Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:3184-DB
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
W.P.(S) No. 484 of 2026
---1.Union of India represented through the General
Manager, South East Central Railway, Bilaspur Zone, New
GM Building, South East Central Railway, P.O. & P.SBilaspur, Chattisgarh-495001 viz. Sanjay Kumar Oswal,
aged about 59 Years, S/o Late M C Oswal, presentlyposted
as Deputy Chief Personnel officer (Gaz), South East
Central Railway Bilaspur, Chhattisgarh, Officer's Colony,
South East Central Railway Bilaspur, P.O. & P.S. Bilaspur
Chhattisgarh.
2. The Principal Financial Adviser (FA & CAO) South
Eastern Central Railway, Bilaspur Zone, New GM
Building, South East Central Railway, P.O. & P.SBilaspur, Chattisgarh-495004.
3. The Divisional Railway Manager, South Eastern Central
Railway, Bilaspur Division, DRM Complex, South East
Central Railway, P.O. & P.S- Bilaspur, Chattisgarh495004.
4. The Senior Divisional Finance Manager, South Eastern
Central Railway. Bilaspur Division, DRM Complex, South
East Central Railway, P.O. & P.S- Bilaspur, Chattisgarh495004
.…Petitioners
Versus
1. Dr. Ranjit John Lakra (Retd. ACMS SHAHDOL), aged
about 58 years, S/o Late J.M. Lakra, R/o Flat No.3A
Archana Enclave, Harihar Singh Road, Morabadi, P.O.Morabadi, P.S.-Bariatu, Ranchi, Jharkhand-834008.
Respondent
2. State Bank of India through its Assistant General
manager, Centralized Pension Processing Centre, 4th
Floor, Administrative Office, Judge Court Road, P.O.
&P.S.-Patna, Bihar-800001.
Proforma Respondent.
------CORAM: HON’BLEMR. JUSTICE SUJIT NARAYAN PRASAD
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARUN KUMAR RAI
------For the Petitioners
: Mr. Ramit Satender, CGC
Ms. Neelam Kumari, Advocate
2026:JHHC:3184-DB
For the Respondents
:Mr. Rajesh Kumar, Advocate
Mr. Amit Kumar, Advocate
Mr. M.K. Sinha, Advocate
------------Order No. 02/Dated: 4th February, 2026
Per Sujit Narayan Prasad, J.
Prayer:
1.
The instant writ petition, filed under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India, is directed
23.05.2025
passed
by
learned
against order dated
Central
Administrative
Tribunal, Patna Bench, Circuit Bench at Ranchi in O.A. No.
051/00206/2024 by which the Original Application was
allowed in following terms:
“(i).The impugned order of the respondents for the recovery of
excess
payment
issued
SR.DFM/BSP/PEN-SETTLE/MISC/
vide
Order/Letter
dated
No.
17.01.2024
(Annexure- 5) is quashed and set aside as the same is
unsustainable in view of the law laid down by the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in the case of State Of Punjab & Others Vs.
RafiqMasih and subsequent DoPT OM dated 02.03.2016.
(ii) Since the counsel for the applicant has decided not to press
for the relief in the form of a direction upon the respondent
railway as well as the respondent bank to refund the amount
which was already recovered from the pension of the applicant
in terms of the order contained in No. SR.DFM/BSP/PENSETTLE/MISC/dated 17.01.2024, the tribunal will restrict its
order to bar any further recovery only on this count of wrong
pension fixation.
2026:JHHC:3184-DB
(ⅲ) The respondent officials from now on will pay the revised
pension as decided after correction in the pension fixation as
per the rules.
The interim order of this tribunal passed on 15.05.2024
restraining the respondents from making any further recovery
on this count of wrong pension fixation will be merged in this
final order.”
Brief facts of the case:
2.
The brief facts of the case,as per the pleading made in the
writ petition, needs to be referred herein reads, which reads
as under:
3.
The applicant, the respondent no. 1 herein, a former
officer of the Indian Railway Medical Service, was appointed
following his qualifying in the 1989 UPSC examination and
joined
as
Assistant
Divisional
Medical
Officer
in
Chakradharpur Division on 26.10.1990. He served the Indian
Railways for over 25 years and took voluntary retirement from
the post of ACMS/Shahdolon on 20.05.2016. The applicant,
the respondent no. 1 herein, took voluntarily retirement in
accordance with the applicable rules, which was duly
accepted by the Respondent Railway(writ petitioner herein).
