Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 8 July 2026
Pronounced on: 24 September 2026
#
CNR No. DLHC010775422025
+
W.P.(C) 15273/2025, CM APPLs. 62572/2025 & 5747/2026
UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
.....Petitioners
Through: Mr. Syed Abdul Haseeb, CGSC
with Mr. Muhammad Aamir Khan,
Advocate
versus
HIMANSHI & 34 ORS.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. K.C. Mittal with Mr.
Yugansh Mittal, Mr. Pulkit Jain and Mr.
Keshav Poonia, Advs.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE C. HARI SHANKAR
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VINOD KUMAR
JUDGMENT (ORAL)
24.09.2026
%
C. HARI SHANKAR, J.
S. No.
1.
2.
3.
4.
A.
B.
C.
C.I
5.
C.II
6.
D.
Subject
Para Nos
A Prefatory Note
1 - 11
Facts
12 - 25
Rival Stands of Learned Counsel
26 - 38
Submissions of Mr. Haseeb, on behalf of
26 - 31
the SSC
Submissions of Mr. K.C. Mittal for the
32 - 38
Respondent
Analysis
39 - 82
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
7.
8.
9.
D.I
D.II
39 - 42
43 – 48.7
44 – 44.8
13.
14. D.III
15.
The Issue before us
The law
Board of High School and Intermediate
Education, UP v. Bagleshwar Prasad
Bihar School Education Board v.
Subhas Chandra Sinha
Ghazanfar Rashid v. Board of High
School and Intermediate Education
Maharashtra State Board of Secondary
and Higher Secondary Education v.
K.S. Gandhi
University of Delhi v. Deepak
Applying the law to the facts
A major discrepancy
16. E.
Conclusion
84 - 87
10.
11.
12.
45 – 45.6
46– 46.5
47 – 47.6
48 – 48.7
49 - 59
61 - 83
A.
A Prefatory Note
1.
We are painfully aware that we are treading, here, on
quicksand.
2.
The candidature of Himanshi, who appeared in a Combined all-
India Examination conducted by the Staff Selection Commission1,
was cancelled, and she was debarred from participating in any
selection by the SSC for 7 years, on the ground that she had resorted
to unfair means in the examination, following the report of a
Committee which had been constituted for the purpose.
She
approached the Central Administrative Tribunal2, which has allowed
her Original Application and set aside the action taken against her.
The SSC is before us in challenge.
1 “SSC” hereinafter
2 “the Tribunal” hereinafter
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
3.
We are conscious of the fact that the preponderance of judicial
thought, in such cases, advises restraint and circumspection, on the
part of the Court, in interfering with the opinions of duly constituted
Committees. Courts are not empowered to sit in appeal over their
decisions.
4.
Judicial review, even in such cases, is, however, not
irremediably foreclosed. There is a rarefied stratosphere of cases in
which, even with the greatest degree of circumspection, it is not
possible to sustain the decision of the Committee, or the consequent
action taken against the candidate.
5.
This case, to our mind, resides in that rarefied stratosphere.
6.
We are convinced that, in such cases, a “one size fits all”
approach would be grossly misdirected. In a case where candidates at
a particular examination centre are suspected to have indulged in
malpractice or unfair means, the authorities have, with them, two
options. One would be to subject all candidates in that centre to a
fresh examination. This approach would usually be adopted where the
use of unfair means is widespread, and it is not possible to reasonably
identify all candidates who are involved. The approach of the Court,
in such a case, would be qualitatively different, always keeping in
mind the necessity to maintain purity in the examination process.
7.
The second option with the authorities – which is what has been
adopted in the present case – is, however, to cancel the candidature of,
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
and penalize, select candidates who, according to the authorities, have
been identified as those who alone have employed unfair means. In
such a case, the onus on the authorities, and the task on the Court,
becomes more onerous.
As we have already observed, a “one size
fits all” approach, in such a case, would be totally contrary to law.
The authorities would have to establish, in respect of each of the
allegedly delinquent candidates, that she, or he, employed unfair
means. The Court, too, would have to examine, in the case of each
candidate, whether the view of the Committee, and the consequent
action taken against the candidate, is justified.
8.
Tested on this touchstone, we are unable to sustain the decision
of the Committee, in the present case, that Himanshi resorted to unfair
means. The various indicia, which are identified in the report of the
Committee itself, as determinative in this regard, are not satisfied in
the case of Himanshi.
9.
The most important reason for us to hold in favour of Himanshi,
in the present case, is the affidavit in rejoinder filed by the SSC in the
present proceedings. The allegation, against all debarred candidates,
including Himanshi, was that they were shifted to terminals other than
those allotted to them, which were compromised and that, by
attempting the rest of the Tier I examination through such
compromised terminals, they performed outstandingly. A comparison
of the terminals to which Himanshi was shifted, which are identified
in the rejoinder affidavit filed by the SSC, with the list of
compromised terminals annexed as Annexure 5 to the Report of the
Scrutiny Committee which examined the issue, however, indicates
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
that the terminals to which Himanshi was shifted were not among the
list of compromised terminals.
Apart from various other reasons
which discredit the allegation of unfair means having been employed
by Himanshi, this single factor, by itself, demolishes the allegation
that Himanshi employed unfair means.
10.
It is inter alia for this reason that we are inclined, in the present
case, to extend, to Himanshi, the benefit of doubt.
11.
With these prefatory observations, we proceed to the facts.
B.
Facts
12.
The judgment dated 14 February 2025, passed by the Tribunal
and under challenge in the present writ petition at the instance of the
SSC, adjudicates a batch of Original Applications3, though it adverts
only to the facts of OA 2953/20224. Writ petitions have been preferred
by the SSC against the impugned judgment insofar as it adjudicates all
the OAs. Mr. Syed Abdul Haseeb, learned CGSC appearing for the
SSC, inter alia contends that the Tribunal could not have extrapolated
the decision in OA 2953/2022 to all other OAs, as the facts in each
case are distinct and different.
13.
The present writ petition, as filed, challenged the impugned
judgment of the Tribunal in so far as it adjudicated as many as 34
OAs, with the applicants in the OAs having been impleaded as
respondents in the writ petition. However, by the very first order
3 "OAs" hereinafter
4 Himanshi v. Staff Selection Commission & others
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
passed by this Court in the present writ petition on 6 October 2025, it
was clarified that the writ petition would be treated as a challenge only
to the impugned order dated 14 February 2025 passed by the Tribunal
in so far as it adjudicated OA 2953/2022, filed by Himanshi.
14.
This judgment, too, therefore, adjudicates the writ petition
referred by the SSC against the impugned judgment in so far as it
decides OA 2953/2022. We would also, therefore, be referring to the
facts pertinent to the said OA, i.e., to the case of Himanshi.
15.
The dispute pertains to the Combined Higher Secondary Level
(10+2) Examination 2019, conducted by the SSC for recruitment to
the post of Lower Division Clerk, Junior Secretariat Assistant, Postal
Assistant, Sorting Assistant and Data Entry Operator. The selection
comprised three stages/tiers. Tier I was a Computer Based
Examination, Tier II was a Descriptive Data and Tier III was a Skill
Test/Typing Test, which was qualifying in nature. Himanshi was a
candidate belonging to Other Backward Classes. She underwent the
Tier I examination at Avirat Education Society5, Shivalik Nagar,
Haridwar, and scored 199.21 normalised marks out of 200, which was
above the prescribed cut off for OBC candidates. She thereafter
participated in Tier II and Tier III and was declared successful. She
was called for document verification scheduled on 22 March 2022,
which, too, she attended.
16.
The final result of the selection was declared by the SSC on 10
May 2022. The results of 104 candidates, including Himanshi’s, were
5 "Avirat" hereinafter
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
withheld, on the ground that they were alleged to have used unfair
means.
17.
A Committee was constituted by the SSC to enquire into the
suspected malpractices adopted by the candidates, primarily by “demapping”, i.e., by attempting the Tier I examination from a terminal
other than the terminal allotted to them, with the later terminal being
allegedly compromised. The report of the Committee, to the extent it
is relevant for the case of Himanshi, may be reproduced as under:
“Report of the Committee constituted to examine the CCTV
footages and Log trial details of the candidates of CHSL
EXAMINATION 2019, whose result has been withheld wrt 90
Candidates.
A Committee has been constituted by Staff Selection
Commission vide Order No.F.No.01/10/2021/C-II (Part-II) dated
17.05.2021 with RD (SR), RD (CR) & DS (Conf.). The mandate of
the committee is to examine the CCTV footages and log trails of
the 90 candidates of CHSLE2019, whose result has been kept
withheld.
2.
The Committee Members held two meetings in Delhi on
23.05.2022 and sought he required log sheets, data etc from the
Service Provider. The same were furnished by 9.6.2022.
3.
After the relevant data points were arranged, the Committee
started to examine the available material. The log files supplied,
required
further processing to
mark
relevant
data
points/information to examine the matter. The performance of the
candidate was superimposed on the logs. The committee through
SQL queries and software program culled out the date of exam,
shift, time stamp, time differential etc., and through software
program identified the actual "Attempts" and "Views" of the
questions by the candidates. Through the program, the number of
attempts made against specific questions were also identified. The
time taken from attempting the first question till the last question
of the overall question paper as well as subjects within the paper
were also extracted.
4.
The committee considered the following factors while
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
examining the logs.
(i)
Score of the candidate
(ii)
Attempts made by the candidate against each
section (subject) viz., General knowledge (GK), Numerical
Ability (NA), Reasoning (RE) and Computer Fundamentals
(CO).
(iii)
The number of correct and incorrect replies.
(iv)
The difficulty level of the questions (difficulty level
was determined based on the number of candidates who
could answer the question correctly)
(v)
The time taken by the candidate to answer the
questions.
(vi)
The time spent by the candidate not attempting
questions (idle time)
(vii) The sequence of answering the questions
(viii) The pattern of correcting the questions answered
incorrectly, on the later occasion through reattempts
(ix)
The pattern of answering the questions in quick
succession/ explosive rate
(x)
Duration taken from the first attempt till the last
attempt
(xi)
The number of candidates appearing in the same
shift from the same venue out of 90 candidates and the
number of questions answered correctly/incorrectly by
these candidates
(xii) The time of demapping as recorded in the logs
(xiii) IP address and MAC id used by the candidate
before and after demapping
5.
Further, CCTV footages of few venues were examined to
observe any abnormalities/ suspicious activity, vis a vis, the
withheld candidates and the findings of the same have been
recorded. As examining the CCTV footages in the format furnished
by the Service Provider required lot of time, after witnessing the
samples to understand different modes/modus operandi adopted at
the venue, the Committee proceeded with examination of the logs.
6.
Examination of CCTV footages:
CCTV footages of few candidates from the venues which
had high success rate have been examined and report attached as
Annexure-2.
The observations out of examination of CCTV footages is
as follows:Venue:
Airavat Education:
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
(i)
Almost all the candidates have been shifted to some
other terminal before closure of entry gate.
(ii)
It seems that there are some fixed compromised
terminals in every lab and most of suspected candidates
shifted to these terminals only.
(iii)
There is one main invigilator who is involved in
almost all the shifting. He was getting help from some other
invigilators also.
(iv)
Almost all the shifted candidates are not being seen
to be complaining about non-working of old terminal.
Rather they have told by invigilators to shift to other
terminal.
(v)
In one or two cases old terminal of the shifted
candidates was used by some other candidate, which clearly
indicates that there was no fault in the already allocated
terminal of the candidate. He was shifted with ill motives
only.
(vi)
Most of the suspected candidates are the first one to
report at the frisking point and then in the lab.
(vii) In few of the cases it also seems that CCTV footage
has also been doctored.
Venue:
Om Kothari Institute of Management and Research
(i)
Most of the withheld candidates in this centre have
appeared from Lab-3.
(ii)
The candidates suspected to be involved in
malpractice is made to sit before the intended
system/terminal which could be compromised.
(iii)
Affixing the cable would be the modus of
facilitating in malpractice.
(iv)
Either the system is taken on the remote access or
actual question is taken through a system placed outside
and terminally shared to the candidate.
7.
The data showing venue-wise suspected and cleared
candidate is shown at Annexure-3. From the table, the scale of
malpractice, venue wise can be made out. As can be observed,
some venues have resorted to rampant malpractice.
8.
Committee also did some data analytics.
i.
The table showing the time taken between first and
last attempt by the Candidates is at Annexure-4. It may be
observed that many Candidates have replied all the
questions In very short duration.
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
ii.
The table showing IP addresses used more than
once in the same shift in a given venue is shown as
Annexure-5. Some IP addresses and MAC addresses are
used frequently by the venues for the compromised
systems.
iii.
The table showing subject wise correct attempts and
time differential between the first and last attempt is shown
as Annexure-6.
9.
After analyzing the log files, the committee is of the view
that malpractice seems to have taken place with the connivance of
the Venue Management/Personnel. The biometric registration
module allots the Candidates to machines with different labels
which are already launched on predetermined random basis
contained in the drive. The intended Candidates are moved to
desired compromised system by remapping them from the earlier
allotted system and remapping them to intended compromised
system.
10.
The system through which candidate appears for the exam
seems to have been taken either on remote access or the actual
system is outside the exam hall on the same LAN and the screen is
shared to the screen(monitor) of the Candidate. It seems that a team
sitting outside the exam hall or at remote place has attempted the
questions. To answer the GK questions, probably help of search
engines are taken. It is observed that in the venues/shift where
there are more candidates involved in the malpractice, one subject
each (out of 4 subjects) is replied/attempted at regular pace on
different candidate's terminal. Later the solved questions of other
subject/topic are replied/attempted at fast pace. In the venues/shift
where there are less number of candidates, say 1 or 2, the questions
are attempted at more or less regular pace as the solving and
answering is resorted to by the team assisting remotely at their
pace and marked simultaneously. In spite of strong apprehensions
looking at the questions answered consistently, benefit of doubt
has been given to some candidates.
