Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of decision: 16th January, 2026
%
+
RFA 556/2017 & CM APPL. 15627-15628/2024
UNION OF INDIA
Through:
.....Appellant
Ms. Radhika Bishwajit Dubey, CGSC
with Ms. Gurleen Kaur Waraich, Mr.
Kritarth Upadhyay and Mr. Ayush
Dogra, Advocates.
versus
CAPTAIN VIDYA SAGAR
Through:
.....Respondent
Mr. Rajesh Srivastava, Advocate.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT BANSAL
AMIT BANSAL, J. (Oral)
CM APPL. 15628/2024 (for condonation of delay)
1.
This application has been filed seeking condonation of 580 days’
delay in filing I.A. 15627/2024.
2.
For the reasons stated, the delay in filing I.A. 15627/2024 stands
condoned.
3.
The application stands disposed of.
CM APPL. 15627/2024 (u/O XXII Rule 4 of CPC, 1908)
4.
This application has been filed to bring on record the legal
representatives of the deceased respondent.
5.
Counsel appearing on behalf of the proposed legal representatives
Digitally Signed
By:AANCHAL TAGGAR
14:50:22
RFA 556/2017
does not oppose this application.
6.
Accordingly, the legal representatives of the deceased respondent are
permitted to be impleaded as respondents. The amended memo of parties
filed along with the application is taken on record.
7.
The application stands disposed of.
RFA 556/2017
8.
The present appeal has been filed seeking setting aside of the
impugned judgment dated 31st August, 2016 passed by the Additional
District Judge-06, South District, Saket Courts, New Delhi (hereinafter the
‘Trial Court’) in Civil Suit No.447/2016 (New Case No.206252/2016),
whereby the suit filed by the appellant was dismissed.
9.
Brief facts necessary for deciding the present appeal are as under:
9.1
The appellant/UOI recruited the respondent as a Trainee Pilot on 26th
June, 1997 vide appointment letter dated 19th March, 1997. As per the terms
of the appointment, the respondent executed a Service Bond dated 7 th June,
1997 (hereinafter ‘Service Bond’), undertaking to serve the appellant/UOI
for a minimum period of 10 years, failing which he would be liable to pay
Rs.7,50,000/- incurred by the appellant/UOI towards training the
respondent.
9.2
The respondent was promoted on 28th May, 2001. The respondent
prematurely resigned from the services of the appellant/UOI via letters dated
18th May, 2005 and 14th February, 2006.
9.3
The appellant/UOI sent letters dated 11th November, 2005 and 21st
February, 2006, reminding him of his continuing financial liability in terms
of the Service Bond executed by him. Since the respondent failed to honour
his commitment in terms of the Service Bond, the present suit was filed,
Digitally Signed
By:AANCHAL TAGGAR
14:50:22
RFA 556/2017
which came to be dismissed by the impugned order dated 31st August, 2016.
10.
During the pendency of the present appeal, the respondent expired on
11th May, 2022 and his legal representatives have been impleaded by an
order passed today.
11.
Ms. Radhika Biswajit Dubey, CGSC appearing on behalf of the
appellant/UOI submits that the Trial Court has failed to construe the terms
of the Service Bond executed by the respondent as also the correspondence
exchanged between the parties.
12.
Ms. Dubey further submits that the findings of the Trial Court that the
aircrafts flown by the respondent were not airworthy, is not supported by
any evidence. The Service Bond executed by the respondent was an
unequivocal contractual promise to serve the stipulated period or refund the
amount spent for training. The Department had duly produced in evidence
the details of the training expenditure and therefore, was entitled to recover
the amount of Rs.7,50,000/-.
13.
Per contra, counsel appearing on behalf of the respondents submits
that there is no infirmity in the impugned order passed by the Trial Court.
14.
I have heard the counsel for the parties and examined the record of the
case.
15.
On the 13th February, 2013, the following issues were framed in the
suit:
Digitally Signed
By:AANCHAL TAGGAR
14:50:22
RFA 556/2017
16.
Issue Nos. 1, 2 and 3 were decided in favour of the appellant/plaintiff
and Issue Nos. 4 and 5 were decided in favour of the respondent/defendant.
17.
The relevant findings of the Trial Court in respect of Issue No.4 are
set out below:
“33. Part II of the Section 56 of the Contract Act lays down that in
case performance of an act, which is agreed to be performed under
the agreement, becomes impossible or unlawful subsequent to
entering into an agreement, the agreement itself becomes void. As has
already been discussed above in details, the pleadings of the
defendant as well as the examination in chief of DW-1 is replete with
assertions that he never had the requisite licence to fly Lear Jet or
Gulf III Stream aircraft and yet he was forced to fly them. In addition,
he also pleaded and deposed that the aircrafts which he was forced to
fly were not even airworthy, jeopardizing the lives of all there on
Digitally Signed
By:AANCHAL TAGGAR
14:50:22
RFA 556/2017
board. In replication, the plaintiff simply denied all assertions made in
the Written Statement without submitting any explanation at all.
