Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 24.12.2025
Pronounced on: 09.01.2026
+
W.P.(C) 77/2015
UNION OF INDIA
Through:
.....Petitioner
Ms.Pratima N. Lakra, CGSC
with Mr.Shailendra Mishra,
Ms.Mansi
Aggarwal
and
Mr.Chanakya Kene, Advs.
versus
SHRI RAJ PRIY SINGH
Through:
.....Respondent
Mr.Sagar
Saxena,
Mr.Krishnandu Haldar and
Mr.Abu Hassan Usmani, Advs.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE NAVIN CHAWLA
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE MADHU JAIN
JUDGMENT
NAVIN CHAWLA, J.
1.
This petition has been filed by the petitioner challenging the
Order dated 11.02.2014 passed by the learned Central Administrative
Tribunal, Principal Bench, New Delhi (hereinafter referred to as the,
‘Tribunal’) in O.A. No. 1517/2012, titled Sh. Raj Priy Singh v. Union
of India, by which the learned Tribunal had been pleased to allow the
O.A. filed by the respondent herein with the following directions:
“20. In the totality of facts and circumstances
of the case, we dispose of the instant Original
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 77/2015
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:55:43
Application with the following directions:
(i)
The impugned order dated 26.12.2011 is
quashed and set aside;
(ii) The respondent is directed to consider
the case of the applicant for allocation of the
State of Rajasthan by creating a
supernumerary post;
(iii) The exercise ordained above shall be
completed by the respondent within a period of
five months from the date of receipt of a
certified copy of this order; and
(iv) There shall be no order as to costs.”
CASE OF THE RESPONDENT BEFORE THE LEARNED
TRIBUNAL:
2.
To give a brief background of the facts in which the present
petition arises, the respondent had joined the Indian Forest Service on
30.08.2010 as a probationer after qualifying for the Indian Forest
Service Examination, 2009 (IFS, 2009).
3.
While filling up the form, he had recorded his willingness to
work in the Home State of Rajasthan in Column 19 thereof by
writing ‘yes’.
4.
The respondent claimed that he had recorded Rajasthan as his
first choice of posting by way of his e-mail dated 08.05.2010. The
respondent, before the said e-mail, had uploaded the preference
forms, including one dated 23.04.2010, wherein he gave Rajasthan
as a 6th choice in preference. He submitted before the learned
Tribunal that this was due to a confusion being caused between the
roman and the arithmetic numerals used in the form. It was
submitted by the respondent that this confusion was recognized by
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 77/2015
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:55:43
the petitioner, leading to the petitioner issuing the Office
Memorandum (O.M.) dated 11.03.2011.
5.
The respondent claimed that though Rajasthan was mentioned
by the respondent as his 6th preference, being his Home State and
the respondent having already stated in his application that he was
willing to be posted in the Home State, the same was of no
consequence and the respondent should have been treated as an
‘insider candidate’ by the petitioner while allocating the cadre in
terms of the Cadre Allocation Policy for the All India ServicesIAF/IPS/IFS, 2008, issued vide O.M. dated 10.04.2008 (hereinafter
referred to as the, ‘Cadre Allocation Policy’).
6.
The respondent further claimed that as per the Union Public
Service Commission (UPSC) Selection List of IFS, 2009, there
were three insider vacancies available for Rajasthan; one in General
category, one in OBC category, and one in ST category. The
respondent claimed that applying Clauses 5 to 8 of the Cadre
Allocation Policy, the third insider vacancy should have been
allocated to the respondent, instead he was allocated Nagaland
cadre, which was his 22nd preference, by an incorrect interpretation
of the Cadre Allocation Policy.
7.
With the above grievance, the respondent had approached the
learned Tribunal in form of the above O.A., praying for the
following reliefs:
“a) Direct the respondent to
Rajasthan Cadre to the applicant.
allocate
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 77/2015
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:55:43
b)
Direct the respondent to take necessary
action to allocate cadre to the applicant as per
his eligibility according to preference of the
applicant out of the remaining 11 vacancies
not taking into account preferences for those
who had not joined.”