11.
RECOMMENDATION:
The committee, after detailed examination and analysis, has
recorded its observation and recommendation against each
candidate. The reasons for the recommendation have also been
recorded. The same is attached herewith as Annexure- 1.
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
Out of 90 candidates examined, the Committee recommends 70
candidates as
suspects. Committee also recommends 20
candidates as can be cleared for the reasons stated therein.
The number of candidates examined:
Candidates found as suspect:
Candidates found clear:
Sd/RD (SR)
S. Roll
No. Number
Exam
Date
14. 200500770 18-039
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
Sd/RD(CR)
Shift
Venue
Code
Center
Name
Avirat 186
Educati
on
Society
DS(Conf)
Score Correct Incorrect
Observation
Remarks
For first 29
minutes
only
questions
with
incorrect.
Candidate
shifted to a
new
machine
and
then
makes very
fast
attempts.
No attempt
in last 10
minutes.
Almost
whole
paper done
in only 21
minutes
with total
94 correct.
Overall
timetaken
from first
attempt till
last attempt
is 00:43:22.
(Time taken
Subject
wisefrom
first attempt
till
last
attemptQA-25
Correct,
Time
taken*
04:52
min:sec.GI22 Correct,
Suspected
Time
taken*03:4
0 min:sec.
GK-23
Correct,
Time
taken*
09:04min:s
ec. EN-24
Correct,
Time
taken*
43:22
min:sec)
Annexure-2
CCTV Observations
*****
Avirat Education:
*****
2005007709: Candidate not traceable.
*****
Annexure-3
Time duration between 1st and last attempt by the Candidates
(Time taken to complete the Exam)
*****
ROLL
NUMBER
2005007709
18.
Score
Remarks
Suspected
Time diff
(HH.mm.ss)
00:43:22
Himanshi addressed representations to the SSC, seeking that her
result be declared. The results of 20 of the candidates, which had been
withheld, were provisionally declared by the SSC on 28 July 2022.
Himanshi, however, was not one among the 20.
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
19.
On 13 September 2022, the SSC issued a show cause notice to
Himanshi alleging use, by her, of unfair means while attempting the
Tier I examination. The following passages, from the show cause
notice, are of relevance:
WHEREAS the Commission had taken a conscious decision with a
view to protecting the integrity of the selection process and to
prevent candidates who are prima facie found indulging in unfair
means in their examination from entering into government service
through such unfair means and in furtherance of the said decision
the result of 104 candidates including Ms. Himanshi has been kept
withheld due to suspected use of unfair means/discrepancies
subject to the further scrutiny in their matter by the Commission.
WHEREAS 90 candidates were found indulge in suspected use of
unfair means i.e. moving to compromised system in examination
hall by getting themselves demapped from the earlier allotted
system and getting themselves remapped to intended compromised
system. Therefore, cases of 90 candidates including that of Ms.
Himanshi's were to be scrutinized by the Committee constituted for
the this purpose.
WHEREAS a Committee had been constituted by the Commission
on 17.05.2021 to examine the CCTV footages and log trails of
these 90 candidates of CHSLE-2019, whose result has been kept
withheld. The committee considered the following factors while
examining the logs.
(i)
Score of the candidate.
(ii)
Attempts made by the candidate against each
section (subject) viz., General knowledge (GK), Numerical
Ability (NA), Reasoning (RE) and Computer Fundamentals
(CO).
(iii)
The number of correct and incorrect replies.
(iv)
The difficulty level of the questions (difficulty level
was determined based on the number of candidates who
could answer the question correctly).
(v)
The time taken by the candidate to answer the
questions.
(vi)
The time spent by the candidate not attempting
questions (idle time).
(vii) The sequence of answering the questions.
(viii) The pattern of correcting the questions answered
incorrectly, on the later occasion through reattempts.
(ix)
The pattern of answering the questions in quick
succession/ explosive rate.
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
(x)
Duration taken from the first attempt till the last
attempt.
(xi)
The number of candidates appearing in the same
shift from the same venue out of 90 candidates and the
number of questions answered correctly/ incorrectly by
these candidates.
(xii) The time of demapping as recorded in the logs.
(xiii) IP address and MAC id used by the candidate
before and after demapping.
WHEREAS, CCTV footages of few venues were examined to
observe any abnormalities/suspicious activity, vis-a-vis, the
withheld candidates and the findings of the same have been
recorded. After witnessing the samples to understand different
modes/modus operandi adopted at the venue, the Committee
proceeded with examination of the logs. After analyzing the log
files, the committee is of the view that malpractice seems to have
taken
place
with
the
connivance
of
the
Venue
Management/Personnel. The biometric registration module allots
the Candidates to machines with different labels which are already
launched on predetermined random basis contained in the drive.
The intended Candidates are moved to desired compromised
system by demapping them from the earlier allotted system and
remapping them to intended compromised system. The system
through which candidate appears for the exam seems to have been
taken either on remote access or the actual system is outside the
exam hall on the same LAN and the screen is shared to the screen
(monitor) of the Candidate. It seems that a team sitting outside the
exam hall or at remote place has attempted the questions. To
answer the GK questions, probably help of search engines are
taken. It is observed that in the venues/shift where there are more
candidates involved in the malpractice, one subject each (out of 4
subjects) is plied/attempted at regular pace on different candidate's
terminal. Later the solved questions of other subject/topic are
replied/attempted at fast pace. In the venues/shift where there are
less number of Candidates, say 1 or 2, the questions are attempted
at more or less regular pace as the solving and answering is
resorted to by the team assisting remotely at their pace and marked
simultaneously.
WHEREAS, the Committee has observed that though as per
records, Ms. Himanshi (Roll No. 2005007709) appeared for CHSL
(Tier-1) Examination-2019 on 18.03.2020 in Shift-2 (i.e. from
01:00 pm to 02:00 pm) at Avirat education Society, S-340, Shivlik
Nagar, near BHEL, Ranipur, Haridwar, Uttarakhand-249403, she is
not traceable in CCTV footage.
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
WHEREAS after analyzing the log files, the Committee has
observed that Ms. Himanshi (Roll No. 2005007709) attempted
only 15 questions with 9 incorrect for first 29 minutes. She was
shifted to a new machine and then she made very fast attempts.
However, no attempt was made in last 10 minutes Almost whole
paper was done only in 21 minutes with total 94 corrects. Overall
time taken from first attempt till last attempt is 00:43:22. (Time
taken Subject wise from first attempt till last attempt-. Quantitative
Aptitude -25 Corrects, Time taken * 4:52 min:sec.; General
Intelligence -22 Corrects, Time taken* 3:40 min:sec. General
Knowledge -23 Corrects, Time taken* 09:04 min:sec English -24
Correct, Time taken* 43:22 min:sec). It may be seen that Ms.
Himanshi (Roll No. 2005007709) has replied all the questions in
very short duration.
WHEREAS, the Committee also observed that almost all the
withheld candidates of CHSLE 2019 who appeared in Tier-I of the
said examination at Avirat education Society, have been shifted to
some other terminal before closure of entry gate. There is one main
invigilator who is involved in almost all the shifting. He was
getting help from some other invigilators also. It seems that there
are some fixed compromised terminals in every lab and most of
suspected candidates shifted to these terminals only. Almost all the
shifted candidates are not being seen to be complaining about nonworking of old terminal. Rather they have told by invigilators to
shift to other terminal. In one or two cases old terminal of the
shifted candidates was used by some other candidate, which clearly
indicates that there was no fault in the already allocated terminal of
the candidate. He was shifted with ill motives only. Most of the
suspected candidates are the first one to report at the frisking point
and then in the lab.
WHEREAS, from the above, it is transpired that Ms. Himanshi
(Roll No. 2005007709) appeared for CHSL (Tier-I) Examination2019 on 18.03.2020 in Shift-2 (i.e. from 01:00 pm to 02:00 pm) at
Avirat education Society, S-340, Shivlik Nagar, near BHEL,
Ranipur, Haridwar, Uttarakhand-249403 and there was no fault in
the already allocated terminal of her as she made no complain
about non-working of it. She with the help of Main Invigilator
deliberately shifted to some fixed compromised terminals at Avirat
education Society with ill motives only. Hence it is clear that Ms.
Himanshi (Roll No. 2005007709) has shared examination terminal
through remote desktop softwares/ Apps/ LAN/VAN, etc, for
getting through the Tier-I of the examination in question.
WHEREAS, the candidates applying for the said Examination
were cautioned and instructed through clause No. 19(19) of the
Notice of the said Examination that:
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
19.
If candidates are found to indulge at any stage in any of the
malpractices listed below during the conduct of examination or
thereafter, their candidature for this examination will be cancelled
and they will be debarred from the examinations of the
Commission for the period mentioned below:
S.
No.
Type of Malpractice
Debarment
period
Sharing
examination 7 Years
terminal through remote
desktop
softwares/Apps/
LAN/VAN, etc.
WHEREAS clause 20 states that "the decision of the Commission
in all matters relating to eligibility, acceptance or rejection of the
applications, penalty for false information, mode of selection,
conduct of examination(s), allotment of examination centres,
selection and allotment of posts/organizations to selected
candidates will be final and binding on the candidates and no
enquiry correspondence will be entertained in this regard."
AND WHEREAS, sharing examination terminal through remote
desktop softwares/ Apps/ LAN/VAN, etc. is sheer violation of
clause 19(19) of the examination notice for CHSLE-2019.
NOW THEREFORE, Ms. Himanshi, D/o Shri Balbir Singh,
Village Nagla Gulab, Post Nibkarori, Farrukhabad, Uttar Pradesh205302 is hereby directed to show cause, within ten (10) days of
the issuance of this notice as to why her candidature for the
Combined Higher Secondary Level (10+2) Examination, 2019
should not be cancelled and she should not be debarred from the
examinations of the Commission for seven (07) years from the date
of misconduct. In case of no response within stipulated time, it will
be presumed that she has nothing to say in this regard and
accordingly her case will be processed further in accordance with
clause 19(19) of the examination notice for CHSLE-2019.
20.
Himanshi replied to the show cause notice on 28 September
2022, denying all allegations.
21.
Himanshi approached the Tribunal by way of OA 2953/2022,
praying that the SSC be directed to declare her result. During the
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
pendency of the OA, the SSC passed an order dated 21 October 2022,
confirming the proposal, in the show cause notice dated 13 September
2022, to cancel the candidature of the respondent and debar her from
participating in any examination conducted by the SSC for a period of
7 years. The order dated 21 October 2022, to the extent it is relevant,
is reproduced thus:
WHEREAS the Commission had taken a conscious
decision with a view to protecting the integrity of the selection
process and to prevent candidates who are prima facie found
indulging in unfair means in their examination from entering into
government service through such unfair means and in furtherance
of the said decision the result of 104 candidates including Ms.
Himanshi has been kept withheld due to suspected use of unfair
means/discrepancies subject to the further scrutiny in their matter
by the Commission.
WHEREAS 90 candidates were found indulging in
suspected use of unfair means i.e. moving to compromised system
in examination hall by getting themselves demapped from the
earlier allotted system and getting themselves remapped to
intended compromised system. Therefore, cases of such 90
candidates including that of Ms. Himanshi were to be scrutinized
by the Committee constituted for this purpose.
WHEREAS a Committee had been constituted by the
Commission on 17.05.2021 to examine the CCTV footages and log
trails of these 90 candidates of CHSLE-2019, whose result has
been kept withheld. The committee considered the following
factors while examining the logs.
(i)
Score of the candidate
(ii)
Attempts made by the candidate against each
section (subject) viz., General knowledge (GK), Numerical
Ability (NA), Reasoning (RE) and Computer Fundamentals
(CO).
(iii)
The number of correct and incorrect replies.
(iv)
The difficulty level of the questions (difficulty level
was determined based on the number of candidates who
could answer the question correctly)
(v)
The time taken by the candidate to answer the
questions.
(vi)
The time spent by the candidate not attempting
questions (idle time)
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
(vii) The sequence of answering the questions
(viii) The pattern of correcting the questions answered
incorrectly, on the later occasion through reattempts
(ix)
The pattern of answering the questions in quick
succession/ explosive rate
(x)
Duration taken from the first attempt till the last
attempt
(xi)
The number of candidates appearing in the same
shift from the same venue out of 90 candidates and the
number of questions answered correctly/ incorrectly by
these candidates
(xii) The time of demapping as recorded in the logs
(xiii) IP address and MAC id used by the candidate
before and after demapping
WHEREAS, CCTV footages of few venues were examined
to observe any abnormalities/suspicious activity, vis-a-vis, the
withheld candidates and the findings of the same have been
recorded. After witnessing the samples to understand different
modes/modus operandi adopted at the venue, the Committee
proceeded with examination of the logs. After analyzing the log
files, the committee is of the view that malpractice seems to have
taken
place
with
the
connivance
of
the
Venue
Management/Personnel. The biometric registration module allots
the Candidates to machines with different labels which are already
launched on predetermined random basis contained in the drive.
