Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 01.12.2025
Pronounced on:07.01.2026
+
W.P.(C) 16919/2025 & CM APPL. 69554/2025, CM APPL.
No.69555/2025
UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
….Petitioners
Through: Mr. Shashank Dixit, CGSC with
Mr. Kunal Raj, Adv.
versus
OM PRAKASH VERMA SSF CT. NO. 1432
....Respondent
Through:
None.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE NAVIN CHAWLA
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE MADHU JAIN
JUDGMENT
MADHU JAIN, J.
1.
This petition has been filed, challenging the Order dated
06.01.2025 passed by the learned Central Administrative Tribunal,
Principal Bench, New Delhi (hereinafter referred to as the ‘Tribunal’)
in O.A. No. 1059/2021, titled as Om Prakash Verma v. Union of
India & Ors., whereby the learned Tribunal allowed the said O.A.
filed by the respondent herein, observing as under:
“12. From the aforesaid, it is apparent that
though the Inquiry Officer has taken on record
all the documents listed as documents in
support of the allegations against the
applicant and reflected under the Annexure
(iii) of the memorandum dated 01.08.2018,
however, none of the documents have been
proved by the respondents before the Inquiry
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 16919/2025
NEGI
18:50:35
Officer. It is also apparent that the Charged
Officer was required to submit his defence
brief before the Inquiry Officer more than a
month before the Presenting Officer has
submitted the brief in support of the
allegations. The same is found to be in
violation of the provisions of Rule 14(19). It is
further observed that in the case in hand, in
place of respondents to prove the allegations,
the applicant was required to prove his
innocence which is also against the provisions
of Rule 14 and settled law on the subject.
13. In his Inquiry Report, under reference, the
Inquiry Officer has nowhere analyzed the
prosecution witness and/or the defence
evidence and merely after recording all the
developments of the 4 hearings and statement
of defence of the applicant, he has concluded
that the Charged Officer was found guilty of
the allegations. The same is in violation of
Rule 14 (23).
xxxx
16. In view of the aforesaid facts and
circumstances, the inquiry report and the
subsequent impugned appellate orders passed
by the respondents are found to be vitiated and
the same are accordingly set aside. The
applicant shall be entitled for consequential
benefits, in accordance with law. The
respondents shall comply with the aforesaid
directions, as expeditiously as possible, and
preferably within 8 weeks of receipt of a copy
of this order. However, the respondents shall
be at liberty to proceed against the applicant,
of course, in accordance with law, if they so
decide.”
FACTS OF THE CASE
2.
In a nutshell, the background of the case is that the respondent
was appointed as a Sepoy in the Secretariat Security Force (‘SSF’)
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 16919/2025
NEGI
18:50:35
under the Ministry of Home Affairs (‘MHA’) on 14.05.1984. He
continued to serve in the SSF cadre until his deputation to the
Reception Organisation (RO), Secretariat Security Organisation
(‘SSO’), under the MHA.
3.
Pursuant to an order dated 11.04.2013, the respondent was
taken on deputation to the post of Junior Reception Officer (‘JRO’),
for a tenure of three years from 05.04.2013 to 04.04.2016. His
deputation was thereafter extended twice, first up to 04.04.2017 and
again up to 04.04.2018, vide orders dated 04.04.2016 and 13.04.2017,
respectively.
4.
Before the expiry of the extended tenure, the respondent sought
a further extension of his deputation tenure for one additional year,
that is, from 05.04.2018 to 04.04.2019. For seeking such extension, he
placed reliance on the DoP&T O.M. F.No.2/6/2016-Estt. (Pay-II)
dated 17.02.2016, which permits the borrowing organisation to retain
an officer up to a maximum deputation period of seven years, in cases
of public interest. However, the competent authority declined his
request for extension on the ground that the SSF was experiencing an
acute manpower shortage and required the respondent’s services.
Consequently, by Office Order dated 10.04.2018, the respondent was
relieved from the post of JRO with effect from the date of the order
and was directed to report to the SSO-II Section.
5.
