Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:UHC:52
HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND AT NAINITAL
Appeal from Order No.217 of 2014
20th, February, 2026
United India Insurance Company Ltd.
--Appellant
Versus
Deepak Rai Chowdhary & others
--Respondents
---------------------------------------------------------------------Presence:Mr. K.K. Shah, learned counsel for the appellant.
Mr. Aakash Sanyal with Ms. Zeba, learned counsel i/b Mr.
Siddhartha Singh, learned counsel for respondent nos.1 & 2.
Mr. Tapan Singh, learned counsel for respondent nos.3 & 5.
No one is present for respondent no.4.
---------------------------------------------------------------------Hon'ble Pankaj Purohit, J.
This Appeal From Order has been preferred by
the appellant–Insurance Company under Section 173 of
the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, challenging the judgment
and award dated 01.03.2014 passed by the Motor
Accident Claims Tribunal / IVth Additional District
Judge, Haridwar in Claim Petition No. 61 of 2011,
whereby
the
Tribunal
has
awarded
a
sum
of
Rs.3,39,000/- along with interest @ 7% per annum in
favour of the claimants on account of the death of their
son Amit Rai Chaudhary in a motor vehicle accident. The
Insurance Company seeks to assail the impugned award
also questioning the computation of compensation.
2.
The facts, in brief, giving rise to the present
appeal are that on 15.01.2007 at about 9:00 a.m., the
2026:UHC:52
deceased Amit Rai Chaudhary, aged about 22 years, was
travelling in a three-wheeler (Auto) bearing registration
No. UA-08-2806 for the purpose of going to his place of
work. When the said vehicle reached near the Degree
College turn at Kankhal, District Haridwar, it met with
an accident and overturned on the road. As a result of
the said accident, Amit Rai Chaudhary sustained serious
injuries. He was immediately taken for medical treatment
to
the
District
Government
Hospital,
Haridwar.
Considering the gravity of his condition, he was referred
to Jolly Grant Hospital; however, while being taken to the
said hospital, he succumbed to the injuries sustained in
the accident. The claim petition was thereafter filed by
the
parents
of the
deceased, namely Deepak
Rai
Chaudhary and Smt. Anjana Rai Chaudhary, asserting
that the deceased was a young, healthy individual and
the sole support of the family.
3.
It was submitted that the accident occurred
solely due to the rash and negligent driving of the
offending vehicle, resulting in the untimely death of their
son, causing immense mental agony and financial loss to
the claimants. It was further stated that the offending
vehicle was owned by respondent no. 1, driven by
respondent no. 2 at the relevant time, and was insured
with respondent no. 4–Insurance Company. On these
assertions, the claimants sought compensation under
Sections 140 and 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act,
1988.The Tribunal, upon consideration of the pleadings
and evidence adduced by the parties, proceeded to
adjudicate the claim petition and ultimately passed the
impugned
award
dated
01.03.2014,
granting
compensation of Rs.3,39,000/- along with interest @ 7%
per annum in favour of the claimants.
4.
2026:UHC:52
In the claim petition, the claimants asserted
that the accident occurred due to the negligent driving of
the Three Wheeler Auto No.UA-08-2806, which was being
driven at a high speed and in an unsafe manner. It was
pleaded that the deceased sustained fatal injuries directly
attributable to the accident. The claimants further
pleaded that the vehicle was insured, and that the driver
was holding a valid driving licence at the relevant time. A
claim for compensation of Rs.15,00,000/- along with
interest was made.
5.
The driver and owner of the offending vehicle
filed their written statements denying negligence and
contending that the accident did not occur in the manner
alleged. They further pleaded that the vehicle was being
driven carefully and that the driver possessed a valid and
effective driving licence.
6.
The
statement,
Insurance
raised
Company,
preliminary
in
its
objections
written
including
maintainability, alleged non-joinder of necessary parties,
denial of negligence, and questioned the income, age, and
dependency of the deceased. It was further pleaded that
the accident was the result of the deceased’s own
negligence and that the claim petition was the outcome of
collusion between the claimants and the vehicle owner.
The Insurance Company also submitted that on the date
of accident Vehicle No.UA-08-2806 did not possess a
fitness certificate and the driver of the said vehicle also
did not carry a valid driving licence, therefore, the
Insurance
Company
was
not
liable
to
pay
any
compensation due to the breach of policy conditions.
7.
On the basis of the pleadings of the parties
following issues were
framed by the
Tribunal for
2026:UHC:52
adjudication:
1) Whether on 15.01.2007 at about 9:00 a.m., due to
overturning of three wheeler auto No. UA-08-2806
near the Degree College crossing, an accident
occurred?