The intended Candidates are moved to desired compromised
system by demapping them from the earlier allotted system and
remapping them to intended compromised system. The system
through which candidate appears for the exam seems to have been
taken either on remote access or the actual system is outside the
exam hall on the same LAN and the screen is shared to the
screen(monitor) of the Candidate. It seems that a team sitting
outside the exam hall or at remote place has attempted the
questions. To answer the GK questions, probably help of search
engines are taken. It is observed that in the venues/shift where
there are more candidates involved in the malpractice, one subject
each (out of 4 subjects) is replied/attempted at regular pace on
different candidate's terminal. Later the solved questions of other
subject/topic are replied/attempted at fast pace. In the venues/shift
where there are less number of candidates, say 1 or 2, the questions
are attempted at more or less regular pace as the solving and
answering is resorted to by the team assisting remotely at their
pace and marked simultaneously.
WHEREAS, the Committee has observed that though as
per records, Ms. Himanshi (Roll No. 2005007709) appeared for
CHSL (Tier-I) Examination-2019 on 18.03.2020 in Shift-1 (i.e.
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
from 01:00 pm to 02:00 pm) at Avirat education Society, S-340,
Shivlik Nagar, near BHEL, Ranipur, Haridwar, Uttarakhand249403, she is not traceable in CCTV footage.
WHEREAS after analyzing the log files, the Committee has
observed that Ms. Himanshi (Roll No. 2005007709) attempted
only 15 questions with 9 incorrect for first 29 minutes. She was
shifted to a new machine and then she made very fast attempts.
However, no attempt was made in last 10 minutes. Almost whole
paper was done only in 21 minutes with total 94 corrects. Overall
time taken from first attempt till last attempt is 00:43:22. (Time
taken Subject wise from first attempt till last attempt. Quantitative
Aptitude -25 Corrects. Time taken* 04:52 min:sec.; General
Intelligence -22 Corrects. Time taken 03:40 min:sec. General
Knowledge -23 Corrects. Time taken 09:04 min:sec.; English -24
Correct. Time taken 43:22 min:sec). It may be seen that Ms.
Himanshi (Roll No. 2005007709) has replied all the questions in
very short duration.
Time taken* - time differential between the time stamps of
first and last attempt in a particular subject
WHEREAS, the Committee also observed that almost all
the withheld candidates of CHSLE-2019 who appeared in Tier-I of
the said examination at Avirat education Society, have been shifted
to some other terminal before closure of entry gate. There is one
main invigilator who is involved in almost all the shifting. He was
getting help from some other invigilators-also. It seems that there
are some fixed compromised terminals in every lab and most of
suspected candidates shifted to these terminals only. Almost all the
shifted candidates are not being seen to he complaining about nonworking of old terminal. Rather they have been told by invigilators
to shift to other terminal. In one or two cases old terminal of the
shifted candidates was used by some other candidate, which clearly
indicates that there was no fault in the already allocated terminal of
the candidate. She was shifted with ill motives only. Most of the
suspected candidates are the first one to report at the frisking point
and then in the lab.
WHEREAS, from the above, it is transpired that Ms.
Himanshi (Roll No. 2005007709) appeared for CHSL (Tier-I)
Examination-2019 on 18.03.2020 in Shift-2 (i.e. from 01:00 pm to
02:00 pm) at Avirat education Society, S-340, Shivlik Nagar, near
BHEL, Ranipur. Haridwar, Uttarakhand-249403 and there was no
fault in the already allocated terminal of her as she made no
complain about non-working of it. She with the help of Main
Invigilator deliberately shifted to sonic fixed compromised
terminals at Avirat education Society with ill motives only. Hence
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
it is clear that Ms. Himanshi (Roll No. 2005007709) has shared
examination terminal through remote desktop softwares/
Apps/LAN/VAN, etc. for getting through the Tier-1 of the
examination in question.
*****
WHEREAS, sharing examination terminal through remote
desktop softwares/ Apps/LAN/VAN, etc. is sheer violation of
clause 19(19) of the examination notice for CHSLE-2019.
*****
WHEREAS in response to the Show Cause Notice dated
13.09.2022. Ms. Himanshi vide her letter dated 28.9.2022
submitted her reply stating that the Show Cause Notice dated
13.09.2022 is merely a sham and it is a post decisional hearing.
Time granted for filing reply is too short and the Show Cause
Notice is being issued in a format only changing few paragraphs.
Once the final result has been declared, there has to be some basis
to scrutinize the candidatures of few candidates. The matter of only
90 candidates was referred to the Committee constituted for this
purpose though result of 104 candidates was kept withheld which
makes it clear that a pick & choose method based on suspicion and
surmises, was adopted for referring these 90 cases including Ms.
Himanshi's case to the Committee. It further shows non-application
of mind as once the result of 104 candidates have been kept
withheld and result of 20 candidates have heen declared then
matter of 84 candidates only should have been referred to the
Committee. She is not a technical person and thus unable to
understand technicality of the issue of demapping. IP address and
MAC ID. She sat at the seat on which she was directed to sit by the
Invigilator. This was in sheer accordance with the general
guidelines governing the examination in question. II she defies
these guidelines or instructions given by the invigilator, her
candidature might have been cancelled immediately. The criteria of
scrutinizing the results on the basis of shifting from one console to
another console clearly establishing non-application of mind. The
act of constituting a Committee to scrutinize the result of selected
candidates on arbitrary ground is against the laid down scheme and
guidelines of the present examination. The report of the Committee
relied upon in the show cause notice was not supplied to her.
WHEREAS the reply to the Show Cause Notice has been
gone through and it is observed that Ms. Himanshi has
misinterpreted various aspects of the Show Cause Notice and her
submission in response to the Show Cause Notice is misconceived
and misleading, Ms. Himanshi misinterpreted the clause 20 this
clause 20 simply reserves the right of the Commission with regard
taking decision in all matters relating to eligibility, acceptance or
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
rejection of the applications, penalty for false information, mode of
selection, conduct of examination(s), allotment of examination
centres, selection and allotment of posts organizations to selected
candidates and further prohibits any sort of enquiry in this regard.
It nowhere says that any reply sought by the Commission, will not
be considered. Further, 10 days time is sufficient for furnishing
reply to the Show Cause Notice. More time gives more chances for
manipulation of facts. It is also intimated that in terms of clause
17.17 of the Notice of the examination in question, the admission
of all the candidates at all stages of the examination is purely
provisional, subject to their satisfying the prescribed eligibility
conditions. If, on verification, at any time before or after the
written examination, it is found that they do not fulfill any of the
eligibility conditions, their candidature for the examination will be
cancelled. Besides. clause No. 19(19) of the Notice of the said
Examination clearly stipulates that "If candidates found to indulge
at any stage in any of the malpractices listed below during the
conduct of examination or thereafter, their candidature for this
examination will be cancelled and they will be debarred from the
examinations of the Commission for the period of 7 Years if found
sharing examination terminal through remote desktop
softwares/Apps/ LAN/VAN, etc."
WHEREAS it is pertinent to mention here that the modus
operandi for cheating adopted by all the candidates to whom Show
Cause Notices were issued, is similar in nature. Further in many
cases Examination Centre, Shift and date of examination are also
the same. Therefore it is obvious that Show Cause Notices issued
to such candidates do not have much variation. Besides, reply of
Ms. Himanshi to the Show Cause Notice is similar to the reply of
S/Shri Shubham Rathi (Roll No.2005007527), Robin Singh (Roll
No.2005007549), Rakshit Kumar No.2201878565) and Ms. Pooja
(Roll No. 2201878727) etc.
WHEREAS it has already been mentioned in the Result
Writup of Final result of CHSLE-2019 that "the result of 104
candidates has also been kept withheld due to suspected use of
unfair means/discrepancies, as per the list attached therewith the
Result Writeup. These cases will be further scrutinized by the
Commission, Therefore result of 104 candidates of CHSLE-2019
was kept withheld for further scrutiny. These 104 candidates
includes 14 such candidates whose candidatures were withheld due
to mismatch in handwritings, signatures and photographs captured
at various stages of the examination in question. Thus only 90
cases were referred to the Committee constituted for the scrutiny of
these cases of demapping & re-mapping.
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
WHEREAS it is also stated that a candidate is shifted from
the assigned seal to another seat if there is some technical glitch in
the system assigned to him/her. In the instant case no such this has
happened as the candidate has not reported any fault in the
assigned system. Further, the report of the Committee contains
details of 80 other candidates as well. Sharing of report amounts
sharing of their details as well.
AND WHEREAS Ms. Himanshu has tailed to rebut the
allegation leveled against her in Show Cause Notice in a
satisfactory manner.
NOW THEREFORE, the candidature of Ms. Himanshi,
D/o Shri Balbir Singh, Village Nagla Gulab, Post Nibkarori,
Farrukhabad, Uttar Pradesh-205302 for the Combined Higher
Secondary Level(10+2) Examination, 2019 is hereby cancelled and
she, in accordance with clause 19(19) of the examination notice for
CHSLE-2019. is debarred from the examinations of the
Commission for seven (07) years from the date of misconduct i.e.
18.03.2020.
22.
Himanshi, therefore, amended her OA, including a challenge to
the order dated 21 October 2022.
23.
The Tribunal has, by judgment dated 14 February 2025,
allowed the OA filed by Himanshi. The reasoning, and the conclusion
of the Tribunal, read thus:
“23. Heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the
records. The respondents justify their action based on the report of
the expert committee. The SSC, being the recruiting agency, is
responsible for conducting multiple recruitment examinations
annually, including the CGLE, which witnesses the participation of
thousands of candidates. To facilitate this extensive process across
the country, SSC engages various computer labs/centers for
conducting the examinations. These centers are mandated to
conduct the exams under CCTV surveillance, and the recorded
footage is expected to be available to SSC if required.
In the present case, before the completion of the
recruitment cycle, SSC had sought the CCTV recordings; however
the centers have failed to provide the same. This raises the question
of the extent of control SSC exercises over these centers. While the
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
centers are required to record and preserve the examination
footage via CCTV, when concerns arose regarding the
candidatures of certain candidates from these centers, only 2 out of
the 7 centers, admittedly, furnished the requested footage.
23.1. The only reason provided by the respondents to doubt the
candidatures of the applicants is that the applicants had shifted
from their allotted consoles during Tier-I exam. Out of 44,000 odd
candidates who shifted from their allotted consoles, 210 made it to
the finalist. Only 90 out of the 210 were subjected to scrutiny. The
reason for subjecting only 90 is that they are from a center where
more than 5 candidates had shifted their consoles. This criterion on
the face of it may seem convenient for the SSC, but it is harsh,
arbitrary, and pick and choose, and not a direct result of any action
of the candidate. The individual candidates has not control once
how many candidates shift from their allotted consoles. It seems
the SSC has tried to make an example of these candidates.
24.
A very harsh punishment has been imposed on the
applicants on one hand their candidature has been cancelled and on
the other they have been banned from any exams to be conducted
by SSC for 7 years. Meaning thereby those candidates who
although shifted from their consoles, but were at a center where
less than 5 candidates had shifted and are selected have been
allowed to go scot-free. Then there are those who although shifted
from their consoles, but did not make it to the final select list are
free to attempt/sit as many times in future exams.
25.
We are aware that the SSC faces a huge challenge while
conducting these exams, however, it has all the resources and the
technology at its beck and call to ensure a free and fair selection.
The SSC is competent and free to ensure that the exam is
conducted without any allegation of cheating etc, however, when it
undertakes an exercise such as the one in the present case, it is
expected that the SSC would have the necessary details and
evidence to back their allegations. Lack of CCTV footage would
necessarily have to be read in favor of the applicant. Furthermore,
the algorithm used to scrutinize only 90 out of 210 selected
candidates raises concerns and cannot be overlooked.
26.
Applicants detailed research concerning the time consumed
in answering the first and last question, by the selected/cleared
after scrutiny candidates, and the applicants also go in favour of the
applicant. Respondent SSC has stated that they have considered the
time consumed as an indicator of the guilt of the applicants,
however, the SSC could not answer the difference between the
applicants and the cleared candidates when the time consumed is
the same.
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
27.
Further the decision to scrutiny the candidates exercise was
undertaken only after the completion of all three stages of the
selection process. At this advanced stage, where the results of TierI, Tier-II, and Tier-Ill had already been declared, subjecting the
Tier-1 examination to additional scrutiny based on an arbitrary
criterion smacks of arbitrariness, vagueness, and malice in law.
28.
Another intriguing factor is that the impugned orders were
issued after the declaration of the final result, despite the applicant
clearing the entire selection process on merit (Tier-1, II, & III) and
successfully completing document verification. Once the final
result was declared, the principle of estoppels barred the authorities
from withholding the applicant's appointment on vague and flimsy
grounds concerning Tier-1.
29.
Given the above discussion we are of the opinion that the
impugned orders needed to be set since they are arbitrary and
based on flimsy grounds, casting a serious stigma on the applicant's
career by proposing a seven-year debarment from SSC
examinations. Such a severe penalty could only be imposed if there
was a clear-cut and conclusive finding of guilt based on legally
tenable grounds. In the present case, no such grounds existed,
making the imposition of this punishment entirely arbitrary and
jeopardizing the applicant's career.
30.
In view of the above, the impugned orders dated 10th May
2022 (concerning to the applicants), 13th September 2022 and 21st
October 2022 are hereby quashed and set aside. The respondents
are further directed to consider the candidature of the applicant in
accordance with the merit secured by the applicants in the CHSL
2019 examination, granting all consequential benefits as per law
within a period of four months from the date of receipt of a
certified copy of this order.
31.
The Original Application stands allowed, along with all
consequential benefits as per law. There shall be no order as to
costs.”
24.
The SSC, by means of the present writ petition, challenges the
decision of the Tribunal.
25.
We have heard Mr. Syed Abdul Haseeb, learned CGSC for the
SSC and Mr. K.C. Mittal, learned Senior Counsel for the respondent.
