Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
$~3 & 4
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of decision: 23rd July 2026
%
(3)
+
MAC.APP. 602/2014
KAMLESH & ORS
Through:
.....Appellants
Mr. Navneet Goyal, Advocate.
versus
RAJENDRA SINGH & ORS
Through:
(4)
+
.....Respondents
Mr. Pradeep Gaur, Mr. Amit Gaur,
Mr. Kaarrtikey Parashar, Advocates
for
Respondent
no.3/Insurance
Company.
MAC.APP. 890/2014
UNITED INDIA INSURANCE CO LTD
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. Pradeep Gaur, Mr. Amit Gaur,
Mr. Kaarrtikey Parashar, Advocates.
versus
KAMLESH & ORS
Through:
.....Respondents
Mr. Navneet Goyal, Advocate.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANISH DAYAL
JUDGMENT
ANISH DAYAL, J (ORAL)
1.
These cross appeals have been filed assailing the impugned award
dated 28th April 2014 passed by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Rohini
Courts, Delhi (‘MACT/Tribunal’) in MACT No.454/2011, which awarded
MAC.APP. 602/2014 & MAC.APP. 890/2014
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:27:35
compensation of Rs.58,12,600/- along with 7.5% interest. While
MAC.APP.602/2014 has been filed by claimants for enhancement of
compensation, MAC.APP. 890/2014 has been filed by the Insurance
Company challenging the impugned award on account of contributory
negligence and quantum of compensation.
2.
The accident in question occurred on 11th October 2011 at about 04:00
a.m., when the deceased was travelling in a tempo bearing registration
no.UAO-8E-9408. When it reached the bridge near VIP Ghat in Haridwar,
Uttarakhand a truck bearing registration no. UP-07-FA-8641 (hereinafter,
‘offending vehicle’), driven by Rajendra Singh (‘driver’) allegedly in a rash
and negligent manner, hit against the tempo. Due to the accident, the
deceased sustained severe injuries and subsequently lost his life.
3.
The claim petition was filed by his legal heirs, i.e., his widow, two
minor children and two parents. The deceased was 34 years of age on the
date of accident and was working as an Assistant Manager with M/s Satyam
Auto Components on a monthly salary of Rs.35,006/-.
4.
Mr. Pradeep Gaur, counsel for Insurance Company, has raised three
points in support of his appeal; first, that income tax has not been deducted
on the notional income assessed by the MACT; second, that future prospects
ought to have been granted at 40%, instead of 50%, considering the deceased
was not in a permanent job and, in fact, was on probation; and third, that
composite negligence must be deducted at 50% on account of the head-on
collision which had occurred.
5.
On the other hand, Mr. Navneet Goyal, counsel for claimants, seeks
enhancement of notional income which has been assessed at Rs. 29,050/,
MAC.APP. 602/2014 & MAC.APP. 890/2014
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:27:35
while the deceased was drawing salary at Rs. 35,006/-. As regards future
prospects, he states that the deceased was extremely well qualified,
notwithstanding, that he had just started working at M/s Satyam Auto
Components, he would been in a consistent series of jobs which would show
that it was akin to a permanent job.
6.
In response for composite negligence arising out of head-on collision,
Mr. Goyal states that no evidence was put on record by the Insurance
Company, by either producing the driver of tempo in which the deceased was
travelling or the driver of truck/offending vehicle with which the collision
had occurred, therefore, no issue of composite negligence can be raised at
this stage. Moreover, composite negligence, if at all, would only provide a
right of recovery from the driver of truck/offending vehicle and not affect the
compensation awarded to the claimant.
7.
He also states that deduction towards personal expenses should have
been one fourth instead of one third, considering there were 4-5 dependants.
8.
