Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of decision: 12th May 2026.
%
+
MAC.APP. 939/2015
UNITED INDIA INSURANCE CO. LTD.
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. Pankaj Seth, Advocate with
Ms. Shruti Jain, Advocate.
versus
KALPANA PANDEY & ORS.
.....Respondent
Through: Mr. S.N. Parashar, Advocate with
Mr. Ritik Singh, Advocate for
respondent nos. 1 to 3.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANISH DAYAL
JUDGMENT
%
ANISH DAYAL, J :(ORAL)
CM APPL. 23608/2026 (for early hearing)
1.
This application has been filed by the respondent nos.1-3 seeking
early hearing of the appeal.
2.
In view of what has been stated in the application, application is
allowed and disposed of.
MAC.APP. 939/2015
1.
This appeal has been filed by the Insurance Company challenging
the award dated 04th August 2015 passed by the Motor Accident Claims
Tribunal, Rohini Courts, Delhi (‘MACT/Tribunal’) in Suit No.
259/2013, awarding compensation of Rs.51,83,640/- along with interest
KUMAR CHOUDHARY MAC. APP. 939/2015
17:07:38
@9% per annum.
2.
Mr. Pankaj Seth, counsel for the Insurance Company, raises issue
on computation of the compensation on the following counts: firstly, that
the notional income was taken at Rs.23,463/- per month on the basis of
the salary certificate but included all the variable perks which should not
have been considered and ought to have been deducted; secondly, that
the MACT wrongly deducted 1/4th towards personal expenses instead of
1/3rd, despite the mother of the deceased having passed away during the
pendency of the proceedings (in 2011), leaving behind only three
dependents and not four; thirdly, that future prospects at 50% ought not
to have been granted, considering the deceased was in private
employment and, therefore, future prospects at 40% should be granted as
per the principles enunciated in National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pranay
Sethi and Ors. (2017) 16 SCC 680; and lastly, that other elements of
compensation are also required to be aligned in accordance with the
principles enunciated in Pranay Sethi (supra).
3.
As regards the issue of deduction towards personal expenses, Mr.
S. N. Parashar, counsel for claimants, draws attention of this Court to a
decision in IIFCO Tokio Gen. Ins. Co. Ltd v. Sh. Anil Kumar Kaushik
& Ors 2026:DHC:2695, where a similar situation had been dealt with by
this Court. Herein also the dependent at the time of the accident was
alive, however, subsequently passed away during the pendency of
proceedings.
4.
This Court relied upon the decision of the Supreme Court in Kirti
and Another v. Oriental Insurance Company (2021) 2 SCC 166,
particularly on paragraph 9, to hold that the deduction towards personal
KUMAR CHOUDHARY MAC. APP. 939/2015
17:07:38
expenses has to be considered on the basis of the status of the family and
the number of dependants on the date of death of the deceased. Relevant
paragraph of Kirti (supra) is extracted as under:
“I. Deduction for personal expenses
9. We have thoughtfully considered the rival
submissions. It cannot be disputed that at the time of
death, there in fact were four dependants of the
deceased and not three. The subsequent death of the
deceased's dependant mother ought not to be a reason
for reduction of motor accident compensation. Claims
and legal liabilities crystallise at the time of the
accident itself, and changes post thereto ought not to
ordinarily affect pending proceedings. Just like how
the appellant claimants cannot rely upon subsequent
increases in minimum wages, the respondent insurer
too cannot seek benefit of the subsequent death of a
dependant during the pendency of legal proceedings.
Similarly, any concession in law made in this regard
by either counsel would not bind the parties, as it is
legally settled that advocates cannot throw away legal
rights or enter into arrangements contrary to law.”
(emphasis added)
5.
In Anil Kumar Kaushik (supra), the conclusion drawn is as under:
“19.
Calculation of compensation in cases where
there is subsequent death of a parent has also been dealt
with by the Coordinate Bench of this Court in Rajwant
Kaur v. Rakesh Kumar, 2025 SCC OnLine Del 3414
where the claim petition was filed by widow, minor
children and father of the deceased, who had expired
during the pendency of claim proceedings. Placing
reliance on the decision of Supreme Court in Kirti
(supra), this Court overturned the findings of the
Tribunal to the extent where 1/3rd had been deducted on
account of personal and living expenses. Relevant
observations of the Court are extracted as under:
“12. In the present case, the deceased was
survived by his wife, two minor children, and
KUMAR CHOUDHARY MAC. APP. 939/2015
17:07:38
his father—who was originally impleaded as
a claimant and declared to be wholly
dependent in the affidavit (Ex. PW1/A).