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
C.
Rival Stands of learned Counsel
C.I
Submissions of Mr. Haseeb, on behalf of the SSC
26.
Arguing on behalf of the Union of India, Mr. Haseeb submits
that the decision to cancel the candidature of Himanshi was taken after
a comprehensive enquiry and evaluation by a duly constituted
Committee. Adverting to the report of the Committee, Mr. Haseeb
points out that the CCTV footage of the area as well as the log trails of
90 suspected cases were examined. Consequent on examination, the
suspicion of use of unfair means was found not to have been
corroborated in the case of 20 candidates whose results were,
therefore, declared. The remaining 70 candidates were, however,
found to have used unfair means, based on the material before the
Committee and the enquiry conducted by it. It was for this reason that
their result was withheld and they were imposed the statutorily
envisaged punishment of 7 years’ debarment.
27.
Though Himanshi was not traceable in the CCTV footage, Mr.
Haseeb points out that the manner in which she attempted and
answered questions substantiates the finding that she had indulged in
unfair means. He submits that
(i)
there were a total of 100 questions in the Tier I
examination,
(ii)
Himanshi attempted 15 questions on the terminal allotted
to her and the remaining 85 questions on the terminal to which
she was shifted,
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
(iii)
she attempted all 100 questions within 43 minutes and 22
seconds,
(iv)
in doing so, she availed only 50 minutes out of the one-
hour permitted to attempt the paper, out of which 29 minutes
were spent on the terminal allotted to her and the remaining 21
minutes were spent on the terminal to which she was shifted,
(v)
in the first 29 minutes, she attempted 15 questions on the
terminal allotted to her, out of which 9 answers were incorrect,
and
(vi)
in the remaining 21 minutes, she attempted the remaining
85 questions on the terminal to which she was shifted, of which
all 85 answers were correct.
Mr. Haseeb submits that Himanshi did not complain of any fault in the
terminal which was allotted to her, as would justify shifting her to
another terminal. The shifting was, therefore, unjustified and,
according to him, deliberately engineered, allowing her to attempt the
paper through a compromised terminal. This fact, along with the
abnormal answering pattern of Himanshi, he submits, was sufficient to
justify the finding that she had resorted to unfair means in collusion
with persons in the examination hall.
28.
It is further submitted by Mr. Haseeb that the case of Himanshi
is not isolated and that similar instances of shifting of terminals
combined with abnormal answering behaviour were observed in the
case of multiple candidates, often at the same centers and shifts,
thereby establishing a uniform modus operandi, with no chance of
coincidence.
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
29.
Mr. Haseeb has placed especial reliance on para 4 of the Report
of the Committee, which enumerates various factors which were
considered by it while examining the logs of the candidates. The study
was, therefore, he submits, thorough, and all relevant indicia were
taken into consideration. Inasmuch as the findings were based on
expert evaluation of complex technical data, Mr. Haseeb submits that
the Tribunal erred in interfering with the decision to cancel
Himanshi’s candidature and debar her for a period of 7 years. For the
proposition that Courts should not interfere in such cases, Mr. Haseeb
places reliance on the judgment of a Division Bench of this Court in
Varun Bhardwaj v. State Bank of India6.
30.
Clause 19(19) of the Notice of Examination, points out Mr.
Haseeb, envisages cancellation of candidature, and debarment for a
period of 7 years, in the case of any candidate who is found indulging
in malpractice, including “sharing examination terminal through
Remote desktop softwares/Apps/LAN/VAN, etc.” The case of the
respondent, he submits, directly attracts this Clause.
31.
Mr. Haseeb, therefore, exhorts this Court to uphold the decision
to cancel the candidature of the respondent and debar her for a period
of 7 years, and, therefore, to set aside the impugned judgment of the
Tribunal.
C.II Submissions of Mr. K.C. Mittal for the Respondent
6 2015 SCC OnLine Del 13636
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
32.
Responding to Mr. Haseeb, Mr. Mittal, appearing for the
respondent, submits that no case for interference with the impugned
judgment of the Tribunal, within the scope of Article 226 of the
Constitution of India, can be said to exist.
33.
Mr. Mittal points out that the petitioner, for no apparent reason,
undertook an investigation into the conduct of the Tier I examination
after a delay of two years and nine months. No complaint, regarding
the manner in which the examination had been conducted, was raised
by anyone. In these circumstances, Mr. Mittal submits that the
findings contained in paras 23 to 28 of the impugned judgment of the
Tribunal are unexceptionable, not meriting any interference.
34.
Mr. Mittal further submits that the explanation tendered by
Himanshi, in reply to the show cause notice issued to her, had not
been considered while deciding to cancel her candidature and debar
her from undertaking any examination for 7 years. The Tribunal, he
submits, was further justified in observing that the decision to subject
only such centers to scrutiny in which more than five cases of demapping had been noticed, was itself arbitrary. Though over 44,000
candidates had, even as per the petitioner, been de-mapped, Mr. Mittal
points out that a select list of 90 candidates were subjected to scrutiny.
An example was, therefore, being sought to be made of these
candidates, without any cogent material to differentiate them from
other de-mapped candidates. In this context, Mr. Mittal has drawn our
attention to the following table naming the 20 candidates who had
been cleared, and whose results had been declared, and who had also
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
taken comparable amounts of time for attempting the examination, as
filed by the respondents in CM 73430/2025:
“31. That for instance, of the 20 candidates cleared by the
committee, the total time taken by candidates from first attempt to
last is as under:
S. No. Name
Roll Number
2002006879
2002006988
2002611247
2002612319
2201601698
2201602433
2201602849
2201879103
2407022429
2407614182
4205121625
4205122422
4205124006
4205126274
4205126513
9202004054
9202004992
9202005449
9202005882
9202009979
Swati Rajbhar
Kailash Singh
Akhilesh Kumar Pal
Ajay Bisht
Sapna
Anuj Kumar
Sunny
Ankur
Mohit
Ajay Kumar
Amit Ranjan
Ashutosh Kumar
Neeraj Mani Pathak
Nitin Kumar
Nitesh Kumar Chaubey
Ambika Balkrishnan M V
Yadunand M T
Sajeevan C
Vishnu Prasad P V
Sachin K Sukumaran
Time (First to Last
Attempt)
00:59:25
00:59:21
00:57:17
00:56:45
00:55:52
00:50:16
00:53:28
00:59:01
00:50:26
00:48:25
00:56:29
00:59:27
00:58:22
00:57:55
00:58:48
00:55:19
00:55:49
00:58:53
00:58:14
00:58:47
Mr. Mittal submits that the total time taken by the above 20 candidates
to attempt the Tier I examination was comparable to the total time
taken by the 30 candidates, including Himanshi, who were the original
respondents in the writ petition, tabulated as under:
“32. That the time difference of the respondent applicants is as
under:
S. No.
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
OA No.
Roll Number
Name
Time
difference
(first question
Attempt
to
Last
attempt
question)
2953/2022
2961/2022
2970/2022
2975/2022
2005007709
2005007549
2201878727
2005007289
2989/2022
2201878565
614/2024
2997/2022
2999/2022
3007/2022
2201602588
2407022831
2005007514
2005007902
3008/2022
2005007527
3010/2022
3012/2022
3013/2022
3015/2022
3018/2022
3019/2022
2005007775
2005007646
2005007416
2005007537
2201603096
2201602186
3020/2022
103/2023
3032/2022
2201602212
2201878805
2201882436
3033/2022
3034/2022
3035/2022
3036/2022
3037/2022
3038/2022
3056/2022
2201603326
2201602643
2201601992
2201878442
2201603065
2201602435
2407022031
3086/2022
3087/2022
99/2023
1974/2024
2005008257
2201602427
2005008262
2201601345
Himanshi
Robin Singh
Pooja
Akash
Baliyan
Rakshit
Kumar
Annu
Sumit
Imran Khan
Manjeet
Malik
Shubham
Rathi
Sagar Sharma
Nitin Tomar
Shekhar
Vishal Kumar
Jatin
Sikandar
Singh
Ashish
Nitin Rana
Vikas
Chauhan
Tushar
Pritam
Bhanu
Ankita
Sumit
Ashu
Kuldeep
Singh
Uttam
Sachin
Sumit
Shivam
00:43:22
00:57:53
00:58:38
00:54:28
00:46:54
00:53:39
00:21:58
00:54:50
00:52:44
00:56:11
00:33:59
00:55:12
00:56:07
00:57:09
00:43:15
00:48:17
00:41:04
00:53:08
00:56:14
00:50:25
00:56:32
00:39:31
00:42:02
00:41:25
00:54:12
00:53:13
00:48:06
00:49:46
00:31:58
It is further submitted by Mr. Mittal that the answering pattern of
Himanshi and other candidates, whose results had been withheld, was
also similar to the candidates who were originally suspected, but
whose results were later cleared, for which purpose he has drawn our
attention to the following tabular statements, contained in CM
73430/2025 filed by the respondent:
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
Cleared Candidates
“Name - Ajay Kumar
Roll No. - 2407614182 Page No. 15 Sr. No. 72
Subject
Quantitative Aptitude
General Intelligence
General Knowledge
English
Total
No. of Correct Section
Wise
Q.
Time In Minutes
43:15
08:30
04:55
46:37
48:25
Committee Report analysis- No Attempts in last 10 minutes. (The
so called Committee report states "Benefits of doubts maybe
given" Page no.)
Name - Mohit
Roll No. 22407022429 Page No. 14 Sr. No. 62
Subject
Quantitative Aptitude
General Intelligence
General Knowledge
English
Total
No. of Correct Section
Wise
Q.
Time In Minutes
19:32
10:48
05:14
11:35
50:26
Committee report analysis- Attempted 21 QA sequentially but did
not visited last 4 QA questions. No Attempt in last 7 minutes (The
so called Committee report states "Benefits of doubts maybe
given" Page no.)
Name - Sunny
Roll No. - 2201602849 Page No. 11 Sr. No. 43
Subject
Quantitative Aptitude
General Intelligence
General Knowledge
English
Total
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
No. of Correct Section
Wise
Q.
Time In Minutes
14:04
53:28
03:55
09:55
53:28
Committee Report analysis - 20 QA (1 incorrect sequentially from
10:41:15 to 10:46:06. Only 6 Questions in last 14 minutes. (The so
called Committee report states "Benefits of doubts maybe given"
Page no.)
Suspected Candidates
Name - Nitin Tomar
Roll No. - 2005007646
O.A. No. 3012/2022
Subject
No. of Correct Section
Wise
Q.
Time In Minutes
Quantitative Aptitude
20:53
General Intelligence
41:54
General Knowledge
17:56
English
10:26
Over all timing first
55:12
attempt
to
last
attempt
Committee remark - "Marked as suspected by the committee"
Name - Shekhar
Roll No. - 2005007416
O.A. No. 3013/2022
Subject
No. of Correct Section
Wise
Q.
Time In Minutes
Quantitative Aptitude
24:22
General Intelligence
06:30
General Knowledge
20:27
English
27:21
Over all timing first
56:07
attempt
to
last
attempt
Committee remark - "Marked as suspected by the committee"
Name - Kuldeep Singh
Roll No. 2407022031
Subject
Quantitative Aptitude
General Intelligence
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
O.A. No. 3056/2022
No. of Correct Section
Wise
Q.
Time In Minutes
23:18
14:04
General Knowledge
English
Over all timing first
attempt
to
last
attempt
05:59
07:51
53:13
Committee remark - "Marked as suspected by the committee"
Name - Annu
Roll No.- 2201602588
O.A. No. 614/2024
Subject
No. of Correct Section
Wise
Q.
Time In Minutes
Quantitative Aptitude
45:34
General Intelligence
23:17
General Knowledge
05:25
English
04:24
Over all timing first
53:39
attempt
to
last
attempt
Committee remark - "Marked as suspected by the committee"
Name - Pooja
Roll No. - 2201:878727
O.A. No. 2970/2022
Subject
No. of Correct Section
Wise
Q.
Time In Minutes
Quantitative Aptitude
13:58
General Intelligence
07:47
General Knowledge
50:51
English
06:07
Over all timing first
58:38
attempt
to
last
attempt
Committee remark - "Marked as suspected by the committee"
Name - Rakshit Kumar
Roll No. - 2201878565
Subject
Quantitative Aptitude
General Intelligence
General Knowledge
O.A. No. 2989/2022
No. of Correct Section
Wise
Q.
Time In Minutes
28:12
27:00
05:48
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
English
Over all timing first
attempt
to
last
attempt
Name - Sachin
Roll No. - 2201602427
02:41
46:54
Ο.Α. No. 3087/2022
Subject
No. of Correct Section
Wise
Q.
Time In Minutes
Quantitative Aptitude
36:57
General Intelligence
11:22
General Knowledge
12:20
English
03:56
Over all timing first
49:46
attempt
to
last
attempt
35.
Mr. Mittal points out that the basis for cancelling the
candidature of Himanshi, as well as of other similarly situated
candidates whose candidature was cancelled, was that they had
attempted the Tier I examination from a terminal other than the one
allotted to them – referred to, by the SSC, as “de-mapping”. However,
while subjecting candidates to scrutiny on this allegation, the SSC had
only selected such centers in which five or more cases of de-mapping
were found to have taken place. The results of candidates who had
undertaken the Tier I examination from terminals other than those
allotted to them, from centers in which five or less cases of the
mapping were found to have taken place, were declared. This, submits
Mr. Mittal, amounted to pick and choose.
36.