IMPUGNED ORDER:
8.
The learned Tribunal, by way of the Impugned Order, held that
though there was a confusion in the proforma seeking preferences
from the candidates and the same led to a clarification being issued by
the petitioner vide Letter dated 11.03.2011, however, the same would
not have any effect on the case of the respondent inasmuch as the
respondent had submitted a new set of preferences vide his
communication dated 11.05.2010 and reiterated the same by way of a
subsequent signed document dated 04.04.2011, giving Rajasthan as a
6th preference for the cadre allocation.
9.
The respondent has not challenged the above finding before us.
Therefore, as far as the present petition is concerned, we have to
proceed on the basis that though the respondent had submitted that he
has no objection on being posted in the Home Cadre, the Home Cadre
of Rajasthan was given by him as his 6th preference, with the 1st
preference being of State of Himachal Pradesh.
10.
On above facts, the learned Tribunal held that as the respondent
could not be allocated his first five preferences, he should have been
considered for his 6th preference, that is, Rajasthan, as an ‘Insider
Candidate’. We quote from the Impugned Order as under:
“16. It is well admitted that the applicant
could not be allocated his first five
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 77/2015
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:55:43
preferences. Therefore, we are of the opinion
that the applicant ought to have been
considered for his 6th preference, which is
Rajasthan as he had opted in the revised
option duly accepted by the respondent vide its
letter dated 04.04.2011. Here, we are of the
opinion that the option made while filling up
the application form cannot be disregarded
altogether. The second question that we are
compelled to ask is that if the applicant is not
considered for his 6th preference, which is of
his Home State, then what would be meaning
and purpose of giving the 6th choice. In that
case, the rules would have simply stated that if
an officer, who has not opted for his Home
State as his first choice, would not be
considered for his Home State in any of the
subsequent options that he has made. The
same, in our opinion, is totally against the
rulings. Instead the position is otherwise. If an
officer has opted for his Home State in a
subsequent option, he has to be considered
against the insider vacancy as per his position
in merit. There is no general insider.
Admittedly, Sudeep Kaur is superior to the
applicant in the order of merit and has rightly
been placed against the OBC vacancy and one
Kapil Chandrawal (SC insider candidate
having rank no.83), has also been rightly
moved to fill in the other vacancy. Still there is
one more insider vacancy against which the
applicant ought to have been considered but
this has not been the case. This issue is
accordingly decided.”
11.
Based on its above finding, the learned Tribunal held that while
it would not be advisable to unsettle the cadre allocation already
conducted by the petitioner, the petitioner must consider the case of
the respondent for allocation of Rajasthan as a cadre by creating a
supernumerary post.
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 77/2015
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:55:43
12.
Aggrieved of the above, the petitioner has filed the present
petition.
SUBMISSIONS OF THE LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE
PETITIONER
13.
The learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the learned
Tribunal has erred in interpreting the Cadre Allocation Policy. She
submits that for being appointed as an ‘Insider Candidate’, the
respondent was required to give his Home State, that is, Rajasthan, as
the 1st preference. In support of this plea, she places specific reliance
on Clause 8 of the Cadre Allocation Policy and the Order of the
learned Tribunal in Ms. Arti Lal IAS Probationer (2010 Batch) v.
Union of India & Anr., (2012) SCC OnLine CAT 565.
14.
Placing reliance on the judgments of the Supreme Court in
Union of India & Ors. v. Rajiv Yadav, IAS & Ors., (1994) 6 SCC 38,
and Union of India & Anr. v. A. Shainamol, IAS & Anr., (2021) 20
SCC 267, she submits that no candidate can claim a vested right to the
allocation of a particular cadre, including his Home State. The
respondent was to join an All India Service and, therefore, has to be
ready to serve at any part of the country and cannot insist on being
allocated the Home State as his cadre. She submits that, therefore, the
learned Tribunal has erred in issuing the above directions to the
petitioner.