It is the case of the petitioners that the respondent did not report
to the SSO-II Section on 11.04.2018, as directed and the first
intimation regarding his alleged illness was received by the petitioners
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 16919/2025
NEGI
18:50:35
only on 26.04.2018, unaccompanied by any contemporaneous medical
certificate explaining the nature of his ailment. Thereafter, the
respondent furnished multiple medical prescriptions from different
private practitioners and hospitals, covering the intermittent dates
between 11.04.2018 and 03.05.2018, all of which were submitted
belatedly on 08.05.2018, in response to the Memorandum dated
04.05.2018, directing him to report for duty. Further, the respondent
marked his biometric attendance between 04.05.2018 and 15.05.2018,
without reporting to the SSO-II Section. He again remained absent
without a sanctioned leave on 21.05.2018, 22.05.2018, and
01.06.2018, and continued to send sporadic intimations of illness
without
accompanying
medical
documentation.
Subsequent
prescriptions were submitted by him from Dr. Baba Saheb Ambedkar
Hospital and a CGHS dispensary only on 25.05.2018, in reply to the
Memorandum dated 21.05.2018, directing him to report as Constable
in SSF. The respondent eventually reported for duty on 04.06.2018,
however, even then, he failed to submit any fitness certificate.
6.
In view of the respondent’s unauthorised and wilful absence,
the Disciplinary Authority issued a Memorandum dated 08.08.2018,
initiating disciplinary proceedings against him under Rule 14 of the
Central Civil Services (Classification, Control & Appeal) Rules, 1965
[hereinafter referred to as ‘CCS (CCA) Rules’]. The Article of
Charges framed against the respondent is as under:
“ARTICLE 1
xxxx
2. That Shri Om Prakash, Constable No.1432
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 16919/2025
NEGI
18:50:35
instead of reporting for duties in SSO-II
Section, sent his joining report as “Junior
Reception Officer” through Central Registry
Section on 04/05/2018. Shri Om Prakash,
No.1432 physically reported for duty as
constable on 04/06/2018(FN).
3. That No.1432 Constable Om Prakash, was
absent from duties w.e.f. 11/04/2018 without
any intimation. He only sent communication
about his illness which was received on
26/04/2018. He had neither sent any
prescription or medical certificate to the
department nor informed about his kind of
illness. He only sent prescription from CGHS,
Pitampura prescribing rest for three days
w.e.f. 11/04/2018 and thereafter three medical
certificates from three different Private
Practitioners prescribing rest from 14/04/2018
to 15/04/2018, 16/04/2018 to 20/04/2018 and
21/04/2018 to 03/05/2018, respectively. These
prescription/Medical certificates were only
submitted on 08/05/2018 as an afterthought in
reply to Memorandum issued to him vide No.
Constable/1432/84/SSO-11 dated 04/05/2018.
He marked his biometric attendance without
physically reporting to SSO Section during
04/05/2018 to 15/05/2018. In a similar
fashion, he again intimated about his illness
on 15/05/2018 without informing his kind of
illness. He sent another intimation about his
illness on 23/05/2018 without informing his
kind of illness and without attaching any
prescription or medical certificate. He only
sent two prescriptions from Dr. Baba Saheb
Ambedkar Hospital, Rohini prescribing rest
from 16/05/2018 to 17/05/2018 and
18/05/2018 to 20/05/2018 respectively and a
prescription
from
CGHS,
Pitampura
prescribing rest for three days w.e.f.
25/05/2018 vide his letter dated 25/05/2018 in
reply to Memorandum Issued to him vide No.
Constable/1432/84/550-II dated 21/05/2018.
He further sent another Medical Certificate
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 16919/2025
NEGI
18:50:35
from a Private Practitioner prescribing rest
from 28/05/2018 to 31/05/2018. The Medical
Certificate was submitted alongwith his
joining report on 04/06/2018 but without any
fitness certificate. He has absented himself
wilfully and unauthorisedly on 21/05/2018,
22/05/2018 and 01/06/2018 without any
justifiable reasons and without any proper
sanction of leave. His above acts shows that it
is a deliberate attempt by him to remain absent
from duties. He kept on sent Medical changing
the Medical Practitioners/Hospitals and
belatedly sent Certificates/Prescriptions from
various sources with a sole motive to divert the
attention of authorities from taking action
against him.”
