Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
( 2026:JHHC:1771 )
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
S.A. No. 145 of 2017
1. Union of India through Ministry of Railways, Rail Bhawan, New
Delhi, P.O.+P.S.- New Delhi, Dist.- New Delhi
2. General Manager, East Central Railway, P.O.+P.S. Hajipur, Dist.
Hajipur, Bihar
3. The Divisional Railway Manager, Eastern Central Railway, P.O.
and P.S.-Dhanbad, District : Dhanbad
4. The Sr. Divisional Personal Officer, Eastern Central Railway,
Dhanbad, P.O. and P.S.-Dhanbad, District: Dhanbad
5. The Welfare Inspector, Eastern Central Railway, Dhanbad, P.O.
and P.S. Dhanbad, District: Dhanbad
…
…
Appellant/Defendants/Respondents
Versus
Madanlal Singh, S/o Biswanath Prasad Singh, R/o Loco Colony, Rly.
Qr. No. 98/B, P.O.-Gomoh, P.S.-Hariharpur, Dist. Dhanbad
… … Appellants/Defendants/Respondents
--CORAM :HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE ANUBHA RAWAT CHOUDHARY
--For the Appellant
: Mr. Prashant Pallav, ASGI
: Mr. Bakshi Vibha, C.G.C.
: Mr. Ayush (A.C. to A.S.G.I.)
For the Respondents
: Mr. Ashutosh Anand, Advocate
: Mr. Vincent Rohit Marki, Advocate
--20/13.01.2026
Heard the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the appellants.
2.
This appeal has been filed against the judgment and decree
dated 24.06.2016 and 08.07.2016 respectively passed by the learned
District Judge, XI, Dhanbad in Civil Appeal No. 28 of 2015 whereby
the learned 1st appellate court has allowed the appeal and reversed the
judgment and decree dated 02.03.2015 and 12.03.2015 respectively
passed by the learned Civil Judge, Jr. Division, Dhanbad in Title Suit
No. 7 of 2006.
3.
The learned counsel for the appellants has submitted that the
impugned judgment passed by the learned 1st appellate court does not
abide by the provision of Order 41 Rule 31 of CPC and therefore a
substantial question of law be framed. He has referred to the judgment
passed by this court in S.A. No. 28 of 2017 reported in 2025 SCC
Online Jhar. 2350 (Sangram Basky and another versus Hauwa
( 2026:JHHC:1771 )
Hembrom and others) decided on 02.01.2025. He has referred to
paragraph 21 of the aforesaid judgment which is quoted as under: “Upon perusal of the impugned judgment passed by the
appellate court, this Court finds that on the bare perusal of
the judgment, the first appellate court has not adjudicated
the appeal in accordance with the provisions of Order 41
Rule 31 of CPC when read with the aforesaid judgments
passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court and Patna High Court.
On the face of it, neither the points for determination were
framed, nor its findings is supported by reasons, nor it has
dealt with the reasons of the learned trial court while
reversing the judgement and decree passed by the learned
trial court.”
4.
After hearing the learned counsel for the appellants, this court
finds that the suit was filed seeking a declaration that order dated
30.07.2003 passed by defendant no. 4 (Sr. Divisional Personal Officer,
Eastern Central Railway) was illegal and also a declaration that
Biswanath Prasad Singh and Radha Prasad Singh are one and the same
person and the plaintiff was entitled for service benefit of his father. A
direction was also sought to the defendant to pay the service benefits
of the deceased’s father of the plaintiff.
5.
The suit was initially filed by the mother namely Basmati Devi
but on account of her death, her son Madan Lal Singh was substituted.
6.
The case of the plaintiff was that Biswanath Prasad Singh had
joined the services under the respondent as back as on 23.08.1964 who
died in harness on 26.07.2000. The plaintiff’s mother i.e. Basamati
devi was entitled to receive the post retiral benefits from the
defendant, but was not paid. She filed a case before Central
Administrative Tribunal being O.A. No. 79 of 2003 and vide order
dated 26.03.2003, the case was disposed of directing the defendant to
consider the representation. The claim was rejected vide order dated
30.07.2003 on the ground that the offer of appointment was given to
one Biswanath Prasad Singh but in his place, his elder brother Radha
Prasad Singh had joined the service and as such Radha Prasad Singh
had impersonated his brother Bishwanath Prasad Singh right from the
year 1964. The basis of said finding by the authority was verification
( 2026:JHHC:1771 )
of LTI on the service record of Bishwanath Prasad Singh, the LTI
affixed on the panchnama by the finger print expert of Railways and
on the basis of the letter and statement given by one Dina Nath Singh,
another brother of the deceased Biswanath Prasad Singh.