Further, points out Mr. Mittal, though it is alleged that the
suspected “compromised” terminals, through which the candidates
who were debarred and whose candidature was cancelled had
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
attempted the Tier I examination, were remotely controlled by others,
there was no finding, by the Committee, of the existence of any such
software, on the said terminals, as would enable such remote access.
37.
Mr. Mittal concludes his submissions by pointing out that the
findings of the Committee are not conclusive, but merely presume use
of unfair means. It employs expressions such as “seems”, “appears”,
“probable” and “suspect”, which indicate that there was no conclusive
finding of use of unfair means by Himanshi.
38.
In support of his submissions, Mr. Mittal relies on the
judgments of this Court in Amit Chhikara v. Union of India7, Staff
Selection Commission v. Sudesh8 and Rinku v. Union of India9 and
the judgment of the High Court of Allahabad in Tanu Chaudhary v.
State of U.P.10
D.
Analysis
D.I
The Issue before us
39.
While there are several decisions of the Supreme Court which
address questions relating to the use of unfair means in examinations,
most of them deal with the issue of whether the examination is
required to be cancelled as a whole, or whether the candidature of the
identified candidates who indulged in unfair means alone should be
7 2018 SCC OnLine Del 11823
8 2014 SCC OnLine Del 7534
9 (2013) 1 LLJ 321
10 2025 SCC OnLine All 5562
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
nullified. In State of U.P. v. Baishakhi Bhattacharyya11, which
considers several earlier authorities on the point, the Supreme Court
has held that, where it is possible to identify the candidates who had
indulged in unfair means, those candidates alone should be debarred,
or their candidature cancelled, and the examination as a whole should
not be nullified. Where, however, the number of candidates is very
large, or there is a possibility of large scale copying or use of unfair
means even though positive material is available only in respect of a
select number of candidates, cancellation of the entire examination has
been held by the Supreme Court to be justified.
40.
We need not, however, dwell on this issue, as the facts of the
present case do not involve any such dispute. The case of the SSC is
that select candidates, who participated in the Tier-I examination from
certain specific centers, indulged in unfair means, and that it had been
possible to identify them. Thus, it is only the candidature of 70
candidates which has been withheld, on the ground that they were
suspected to have used unfair means, out of a total of over 13 lakh
candidates who had undertaken the examination.
41.
We have, therefore, to ascertain whether the Tribunal was right
in its view that cancellation of the candidature and debarment of the
said 70 candidates – or, rather, the candidates who had approached the
Tribunal – was unsustainable, and deserves to be interfered with.
11 (2025) 11 SCC 126
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
42.
Specifically, for the present petition, we would be dealing only
with the case of Himanshi. It is necessary to make this clear, as the
case of Himanshi has certain qualitative differences from the cases of
other candidates.
D.II The law
43.
We proceed to examine some of the instructive authorities on
the issue in controversy. The principles emanating from each
judgment have been italicized, so as to obviate the need for repetition.
44. Board of High School and Intermediate Education, UP v.
Bagleshwar Prasad12
44.1 The candidature of Bagleshwar Prasad13, the original petitioner
before the High Court, in the High School Examination held in 1960,
was cancelled by the Board of High School and Intermediate
Education, UP14 by order dated 5 December 1960.
This was
following a memorandum issued to him, alleging use of unfair means,
to which he submitted his response, which was considered by a subCommittee constituted for the purpose. The allegation of unfair means
was based on the fact that the answer of Bagleshwar, whose Roll
Number was 94734, in response to Question 4 in the examination, was
precisely in the same form as was given by the candidate bearing Roll
Number 94733. On being questioned during inquiry, Bagleshwar
acknowledged the fact that the answers appeared to be identical, but
12 AIR 1966 SC 875
13 “Bagleshwar” hereinafter
14 “The Board” hereinafter
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
denied the allegation of use of unfair means. The sub-Committee
returned a finding adverse to Bagleshwar, following which his
candidature, as well as the candidature of the candidate bearing Roll
Number 94733, was cancelled. The High Court, which was petitioned
by Bagleshwar, allowed his writ petition, against which decision the
Board appealed to the Supreme Court.
44.2 The High Court returned a finding that the case against
Bagleshwar was one of no evidence. The Supreme Court, at the very
outset, acknowledged, in para 4 of the report, that a report of a
Committee which was unsupported by any evidence would be
erroneous on its face and would, therefore, be liable to be quashed
under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
44.3 The Supreme Court, however, ultimately reversed the decision of
the High Court. It was observed, by the Supreme Court, that the High
Court had erred in presuming that the only allegation against
Bagleshwar was that he had copied from the candidate bearing Roll
Number 94733. The actual charge against Bagleshwar, it was noted,
was that the identity of the answers entered by Bagleshwar and the
candidate bearing Roll Number 94733 indicated copying. That would
not, however, necessarily mean that Bagleshwar had copied from the
candidate bearing Roll Number 94733. The inquiry proceedings made
it clear that the allegation was that either Bagleshwar had copied from
the candidate bearing Roll Number 94733, or that the candidate
bearing Roll Number 94733 had copied from Bagleshwar, or that both
had copied from a common source. The High Court had, therefore,
erred in presuming that the allegation was limited to copying, by
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
Bagleshwar, from the candidate bearing Roll Number 94733. The
other two alternatives, i.e., that the candidate bearing Roll Number
94733 may have copied from Bagleshwar or that both may have
copied from a common source, were overlooked by the High Court.
44.4 The Supreme Court further observed that other circumstances,
which were also relevant and significant, were also ignored by the
High Court. The examination had been conducted at a centre in which
unfair means had earlier been adopted on a very large scale by a large
number of students. The examination appeared to have been
conducted in an atmosphere which was not congenial to enforcement
of the discipline required while conducting examinations. It was for
these reasons that the said centre had been abolished as an
examination centre for some years, but was restarted in 1960, leading
to unfortunate results.
44.5 Following these factual observations, the Supreme Court
reasoned and held as under:
“10. In dealing with the question as to whether the Committee
was justified in coming to this conclusion against the respondent, it
would not be reasonable to exclude from consideration the
circumstances under which the whole enquiry came to be held and
the general background of the prevailing disturbed and riotous
atmosphere in the Examination Hall during the days that the High
School Examination was held at the center in 1960. Unfortunately,
the High Court has ignored this background altogether.
11.
Before the High Court, a statement was filed showing the
seating arrangement in Room No. 10 where the respondent was
sitting for writing his answers. It appears that he was No. 3 in the
3rd row, whereas the other candidate with Roll No. 94733 was No.
4 in the second row. The High Court was very much impressed by
the fact that the respondent could not have looked back and copied
from the answer-book of the other candidate, and the High Court
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
did not think that there was any evidence to show that the other
candidate could have copied from the respondents paper with his
connivance. We have looked at the incorrect answers ourselves and
we are not prepared to hold that the identical incorrect answers
were given by the two candidates either by accident or by
coincidence. Some of the incorrect answers, and, particularly, the
manner in which they have been given, clearly suggest that they
were the result of either one candidate copying from the other, or
both candidates copying from a common source. The significance
of this fact has been completely missed by the High Court. The
question before the Enquiry Committee had to be decided by it in
the light of the nature of the incorrect answers themselves, and that
is what the Enquiry Committee has done. It would, we think, be
inappropriate in such a case to require direct evidence to show that
the respondent could have looked back and copied from the answer
written by the other candidate who was sitting behind him. There
was still the alternative possibility that the candidate sitting behind
may have copied from the respondent with his connivance. It is
also not unlikely that the two candidates may have talked to each
other. The atmosphere prevailing in the Examination Hall does not
rule out this possibility. These are all matters which the Enquiry
Committee had to consider, and the fact that the Enquiry
Committee did not write an elaborate report, does not mean that it
did not consider all the relevant facts before it came to the
conclusion that the respondent had used unfair means.
12.
In dealing with petitions of this type, it is necessary to bear
in mind that educational institutions like the Universities or
appellant No. 1 set up Enquiry Committees to deal with the
problem posed by the adoption of unfair means by candidates, and
normally it is within the jurisdiction of such domestic Tribunals to
decide all relevant questions in the light of the evidence adduced
before them. In the matter of the adoption of unfair means, direct
evidence may sometimes be available, but cases may arise where
direct evidence is not available and the question will have to be
considered in the light of probabilities and circumstantial evidence.
This problem which educational institutions have to face from time
to time is a serious problem and unless there is justification to do
so, courts should be slow to interfere with the decisions of
domestic Tribunals appointed by educational bodies like the
Universities. In dealing with the validity of the impugned orders
passed by Universities under Art. 226, the High Court is not sitting
in appeal over the decision in question; its jurisdiction is limited
and though it is true that if the impugned order is not supported by
any evidence at all, the High Court would be justified to quash that
order. But the conclusion that the impugned order is not supported
by any evidence must be reached after considering the question as
to whether probabilities and circumstantial evidence do not justify
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
the said conclusion. Enquiries held by domestic Tribunals in such
cases must, no doubt, be fair and students against whom charges
are framed must be given adequate opportunities to defend
themselves, and in holding such enquiries, the Tribunal, must
scrupulously follow rules of natural justice; but it would, we think,
not be reasonable to import into these enquiries all considerations
which govern criminal trials in ordinary courts of law. In the
present case, no animus is suggested and no malafides have been
pleaded. The enquiry has been fair and the respondent has had an
opportunity of making his defence. That being so, we think the
High Court was not justified in interfering with the order passed
against the respondent.”
44.6 Thus, the Supreme Court emphasized, in this judgment, the fact
that surrounding circumstances were also of relevance while deciding
whether the findings in the inquiry into the allegation of unfair means
merited interference in judicial review. Additionally, the Supreme
Court itself examined the incorrect answers and found that they were
identical. The answers, and the manner in which they were given,
according to the Supreme Court, clearly suggested that either
Bagleshwar had copied from the candidate bearing Roll Number
94733, or vice versa, or that both had copied from a common source.
44.7 The Supreme Court observed that the High Court had
proceeded on the premise that Bagleshwar was seated in front of the
candidate bearing Roll Number 94733, and there was no evidence to
indicate that Bagleshwar had turned back and copied from the
candidate behind him. It was equally possible, observed the Supreme
Court, that the candidate behind Bagleshwar had copied from him or
that both had copied from a common source. The atmosphere which
prevailed in the examination hall, especially, did not rule out such a
possibility. All these factors had weighed with the Inquiry Committee
in reaching at a finding against Bagleshwar, and the Supreme Court
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
had found that the High Court had failed to holistically consider all
these factors.
44.8 Finally, of course, the Supreme Court has, in para 12 of its
report, observed that direct evidence could not always be accepted in
cases of adoption of unfair means in examinations and that the
decisions of domestic Tribunals adopted by educational bodies to
inquire into such allegations would not ordinarily merit interference
in judicial review, unless there was justification to do so.
Bihar School Education Board v. Subhas Chandra Sinha15
45.1 The writ petition, from which the appeal before the Supreme
Court emanated in this case, was instituted by 36 school students,
challenging the decision of the Bihar School Examination Board16 to
cancel the Secondary School Examination of 1969 in respect of the
Hanswadih Centre in one district in Bihar. A mandamus to the BSEB,
to declare the results, was also sought.
45.2 The Supreme Court noted that 80% of the students who had
undertaken the examination at the Hanswadih Centre succeeded,
whereas the average at other centers was only 50%. The matter was
referred to the Unfair Means Committee of the BSEB, which
examined the answer books where the percentage was over 80% and
reported large scale use of unfair means. Following this, the decision
to cancel the examination was taken.
15 (1970) 1 SCC 648
16 “BSEB” hereinafter
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
45.3 The High Court, which was petitioned in the matter,
acknowledged that the high percentage of success at the Hanswadih
Center did give rise to a suspicion that unfair means were adopted.
However, as the material on which the BSEB proceeded was not
shown to the affected candidates, who were also not given an
opportunity to show cause, it was held that the principles of natural
justice were violated and, on that ground, the decision to cancel the
examination was set aside. A mandamus was issued, to declare the
results of the Hanswadih Center. The BSEB appealed to the Supreme
Court.
45.4 The Supreme Court observed, at the outset, that the opinion of
the Unfair Means Committee was by itself sufficient for taking action,
and that the results of the affected candidates had been withheld for
the purpose of completing enquiries. In the meanwhile, there was no
infirmity in the decision to declare the results of the candidates who
had appeared from other centers.
45.5 The Supreme Court further observed that while, at other
centers, the percentage of successful candidates was, on an average,
50%, the success rate of candidates who had undertaken the
examination at the Hanswadih Center was between 70% and 100%,
with over 90% in many subjects. To satisfy itself, the Supreme Court
also requisitioned some of the answer books for its own inspection,
and found that there was remarkable agreement in the answers in the
said answer book. This, according to the Supreme Court, indicated,
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
without doubt, that the students had received assistance from some
outside source. The finding that unfair means had been adopted by the
students who had undertaken the examination at the Hanswadih
Center was, therefore, found to be justified. We may reproduce, for
this purpose, paras 12 and 14 of the report, thus:
“12. These figures speak for themselves. However, to satisfy
ourselves we ordered that some answer books be brought for our
inspection and many such were produced. A comparison of the
answer books showed such a remarkable agreement in the answers
that no doubt was left in our minds that the students had assistance
from an outside source. Therefore the conclusion that unfair
means were adopted stands completely vindicated.
*****
14.
