Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
+
Date of Decision : 05.01.2026
W.P.(C) 40/2026
UNION OF INDIA THROUGH SECRETARY
MINISTRY OF DEFENCE & ORS.
.....Petitioners
Through: Mr. Nirvikar Verma, SPC and Mr.
Mritunjay Jha.
versus
AIR CMDE ASHOK KUMAR UPADHYAYA RETD 17757 T
.....Respondent
Through: Mr. Praveen Kumar, Adv.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V. KAMESWAR RAO
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA
V. KAMESWAR RAO, J. (ORAL)
CM APPL. 88/2026 (Exemption)
1.
Exemption is allowed, subject to all just exceptions.
2.
The application stands disposed of.
W.P.(C) 40/2026, CM APPL. 87/2026
3.
This writ petition lays a challenge to an order dated 21.03.2023
passed by the learned Armed Forces Tribunal, Principal Bench, New Delhi
(Tribunal) in Original Application (OA) No.859/2020 whereby the Tribunal
has allowed the OA filed by the respondent herein by giving the following
directions:“5. In view of the aforesaid judicial pronouncements
and the parameters referred to above, the applicant is
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
14:52:34
W.P.(C) 40/2026
entitled for disability element of pension in respect of
disability 'Hypertension'. Accordingly, we allow this
application holding that the applicant is entitled to
disability element of pension @30% rounded off to
50% with effect from the date of his discharge in terms
of the judicial pronouncement of the Hon'ble Supreme
Court in the case of Union of India Vs. Ram Avtar
(Civil Appeal No. 418/2012), decided on 10.12.2014.
6. The respondents are thus directed to calculate,
sanction and issue the necessary PPO to the applicant
within a period of three months from the date of receipt
of copy of this order and the amount of arrears shall be
paid by the respondents, failing which the applicant
will be entitled for interest @6% p.a. from the date of
receipt of copy of the order by the respondents.”
4.
The facts as noted from the record are the respondent was
commissioned in the Air Force on 21.12.1984.
He was released from
service on attaining the age of superannuation on 31.01.2019 with
permanent low medical category A4G-2P. The Release Medical Board
(RMB) of the respondent was held at Air Force Station, New Delhi on
08.08.2018.
He was found to be in low medical category having the
disability of Primary Hypertension. It is noted that the RMB opined that the
disability of the respondent is neither attributable nor aggravated by military
service.
5.
The only submission made by the learned counsel for the petitioners
is that the finding of the Tribunal that the disability was attributable to the
military service is clearly erroneous inasmuch as it is not necessarily that
hypertension is caused due to military service only. In other words, the same
can be caused due to reasons other than military service. It is also his
submission that the Tribunal has overlooked the Entitlement Rules 2008
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
14:52:34
W.P.(C) 40/2026
which govern the attributability/aggravation and no longer permit a blanket
presumption in favour of the claimant. He states that the Tribunal has erred
in allowing the respondent’s claim for disability pension despite the opinion
of the RMB.
6.
On the other hand, the learned counsel for the respondent has drawn
our attention to a judgment of the co-ordinate Bench of this Court in the case
of Union of India and Ors. v. HFO Satyvir Singh (Retd.),
2025:DHC:6640-DB wherein in paragraph 4 onwards, the Court on
identical issue has held as under:“4. The respondent was released in Low Medical
Category on his being found to be suffering from
Primary Hypertension. From the record, including the
proceedings of the Release Medical Board, the
following facts emerged:
12.The respondent had served in the Indian Air
Force for over 38 years 8 months before he
was diagnosed as suffering from Primary
Hypertension.
(ii) The respondent, in his self-declaration,
specifically declared that he had not been
suffering from Primary Hypertension prior to
joining the Indian Air Force. The declaration
reads thus:
3. Did you suffer from any disability before
joining the Armed Forces? If so give details and
dates: NO
The correctness of this declaration is not doubted
either by the RMB or by the petitioner before the
AFT or before this Court.
(iii) The reason regarding the Primary
Hypertension suffered by the respondent has not
been attributable to military service, as entered by
the RMB reads thus:
“Primary Hypertension (Old): Onset in peace and
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
14:52:34
W.P.(C) 40/2026
served in peace only prior to (up to one year and
after onset).
