Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
$~4 & 5
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW
DELHI
Date of decision: 04th August 2026
%
(4)
#
CNR No. DLHC012109112014
+
MAC.APP. 1018/2014 & CM APPL. 14411/2026
UNITED INDIA INSURANCE CO LTD
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. Sankar N. Sinha, Adv.
versus
SARFARAZ SAFI AND ORS
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Punishk Handa, Adv. for R-1.
Ms Manisha Tyagi, Adv. for R-2 &
R-3.
(5)
#
CNR No. DLHC010300322026
+
MAC.APP. 419/2026
SARFARAZ SAIFI
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. Punishk Handa, Adv.
versus
UNITED INDIA INSURANCE CO LTD AND ORS .....Respondent
Through: Mr. Sankar N. Sinha, Adv.
Ms Manisha Tyagi, Adv. for R-2 &
R-3.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANISH DAYAL
JUDGMENT
ANISH DAYAL, J (ORAL)
1.
These cross-appeals have been filed impugning order dated 5th
Digitally Signed
MAC.APP. 1018/2014 & MAC.APP. 419/2026
By:MANISH KUMAR
12:09:40
September 2014 passed by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, South-East
District, Saket Courts (‘MACT/Tribunal’) in Suit No.792/11, whereby
compensation of Rs. 28,50,012/- along with interest at 9% per annum was
awarded.
2.
MAC.APP. 1018/2014 has been filed by the Insurance Company,
whereas MAC.APP. 419/2026 has been filed by injured/claimant seeking
enhancement of compensation.
3.
The accident in question occurred on 23rd September 2011 at about
06:15 p.m., when the claimant/appellant, along with his friend, attempted to
board a DTC bus at Jamia College bus stand, as the earlier bus was
overcrowded. Though the bus initially slowed down on giving hand
indication, it suddenly accelerated while the claimant was in process of
boarding, causing him to lose balance and fall. As a result of the accident, he
sustained grievous injuries to his right hand. An FIR was registered against
the driver, and he was charge-sheeted as well for rash and negligent driving.
4.
Mr. Sankar N. Sinha, counsel for Insurance Company, challenges the
impugned award on the following counts:
i.
Determination of functional disability at 90% by the MACT despite
there being permanent disability of 90% only to the right upper limb.
ii.
Future prospects ought to have been granted at 40%, instead of 50%,
aligning themselves with the principles enunciated in National
Insurance Company Ltd. vs. Pranay Sethi & Ors. (2017) 16 SCC
680.
iii.
Contributory negligence ought to have been fastened on the claimant.
Digitally Signed
MAC.APP. 1018/2014 & MAC.APP. 419/2026
By:MANISH KUMAR
12:09:40
5.
Counsel for claimant/injured seeks enhancement on the ground that
notional income has been assessed on the basis of the minimum wages of an
unskilled worker at Rs. 6,422/- per month, despite the claimant being a
matriculate. It is contended that the notional income ought to have been
assessed on the basis of the minimum wages applicable to a matriculate, i.e.
Rs. 7,800/- per month.
6.
He further states that the Supreme Court in Jitendra v. Sadiya and
Ors. 2025 SCC Online SC 261, which was a case of amputation of the right
hand, assessed functional disability at 80%.
Analysis
7.
On the issue of contributory negligence, counsel for injured/claimant
points out to the order passed by this Court dated 20th August 2025, whereby
it was recorded that the only ground for challenge in the appeal is on grant
of future prospects, on the basis of submission made by counsel for appellant.
Order dated 20th August 2025 is extracted as under for ease of reference:
“1. Learned Counsel for the Appellant submits that the
only ground for challenge in the present Appeal is on
the grant of future prospects.”
(emphasis added)
8.
He further points out the order dated 18th September 2025, whereby
the Court has reiterated the limited ground of appeal raised by the Insurance
Company. Order dated 18th September 2025 is extracted as under for ease of
reference:
“Learned Counsel for the Appellant submits that his
challenge is based on the judgment passed by the
Supreme Court in National Insurance Company Ltd. v.