Reliance was placed upon Ghanshyam Das Gupta17 to
which we referred earlier. There the examination results of three
candidates were cancelled, and this Court held that they should
have received an opportunity of explaining their conduct. It was
said that even if the inquiry involved a large number of persons,
the Committee should frame proper regulations for the conduct of
such inquiries but not deny the opportunity. We do not think that
that case has any application. Surely it was not intended that where
the examination as a whole was vitiated, say by leakage of papers
or by destruction of some of the answer books or by discovery of
unfair means practised on a vast scale that an inquiry would be
made giving a chance to every one appearing at that examination
to have his say? What the Court intended to lay down was that if
any particular person was to be proceeded against, he must have a
proper chance to defend himself and this did not obviate the
necessity of giving an opportunity even though the number of
persons proceeded against was large. The Court was then not
considering the right of an examining body to cancel its own
examination when it was satisfied that the examination was not
properly conducted or that in the conduct of the examination the
majority of the examinees had not conducted themselves as they
should have. To make such decisions depend upon a full-fledged
judicial inquiry would hold up the functioning of such autonomous
bodies as Universities and School Board. While we do not wish to
whittle down the requirements of natural justice and fair-play in
cases where such requirement may be said to arise, we do not want
that this Court should be understood as having stated that an
17 Board of High School and Intermediate Education, U.P. v. Ghanshyam Das Gupta, (1962) 3 Supp
SCR 36
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
inquiry with a right to representation must always precede in every
case, however different. The universities are responsible for their
standards and the conduct of examinations. The essence of the
examinations is that the worth of every person is appraised without
any assistance from an outside source. If at a centre the whole
body of students receive assistance and are managed to secure
success in the neighbourhood of 100% when others at other centres
are successful only at an average of 50%, it is obvious that the
University or the Board must do something in the matter. It cannot
hold a detailed quasi-judicial inquiry with a right to its alumni to
plead and lead evidence etc., before the results are withheld or the
examinations cancelled. If there is sufficient material on which it
can be demonstrated that the university was right in its conclusion
that the examinations ought to be cancelled then academic
standards require that the university's appreciation of the problem
must be respected. It would not do for the Court to say that you
should have examined all the candidates or even their
representatives with a view to ascertaining whether they had
received assistance or not. To do this would encourage
indiscipline if not also perjury.”
(Emphasis supplied)
45.6 Thus, obtaining assistance from an outside source is
irreversibly fatal to the examination process. Also, this decision holds
that circumstantial evidence, if overwhelming in nature and capable
of vouchsafing the allegation that outside assistance was availed, is by
itself sufficient to cancel the entire examination.
Ghazanfar Rashid v. Board of High School and Intermediate
Education18
46.1 An instructive decision on the scope of interference with
decisions of administrative authorities inquiring into allegations of use
of unfair means in examinations is to be found in the judgment of the
Full Bench of the High Court of Allahabad in Ghazanfar Rashid v.
Board of High School and Intermediate Education, authored by
18 AIR 1979 All 209
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
K.N. Singh J (as he then was). In that case, the allegation of unfair
means was investigated by the Examinations Committee constituted
under the U.P. Intermediate Education Act, 1927. The Full Bench
relied on an earlier decision of another Full Bench of the Allahabad
High Court in Triambakanti Tripathi v. Board of High School19.
Paras 26 to 28 and 35 of the report are relevant, and may be
reproduced:
“26. A Full Bench of our Court in Triambakanti Tripathi v.
Board of High School, held that while considering the question of
use of unfair means the Examinations Committee would be
justified to draw inferences on the basis of answer books and other
materials that the examinee had answered the question by
adopting some improper method. The Examinations Committee is
entitled to base its evidence on intrinsic evidence provided by the
petitioner's own answer book. The Bench observed:
“In dealing with the validity of the order passed by such
authorities, the High Court does not sit in appeal over the
decision of the authority concerned, its jurisdiction is
limited and it is true that if the order in question is not
supported by any evidence at all, the High Court may quash
it, but the conclusion that the order is not supported by any
evidence must be reached after considering the question as
to whether probabilities and circumstantial evidence do not
justify that conclusion.”
27.
If the Examinations Committee relying on the probabilities
and circumstantial evidence and the intrinsic evidence available in
the answer book of the examinee comes to the conclusion that
unfair means was used it is outside the jurisdiction of the High
Court to re-appraise and re-assess the evidentiary value of those
circumstances to take a different view. The Examinations
Committee and the Screening Committee are constituted of
experts, they are the sole judges to determine the question of use of
unfair means on the basis of material present on record. Their
decision cannot be interfered with by this Court under Article 226
of the Constitution unless the decision is mala fide, arbitrary or
capricious. Any decision of an authority, quasi judicial or
administrative, is vitiated on the ground of mala fides. Similarly,
decision of a quasi judicial authority would be vitiated if it is based
on no evidence or if it is arbitrary and the conclusion to which the
19 AIR 1973 All 1
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
authority has arrived at could not be reached by any reasonable
person or body of persons.
28.
These principles are well settled but the real difficulty
arises in their application to the particular facts of a case. While
applying these principles it must be borne in mind that in case of
no evidence the order would be vitiated only when there is not a
single piece of evidence direct or indirect, oral or documentary, or
even circumstantial evidence based on probabilities to sustain the
decision of the authority concerned, but if there is some evidence
of circumstantial nature, which may even include probabilities, it
would not be a case of no evidence. Inadequacy of evidence does
not fall within the principle of no evidence. If there be any
evidence, howsoever weak it may be in its probative value, it will
not be a case of no evidence and the High Court has no
jurisdiction to interfere with the finding, Similarly, while
considering the question of arbitrariness it must be kept in mind
that if two views are possible on the material on record, and if the
Examinations Committee has bona fide taken one view, it is not
open to the High Court to interfere with that finding merely
because a different view is possible. The High Court can interfere
if the order is wholly arbitrary and so capricious that no
reasonable person could come to the conclusion on the material on
record, but if a person can reasonably come to that conclusion, the
High Court has no jurisdiction to interfere with the order. An
arbitrary decision of a quasi judicial authority would be perverse
and liable to be quashed. It is however not permissible to assume
possibilities or circumstances in support of the examinee's
innocence and then to interfere with the decision of the
Examinations Committee on the ground that there was no
conclusive evidence to hold the examinee guilty of the charge of
use of unfair means. If several probabilities are available in the
circumstances of a case, some of which support the examinee's
innocence, while other circumstances support the decision of the
Examinations Committee holding the examinee guilty, in that
situation it is not permissible to interfere with the decision of the
Examinations Committee as that would amount to appraisal of
evidence.
*****
35.
As discussed earlier, it is not open to this Court to interfere
with the order of the Examinations Committee on the ground that
another view could be taken on the material on record. In
answering questions relating to Mathematics and Physics or
Chemistry if necessary answer is arrived at by an examinee
through wrong working it would be reasonably possible for the
Examinations Committee to draw an inference that the examinee
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
had used unfair means. Even if it is possible that the examinee may
have omitted the necessary steps due to inadvertence or certain
reasons, it is for the Examinations Committee to consider that
explanation and it is not open to this Court to re-assess the
circumstances and to interfere with the decision of the
Examination Committee. If the Examinations Committee, relying
upon the probabilities of circumstantial evidence, comes to the
conclusion that the examinee had used unfair means, it is not open
to this Court to interfere with that order merely on the basis of
other possibilities. In all the aforesaid cases relied upon by the
petitioner, this Court held that absence of certain requisite steps did
not necessarily imply that the examinee must have used unfair
means. In each of the aforesaid cases the principle of Criminal trial
was applied as it was held that omission to record requisite
calculation or to take requisite steps could not be conclusive proof
of the fact that the examinee had used unfair means. These
decisions are in our opinion contrary to the principles laid down by
the Supreme Court in the cases discussed earlier. For the same
reason we do not approve the view taken by a learned Single Judge
of this Court in Promod Kumar Mittal's case20. In view of the law
laid down by the Supreme Court in Bagleshwar Prasad's case and
the Full Bench decision of our Court in Triambakpati Trtpathi's
case, we are of the opinion that cases relied upon by the petitioner,
namely, Udai Prakash Gautam v. Board of High School21;
Sarman Lal v. Board of High School22, Prem Nath Khanna v.
Board of High School, Promod Kumar Mittal v. State of U.P. and
Ajai Kumar v. Madhyamik Shiksha Parishad23, do not lay down
correct law. In the instant case the petitioner while answering
question No. 1 of Chemistry Second Paper had not taken necessary
steps, yet he arrived at the correct formula. We have earlier quoted
the answer given by the petitioner and also the steps which were
necessary to be undertaken before the formula could be arrived at.
The petitioner without proper working and requisite steps arrived
at the correct formula. The Screening Committee as well as the
Examinations Committee both were of the opinion that the
petitioner had no knowledge of the question and he got the correct
answer by means of some external source. Therefore he was guilty
for having used unfair means. The petitioner's answer to question
No. 1 contains intrinsic evidence to support the decision of the
Examinations Committee. The inference drawn by the
Examinations Committee that the petitioner solved the question by
using unfair means is a reasonable inference which cannot be
interfered with by this Court even if some other view is also
possible. The petitioner's contention that the impugned order is not
20 Promod Kumar Mittal v. State of U.P., 1973 ALJ 625
21 Judgment dated 26 August 1977 in WP 12048/1975
22 Judgment dated 5 May 1976 in WP 9538/1976
23 AIR 1979 All 13
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
based on any evidence and there is no material on record to support
the finding of the Examinations Committee is without any
substance.”
46.2 The Full Bench of the High Court of Allahabad has, clearly,
advocated a policy of near total lack of interference with the decision
of any expert Committee which may have inquired into the aspect of
use of unfair means in an examination. The Full Bench held that the
Court would not be justified in interfering with the conclusion of the
expert Committee solely on the ground that another conclusion was
also possible on the material which was available with the Committee,
as that would amount to re-appreciation of evidence.
46.3 Ghazanfar Rashid was approved by the Supreme Court in its
judgment in Maharashtra State Board of Secondary and Higher
Secondary Education v. K.S. Gandhi24:
29.
In Ghazanfar Rashid v. Secretary, Board of High School
and Intermediate Education, U.P. a Full Bench, speaking through
our learned brother K.N. Singh, J. (as he then was) dealing with the
standard of proof of the charge of use of unfair means at the
examination, it was held that it was the duty of the Examination
Committee etc., to maintain purity of examination and if examinee
is found to have used unfair means at the examination, it is the
duty of the Examination Committee to take action against the
erring examinees to maintain the educational standard. Direct
evidence is available in some cases but in a large number of cases
direct evidence is not available. In that situation the Examination
Committee has of necessity to rely on circumstantial evidence
which may include the answer given by the examinee, the report of
the Superintendent of the centre, the invigilator and the report of
the experts and other attending circumstances. The Examination
Committee, if it relies upon such evidence to come to the
conclusion that the examinee has used unfair means in answering
questions then it is not open to the High Court to interfere with
that decision, merely because the High Court may take a different
view on reassessment of those circumstances. While it is open to
24 (1991) 2 SCC 716
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
the High Court to interfere with the order of the quasi-judicial
authority, if it is not supported by any evidence or if the order is
passed in contravention of the statutory provisions of the law or in
violation of the principles of natural justice, the court has no
jurisdiction to quash the order merely on the ground that the
evidence available on record is insufficient or inadequate or on the
ground that different view could possibly be taken on the evidence
available on the record. The Examination Committee has
jurisdiction to take decision in the matter of use of unfair means
not only on direct evidence but also on probabilities and
circumstantial evidence. There is no scope for importing the
principles of criminal trial while considering the probative value of
probabilities and circumstantial evidence. The Examination
Committee is not bound by technical rules of evidence and
procedure as are applicable to courts. We respectfully agree with
the ratio.”
(Emphasis supplied)
46.4 It might not, however, be correct to apply the law declared by
the Full Bench in Ghazanfar Rashid, agnostic of the facts which were
before the Court in that case. The nature of the unfair means which
were alleged to have been employed by the candidate in that case is
qualitatively different from the unfair means which, allegedly, were
employed by the respondent in the case before us. The allegation
against the candidate, in the case before the Full Bench, was that he
had arrived at the correct answer, in respect of a question which
required proper working, following certain steps, before it could be
answered. The Examination Committee found that, without any
working, or following the steps which were required to be followed in
order to solve the question, the candidate had directly arrived at the
correct answer. The Full Bench held that the question of whether it
was possible to answer the problem posed to the candidate directly,
without resorting to any calculation or working, was one in which the
opinion of the Examinations Committee, which was possessed of the
requisite expertise in that regard, had to be respected. A Court did not
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
possess the expertise, or the intellectual wherewithal, to substitute its
own view, in such a case, for the view of the Examinations
Committee. The fact that the candidate arrived at the correct answer
without any working was regarded, by the Court, as “intrinsic
evidence”, contained in the answer provided by the candidate itself,
which would support the findings of the Examinations Committee.
46.5 No such allegation plagues the respondent before us. While
examining the extent to which the decision of the Full Bench of the
High Court of Allahabad in Ghazanfar Rashid would apply,
therefore, we have to bear in mind the off-quoted truism, in law, that
the precedential value of decisions has to be understood in the light of
the facts which were before the Court. Apropos judgments of the
Supreme Court, this principle has been reiterated in several
authorities25, which hold that judgments of courts are not to be likened
to theorems of Euclid, and blind adherence to the law declared, even if
by the Supreme Court, innocent of the issue and the facts which were
before the Court, and the context in which the ratio was rendered, may
not be appropriate.
47.
Maharashtra State Board of Secondary and
Secondary Education v. K.S. Gandhi
Higher
47.1 It was alleged, in this case, that the moderators’ mark sheets, in
the case of 283 candidates who had undertaken the examination in
question, were fabricated and the marks increased, with the
25 Refer Chintels (India) Ltd v. Bhayana Builders (P) Ltd, (2021) 4 SCC 602, Sanjay Dubey v. State of
M.P., (2023) 17 SCC 187, Natwar Singh v. Director of Enforcement, (2010) 13 SCC 255 and C.C.E. v.
