Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on:22.12.2025
Pronounced on: 16.01.2026
+
W.P.(C) 19448/2025 & CM APPL. 81118/2025
UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
Through:
.....Petitioners
Mr.Piyush Gupta, CGSC.
Versus
PAWAN KUMAR JAIN (EX-CGS)
Through: Nemo.
.....Respondents
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE NAVIN CHAWLA
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE MADHU JAIN
JUDGMENT
MADHU JAIN, J.
1.
The present petition has been filed by the petitioner, challenging
the Order dated 16.07.2025 passed by the learned Central
Administrative Tribunal, Principal Bench, New Delhi (hereinafter
referred to as the ‘Tribunal’) in O.A. No. 2039/2020, titled as Pawan
Kumar Jain v. Union of India & Ors., filed by the respondent herein,
whereby the learned Tribunal has partly allowed the said O.A., with
the following directions:
“8. In view of the same, we disposed of the
present matter by partly allowing the O.A. to
the extent that we direct the respondents that a
refixation order of the pay and pension of the
applicant be passed, taking into account that
the amount to be recovered is for the
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 19448/2025
NEGI
20:02:09
withholding of increments for three years
from19.08.1998 to be confined to the date of
his promotion on 01.03.2002. Subject to the
said adjustment, the refund of the balance
amount is to be made to the applicant out of
the amount already recovered from the
applicant, i.e. Rs. 8,11,083/-. Since the
respondents are at fault, the appropriate
orders for the restoration of pay are
accordingly to be issued and the pay of the
applicant is restored to the basic pay of Rs.
64,100/. The said exercise shall be completed
by the respondents within a period of three
months from the date of receipt of a certified
copy of this order. The O.A. is allowed in the
above terms. Pending M.As, if any, are also
disposed of. No order as to costs.”
FACTS OF THE CASE
2.
In succinct, the background of the case is that the respondent
joined the services of Northern Railway on 03.10.1986 as a Goods
Clerk and was promoted to the post of Sr. Goods Clerk in the pay
grade of Rs.1200-2040 and then as the Head Goods Clerk in the pay
grade of Rs.5000-8000.
3.
While he was serving as a Goods Supervisor, disciplinary
proceedings were initiated against him, in the year 1997–1998 under
the Railway Servants (Discipline and Appeal) Rules, 1968, in relation
to certain lapses in the performance of his official duties.
4.
Upon conclusion of the disciplinary proceedings, the competent
Disciplinary Authority, vide order dated 19.08.1998, imposed a minor
penalty of ‘withholding of increments for a period of three years
without cumulative effect’. The said penalty order was duly
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 19448/2025
NEGI
20:02:09
communicated to the respondent.
5.
It is an undisputed fact that the respondent neither challenged
the penalty order by way of appeal or revision nor questioned its
legality at any point of time. Consequently, the penalty order attained
finality and remained valid and subsisting.
6.
It is the case of the petitioners that due to an administrative
oversight, the said penalty was not implemented in the respondent’s
service records at the relevant time. As a result, the respondent
continued to draw increments in the normal course and was promoted
to the higher pay scale of Rs.5000–8000 with effect from 26.04.1999,
during the subsistence of the penalty period. His pay was fixed at the
minimum of the promotional scale, and further increments were
granted thereafter.
7.
The respondent continued to draw salary and consequential
benefits on the basis of the aforesaid pay fixation throughout the
remainder of his service. He, ultimately, retired from service on
31.05.2020 upon attaining the age of superannuation, while holding
the post of Chief Goods Supervisor.
8.
At the time of processing the respondent’s retirement and
pensionary benefits, a scrutiny of his service records revealed that the
penalty imposed vide Order dated 19.08.1998 had never been
implemented. In order to give effect to the penalty order, which had
already attained finality, the petitioners issued an order dated
20.04.2020, retrospectively implementing the penalty from the due
date. Consequently, upon refixation of the respondent’s pay and
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 19448/2025
NEGI
20:02:09
review of the promotion granted during the penalty period, an excess
payment amounting to Rs. 8,11,083/- was computed and recovered
from his Death-cum-Retirement Gratuity (hereinafter referred to as
‘DCRG’).
9.
Aggrieved by the recovery and the refixation of pay, the
respondent submitted a representation dated 11.08.2020 seeking
refund of the recovered amount and restoration of his pay. The said
representation was rejected on the ground that the recovery had been
effected to enforce a valid disciplinary penalty and to rectify an error
made on the part of the petitioner which had resulted in excess
payment.
10.
Thereafter, the respondent approached the learned Tribunal by
filing the O.A., seeking refund of the recovered amount, restoration of
his basic pay, and consequential revision of pensionary benefits.
11.
The learned Tribunal, vide the Impugned Order, partly allowed
the Original Application, while holding that the penalty order dated
19.08.1998 was valid and had not been challenged by the respondent,
the learned Tribunal directed that the recovery should be confined to
the period of withholding of increments from 19.08.1998 up to the
date of promotion on 01.03.2002. The learned Tribunal further
directed restoration of the respondent’s basic pay to Rs. 64,100/- and
refund of the remaining amount out of Rs.8,11,083/- recovered from
his retirement dues.
12.
Aggrieved of the Impugned Order, the petitioner has filed the
present petition.
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 19448/2025
NEGI
20:02:09
SUBMISSIONS OF THE LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE
PETITIONERS
13.
The learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the learned
Tribunal has gravely erred in partly allowing the O.A., despite
recording a clear and categorical finding that the penalty order dated
19.08.1998, imposing punishment of withholding of increments for
three years without cumulative effect, was valid, subsisting, and had
never been challenged by the respondent at any stage.
14.