Pranay Sethi & Ors.; (2017) 16 SCC 680. The record
reflects however, that the Impugned Award was passed
Digitally Signed
MAC.APP. 1018/2014 & MAC.APP. 419/2026
By:MANISH KUMAR
12:09:40
prior to the judgment in Pranay Sethi case being
pronounced and based on the judgment of the Supreme
Court in Sarla Verma & Ors. v. DTC & Anr; (2009) 6
SCC 121, thus the only issue that arises in the present
Appeal is whether at the Appellate stage, this Court can
reduce the compensation awarded based on a change
in law after the Impugned Award has been passed.”
(emphasis added)
9.
Nevertheless, the plea of Insurance Company should be considered in
the interest of justice.
10.
As regards the assessment of functional disability, it is noted that the
disability certificate exhibited as Ex. PW1/L certifies that the claimant has
suffered 90% permanent disability in relation to the right upper limb (right
hand). In this regard, the testimony of the injured also needs to be noted,
wherein he has stated in detail the nature of the treatment he underwent. He
stated that immediately after the accident, he was admitted to Holy Family
Hospital and was thereafter shifted to Apollo Hospital on 24th September
2011, from where he was discharged on 05th October 2011. As per the
discharge summary, he had sustained a crushed injury at the right wrist with
no blood supply and sensation, along with crushed avulsion injury, resulting
in no blood supply and near-total amputation of the right hand with
devascularisation.
11.
He was again admitted on 24th October 2011 and discharged on 01st
November 2011. During this admission, he underwent debridement of the
necrotic skin. His treatment continued thereafter, and he was admitted to
Apollo Hospital again on 20th February 2012 and discharged on 21st February
2012, where he received post-replantation treatment. He was again admitted
Digitally Signed
MAC.APP. 1018/2014 & MAC.APP. 419/2026
By:MANISH KUMAR
12:09:40
to Apollo Hospital on 06th March 2013 and discharged on 09th March 2013.
He was treated for loss of the carpal on the ulna side, adduction deformity of
the wrist with contracture.
12.
He was again admitted in May 2013 and June 2013. The doctor noted
that it was a follow-up case of replantation of the right hand with a groin
flap. As the main blood supply to the thumb had been interrupted, he
underwent a right upper limb angiography on 15th March 2014, and his
treatment was advised to continue.
13.
In these circumstances, even though the MACT has assessed the
functional disability at 90% in the opinion of the court and considering the
principles enunciated in Raj Kumar v. Ajay Kumar (2011) 1 SCC 343, the
functional disability with respect to the body would have to be assessed at a
lower percentage.
14.
Reliance placed by counsel for claimant on Jitendra (supra) is
misplaced, as the claimant in that case was working as a labourer, unlike the
injured/claimant in the present case.
15.
Considering that, apart from the right hand, the rest of his functionality
was not affected, and further considering that the injured was only 16 years
of age and would have been capable of securing a vocation that did not
require excessive use of his right hand, therefore, the functional disability is
assessed at 75%.
16.
Future prospects shall be taken at 40%, in accordance with the
principles laid down in Pranay Sethi (supra), as the injured was 16 years of
age at the time of accident and did not have a permanent job.
Digitally Signed
MAC.APP. 1018/2014 & MAC.APP. 419/2026
By:MANISH KUMAR
12:09:40
17.
As regards the minimum wages, considering that the injured was a
matriculate, the notional income would be taken at the minimum wages of a
matriculate, which was Rs. 7,826/- per month at the relevant time.
18.
While computing the compensation, the MACT has awarded an
amount of Rs. 10,000/- under the head of loss of studies in paragraph no. 22
of the impugned award. However, while calculating the compensation in the
table contained in paragraph 28 of the impugned award, the said amount has
been considered under the head of loss of income. Considering there is no
separate head of loss of studies under the principles enunciated in Pranay
Sethi (supra) or Raj Kumar (supra), the award under that head cannot be
sustained. Nevertheless, the fact that the injured suffered loss of studies as a
consequence of the accident cannot be disregarded and must be accounted
for while determining just compensation under the appropriate recognised
heads. Accordingly, the impact of loss of studies is taken into consideration
while recomputing compensation under the appropriate heads, as under.
