Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
#
Judgment reserved on: 25.09.2026
Judgment delivered on: 12.10.2026
CNR No. DLHC011071832025
+
O.M.P. (COMM) 563/2025 & I.A. 32786-32787/2025
UNION OF INDIA
.....Petitioner
Versus
SWADESHI CIVIL INFRASTRUCTURE PVT. LTD.
.....Respondent
Advocates who appeared in this case:
For the Petitioner:
Mr. Siddhartha Shankar Ray, CGSC with
Ms. Sonali Modi, Advocates.
For the Respondent:
Mr. Dinkar Singh and Mr. Rohit Singh,
Advocates.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MANOJ JAIN
JUDGMENT
1.
The present petition has been filed by Union of India under Section
34 of Arbitration & Conciliation Act, 1996 (hereinafter referred to as „said
Act‟).
2.
The impugned Award is dated 12.06.2025.
3.
The challenge is, however, restricted to claim Nos.1, 4 and 7.
4.
A dispute arose between the parties in relation to agreement dated
30.07.2018. The work in question related to construction of 76 multi-storied
flats at Dr. B.D. Marg, New Delhi. These were being constructed for
Hon‟ble Members of Parliament of Lok Sabha.
5.
Before learned Arbitral Tribunal, both the parties agreed that the
Signed By:SONIA
THAPLIYAL
17:04:28
O.M.P. (COMM) 563/2025
claims and counter-claims could be adjudicated on the basis of the
respective pleadings and documents, without leading any oral evidence.
Therefore, the adjudication is based on the pleadings and documents only.
6.
As noted above, the subject matter of the present petition relates to
claim Nos.1, 4 & 7. These are as under: Claim No.1:
Claim No.4:
Claim No.7:
Non-payment of Bonus under clause 2A of the agreement.
Interest from the date of cause of action till the date of
Award.
18% GST or as applicable (on the date of payment on the
amount to be released on which GST is to be paid
7.
Let me examine these, one by one.
8.
The learned Arbitral Tribunal has awarded a sum of Rs.
7,46,53,850/- under Claim No. 1.
9.
As per the agreement, the contractor (respondent herein) becomes
entitled to bonus if he is able to complete the work, ahead of scheduled
completion date. The completion date may also get stretched for any
justified extension, as agreed and determined by the parties. The aspect of
entitlement of bonus emanates from clause 2A of the agreement which
reads as under: “In case, the contractor completes the work ahead of stipulated
date of completion or justified extended date of completion as
determined under clauses 5.3, 12 & 15, a bonus @ 1% (one per
cent) of the tendered value per month computed on per day basis,
shall be payable to the contractor, subject to a maximum limit of
5% (five per cent) of the tendered value. Provided that justified
time for extra work shall be calculated on pro-rata basis as cost of
extra work X stipulated period/tendered value. The amount of
bonus, if payable, shall be paid along with final bill after
completion of work. Provided always that provision of the Clause
2A shall be applicable only when so provided in „Schedule F‟.”
10.
Thus, contractor would be entitled to bonus if the work is completed
Signed By:SONIA
THAPLIYAL
17:04:28
O.M.P. (COMM) 563/2025
ahead of stipulated date of completion or justified extended date of
completion as determined under clauses 5.3, 12 & 15.
11.
Learned counsel for the petitioner contends that the contractor was
entitled to bonus when it was able to complete the work prior to the
stipulated date or within any justifiable extension granted and determined
under the abovesaid relevant clauses only i.e. clause 5.3, 12 and 15. He
submits that clause 2A is conspicuously absent about extension given under
a different clause i.e. clause 5.2 and, therefore, if the time is extended under
clause 5.2, the contractor does not become entitled to bonus. It is argued
that since learned Arbitral Tribunal has considered extension under clause
5.2 also for the purposes of grant of bonus, the award is in teeth of
stipulated terms of the contract and, therefore, not sustainable. It is
submitted that the parties were bound by the terms of the contract and since
there was no ambiguity therein, it was not permissible for the learned
Arbitral Tribunal to have, virtually, rewritten the contractual terms, by
giving a fanciful interpretation. Learned counsel for the petitioner relies
upon Navayuga Engineering Co. P. Ltd. vs. Public Works Department &
Anr.: 2016 SCC OnLine Del 1546, Indian Oil Corporation Ltd. vs. Tapas
Kumar Das: 2025 SCC OnLine Cal 10174, Union of India Vs. Jindal Rail
Infrastructure Ltd: 2022 SCC Online Del 1540, PSA Sical Terminals Pvt.