(iv) We have already held, in our judgment in
Gawas Anil Madso, that where the applicant was
not suffering from the ailment at the time of entry
into service, the RMB is required to positively
identify the cause for the ailment, to justify a
finding that it is not attributable to military
service. The Commanding Officer’s certificate
specifically states that the respondent was not
responsible, owing to any act or omission of his,
for the ailment from which he was suffering. The
entry in that regard reads as under:
5(a). Was the disability attributable to
individuals own negligence or
misconduct (If Yes, in what way?) No
(v) Regarding para 43 of the Chapter VI of the
GMO 2008, we have, in our judgment in UOI v
WO Binod Kumar Sah (Retd ), 2025 SCC OnLine
Del 2355 observed thus:
“12. Para 43 of the Chapter VI of the GMO
2008, vivisected into its individual
components, specifies that, while dealing
with hypertension,
12.the RMB is required to determine whether
the hypertension is primary or secondary,
(ii) if the hypertension is secondary,
entitlement consideration should be directed
to the underlying disease process,
(iii) where disablement for essential
hypertension appears to have arisen to, or
become worse in, service, it has to be
considered whether service compulsion
caused aggravation,
(iv) in cases where the disease has been
reported after long and frequent spells of
service in Field/HAA/Active Operational
Areas, the case could be explained by
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
14:52:34
W.P.(C) 40/2026
variable response exhibited by different
individuals to stressful situations and
(v) primary hypertension would be
considered aggravated if it occurred while
the officer was serving in field areas, HAA,
CIOPS
areas or prolonged afloat service.”
(vi) The RMB has certified the respondent as
suffering from 30% disability on account of
Primary Hypertension, lifelong.
5. In such circumstances, we have held in our decision
in Ex Sub Gawas Anil Madso that the respondent
would be entitled to disability pension.
6. We do not deem it necessary to reproduce our
findings in the said decision, so as not to burden this
judgment.
7. We have also been conscious of the fact that we are
exercising certiorari jurisdiction over the decision of
the AFT and are not sitting in appeal over the said
decision.
8. The parameters of certiorari jurisdiction are
delineated in the following passages of Syed Yakoob v
K.S. Radhakrishnan, AIR 1964 SC 477 :
“7. The question about the limits of the
jurisdiction of High Courts in issuing a writ of
certiorari under Article 226 has been frequently
considered by this Court and the true legal
position in that behalf is no longer in doubt. A
writ of certiorari can be issued for correcting
errors of jurisdiction committed by inferior courts
or tribunals: these are cases where orders are
passed by inferior courts or tribunals without
jurisdiction, or is in excess of it, or as a result of
failure to exercise jurisdiction. A writ can
similarly be issued where in exercise of
jurisdiction conferred on it, the Court or Tribunal
acts illegally or properly, as for instance, it
decides a question without giving an opportunity,
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
14:52:34
W.P.(C) 40/2026
be heard to the party affected by the order, or
where the procedure adopted in dealing with the
dispute is opposed to principles of natural justice.
There is, however, no doubt that the jurisdiction
to issue a writ of certiorari is a supervisory
jurisdiction and the Court exercising it is not
entitled to act as an appellate Court. This
limitation necessarily means that findings of fact
reached by the inferior Court or Tribunal as
result of the appreciation of evidence cannot be
reopened or questioned in writ proceedings. An
error of law which is apparent on the face of the
record can be corrected by a writ, but not an
error of fact, however grave it may appear to be.
In regard to a finding of fact recorded by the
Tribunal, a writ of certiorari can be issued if it is
shown that in recording the said finding, the
Tribunal had erroneously refused to admit
admissible and material evidence, or had
erroneously admitted inadmissible evidence which
has influenced the impugned finding. Similarly, if
a finding of fact is based on no evidence, that
would be regarded as an error of law which can
be corrected by a writ of certiorari. In dealing
with this category of cases, however, we must
always bear in mind that a finding of fact
recorded by the Tribunal cannot be challenged in
proceedings for a writ of certiorari on the ground
that the relevant and material evidence adduced
before the Tribunal was insufficient or inadequate
to sustain the impugned finding. The adequacy or
sufficiency of evidence led on a point and the
inference of fact to be drawn from the said finding
are within the exclusive jurisdiction of the
Tribunal, and the said points cannot be agitated
before a writ Court. It is within these limits that
the jurisdiction conferred on the High Courts
under Article 226 to issue a writ of certiorari can
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
14:52:34
W.P.(C) 40/2026
be legitimately exercised (vide Hari Vishnu
Kamath v Syed Ahmad Ishaque, (1954) 2 SCC 881
Nagandra Nath Bora v Commissioner of Hills
Division and Appeals Assam, IR 1958 SC 398 and
Kaushalya Devi v Bachittar Singh, AIR 1960 SC
1168.