19.
Considering that the injured would have suffered loss of studies,
resulting in a corresponding loss of amenities, the compensation awarded
under the head of loss of amenities is enhanced from Rs. 50,000/- to Rs.
1,50,000/-.
20.
In light of the nature of the injuries suffered by the injured, the
prolonged treatment undergone by him, and the pain and trauma endured,
the compensation awarded under the head of pain and suffering is enhanced
to Rs. 1,50,000/-.
21.
The injured was only 16 years old at the time of the accident and has
Digitally Signed
MAC.APP. 1018/2014 & MAC.APP. 419/2026
By:MANISH KUMAR
12:09:40
suffered 90% permanent disability in relation to the right upper limb (right
hand). Considering his young age and the impact of the disability on his
future matrimonial prospects, the compensation awarded under the head of
loss of marriage prospects is enhanced to Rs. 1,50,000/-.
22.
Accordingly, the revised computation is as under:
Sr.
No.
Heads
1.
Expenditure on Medical Bills
and medical treatment (A)
Expenditure on conveyance,
and special diet (B)
Attendant Charges (C)
Income of injured per
month(E)
Loss of Income/Loss of
studies during treatment (C)
Add: Future prospects (F)
2.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
Awarded by the
Tribunal
PECUNIARY LOSS
Rs. 2,67,356/-
Rs. 2,67,356/-
Rs. 50,000/-
Rs. 50,000/-
Rs. 2,00,000/Rs. 6,422/-
Rs. 2,00,000/Rs. 7,826/-
Rs. 10,000/-
NIL
50%
40% of Rs. 7,826/- = Rs.
3,130.40
75%
Rs. 17,74,936.80/-
Multiplier (G)
Functional disability (H)
90%
Loss of future income/future
Rs. 18,72,656/earnings [(E+F) x 12 x G x H]
= (I)
NON- PECUNIARY LOSS
Pain and suffering (J)
Rs. 1,25,000/Loss of amenities of life (K)
Rs. 1,25,000/Rs.1,00,000/
Compensation
for
disfigurement (L)
Rs. 1,00,000/Compensation for marriage
prospects (M)
Total compensation (A + B +
Rs. 28,50,012/C + I+ J+ L + M) = N
Interest awarded
Reduced Compensation
Awarded by
this Court
Rs. 1,50,000/Rs. 1,50,000/Rs.1,00,000/
Rs. 1,50,000/-
Rs. 27,42,292.8/(rounded to Rs.
28,42,300/-)
9% per annum
9% per annum
Rs. 7,712/-
Digitally Signed
MAC.APP. 1018/2014 & MAC.APP. 419/2026
By:MANISH KUMAR
12:09:40
23.
Accordingly, the compensation is reduced by Rs. 7,712/-.
24.
Vide order dated 12th November 2014, the Court directed the Insurance
Company to deposit the entire awarded compensation along with accrued
interest and further directed release of 50% of the amount.
25.
The reduced compensation (originally awarded compensation –
revised computation) along with accrued interest thereon be refunded to the
Insurance Company.
26.
Accordingly, these appeals are disposed of in the above terms. Pending
applications, if any, are rendered infructuous.
27.
Statutory deposit, if any, shall be refunded to appellant/Insurance
Company.
28.
Copy of this judgment be sent to the concerned MACT/bank for
information and necessary compliance.
29.
Judgment be uploaded on the website of this Court.
(ANISH DAYAL)
JUDGE
AUGUST 04, 2026/vs/bp
Digitally Signed
MAC.APP. 1018/2014 & MAC.APP. 419/2026
By:MANISH KUMAR
12:09:40
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review