7.
It was pleaded in the suit that Biswanath Prasad Singh and
Radha Prasad Singh were one and the same person and one Manoj
Kumar who had made the complaint on 23.10.2000 alleging that he
was the son of Biswanath Prasad Singh and was entitled to receive the
service benefit of Biswanath Prasad Singh had given another letter to
defendant no. 2 stating that his name was wrongly shown in the voter
list as son of Biswanath Prasad Singh so he had filed the objection and
that he is the son of Budhnath, who never worked with the defendants.
Manoj Kumar also admitted that Biswanath Prasad and Radha Prasad
Singh were one and the same person and the plaintiff is the legal heir
of deceased Biswanath Prasad Singh. Manoj Kumar had also sworn an
affidavit dated 06.02.2004 to that effect. The plaintiff also relied upon
the PAN Number issued to Biswanath Prasad Singh and also the deed
of exchange dated 22.12.1991 executed by Smt. Kanti Devi to Most.
Rajia, daughter of Paran Singh which showed that Biswanath Prasad
Singh was the husband of the plaintiff and that he had an alias name
namely Radha Prasad Singh. Partition deed was also relied upon
where the Bishwanath Prasad Singh was shown having alias name as
Radha Nath Singh.
8.
The defendants filed a written statement opposing the prayer. It
was their case that offer of appointment was given to Biswanath
Prasad Singh and in his place his elder brother Radha Prasad Singh
had joined w.e.f. 23.08.1964 through impersonation and the finger
print expert of the Railways opined that Radha Prasad Singh rendered
his service in the place of Bishwanath Prasad Singh from 23.08.1964
to 26.07.2000 till death and on this basis, the claim of post retiral
benefit was sought to be denied to the plaintiff. It was asserted that
after enquiry a speaking order dated 30.07.2003 was passed rejecting
the claim of the plaintiff seeking post retiral benefit. It was also
asserted that the fact came to notice only when Manoj Kumar Singh
( 2026:JHHC:1771 )
son of late Biswanath Prasad Singh intimated by his application that
dated 23.10.2000 that his father namely Biswanath Prasad Singh had
expired in the year 1983-84 and Dinanath Singh, brother of late
Bishwanath Prasad Singh, intimated the office of the defendants as to
the family particulars of Babu Lal Singh on 02.10.2000, according to
which Radha Prasad Singh, Bishwanath Prasad Singh, Srinath Singh
and Dina Nath Singh were sons of late Babu Lal Singh. On this basis,
it was asserted that Radha Prasad Singh had impersonated himself as
Biswanath Prasad during his service.
9.
The learned trial Court framed the issues including the issue as
to whether Bishwanath Prasad Singh and Radha Prasad Singh are
one and the same person?
The plaintiff exhibited oral and
documentary evidences and Manoj Kumar was examined as P.W. 2.
and plaintiff herself was examined as P.W. 1. Numerous documentary
evidences were exhibited including the affidavit of Dina Nath Singh
as exhibit-5 and affidavit of Manoj Kumar Singh as Exhibit-5/a and
also exhibit-7 which was registered sale deed no. 14926 dated
25.10.1991 and also exhibit 7/a to 7/b which were the two-voter
identity card of Basmati Devi and Madan Lal Singh.
10.
On the other hand, the defendants only filed their written
statement and did not adduce any evidence in the course of trial.
11.
The learned Trial Court first decided the issue as to whether
Bishwanath Prasad Singha and Radha Prasad Singh were one and the
same person. The learned court highlighted that during cross
examination, P.W. 1 had admitted in paragraph 31 that on 02.10.2000
one Dina Nath Singh had submitted family list of Late Babu Lal Singh
who had four sons namely Radha Singh, Biswanath Singh, Dina Nath
Singh and Srinath Singh and on this basis the court recorded that the
plaintiff herself had admitted that Radha Prasad Singh and Biswanath
Prasad Singh were two persons. The court further observed that the
plaintiff did not produce any family list and Khatiyan of her native
place Rohtas Bihar in support of her claim. While considering the
exchange deed (Exhibit-7) the court observed that the first name
Radha Prasad Singh as Biswa Prasad Singh and so the inference can
( 2026:JHHC:1771 )
be drawn that the deceased employee having the first name as Radha
Prasad Singh. It was also observed that affidavit sworn before Public
Notary cannot be treated as evidence.
12.
While considering the evidence of P.W. 2, on whose
application the defendant authorities have conducted the inquiry, the
learned trial court observed that this witness had admitted the claim of
the plaintiff with ulterior motive. But he admitted that inquiry was
made by the Railway authority on his application and he did not give
any documentary evidence in support of his claim.