7.
On denial of charges by the respondent, inquiry proceedings
were conducted in four regular hearings, held on 26.02.2019,
28.02.2019, 07.03.2019, and 27.03.2019. Evidence of the prosecution
witness was recorded, listed documents were taken on file, and the
respondent was afforded an opportunity to submit a defence
statement.
8.
The Inquiry Officer, on the basis of documentary and oral
evidence adduced before him, vide his report dated 10.05.2019, held
the charges levelled against the respondent to be proved, on reaching
the finding that the respondent had absented himself from duty on
21.05.2018, 22.05.2018 and 01.06.2018, without any proper sanction
of leave and had also marked his biometric attendance during
04.05.2018 to 15.05.2018, without actually reporting to the concerned
authority in the SSO-II Section.
9.
Accordingly, the Disciplinary Authority, upon consideration of
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 16919/2025
NEGI
18:50:35
the inquiry record, vide order dated 19.06.2019, imposed a major
penalty of “reduction to two (2) lower stages in the time-scale of pay
till retirement on 31.12.2019 with cumulative effect and during the
penalty period he will not earn any increments of pay”, as envisaged
under Rule 11 (v) of the CCS (CCA) Rules.
10.
The Appellate Authority, by order dated 26.09.2019 upheld the
penalty and rejected the respondent’s appeal against the penalty order.
11.
A further Review Petition submitted by the respondent under
Rule 29-A of the CCS (CCA) Rules was also rejected by the
competent authority vide order dated 29.07.2020.
12.
The respondent thereafter approached the learned Tribunal by
filing the above O.A., challenging the Charge Memorandum, the
Inquiry Report, the penalty order, the order passed by the Appellate
Authority and the review order, on the ground that the inquiry was not
conducted in a just and fair manner.
13.
The learned Tribunal, by its Impugned Order dated 06.01.2025,
held the actions of the Inquiry Officer to be in violation of Rule 14 of
the CCS (CCA) Rules and allowed the said O.A. with the abovequoted directions.
14.
Aggrieved thereby, the petitioners have filed the present Writ
Petition.
15.
None appeared on behalf of the respondent when the matter was
taken up for hearing. In the absence of any representation, the
respondent was proceeded ex parte and the matter is considered on the
basis of the pleadings on record, the submissions advanced by the
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 16919/2025
NEGI
18:50:35
petitioners and the material available before this Court.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE PETITIONERS
16.
The learned counsel for the petitioners submits that the
respondent was sent on deputation as a Junior Reception Officer
(JRO) for the prescribed tenure of three years from 05.04.2013, which
was extended twice, up to 04.04.2018 and his request for further
extension of deputation was legitimately declined. He submits that the
governing
DoP&T
instructions,
particularly the
O.M.
dated
17.02.2016, stipulate that deputation beyond five years is permissible
only in exceptional circumstances and only when compelling
administrative necessity exists. However, owing to acute manpower
shortage in the respondent’s parent cadre, that is, SSF, no justification
existed for continuation of his deputation beyond the permissible
tenure. Consequently, the Competent Authority declined extension of
his tenure and relieved him from the deputation post with effect from
10.04.2018. The learned counsel further submits that deputation is not
a vested right and does not entitle continuation beyond the approved
tenure.
17.
The learned counsel further submits that upon being relieved
from the borrowing organization, the respondent was required to
report to SSO on 11.04.2018 and rejoin duty as Constable. However,
he failed to do so and remained wilfully absent from duty, without
sanctioned leave. His first communication asserting illness was
received only on 26.04.2018 and was unaccompanied by any medical
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 16919/2025
NEGI
18:50:35
certificate or prescription. He further submits that the respondent
thereafter furnished multiple medical certificates from different
private
practitioners
only belatedly on
08.05.2018,
after a
Memorandum was issued against him. The learned counsel submits
that these documents were inconsistent, lacked continuity, did not
cover the entire period of alleged illness, and were insufficient to
justify his prolonged absence. Despite the Memorandum dated
04.05.2018 and Order dated 09.05.2018, directing the respondent to
join duty as a Constable in SSF immediately on repatriation from the
post of JRO, he failed to comply.
