Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
+
Date of Decision : 09.01.2026
W.P.(C) 254/2026, CM APPL. 1178/2026(Stay) & CM APPL.
1179/2026(Exemption)
UNION OF INDIA THROUGH SECRETARY
MINISTRY OF DEFENCE & ORS.
.....Petitioners
Through: Mr Arnav Kumar, CGSC and Mr
Keshav Mittal, Advocate.
versus
GP CAPT DILISH MALIK RETD19371
Through: None.
.....Respondent
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V. KAMESWAR RAO
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA
V. KAMESWAR RAO, J. (ORAL)
1.
This petition has been filed by the petitioners challenging the Order
dated 17.08.2023 (‘Impugned Order’) passed by the Armed Forces Tribunal,
Principal Bench, New Delhi (‘Tribunal’) in Original Application No. 2339
of 2019 (‘OA’, for short). The Tribunal has held that the respondent is
entitled to disability element of pension due to Primary Hypertension at 30%
for life and Diabetes Mellitus at 20% for life, compositely at 44% for life,
rounded off to 50% with effect from the date of discharge .
2.
The petitioners are seeking the following prayers in the present
petition:“a. Issue a Writ or direction in the nature of Certiorari,
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
10:05:09
W.P.(C) 254/2026
setting aside the Order dated 17.08.2023 passed by the Ld.
Armed Forces Tribunal, Principal Bench, New Delhi in
Original Application No. 2339 of 2019 titled “Gp Capt
Dilish Malik (Retd)Versus Union of India and Others”; and
/ or”
3.
The facts as noted from the impugned order are that the respondent
underwent primary medical examination and was declared ‘fit’ in medical
category ‘A4G1’ before commissioning in Indian Air Force vide AFMSF2A dated 16.06.1987, on 29.01.1988. On 28.03.2018, the Release Medical
Board (‘RMB’, for short) of the respondent was held wherein, it was held
that the respondent is suffering from; (a) Primary Hypertension (Old) I-10.0,
Z-09.0 assessed at 30% and (b) Asymptomatic Transaminitis (Old) R94.5,
Z-09 at 1-5% and (c) Diabetes Mellitus (Old) Type-II E11.0, Z-09.0
assessed at 20% (composite for all the disabilities assessed @ 50% for life).
The RMB gave an opinion that the disability/disabilities are neither
attributable nor aggravated by the Air Force service. On 31.08.2018, the
respondent was released from the service on attaining the age of
superannuation with permanent low medical category [A4G2 (P)].
4.
Thereafter, on 19.11.2018, the claim of the respondent for disability
pension was also rejected by the Air Force vide letter No. Air
HQ/99797/4050/Dis/O/DAV-1 (B), with an option to appeal before the
Appellate Committee. The respondent filed the First Appeal for grant of
disability pension on 12.10.2019. The same was rejected vide letter No. Air
HQ/ 99797/4050/Dis/O/DAV-1(B) dated 21.11.2019 in terms of Regulation
37 of Pension Regulations for the Air Force 1961 (Part-1). The respondent
filed the OA before the Tribunal, challenging the decision.
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
10:05:09
W.P.(C) 254/2026
5.
The Tribunal, in view of the judgment of the Supreme Court in the
case of UoI & Ors. v. Ram Avatar, Civil Appeal No. 418/2012, decided on
10.12.2014, has held as under:“19. Thus, the OA 2339/2019 is allowed and the applicant is
held entitled to the grant of the disability element of pension
qua the disability Primary Hypertension @ 30% for life and
Diabetes Mellitus @ 20% for life, assessed by the RMB dated
28.03.2018 compositely@ 44% for life, which in terms of the
verdict of the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in Civil Appeal
418/2012 dated 10.12.2014 titled as UOI & Ors. Vs. Ramavtar,
is rounded off to 50% for life from the date of discharge of the
applicant.
20. The respondents are directed to calculate, sanction and
issue the necessary Corrigendum PPO to the applicant within
three months from the date of receipt of the copy of this order
and in the event of default, the applicant shall be entitled to the
interest @6% per annum till the date of payment."
6.
Mr. Arnav Kumar, the learned CGSC appearing for the petitioners
submits that the impugned order is per incuriam as the provisions contained
in the Entitlement Rules, 2008 were not reconciled by the Tribunal, wherein
the general presumption to be drawn in order to ascertain the principle of
attributable to or aggravated by military service has been done away with.
He also contends that the Tribunal has overlooked the opinion of the RMB,
wherein, it is held that the respondent’s disability is neither attributable to
nor aggravated by military service.
7.