13.
The other witnesses were also considered.
14.
Ultimately the court held in paragraph 11 as under:“ 11. On perusal of the record I find an affidavits dated
02.11.04 sworn by Dinanath Singh before executing
magistrate, Dehri on Sone (Rohtas) which is Ex. 5 has
been filed on behalf of plaintiff, he shows in para 4 that
welfare inspector took his signature on the white paper
without his consent. Thus, inference may be drawn that
railway conducted the inquiry through it's welfare
inspector and who went plaintiff’s native place at Azad
Basti, P.S. Maharajganj, PO-Tilothu, Dist-Rohtas, Bihar
and after inquiry submitted report. It is also fact that
Dinanth Singh is still living and his affidavit before
Executive Magistrate is of no valued and same cannot be
treated as evidence U/s 3 of Evidence Act, until and unless
he came before the court and adduced and is subjected
himself for cross-examination.
From perusal of the record I also find that no voter list
and any revenue document and family list issued by the
government regarding deceased's native place, could be
furnished by the plaintiff's side which may shows that late
Bishwanath Prasad singh alias Radha Pd. Singh were
same persons. In absence of documentary evidence of
native place at Rohtas it cannot be held that both
Bishwanath Prasad singh and Radha Pd. Singh was same
person and the documents furnished by the plaintiff side
was prepared at Gomo, Dhanbad and they are not
sufficient to rebut the finding of Railway and to decide the
case in favour of plaintiff. So this issue is decided against
the plaintiff and favour to defendant side.”
15.
Thus, the learned trial court was ultimately of the view that in
absence of any documentary evidence of native place at Rohtas, it
( 2026:JHHC:1771 )
could not be held that Bishwanath Prasad Singh and Radha Prasad
Singh were one and the same person and the documents furnished by
the plaintiff were prepared at Gomo, Dhanbad and they were not
sufficient to rebut the finding of the Railway and decide the case in
favour of the plaintiff. It is important to note that the Railways did not
adduce any evidence and even the finding of the Railways and the
materials which the Railway authority collected during inquiry was
not placed on record, although the written statement of the Railways
referred to various verification by the handwriting expert which
became one of the basis for the Railways to come to the conclusion
that Biswanath Prasad Singh and Radha Prasad Singh were not one
and the same person.
16.
The learned 1st appellate court has considered the materials on
record threadbare and has also taken note of the issues which were
framed by the learned trial court in paragraph 5 of the impugned
judgment and the learned appellate court has dealt with the core issue
involved in this case. While discussing the evidences as to whether
Bishwanath Prasad Singh and Radha Prasad Singh were one and the
same person, the learned 1st appellate court has specifically recorded
in paragraph 14 as follows: “After hearing both sides and perusing the materials on
record I am of the view that the main point for determination
involved in this appeal is whether late Bishwanath Prasad
Singh and Radha Prasad Singh are one and the same
person.”
17.
The learned 1st appellate court has considered the evidence of
P.W. 1 Basmati Devi, the original plaintiff in paragraph 15 as
follows:“ On this point PW 1 Basmati Devi, the original plaintiff and
the wife of deceased Lt. Bishwanath Prasad Singh has
deposed that her husband Lt. Bishwanath Prasad Singh joined
in Eastern Railway as fitter/khalashi on 21.8.64 at Gomoh
and ultimately on 26.7.2000 while in service he died and since
then she has not received any retirement benefit, pension etc.
even after giving several applications to the railway and
ultimately at the direction of Hon'ble CAT, the defendant no.
( 2026:JHHC:1771 )
IV decided and rejected her representation on 30.7.03 on the
ground that one Radha Prasad Singh had joined the service in
place of Bishwanath Prasad Singh which is out and out wrong
whereas Bishwanath Prasad Singh and Radha Prasad Singh
were one and the same person. The defendant no. IV says that
the finger print expert of railway on verification of LTI of
Bishwanath Prasad Singh in service record and LTI of
panchnama was found to be of Radha Prasad Singh. She has
further deposed that on 23.10.2000 Manoj Kumar had given
an application before the railway that he was the son of
Bishwanath Prasad Singh and so he was entitled to service
etc. in place of him and subsequently the said Manoj Kumar
had further given an application that his previous application
dt. 23.10.2000 was based on wrong entry of the name of his
father as Bishwanath Prasad Singh in voter list whereas the
fact is that he was the son of Budhnath Singh and his father
had never worked in Railway and further stated that
Bishwanath Prasad Singh & Radha Prasad Singh were one
and the same person and Basmati Devi being his wife and
Madanlal being his son are his heirs. Not only this, Deolagna
Kuer, the mother of Manoj Kumar has also given an affidavit
on 6.2.04 regarding the same fact. She has further deposed
that the regd. Sale deed dated 25.10.91 also proves that
Radha Prasad Singh and Bishwanath Prasad Singh were one
and the same person. This witness has also proved several
documents. In paragraph 25 of her cross-examination also
she has admitted that the registered sale deed is the proof that
her husband had two names as Bishwanath Prasad Singh &
Radha Prasad Singh.”
