Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of decision: 25th February 2026
+
MAC.APP. 1155/2018 & CM APPL. 54122/2018
UNITED INDIA INSURANE CO LTD
Through:
.....Appellant
Ms. Suman Bagga & Ms. Mouli
Sharma, Advs.
versus
RAJMAL KAUSHIK & ORS
.....Respondents
Through: Ms. Tejaswini Verma and Ms.
Manika Gaba, Advocates for R-1
Mr. Sanjay Rathi, Adv.
Mr. Vikrant Nilesh Goyal, Mr.
Yash Basoya, Mr. Rakshit Tyagi,
Mr. Kunal Dixit, Advs. for R-3
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANISH DAYAL
JUDGMENT
ANISH DAYAL, J (ORAL)
1.
This appeal has been filed by Insurance Company challenging the
award dated 27th October 2018 passed by the Motor Accidents Claims
Tribunal, North West District, Rohini Courts, Delhi [‘Tribunal’] in MACT
Petition No.103/12, whereby a compensation of Rs.10,45,777/- was
awarded with interest @ 9% per annum.
Incident
2.
On 07th December 2011 at about 5:00 a.m., the claimant/respondent
Signature Not VerifiedMAC.APP. 1155/2018
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:16:24
no. 1, Sh. Rajmal Kaushik, was returning from Pitampura, Delhi to his
residence on a motorcycle bearing registration no. DL-8S-AA-8687. When
he reached opposite C & D Block, Shalimar Bagh, Ring Road, a Delhi
Transport Corporation (DTC) bus bearing registration no. DL-1PC-7357,
plying on Route No. 883 and being driven by respondent no. 2 in a rash
and negligent manner, struck the motorcycle from behind. As a result, the
claimant fell onto the road and sustained grievous injuries.
3.
Claimant/Injured was immediately removed to Jaipur Golden
Hospital, Delhi, where he remained admitted from 07th December 2011 to
12th December 2011. FIR No. 438/2011 dated 07th December 2011 under
Sections 279/337 of the Indian Penal Code 1860 [IPC] was registered at
Police Station Shalimar Bagh with respect to the said accident. The
Detailed Accident Report [DAR] dated 18th February2012 was filed by the
Investigating Officer and was treated as a claim petition under Section
166(4) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, against the driver, owner and
insurer [appellant herein] of the offending bus. The claimant, aged about
49 years at the time of the accident, was employed as a Beldar with the
Delhi Development Authority [‘DDA’] earning Rs. 19,045/- per month. He
suffered post-traumatic stiffness of the right knee and right ankle and was
assessed to have sustained 26% permanent physical disability in relation
to the right lower limb.
Analysis
4.
Ms. Suman Bagga, counsel for Insurance Company, has challenged
computation of impugned award to the extent of calculation for loss of
future income. It has been contended that, as per the salary slip exhibited
Signature Not VerifiedMAC.APP. 1155/2018
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:16:24
as Exhibit PW-4/A, and produced by the Executive Engineer, DDA,
injured/claimant was working as a Beldar and, on the date of accident
being 7th December 2011, net salary would be Rs.19,045/- in that month.
5.
Said salary was incorporated while calculating the loss of income for
149 days when injured/claimant was on leave, as is evident from
paragraph 10 of the impugned award. However, while calculating the loss
of future income, the Tribunal took into account Form 16 filed for
Assessment Year 2012-2013, and gross income was taken as Rs.2,76,856/, and therefore monthly income was calculated at Rs.23,071/-.
6.
It is contended that once the salary slip was duly exhibited and
endorsed by the Executive Engineer (DDA) and proved by testimony of
PW-4 from office of the Executive Engineer, DDA, Narela, the question
of adopting two different figures for income cannot be sustained.
Accordingly, even for the purpose of loss of future income, amount of Rs.
19,045/- per month ought to be considered.
7.
Ms. Suman Bagga, counsel, further states that the injured/claimant
continues to be in service with DDA and, therefore, there has been no loss
of income to justify the application of the multiplier of ‘13’. Instead, at
best, multiplier of ‘9’ ought to have been adopted, which can be considered
for post-retirement period.
8.
In support, reliance is placed on following decisions of this Court
wherein it has been held that where an injured/claimant continues in
gainful employment despite disability, the appropriate multiplier is to be
applied only to the post-retirement period, and loss of future earning
capacity must be computed with reference to the income at the time of
Signature Not VerifiedMAC.APP. 1155/2018
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:16:24
superannuation, including future prospects, rather than treating the
disability as resulting in an immediate loss of earning. For ease of reference
relevant paragraphs of these judgements are extracted as under:
a. Desh Raj Singh Gautam v. Sunil Kumar And Ors. 2016:DHC:415:
“4. It is noted that the tribunal awarded lumpsum
amount of ₹2 Lakh on account of loss of future income
due to disability. This was not a correct approach.
Admittedly, the claimant was a regular employee of
MTNL. It is conceded by the counsel representing him
that he would continue in service till he attains the age
of 60 years and, thus, there would be no loss of income
till that stage. However, the loss of income post
retirement will have to be appropriately computed.
Since the retirement would occur at the age of 60
years, it had to be calculated with the multiplier of 9.
Computed thus, the loss of future earnings on account
of disability to the extent of 25% would come to
(₹19,000 x 25/100 x 12 x 9) ₹5,13,000/-. Since the
tribunal had awarded only lupmsum of ₹2 Lakh, the
award deserves to be enhanced by ₹3,13,000/-.