2) Whether in the said accident, the son of the
claimants, Amit Rai Chaudhary, sustained grievous
injuries and died while being taken for treatment?
3) Whether at the time, place and date of accident,
the offending vehicle three wheeler auto No. UA-082806 was insured with respondent no.4?
4) Whether at the time of accident, the driver of the
offending vehicle was holding a valid and effective
driving licence?
5) Whether at the time of accident, the offending
vehicle was being driven with valid and effective
documents?
6)
Whether
the
claimants
are
entitled
to
compensation, if so, from whom and to what extent?
8.
While deciding Issue No. 1, the Tribunal, upon
appreciation of oral and documentary evidence on record,
including the testimony of the witnesses, FIR, site plan,
post-mortem
report
and
other
medical
recorded
clear
finding
that
the
a
documents,
accident
dated
15.01.2007 occurred in the manner pleaded in the claim
petition. The Tribunal held that the offending vehicle was
involved in the accident at the stated time and place and
that the occurrence of the accident stood duly proved.
Accordingly, Issue No. 1 was decided in favour of the
2026:UHC:52
claimants.
9.
On
Issue
No.
2,
the
Tribunal
examined
whether the death of Amit Rai Chaudhary was the result
of
injuries
sustained
consideration
of
the
in
the
medical
said
accident.
evidence,
Upon
including
treatment papers and post-mortem report, the Tribunal
found that the deceased sustained grievous injuries in
the accident and subsequently succumbed to those
injuries while being taken for further treatment. The
Tribunal thus held that there was a direct link between
the accident and the death of the deceased. Issue No. 2
was accordingly decided in favour of the claimants.
10.
While deciding Issue No. 3, the Tribunal
considered the insurance policy produced on record and
recorded a categorical finding that the offending vehicle
was
duly
insured
with
the
respondent
Insurance
Company on the date of the accident. The validity of the
insurance policy was not successfully disputed. Issue No.
was,
therefore,
decided
against
the
Insurance
Company.
11.
On Issue No. 4, the Tribunal examined the
driving licence of the driver of the offending vehicle and,
on appreciation of documentary evidence, recorded a
finding that the driver was holding a valid and effective
driving licence on the date of the accident. The plea
raised by the Insurance Company regarding invalidity of
the licence was rejected. Accordingly, Issue No. 4 was
decided against the Insurance Company.
12.
While deciding Issue No. 5, the Tribunal held
that the offending vehicle was being driven with valid
registration and other necessary documents at the time
2026:UHC:52
of the accident. No breach of statutory requirements was
proved by the Insurance Company. Hence, Issue No. 5
was decided in favour of the claimants.
13.
On Issue No. 6, the Tribunal assessed the age,
income and dependency of the deceased and, after
applying the appropriate multiplier and deductions,
computed the compensation payable to the claimants.
The Tribunal held that the claimants were entitled to
compensation of Rs.3,39,000/- along with interest @ 7%
per annum, fastening liability upon the Insurance
Company.
14.
The
learned
counsel
for
the
appellate-
Insurance Company argued that on the date of accident
Vehicle
No.UA-08-2806
did
not
possess
a
fitness
certificate and the driver of the said vehicle also did not
carry a valid driving licence, therefore, the Insurance
Company was not liable to pay any compensation due to
the breach of policy conditions. He further submitted
that there is contributory negligence inasmuch as the
accident occurred due to own negligence of the deceased.
15.
The learned counsel for the respondent - claimants
has supported the finding of the learned Tribunal by
submitting that the issuance of the fitness certificate on
the very date of the accident conclusively establishes that
the vehicle, upon due inspection by the competent
authority, was found to be roadworthy. It is contended
that such certification could not have been granted
unless the vehicle satisfied the statutory requirements of
fitness, and therefore, a reasonable presumption arises
that the vehicle was fit for use at the relevant time. In
absence of any cogent evidence led by the insurer to
prove mechanical unfitness, mere reliance on the timing
2026:UHC:52
of issuance of the fitness certificate does not establish
any breach of policy conditions.
16.
Having heard and gone through the pleadings
of the parties and upon perusal of the material on record,
this Court finds that the Tribunal has returned clear and
well-reasoned findings on each of the issues framed,
which are supported by the evidence adduced and do not
call for interference in appellate jurisdiction under
Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act. This Court has
carefully examined the impugned award in the light of
the pleadings, evidence and the issue-wise findings
returned by the Tribunal. The Tribunal has recorded
distinct and categorical findings on the occurrence of the
accident, the causal link between the accident and the
death of the deceased, the validity of the insurance cover,
the driving licence of the driver, and the entitlement of
the claimants to compensation. Each of these findings is
supported by oral and documentary evidence and does
not suffer from any perversity or misapplication of law.