Although the father of the deceased passed
away during the pendency of the claim,
dependency at the time of the accident is the
relevant consideration for this computation
and the fact remains that on the date the
cause of action arose there were four
claimants.
13. The learned Tribunal failed to appreciate
this legal position and thus erred in applying
the deduction of one-third instead of onefourth. The same is liable to be corrected.”
20. In the present case, finding of the Tribunal as
regards the issue of dependency is extracted as under:
“22. It was contended by Ld. counsel for the
respondent no.3 that the mother of deceased
has died during the proceedings and the
petitioner is not financially dependent on the
deceased, so in view of the law laid down in
the case of Saria Verma (Supra), the
petitioner is not entitled to compensation.
towards Loss of Dependency. I do not agree
with this contention as at the time of the death
of deceased, the mother of the deceased was
alive. Even otherwise, he would have
contributed to the income of the family. He
could be the source of survival for his father
at his old age.”
21. In the present case, the claim petition had been filed
by mother of deceased, as also the police complaint.
While she subsequently passed away during the
pendency of the proceedings, the Tribunal has rightly
granted loss of dependency, considering that she was
alive when the accident took place and her subsequent
death would not make a difference and she would be
considered a dependent. However, father of deceased
KUMAR CHOUDHARY MAC. APP. 939/2015
17:07:38
being 40 years of age at the time of accident, would not
be a considered to be dependent on his minor son.”
(emphasis added)
6.
Considering that this view has already been taken by this Court,
the argument of the appellant/Insurance Company, in this regard, cannot
be accepted since at the date of the accident, the mother of the deceased
was alive.
7.
Mr. Pankaj Seth, counsel for the appellant, vehemently countered
this issue on the ground that the name of the mother of the deceased had
been deleted from the array of parties before the MACT and, therefore,
neither compensation in her favour nor loss of dependency was
considered.
8.
On this account, he has contended that, for the purpose of
deduction towards personal expenses, the mother ought not to be taken
into account as a dependent. However, in view of the decisions of the
Supreme Court in Kirti (supra) and this Court in Anil Kumar Kaushik
(supra), the deletion of the mother as a claimant may not affect the
assessment of notional income, which has to be made in reference to the
date of the accident.
9.
Loss of dependency no doubt is calculated on the basis of the
notional income, however, it is also noted that no compensation has been
granted in the name of the mother of the deceased.
10.
The MACT has granted compensation only to the widow and the
two children in the ratio of 50:25:25. This was also confirmed by the
order of this Court dated 08th February 2016.
11.
As regards deduction of allowances, the Court has examined the
salary certificate and is inclined to accept the plea of the Insurance
KUMAR CHOUDHARY MAC. APP. 939/2015
17:07:38
Company, considering that the variable perks under the head of Oil
Incentive, Mobile Allowance, Vehicle Maintenance Allowance, Medical
Allowance, and Bonus are not only classified as “variable” but are also
not for the benefit of the family.
12.
Therefore, keeping this in mind, these allowances should not have
been taken as part of the notional income, and the same shall stand
deducted from the notional income. Accordingly, the notional income of
the deceased will be Rs. 20,512/- per month.
13.
As regards the issue of future prospect, there is no doubt that the
deceased was in private employment, and whether future prospects at
50% or 40% are to be considered will depend on the permanency of the
job of the deceased.
14.
To this effect, Mr. Parashar has drawn attention, firstly, to the
testimony of PW2, Manager (Administration), M/s Svam Power Plants
Pvt. Ltd., recorded on SA. It was stated that the deceased was serving in
the company as Assistant Manager in 2007. His service record, including
his salary slips, appointment letter, promotion letter, increment policy,
provident fund, and joining letter, had been placed on record.
15.
Secondly, it was stated in his testimony that every employee of the
company was entitled to 50% increase in gross salary as annual
increment and that the work of the deceased was satisfactory. It was
further stated that the deceased would have been promoted as Senior
Manager getting a salary of Rs. 45,000/- per month (gross) in case he
was in service.
16.
Thirdly, it was stated that the deceased was in service since 2007
prior to the accident.