On the issue of benchmark income, MACT assessed the same on the
basis of evidence of Mr. Satish Kumar Saluja, Assistant Manager, M/s
Satyam Auto Components (‘PW2’) where the deceased was working. He had
produced the employment/service record of deceased and stated that he was
drawing a salary of Rs.35,006/- per month. Relying upon the wage sheet,
exhibited as Ex.PW2/5 and the cross examination of PW2, MACT noted that
salary for the month of September 2011 was Rs. 29,050/- from which an
amount of Rs. 1,848/- had been deducted towards provident fund (‘PF’) and
Rs. 440/- had been deducted towards food coupon. Accordingly, an amount
of Rs. 26,762/- had been credited in the account of deceased. Further
MAC.APP. 602/2014 & MAC.APP. 890/2014
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:27:35
amounts towards magazine reimbursement, medical reimbursement, leave
travel allowance (‘LTA’) reimbursement were given, on the basis of
submission of actual bills by the deceased, along with the bonus which was
payable on an annual basis. It was admitted that, the appointment letter did
not find any mention that he was entitled to increment in his salary.
Accordingly, benchmark income was taken at Rs.29,050/- per month by the
MACT.
9.
The salary slip of deceased dated 1st November 2011, for the period of
1st September 2011 till 10th October 2011 has been exhibited as Ex.PW2/3
and the bifurcation is given as under:
Description
Amount (Rs.)
Basic Salary
15,400.00/-
House Rent Allowance
7,700.00/-
Children Education Allowance 600.00/-
10.
Washing Allowance
800.00/-
Conveyance Allowance
800.00/-
Membership Allowance
150.00/-
Performance Bonus
3,600.00/-
Magazine Reimbursement
275.00/-
Phone Reimbursement
600.00/-
Medical Reimbursement
1,250.00/-
LTA Reimbursement
1,283.00/-
PF
1,848.00/-
Bonus
700.00/-
TOTAL
35,006.00/-
The issue of allowances has been considered by this Court in E. Neeta
Devi & Ors. v. Ashwani Kumar & Ors. 2026:DHC:5184 where the Court
MAC.APP. 602/2014 & MAC.APP. 890/2014
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:27:35
traversed through a line of judgments, inter alia, National Insurance Co.
Ltd. v. Indira Srivastava & Ors. (2008) 2 SCC 763, Meenakshi v. Oriental
Insurance Co. Ltd. 2024 SCC OnLine SC 1872 Manorma Sinha v.
Divisional Manager Oriental Insurance Ltd. 2025 SCC OnLine SC 2241
holding that deductions which accrue to the benefit of the family, have to be
taken into account for the purposes of income. Principles culled out by the
Court in E. Neeta Devi (supra) are extracted as under:
“36. Principles which can be culled out from the above
decisions are enunciated as under:
(i) Income is not limited to the pay packet carried
home by an employee, but also allowances which
are beneficial to the members of the entire family
shall be considered as part of the pay packet.
(ii)
Allowances
such
as
transport
allowance/conveyance allowance, house rent
allowance, provident fund contribution and special
allowances which are fixed pro-rata with reference
to the basic salary will be included before
assessment of future prospects.
…
(vi) Salary may be bifurcated by employer into
diverse heads, however, while calculating
compensation arising out of the death of the
employee, various entitlements received by the
employee have to be considered.”
(emphasis added)
11.
Accordingly, on the basis of the salary slip, this Court is inclined to
include allowances towards house rent allowance (‘HRA’), children’s
education,
washing
allowance,
conveyance
allowance,
magazine
reimbursement, phone reimbursement and PF to the basic salary. Additional
bonus which has been given at Rs.700/- will not be taken into account,
considering it is possibly an additional amount given separately.
MAC.APP. 602/2014 & MAC.APP. 890/2014
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:27:35
Accordingly, the salary of deceased will be taken at Rs. 28,023/- per month
and Rs. 3,36,276/- annually.
12.
As regards deduction towards income tax, the tax slab which was
prevalent during financial year (‘FY’) 2011-2012 was ‘Nil: Upto Rs.
1,80,000/-’ and ‘10%: Rs. 1,80,000/- to 5,00,000/-’ accordingly, tax will be
deducted at Rs. 15,627.6/-. Therefore, annual income of deceased will be
assessed at Rs. 3,20,649/13.