18.
He further submits that between 04.05.2018 and 15.05.2018,
the respondent marked biometric attendance at the office gate but did
not report to the SSO Section or his Reporting Officer. Marking of
biometric
attendance
without
assuming
duty
amounts
to
misrepresentation and was an attempt to create a misleading record of
presence. The respondent again remained absent without sanctioned
leave on 21.05.2018, 22.05.2018, and 01.06.2018, and even the
intimations sent by him were vague, unsupported by medical evidence
and failed to disclose the nature of his ailment.
19.
He further submits that, in these circumstances, disciplinary
proceedings were initiated under Rule 14 of the CCS (CCA) Rules,
1965. The Article of Charge alleged failure to comply with lawful
directions upon repatriation, misuse of biometric attendance,
unauthorized absence on multiple dates and conduct unbecoming of a
government servant under Rule 3(1)(iii) of the CCS (Conduct) Rules,
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 16919/2025
NEGI
18:50:35
1964. The inquiry was conducted in strict adherence to the statutory
procedure. The respondent was afforded full opportunity to inspect
documents, cross-examine departmental witnesses and lead defence
evidence. After a comprehensive review of the material on record, the
Inquiry Officer held the charges to be proved. The findings were
reasoned and based on documentary evidence, including attendance
records, memoranda and the respondent’s own communications.
20.
He further submits that the Disciplinary Authority, upon
independent consideration of the inquiry report and the respondent’s
representation, imposed the penalty of reduction of two lower stages
in the time-scale of pay till retirement with cumulative effect. The
Appellate and Revisional Authorities upon examining the matter,
upheld the penalty. He contends that the penalty is proportionate to
the gravity of the misconduct established on record.
21.
He further submits that the respondent’s conduct namely,
refusal to join duties after repatriation, continued unauthorized
absence, misuse of biometric attendance and failure to furnish credible
medical justification constitutes serious indiscipline, particularly in a
security sensitive organisation. Administrative discipline and public
interest require a firm action against the respondent.
22.
He further submits that, in view of the above, the
administrative decisions culminating in the imposition of a major
penalty warrant affirmation as they are neither arbitrary nor
disproportionate. He submits that the orders are also fully supported
by the evidentiary record and the applicable rules, therefore, the
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 16919/2025
NEGI
18:50:35
tribunal erred in setting them aside.
ANALYSIS AND FINDINGS
23.
We have considered the submissions advanced by the learned
counsel for the petitioner and perused the material on record.
24.
At the outset, it is not in dispute that the respondent was taken
on deputation as a JRO for a fixed tenure, which stood extended from
time to time up to 04.04.2018. It is equally undisputed that deputation
beyond the said period was declined by the competent authority and
the respondent was relieved from the borrowing organisation by the
Office Order dated 10.04.2018, directing him to report back to his
parent cadre.
25.
The central issue that arises for consideration is whether the
disciplinary proceedings initiated against the respondent and the
consequential penalty imposed upon him suffer from such procedural
infirmity, or non-consideration of relevant material, that would render
the action of imposing a major penalty unsustainable in law and
warrant interference by this Court in exercise of its writ jurisdiction
under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
26.
The disciplinary proceedings in the present case were assailed
primarily on the grounds of procedural infirmity in the conduct of the
inquiry, non-compliance with the statutory safeguards under Rule 14
of the CCS (CCA) Rules and unanalysed prosecution witness and/or
the defence evidence. The sustainability of the impugned disciplinary
action, therefore, has to be examined on these parameters.
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 16919/2025
NEGI
18:50:35
27.