8. It is, of course, not easy to define or adequately
describe what an error of law apparent on the
face of the record means. What can be corrected
by a writ has to be an error of law; hut it must be
such an error of law as can be regarded as one
which is apparent on the face of the record.
Where it is manifest or clear that the conclusion
of law recorded by an inferior Court or Tribunal
is based on an obvious mis-interpretation of the
relevant statutory provision, or sometimes in
ignorance of it, or may be, even in disregard of it,
or is expressly founded on reasons which are
wrong in law, the said conclusion can be
corrected by a writ of certiorari. In all these
cases, the impugned conclusion should be so
plainly inconsistent with the relevant statutory
provision that no difficulty is experienced by the
High Court in holding that the said error of law is
apparent on the face of the record. It may also be
that in some cases, the impugned error of law may
not be obvious or patent on the face of the record
as such and the Court may need an argument to
discover the said error; but there can be no doubt
that what can be corrected by a writ of certiorari
is an error of law and the said error must, on the
whole, be of such a character as would satisfy the
test that it is an error of law apparent on the face
of the record. If a statutory provision is
reasonably capable of two constructions and one
construction has been adopted by the inferior
Court or Tribunal, its conclusion may not
necessarily or always be open to correction by a
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
14:52:34
W.P.(C) 40/2026
writ of certiorari. In our opinion, it is neither
possible nor desirable to attempt either to define
or to describe adequately all cases of errors
which can be appropriately described as errors of
law apparent on the face of the record. Whether
or not an impugned error is an error of law and
an error of law which is apparent on the face of
the record, must always depend upon the facts
and circumstances of each case and upon the
nature and scope of the legal provision which is
alleged to have been misconstrued or
contravened.”
(Emphasis supplied)
9. Within the limited parameters of the certiorari
jurisdiction and keeping in view the facts of the case
outlined hereinabove, we find no cause to interfere
with the impugned judgment of the AFT, which is
affirmed in its entirety.
10. In addition, we find that our view stands fortified
by paras 45.1, 46 and 47 of the judgment of the
Supreme Court, rendered on 23 April 2025 in Bijender
Singh v UOI, 2025 SCC OnLine SC 895 which may be
reproduced thus:
“45.1. Thus, this Court held that essence of the
Rules is that a member of the armed forces is
presumed to be in sound physical and mental
condition at the time of his entry into the service
if there is no note or record to the contrary made
at the time of such entry. In the event of
subsequent discharge from service on medical
ground, any deterioration in health would be
presumed to be due to military service. The
burden would be on the employer to rebut the
presumption that the disability suffered by the
member was neither attributable to nor
aggravated by military service. If the Medical
Board is of the opinion that the disease suffered
by the member could not have been detected at
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
14:52:34
W.P.(C) 40/2026
the time of entry into service, the Medical Board
has to give reasons for saying so. This Court
highlighted that the provision for payment of
disability pension is a beneficial one which
ought to be interpreted liberally. A soldier
cannot be asked to prove that the disease was
contracted by him on account of military service
or was aggravated by the same. The very fact
that upon proper physical and other tests, the
member was found fit to serve in the army would
give rise to a presumption that he was disease
free at the time of his entry into service. For the
employer to say that such a disease was neither
attributable to nor aggravated by military
service, the least that is required to be done is to
furnish reasons for taking such a view.
46. Referring back to the impugned order dated
26.02.2016, we find that the Tribunal simply
went by the remarks of the Invaliding Medical
Board and Re-Survey Medical Boards to hold
that since the disability of the appellant was less
than 20%, he would not be entitled to the
disability element of the disability pension.
