Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 16.12.2025
Pronounced on: 12.01.2026
+
W.P.(C) 4366/2014
UNION OF INDIA
Through:
..... Petitioner
Mr. Ruchir Mishra, Mr. Sanjiv
Kumar Saxena, Mr. Mukesh
Kumar Tiwari, Ms. Reba Jena
Mishra and Ms. Poonam
Shukla, Advs.
versus
VED PAL SINGH & ANR.
Through:
..... Respondents
Mr. A.K. Trivedi, Adv.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE NAVIN CHAWLA
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE MADHU JAIN
JUDGMENT
NAVIN CHAWLA, J.
1.
This petition has been filed by the petitioner, challenging the
Order dated 03.12.2013 passed by the learned Central Administrative
Tribunal, Principal Bench, New Delhi (hereinafter referred to as the
„Tribunal‟) in O.A. 1020/2012, titled Ved Pal Singh v. Union of India
& Anr., whereby the learned Tribunal allowed the said O.A. filed by
the respondent no.1 herein with the following directions:
“23. In the above facts and circumstances of
the case, we allow this OA. Consequently, we
quash and set aside the impugned order dated
29.11.2011, charge sheet dated 13.12.2002,
Inquiry Officer's report dated 29.11.2005. The
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 4366/2014
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
respondents shall release the entire withheld
monthly pension, gratuity and any other
pensionary benefits to the Applicant with
interest at GPF rate. The aforesaid directions
shall be complied with, within a period of 2
months from the date of receipt of a copy of
this order.”
BRIEF FACTS OF THE CASE:
2.
To give a brief background of the facts giving rise to the present
petition, the respondent no.1 joined the Delhi Administration on
16.11.1965. He was promoted and appointed to Grade-I of the Delhi
Administrative Subordinate Services (DASS) on a regular basis on
28.06.1980, which was a Gazetted Group „B‟ post. Thereafter, under
Rule 25(3) of the Delhi, Andaman & Nicobar Islands, Lakshadweep,
Daman & Diu, and Dadra & Nagar Haveli Civil Service Rules,
(DANICS Rules) 1971, he was promoted and appointed on ad-hoc
basis against a duty post in the DANICS Civil Service, vide Order No.
F.30/18/89-SI
dated
22.01.1990.
The
respondent
no.1
was
subsequently regularised in the said post vide Notification No.
14016/8/2000-UTS-II dated 21.08.2001, issued by the Ministry of
Home Affairs, Government of India, pursuant to his selection by the
Departmental Promotion Committee with the approval of the Union
Public
Service
Commission
(UPSC).
The
respondent
no.1
superannuated on 31.12.2002 from the post of Assistant Registrar in
the office of the Registrar, Cooperative Societies, Government of
Delhi.
3.
In the year 1996, a Memorandum dated 30.05.1996 was issued
to him alleging irregular issuance of 26 ST-1 forms and 355 ST-35
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 4366/2014
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
forms to M/s Pilco Systems, and 25 ST-1 forms and 40 ST-35 forms
to M/s Krishna Stores, allegedly without ensuring adequate safeguards
for Government revenue.
4.
The respondent no.1 replied to the said Memorandum vide
representation dated 10.06.1996, explaining that the ST-1 forms
allegedly issued to M/s Pilco Systems on 28.09.1987 and 29.07.1988,
and the ST-35 forms allegedly issued on 29.07.1988, 19.08.1988, and
30.09.1988, were issued strictly in accordance with the applicable
rules and under written orders of the then Sales Tax Officer (STO),
Shri P. R. Meena, and not on the respondent‟s own direction. The
respondent no. 1 further claimed that the dealers concerned were
regular dealers who had been issued such forms earlier as well. The
respondent no.1 also pointed out that, at the relevant time, he was
overburdened with work due to frequent changes of Sales Tax
Officers (STOs) and was required to handle both „A‟ and „B‟ category
cases, in addition to the alphabetical division of work.
5.
It is the case of the respondent no.1 that after submission of his
reply, the authorities allegedly found the explanation satisfactory and
took no further action for over six years, during which period the
respondent no.1 was granted all due promotions.
6.