One of the material aspects emerging from the inquiry record
relates to the manner in which the departmental inquiry was
conducted. The proceedings reveal that on multiple dates of hearing,
including at crucial stages, the Presenting Officer was not present and
the inquiry, nonetheless, proceeded. Though the CCS (CCA) Rules do
not expressly mandate the presence of the Presenting Officer at every
sitting, the Presenting Officer plays a vital role in presenting the
departmental case and in assisting the Inquiry Officer in marshalling
evidence. Conducting substantive stages of the inquiry in his absence,
without recording reasons or adopting adequate safeguards has a
bearing on the fairness of the inquiry process.
28.
The inquiry proceedings also required compliance with Rule
14(18) of the CCS (CCA) Rules, which reads as under:
“(18) The inquiring authority may, after the
Government servant closes his case, and shall,
if the Government servant has not examined
himself, generally question him on the
circumstances appearing against him in the
evidence for the purpose of enabling the
Government servant to explain any
circumstances appearing in the evidence
against him.”
29.
A scrutiny of the inquiry record shows that while the respondent
was examined, the questioning does not reflect that the incriminating
circumstances forming the basis of the charges, particularly relating to
unauthorised absence, medical documents and marking of biometric
attendance were specifically put to him in the manner contemplated
under the said rule. This requirement is not a mere formality but a
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 16919/2025
NEGI
18:50:35
substantive safeguard intended to afford the charged officer a
meaningful opportunity to explain adverse material. It is also pertinent
to note here that the respondent was required to submit his defence
brief more than a month before the Presenting Officer submitted the
brief in support of allegations levelled.
30.
A perusal of the inquiry record also indicates that while the
medical documents submitted by the respondent formed part of the
record, the finding of guilt was recorded without a reasoned
consideration of the said defence. Non-consideration or inadequate
consideration of relevant defence material, particularly when such
material directly bears upon the nature of the alleged misconduct,
vitiates the decision-making process in a disciplinary inquiry. As
noted by the learned Tribunal, the Inquiry Officer has also nowhere
analysed the prosecution witness and/or the defence evidence and has
held the respondent guilty merely after recording the developments of
the four hearings conducted.
31.
Equally significant is the requirement under Rule 14(23) of the
CCS (CCA) Rules, which reads as under:
“(23) (i) After the conclusion of the inquiry, a
report shall be prepared and it shall contain(a) the articles of charge and the statement of
the
imputations
of
misconduct
or
misbehaviour;
(b) the defence of the Government servant in
respect of each article of charge;
(c) an assessment of the evidence in respect of
each article of charge;
(d) the findings on each article of charge and
the reasons therefor.
EXPLANATION- If in the opinion of the
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 16919/2025
NEGI
18:50:35
inquiring authority the proceedings of the
inquiry establish any article of charge
different from the original articles of the
charge, it may record its findings on such
article of charge:
Provided that the findings on such article of
charge shall not be recorded unless the
Government servant has either admitted the
facts on which such article of charge is based
or has had a reasonable opportunity of
defending himself against such article of
charge.
(ii) The inquiring authority, where it is not
itself the disciplinary authority, shall forward
to the disciplinary authority the records of
inquiry which shall include :(a) the report prepared by it under clause (i);
(b) the written statement of defence, if any,
submitted by the Government servant;
(c) the oral and documentary evidence
produced in the course of the inquiry;
(d) written briefs, if any, filed by the
Presenting Officer or the Government servant
or both during the course of the inquiry; and
(e) the orders, if any, made by the disciplinary
authority and the inquiring authority in regard
to the inquiry.”
32.
The penalty order, also does not disclose any reasoned
consideration of the respondent’s defence, particularly his explanation
relating to illness and the medical material placed on record. Mere
concurrence with the findings of the Inquiry Officer, without dealing
with the defence raised, does not satisfy the mandate of Rule 14(23) of
the CCS (CCA) Rules.
33.
The charge relating to marking of biometric attendance without
assuming duty also require independent consideration. The inquiry
record does not reflect a clear and reasoned determination as to
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 16919/2025
NEGI
18:50:35
whether such conduct, in the factual context pleaded, amounted to
deliberate misrepresentation or was integrally connected with the
respondent’s explanation regarding illness and absence. The absence
of such analysis weakens the foundation of the charge.
34.