KUMAR CHOUDHARY MAC. APP. 939/2015
17:07:38
17.
This Court in the Uttar Pradesh State Road Transport
Corporation v. Rajender Singh and Ors. 2026:DHC:2693, wherein the
Court relying upon salary slips, letter of traineeship, appointment letters,
and
progressive career plan of the deceased, which shows that the
deceased’s salary was consistently increasing, and relying on the
judgment of High Court of Madhya Pradesh at Jabalpur in Anjum
Ansari v. R. Rajesh Rao 2024 SCC OnLine MP 9613, held that since the
deceased was below 40 years of age and had a fixed income job in a
private company, therefore, future prospects should be 50%.
18.
In the present case, considering the testimony of PW2 and the
documents placed on record before the Tribunal, it is evident that, had
the deceased continued in service, he would have received regular
increments. In light of the judgments in Rajender Singh (supra) and
Anjum Ansari (supra), this Court is of the considered opinion that the
Tribunal rightly applied future prospects at 50%.
19.
On the basis of principles enunciated in National Insurance Co.
Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi and Ors. (2017) 16 SCC 680, the following will be
altered:
i.
Loss of love and affection ought not to be granted on the basis of
the principles enunciated in United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v.
Satinder Kaur @ Satwinder Kaur and Ors. (2021) 11 SCC 780;
ii.
Funeral expenses ought to be Rs. 15,000/- instead of Rs. 25,000/-;
iii.
Loss of consortium will be Rs. 40,000/- x 3 = 1,20,000/- instead
of Rs. 10,000/-;
iv.
Loss of estate will be Rs. 15,000/-.
20.
Revised compensation, therefore, is as under:
KUMAR CHOUDHARY MAC. APP. 939/2015
17:07:38
Sr. No. Heads
1.
Monthly income of the
deceased (A)
2.
Add-Future Prospects (B)
Awarded by the
Tribunal
Rs. 23,463/-
Awarded by the
Court
Rs. 20,512/-
50% of Rs.
17,597.25 = Rs.
8,798.63/-*
50% of Rs.
20,512/- = Rs.
30,768/1/4th of Rs.
30,768/- = Rs.
7,692/Rs. 2,76,912/-
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
*These
Less-personal expenses of the
deceased (C)
Annual loss of dependency
[(A+B) - C ] x 12= D]
Multiplier (E)
Total loss of dependency (D x
E) = (F)
Compensation for loss of love
and affection (G)
Compensation for loss of
consortium (H)
Compensation for loss of estate
(I)
Compensation towards funeral
expenses (J)
Total Compensation
(F+G+H+I+J = K)
Interest Awarded
Reduced Compensation
1/4th of Rs. 23,463/= Rs. 5,865.75/-*
Rs. 3,15,540/-*
Rs. 44,30,592/-
Rs. 50,48,640/Nil
Rs. 1,00,000/Rs. 10,000/-
Rs. 1,20,000/-
Nil
Rs. 15,000/-
Rs. 25,000/-
Rs. 15,000/-
Rs. 51,83,640/-
Rs. 45,80,592/-
9% per annum
Rs. 6,03,048/-
9% per annum
components have been wrongly calculated by the Tribunal, as the Tribunal has
inadvertently first reduced the personal expenses and then later added future prospects to them.
However, the same has been corrected by this Court in the revised computation.
21.
Accordingly, the compensation is reduced by Rs. 6,03,048/-.
22.
By order dated 18th December 2015, this Court directed the
Insurance Company to deposit the awarded amount with the Registrar
General of this Court. Further, direction was passed for release of 50%
of the amount in terms of the Award.
23.
The balance compensation as per the revised compensation be
KUMAR CHOUDHARY MAC. APP. 939/2015
17:07:38
released to the claimants as per the scheme in the impugned award, and
the reduced amount be refunded to the Insurance Company, along with
accrued interest.
24.
Accordingly, the appeal is disposed of. Pending applications are
rendered infructuous.
25.
Statutory
deposit,
if
any,
shall
be
refunded
to
the
appellant/Insurance Company.
26.
Copy of this judgment be sent to the UCO Bank, High Court of
Delhi Branch for information and necessary compliance.
27.
Judgment be uploaded on the website of this Court.
(ANISH DAYAL)
JUDGE
MAY 12, 2026/RK/bp
KUMAR CHOUDHARY MAC. APP. 939/2015
17:07:38
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review