It is the case of the respondent no.1 that, however, after an
inordinate delay of about 14–15 years from the alleged incidents, and
merely a few days prior to his retirement, a major penalty charge-sheet
was issued by the Chief Secretary, Government of NCT of Delhi, vide
Memorandum dated 13.12.2002. It was alleged therein that during the
years 1987 and 1988, while working as Assistant Sales Tax Officer
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 4366/2014
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
(ASTO) in the erstwhile Ward No. 23 (New Ward No. 54) of the Sales
Tax Department, the respondent no.1 had issued ST-1 and ST-35
forms in quick succession to M/s Pilco Systems and M/s Krishna
Stores without getting their transactions verified through lower
functionaries and without invoking Section 18 of the Delhi Sales Tax
Act, 1975 for enhancement of sureties, thereby allegedly causing loss
to Government revenue.
7.
It is the case of the respondent no.1 that immediately upon
receipt of the charge-sheet, he denied the allegations vide letter dated
20.12.2002 and sought supply of the listed documents, including the
applications filed by the dealers for statutory forms, ST-II accounts,
relevant instructions/orders, and inspection of the dealers‟ files. He
also objected to the initiation of disciplinary proceedings after an
unexplained delay of nearly 15 years, particularly on the eve of his
retirement. Despite repeated reminders dated 26.12.2002, 20.01.2003,
03.04.2003, and 17.04.2003, the documents supplied were illegible,
smudged, and blackened, rendering them unusable for the purpose of
defence, and clear and legible copies were never supplied to him.
8.
It is further the case of the respondent no.1 that he was
subjected to discrimination, as no action was taken against other
officers who had similarly issued statutory forms to the same dealers,
including Shri P.R. Meena, the then STO, on whose written directions
the impugned forms were issued by the respondent no.1 in good faith.
9.
It is the case of the respondent no.1 that the inordinate and
unexplained delay in issuing the charge-sheet caused grave and
irreparable prejudice to him. Due to the passage of time, it became
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 4366/2014
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
impossible to recall the exact instructions, prevailing practices, and
circumstances under which the forms were issued. Relevant records
and instructions were no longer available, and contemporaneous
officers were also unavailable to testify, thereby seriously impairing
the respondent‟s defence.
10.
It is the case of the respondent no.1 that he consistently
maintained that the issuance of statutory forms was strictly in
accordance with Rule 8 of the Delhi Sales Tax Rules and Circular
Nos. 10 of 1985–86 and 18 of 1988–89, which permitted the issuance
of forms for past as well as future transactions, and that deductible
sales were clearly defined under Sections 4, 5, 7, and 8 of the Delhi
Sales Tax Act, 1975.
11.
Aggrieved by the issuance of the charge-sheet, the respondent
no.1 filed O.A. No. 1768/2003. The said O.A. was disposed of by the
learned Tribunal by its order dated 11.11.2003, granting liberty to the
respondent no.1 to make a representation on the issue of prejudice
caused by delay to the Disciplinary Authority. In compliance thereof,
the respondent no.1 submitted representations dated 03.03.2004 to the
Chief Secretary and the Joint Secretary (UT–Delhi), which remained
unanswered.
12.
Thereafter, the respondent no.1 filed another O.A., being O.A.
No. 1174/2005 before the learned Tribunal, which was dismissed vide
Order dated 05.04.2005, with liberty to raise all issues during the
disciplinary proceedings and before appropriate forums thereafter.
13.
The respondent no.1 challenged the said order by filing W.P.(C)
No. 12808/2005, which was disposed of vide judgment dated
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 4366/2014
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
25.08.2005, with following directions:
“We are satisfied that the petitioner should be
given an opportunity to cross-examine
witnesses of the prosecution and examine
himself in the proceeding as a defence witness.
At the same time, we do not desire that there
should be any delay in completing the
departmental proceeding. We are informed
that in the ex-parte proceeding conducted,
inquiry report has already been submitted by
the inquiry officer to the Disciplinary
Authority without affording a proper
opportunity to the petitioner to cross examine
the prosecution witnesses and also to examine
himself as defence witness. In that view of the
matter, the inquiry report which is submitted is
directed to be recalled and after cross
examination of the prosecution witnesses and
examination of the petitioner as defence
witness, a fresh inquiry report on the basis of
the record and the evidence adduced shall be
submitted by the Inquiry Officer. Thereafter, it
shall be open to the Disciplinary Authority to
proceed in the matter in accordance with law.
The petitioner shall have the liberty to
examine the record of the disciplinary
proceeding on 8th September, 2005. We direct
that the prosecution witnesses shall beamed
available before the inquiry officer for cross
examination by the petitioner or his defence
assistant on 12th September, 2005 and on 13th
September, 2005, the petitioner shall examine
himself as defence witness. Thereafter, the
inquiry officer, upon considering of the
evidence on record, shall submit his report in
accordance with law.