Personal and living expenses have been wrongly deducted by the
MACT at 1/3rd considering that there were five legal heirs. Even if the father
of deceased is not taken as a dependent, even then the deduction ought to
have been 1/4th considering the mother of deceased to be a dependent.
14.
As regards future prospects, the Court is in agreement with the plea
raised by Insurance Company that 40% should have been awarded,
particularly taking into account the testimony of PW2, who stated that
deceased was appointed on probation for a period of six months and was
under probation, at the time of his death.
15. To this extent, reliance may be placed upon the decision of Madhya
Pradesh High Court in Anjum Ansari v. R. Rajesh Rao, 2024 SCC OnLine
MP 9613 where the Court held that, in view of the principles laid down in
National Insurance Co. Ltd v. Pranay Sethi (2017) 16 SCC 680, it is not
correct to state that only a government servant would be treated as having a
permanent job. The Madhya Pradesh High Court noted that the deceased was
working as an Assistant Professor at Corporate Institute of Science &
Technology, Bhopal, and that the salary drawn by the deceased was subject
to periodic revisions/hikes, therefore, he was considered to be in permanent
MAC.APP. 602/2014 & MAC.APP. 890/2014
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:27:35
job. The relevant paragraphs are extracted hereinbelow.
“8. In this court's opinion, above issue stands settled by
Five Judges Bench of Hon'ble Apex Court in National
Insurance Company Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi, (2017) 16
SCC 680 : AIR 2017 SC 5157 as under:—
55. “Presently, we come to the issue of addition of
future prospects to determine the multiplicand.
56. In Santosh Devi ((2012) 6 SCC 421 : AIR 2012
SC 2185) the Court has not accepted as a principle
that a self-employed person remains on a fixed
salary throughout his life. It has taken note of the
rise in the cost of living which affects everyone
without making any distinction between the rich
and the poor. Emphasis has been laid on the extra
efforts made by this category of persons to
generate additional income. That apart, judicial
notice has been taken of the fact that the salaries of
those who are employed in private sectors also
with the passage of time increase manifold. In
Rajesh s case, the Court had added 15% in the case
where the victim is between the age group of 15 to
60 years so as to make the compensation just,
equitable, fair and reasonable. This addition has
been made in respect of self-employed or engaged
on fixed wages.
57.………. In such an adjudication, the duty of the
tribunal and the courts is difficult and hence, an
endeavour has been made by this Court for
standardisation which in its ambit includes
addition of future prospects on the proven income
at present As far as future prospects are concerned,
them has been standardisation keeping in view the
principle of certainty, stability and consistency. We
approve the principle of “standardisation” so that
a specific and certain multiplicand is determined
for applying the multiplier on the basis of age.
59. Having bestowed our anxious consideration,
we are disposed to think when we accept the
MAC.APP. 602/2014 & MAC.APP. 890/2014
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:27:35
principle of standardisation, there is really no
rationale not to apply the said principle to the selfemployed or a person who is on a fixed salary. To
follow the doctrine of actual income at the time of
death and not to add any amount with regard to
future prospects to the income for the purpose of
determination of multiplicand would be unjust The
determination of income while computing
compensation has to include future prospects so
that the method will come within the ambit and
sweep of just compensation as postulated under
Section 168 of the Act In case of a deceased who
had held a permanent job with inbuilt grant of
annual increment, there is an acceptable certainty.