Replication contains plain and blank denials. The conduct of the
plaintiff while dealing with application of the defendant seeking leave
to defend and its own application under Order XII Rule 6 of the Code
of Civil Procedure, 1908 has already been highlighted. Further, the
cross examination of defendant is extremely illustrative where the
plaintiff did not even bother to give a suggestion of falsehood to the
defendant regarding his assertions. Whatever brief cross
examination was done was only restricted to the assertion of the
defendant that he was singled out for discriminatory treatment in so
far as payment of proportionate bond money is concerned.
34. It is thus, reasonable to conclude that the act for which the
defendant was recruited i.e. flying became unlawful and impossible
to perform in as much as he was forced to fly an aircraft for which
he had no licence. In addition, the aircraft itself were not airworthy
but were being flown against rules. The corollary is that the
agreement i.e. Service Bond became void for the reason that the
performance of service itself became unlawful and impossible to
perform.”
[Emphasis supplied]
18.
The aforesaid finding was based on the evidence led on behalf of the
defendant/respondent as set out in paragraph 27 of the impugned judgment,
which is reproduced below:
“27. The para-17 of the evidence by way of affidavit of DW-1 is reproduced as
under:
“17. I say that the malpractices carried out in the plaintiff
(department) violating flight safety the excerpts of the same are given
herein under for easy reference.
(a) A reference may be drawn from Flight Commander, G-III, Capt.
VK Singh letter written to Commander Air Wing, Palam, New Delhi.
It is attached as Annex-III and is titled as “Continuance of Operations
on G-III aircraft VTENR -A serious compromise on Flight safety.
Excerpts of the same are given under the easy reference.
(b) M/s GAC is of the opinion that CB-125 is a Fuselage Station 580
Digitally Signed
By:AANCHAL TAGGAR
14:50:22
RFA 556/2017
COMSCAN inspection which is an “AMM Chapter 5” inspection and
is required. The adverse effects of continued flight oper
ations without complying with this Chapter 5 inspection are severe.
Major structural failure can occur with continued flight operations.
(c) Criticality of FS580 being subject to corrosion has been
reaffirmed by M/s GAC as well.
(d) “This inspection has been recommended so as to detect signs of
material loss/corrosion at the intermating surface of Web and Rear
beam of port/starboard wing at FS-425 without having to remove all
the parts. The criticality of this too deals with airframe areas/parts
that have direct bearing on the structural integrity of the aircraft.”
(e) “Concessions against execution of CMP Codes 321250 and
321255 is a direct compromise on the aircraft structure (Main
Landing Gear)/airframe. Thus, this too is a compromise on flight
operations and is unacceptable. In addition, in the absence of
manufacturer approved/authorized technical know how, the basis of
granting extension to the functioning of a very major load bearing
member, is bereft of logic and difficult for the aircrew to comprehend.
(f) It can be seen that VIENR was on concession for one
airframe/aircraft structure related maintenance activity in Mar 2003.
Two more concessions on airframe/structure were given on 31 Oct
2003. The fourth relating to the undercarriage system was given on 8th
Apr 2005. Thus, compromising on the structural integrity of the
aircrafts is on the increase. This is not healthy and is against all
norms of flight safety. Considering the overall picture of the aircraft
structure/airframe related concessions/extensions with which G-III
aircraft VTENR is on flight line, structural integrity compromise are
far too many for the comfort of any aircrew. While the aircrew fully
train themselves to handle abnormal situations arising in the air due
to failure of dubious structural integrity is an extremely challenging
task. No one trains for this situation.””
19.
The Trial Court has also noted that the appellant/plaintiff did not
cross-examine the defendant/respondent in respect of the said evidence.
Accordingly, the Trial Court correctly came to the conclusion that the
evidence led by the respondent/defendant remained unrebutted. The Trial
Digitally Signed
By:AANCHAL TAGGAR
14:50:22
RFA 556/2017
court has also correctly held that the Service Bond became void under
Section 56 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, since the performance of the
service itself became impossible to perform.
20.
In my view, there is no infirmity in the impugned judgment passed by
the Trial Court. The Trial court has correctly appreciated the evidence led on
behalf of the parties to come to the conclusion that the appellant/plaintiff
was not entitled to recover the amount under the Service Bond from the
respondent/defendant.
21.
Accordingly, there is no merit in the appeal and the same is dismissed.
22.
All the pending applications stand disposed of.
AMIT BANSAL, J
JANUARY 16, 2026
Vivek/-
Digitally Signed
By:AANCHAL TAGGAR
14:50:22
RFA 556/2017
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review