In terms of the aforesaid order, the Writ
Petition stands disposed of. Copies of this
order be issued dasti to counsel appearing for
the parties under the signatures of the Court
Master of this Court.
So far as the question of delay in initiation of
departmental proceeding is concerned, we
have heard learned counsel for the petitioner.
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 4366/2014
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
We find no reason to take a different view than
what has been taken by the Tribunal. The said
contention, therefore, is held to be without
merit. However, the issue relating to the
promotion of the petitioner, left open by the
learned Tribunal in its impugned order, is not
being examined by us.
The same, as has been done by the learned
Tribunal, is kept open.”
14.
Pursuant to the judgment dated 25.08.2005, the matter was
remitted to the Inquiry Officer for further inquiry.
15.
It is the case of the respondent no.1 that the inquiry was
conducted in a biased and arbitrary manner, in violation of Rule 14 of
the CCS (CCA) Rules, particularly Rule 14 (18), as the respondent
no.1 was neither examined nor afforded an opportunity to explain the
circumstances appearing against him.
16.
The Inquiry Officer submitted his report dated 02.11.2005,
which was communicated to the respondent no.1 on 29.11.2005. The
respondent no.1, thereafter, submitted his representation dated
19.12.2005 against the Inquiry Report.
17.
The case file was referred to the Central Vigilance Commission
(CVC) for its second-stage advice, and vide Office Memorandum
dated 16.01.2009, the CVC advised the imposition of a penalty by
way of a suitable cut in the pension of the respondent no.1.
18.
Thereafter, the matter was referred to the UPSC for its advice.
Vide its advice dated 18.11.2011, the UPSC inter alia stated that the
charges established against the respondent no.1 constituted grave
misconduct and that the ends of justice would be met if a penalty of
withholding 50% of the monthly pension otherwise admissible to the
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 4366/2014
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
respondent no. 1 was imposed on him on a permanent basis. The
UPSC further advised that the gratuity admissible to the respondent
no. 1 should also be permanently withheld.
19.
It is the case of the respondent no.1 that although the
Disciplinary Authority obtained the advice of the UPSC, a copy
thereof was not supplied to him, nor was he afforded an opportunity to
submit his response. It is further alleged that the Disciplinary
Authority, solely relying upon the UPSC‟s advice and without
independent application of mind to the respondent no.1 submissions,
passed the penalty order dated 29.11.2011, holding the charge to be
partly proved and imposing the aforesaid penalty.
20.
The respondent no.1 challenged the penalty order before the
learned Tribunal by filing the present O.A., which was allowed vide
the Impugned Order.
21.
Aggrieved thereby, the petitioner has filed the present petition.
SUBMISSIONS OF THE LEARNED COUNSEL ON BEHALF OF
THE PETITIONER:
22.
The learned counsel for the petitioner submits that, consequent
upon the retirement of the respondent no.1 on superannuation on
31.12.2002, the disciplinary proceedings already initiated against him
were deemed to have continued in terms of Rule 9 of the CCS
(Pension) Rules, 1972. He submits that the charge-sheet under Rule 14
of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965 had been issued to the respondent no.
1 in respect of serious lapses committed by respondent no. 1 while he
was posted in the Sales Tax Department. He submits that respondent
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 4366/2014
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
no. 1 failed to invoke Section 18 of the Delhi Sales Tax Act, 1975 to
safeguard government revenue, as he issued statutory forms in quick
succession to the dealer. He submits that the Inquiry Officer‟s analysis
in paragraph IX(p) of the inquiry report records that the respondent
no. 1 ought to have prescribed an appropriate amount of additional
surety, keeping in view the nature and scale of the dealer‟s business
and the amount of tax likely to be saved by the dealer with the aid of
the statutory forms issued to the dealer. He submits that the Inquiry
Officer conducted the inquiry proceedings strictly in accordance with
the provisions of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965 as well as the applicable
instructions and rules, and duly considered every aspect of the case on
record, as is evident from the findings recorded in the inquiry report.
He submits that the contention of the respondent no. 1 that the Inquiry
Officer conducted the inquiry in a biased manner and without
following the prescribed rules is incorrect and not borne out from the
record. He submits that as per the order sheets dated 12–13.09.2005 of
the inquiry proceedings, the respondent no. 1 was afforded ample
opportunity for self-examination as a defence witness and was duly
examined and cross-examined in accordance with the statements and
cross-examination of Shri V. P. Singh, which are available on record.
23.
The learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the learned
Tribunal failed to appreciate the observations of the UPSC. He
submits that the Impugned Order does not accord due consideration or
weight to the examination of the case by the petitioner/the department,
the report of the Inquiry Officer, the advice of the CVC, and the
statutory advice of the UPSC. He further submits that the impugned
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 4366/2014
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
order is perverse, arbitrary, unjustified, and bad in law, inasmuch as
the learned Tribunal failed to appreciate the inquiry report, the
statements of witnesses, the evidence on record, and the facts and
circumstances of the case.
24.
He submits that the prosecution witnesses unequivocally
deposed during the inquiry proceedings that the certification and
issuance of statutory forms are not carried out by the ASTO on behalf
of the STO. Once the forms are sanctioned and delivered to the dealer,
entries are made by the Record Keeper on separate form-issuance
sheets, which are thereafter signed by the form-issuing authority. He
further submits that it was established that the respondent no. 1 never
indicated on the issuance sheets that the statutory forms were issued
on the directions of the STO, and that such a quasi-judicial function
cannot be exercised on behalf of another authority. He submits that the
contention of the respondent no. 1 that he issued a large number of
forms on the directions of the STO cannot be accepted. He further
submits that the respondent no. 1 was required to exercise due
restraint, particularly since the dealers were newly registered. He
further submits that the inquiry established, through the depositions of
prosecution
witnesses
and
assessment
records,
that
a
disproportionately large number of statutory forms were issued for
substantial amounts, while the corresponding turnovers declared by
the dealers were significantly underreported, and in some cases,
records of purchasers were not available. He submits that despite these
red flags, the respondent no. 1 failed to invoke the provisions of the
Delhi Sales Tax Act, 1975, including Section 18, to safeguard
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 4366/2014
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
government revenue, and issued statutory forms in quick succession
without ordering surveys to verify the bona fides of the dealers. He
submits that this failure enabled the misuse of the statutory forms and
resulted in serious prejudice to government revenue.
25.
He submits that the entire basis of the reasoning adopted by the
learned Tribunal, that since no actual pecuniary loss was proved to
have been caused to the Government, Rule 9 of the CCS (Pension)
Rules could not have been invoked against the respondent no.1, is
wholly flawed and not sustainable in law.
26.
He submits that, therefore, the present petition deserves to be
allowed.
SUBMISSIONS OF THE LEARNED COUNSEL ON BEHALF OF
THE RESPONDENT NO.1:
27.
On the other hand, the learned counsel for the respondent no.1
submits that the charge-sheet dated 13.12.2002 was issued after an
inordinate and wholly unexplained delay of nearly 14–15 years from
the alleged incidents of 1987–1988. The charge-sheet was served
merely days before the respondent‟s retirement on 31.12.2002,
causing grave and irreparable prejudice to his defence. Owing to the
passage of time, the respondent no.1 was unable to recall the precise
circumstances, instructions, and prevailing practices governing the
issuance of statutory forms. He submits that the relevant records were
no longer available, and contemporaneous officers could not be traced,
thereby seriously impairing his right to effectively defend himself. He
further submits that the inquiry proceedings were conducted in gross
violation of the principles of natural justice and Rule 14(18) of the
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 4366/2014
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965. He further submits that the respondent no.1
was neither properly examined nor afforded a fair opportunity to
explain the circumstances appearing against him. Despite the
directions issued by this Court on 25.08.2005, the inquiry was
conducted in a biased, arbitrary, and mechanical manner.
28.
The learned counsel further submits that despite repeated
requests and reminders dated 26.12.2002, 20.01.2003, 03.04.2003, and
17.04.2003, the respondent no.1 was never supplied with clear and
legible copies of the documents relied upon by the department. He
submits that the documents furnished were illegible, smudged, and
blackened, rendering them unusable for preparing an effective
defence, in clear violation of the respondent‟s right to a fair hearing.
29.
He
submits
that
the
respondent
no.1
was
subjected
to discriminatory and selective treatment, as no disciplinary action
was initiated against other officers who had similarly issued statutory
forms to the same dealers. He further submits that notably, Shri P.R.
Meena, the then STO, on whose written directions the impugned
forms were issued by the respondent no.1 in good faith and in
discharge of official duties, was not proceeded against, thereby
vitiating the entire proceedings. He further submits that the respondent
no.1 consistently maintained that the statutory forms were issued
strictly in accordance with Rule 8 of the Delhi Sales Tax
Rules and Circular Nos. 10 of 1985-1986 and 18 of 1988-1989, which
expressly permitted issuance of forms for both past and future
transactions. He submits that the dealers concerned were regular
dealers who had been issued such forms earlier as well, and that under
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 4366/2014
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
the prevailing rules, there was no requirement for prior verification of
transactions by lower functionaries before issuance of the forms.