But to slate that the legal representatives of a
deceased who was on a fixed salary would not be
entitled to the benefit of future prospects for the
purpose of computation of compensation would be
inapposite. It is because the criterion of distinction
between the two in that event would be certainty on
the one hand and staticness on the other. One may
perceive that the comparative measure is certainty
on the one hand and uncertainty on the other but
such a perception is fallacious. It is because the
price rise does affect a self-employed person; and
that apart there is always an incessant effort to
enhance one's income for sustenance. The
purchasing capacity of a salaried person on
permanent job when increases because of grant of
increments and pay revision or for some other
change in service conditions, there is always a
competing attitude in the private sector to enhance
the salary to get better efficiency from the
employees. Similarly, a person who is selfemployed is bound to gamer his resources and
raise his charges/fees so that he can live with same
facilities. To have the perception that he is likely to
remain static and his income to remain stagnant is
contrary to the fundamental concept of human
MAC.APP. 602/2014 & MAC.APP. 890/2014
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:27:35
attitude which always intends to live with
dynamism and move and change with the time.
Though it may seem appropriate that there cannot
be certainty in addition of future prospects to the
existing income unlike in the case of a person
having a permanent job yet the said perception
does not really deserve acceptance. We are
inclined to think that there can be some degree of
difference as regards the percentage that is meant
for or applied to in respect of the legal
representatives who claim on behalf of the
deceased who had a permanent job than a person
who is self-employed or on a fixed salary. But not
to apply the principle of standardisation on the
foundation of perceived lack of certainty would
tantamount to remaining oblivious to the marrows
of ground reality………
61. In view of the aforesaid analysis, we proceed to
record our conclusions:
(i)
XXX
XXX
XXX
XXX
(ii) XXX
XXX
XXX
XXX
(iii) While determining the income, an addition of
50% of actual salary to the income of the deceased
towards future prospects, where the deceased had
a permanent job and was below the age of 40 years,
should be made. The addition should be 30%, if the
age of the deceased was between 40 to 50 years. In
case the deceased was between the age of 50 to 60
years, the addition should be 15%. Actual salary
should be read as actual salary less tax.
(iv) In case the deceased was self-employed or on
a fixed salary, an addition of 40% of the
established income should be the warrant where
the deceased was below the age of 40 years. An
addition of 25% where the deceased was between
the age of 40 to 50 years and 10% where the
deceased was between the age of 50 to 60 years
should be regarded as the necessary method of
computation…………….”
MAC.APP. 602/2014 & MAC.APP. 890/2014
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:27:35
9. Thus, from observations as well as principle of law
laid down by Hon'ble Apex Court in Pranay
Sethi (Supra), it is clearly evident that if a person is in
such a job wherein his salary is increased
periodically/receives annual increment etc., then, such
person would be treated as being in “permanent job”.
Hence, in view of principle of law laid down in Pranay
Sethi (Supra), it is not correct that only government
servant would be treated as being in “permanent job”
(emphasis added)
16.
However, in the case at hand, there was no documentary proof to show
that deceased could claim any increment in his salary. Consistent jobs in
various companies on the basis of a professional degree, in the opinion of
this Court, cannot be treated as a permanent job. Therefore, the plea raised
by Insurance Company is accepted to that extent.
17.
As regards the issue of negligence, it would have been up to the
Insurance Company to prove that there was composite negligence. No site
plan has been placed on record. The Mechanical Inspection Report (‘MIR’)
noted damage on the driver’s side of the truck/offending vehicle and apart
from that, nothing much can be ascertained in terms of whose negligence
was it on the basis of MIR. Every head on collision, in the opinion of this
Court, cannot automatically lead to a 50% composite negligence, but has to
be proved on the basis of evidence. Driver of the tempo is not a part of the
proceedings, either before the MACT or in the appeal, therefore, no evidence
has been brought on record for the Court’s assessment.
18.
Driver of the truck/offending vehicle has been impleaded in the
proceedings as respondent no.1 in MAC.APP. 602/2014 and respondent no.6.
in MAC.APP. 890/2014, however, he has not joined the proceedings. Even
MAC.APP. 602/2014 & MAC.APP. 890/2014
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:27:35
before the MACT, a written statement was filed but no testimony was given.
Steps have not been taken by the Insurance Company before the MACT or
even in this appeal, therefore, the claim for composite negligence cannot be
raised at this stage.
19.