The learned counsel further submits that due to an
administrative lapse, the penalty imposed on 19.08.1998 was not
implemented in the respondent’s service records, which resulted in the
respondent being granted promotion to the higher grade of Rs. 5000–
8000 vide Office Letter No. 758E/577/P2 dated 26.04.1999, during the
subsistence of the penalty period. He submits that had the penalty
been implemented in time, the respondent would not have been
eligible for promotion prior to completion of the penalty period, that
is, till 30.08.2002.
15.
He submits that the error came to light in April 2020 while
examining the respondent's service records for processing his
retirement dues. Upon detecting the lapse, the petitioners issued an
Order dated 20.04.2020 implementing the penalty retrospectively from
its original date and revised the respondent's pay accordingly. As a
consequence, an excess payment of Rs. 8,11,083/- was computed and
recovered from the respondent's DCRG. He further submits that the
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 19448/2025
NEGI
20:02:09
penalty was given retrospective implementation vide Office Letter No.
729E/25/2352/P2 dated 20.04.2020, and the respondent's promotion
and pay fixation were accordingly reviewed and the recovery effected
vide the aforesaid Order was not punitive in nature but was a lawful
administrative correction undertaken to prevent unjust enrichment of
the respondent.
16.
Reliance is placed upon the Judgment of this Court in Bank of
Baroda v. Gurdev Singh Minhas, 2025:DHC:1979-DB, to submit that
the employee cannot insist upon continuance of pension on an
incorrect or inflated figure. He submits that this Court has emphasized
that, at the very least, the pension must be paid prospectively in
accordance with the revised Pension Payment Order which reflects the
correct entitlement.
ANALYSIS AND FINDINGS
17.
We have considered the submissions advanced by the learned
counsel for the petitioners and have perused the material on record.
18.
None has appeared on behalf of the respondents.
19.
From the above, the issue that arises for consideration is
whether recovery of Rs. 8,11,083/- from the respondent’s retiral dues
at the time of his superannuation, after an inordinate delay, on account
of administrative lapse in implementing a valid penalty, is legally
sustainable when the respondent is not at fault.
20.
Upon perusal of the record, it is evident that the respondent was
imposed a minor penalty of withholding of increments for three years
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 19448/2025
NEGI
20:02:09
without cumulative effect vide order dated 19.08.1998, which
admittedly attained finality, as it was never challenged. It is also
undisputed that the said penalty order was not implemented by the
Department for a prolonged period due to an administrative lapse,
with no fault of the respondent. Consequently, the respondent
continued to draw increments, was promoted in due course, and his
pay was fixed accordingly.
21.
The failure to give effect to the penalty order at the relevant
time was entirely on account of the department’s omission. The
recovery of Rs. 8,11,083/- was effected only at the stage of retirement,
that is upon the respondent’s superannuation on 31.05.2020, when he
was drawing pay as fixed by the employer itself. The said recovery
was given a retrospective effect after a lapse of more than 20 years
from the date of imposition of penalty.
22.
The question as to whether the employer can, after such an
inordinate delay and at the stage of superannuation, recover the
alleged excess amount from retiral dues, is no longer res integra. The
Supreme Court in State of Punjab & Ors. v. Rafiq Masih (White
Washer) & Ors., (2015) 4 SCC 334, has laid down clear
circumstances where recovery of excess or wrongful payments would
be impermissible in law. The relevant portion is extracted as under:
“18. It is not possible to postulate all
situations of hardship, which would govern
employees on the issue of recovery, where
payments have mistakenly been made by the
employer, in excess of their entitlement. Be
that as it may, based on the decisions referred
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 19448/2025
NEGI
20:02:09
to herein above, we may, as a ready reference,
summarise the following few situations,
wherein recoveries by the employers, would be
impermissible in law:
(i) Recovery from employees belonging to
Class-III and Class-IV service (or Group 'C'
and Group 'D' service).
(ii) Recovery from retired employees, or
employees who are due to retire within one
year, of the order of recovery.
(iii) Recovery from employees, when the
excess payment has been made for a period in
excess of five years, before the order of
recovery is issued.
(iv) Recovery in cases where an employee has
wrongfully been required to discharge duties
of a higher post, and has been paid
accordingly, even though he should have
rightfully been required to work against an
inferior post.
(v) In any other case, where the Court arrives
at the conclusion, that recovery if made from
the employee, would be iniquitous or harsh or
arbitrary to such an extent, as would far
outweigh the equitable balance of the
employer's right to recover.
23.
The present case squarely falls within more than one of the
aforesaid categories. The submission of the petitioners that recovery
was merely a “lawful administrative correction” cannot override the
equitable limitations imposed by the Supreme Court in Rafiq Masih
(supra)
24.
So far as reliance of the learned counsel for the petitioners on
the judgment of Gurdev Singh Minhas (supra) is concerned, we do
not find merit in the said submission. The facts in the said case were
materially distinct, inasmuch as the issue concerned erroneous fixation
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 19448/2025
NEGI
20:02:09
of pension, which was subsequently corrected by issuance of a revised
Pension Payment Order. In the present case, recovery was sought
from Death-cum-Retirement Gratuity at the time of superannuation by
retrospectively reopening pay and promotion matters spanning over
two decades, solely on account of a departmental lapse in
implementing a penalty.
CONCLUSION
25.
In view of the settled legal position laid down in Rafiq Masih
(supra), the present writ petition, being bereft of merit, is dismissed.
The Impugned Order of the learned Tribunal is upheld.
26.
The pending applications, if any, are disposed as being
infructuous.
27.
There shall be no orders as to costs.
MADHU JAIN, J
NAVIN CHAWLA, J.
JANUARY 16, 2026/Av/as
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 19448/2025
NEGI
20:02:09
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review