30.
He submitted that although the Disciplinary Authority obtained
the advice of the UPSC dated 18.11.2011, a copy thereof was never
supplied to the respondent no.1, nor was he afforded any opportunity
to submit his response. He submits that this constitutes a serious
procedural irregularity and a clear violation of the principles of natural
justice, as the respondent no.1 was entitled to know and respond to the
material relied upon for imposing the penalty. In support, he places
reliance on the judgment of the Supreme Court in Union of India &
Ors. v. S.K. Kapoor, (2011) 4 SCC 589.
31.
The learned counsel submits that the Disciplinary Authority
mechanically adopted the UPSC‟s advice without any independent
application of mind to the facts of the case or to the detailed
representations submitted by the respondent no.1. He submits that the
penalty Order dated 29.11.2011 reflects complete absence of
consideration of proportionality or mitigating circumstances. Even
assuming the charges to be established, the penalty of withholding
50% of the monthly pension on a permanent basis and permanent
withholding of the entire gratuity is grossly disproportionate, harsh,
and shockingly unjust. He submits that the respondent no.1 had
rendered more than 37 years of unblemished service and was granted
promotions even after the alleged irregularities came to light in 1996.
No monetary loss to the government was ever quantified or
established. He submits that the authorities were aware of the
allegations as early as 1996, when a Memorandum dated 30.05.1996
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 4366/2014
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
was issued, to which the respondent no.1 submitted a detailed
explanation on 10.06.1996. No action was taken for over six years
thereafter, during which period the respondent no.1 was granted all
due promotions, including promotion to the DANICS Grade-II. He
submits that the sudden revival of stale charges on the eve of
retirement, without any fresh material or justification, clearly smacks
of mala fides.
32.
He submits that the inquiry failed to establish any mala fide
intent, personal gain, or corruption on the part of the respondent no.1.
At the highest, the allegations pertain to alleged procedural
irregularities in a context where the respondent no.1 was
overburdened with work due to frequent changes of STOs and was
handling multiple categories of cases. He submits that the statutory
forms were issued on the written directions of the then STO, and that
the respondent no.1 acted bona fidely in discharge of his official
duties. He submits that in terms of Rule 9 of the CCS (Pension) Rules,
pension can be withheld only where allegations of „grave misconduct
or negligence‟ are proved. He submits that in the present case, this
yardstick has not been met. In support, he places reliance on the
judgment of the Supreme Court in D.V. Kapoor v. Union of India &
Ors., (1990) 4 SCC 314; and of this Court in Union of India & Ors. v.
T.P. Venugopal, 2007 SCC OnLine Del 1498.
33.
The learned counsel for the respondent no.1 submits that, in
view of the aforesaid facts and the settled legal position, the Impugned
Order passed by the learned Tribunal does not suffer from any
perversity, either on facts or in law, and therefore, the Writ Petition
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 4366/2014
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
deserves to be dismissed with costs in favour of the respondent no.1.
ANALYSIS AND FINDINGS:
34.
We have considered the submissions advanced by the learned
counsels for the parties and have perused the material on record.
35.
Before we proceed further, we would note that in the
Impugned Order, the learned Tribunal rejected the plea of the
respondent no. 1 that there was an inordinate delay in the issuance of
the charge-sheet and that, since the respondent no. 1 was discharging
quasi-judicial functions, disciplinary proceedings could not have
been initiated against him. The learned Tribunal also rejected the
submission of the respondent no. 1 that he was subjected to
discrimination inasmuch as the proceedings against Mr. P.R. Meena,
the then STO, had been dropped by the petitioner, whereas the
respondent no.1 was punished. Relying upon the judgment of this
Court in Union of India & Anr. v. Biswabijoyee Panigarihi & Anr.,
2013:DHC:3321-DB, the learned Tribunal further held that it was not
necessary for the Disciplinary Authority to furnish a copy of the
opinion received from the UPSC to the respondent no. 1 prior to the
issuance of the penalty order, and that the same was required to be
supplied along with the penalty order.
38.
There is no challenge to the above findings of the learned
Tribunal by the respondent no.1.
39.
