Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
#
+
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
CNR No. DLHC011441382016
O.M.P. (COMM) 253/2016
UNION OF INDIA
.....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Jasvinder Singh and Ms.
Shipra Shukla, Advs.
versus
M/S B.L MEHTA CONSTRUCTION PVT. LTD.
.....Respondent
Through: Mr. Jeevesh Nagrath, Sr. Adv.
with Ms. Kirti Mewar, Mr.
Arjun Gaur, Ms. Kriti Sharma,
Ms. Bhumi Jain and Mr.
Ayushmann Chouksey, Advs.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE OM PRAKASH SHUKLA
%
JUDGMENT (ORAL)
17.08.2026
1.
The present petition under Section 34 of the Arbitration and
Conciliation Act, 19961 is being preferred by the Petitioner/Union of
India
assailing
the
arbitral
award
dated
30.10.2014
as
corrected/amended by the consequential additional award dated
11.11.20142 rendered by the learned Sole Arbitrator Shri Satish
Chander, Chief-Engineer (Contracts).
2.
By way of the impugned award, the learned Sole Arbitrator
substantially allowed various monetary claims preferred by the
Respondent/Contractors and rejected the recoveries/counter claims
raised by the Petitioner.
1 “the Act” hereinafter
2 the impugned award
Signed By:GUNN
20:06:07
O.M.P. (COMM) 253/2016
3.
Briefly put, the Petitioner had invited tenders for the work
described as “construction of dwelling unit including allied external
services for officers and PBOR at Sector – 31, Chandigarh. The tender
submitted by the Respondent was accepted on 06.03.2007 for a total
contract value of Rs.28,23,81,272.50/-.
4.
Pursuant thereto, the parties entered into contract for the
aforesaid work. The stipulated date of commencement of the work
was 16.03.2007 and the stipulated date of completion was 15.03.2008.
The contract period was subsequently extended and the Respondent
was granted an extension up to 15.05.2008
5.
Upon completion of the physical works, dispute arose between
the parties in relation to, inter alia, payment and pre-audit clearance of
the final bill, reimbursement of additional sales tax/VAT liability,
ward charges incurred in respect of the dwelling units which had not
been handed over, composition fees paid to the local authorities, and
interest on running account bills.
6.
In view of the disputes, the Engineer-in-Chief being the
appointing authority under the contract referred the disputes to
arbitration vide letter dated 21.11.2012.
7.
The Respondent raised 25 claims before the learned Arbitrator
while the Petitioner raised recoveries/counter claims, principally
Signed By:GUNN
20:06:07
O.M.P. (COMM) 253/2016
towards alleged unadjusted sales tax liability amounting to Rs.64.84
lakhs.
8.
The learned Arbitral Tribunal rejected the Petitioner’s Section
16 objection that Claims Nos. 1 to 20, 22 and 23 stood waived under
Condition No. 55 after submission of the final bill and No-Demand
Certificate.
9.
The Tribunal relied on the contractor’s letter dated 22.12.2011,
whereby the contractor stated that, since the final bill had remained
unpaid for about 3.5 years, the No-Demand Certificate stood revoked
and the final bill was to be treated as signed under protest, and held
that the contractor was entitled to withdraw the No-Demand
Certificate.
10.
The Tribunal therefore treated the said claims as arbitrable and
proceeded to adjudicate them on merits, including Claim No. 8 for
reimbursement of ₹6.12 lakh paid to the UT Administration.
11.
On merits, the learned Arbitral Tribunal examined the
individual claims on the basis of the contract, and substantially
allowed the Respondent’s claims.
12.
Learned Counsel appearing for the Petitioner assailed the
impugned award principally on the following grounds: -
(i)
It is contended that the Respondent had submitted the
final bill on 10.12.2009 along with an unconditional “no
demand certificate”. According to the learned Counsel
Signed By:GUNN
20:06:07
O.M.P. (COMM) 253/2016
for the Petitioner, in view of the Condition 55 of the
General Conditions of Contract3, submission of the final
bill accompanied by the no demand certificate brought
the contractual claims to an end and no further arbitral
dispute survived.