The Tribunal has first found that the accident occurred
in the manner pleaded and that the offending vehicle was
involved at the stated time and place. It has thereafter
independently
examined
the
medical
evidence
and
returned a clear finding that the deceased sustained fatal
injuries in the said accident and succumbed thereto.
These findings are based on contemporaneous records
including treatment papers and post-mortem report and
warrant no interference. The Tribunal has also examined
the insurance policy and the driving licence and has
recorded findings that the offending vehicle was duly
insured and that the driver was holding a valid and
effective driving licence on the date of the accident. The
finding that the licence held by the driver authorised him
2026:UHC:52
to drive the offending vehicle is in consonance with the
settled legal position governing light motor vehicles. The
argument put forth by the Insurance Company that the
certificate of fitness was obtained on the very same date
establishes that upon inspection by the competent
authority, the vehicle was found roadworthy. In absence
of
any
evidence
to
show
that
the
vehicle
was
mechanically defective or unfit at the time of accident, a
reasonable inference can be drawn that the vehicle was
roadworthy and capable of certification even at the time
of accident. Mere timing of issuance of fitness certificate
cannot be treated as conclusive proof of unfitness,
particularly when the burden lies upon the insurer to
establish breach of policy conditions. Therefore, no
breach of policy conditions has been established from the
record.
17.
Furthermore, the record reflects that the
driver, owner and insurer of the offending vehicle were
duly impleaded before the Tribunal and the accident was
found to have occurred due to the negligence of the
offending vehicle alone. In such circumstances, the
adjudication of the claim petition is not rendered
defective on account of absence of any other party, nor is
any prejudice shown to have been caused. The Tribunal
has separately examined the occurrence of the accident
and the cause of death and, on appreciation of oral and
documentary evidence, has recorded a categorical finding
that the deceased sustained fatal injuries in the accident
in question and succumbed thereto. No material is borne
out from
the
record
to
indicate
any contributory
negligence on the part of the deceased. The finding on
negligence is thus based on evidence and warrants no
interference. The proceedings, therefore, cannot be said
2026:UHC:52
to be vitiated on the ground of non-joinder.
18.
So far as the adjudication of compensation is
concerned, the Tribunal has correctly assessed the age of
the deceased as 22 years. In the absence of cogent
documentary proof of income, the Tribunal adopted a
notional
annual
income
of
Rs.36,000/-,
which
is
reasonable having regard to the age of the deceased, the
nature of work and the period of the accident. The
deceased being a bachelor, the Tribunal deducted 50%
towards personal and living expenses, which is in
accordance with settled principles. The Tribunal then
applied a multiplier of 18, which is the appropriate
multiplier for the age group of the deceased. On the
aforesaid basis, the Tribunal computed the annual
dependency at Rs.18,000/- after deduction, and by
applying the multiplier of 18, arrived at a loss of
dependency
of
Rs.3,24,000/-.
In
addition
thereto,
amounts were awarded under conventional heads such
as funeral expenses and loss to estate, keeping in view
the law prevailing at the relevant time, resulting in a total
compensation of Rs.3,39,000/-. The interest awarded at
the rate of 7% per annum is also within reasonable
limits. The Tribunal has thus applied the correct
multiplier, made the proper deduction towards personal
expenses,
and
awarded
compensation
under
conventional heads in a manner consistent with the
settled principles governing assessment of compensation.
The computation is logical, proportionate and just. No
material is borne out from the record to indicate
contributory negligence, collusion, or any procedural
irregularity affecting the adjudication of the claim.
19.
This
Court
finds
that
the
Tribunal
has
2026:UHC:52
appreciated the evidence in its correct perspective,
adhered to the legal principles applicable to motor
accident claims, and passed a reasoned award. The
impugned award does not disclose any error of law or
perversity
warranting
interference
in
appellate
jurisdiction under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act.
20.
In view of the above discussion, the appeal is
dismissed. Rs. 2,54,250 appears to be deposited by the
appellant- Insurance Company before the claims tribunal
pursuant to interim order dated 09.07.2014 passed by
the court. Rest of the amount of compensation shall be
deposited by the appellant-Insurance Company before
the claims tribunal within 2 months from today along
with interest up to date. The respondent-claimant shall
be entitled to receive the compensation so deposited
adjusting the compensation, if any, already received.
(Pankaj Purohit, J.)
20.02.2026
AK
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review