4.
Post-retirement, his pension and other benefits were
processed and disbursed by the appellant-Railway after
verifying his service records. The applicant received a gratuity
amounting to 20 lakhs and a commutation amount of ₹52.74
2026:JHHC:3184-DB
lakhs. A Pension Payment Order (PPO) dated 26.10.2016,
under the 7th Pay Commission, fixed his basic pension at
Rs. 1,24,750 with a monthly commutation factor of Rs.
49,900.
5.
It is the case of the applicant, the respondent no. 1
herein, that he regularly received his pension without
interruption from May 2016 until January 2024. But, all of a
sudden, on 31.01.2024, the applicant, the respondent no. 1
herein, was informed by the Bank about a recovery of Rs.
6,95,346 from his pension account, following a directive
issued by Sr. DFM, Bilaspur, who revised his basic pension to
₹1,18,750.
6.
This adjustment, communicated through the Bank and
not by the Railway authorities directly, was carried out
without any prior notice or opportunity for the applicant to
respond. Subsequent thereto, the pension disbursements
were significantly reduced due to ongoing monthly deductions
of ₹44,000.
7.
The applicant, the respondent no. 1 herein, contends that
the recovery order violates principles of natural justice as it
was
issued
after
more
than
seven
years
after
the
commencement of his pension and without providing him a
chance to be heard. He argues that he played no role in the
original pension calculation, which was entirely carried out
2026:JHHC:3184-DB
by the appellant-Railway. It has been contended that the
recovery thus placed undue financial and mental hardship on
him despite no wrong doing on his part.
8.
The case of the petitioner/Railway is that the pension
of the respondent no. 1-applicant since has erroneously been
fixed which was to be deducted by the authorities sometimes
in the year 2021. However the same was executed sometimes
in
the
year
vide
order
dated
17.01.2024
and
accordingly, the pension of the respondent no. 1-applicant
was re-fixed and order of recovery was passed, which was
assailed by the respondent no. 1-applicant before the
Tribunal by filing Original Application.
9.
The learned Tribunal, after hearing learned counsel for
the parties, quashed and set aside the impugned order dated
17.01.2024 holding the same to be unsustainable in view of
law laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of
State Of Punjab & Others Vs. Rafiq Masih and subsequent
DoPT OM dated 02.03.2016, against which instant writ
petition has been filed.
Submission on behalf of Petitioners-Railway:
10. Mr. Ramit Satender, learned counsel for the petitionersrailway has assailed the impugned order on the ground that
the applicant-respondent no. 1 herein, although was well
conscious with the decision already taken in the year 2021
2026:JHHC:3184-DB
reducing the quantum of pension but the same was not
challenged rather the same was challenged after lapse of
three years in the year 2024, when the impugned order was
acted upon the decision so taken in the year 2021, by filing
the Original Application before the Tribunal.
11. It
has
been
contended
that
when
the
applicant-
respondent no. 1 was well conscious about the wrong fixation
of pay, based upon which the pension has already been fixed
and even after knowing the aforesaid fact when it was not
challenged immediately then in such circumstances the
decision to recover in consequence thereof, the decision taken
in the year 2021, ought not to have been interfered with by
the tribunal relying upon the judgment rendered in the case
of State Of Punjab & Others Vs. RafiqMasih (supra).
Submission on behalf of respondent No. 1:
12. Per contra, learned counsel for the respondent no. 1 has
defended the order passed by the learned tribunal and
submitted that the order passed by the learned tribunal
requires no interference.
13. The learned counsel has further submitted that the learned
Tribunal after taking into consideration the factual aspect
that applicant/respondent no. 1 has no role in erroneous
pension fixation and the fixation was carried out by the
responsible officers after due approval from the competent
2026:JHHC:3184-DB
authority,
has passed the impugned order, therefore the
said order requires no intereferece by this Court.
Analysis:
14. We have heard learned counsel for the parties and gone
through the finding recorded by the learned tribunal.