SUBMISSIONS OF THE LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE
RESPONDENT
15.
On the other hand, the learned counsel for the respondent
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 77/2015
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:55:43
submits that in terms of Clause 7 of the Cadre Allocation Policy, the
rules for allocation of the Home Cadre have been prescribed. He
submits that there were three Home Cadre vacancies in the impugned
selection process; one for general category, one for OBC category and
one for ST category. Ms.Sudeep Kaur was appointed against the
insider OBC vacancy, and Mr.Kapil Chandrawal, an insider SC
candidate was appointed against the second insider vacancy. For the
third insider vacancy, the respondent should have been allocated the
same as he was the senior most OBC insider candidate and had stated
that he was willing to be allocated his Home State. However, by a
wrong interpretation of the Cadre Allocation Policy, the respondent
was not allocated his Home State but instead allocated Nagaland
cadre, which was his 22nd preference.
15.
Placing reliance on the judgment of the Supreme Court in C.M.
Thri Vikrama Varma v. Avinash Mohanty & Ors., (2011) 7 SCC
385; of this Court in a batch of connected petitions including in
Himanshu Kumar Verma & Anr. v. Union of India & Ors., (2019)
SCC OnLine Del 8353, and on the judgment of the Kerala High Court
at Ernakulam in Shilpa. D IPS v. Union of India & Ors.,
2025:KER:37197, he submits that while a candidate may not have a
vested right to being allocated a particular cadre, the candidate has a
right to be considered fairly and in accordance with the rules
applicable to the cadre allocation.
16.
He submits that, in the present case, a reading of Clauses 5 to 8
of the Cadre Allocation Policy would clearly show that preference has
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 77/2015
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:55:43
to be given for allocation of Home Cadre to the candidates who opt for
Home Cadre, and it is only when there is no Insider Candidate
available, that the vacancy will be shifted to outsider category.
17.
He submits that the rules have to be interpreted with their
normal grammatical meaning and hardship cannot dictate the
interpretation of the rules. If there is a conflict between the rules and
the policy directives, it is the statutory rules which will prevail. In
support, he places reliance on the judgments of the Supreme Court in
Union of India & Ors. v. Somasundaram Viswanath & Ors., (1989)
1 SCC 175, Gurudevdatta VKSSS Maryadit & Ors. v. State of
Maharashtra & Ors., (2001) 4 SCC 534; and Rohitash Kumar &
Ors. v. Om Prakash Sharma & Ors., (2013) 11 SCC 451.
ANALYSIS & FINDINGS
18.
We have considered the submissions made by the learned
counsels for the parties.
19.
As far as the facts are concerned, they are not in dispute and can
be stated as under:
i.
The respondent, in his application form, had in answer to
Column 19 stated as under:
In case you are finally recommended and appointed to the Indian YES
Forest Service indicate whether you would like to be considered for
allocation to the State/UT to which you belong.
ii. The respondent, in his final preference, had given 1st preference
to the State of Himachal Pradesh, with Rajasthan as his 6th preference
and Nagaland being his 22nd preference.
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 77/2015
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:55:43
iii. There were a total of 3 ‘Insider’ vacancies for the State of
Rajasthan, which were divided into various categories as under:
Name of
the
State/
Joint
Cadre
Rajasthan
General
(Unreserved)
Other Backward
Classes
Scheduled Castes
Scheduled Tribes
Total
Insider
Insider
Insider
Insider
Total
Outsider
Outsider
Outsider
Outsider
iv. The final allocation for the State of Rajasthan was as under:
Rank
No.
Name of
Candidate
Bijo Joy
Vikram
Kesharee
Pradhan
Sudeep Kaur
Anita
Supongsashi
Kapil Chandrawal
Home State
declared
Kerala
Orissa
Category
Insider/Outsider
General
General
Outsider
Outsider
Rajasthan
Uttar Pradesh
Nagaland
Rajasthan
OBC
SC
ST
SC
Insider
Outsider
Outsider
Insider
v. The respondent had secured 64th rank in the final merit and was
an OBC category candidate, however, in spite of non-availability of
Insider candidate for the General vacancy, instead of being allocated
Rajasthan, his Home State, was allocated Nagaland, that is, his 22nd
preference.