Ltd. Vs The Board of Trustees of V.O. Chidambranar Port Trust Tuticorin
& Ors.: (2023) 15 SCC 781 and SEPCO Electric Power Construction
Corpn. Vs. GMR Kamalnga Energy Ltd.: (2026) 2 SCC 542.
12.
Such contentions have been refuted by learned counsel for the
contractor.
13.
It is submitted that there is no rewriting of the contractual terms or
Signed By:SONIA
THAPLIYAL
17:04:28
O.M.P. (COMM) 563/2025
conditions and that clause 2A, clearly, contemplates bonus when the work
is completed before the stipulated date of completion and since the
stipulated date of completion got extended by virtue of grant of time under
clause 5.2, in any case, the contractor was rightly held entitled to bonus. He
submits that, moreover, there is no prohibition postulated anywhere in the
agreement that bonus would not be granted if time was to be extended
under clause 5.2. It is, thus, argued that the learned Arbitral Tribunal has,
rightly, considered the contractual obligations and awarded bonus. Learned
counsel for the respondent has placed reliance upon Paragon Constructions
(India) Pvt Ltd v. Union of India & Anr. 2008 SCC OnLine Del 51; Union
of India v. M/s. N.N. Buildcon Pvt. Ltd. 2015 SCC OnLine Del 11647 and
Roshan Real Estate Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India 2023 SCC OnLine Del 2515.
14.
I have given anxious consideration to the rival contentions and
perused the material on record.
15.
Admittedly, there was dispute between the parties with respect to
number of hindrance days. According to contractor, though there was
hindrance on 769 days, the petitioner herein allowed hindrance for 236 days
only. Learned Tribunal, after careful perusal of the record and after
examining the various hindrances in great detail, justified hindrance for 144
days under clause 5.3; extension of 114 days towards additional work; and
hindrance for 138 days under clause 5.2. It also observed that there was no
hindrance in context of clause 15.
16.
The dispute, at the moment, is regarding hindrance for 138 days
under clause 5.2 only.
17.
The petitioner does not challenge the calculation regarding hindrance
days. Its contention is merely to the effect that for said 138 days, the
Signed By:SONIA
THAPLIYAL
17:04:28
O.M.P. (COMM) 563/2025
contractor is not entitled to bonus.
18.
Let me see the relevant clauses.
19.
Clause 5.2 and 5.3 read as under: “5.2 if the work(s) be delayed by: (i) force majeure, or
(ii) abnormally bad weather, or
(iii) serious loss or damage by fire, or
(iv) civil commotion, local commotion of workmen, strike or
lockout, affecting any of the trades employed on the work,
or
(v) delay on the part of other contractors or tradesmen
engaged by Engineer-in-Charge in executing work not
forming part of the Contract, or
(vi) non-availability of stores, which are the responsibility
of Government to supply or
(vii) non-availability or break down of tools and Plant to be
supplied or supplied by Government or
(viii) any other cause like above which, in the reasoned
opinion of the Engineer-in-Charge is beyond the
Contractor‟s control.”
then upon the happening of any such event causing delay, the
Contractor shall immediately give notice thereof in writing to the
Engineer-in-Charge for entry in the hindrance register (physical
or we-based as prescribed in schedule F) but shall nevertheless
use constantly his best endeavours to prevent or make good the
delay and shall do all that may be reasonably required to the
satisfaction of the Engineer-in-Charge to proceed with the work.
The contractor shall have no claim of damages for extension of
time granted or rescheduling of milestone/s for events listed in
sub clause 5.2.
5.3
In case the work is hindered by any reasons, in the
opinion of the contractor, by the Department or for someone for
whose action the Department is responsible, the contractor may
immediately give notice thereof in writing to the Engineer-inCharge in the same manner as prescribed under sub Clause 5.2
seeking extension of time or rescheduling of milestone/s. The
authority as indicated in Schedule „F‟ shall, if justified, give a fair
and reasonable extension of time and reschedule the mile stones
for completion of work after due consideration of the same within
30 days of receipt of such request. In event of non application by
the contractor for extension of time E-in-C after affording
opportunity to the contractor may give, supported with a
Signed By:SONIA
THAPLIYAL
17:04:28
O.M.P. (COMM) 563/2025
programme, a fair and reasonable extension within a reasonable
period of occurrence of the event.