15. This Court is conscious regarding its jurisdiction which is to
be exercised by the High Court in exercise of power
conferred under Article 226 of the Constitution of India in
the matter of order passed by the tribunal, as per the ratio
laid down by Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of L. Chandra
Kumar Vs. Union of India &Ors. reported in(1997) 3 SCC
261 particularly paragraph 99, wherein it has been held
that the High Court is having power of judicial review to look
into the legality and propriety of the order of the tribunal to
the extent that if the order passed by the tribunal suffers
from any perversity or the order is passed without following
the principles of natural justice or there is error apparent on
the face of order. For ready reference, paragraph 99 of the
judgment is quoted as under:
"99. In view of the reasoning adopted by us, we hold that
clause 2(d) of Article 323-A and clause 3(d) of Article 323-B,
to the extent they exclude the jurisdiction of the High Courts
and the Supreme Court under Articles 226/227 and 32 of the
Constitution, are unconstitutional. Section 28 of the Act and
the "exclusion of jurisdiction" clauses in all other legislations
enacted
under
the
aegis
of Articles
323-A and 323-
B would, to the same extent, be unconstitutional. The
2026:JHHC:3184-DB
jurisdiction conferred upon the High Courts under Articles
226/227 and upon the Supreme Court under Article 32 of
the Constitution is a part of the inviolable basic structure of
our Constitution. While this jurisdiction cannot be ousted,
other courts and Tribunals may perform a supplemental role
in discharging the powers conferred by Articles 226/227 and
32 of the Constitution. The Tribunals created under Article
323-A and Article 323- B of the Constitution are possessed
of the competence to test the constitutional validity of
statutory provisions and rules. All decisions of these
Tribunals will, however, be subject to scrutiny before a
Division Bench of the High Court within whose jurisdiction
the Tribunal concerned falls. The Tribunals will, nevertheless,
continue to act like courts of first instance in respect of the
areas of law for which they have been constituted. It will not,
therefore, be open for litigants to directly approach the High
Courts even in cases where they question the vires of
statutory legislations (except where the legislation which
creates the particular Tribunal is challenged) by overlooking
the jurisdiction of the Tribunal concerned. Section 5(6) of the
Act is valid and constitutional and is to be interpreted in the
manner we have indicated."
16. The power of judicial review has also been deliberated by the
Hon’ble Apex Court, which is to be considered while
exercising the said power only to the extent that if any order
is being passed found to be having error on the face of the
order or without jurisdiction or suffers from perversity. The
error apparent on the face of the order means that if the
order appears on its face having with error, then only the
power of judicial review is to be exercised.
17. The Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of West Bengal Central
School Service Commission vs. Abdul Halim, (2019) 18
SCC 39,has held at paragraph-30 that the power of judicial
2026:JHHC:3184-DB
review must be exercised by the Court after determining that
the impugned is vitiated by an error apparent on the face of
the record and not the same has been established by a
process
of
reasoning.
Paragraph-30
of
the
aforesaid
judgment is being referred as under:
“30. In exercise of its power of judicial review, the Court
is to see whether the decision impugned is vitiated by an
apparent error of law. The test to determine whether a
decision is vitiated by error apparent on the face of the
record is whether the error is self-evident on the face of
the record or whether the error requires examination or
argument to establish it. If an error has to be established
by a process of reasoning, on points where there may
reasonably be two opinions, it cannot be said to be an
error on the face of the record, as held by this Court in
SatyanarayanLaxminarayanHegde
v.
MillikarjunBhavanappaTirumale
[SatyanarayanLaxminarayanHegde
v.
MillikarjunBhavanappaTirumale, AIR 1960 SC 137] . ---.”
18. In the case of T.C. Basappa vs. T. Nagappa and Anr.,
(1955) 1 SCR 250, their Lordship have held that the patent
error in a decision can be corrected by writ of certiorari,
when it is manifested by the error apparent on the face of
the proceedings. The relevant portion of the aforesaid
judgment is quoted hereunder:
“11. … An error in the decision or determination itself may
also be amenable to a writ of certiorari but it must be a
manifest error apparent on the face of the proceedings e.g.
when it is based on clear ignorance or disregard of the
provisions of law. In other words, it is a patent error which
can be corrected by certiorari but not a mere wrong decision.
….”
2026:JHHC:3184-DB
19. Thus, on the basis of the aforesaid settled legal position it is
evident that the power of judicial review can be exercised, if
error on the face of the order impugned, challenged under
the Article 226 of Constitution of India, appears to be there.
20. This Court is now proceeding to examine the propriety of the
order passed by the learned tribunal in order to assess as to
whether the finding so recorded by the learned tribunal is
coming under the fold either of error apparent on the face of
the order and suffers from perversity.
21. The fact since has already been referred hereinabove but for
better appreciation of the consideration of the aforesaid
issue, the admitted facts once again is being reiterated
herein.