Alnoori Tobacco Products, (2024) 6 SCC 186, among several others
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
connivance of the candidates or their parents and guardians. The
Standing Committee which enquired into the allegation found it to be
substantiated.
47.2 One of the submissions before the Supreme Court was that the
parents and guardians were not allowed to participate in the enquiry,
which vitiated it. The Supreme Court observed that, even though the
parents/guardians of the students were not allowed to participate in the
enquiry, the students themselves, when questioned, identified their
answer sheets and also admitted that, in the moderators’ mark sheets,
their marks had been increased to the advantage. However, they
denied any complicity, in this act, either of their parents/guardians or
of themselves.
47.3 The Supreme Court noted that, even while so denying any
complicity, the students did not contend that they were coerced to
answer the questions in a particular manner.
47.4 In affirming the view of the authorities and rejecting the plea of
the students, the Supreme Court placed reliance on its earlier decisions
in Bagleshar Prasad and Subhas Chandra Sinha, as well as the
judgment of the Full Bench of the High Court of Allahabad in
Ghazanfar Rashid (in para 29 of the report, already extracted supra),
before providing its own reasons. Paras 26, 27 and 38 to 40 of the
report are of relevance, and maybe reproduced thus:
“26. Counsel on either side generated considerable debate on
“the standard of proof” in a domestic enquiry. Sri Jaitley placed
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
reliance on paragraph 19 of Vol. 17 of Halsbury's Laws of
England, 4th edn. at page 16, which reads thus:
“19. Standard of proof.— To succeed on any issue the party
bearing the legal burden of proof must (1) satisfy a judge or
jury of the likelihood of the truth of his case by adducing a
greater weight of evidence than his opponent, and (2)
adduce evidence sufficient to satisfy them to the required
standard or degree of proof. The standard differs in
criminal and civil cases.
In civil cases the standard of proof is satisfied on a
balance of probabilities. However, even within this formula
variations in subject matter or in allegations will affect the
standard required; the more serious the allegation, for
example fraud, crime or professional misconduct, the
higher will be the required degree of proof, although it will
not reach the criminal standard.
In criminal cases, the standard required of the
prosecution is proof beyond reasonable doubt. This
standard is also requisite in cases of committal for
contempt, and in pension claims cases.
In matrimonial cases it seems that proof on balance
of probabilities is sufficient.
Once a matter is established beyond reasonable
doubt it must be taken for all purposes of law to be a fact,
as there is no room for a distinction between what is found
by inference from the evidence and what is found as a
positive fact.”
and contended that the standard of proof of fabrication of record in
a domestic inquiry does not differ from criminal charge and it must
be of a higher degree. In the Board of High School and
Intermediate Education, U.P. v. Bagleshar Persad, relied on by
Sri Andhyarujana the facts were that the appellant Board accepting
the findings of the Committee that the respondent used unfair
means in answering the subjects, cancelled the declaration of the
results of the respondent in the High School Certificate
Examination held in 1960. The charges were based on the facts
that in the Hindi paper the respondent gave wrong answers to a
particular question in the same way in which the answers have
been given by another candidate who was having consecutive
number. The High Court held that the findings of the Committee
were based on no evidence and quashed the cancellation of the
results. On appeal, this Court held that the respondent admitted that
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
the mistakes in answers in the two papers were identical and he
pleaded that he could not say anything as to why this happened.
The proof of charges was inferred that as either the respondent
copied from the answer book of the candidate with the consecutive
number or that it was conveyed by the said candidate or that both
of them had copied from any other source. It was accordingly held
that it would amount to the adoption of unfair means. The High
Court, therefore, committed error in assuming that there is no
evidence in proof of it. At page 774 this Court further held that in
dealing with question as to whether the Committee was justified in
arriving at its conclusion against the respondent it would not be
reasonable to exclude from the consideration of the circumstances
on which the whole enquiry came to be held and the general
background of the atmosphere in the examination hall. It was also
further held at page 775 that educational institutions like the
universities set up enquiry committees to deal with the problem of
adoption of unfair means by candidate and normally it is within the
jurisdiction of such domestic tribunals to decide all relevant
questions in the light of the evidence adduced before them. In the
matter of the adoption of unfair means direct evidence may
sometimes be available but cases may arise where direct evidence
is not available and the question will have to be considered in the
light of the probabilities and circumstantial evidence. This is the
problem with the educational institutions. How to face it, is a
serious problem and unless there is justification to do so, court
should be slow to interfere with the decisions of domestic tribunal
appointed by the educational body like universities. In dealing with
the validity of the impugned order passed by the universities under
Article 226 the High Court is not sitting in an appeal over the
decision on this question. Its jurisdiction is limited and though it is
true that if the impugned order is not supported by any evidence,
the High Court may be justified to quash the order. But the
conclusion that the impugned order is not supported by any
evidence must be reached after considering the question as to
whether the probabilities and circumstantial evidence do not
justify the said conclusion. The enquiry held by domestic tribunals
in such cases must, no doubt be fair and the students must be given
adequate opportunity to defend themselves and in holding such
enquiries, the tribunal must follow the rules of natural justice.
Accordingly, it was held that the appeal was allowed and the order
of the High Court was set aside and that of the domestic tribunal
was confirmed.
27.
In Bihar School Examination Board v. Subhas Chandra
Sinha, this Court emphasised that the essence of an examination is
that the worth of every person is appraised without any assistance
from an outside source. The academic standards require that the
authority's appreciation of the problem must be respected. A fullSignature Not Verified
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
fledged judicial inquiry was not required. It is not necessary to
conduct an inquiry in each individual case to satisfy itself who are
the candidates that have adopted unfair means when the
examination as a whole had to go. It was further held at p. 968-F to
H that:
“While we do not wish to whittle down the requirements of
natural justice and fair play in cases where such
requirement may be said to arise, we do not want that this
Court should be understood as having stated that an inquiry
with a right to representation must always precede in every
case, however different. The universities are responsible for
their standards and the conduct of the examinations. The
essence of the examinations is that the worth of every
person is appraised without any assistance from an outside
source ….
The University or the Board cannot hold a detailed quasijudicial inquiry with a right to its alumni to plead and lead
evidence etc. before the results are withheld or
examinations cancelled. If there is sufficient material on
which it could be demonstrated that the Authority was right
in its conclusion that the examination ought to be cancelled
then academic standards require that the Authority's
appreciation of the problem must be respected. It would not
be for the courts to say that we should have examined all
the candidates or even their representatives with a view to
ascertaining whether they had received assistance or not.
To do this, would encourage indiscipline, if not also
perjury.”
It is true as stated by Sri Chidambaram that the above ratio was
laid in the context of the cancellation of examination of the entire
centre. But the general principles must be kept in view while
dealing with the problem faced by the academic institutions.
*****
38.
From this legal setting we have to consider whether the
inference deduced by the Education Standing Committee that the
fabrication of moderators' mark sheets was done at the behest of
either the examinee or the parent or guardian is based on the
evidence on record. It is already found that the examinees admitted
the forgery of their concerned moderators' mark sheets resulting in
the increase of marks to their advantage. The fabrication of the
moderators' mark sheets was done after the scrutiny by the
concerned officials in the office of the State Board at Bombay and
before the moderators' mark sheets were taken out to Pune to feed
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
the computer. Why one is expected or interested to wade through
eighty thousand moderators' mark sheets to locate only the 283
examinees' mark sheets and add marks by fabrication? Unless
either the examinee or parent or guardian approached the
fabricator; gave the number and instructed him/them to fabricate
the marks, it would not be possible to know their number to
fabricate. The act of fabrication is an offence. Merely that it was
done in one subject or more than one makes little difference. Its
gravity is not mitigated if it is committed in one subject alone. This
is not an innocent act or a casual mistake during the course of
performance of the official duty as is sought to be made out. It was
obviously done as a concerted action. In view of the admitted facts
and above circumstances the necessary conclusion that could
unerringly be drawn would be that either the examinee or the
parent or guardian obviously was a privy to the fabrication and
that the forgery was committed at his or her or parent's or
guardian's behest. It is, therefore, clear that the conclusion
reached by the Education Standing Committee that the fabrication
was done at the instance of either the examinees or their parents or
guardians is amply borne out from the record. The High Court in
our view overstepped its supervisory jurisdiction and trenched into
the arena of appreciation of evidence to arrive at its own
conclusions on the specious plea of satisfying ‘conscience of the
court’.
39.
The question then is whether the rules relating to mode of
punishment indicated in the Appendix ‘A’ to the resolution are
invalid. We have given our anxious thought to the contention and
to the view of the High Court. In our view the punishments
indicated in the last column is only the maximum from which it
cannot be inferred that it left no discretion to the disciplinary
authority. No axiomatic rule can be laid that the rule making
authority intended that under no circumstances, the Examination
Committee could award lesser penalty. It depends on the nature
and gravity of the misconduct to be dealt with by the disciplinary
authority. In a given case, depending on the nature and gravity of
the misconduct lesser punishment may be meted out. So by mere
prescription of maximum penalty rules do not become invalid.
40.
We have no hesitation to conclude that when the evidence
justified the Education Standing Committee to record the finding
that the examinees, parents or guardians are parties to the
fabrication, it is not open to the High Court under Article 226 to
itself evaluate the evidence and to interfere with the finding and to
quash the impugned notification. This Court under Article 136 has
to correct the illegalities committed by the High Court when it
exceeded its supervisory jurisdiction under Article 226. In view of
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
the fair attitude adopted by the counsel for the Board, it is not
necessary to go into the question of quantum of punishment.”
47.5 The Supreme Court, therefore, held, in this case, that, if the
evidence justified the conclusion of the Committee which was
examining the aspect of unfair means, the High Court, under Article
226 of the Constitution, was not empowered to itself re-appreciate the
material and arrive at a contrary conclusion. The issue before the
Supreme Court was whether, without examining the parents or
guardians of the students, the Committee was justified in concluding
that they were complicit in fabrication of the marks awarded to the
students in the moderators’ mark sheets. Inasmuch as (i) the students
identified their answer books, (ii) the students acknowledged the fact
that their marks had been fabricated therein, to their advantage, and
(iii) without being informed by the student, or her, or his, parent or
guardian, of the details of the student, the fabricator would obviously
not be able to know where the fabrication was required to be
undertaken, the Supreme Court held that it was an inevitable
conclusion that the examinee, or her, or his, parent or guardian, was
party to the fabrication of the marks. All necessary ingredients, as
would lead to an inevitable conclusion of complicity being present, the
Supreme Court held that the failure to examine the parents or
guardians of the students was not fatal to the conclusion of the
Committee.
47.6 Further, the Supreme Court also clarified, in para 29 of the
report, that the tests adopted by the earlier decision in K.S. Gandhi
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
would also apply where certain students were being debarred, instead
of cancelling the entire examination.
University of Delhi v. Deepak26
48.1 We may finally refer to a recent judgment of the Coordinate
Bench of this Court in University of Delhi vs. Deepak. The dispute in
that case related to an examination for filling up vacancies of nonteaching posts in the Delhi University27 conducted by the National
Testing Agency28. 151 candidates were selected, in order of merit, for
the post of Laboratory Attendant. During interaction with these
candidates, the University found that they lacked basic knowledge
required for the post for which they had been selected, though they
had secured very high marks in the examination, which included
questions relating to science and mathematics. Suspecting use of
unfair means by them, the University placed their joining on hold,
while selecting the remaining candidates. This decision was
challenged by the candidate before this court. A learned Single Judge
allowed the writ petition, quashed and set aside the decision to defer
the joining of the said candidates and directed the University to
complete the process of document verification, take the process of
selection to its logical conclusion and appoint the candidates.
48.2 Aggrieved thereby, the University of Delhi filed a Letters
Patent Appeal, which has come to be allowed by the Division Bench
by the judgment under discussion.
26 2026 SCC OnLine Del 6744
27 “University” hereinafter
28 “NTA” hereinafter
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
48.3 We may note, at the outset, that the relevance of this decision
may be limited by the fact that the challenge, before this Court, was to
the holding up of the results of the suspected candidates, pending
inquiry. The Division Bench has, at more than one place in the
decision, noted that the existence or otherwise of culpability on the
part of the candidates whose results had been withheld would become
apparent only following a full-scale inquiry. The Division Bench was,
therefore, concerned with the issue of whether a case for judicial
review of the decision to withhold the results of the candidates whose
performance was under scrutiny, was, or was not, made out. We, in
the present case, are, on the other hand, concerned with a case in
which the inquiry has concluded, and the respondent has been found
guilty of using unfair means, resulting in the awarding of the drastic
punishment not only of cancellation of her candidature, but also of
debarment from participation in further examinations held by the SSC
for 7 years.
48.4 The Division Bench noted that the Committee which had
enquired into the matter had observed that the successful candidates
were disproportionately concentrated in a few specific examination
centres and that there was substantial disparity between the marks
scored by the students who attempted the examination from the said
centres, when compared with the marks scored by them in Classes X
and XII. A visible pattern, in the correct and incorrect responses of the
candidates from the suspected centres, and the fact that the said
candidates had not left any questions unattempted, was also noted.