Such extension of time or rescheduling of milestone/s shall be
without prejudice to any other right or remedy of the parties in
contract or in law; provided further that for concurrent delays
under this sub clause and sub clause 5.2 to the extent the delay is
covered under sub Clause 5.2 the contractor shall be entitled to
only extension of time and no damages.”
(emphasis supplied)
20.
There is a subtle difference between clause 5.2 and 5.3.
21.
While clause 5.2 talks about the delay attributable to force majeure,
abnormal weather conditions, loss or damage by fire, local commotion of
workmen, strike etc., clause 5.3 stands attracted when the work is hindered
for act and conduct attributable to Department only. As would be evident,
certain exigencies mentioned in clause 5.2 viz non-availability of stores,
which are the responsibility of Government to supply or non-availability or
break down of tools and Plant to be supplied or supplied by Government
are also of the nature specified in clause 5.3.
22.
Indubitably, clause 2A, as extracted above, is very clear and specific.
It provides that bonus would accrue if the contractor completes the work
ahead of stipulated date or justified extended date of completion as
determined under clause 5.3, 12 and 15. Thus, the bonus would become
allowable where the work is completed ahead of stipulated date. Of course,
though the justifiable extension under three clauses have been specifically
mentioned in Clause 2A, there is no denying the fact that if there are
hindrance days attributable to force majeure conditions, such days also
need to be taken into account, which, in turn, would impact the dead-line of
completion. Force majeure clause, generally, acts as an “eclipse” provision.
When a catastrophic, unpredictable event like natural disasters, pandemics,
Signed By:SONIA
THAPLIYAL
17:04:28
O.M.P. (COMM) 563/2025
government shutdowns etc. occur, the clause suspends contractual timelines
and results in automatic extension of time without penalty. Though, the
contractor is not permitted to seek any damages or penalty on account of
such delay, but if despite such hindrance, the contractor is able to deliver
the project ahead of the scheduled deadline, it, quite clearly, becomes
entitled to grant of bonus. Mere fact that because clause 5.2 is not
mentioned under clause 2A, would not carry any significance. All in all, if
work is completed in advance, the bonus is a natural consequence.
23.
Learned Arbitral Tribunal observed, and rightly so, that clause 5.2
merely bars contractor to seek any damages. It held that as per clause 5.2,
the contractor was precluded from seeking any claim of any damages for
extension of time or rescheduling of milestone and since there was no
embargo in claiming any bonus, learned Arbitral Tribunal included the
hindrance days, under clause 5.2 also, for the purposes of grant of bonus. In
N.N. Buildcon (supra), learned Division Bench of this Court observed that
the Arbitral Tribunal had correctly interpreted the bonus provision and
applied the principles of calculation of the bonus. It observed that if there
are hindrances in the completion of the work, which lead to delay, then the
period during which the hindrances occurred have to be excluded from the
period stipulated for completion of the work. It held that if after exclusion
of the delay period so computed the work is completed by the contractor in
a period lesser than the stipulated period for completion, the contractor
would be entitled to bonus.
Thus, the hindrance which has been,
eventually, acknowledged and approved by the Department would not be an
impediment in seeking bonus.
24.
Admittedly, Arbitral Tribunal is not empowered to re-write the
Signed By:SONIA
THAPLIYAL
17:04:28
O.M.P. (COMM) 563/2025
contract and cannot ignore determinative clauses or supplant contractual
stipulations. Petitioner, to the above extent, is justified in relying upon the
precedents cited at the Bar. In Navayuga (supra), though it was observed
that the “scheduled completion time” was a defined term and could not be
altered by the parties but therein the issue was altogether different i.e.
whether in the absence of a covenant prohibiting compensation, the
Arbitrator could have granted market rate beyond the stipulated period of
contract. Therefore, no advantage can be extracted therefrom. Moreover,
undeniably, interpretation and construction of contractual terms is well
within the domain of Arbitral Tribunal and the Courts would be slow and
reluctant to interfere with the same, unless the interpretation given by
Arbitral Tribunal is completely absurd and contrary to agreement or is not
even a remote possibility. Reference be also made to Ssangyong
Engineering & Construction Company Limited v. NHAI: (2019) 15 SCC
131.