22. It is admitted case that the applicant-respondent no. 1 was
appointed under Indian Railway Medical Officer, sometimes
in the year 1990 and after serving a considerable period of
25 years, he voluntarily retired from service in the year
2016. After getting Voluntary Retirement he received all his
retiral benefits as also his pension was fixed as per last pay
drawn. However, sometimes in the year 2021, the writ
petitioner-Railway
detected
that
the
pension
of
the
applicant-respondent no. 1 was wrongly fixed. Therefore, it
is an admitted case that initialy no such anomaly or error
was found in fixation of pay and consequential pension of
2026:JHHC:3184-DB
the respondent no.1/applicant rather when after four years
of taking voluntary retirement by the applicant-respondent
no. 1,
the writ petitioner-railway sometimes in the year
2021 detected that the pension of the applicant-respondent
no. 1 has wrongly been fixed and
in the year 2024 the
impugned order dated 17.01.2024 was passed after eight
[08] years of taking voluntary retirement by the employee, by
which order of recovery and order of deduction in pension
has been passed.
23. It is equally admitted that the decision so taken in the year
2021 of wrong fixation of pension has not been challenged
by the applicant-respondent no. 1 before the tribunal
immediately after decision so taken by the writ petitionersrailway rather the challenge was made in the year 2024
when the decision so taken of reducing the quantum of
pension and order of recovery of excess amount was passed
vide
order
dated
17.01.2024,
by
filing
the
Original
Application before the tribunal.
24. One of the ground has been taken by the writ petitionersrailway that fact about reduction of amount of pension even
though was well known to the respondent no. 1-applicant
sometimes in the year 2021 but he chose not to challenge
the same meaning thereby he accepted the decision so taken
by the authority, the writ petitioners.
2026:JHHC:3184-DB
25. But we are not in agreement with such argument since the
said argument if will be accepted then the issue of cause of
action or the recurring cause of action will be diluted. Law is
well settled that in the matter of pension, the principle of
“recurring cause of action” would be applicable and the
recurring cause of action has been interpreted by Hon’ble
Apex Court that in the matter of pension due to reduction
therein the pensioner is having cause of action even after
lapse of consideration period of time reason being that the
pensioner is being made to suffer day-by-day and month-tomonth basis.
26. “Recurring” means suffering of the litigant, particularly, the
public servant if the suffering is continuing day by day, the
same will be said to be recurring cause of action.
Recurring/successive
wrongs”
are
those
which
occur
periodically, each wrong giving rise to a distinct and separate
cause of action. A recurring or successive wrong, occurs
when successive acts, each giving rise to a distinct and
separate cause of action, are committed and each act, in
itself wrongful, constitutes a separate cause of action for
sustaining a claim or a complaint, reference in this regard be
made to the judgment rendered by the Hon’ble Apex Court in
the case of M.R. Gupta v. Union of India [(1995) 5 SCC
628], wherein at paragraph 5, it has been held as under:
2026:JHHC:3184-DB
“5. Having heard both sides, we are satisfied that the
Tribunal has missed the real point and overlooked the crux
of the matter. The appellant's grievance that his pay
fixation was not in accordance with the rules, was the
assertion of a continuing wrong against him which gave
rise to a recurring cause of action each time he was paid a
salary which was not computed in accordance with the
rules. So long as the appellant is in service, a fresh cause
of action arises every month when he is paid his monthly
salary on the basis of a wrong computation made contrary
to rules. It is no doubt true that if the appellant's claim is
found correct on merits, he would be entitled to be paid
according to the properly fixed pay scale in the future and
the question of imitation would arise for recovery of the
arrears for the past period. In other words, the appellant's
claim, if any, for recovery of arrears calculated on the
basis of difference in the pay which has become time
barred would not be recoverable, but he would be entitled
to proper fixation of his pay in accordance with rules and
to cessation of a continuing wrong if on merits his claim is
justified. Similarly, any other consequential relief claimed
by him, such as, promotion etc. would also be subject to
the defence of laches etc. to disentitle him to those reliefs.
The pay fixation can be made only on the basis of the
situation existing on 1-8-1978 without taking into account
any other consequential relief which may be barred by his
laches and the bar of limitation. It is to this limited extent
of proper pay fixation the application cannot be treated as
time barred since it is based on a recurring cause of
action.”