According to him, the Tribunal has failed to appreciate that there
cannot be universal or perpetual yardstick for adopting presumption or
deemed attributability in all cases where disease was not detected at the time
of entry into service but has arisen during service which is diagnosed by
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
10:05:09
W.P.(C) 254/2026
medical authority at the time of release or retirement as held by the
Supreme Court in the cases of UOI & Ors v. Ex Sep R Munusamy 2022
SCC OnLine SC 892 and Ex CFN Narsingh Yadav v. Union of India,
(2019) 9 SCC 667.
8.
Mr. Kumar submits that the basic criterion to award disability pension
in terms of Rule 6 of the Entitlement Rules, 2008, is that there should be a
causal connection between the disability/death and the military service. In
the case of the respondent, the RMB and Competent Medical Authorities
and Administrative Authorities, have held that the disabilities of the
respondent are neither attributable to nor aggravated by the military service.
9.
He submits that the Rule 10 of Entitlement Rules, 2008, carves out
two conditions which are to be simultaneously satisfied for a disability to be
attributable to military service; (a) that the disease has arisen during the
period of military service; (b) that the disease has been caused by the
conditions of employment in the military service. He also submits that, Rule
11 of Entitlement Rules, 2008, provides that a disability will be conceded to
have been aggravated by military service if the onset of the disability is
hastened or the subsequent course is worsened by specific conditions of
military service.
10.
According to him, a disability shall be conceded to be aggravated by
service if its onset is hastened or subsequent course is worsened by specific
condition of the military service, such as, posted in extreme climatic
condition, environmental factors, etc. The disability of the respondent
cannot be held to be aggravated by military service. He by relying on the
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
10:05:09
W.P.(C) 254/2026
judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Secretary, Ministry of
Defence and Others v. A.V. Damodaran (Dead) through LRs and Others,
(2009) 9 SCC 140., contends that the Release/ Invalidating Board draws a
conclusion as to whether the disability has a causal connection with military
service or not and on the basis of the same, the Release / Invalidating Board
recommends whether the disability is attributable to or aggravated by
military service.
11.
He submits that the reliance placed by the Tribunal in Dharamvir
Singh v. Union of India & Ors., 2013 (7) SCC 316, is misplaced inasmuch
as the rule position under entitlement rules 1982 have been superseded by
Entitlement Rules, 2008. Therefore, post 2008, cases are governed by
Entitlement Rules 2008 and not Entitlement Rules, 1982. He also submits
that the Tribunal has erred in not appreciating the settled principle of law
that the opinion of the RMB should not be disputed unless there is strong
medical evidence to the contrary.
12.
He submits that the Supreme Court in the case of Union of India and
Another v. Talwinder Singh, reported as (2012) 5 SCC 480., has held that
the court should not interfere with the order based on opinion of experts on
the subject. It would be safe for the courts to leave the decision to experts
who are more familiar with the problems they face than the courts generally
can be. He submits that the Tribunal has gone beyond the provision to
interpret the policy which was never in challenge and has transgressed into
the realm of policy making, and relies on the judgment of the Supreme
Court in Dhanraj v. Vikram Singh, 2023 SCC OnLine SC 724.
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
10:05:09
W.P.(C) 254/2026
13.
He submits that the Rule 15 of Guide to Medial Office (Military
Pension), 2008 also provides for reassessment with regard to percentage of
disability and provides as opportunity to individual to request for review. He
also submits that, as per Pension Regulations for the Indian Air Force, 1961
(Part-I), the disability pension can be granted only when the individual who
is invalided out/ discharged/ retired from service while fulfilling the
following conditions:
a. disability must be attributable to or aggravated by service, and;
b. degree of disablement should be assessed at 20% or more.
14.
He submits that the Tribunal has not considered the fact that, not only
medical board but also Administrative Authority i.e. Appellate Committee
on First Appeal (‘ACFA’, for short) also examined the case and has given
detailed reasons as to why disability element cannot be granted to the
respondent. The ACFA, by giving detailed reasons in addition to the reasons
given by medical authorities, has discharged its obligation. He also submits
that, the petitioners have approached the Court in view of the law laid down
by the Supreme Court in judgment dated 21.03.2023 in titled as Union of
India & Ors. v. Parashotam Dass, Civil Appeal No.447/2023.
15.
Having heard the learned counsel for the petitioners and perused the
record, at the outset, we may state here that the three authorities had
assessed the disability of Primary Hypertension and Diabetes Mellitus at
30% and 20%, respectively. The RMB gave an opinion that the disabilities
are neither attributable to nor aggravated by the Air Force service.