18.
So far as the evidence of P.W. 2 is concerned, the same has also
been considered which reveals that he was in inimical terms with
Basmati Devi due to land dispute. It is not in dispute even from the
side of the defendants that the entire enquiry triggered by virtue of
application furnished by P.W. 2 Manoj Kumar. P.W. 2 had also stated
in his application that Biswanath Prasad Singh worked till 1983-84 but
he deposed before the court that such fact was incomplete and he also
deposed that his father is Budh Nath Prasad Singh and he is not the
son of Biswanath Prasad Singh, although in the application of
complaint he stated himself to be the son of Biswanath Prasad Singh.
The learned 1st appellate court recorded in paragraph 20 that on the
( 2026:JHHC:1771 )
basis of oral evidence of P.W. 1 Basmati devi, P.W. 2 Manoj Kumar,
P.W. 3, 4, 5 it was clear that Biswanath Prasad Singh and Radha
Prasad Singh were one and the same person.
19.
The 1st appellate court also specifically considered the
documentary evidences placed on record including the Registered
deed of exchange dated 25.10.1991 wherein Biswanath Prasad Singh
was shown with alias name as Radha Prasad Singh. The court
recorded that this deed of exchange was much earlier when the dispute
arose with regard to genuineness of the name of Biswanath Prasad
Singh as Radha Prasad Singh. The court also took into consideration
Exhibit-4/b which was the application given by Manoj Kumar who
stated that Biswanath Prasad Singh had also known as Radha Prasad
Singh.
20.
The learned 1st appellate court on the basis of the evidence
adduced on behalf of the witnesses of the plaintiff observed that the
onus shifted upon the defendants to counter the evidence of the
plaintiff or to prove the basis of the finding dated 30.07.2003 passed
by defendant no. 4 but this onus was not discharged by the defendants.
The learned court ultimately held that on the basis of oral and
documentary evidence, Biswanath Prasad Singh and Radha Prasad
Singh were one and the same person and observed that the learned
trial court failed to properly appreciate the evidences on record and
passed the judgment and decree which deserved to be set aside.
21.
This court finds that not only the point of determination was
framed by the learned 1st appellate court observing that the main point
was that whether Biswanath Prasad Singh and Radha Prasad Singh
were one and the same person, but the learned 1st appellate court has
also recorded that the learned trial court had not appreciated the
evidence on record properly while passing the impugned judgment.
The learned 1st appellate court has considered every material placed on
record threadbare including the sale deed dated 25.10.1991 which
showed that Biswanath Prasad Singh with an alias name of Radha
Prasad Singh and admittedly at that point of time, there was no dispute
as to the identity of Biswanath Prasad Singh and Radha Prasad Singh.
( 2026:JHHC:1771 )
The false complaint lodged by Manoj Kumar was also duly explained
and considered by the learned 1st appellate court. The defendants did
not adduce any evidence and even their own enquiry report was not
placed on record.
22.
This court finds that the learned trial court was of the view that
the plaintiff was unable to rebut the finding of the Railways in the
enquiry report so as to decide the case in favour of the plaintiff and the
learned 1st appellate court had considered the materials on record and
had recorded that the plaintiff had duly adduced evidence and the onus
shifted upon the defendants to prove their case of impersonation. This
court finds that the learned 1st appellate court has decided the case in
accordance with law and there is no violation of the mandate of Order
41 rule 31 of CPC. Accordingly, the judgment relied upon by the
appellants does not help the appellants in any manner. Further, no
perversity in the matter of appreciation of evidence by the learned 1 st
appellate court has been pointed out by the learned counsel for the
appellants.
23.
This court is of the considered view that no substantial question
of law, much less the substantial question of law as suggested by the
learned counsel for the appellants arise for consideration in this case.
Consequently, this 2nd appeal is hereby dismissed.
24.
Pending I.A., if any, is closed.
25.
Let this order be communicated to the court concerned through
FAX.
(Anubha Rawat Choudhary, J.)
Dated: 13/01/2026
Uploaded on: 26.02.2026
Binit
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review