25.
Moreover, Award can be set aside only if there is any patent illegality
or when it is against public policy of India or based on „no evidence‟ or
delineates „no reason‟ for passing the Award. The Court seized with any
such petition is not required to act as a Court of appeal. There is nothing to
indicate that learned Arbitral Tribunal has given any illogical or illegal
interpretation to the abovesaid clause 2A. The extension provided under
clause 5.2 is also liable to be counted for the purposes of grant of bonus
and, as already noted above, it only debars any such contractor to seek
damages for the resultant delay. There is nothing to indicate that it would
disentitle any contractor to seek bonus.
26.
Evidently, the interpretation and reasons given by the Tribunal are
Signed By:SONIA
THAPLIYAL
17:04:28
O.M.P. (COMM) 563/2025
not only justifiable but also equitable.
27.
The delay consequent upon force majeure events, which found
favour by the Department even, cannot be, therefore, permitted to be
knocked out and asphyxiated in the manner contemplated by the petitioner
herein, when the contractor is not seeking any damages at all. Since the
work has been completed ahead of schedule, the claimant becomes entitled
for bonus of early completion of work and, therefore, this Court does not
find any reason to interfere with the Award, respecting claim No.1.
28.
Claim No.4 pertains to grant of interest qua claim No.1 only.
29.
Admittedly, the claimant had not sought interest with respect to claim
No.2. This is evident from his petition. However, while awarding interest
under claim No.4, learned Arbitral Tribunal has granted interest not only
for claim No.1 but also for claim No.2. Since the claimant had never
prayed for any interest with respect to claim No.2, grant of interest
respecting claim No.2 was beyond the scope of arbitration proceedings and
was, therefore, per se illegal and unjustifiable.
30.
As per the majority view in Gayatri Balasamy vs. ISG Novasoft
Technologies Ltd.: 2025 SCC OnLine SC 986, the Court has limited powers
under Sections 34 and 37 of Arbitration and Conciliation Act to modify the
arbitral Award, which power can be exercised (i) when the award is
severable, by severing the “invalid” portion from the “valid” portion of the
award, (ii) by correcting any clerical, computational or typographical errors
which appear erroneous on the face of the record, (iii) post award interest
may be modified in some circumstances; and/or (iv) by invoking Article
142 of the Constitution within the prescribed limits of the constitution and
with great care and caution.
Signed By:SONIA
THAPLIYAL
17:04:28
O.M.P. (COMM) 563/2025
31.
Coming to claim No.7, while answering the same in favour of the
claimant, learned Tribunal has, merely, held that the actual amount of GST
payable or paid by claimant against the amount of Award shall be
reimbursed within three months, else on proof of payment, the petitioner
herein shall pay 12% future interest from the date of submission of proof of
payment of GST. It is argued by petitioner that no GST is payable on a
claim awarded under Sections 73 and 74 of Indian Contract Act, 1872. It is
also supplemented that while awarding 18% GST, no reason has either been
assigned by learned Arbitral Tribunal.
32.
Arbitration Awards, particularly those concerning construction and
infrastructure, need to be analysed component-wise for GST purposes.
33.
This is for the reason that different claims, within the same Award,
may invite different tax consequences. Amount awarded for additional
work, price escalation, or upward revision of contract value retain the
character of consideration for supply and might be liable to GST, whereas
amount awarded as compensation for breach of contract, liquidated
damages, loss, delay, or reimbursement of damage may not imply „supply‟
and may fall outside GST.
34.
Since learned Tribunal has merely directed for reimbursement
wherever GST is payable, this Court does not find any requirement of
interfering with claim No.7.
35.
The grant of interest, in relation to claim No.2, is both invalid and
severable from rest of the Award, and, therefore, the present petition stands
allowed in part and the Award insofar as it grants interest with respect to
claim No.2 is, hereby, set aside.
36.
The petition stands disposed of in aforesaid terms.
Signed By:SONIA
THAPLIYAL
17:04:28
O.M.P. (COMM) 563/2025
37.
Pending applications also stand disposed of in aforesaid terms.
(MANOJ JAIN)
JUDGE
OCTOBER 12, 2026
st
Signed By:SONIA
THAPLIYAL
17:04:28
O.M.P. (COMM) 563/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review