Tribunal did not examine the issue as to whether
the disability was attributable to or aggravated by
military service. In the instant case neither has it
been mentioned by the Invaliding Medical Board
nor by the Re-Survey Medical Boards that the
disease for which the appellant was invalided out
of service could not be detected at the time of
entry into military service. As a matter of fact,
the Invaliding Medical Board was quite
categorical that no disability of the appellant
existed before entering service. As would be
evident from the aforesaid decisions of this
Court, the law has by now Crystallized that if
there is no note or report of the Medical Board
at the time of entry into service that the member
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
14:52:34
W.P.(C) 40/2026
suffered from any particular disease, the
presumption would be that the member got
afflicted by the said disease because of military
service. Therefore the burden of proving that the
disease is not attributable to or aggravated by
military service rest entirely on the employer.
Further, any disease or disability for which a
member of the armed forces is invalided out of
service would have to be assumed to be above
20% and attract grant of 50% disability pension.
47. Thus having regard to the discussions made
above, we are of the considered view that the
impugned orders of the Tribunal are wholly
unsustainable in law. That being the position,
impugned orders dated 22.01.2018 and
26.02.2016 are hereby set aside. Consequently,
respondents are directed to grant the disability
element of disability pension to the appellant at
the rate of 50% with effect from 01.01.1996
onwards for life. The arrears shall carry interest
at the rate of 6% per annum till payment. The
above directions shall be carried out by the
respondents within three months from today.”
11. The present petition is, accordingly, dismissed.
12. Compliance with the impugned judgement of the
AFT, if not already ensured, be ensured within a
period of four weeks from today.”
(emphasis supplied)
7.
That apart the Tribunal has relied upon the judgment of the Supreme
Court in the case of Dharamvir Singh v. Union of India and Others, 2013
(7) SCC 316 wherein, the Supreme Court in paragraph 28 has stated as
under:“28. A conjoint reading of various provisions,
reproduced above, makes it clear that:
(i) Disability pension to be granted to an individual
who is invalidated service which on account of from a
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
14:52:34
W.P.(C) 40/2026
disability is attributable to or aggravated by military
service in non-battle casualty and is assessed at 20%
or over. The question whether a disability is
attributable оr aggravated by military service to be
determined under "Entitlement Rules for Casualty
Pensionary Awards, 1982" of Appendix-II (Regulation
173).
(ii) A member is to be presumed in sound physical and
mental condition upon entering service if there is no
note or record at the time of entrance. In the event of
his subsequently being discharged from service on
medical grounds any deterioration in his health is to be
presumed due to service. (Rule 5 r/w Rule 14(b)].
(iii) Onus of proof is not on the claimant (employee),
the corollary is that onus of proof that the condition for
non-entitlement is with the employer. A claimant has α
right to derive benefit of any reasonable doubt and is
entitled for pensionary benefit more liberally. (Rule 9).
(iv) If a disease is accepted to have been as having
arisen in service, it must also be established that the
conditions of military service determined or
contributed to the onset of the disease and that the
conditions the circumstances were due of duty military
service. [Rule 14(c)].
(v) If no note of any disability or disease was made at
the time of individual's acceptance for military service,
α disease which has led to an individual’s discharge or
death will be deemed to have arisen in service [14(b)].
(vi) If medical opinion holds that the disease could not
have been detected on medical examination prior to
acceptance for service and that disease will not be
deemed to have arisen during service, the Medical
Board is required to state the reasons. [14(b)]; and
(vii) It is mandatory for the Medical Board to follow
the guidelines laid down in Chapter-II of the "Guide
Medical (Military Pension), 2002 "Entitlement to
General Principles", including paragraph 7,8 and 9
referred to above.”
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
14:52:34
W.P.(C) 40/2026
8.
That apart the Tribunal has also referred to the amendment to Chapter
VI of the ‘Guide to Medical Officers (Military Pension), 2008’ wherein para
43 reads as under:“43. Hypertension consideration should be to
determine whether the hypertension is primary or
secondary. If (e.g. Nephritis), and it is unnecessary to
notify hypertension separately.
As in the case of atherosclerosis, entitlement of
attributability is never appropriate, but where
disablement for essential hypertension appears to have
arisen or become worse in service, the question
whether service compulsions have caused aggravation
must considered. However, in certain cases the disease
has been reported after long and frequent spells of
service in field/HAA/active operational area. Such
cases can be explained by variable response exhibited
by to stressful different individuals situations. Primary
hypertension will be considered aggravated if it occurs
while serving in Field areas, HAA, CIOPS areas or
prolonged afloat service.”
9.
In substance, the Tribunal held that the hypertension could have
resulted because of the rigorous military training and associated stress and
strain of the service.
10.