27. Further, the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Union of
India v. Tarsem Singh [(2008) 8 SCC 648] at paragraph 4
held as under:
4. The principles underlying continuing wrongs and
recurring/successive wrongs have been applied to service
law disputes. A “continuing wrong” refers to a single
wrongful
act
which
causes
a
continuing
injury.
2026:JHHC:3184-DB
“Recurring/successive wrongs” are those which occur
periodically, each wrong giving rise to a distinct and
separate cause of action. This Court in Balakrishna
Savalram
Pujari
Waghmare
v.
Shree
Dhyaneshwar
Maharaj Sansthan [AIR 1959 SC 798] explained the
concept of continuing wrong (in the context of Section 23 of
the Limitation Act, 1908 corresponding to Section 22 of the
Limitation Act, 1963) : (AIR p. 807, para 31)
“31. … It is the very essence of a continuing wrong that it
is an act which creates a continuing source of injury and
renders the doer of the act responsible and liable for the
continuance of the said injury. If the wrongful act causes
an injury which is complete, there is no continuing wrong
even though the damage resulting from the act may
continue. If, however, a wrongful act is of such a character
that the injury caused by it itself continues, then the act
constitutes a continuing wrong. In this connection, it is
necessary to draw a distinction between the injury caused
by the wrongful act and what may be described as the
effect of the said injury.”
28. The law is already settled by Hon'ble Apex Court that the
pension will be said to be recurring cause, reference in this
regard be made to the judgment rendered in the case of M.L.
Patil (Dead) through Legal Representatives v. State of
Goa, (2023) 1 SCC 660. For ready reference the relevant
paragraph of the aforesaid judgment is being quoted
hereunder as:—
“6. As such, the High Court may be right and/or justified
in denying any salary for the period of two extra years to
the writ petitioners if they would have continued in service,
on the ground of delay. However, as far as the pension is
concerned, it is a continuous cause of action. There is no
justification at all for denying the arrears of pension as if
they would have been retired/superannuated at the age of
2026:JHHC:3184-DB
60 years. There is no justification at all by the High Court
to deny the pension at the revised rates and payable only
from 1-1-2020. Under the circumstances, the impugned
judgment and order [Laxman J. Chavan v. State of Goa,
2020 SCC OnLine Bom 236] passed by the High Court is
required to be modified to the aforesaid extent.”
29. It is pertinent to mention herein that there is no explanation
on behalf of writ petitioners-railway that what prevented the
authority in acting upon the the decision so taken in the
year 2021 i.e., the day when the decision was taken to
reduce the pension, rather, they sat idle on the decision so
taken in the year 2021 for a long period of more than three
years, and only after that in the year 2024 acted upon,
which prompted the applicant to approach the tribunal.
30. This Court, therefore, is of the view that the argument to
that effect as has been advanced on behalf of writ petitioners
that the decision so taken by reducing the quantum of
pension in view of argument since has been challenged in
the year 2024, as such no indulgence ought to have been
given by the tribunal but based upon the reason as aforesaid
we hereby reject the said argument holding it, having no
substance.
31. So far as recovery is concerned, the law is well settled that
salary or pension or any financial benefit is not allowed to be
taken contrary to the entitlement and if such amount is
being paid contrary to the entitlement then the State will
have the liberty to rectify it so that the illegality may not be
2026:JHHC:3184-DB
perpetuated, reference in this regard be made to the
judgment rendered by the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of
Union of India v. Arulmozhi Iniarasu, (2011) 7 SCC 397
wherein at paragraph 26 it has been held that only because
an illegality has been committed, the same cannot be
directed to be perpetuated, for ready reference the relevant
paragraph is being quoted as under:
“26. Lastly, as regards the submission that the action of
the appellants is highly discriminatory inasmuch as some
similarly situated persons have been appointed/absorbed
as Sepoys, the argument is stated to be rejected. It is well
settled that a writ of mandamus can be issued by the High
Court only when there exists a legal right in the writ
petitioner and corresponding legal obligation on the State.
Only because an illegality has been committed, the same
cannot be directed to be perpetuated. It is trite law that
there cannot be equality in illegality. (Ref. Sushanta
Tagore v. Union of India [(2005) 3 SCC 16] , U.P. State
Sugar Corpn. Ltd. v. Sant Raj Singh [(2006) 9 SCC 82 :
SCC
(L&S)
1610]
, State v. Sashi
Balasubramanian [(2006) 13 SCC 252 : (2007) 3 SCC (Cri)
337]
and State
of
Orissa v. Prasana
Kumar
Sahoo [(2007) 15 SCC 129 : (2010) 2 SCC (L&S) 765] .)”