20.
In the above facts, we need to determine if the respondent had
rightly been excluded from being allocated Rajasthan cadre under the
Cadre Allocation Policy.
21.
The Cadre Allocation Policy, so far as is relevant to answer the
above issue, is contained in Clause 5 to Clause 8 thereof, which are reproduced hereinunder:
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 77/2015
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:55:43
“5. The candidates shall give their choice in
the order of their preference from amongst the
various State cadres including his „Home
cadre/state‟ and if a candidate does not give
any preference for any of the cadre(s), it will
be presumed that he has no specific preference
for those cadre(s). Accordingly, if he is not
allotted to any one of the cadres for which he
has indicated preference, he shall be allotted
along with other such candidates in the order
of rank to any of the remaining cadres,
arranged in alphabetical order, in which there
are vacancies in his category after allocation
of all the candidates who can be allotted to
cadres in accordance with their preference.
6.
A candidate shall be allotted to his
Home cadre or any other cadre, as the case
may be, on the basis of his merit, preference
and vacancy available at his turn in his
category.
7.
The following shall be the formula for
filling up of an insider vacancy belonging to a
particular category for which a candidate is
not available.
a.
When no candidate is available against
an Insider SC vacancy in a Cadre, the same
shall be filled up by bringing in the senior
most insider officer available in the merit list
of ST candidates (failing which in the merit list
of OBC candidates and in the merit list of the
Unreserved candidates in that order), and
shifting the SC vacancy of the Cadre to the
cadre to which the incoming officer would
have normally been allotted against the
available outsider vacancy in his category
(failing which to the next cadre in alphabetical
order in which the outsider vacancy is
available).
b.
When no candidate is available against
an Insider ST vacancy in a Cadre, the same
shall be filled up by bringing in the senior
most insider officer available in the merit list
of SC candidates (failing which in the merit
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 77/2015
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:55:43
list OBC list and in the merit list of the
Unreserved candidates in that order) and
shifting the ST vacancy of the Cadre, to the
cadre to which the incoming officer would
have normally been allotted against the
available outsider vacancy in his category
(failing which to the next cadre in alphabetical
order in which the outsider vacancy is
available).
c.
When no candidate is available against
an Insider OBC vacancy in a Cadre, the same
shall be filled up by bringing in the senior
most insider officer available in the merit list
of ST candidates (failing which in the merit list
of SC candidates and in the merit list of the
Unreserved candidates in that order) and
shifting the OBC vacancy of the Cadre to the
cadre to which the incoming officer would
have normally been allotted against the
available outsider vacancy in his category
(failing which to the next cadre in alphabetical
order in which the outsider vacancy is
available).
Provided that in every such case listed in
clause (a), (b) and (c) above, if insiderphysically-disabled-candidate(s)
of
the
relevant community is/are available, such
physically disabled candidate (senior most in
the merit list) shall be so adjusted. In other
words, a physically disabled candidate would
have a higher claim for being adjusted as
compared with non-physically disabled
candidates of his community.
d.
When no insider unreserved candidate
is available against an Insider Unreserved
vacancy available in a Cadre but insider
SC/ST/OBC candidate(s) is/are available, such
senior most ST candidate (failing which such
senior most SC candidate and such senior
most OBC candidate in that order) shall be
adjusted by shifting out the Unreserved insider
vacancy to the next cadre in alphabetical
order having outsider vacancy in that category
and bringing in an Outsider vacancy of that
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 77/2015
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:55:43
category from that cadre.
8.
The cadre allocation shall consist of
three steps as follows:
(i)
First, all those candidates who can be
allocated against the insider vacancies
available in their category would be so
allocated.