The above judgment of this Court in HFO Satyvir Singh (Retd.)
(supra) has referred to the recent judgment of the Supreme Court in
Bijender Singh v. UoI, 2025 SCC OnLine SC 895. The conclusions of
which have been reproduced by us. In the said judgment, the Supreme
Court has clearly held that if there is no note or report of the medical board,
at the time of entering into the service that the member suffered from any
particular disease, the presumption would be that the member got infected
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
14:52:34
W.P.(C) 40/2026
the same disease because of the military service. Therefore, the burden of
proving that the disease is not attributable to or aggravated by military
service rest entirely on the employer. It is also held that the employer is
required to furnish the reasons for saying that the disease was neither
attributable nor aggravated by the military service.
11.
In the present case, the RMB says that onset of the Primary
Hypertension was in June 2015, when the respondent was posted in peace
area. Prior to onset, the individual served in peace station. There was no
delay in diagnoses nor close time association with stress/strain or dietary
compulsion of the field CI Ops/HAA, hence NANA in terms of para 43, Chapter VI, GMO 2002amendment 2008.
12.
The above opinion, does not give any reason for the respondent to get
the disability for non-military service reason. In effect, a Coordinate Bench
of this Court in the case of Union of India v. Col. Balbir Singh (Retd.) and
other connected matters, 2025:DHC:5082-DB has in paragraphs 64,65, 71
and 79 held as under:“64. From the above-extracted paragraphs of the
GMO, 2008, it is evident that the GMO recognises
Ischaemic Heart Disease (IHD) as a spectrum
encompassing asymptomatic IHD, chronic stable
angina, unstable angina, acute myocardial infarction,
and sudden cardiac death, all of which arise as a result
of atherosclerosis. Prolonged stress and strain
accelerates
atherosclerosis
by
triggering
neurohormonal mechanisms and autonomic storms.
The medical understanding of IHD, as extracted from
the GMO, 2008, highlights that the challenges of
service in field and high-altitude areas, apart from
involving physical hardship, also encompass
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
14:52:34
W.P.(C) 40/2026
significant mental stressors. The solitude and
prolonged separation from family create an
environment of persistent mental strain, often
compounded by other additional burdens such as
concerns regarding the security of one’s family and
familial responsibilities. Furthermore, the constraints
of compulsory group living inherently curtail personal
freedom of activity.
65. Furthermore, from Paragraph 43 of the GMO,
2008, it is evident that cases of hypertension may arise
due to the differing individual responses to stressful
situations and can occur after prolonged and frequent
spells of service in the field, high altitude, or
operational areas.
xxx
xxx
xxx
71. Moreover, it must be noted that lifestyle varies
from individual to individual. Therefore, a mere
statement that a disease is a lifestyle disorder cannot
be a sufficient reason to deny the grant of Disability
Pension, unless the Medical Board has duly examined
and recorded particulars relevant to the individual
concerned.
xxx
xxx
xxx
79. Considering all the factors together, it is evident
that the mere fact that the onset of the disease occurred
during a peace area posting is not sufficient to negate
the cumulative stress of military service, which can
contribute to the development of diseases such as
Primary Hypertension, IHD etc. The RMB's opinion
that the onset took place in a peace station and
therefore the disease is not attributable to or
aggravated by military service cannot be sustained.
…
(Emphasis Supplied)
13.
So, it follows that the RMB’s opinion that the onset of the disease
took place in peace station and therefore, the disease is not attributable nor
aggravated by military service, is not sustained in the aforesaid case.
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
14:52:34
W.P.(C) 40/2026
14.
In view of our aforesaid discussion, we are of the view that the
Tribunal has rightly held that the respondent herein is entitled to disability
element of pension because of disability, “Primary Hypertension”. On such
a finding, the Tribunal allowed the disability element of pension at 30%
rounded off to 50% with effect from the date of discharge of the respondent.
15.
In view of the conclusion drawn by the Tribunal, more so, by relying
upon the judgment of the Supreme Court in Union of India v. Ram Avtar,
Civil Appeal No. 418/2012, decided on 10.12.2014, we are of the view that
the Tribunal is justified in allowing the OA. As the writ petition lacks
merits, we dismiss the same along with pending application.
V. KAMESWAR RAO, J
MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA, J
JANUARY 05, 2026/sr
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
14:52:34
W.P.(C) 40/2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review