Ordered accordingly. Needless to say, it shall carry
interest as levied by the tribunal.”
(emphasis added)
b. TATA AIG General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Sh. Dipanjan Ghosh
2016:DHC:1821:
“4. In the face of the fact that there is no loss of
employment and the claimant has continued to be in
service, there is substance in the contention raised by
the insurance company. But it cannot be forgotten that
there would be loss of future earnings arising out of
the disability suffered, once the claimant retires.
Ordinarily, the employees even in private service are
superannuated at the age of 60 years. In these
circumstances, the loss of future earnings due to
Signature Not VerifiedMAC.APP. 1155/2018
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:16:24
disability requires to be recalculated on the multiplier
of 9.”
5. Having regard to the fact that there is bound to be
increase in the income over the period the claimant
continues to serve in the present employment, the
element of future prospects would have to be added.
Since the loss of future earning capacity is to be
computed with reference to the income that would be
available at the time of superannuation, the current
income is increased by 30% and, thus, the notional
income on which future earning capacity may be
assessed is calculated as (55,000 x 130 ÷ 100)
₹71,500/- per month. The loss of earnings at 40%
disability comes to (71,500 x 40 ÷ 100) ₹28,600/-. On
the multiplier of 9, the total loss of future earnings
comes to (28,600 x 12 x 9) ₹30,88,800/- rounded off to
₹30,90,000/-. Since the Tribunal calculated this
portion of the compensation at ₹39,60,000/-, the total
compensation ordered to be paid has to be reduced by
(39,60,000 – 30,90,000) ₹8,70,000/- . In this view, the
compensation is reduced to (49,20,420 – 8,70,000)
₹40,50,420/- rounded off to ₹40,51,000/. It shall carry
interest at 9% per annum as directed by the Tribunal.”
(emphasis added)
9.
In order to avoid any duplication of amounts being granted to
claimant, who continues to be secure in his employment with DDA, the
submission of counsel for Insurance Company is acceptable. Accordingly,
multiplier of ‘9’ shall be taken.
10.
Other aspects of compensation will remain unchanged, except for
non-pecuniary components, which ought to be enhanced to accommodate
the distress and deprivation caused to the injured.
11.
Compensation is now recomputed as under :
Signature Not VerifiedMAC.APP. 1155/2018
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:16:24
SR.
NO.
HEADS
AWARDED BY
THE
TRIBUNAL
AWARDED BY
THIS COURT
PECUNIARY LOSS
Expenditure on treatment (A)
Nil
Nil
Expenditure on conveyance (B)
Rs.20,000 /-
Rs.20,000/-
Expenditure on special diet (C)
Cost of nursing / attendant (D)
Rs.20,000 /Rs.35,000 /-
Rs.20,000/Rs.35,000/-
Loss of earning capacity (E)
Rs.7,01,812 /-
Rs. 4,01,088/-
Loss of income (F)
Rs. 81,950/-
Rs.81,950/-
Any other loss which may
require any special treatment or
aid to the injured for the rest of
his life (G)
Nil
Nil
Medical Expenses
Compensation for mental and
physical shock (H)
Nil
Nil
Pain and suffering (I)
Loss of amenities of life (J)
Rs.50,000/Rs.50,000/-
Rs.1,00,000/Rs.1,00,000/-
Disfiguration (K)
Nil
Nil
Loss of marriage prospects (L)
Nil
Nil
Loss of earning, inconvenience,
Nil
Nil
hardships, disappointment,
frustration, mental stress,
dejectment and unhappiness in
future life etc. (M)
DISABILITY RESULTING IN LOSS OF EARNING CAPACITY
Percentage of disability assessed
26% permanent
26% permanent
and nature of disability as
disability
disability
permanent or temporary
Rs.87,015/-
Loss of amenities or loss of
expectation of life span on
account of disability
Nil
Nil
Percentage of loss of earning
capacity in relation to disability
15%
15%
Signature Not VerifiedMAC.APP. 1155/2018
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:16:24
Rs.87,015/NON PECUNIARY LOSS
Loss of future income (Income
X% Earning capacity x
Multiplier)
TOTAL COMPENSATION
INTEREST AWARDED
12.
Rs.7,01,812/-
Rs. 4,01,088/-
[Rs.23,071 + 30% x
12 x 13 x 15%]
[Round of
Rs.4,01,087.7/-]
RS. 10,46,000/[Round of
Rs.10,45,777]
9%
[Rs. 19,045/- + 30%
x 12 x 9 x 15%]
RS.8,45,053/-
9%
Vide order dated 20th December 2018, entire compensation with
accrued interest stood deposited by the Insurance Company before the
Registry of this Court.
13.
Excess amount shall be refunded to Insurance Company; balance
amount shall continue to be retained in Fixed Deposit Returns [‘FDRs’]
and disbursed in terms of directions in impugned award.
14.
Rs.2,00,000/- be released upon dilution of FDRs, and balance
amount shall be retained in form of FDRs.
15.
A copy of this judgment be sent to the concerned Tribunal.
16.
Accordingly, the appeal stands allowed and disposed of.
17.
Pending applications, if any, are rendered infructuous.
18.
Statutory deposit (if any) shall be refunded to appellant.
19.
Judgement be uploaded on the website of this Court.
ANISH DAYAL, J
FEBRUARY 25, 2026/sm/tk
Signature Not VerifiedMAC.APP. 1155/2018
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:16:24
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review