(ii) Second, the candidates who are eligible
for allocation to their Home State as per para
7 above will be allocated-first as per clause
(d) of para 7 and then as per the remaining
part of para 7. In the context of clause (a), (b)
and (c) of para 7 above, the cadres to which
the incoming officers would have normally
been allocated would be determined by
allocating all the candidates remaining
unallocated after allocation as per clause (i)
of para 8 and clause (d) of para 7 above,
against the outsider vacancies plus all the
insider vacancies remaining unallocated after
the said allocation as per clause (i) of para
8 and clause (d) of para 7 above. Wherever the
allocation happens to be against only the
unallocated insider vacancy and no outsider
vacancy is available in the cadre to facilitate
the exchange, the next cadre in alphabetical
order in which outsider vacancy is available in
the relevant category would be considered for
transfer of SC/ST/OBC vacancy as per clause
(a), (b) and (c) of para 7 above. If an insider
vacancy cannot be filled as per para 7 above,
it would be converted to outsider vacancy and
filled as such, duly accounting the fact of
unfilled insider vacancy in the insider-outsider
roster of the relevant cadre.
(iii) Finally, all the remaining candidates
will be listed under their respective category
in the order of merit and then allocated to a
cadre on the basis of their merit, preference
and the outsider vacancies in their category
(including the outsider vacancies resulting
from conversion of insider vacancies, which
remained eventually unfilled after the
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 77/2015
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:55:43
allocation as per clause (i) and (ii) of para 8
above) available at their turn in the cadres
other than their home cadre. Notwithstanding
this, however, if during the course of
allocation against the outsider vacancies as
above a candidate is going to be allocated to
his own home cadre because there are no
other vacancies left for allocation other than
those in his home cadre, an „exchange‟ would
be resorted to whereby the allocation of such
candidate would be swapped with the cadre
allotted to the first candidate above him in the
list whose home state and allotted cadre are
different.”
22.
A reading of the above Policy would show that a candidate has
to give his/her choice in order of his/her preference from amongst the
various State cadres, including his/her ‘Home Cadre/State’. The
candidate shall be allocated his home cadre or any other cadre, as the
case may be, on the basis of his merit, preference and vacancy
available ‘at his turn in his category’. Clause 7 of the Cadre Allocation
Policy gives a formula for filling up of an insider vacancy, that is, a
vacancy earmarked for the Home State cadre. However, before we
deal with the same in detail, we would first like to note Clause 8 of the
Cadre Allocation Policy, which states that the cadre allocation shall
consist of three steps, with the first being that all those candidates who
can be allocated against the insider vacancies available in their
category would be allocated first; thereafter, the candidates who are
eligible for allocation to their Home State as per Clause 7 above will
be allocated by first applying Clause 7(d) and thereafter, Clause 7(a),
(b) and (c); and it is only thereafter that the remaining candidates will
be listed under their respective categories in order of merit and
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 77/2015
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:55:43
allocated a cadre on the basis of their merit, preference, and outsider
vacancies in their category including the ones resulting from
conversion of insider vacancies available at their turn in the cadres
other than their home cadre. Therefore, once the Insider Vacancies are
filled, the allocation proceeds for the Outsider Vacancies, which
would also include the leftover vacancies of the Insider Vacancies.
23.
We are of the opinion that if Clause 8 of the Cadre Allocation
Policy is to operate, the candidate must give his/her Home State as
his/her first preference otherwise the whole scheme of Clause 8 would
fail. This can be easily seen from the following example- Let us say, a
candidate, like in the present case the respondent, had not given his
Home State as the first preference but as the 6th preference. The
candidate, because of merit, was entitled to one of the first five
preferences that he had given as an outsider candidate. In case the
preference of Home State is to prevail, such a candidate would
necessarily be given the home cadre though that was not his choice,
over and above the first five preferences. This would deny such a
candidate of his right to be allocated a cadre in accordance with his
merit and preference. The Cadre Allocation Policy does not provide
for the same.
24.