Moreover, it has been pointed out by Mr. Navneet Goyal, counsel for
claimants, that charge-sheet has been filed against the driver of
truck/offending truck and the driver of tempo has not been challaned. Even
the testimony of PW3, who was an eye-witness to the accident, does not elicit
anything in favour of Mr. Gaur’s submissions.
20.
Quite to the contrary, PW3’s testimony seems to suggest that the
tempo was being driven on the left side of the road and the truck/offending
vehicle came from the opposite direction. The accident took place on a bridge
where there was no divider, width of the road was 22 meters and there was
no other vehicle nearby. The truck/offending vehicle had been seized on the
spot and PW3 had remained on the spot and had even accompanied the
deceased to the hospital. Therefore, the testimony was credible. Nothing
further was elicited in the cross-examination to suggest that the driver of
tempo was also driving in a rash and negligent manner. Therefore, this plea
is rejected.
21.
Further alignments with respect to loss of consortium, loss of estate,
funeral expenses and loss of love and affection shall be made in respect of
decisions of the Supreme Court in Pranay Sethi (supra) and United India
Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Satinder Kaur, (2021) 11 SCC 780. These heads shall
be assessed at:
“Loss of consortium = Rs. 2,00,000/- (Rs. 40,000 x 5)
MAC.APP. 602/2014 & MAC.APP. 890/2014
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:27:35
Loss of love and affection= Nil
Funeral expenses= Rs. 15,000/Loss of estate= Rs. 15,000/-”
22.
Accordingly, revised computation is as under:
S.
No.
Heads
Income of deceased (A)
Awarded by the
Tribunal
Rs. 29,050/-
Awarded by this
Court
Rs. 26,721/(Rs. 3,20,649/-÷12)
Add: Future Prospects (B)
Rs. 14,525/-
Rs. 10,688/-
Less: Personal expenses of
deceased (C)
Rs. 14,525/-
Rs. 9,353/-
Loss of dependency (A+B)-C=D
Rs. 29,050/-
Rs. 28,056/-
Annual loss of dependency (D x
12)= (E)
Multiplier (F)
Total loss of dependency (E x F)=
(G)
Compensation for loss of
consortium (H)
Rs. 3,48,600/-
Rs. 3,36,672/-
Rs. 55,77,600/-
Rs. 53,86,752/-
Rs. 1,00,000/-
Rs. 2,00,000/-
Loss of love and affection (I)
Rs. 1,00,000/-
Nil
Compensation for loss of estate
(J)
Compensation towards funeral
expenses (K)
Rs. 10,000/-
Rs. 15,000/-
Rs. 25,000/-
Rs. 15,000/-
Total compensation
(G+H+I+J=K)= L
Rate of Interest Awarded
Rs. 58,12,600/-
Rs. 56,16,752/-
7.5%
7.5%
Directions
23.
Accordingly, the compensation has been reduced by Rs. 1,95,848/-
[‘reduced compensation’]
MAC.APP. 602/2014 & MAC.APP. 890/2014
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:27:35
24.
By order dated 29th September 2014, this Court had directed the
Insurance Company to deposit the entire compensation along with accrued
interest before the Registrar General of this Court and release of 60% amount
in favour of claimants, in accordance with the directions of the MACT in the
impugned award.
25.
Considering that compensation has been reduced, it is directed that the
excess compensation (original compensation – reduced compensation),
along with accrued interest, be refunded to Insurance Company. Balance
amount, along with accrued interest, shall be released to claimants as a
lumpsum considering that the appeal is of 2014, and much time has been
passed.
26.
Appeals are disposed of in the above terms.
27.
Pending applications, if any, are rendered infructuous.
28.
Copy of this judgment be sent to the concerned Bank for information
and compliance.
29.
Statutory deposit, if any, shall be refunded to Insurance Company,
only if the order of deposit has been complied with.
30.
Judgment be uploaded on the website of this Court.
(ANISH DAYAL)
JUDGE
JULY 23, 2026/ak/sp
MAC.APP. 602/2014 & MAC.APP. 890/2014
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:27:35
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review