(ii)
It is submitted that the Petitioner had raised an objection
to the jurisdiction of the learned Arbitrator under Section
16 of the Act vide application dated 25.07.2013.
however, the objection was kept pending and decided
only with the final award, which the petitioner contends
was contrary to Section 16(5) and amounted to a serious
procedural irregularity.
(iii)
It was contended that the Respondent had failed to
produce the necessary documents proving actual payment
of tax, which was a contractual prerequisite for
reimbursement.
Further,
the
Respondent’s
tax
assessments for relevant years were under challenge and
the liability for FY 2008–09 had not been finally
determined. Therefore, in the absence of proof of actual
tax payment, the petitioner’s recovery claim of ₹64.84
lakh ought not to have been allowed.
(iv)
The Petitioner also challenged the award of Rs.33 lakhs
towards watch and ward expenses calculated at Rs.1.50
lakhs per month for a period of 22 months. It is submitted
3 “GCC” hereinafter
Signed By:GUNN
20:06:07
O.M.P. (COMM) 253/2016
that the Respondent had not produced primary evidence,
vouchers
or
other
contemporaneous
material
to
substantiate the alleged expenditure.
13.
Learned Counsel appearing for the Respondent on the contrary
supports the impugned award and submitted that none of the grounds
contemplated under Section 34 of the Act is made out.
14.
He submits that the final bill submitted in 2009 remained
unpaid for more than three and a half years, despite condition 56
requiring settlement within six months. It is contended that owing to
the prolonged withholding of payments on account of audit objection,
the Respondent revoked the no demand certificate vide letter dated
22.12.2011 and treated the final bill as being under protest. Reliance
was place upon R.L. Kalathia & Co. vs State of Gujarat4, to contend that
issuance of a no demand certificate does not in every case constitute
an absolute bar to subsequent genuine claims.
15.
It is further submitted that the objections under Section 16 had,
were duly adjudicated by the learned Arbitrator vide order dated
12.12.2013, whereby the plea of accord and satisfaction was rejected
on the ground that the final bill itself had remained unpaid. According
to the Respondent, there is no statutory mandate requiring every
objection under Section 16 to be determined as isolated preliminary
issue before the Tribunal proceeds consider the merits. Reliance is
placed upon Maharshi Dayanand University & Anr. v. Anand Coop.
(2011) 2 SCC 400
Signed By:GUNN
20:06:07
O.M.P. (COMM) 253/2016
L/C Society Ltd. & Anr.5
16.
On Counter Claim No. 6, it is submitted that it is squarely
covered by Special Condition 25.3 of the contract, which
contemplated adjustment on account of statutory increases in tax
liability after submission of the tender.
17.
The Respondent relied upon the relevant provisions regarding
tax concession upon audit certificates and account evidencing the
additional tax lability incurred by him
18.
Lastly on Claim No. 8, it is submitted that the watch and ward
expenditure became necessary because despite completion of the
dwelling unit, the Petitioner failed to take over possession for a period
of approximately 22 months, thereby requiring the Respondent to
continue to maintain and safeguard the completed units.
19.
I have heard learned Counsel for the parties and perused the
impugned award, the arbitral record and the written arguments placed
on record.
20.
Before considering the individual grounds of challenge, it is
opposite to reiterate the limited scope of the judicial scrutiny under
Section 34 of the Act. The Court exercising jurisdiction under Section
34 does not sit as a Court of appeal over an arbitral award. Reappreciation
of
evidence,
re-assessment
of
factual
findings,
substitution of Court’s own interpretation of contractual provisions at
(2007) 5 SCC 295
Signed By:GUNN
20:06:07
O.M.P. (COMM) 253/2016
that of the Arbitral Tribunal is impermissible merely because another
view may be possible.
21.
The Section 34 Court is required to examine whether the award
suffers any of the statutory infirmities contemplated under Section 34
of the Act. On the other hand, where the Tribunal has adopted
plausible interpretation of the contractual terms and have arrived at
findings on the basis of the material placed before it, the Court would
not ordinarily interfere with such findings.