However, despite the above findings, the learned Tribunal, in
the Impugned Order, further held that there was no finding of „grave
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 4366/2014
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
misconduct or negligence‟ against the respondent no. 1 by the
Disciplinary Authority and, on that basis, proceeded to quash the
charge-sheet, the report of the Inquiry Officer, and the order passed
by the Disciplinary Authority. The learned Tribunal also directed that
the withheld pension and gratuity be released to the respondent no. 1
along with the interest at the GPF rates. We quote from the
Impugned Order as under:
“22. It is an admitted fact that the Applicant
was charge sheeted on 13.12.2002 and he
retired from service on 31.12.2002 and the
disciplinary proceedings continued under Rule
9(2)(a) of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972. The
charge against the Applicant was that while he
was functioning as ASTO in Ward 23, he
“committed misconduct in as much as he had
issued 260 ST-I forms and 355 ST-35 forms to
M/s Pilco Systems, and 25 ST-I and 40 ST-35
to M/s Krishna Stores in quick succession. He
failed to keep a check over the nefarious
activities of both the dealers by getting the
transactions of the dealers (as shown in ST-II
A/cs) verified through lower functionaries.
Shri Singh also failed to invoke provisions of
Sec 18 of DST Act, 1976 by enhancing the
sureties of both the dealers in view of huge
purchases indicated in ST-II A/cs furnished by
them. Loss of revenue caused to the Sales Tax
Department by M/s Pilco systems & M/s
Krishna Stores are to the tune of Rs.30 crores
and Rs.29 crores respectively”. The
conclusion arrived at by the Enquiry Officer in
his report is that the charge against Shri V.P.
Singh exhibiting negligence, lack of integrity
in issuing statutory forms to both the dealers
in quick succession causing heavy loss of
revenue to the Government is proved. In fact,
the specific allegation against tine Applicant
was that the loss of Rs.29 crores was caused
by the Applicant. However, the findings was
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 4366/2014
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
that charge against the Applicant exhibiting
negligence, lack of integrity in issuing
statutory forms to both the dealers in quick
succession causing heavy loss of revenue to
the Government is proved. At least, there
should have been some evidence to that effect
from any of the prosecution witnesses.
However, in the entire report there is no
evidence on behalf of the witnesses that any
financial loss had occurred. Thus, when the
crux of the charge was that on account of
misconduct or negligence of the Applicant
there was a loss of Rs.29 crores and if the
same was not proved, it cannot be concluded
that the charge has been proved. Even the
Disciplinary Authority has also stated that the
charge proved was only partly and the exact
revenue loss could not be accounted.
Therefore, in absence of any allegation that
the Applicant was guilty of grave misconduct
or negligence during the period of service, and
if the President has not found to that extent as
provided in Rule 9(1) of the CCS Pension)
Rules, 1972, no pension or gratuity of the
Applicant could have been withheld.
23. In the above facts and circumstances of
the case, we allow this OA. Consequently, we
quash and set aside the impugned order dated
29.11.2011, charge sheet dated 13.12.2002,
Inquiry Officer’s report dated 29.11.2005. The
respondents shall release the entire withheld
monthly pension, gratuity and any other
pensionary benefits to the Applicant with
interest at GPF rate. The aforesaid directions
shall be complied with, within a period of 2
months from the date of receipt of a copy of
this order.”
40.
We are unable to sustain the above finding of the learned
Tribunal.
41.
The respondent no. 1 was issued the following Article of
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 4366/2014
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
Charge on 13.12.2002:
“While functioning as ASTO in old ward-23
(new ward-54), Shri V.P. Singh committed
misconduct in as much as he had issued 260
ST-I forms and 355 ST-35 forms to M/s Pilco
Systems, and 25 ST-I and 40 ST-35 to M/s
Krishna Stores in quick succession. He failed
to keep a check over the nefarious activities of
both the dealers by getting the transactions of
the dealers (as shown in ST-II A/cs) verified
through lower functionaries. Shri Singh also
failed to invoke provisions of Sec 18 of DST
Act, 1976 by enhancing the sureties of both the
dealers in view of huge purchases indicated in
ST-II A/cs furnished by them. Loss of revenue
caused to the Sales Tax Department by M/s
Pilco systems & M/s Krishna Stores are to the
tune of Rs.30 crores and Rs.29 crores
respectively.
Thus, Shri V.P. Singh by his above acts,
exhibited negligence, lack of integrity in
issuing statutory forms to both the dealers in
quick succession causing heavy loss of revenue
to the Sales Tax Department and thus acted in
a manner which is unbecoming of a Govt.
servant, thereby violating the provisions of
Rule 3 of CCS (Conduct) Rules, 1964.”
42.
