.
27.
Accordingly, balance compensation, along with accrued interest, will
be released to the claimant as a lump sum, considering the accident is of
2014.
28.
Appeals stand disposed of in the above terms. Pending applications
are rendered infructuous.
29.
Statutory deposit, if any, be refunded to the Insurance Company only
if the order of deposit has been complied with.
MAC.APP. 894/2017 & MAC.APP. 762/2018
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
12:16:35
30.
Copy of this judgment be sent to the concerned MACT/bank for
information and necessary compliance.
31.
Judgment be uploaded on the website of this Court.
(ANISH DAYAL)
JUDGE
SEPTEMBER 28, 2026/ak/bp
MAC.APP. 894/2017 & MAC.APP. 762/2018
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
12:16:35
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review