22.
The first contention of the Petitioner is that the learned
Arbitrator committed a material procedural irregularity by failing to
decide the objection under Section 16 of the Act as a preliminary
issue.
23.
The submission is without merit. Section 16 embodies a
principal of kompetenz-kompetenz and empowers the Arbitral Tribunal
to rule on its own jurisdiction including objections with respect to the
existence or validity of the arbitration agreement.
24.
According to this court, the provisions does not mandate that
every jurisdictional objection must necessarily be adjudicated as a
separate preliminary issue before the Tribunal proceed to consider the
merits.
25.
In the present case, the objection was not left undecided. The
learned Arbitrator considered the Petitioner’s application under
Section 16 and vide order dated 12.12.2013, rejected the plea founded
Signed By:GUNN
20:06:07
O.M.P. (COMM) 253/2016
upon accord and satisfaction.
26.
The Tribunal held inter alia, that since the final bill itself had
remained unpaid, the Petitioner could not contend that the parties had
arrived at a full and final settlement of the disputes.
27.
Thus, the grievance of the Petitioner is not that the jurisdictional
objection was never adjudicated but essentially that it was not
adjudicated at the particular stage desired by the Petitioner. Such an
objection, in the facts of the present case, does not constitute a
sufficient ground for setting aside the subsequent award.
28.
The substantive plea of accord and satisfaction also fails to
commend acceptance. The mere execution or submission of the no
demand certificate cannot in all circumstances operate as an absolute
bar against the raising of genuine claims.
29.
The surrounding circumstances, including the circumstances in
which the certificate was furnished and whether the contractual dues
had actually discharged being relevant consideration.
30.
The learned Arbitrator has found that the final bill has remained
unpaid for a substantial period and that the Respondent subsequently
revoked the no demand certificate vide its letter dated 22.12.2011. The
Tribunal, upon consideration of the contractual provisions and the
surroundings circumstances, concluded that there were no concluded
accord and satisfaction between the parties.
Signed By:GUNN
20:06:07
O.M.P. (COMM) 253/2016
31.
The principal laid down by Hon’ble Supreme Court in Arabian
Exports (P) Ltd. v. National Insurance Co. Ltd.6 supports the
proposition that a no demand certificate by itself irrespective of the
circumstances in which it came to be issued, does not necessarily
extinguish an otherwise subsisting claim.
32.
In view of this court, the finding recorded by the learned
Arbitrator is a finding of fact based upon the contractual document
and the circumstances placed before him.
33.
The Petitioner could not satisfy that such finding is perverse and
supported by no evidence or otherwise contrary to the fundamental
terms of the contract.
34.
Consequently, the challenge found upon condition 55 of the
GCC and the alleged accord and satisfaction is rejected.
35.
The Petitioner has challenged the award of Rs.69,84,000/-
towards the reimbursement of additional sales tax liability and the
rejection of its corresponding counter-claim and recovery.
36.
The learned Arbitrator examined special condition 25.3 of the
Contract, which provided for appropriate contractual adjustment in the
event of statutory variation in the tax burden subsequent to submission
of the tender.
37.
The Tribunal found, upon consideration of the material placed
(2025) 10 SCC 388
Signed By:GUNN
20:06:07
O.M.P. (COMM) 253/2016
before it that the tax concession available at the time of tender have
subsequently been withdrawn by the Union Territory administration
vide notification dated 21.05.2007, resulting in an increased tax
liability.
38.
The Respondent has also placed on record audited accounts,
certificates and material relating payments under the registered TIN.
39.
Upon appreciation of the contractual provisions and the
evidence, the learned Arbitration awarded Rs.69,84,000/- towards the
additional tax liability, at the same time the learned Tribunal directed
the Respondent to furnish the bank guarantee so as to safeguards the
interest of the Petitioner pending finalisation of the assessment for the
relevant financial year.
40.
This direction demonstrates the that the learned Arbitrator did
not mechanically accept the Respondent’s claim. The Tribunal
assessed the contractual entitlement as well as the potential
consequence of subsequent tax assessment and incorporated an
appropriate safeguard.