On the basis of the Inquiry Report, the advice of the CVC and
the UPSC, the Disciplinary Authority, vide Order dated 29.11.2011,
imposing the punishment of permanent forfeiture of 50% of the
pension, as well as the gratuity payable to the respondent no. 1,
observed as under:
“9. And whereas/on examination of the
inquiry report, the statement of witnesses,
evidence on record and facts &circumstances
of the case, the following points emerged:(i)
The prosecution witnesses clearly
deposed in the inquiry that certification of
issuance of forms is not done by ASTO on
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 4366/2014
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
behalf of the STO. After forms are sanctioned
and delivered to the dealer, the Record Keeper
marks entry thereof on separate forms issuing
sheets and the form issuing authority puts his
signature on the sheets.
(ii) C.O. has never indicated on the
issuance sheets that the statutory forms were
issued on the directions of the STO. Further,
such quasi judicial function cannot be done on
behalf of another authority. The contention of
the Charged Officer that he issued large
number of forms on the directions of the STO
on number of occasions cannot be
accepted/believed. The C.O. should have
exercised restraints in issuing forms keeping in
mind that these dealers were newly registered.
(iii) It is clearly established during inquiry
by the deposition of prosecution witnesses that
survey is carried out when forms receiving
dealer is using those forms for very heavy
purchases. From the assessment orders, it is
very much clear that very large number of
forms have been issued for very big amounts
whereas the amount as reflected by the dealers
are under shown. No records of purchasers
are also available in respect of some forms.
(iv) The Charged Officer has failed to
invoke Delhi Sales Tax Act, 1975, to safeguard
the revenue as he has issued statutory forms in
quick succession to the dealer. Thus, the C.O.
had issued these forms without safeguarding
the government revenue. Had he invoked
Section 18 of the Delhi Sales Tax Act. 1975
and had he ordered STI survey to check the
bonafide dealers, the misuse of statutory forms
issued by the C.O. could have been
noticed/avoided.
10. And whereas, while rendering their
advice, the UPSC has observed that the C.O.
had not resorted to any precaution to
safeguard the revenue interest of the
Government. The form issuing sheets are
bearing his signatures as a token of his
order/approval for issue of a particular
number of forms to these dealers. The C.O.
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 4366/2014
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
appeared to be in close connivance with
dealers as immediately after the forms were
issued the dealers stopped responding to the
assessment notices issued by the subsequent
assessing authorities and were not available in
the market. Though exact loss of revenue
caused to the Sales Tax Department vis-à-vis
the charge against the C.O. could not be
computed, the charges against the C.O. for
exhibiting negligence and lack of integrity in
issuing statutory forms to both the dealers in
quick succession causing heavy loss of revenue
stand proved. The charge is as such, partly
proved as the total loss could not be computed.
11. And whereas, in view of the foregoing, it
is clearly established that the C.O. had issued
large number of statutory forms to both the
dealers without safeguarding the revenue of
the government by not enhancing sureties of
both the dealers in view of heavy
purchase/transactions made by them. He had
also failed to verify their activities through
lower functionaries (i.e.,STI). Since, the exact
revenue loss could not be computed, though
loss to the tune of Rs.30 crores and Rs.29.00
crores respectively are indicated in the
chargesheet, the charge is partly proved.
12. And now, therefore, after considering
the enquiry report, the evidence on record and
the facts and circumstance of the case the
President, by virtue of power vested under
Rule 9 of CCS(Pension) Rules, 1972 has
decided in agreement with the advice of UPSC
that the charge is partly proved and grave and
that the ends of justice would be met in this
case if the penalty of withholding of 50% of
the monthly pension otherwise admissible to
Shri V. P. Singh, DANICS (Retd.) i.e. the
Charged Officer is imposed on him on a
permanent basis and further the gratuity
admissible to him should also be withheld
permanently and orders accordingly.”
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 4366/2014
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
43.
From a reading of the above, it is apparent that the
Disciplinary Authority, on the basis of the Inquiry Officer‟s report as
well as the advice received from the UPSC, found that the
respondent no. 1 had issued a large number of statutory forms to the
two dealers without safeguarding the revenue of the Government,
inasmuch as he failed to enhance the sureties of these dealers despite
the heavy purchase/transactions undertaken by them. He also failed
to verify the activities of these dealers through the lower
functionaries. The Disciplinary Authority, however, further observed
that the exact revenue loss attributable to the acts/inaction of the
respondent no. 1 could not be computed, although losses of Rs. 30
crores and Rs. 29 crores, respectively, in respect of the two dealers
had been indicated. It was only on account of the inability to
ascertain the exact loss caused that the charge was held to be
partially proved. The learned Tribunal has not interfered with the
aforesaid findings and observations of the Disciplinary Authority. In
such a scenario, we find no justification in the conclusion of the
learned Tribunal that respondent no. 1 was not held guilty of „grave
misconduct or negligence‟.