16.
We may reproduce the RMB opinion in the following manner:-
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
10:05:09
W.P.(C) 254/2026
17.
The Appellate Committee has also rejected the letter of the respondent
herein by stating as under:-
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
10:05:09
W.P.(C) 254/2026
18.
Suffice to state, even the representation made by the respondent to the
Appellate Authority was rejected. Similarly, even the review thereafter was
rejected.
19.
It may be stated here that the disability of Asymptomatic
Transaminitis (old) was not pressed before the Tribunal. So, the disabilities
has to be seen in the context of Primary Hypertension and Diabetes
Mellitus-II. Suffice to state that, in Union of India & Others v. 1481129 P
Ex Hav Ram Kumar, 2026, DHC, 197-DB, this Court has held under:“9. In W.P.(C) 88/2026 titled Union of India v. 781466 Ex.
SGT Krishna Kumar Dwivedi, decided by this Bench on
06.01.2026, our attention was drawn to the authoritative
judgments of the coordinate Benches of this Court passed in
W.P.(C) 3545/2025 titled Union of India v. Ex. Sub Gawas Anil
Madso, 2025: DHC: 2021-DB and W.P.(C) 140/2024 titled
Union of India vs. Col. Balbir Singh (Retd.) and other
connected matters, 2025: DHC: 5082-DB, which have
conclusively held that even under 2008 Entitlement Rules, an
officer who suffers from a disease at the time of his release and
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
10:05:09
W.P.(C) 254/2026
applies for disability pension within 15 years from release of
service, is ordinarily entitled to disability pension and he does
not have any onus to prove the said entitlement. The 2008
Entitlement Rules, however, contemplate that in the event the
Medical Board concludes that the disease though contracted
during the tenure of military service, was not attributable to or
aggravated by military service, it would have to give cogent
reasons and identify the cause, other than military service, to
which the ailment or disability can be attributed. The
judgments hold that a bald statement in the report would not be
sufficient, for the military department for denying the claim of
disability pension. The burden to prove the disentitlement
therefore remains on the military department even under 2008
Entitlement Rules and the aforesaid judgments emphasize on
the significance of the Medical Board giving specific reasons
for denial of this beneficial provision. The judgments hold that
the onus to prove a casual connection between the disability
and military service is not on the officer but on the
administration.
10. We for benefit also note that the Supreme Court in its
recent opinion in the case of Bijender Singh vs. Union of India
and Others, 2025 SCC OnLine SC 895, wherein at paragraphs
45.1, 46 and 47, the Supreme Court held as under:
“45.1. Thus, this Court held that essence of the Rules is that a
member of the armed forces is presumed to be in sound
physical and mental condition at the time of his entry into the
service if there is no note or record to the contrary made at
the time of such entry. In the event of subsequent discharge
from service on medical ground, any deterioration in health
would be presumed to be due to military service. The burden
would be on the employer to rebut the presumption that the
disability suffered by the member was neither attributable to
nor aggravated by military service. If the Medical Board is of
the opinion that the disease suffered by the member could not
have been detected at the time of entry into service, the
Medical Board has to give reasons for saying so. This Court
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
10:05:09
W.P.(C) 254/2026
highlighted that the provision for payment of disability
pension is a beneficial one which ought to be interpreted
liberally. A soldier cannot be asked to prove that the disease
was contracted by him on account of military service or was
aggravated by the same. The very fact that upon proper
physical and other tests, the member was found fit to serve in
the army would give rise to a presumption that he was disease
free at the time of his entry into service. For the employer to
say that such a disease was neither attributable to nor
aggravated by military service, the least that is required to be
done is to furnish reasons for taking such a view.
46. Referring back to the impugned order dated 26.02.2016,
we find that the Tribunal simply went by the remarks of the
Invaliding Medical Board and Re-Survey Medical Boards to
hold that since the disability of the appellant was less than
20%, he would not be entitled to the disability element of the
disability pension. Tribunal did not examine the issue as to
whether the disability was attributable to or aggravated by
military service. In the instant case neither has it been
mentioned by the Invaliding Medical Board nor by the ReSurvey Medical Boards that the disease for which the
appellant was invalided out of service could not be detected at
the time of entry into military service. As a matter of fact, the
Invaliding Medical Board was quite categorical that no
disability of the appellant existed before entering service. As
would be evident from the aforesaid decisions of this Court,
the law has by now crystalized that if there is no note or
report of the Medical Board at the time of entry into service
that the member suffered from any particular disease, the
presumption would be that the member got afflicted by the
said disease because of military service. Therefore the burden
of proving that the disease is not attributable to or aggravated
by military service rest entirely on the employer. Further, any
disease or disability for which a member of the armed forces
is invalided out of service would have to be assumed to be
above 20% and attract grant of 50% disability pension.