41.
The challenge raised by the Petitioner essentially seeks
reappreciation of the tax records and the evidentiary material
considered by the Tribunal.
42.
Such an exercise is beyond the permissible scope of Section 34
jurisdiction.
Signed By:GUNN
20:06:07
O.M.P. (COMM) 253/2016
43.
Unless, the finding of the Arbitral Tribunal is shown to be
perverse based on no evidence, contrary to the express terms of the
contract, this Court cannot substitute its own assessment of the
evidence for that of the learned Tribunal.
44.
No such infirmity has been demonstrated or pleaded in the
present case. The challenge to claim no. 6 and the corresponding
counter-claim is accordingly rejected.
45.
The Petitioner has also challenged the award of Rs.33 lacs
towards watch and ward charges assessed at Rs.1.50/- lacs per month
for 22 months.
46.
The learned Arbitrator recorded a specific finding that although
the physical works had been completed, the dwelling units could not
be handed over immediately and remained under the Respondent’s
care for a considerable period on account of delay and taking over
possession by the Petitioner.
47.
The Tribunal considered the nature and magnitude of the
project. The number of dwelling units involved and the expenditure
necessarily incurred in maintaining and safeguarding the completed
works during the period for which possession remain with the
Respondent.
48.
On that basis, the Tribunal assess the reasonable monthly
expenditure at Rs.1.50 lacs and awarded Rs.33,00,000/- for the period
of 22 months.
Signed By:GUNN
20:06:07
O.M.P. (COMM) 253/2016
49.
The Petitioner’s objection that the award was not supported by
individual vouchers or primary expenditure records cannot, by itself
justify interference under Section 34. The assessment of the quantum
of damages or expenditures were based on the material available
before the Tribunal and is within its domain.
50.
The Petitioner could not satisfy that the aforesaid finding is
such that no reasonable person could have arrived at nor it has been
shown that the Tribunal ignored any material contractual stipulation or
proceeded
on
a
wholly
extraneous
consideration.
In
these
circumstances, the challenge to claim no. 8 is also therefore rejected.
51.
The Petitioner also questioned the award of interest on delayed
running accounts bill and the grant of pre-suit and pendente lite
interest.
52.
Section 31 (7) of the Act confers upon the Arbitral Tribunal, the
statutory power to award interest in accordance with the parameters
prescribed therein. The exercise of such discretion, particularly where
the Tribunal has recorded reasons for the award of interest does not
warrant interference unless the award is shown contrary to the contract
or to the provision of the Act.
53.
No such infirmity has been established before this Court. The
challenge to the award of interest is accordingly rejected.
54.
The jurisdiction exercised by this Court under Section 34 of the
Signed By:GUNN
20:06:07
O.M.P. (COMM) 253/2016
Act is supervisory and not the appellate.
55.
The Court is not required to sit in appeal qua the findings of an
Arbitral Tribunal or to undertake a fresh evaluation of the evidence
merely because the Petitioner seeks to persuade the Court to arrive at a
different conclusion.
56.
The learned Sole Arbitrator has considered the contractual
provisions, the rival contention and the evidence placed before him
and has rendered a well-reasoned award.
57.
The findings relating to accord and satisfaction, reimbursement
of additional sales tax, watch and ward charges and interest are based
on the material available on arbitral record and falls within the
permissible domain of arbitral adjudication.
58.
The Petitioner could not establish that the impugned award
suffers for patent illegality, perversity, violation of the fundamental
policy of India law or any other good ground contemplated in the
Section 34 of the Act.
59.
This Court, therefore, finds no good ground, warranting
interference with the impugned award dated 30.10.2014, as amended
by the consequential additional award dated 11.11.2015.
60.
Accordingly, the present petition is dismissed with no orders as
to cost.
Signed By:GUNN
20:06:07
O.M.P. (COMM) 253/2016
61.
Pending applications, if any, stand disposed of.
OM PRAKASH SHUKLA, J
AUGUST 17, 2026/ss/at
Signed By:GUNN
20:06:07
O.M.P. (COMM) 253/2016
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review