44.
In Union of India & Ors. v. B. Dev, (1998) 7 SCC 691, the
Supreme Court held that the contention that Rule 9 of the CCS
(Pension) Rules cannot be invoked, even in cases of grave
misconduct, unless pecuniary loss is caused to the Government, is
unsustainable. We quote from the judgment as under:
“11. Rule 9 gives to the President the right of
— (1) withholding or withdrawing a pension
or part thereof, (2) either permanently or for a
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 4366/2014
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
specified period, and (3) ordering recovery
from a pension of the whole or part of any
pecuniary loss caused to the Government. This
power can be exercised if, in any departmental
or judicial proceedings, the pensioner is found
guilty of grave misconduct or negligence
during the period of his service. The power,
therefore, can be exercised in all cases where
the pensioner is found guilty of grave
misconduct or negligence during the period of
his service. One of the powers of the President
is to recover from pension, in a case where
any pecuniary loss is caused to the
Government, that loss. This is an independent
power in addition to the power of withdrawing
or withholding pension. The contention of the
respondent, therefore, that Rule 9 cannot be
invoked even in cases of grave misconduct
unless pecuniary loss is caused to the
Government, is unsustainable.”
45.
The Supreme Court further held that the definition of „grave
misconduct‟ under Explanation (b) to Rule 8 of the CCS (Pension)
Rules is not exhaustive.
46.
In the present case, the respondent no. 1 has been found guilty
of „grave negligence‟ if not of „grave misconduct‟. Merely because
the exact quantum of loss caused to the Government could not be
proved in the Inquiry would not relieve the respondent no. 1 of such
finding of the „grave misconduct or negligence‟ and the consequent
withholding of his pension.
47.
In B. Dev (supra), the Supreme Court also examined the
decision of D.V. Kapoor (supra) and distinguished the same by
observing as under:
“13. Our attention is drawn to a decision of
this Court in D.V. Kapoor v. Union of India
[(1990) 4 SCC 314 : 1990 SCC (L&S) 696 :
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 4366/2014
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
(1990) 14 ATC 906 : AIR 1990 SC 1923] . In
that case also, disciplinary proceedings were
initiated against the government servant under
Rule 3(ii)(iii) of the CCS (Conduct) Rules and
were later continued under Rule 9 of the CCS
(Pension) Rules, 1972. The charge against the
appellant there was that he absented himself
from duty without any authorisation and
despite his being asked to join duty, he
remained absent. The Enquiry Officer,
however, held that his absenting himself from
duty could not be termed as entirely wilful
because he could not move due to his wife's
illness. The Enquiry Officer recommended that
the case of the appellant should be considered
sympathetically. The recommendation and
finding of the Enquiry Officer were accepted
by the President. However, it was decided to
withhold full gratuity and payment of pension
in consultation with the Union Public Service
Commission. In these circumstances, this
Court held that there was no finding that the
appellant had committed grave misconduct as
charged and that the exercise of power under
Rule 9 was not warranted.”
48.
The judgment in D.V. Kapoor (supra), therefore, could also
not have been invoked by the learned Tribunal in the facts of the
present case.
49.
In T.P. Venugopal (supra), the Court was considering a case
where forgery was alleged to have been committed by officers
subordinate to the Charged Officer. The Court also found that none
of the findings in the Inquiry Report indicated that the Charged
Officer had committed grave misconduct or was guilty of grave
negligence in permitting the subordinates to introduce fraudulent
documents, incomplete processing, and passing of bills without
proper verification. The Court held that simply because the Charged
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 4366/2014
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
Officer had passed the subject bills on the same date does not
constitute any grave misconduct on the part of the Charged Officer,
who had acted also as per the past practice. The said judgment is,
therefore, clearly distinguishable from the facts of the present case,
where the UPSC has, in fact, opined that the connivance of the
respondent no. 1 with the guilty dealers could not be ruled out.
50.
In the above facts and in view of the above discussion, we are
unable to sustain the Impugned Order passed by the learned Tribunal.
The same is accordingly set aside.
51. The petition is allowed in the above terms. The parties shall bear
their respective costs.
NAVIN CHAWLA, J.
MADHU JAIN, J.
JANUARY 12, 2026/DG
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 4366/2014
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review