32. Thus, Law is also well settled that if any illegality has been
pointed out, then it is the bounden duty of the authority to
rectify it to follow the principle that illegality cannot be
allowed to be perpetuated.
33. Here, the only issue is as to whether recovery can be said to
be justified if there is no mis-representation on the part of
the applicant [employee] that too after separation from
2026:JHHC:3184-DB
service in consequence of voluntary retirement, way back in
May, 2016.
34. The issue since is of recovery and hence, the proposition
which has been laid down by the Hon'ble Apex Court in
judgments passed time to time needs to be referred herein.
35. Initially, the Hon'ble Apex Court has considered the issue of
recovery in the case of Shyam Babu Verma vs. Union of
India, (1994) 2 SCC 521 wherein the recovery has been
said to be improper if the recovery is being made from the
salary of the concerned employee on the basis of wrong
fixation if there is no misrepresentation or fraud said to be
committed on the part of the concerned public servant. For
ready reference, relevant paragraph of the said judgment is
being referred as under:
"11. Although we have held that the petitioners were entitled
only to the pay scale of Rs 330-480 in terms of the
recommendations of the Third Pay Commission
w.e.f.
January 1, 1973 and only after the period of 10 years, they
became entitled to the pay scale of Rs 330- 560 but as they
have received the scale of Rs 330-560 since 1973 due to no
fault of theirs and that scale is being reduced in the year
1984 with effect from January 1, 1973, it shall only be just
and proper not to recover any excess amount which has
already been paid to them. Accordingly, we direct that no
steps should be taken to recover or to adjust any excess
amount paid to the petitioners due to the fault of the
respondents, the petitioners being in no way responsible for
the same.
2026:JHHC:3184-DB
36. Again, in Sahib Ram v. State of Haryana and Ors. [1995
Supp (1) SCC 18], the Hon'ble Apex Court held that
although the appellant therein did not possess the required
educational qualification, yet the Principal granting him the
relaxation, had paid his salary on the revised pay scale and
this was not on account of misrepresentation made by the
appellant but by a mistake committed by the Principal and
as such the amount already paid to the appellant need not
be recovered. For ready reference the relevant paragraph is
being quoted as under:
"5. Admittedly the appellant does not possess the required
educational qualifications. Under the circumstances the appellant
would not be entitled to the relaxation. The Principal erred in
granting him the relaxation. Since the date of relaxation the
appellant had been paid his salary on the revised scale. However,
it is not on account of any misrepresentation made by the
appellant that the benefit of the higher pay scale was given to him
but by wrong construction made by the Principal for which the
appellant cannot be held to be at fault. Under the circumstances
the amount paid till date may not be recovered from the
appellant."
37. Subsequent to the aforesaid judgment, the Hon'ble Apex
Court has considered the issue of recovery in the case
of Chandi Prasad Uniyal vs. State of Uttarakhand,
(2012) 8 SCC 417 wherein by deferring with the view taken
by the Hon'ble Apex Court in Shyam Babu Verma vs.
Union of India (supra) has taken the contrary view by
holding therein that if the amount has been paid, the same
since is of a tax payers money, hence, the same is to be
2026:JHHC:3184-DB
recovered from the concerned employee. Relevant paragraph
of the judgment rendered in Chandi Prasad Uniyal vs.
State of Uttarakhand (supra) is being referred as under:
"14. We are concerned with the excess payment of public money
which is often described as "taxpayers' money" which belongs
neither to the officers who have effected overpayment nor to the
recipients. We fail to see why the concept of fraud or
misrepresentation is being brought in in such situations. The
question to be asked is whether excess money has been paid or
not, may be due to a bona fide mistake. Possibly, effecting excess
payment of public money by the government officers may be due
to various reasons like negligence, carelessness, collusion,
favouritism, etc. because money in such situation does not belong
to the payer or the payee. Situations may also arise where both
the payer and the payee are at fault, then the mistake is mutual.
Payments are being effected in many situations without any
authority of law and payments have been received by the
recipients also without any authority of law. Any amount
paid/received without the authority of law can always be
recovered barring few exceptions of extreme hardships but not as
a matter of right, in such situations law implies an obligation on
the payee to repay the money, otherwise it would amount to
unjust enrichment."