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
10:05:09
W.P.(C) 254/2026
47. Thus having regard to the discussions made above, we are
of the considered view that the impugned orders of the
Tribunal are wholly unsustainable in law. That being the
position, impugned orders dated 22.01.2018 and 26.02.2016
are hereby set aside. Consequently, respondents are directed
to grant the disability element of disability pension to the
appellant at the rate of 50% with effect from 01.01.1996
onwards for life. The arrears shall carry interest at the rate of
6% per annum till payment. The above directions shall be
carried out by the respondents within three months from
today.”
xxx
xxx
xxx
13. At this juncture it would be apposite to refer to the
judgment of the coordinate Bench of this Court in Union of
India v. Col. Balbir Singh (Retd.) (supra), wherein the Court
emphasized on the significance of the Release Medical Board
recording clear and cogent reasons for denying the entitlement
of disability pension to the officer. The relevant paragraphs of
the said judgment are as under: “50. In this regard, it is further relevant to note the observations
of the Supreme Court in the Rajumon T.M. v. Union of India
&Ors., 2025 SCC OnLine SC 1064, the relevant portions of which
reads as under:
……
……
25. We, therefore, hold that if any action is taken by the authority for the
discharge of a serviceman and the serviceman is denied disability
pension on the basis of a report of the Medical Board wherein no
reasons have been disclosed for the opinion so given, such an action of
the authority will be unsustainable in law.”
51. In view of the above, it is essential for the Medical Boards to
record and specify the reasons for their opinion as to whether the
disability is to be treated as attributable to or aggravated by
military service, especially when the pensionary benefits of the
Force personnel are at stake.
……….
53. Particularly in this milieu, it is of paramount importance that
Medical Boards record clear and cogent reasons in support of their
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
10:05:09
W.P.(C) 254/2026
medical opinions. Such reasoning would not only enhance
transparency but also assist the Competent Authority in adjudicating
these matters with greater precision, ensuring that no prejudice is
caused to either party.
………
56. It must always be kept in view that the Armed Forces personnel,
in defending this great nation from external threats, have to perform
their duties in most harsh and inhuman weather and conditions, be it
on far-flung corner of land, in terrains and atmosphere where limits
of mans survival are tested, or in air or water, where again
surviving each day is a challenge, away from the luxury of family
life and comforts. It is, therefore, incumbent upon the RMB to
furnish cogent and well-reasoned justification for their conclusions
that the disease/disability suffered by the personnel cannot be said
to be attributable to or aggravated by such service conditions. This
onus is not discharged by the RMB by simply relying on when such
disability/disease is noticed first.
………
77. Thus, in view of the above, the RMB must not resort to a vague
and stereotyped approach but should engage in a comprehensive,
logical, and rational analysis of the service and medical records of
the personnel, and must record well-reasoned findings while
discharging the onus placed upon it.”
(Emphasis Supplied)
20.
Having noted the position of law, we examine the facts of this case,
the respondent was appointed in the Air Force on 29.01.1988. He retired
from service on 31.08.2018 after rendering 30 years 07 months and 03 days
of service. The RMB proceedings as noted by the Tribunal for both the
disabilities of Primary Hypertension and Diabetes Mellitus primarily states
that these are lifestyle related metabolic disorder. The onset was in the years
2002 and 2015 respectively.
21.
Therefore, the opinion of the RMB is that the disabilities are neither
attributable nor aggravated by the Air Force service. The RMB does not give
any reasons except stating that it is a lifestyle disorder. It was required to
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
10:05:09
W.P.(C) 254/2026
give the reasons as to how the disability is not relatable to Air Force service
or for that matter, it is relatable to lifestyle disorder.
22.
It must be noted that lifestyle varies from individual to individual.
Therefore, a mere statement that the disease of lifestyle disorder would not
be a sufficient reason to deny the grant of disability pension unless Medical
Board has duly examined and recorded particulars relevant to the individual
concerned.
23.
Hence, in view of the settled position of law, it is clearly applicable to
the facts of the case, we are of the view that in the absence of reasons by the
RMB, the conclusion drawn by the Tribunal cannot be interfered with. The
petition being devoid of merits is dismissed along with pending applications.
V. KAMESWAR RAO, J
MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA, J
JANUARY 09, 2026/sr
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
10:05:09
W.P.(C) 254/2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review