We place our reliance on the Judgment of the Supreme Court in
State of Uttar Pradesh & Ors. v. Saroj Kumar Sinha, (2010) 2 SCC
772, wherein the court observed as under:
“28. An inquiry officer acting in a quasijudicial authority is in the position of an
independent adjudicator. He is not supposed
to be a representative of the department/
disciplinary
authority/Government.
His
function is to examine the evidence presented
by the Department, even in the absence of the
delinquent official to see as to whether the
unrebutted evidence is sufficient to hold that
the charges are proved. In the present case the
aforesaid procedure has not been observed.
Since no oral evidence has been examined the
documents have not been proved, and could
not have been taken into consideration to
conclude that the charges have been proved
against the respondents.
29. Apart from the above, by virtue of Article
311(2) of the Constitution of India the
departmental enquiry had to be conducted in
accordance with the rules of natural justice. It
is a basic requirement of the rules of natural
justice that an employee be given a reasonable
opportunity of being heard in any proceedings
which may culminate in punishment being
imposed on the employee.
30. When a departmental enquiry is
conducted against the government servant it
cannot be treated as a casual exercise. The
enquiry proceedings also cannot be
conducted with a closed mind. The inquiry
officer has to be wholly unbiased. The rules of
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 16919/2025
NEGI
18:50:35
natural justice are required to be observed to
ensure not only that justice is done but is
manifestly seen to be done. The object of rules
of natural justice is to ensure that a
government servant is treated fairly in
proceedings which may culminate in
imposition
of
punishment
including
dismissal/removal from service.”
(emphasis supplied)
35.
We further place our reliance on the Judgment of the Supreme
Court in Roop Singh Negi v. Punjab National Bank & Ors., (2009) 2
SCC 570, wherein it was held as under:
“14. Indisputably, a departmental proceeding
is a quasi-judicial proceeding. The enquiry
officer performs a quasi-judicial function. The
charges levelled against the delinquent officer
must be found to have been proved. The
enquiry officer has a duty to arrive at a finding
upon taking into consideration the materials
brought on record by the parties. The
purported
evidence
collected
during
investigation by the investigating officer
against all the accused by itself could not be
treated to be evidence in the disciplinary
proceeding. No witness was examined to prove
the said documents. The management
witnesses merely tendered the documents and
did not prove the contents thereof. Reliance,
inter alia, was placed by the enquiry officer on
the FIR which could not have been treated as
evidence.”
36.
It is well settled that the scope of interference under Article 226
of the Constitution is limited and does not extend to re-appreciation of
evidence or substitution of the Court’s view for that of the disciplinary
authority. However, where the decision-making process is vitiated by
non-compliance with mandatory procedural requirements, denial or
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 16919/2025
NEGI
18:50:35
non-consideration of relevant defence material, judicial review is
permissible to ensure fairness, proportionality and legality in
administrative action.
CONCLUSION
37.
In view of the foregoing discussion, this Court is also of the
considered opinion that the disciplinary proceedings initiated against
the respondent suffer from material procedural infirmities, including
non-compliance of the mandatory safeguards under Rule 14 of the
CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965, inadequate consideration of the defence put
forth by the respondent and the absence of a reasoned evaluation of
relevant material bearing upon the charges.
38.
As a necessary consequence of the above findings, the inquiry
report dated 10.05.2019 and the subsequent penalty, appellate and
review orders passed by the respondents stood vitiated and were
rightly set aside by the learned Tribunal.
39.
We, therefore, find no infirmity or illegality in the Impugned
Order passed by the learned Tribunal.
40.
Accordingly, the Impugned Order passed by the learned
Tribunal is upheld and the petition is accordingly dismissed.
41.
The petitioners shall grant all consequential benefits to the
respondent in terms of the Impugned Order and complete the
aforesaid exercise within a period of 8 weeks from the date of this
judgment.
42.
The pending applications also stand disposed of.
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 16919/2025
NEGI
18:50:35
43.
There shall be no order as to costs.
MADHU JAIN, J.
NAVIN CHAWLA, J.
JANUARY 07, 2026/k
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 16919/2025
NEGI
18:50:35
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review