38. The Hon'ble Apex Court in view of the conflicting judgment
on the issue of recovery has referred the matter before the
Larger Bench in the case of State of Punjab and Ors. vs.
Rafiq Masih (White Washer) and Ors., (2014) 8 SCC 883
but the Hon'ble Apex Court without answering the reference
remitted
the
matter
before
appropriate disposal.
the
Division
Bench
for
2026:JHHC:3184-DB
39. Consequently, the Division Bench of the Hon'ble Apex Court
in the case of State of Punjab and Ors. vs. Rafiq Masih
(White Washer) and Ors., (2015) 4 SCC 334 at paragraph18, has laid down the guidelines which is required to be
followed by the State in making recovery. For ready
reference,
paragraph-18
of the
said
judgment is
being
referred as under:
18. It is not possible to postulate all situations of hardship
which would govern employees on the issue of recovery,
where payments have mistakenly been made by the
employer, in excess of their entitlement. Be that as it may,
based on the decisions referred to hereinabove, we may, as a
ready reference, summarise the following few situations,
wherein recoveries by the employers, would be impermissible
in law:
(i)Recovery from the employees belonging to Class III and Class IV
service (or Group C and Group D service).
(ii)Recovery from the retired employees, or the employees who are
due to retire within one year, of the order of recovery.
(iii)Recovery from the employees, when the excess payment has
been made for a period in excess of five years, before the order of
recovery is issued.
(iv)Recovery in cases where an employee has wrongfully been
required to discharge duties of a higher post, and has been paid
accordingly, even though he should have rightfully been required
to work against an inferior post.
(v)In any other case, where the court arrives at the conclusion, that
recovery if made from the employee, would be iniquitous or harsh
or arbitrary to such an extent, as would far outweigh the equitable
balance of the employer's right to recover.”
40. It is evident from the guideline, as referred hereinabove,
which is altogether five in number and fifth is conferment of
2026:JHHC:3184-DB
power upon the Court to adjudge by making a balance of
financial hardship holding therein that where the court
arrives at the conclusion, that recovery if made from the
employee, would be iniquitous or harsh or arbitrary to such
an extent, as would far outweigh the equitable balance of the
employer's right to recover.
41. After having referred relevant paragraph of
the judgment
rendered by the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of State of
Punjab &Ors Vs. Rafiq Masih (White Washer) &Ors
(supra), basing upon which the learned tribunal has also
passed order, which is impugned herein, now the Court is
proceeding to consider as to whether the order so passed by
the tribunal suffers from the error apparent on the face of
the order or perversity.
42. It is evident by considering the admitted fact, as referred
hereinabove that the amount sought to be recovered after
lapse of 8 years but there is no justification about nonrecovery of the said amount from the day i.e. in year 2021,
when the decision was finally taken by the authority till
date of passing of the impugned order i.e.17.01.2024.
43. It is admitted fact that the applicant was not holding the
post of either class IV or Class III rather was holding the
post of Additional Chief Medical Superintendent. The
question of adjudging the financial hardship as per the
2026:JHHC:3184-DB
guidelines,
as
available
judgment
rendered
in
under
paragraph
of
the
State
of
&Ors
Vs.
Punjab
RafiqMasih (White Washer) &Ors (supra), is relevant in
the context.
44. We are conscious that the employee after separation from
service is getting the pension which is half of the salary plus
dearness relief, since there is no provision for the pensioner
to get the dearness allowance rather the dearness allowance
is considered to be the dearness relief and is merged to the
amount of pension. The question of hardship of a pensioner
after eight years on getting reduced pension is the core of
consideration by this Court.
45. There is no justification as to why for 8 years the employer
sat idle and had not recovered the amount rather the
amount so deducted is after lapse of 8 years having no
proper explanation and there cannot be any explanation
once the decision has been taken in the year 2021 then why
the decision so taken for deduction in pension and recovery
was not acted upon immediately rather after lapse of more
than 3 years, in the year 2024 the impugned order of
recovery and deduction in pension has been passed.
46. This Court, considering the fact that after lapse of 8 years
from separation from service if the amount will be allowed to
be deducted from the monthly pension even though
2026:JHHC:3184-DB
admittedly there was no misrepresentation on the part of the
employee concerned, as per the admitted case of the writ
petitioner-employer [railway herein], is of the view that even
though the applicant-employee [respondent no. 1 herein] is
not holding the post of Class III or Class IV but judging the
financial hardship as per the guidelines, as available under
paragraph 18 of the judgment rendered in State of Punjab
&Ors Vs. RafiqMasih (White Washer) &Ors (supra),
certainly applicant/respondent no. 1 would be made to
suffer without his fault.