A harmonious reading of Clauses 5 to 8 of the Cadre Allocation
Policy can mean that the petitioner shall first allocate the insider
vacancies as per the category of the candidates who have given Home
State as the first preference. In case the insider vacancy still remains
vacant and unfilled, Clause 7 of the Cadre Allocation Policy will be
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 77/2015
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:55:43
put into operation and the vacancies will be allocated in accordance
thereto, to the remaining candidates who had given Home State as
their first preference, however, due to lack of vacancy or the vacancy
being filled in their category as Insiders, could not be allocated the
Home Cadre. Once this exercise is completed, the leftover Insider
vacancies shall be treated as Outsider vacancies and shall be allocated
to remaining candidates as per their merit and preference.
25.
The Cadre Allocation Policy cannot be read to mean that
irrespective of the preference of the candidate, if an insider vacancy is
available in his Home cadre and he has opted for the same, only the
Home cadre will be allocated to such a candidate. This, to our mind,
would defeat the rights of the candidate to be allocated the cadre as
per his/her merit and his/her preference.
26.
The above mode of allocation of cadre was also explained by
the learned Tribunal in its judgment in Ms.Arti Lal (supra), with
which we agree.
27.
While considering the claim of a candidate for allocation of a
particular cadre, the Supreme Court in A. Shainamol (supra),
following the judgment in Rajiv Yadav (supra), held that the
allocation of a particular cadre is not a matter of right; while a selected
candidate has a right to be considered for appointment and being
allocated a cadre in terms of the Cadre Allocation Policy, he/she has
no right to be allocated a particular cadre of his/her choice or to
his/her Home State; allotment of cadre is an incidence of service and
the candidate must be willing to serve in any cadre that is allocated to
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 77/2015
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:55:43
him/her in accordance with the Policy.
28.
In C.M. Thri Vikrama Varma (supra), which has been relied
upon by the learned counsel for the respondent, this principle was
reiterated by observing that a member appointed to the All India
Service has no right to be allocated a particular State cadre, but only
has a right to a fair and equitable treatment in the matter of allocation
under Article 14 and Article 16(1) of the Constitution of India.
29.
While there can be no dispute with the legal principles of
interpreting a statute/rule/policy document, that such interpretation
must be in accordance with the natural, ordinary or popular sense and
in accordance with the grammatical meaning assigned to the words
used, and cannot be governed by the considerations of hardship or
inconvenience being caused to any party, however, applying the above
rules, we find that no fault can be ascribed to the petitioner in not
allocating the Home Cadre of Rajasthan which the respondent claimed
as a 6th preference. The judgments of the Supreme Court in
Somasundaram Viswanath (supra), Gurudevdatta VKSSS (supra)
and in Rohitash Kumar (supra) cannot come to the aid of the
respondent.
30.
In Himanshu Kumar Verma (supra), this Court found that the
interpretation and implementation of the Cadre Allocation Policy,
2017, resorted to by the respondents therein, was unreasonable and
arbitrary. We do not find any such case being made out by the
respondent herein.
31.
In Shilpa. D IPS (supra), the High Court of Kerala at
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 77/2015
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:55:43
Ernakulam found fault in the number of vacancies having been
allocated for the insider candidates in various categories and the
subsequent allocation thereof. The said judgment, therefore, will have
no application to the facts of the present case.
32.
Keeping in view the above, we are unable to sustain the
Impugned Order passed by the learned Tribunal. In our view, the
respondent was rightly not considered for the insider vacancy for his
Home Cadre, that is, the State of Rajasthan, as he had chosen the same
as his 6th preference of his cadre allocation, and when considered for
the same as an Outsider Candidate, did not qualify as per his merit.
33.
The Impugned Order passed by the learned Tribunal is,
accordingly, set aside.
34.
The petition is allowed.
35.
The parties shall bear their own costs.
NAVIN CHAWLA, J.
MADHU JAIN, J.
JANUARY 9, 2026/sg/ik
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 77/2015
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:55:43
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review