47. This Court, therefore, is of the view that the view which has
been taken by the learned tribunal is neither suffers from
any perversity nor the order is passed without following the
principles of natural justice nor there is error apparent on
the face of order.
48. This Court in exercise of power conferred under Article 226
of the Constitution of India to exercise the power of judicial
review is of the view that the impugned order dated
23.05.2025 passed by the learned tribunal, requires no
interference.
49. Now proceeding further, as has been referred above, as to
why no decision for correction of erroneously fixed pension
was
taken
immediately
after
separation
of
the
applicant/respondent from service in year 2016 and only in
2026:JHHC:3184-DB
the year 2021 decision was taken to rectify the said error
and even
then impugned order for
execution of recovery
was passed on 17.01.2024.
50. Admittedly, the writ petitioners are dealing with the public
money and certainly the public money means the tax payers
money and as such nobody can be allowed to play with the
public money. The question of wrong fixation of the pension
is the core of the issue. It is admitted fact that fixation of
pension is not under the domain of the employee rather it is
under the exclusive domain of employer then why the
pension was fixed errenously and the said error was
allegedly detected after lapse of more than five years 2021
and even after detection of the said wrong fixation no action
was taken for a long period of three years and only in the
year 2024 vide impugned order dated 17.01.2024, the order
of recovery and re-fixation of pension was passed.
51. It is the matter of enquiry to be done by the authority
concerned. The fault lies upon the authorities/officers who
are in the helm of the affairs and hence, in order to put a
restrain, it is the right time to pass an order by this Court in
exercise of power conferred under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India.
52. It needs to refer herein that in almost similar circumstances
this Court in the case of The State of Jharkhand & Ors.
2026:JHHC:3184-DB
vs. Kamla Devi & Anr., (L.P.A. No.666 of 2018) has passed
direction upon the authority concerned to fix accountability
upon the erring officials, for ready reference the relevant
pargraph of the said order is being quoted as under:
“43. We, therefore, are of the view that when the Hon’ble Apex
Court has passed an order in the case of Rafiq Masih (Supra)
which binds under Article 141 of the Constitution of India and as
such, there cannot be any recovery if one or the other cases are
falling under the category of paragraph-18 thereof.
44. But the question is that how such occasion has come, if the
authority who are the authority to fix the pay scale or extend the
benefit in the capacity of his competency if will take such decision
in pursuant to the entitlement/decision, as per the policy decision
of the State, then where is the question of making excess payment
to the concerned employee. Therefore, the fault lies upon the
authority who are in the helm of the affairs and hence, in order to
put a restrain, it is the right time to pass an order by this Court in
exercise of power conferred under Article 226 of the Constitution
of India, which we are exercising sitting in intra-court appeal,
since, the intracourt appeal is the furtherance of the proceeding of
Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
45. In view thereof, let accountability be fixed upon the erring
officials in the present case and after conducting due inquiry by
following the due procedure of law, i.e., by following the principle
of natural justice, the required decision be taken for making
recovery from the concerned erring officials.
46. Let this order be communicated to the Chief Secretary, Govt. of
Jharkhand and the Secretary, Department of Finance, Govt. of
Jharkhand.
53. In similar circumstances herein
this Court,
since
is
exercising the power conferred under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India and as such cannot close its eyes in
spending the public money like this and due to the fault
2026:JHHC:3184-DB
committed by the pay-fixation authority, why the state exchequar will suffer.
54. This Court, therefore, is of the view that a further direction
is required to passed upon the Chairman, Railway Board to
conduct enquiry as to for whose fault, the pension
has
wrongly been fixed and after fixing the accountability let the
excess amount paid be recovered from the concerned(s).
55. In view thereof, let accountability be fixed upon the erring
officials in the present case and after conducting due inquiry
by following the due procedure of law, i.e., by following the
principle of natural justice, the required decision be taken
for making recovery from the concerned erring officials.
56. The instant writ petition stands dismissed with the aforesaid
direction and observation.
57. Pending Interlocutory Application, if any, stands disposed.
(Sujit Narayan Prasad, J.)
(Arun Kumar Rai, J.)
4th February, 2026
A.F.R./ Alankar
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review