This Court held that, in such circumstances, “in the context of an
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
objective examination, particularly one involving negative marking,
the absence of any questions that are not attempted, when coupled
with commonality in incorrect answers and high scores from the same
centres, was a relevant circumstance for accessing whether the
declared result reflected genuine merit”. The Court further observed
that the findings of the Committee “were not based merely on
subjective impressions, but on data analysis undertaken by the
Committee and placed on record in the form of colour-coded Excel
sheets and other comparative material”, which “furnished a cogent
basis for the University to establish serious doubt regarding the
sanctity of the examination process”. The relevant question, in such
cases, was “whether the selected candidates from the identified
centres displayed patterns which, when tested against the available
data, gave rise to a reasonable inference that the examination process
had been compromised”. This Court also noted that, in such a large
recruitment examination, in which candidates from across the country
participated, “the emergence of a disproportionately large number of
successful candidates from a few contiguous or approximate regions
was not an ordinary feature and was rightly treated by the University
as a matter requiring closer examination”. “Such concentration of
successful candidates from limited geographical pockets, when viewed
in conjunction with other material circumstances noticed by the
Committee”, according to this Court, “constituted a relevant
circumstance supporting the University’s decision to subject the
fairness of the selection process to further scrutiny”.
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
48.5 We do not deem it necessary, or even appropriate, to advert
further to the observations and findings contained in the judgment of
the Division Bench, as the Court was, in that case, only concerned
with whether the decision of the University, to subject the
performance of certain candidates to further scrutiny data, or did not,
called for interference. Quite obviously, the extent of judicial enquiry,
in a case where the matter was still being enquired into at the
administrative level, would be far more lenient than the extent of
enquiry which would be justified in a case in which the administrative
enquiry has completed and punishment meted out.
48.6 Nonetheless, the decision in Deepak is important in one respect,
with which we are entirely in concurrence. One of the arguments
advanced before this Court, in the said case, was that, in subjecting
students at certain specific centres to investigation, discrimination had
resulted. This Court negatived the contention. Paras 32 to 34 of the
report are, in this context, relevant:
“32. Further, the University was justified in analysing the data
pertaining to the suspected centres, which were identified on the
basis that at least three successful candidates had emerged from
each of the said centres. The object of the exercise was not to
undertake an abstract statistical study of the entire examination, but
to examine whether the merit list, to the extent it reflected an
abnormal concentration of successful candidates from suspected
centres, disclosed indicators of manipulation or adoption of unfair
means. Once the concern of the University arose from the
concentration of selected candidates at specific centres, it was both
reasonable and permissible for the Committee to focus its scrutiny
on those centres where such concentration was found.
33.
The centres from which no candidate was selected, or from
which no meaningful cluster of selected candidates emerged, were
not required to be examined as such centres did not contribute to
the impugned merit pattern which had prompted the inquiry. The
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
purpose of the Committee's analysis was to assess the credibility of
the selection of successful candidates and not to determine, in
isolation, whether every examination centre in the country had
functioned without any irregularity. In cases of suspected
examination malpractice, the inquiry may legitimately be centred
on the class of candidates and centres which reveal statistically
unusual or otherwise suspicious features. Such a focused inquiry
cannot be characterised as selective merely because it did not
extend, with equal detail, to centres from which no candidate was
selected or from which no abnormal pattern emerged.
34.
Accordingly, we of the view that the methodology adopted
by the University cannot be rejected solely on the ground that it
did not analyse all candidates across all centres. The relevant
question was whether the selected candidates from the identified
centres displayed patterns which, when tested against the available
data, gave rise to a reasonable inference that the examination
process had been compromised.”
(Emphasis supplied)
48.7 The finding, in the impugned judgment of the Tribunal that, in
the decision of the SSC to select, for enquiry, centres where there were
more than five cases of de-mapping, was arbitrary cannot, therefore,
be accepted. Latitude has to be retained with the examining authority
to take an informed decision as to the extent of enquiry to be
conducted. So long as there is an intelligible differentia guiding the
said decision, the Court would not castigate it as arbitrary. The
decision to subject the examination centres in which more than five
cases of de-mapping had been found, to further enquiry cannot,
therefore, be it so regarded as arbitrary.
D.III Applying the law to the facts
49.
Before proceeding further, we may note that Mr. Haseeb,
learned CGSC, with characteristic forthrightness, acknowledged the
fact that debarring of Himanshi from participating in any further
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
examination of the SSC for 7 years might be too extreme a penalty.
Despite this frank acknowledgement, if we were to arrive at the
ultimate conclusion that the findings of the Committee regarding
employment of unfair means by Himanshi does not merit interference,
it would be arguable whether we would have the jurisdiction to reduce
the penalty below the statutorily envisaged punishment of cancellation
of candidature accompanied by 7 years’ debarment. The validity of
the said punishment per se is not under challenge.
50.
Be that as it may, for reasons which follow hereinafter, we are
of the opinion that, in the present case, the decision to cancel the
candidature of Himanshi and penalize her with 7 years’ debarment is
not justified on facts or in law.
51.
Before setting out our reasons for so holding, we may observe
that the manner in which the Tribunal has dealt with the issue cannot
be regarded as satisfactory. There is no detailed examination of the
law or the facts of the case, even in so far as they apply to the
respondents. Further, the Tribunal has clubbed the case of 34
applicants before it in individual OAs into one judgment which
examines the facts only in the case of Himanshi, despite the facts
obtaining – and, in certain cases, the allegations levelled – being
different. The impugned judgment fails to notice these differences.
52.
Inasmuch as the present judgment is restricted to the case of
Himanshi, the applicant in OA 2953/2022, we are not commenting on
the impugned judgment insofar as it relates to other applicants before
the Tribunal.
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
53.
Clearly, the question of whether the decision against Himanshi
was, or was not, sustainable, would have to be decided essentially on
the basis of the findings of the scrutiny committee, which have been
reproduced in extenso in para 17 supra.
54.
The adverse observations contained in the said report covers all
the candidates whose performance was under scrutiny. They are,
therefore, generalized in nature, with the Annexures to the report
referring to the individual candidates.
55.
We are, therefore, restricting our examination, in this judgment,
to the issue of whether the report makes out a case of use of unfair
means by Himanshi. This judgment should not, therefore, be regarded
as a final pronouncement on the allegation of use of unfair means by
any of the other candidates whose candidatures were cancelled
following the report of the Committee.
56.
Having set out the factors which the Committee was supposed
to be taken into consideration in para 6, the Report further observes
that
(i)
with respect to Avirat,
(a)
the terminals of almost all candidates had been
shifted before closure of the entry gate,
(b)
it seemed that there were some fixed compromised
terminals in every lab,
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
(c)
most of the suspected candidates had been shifted
only to these terminals,
(d)
almost all the shifted candidates had not
complained about non-working of the old terminals,
(e)
rather, the candidates had been told by the
invigilators to shift to the other terminal,
(f)
in one or two cases, the earlier terminal of the
shifted candidate was later used by some other candidate,
thereby indicating that there was no fault in the said
terminal and that the shifting was with ill motives,
(g)
most of the suspected candidates were the first to
report at the frisking point and then in the lab, and
(h)
in some cases, it also seemed that CCTV footage
had been doctored, and
(i)
many candidates had answered the questions in a
very short duration,
(ii)
the table showing IP addresses used more than once in
the same shift in the given venue was annexed as Annexure 5 to
the report, which revealed that some IP addresses and MAC
addresses had been used frequently by the venues for the
compromised systems,
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
(iii)
the allegedly compromised system, to which the
candidates were shifted “seemed to have been taken either on
remote access or the actual system (was) outside the exam hall
of the same LAN and the screen (was) shared to the screen
(monitor) of the candidates”,
(iv)
it seemed that a team was sitting outside the examination
hall or at a remote place, attempting the questions,
(v)
to answer GK questions, probably help of a search engine
had been taken and
(vi)
it further seemed that one subject was attempted at the
first terminal at a slow pace and the remaining subjects were
attempted at the terminal to which the candidates were shifted at
a fast pace.
57.
We are in agreement with Mr. Mittal that such findings could
not constitute a basis to cancel the candidature of Himanshi. There is
not a single conclusive finding. Every observation, and every finding,
is tentative in character. The penalizing of a candidate on the basis of
such presumptuous and tentative observations is, by itself,
unsustainable in law.
58.
The report notes that, despite strong apprehensions following
these observations, benefit of doubt had been given to some
candidates. Why such benefit of doubt was extended, and how the
candidates to whom such benefit of doubt was extended were different
from the others to whom the Committee was not so generous, is left
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
blissfully unsaid.
59.
The Annexures to the report deal with the material against the
individual candidate. Insofar as the respondent Himanshi is concerned,
it is noted that she was not traceable on the CCTV. As such, there is
no photographic or videographic material on the basis of which the
shifting of Himanshi to another terminal could be concluded as having
been done for any ulterior motive.
60.
Further, the SSC has itself acknowledged, over 44000
candidates were demapped, all over India.
As such, shifting of
terminals, when the allotted terminal was not working properly, was
not unusual and, quite certainly, this fact by itself could not invite any
adverse inference.
61.
A major discrepancy
61.1 In the case of Himanshi, there is another, glaring discrepancy,
which reflects near total non-application of mind. The affidavit in
rejoinder filed by the SSC identifies the IP/MAC addresses of
Himanshi’s original terminal and the terminal to which she was
shifted. This allegation is completely at variance with the Report of
the Committee.
61.2 The MAC id/IP addresses of the systems to which the candidates
had been shifted and which were allegedly compromised are also
noted in the Annexures to the report. Insofar as Himanshi is
concerned, no such MAC address or IP address has been identified.
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
61.3 Para 23(d) of the rejoinder affidavit filed by the SSC reads thus:
“d.
The MAC ID history further shows the following seat
chronology: Candidate was seated on computer node with MAC
No. 7845C4368CC2 from 13:04:00 to 13:24:53 (23 minutes 53
seconds). During this period candidate has visited only 14
questions of which she has given final response of only 7
questions.
Further, candidate was seated on computer node with MAC No.
D4BED9CCAA3B from 13:28:49 to 13:49:02 (20 minutes 13
seconds) However, during this period remaining 84 questions were
attempted. Hence, as per the logs it can be clearly seen behavioural
shift inconsistent with human test pattern.”
61.4 This allegation is reiterated in para 26 of the rejoinder, thus:
“Immediately, after seat change, in 20 Minutes 13 seconds, final
responses of 91 questions were given out of which 74 Questions
were attempted on their first visit (81.3%). Then remaining 16
Minutes 54 seconds candidates did not attempt any question.”
62.
Annexure 5 to their report of the Committee, however, enlists
the IP/Mac addresses used more than once at a given venue. The table
reads thus:
Annexure-5
IP/Mac addresses used more than once in a given venue
Center Name
Venue
IP Address
Mac Address
Number
Code
Anuradha Digital Services
14945
10.1.1.240
80C16EE5365F
Anuradha Digital Services
14945
10.1.1.241
E8393536C9A1
Anuradha Digital Services
14945
10.1.1.239
24BE050F8F03
Anuradha Digital Services
14945
10.1.11.18
3CD92B6C83AB
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
Anuradha Digital Services
14945
10.1.1.143
80C16EEE03A1
Avirat Education Society
10.1.1.11
1803734B8119
Avirat Education Society
10.1.2.7
D4BED9DB5CFC
Avirat Education Society
10.1.2.9
4437E6C27DA1
Avirat Education Society
10.1.2.13
FC4DD432273C
Om Kothari Institute of
16638
10.3.8.35
14FEB5E945AB
16638
10.3.8.13
BC305BC71F65
16638
10.2.5.69
AC162D113BC2
16638
10.3.8.39
BC305BB3150E
16638
10.3.8.18
B4B52FCEC45
16638
10.2.5.17
A0D3C1058088
16638
10.2.4.43
B8AC6F3DDF42
RSM Finserv Ltd.
10.1.1.39
002264AC5FBA
RSM FInserv LTd.
10.1.2.134
001D607186D8
Management
And
Research
Om Kothari Institute of
Management
And
Research
Om Kothari Institute of
Management
And
Research
Om Kothari Institute of
Management
And
Research
Om Kothari Institute of
Management
And
Research
Om Kothari Institute of
Management
And
Research
Om Kothari Institute of
Management
And
Research
63.
The four allegedly compromised terminals in Avirat were,
therefore
having
the
Mac/IP
addresses
1803734B8119,
D4BED9DB5CFC, 4437E6C27DA1 and FC4DD432273C.
The
terminal to which Himanshi was shifted, as per para 23(d) of the
rejoinder affidavit, viz. MAC No. D4BED9CCAA34B, was not a
compromised terminal.
64.
This single factor, by itself, is sufficient to discredit the finding
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
that Himanshi had resorted to unfair means.
65.
This is all the more so as there is no other evidence against
Himanshi, except the allegation that she attempted a majority of the
examination from the second, allegedly compromised, terminal. Once
the second terminal used by Himanshi is not found by the Committee
to be one of the compromised terminals at Avirat, this allegation loses
all substance.
66.
Besides, there is no CCTV footage available in the case of
Himanshi, on the basis of which it could be alleged that she had not
found anything amiss in her terminal or that the invigilator had on his
own asked her to shift to another terminal without any complaint. The
circumstances in which Himanshi shifted to another terminal are also
unknown. There is nothing to indicate that the said terminal was
compromised or that the other candidates had used the same terminal
in a manner similar to Himanshi.
67.
The averments in the rejoinder of SSC, and the report of the
Committee, are also discordant with respect to the number of
questions attempted by Himanshi, and the time taken by her to do so.
The Committee Report alleges that she attempted 15 questions in the
first 29 minutes on the terminal allotted to her, and the remaining 84
questions in the remaining 21 minutes in the terminal to which she
was shifted. As against this, the rejoinder affidavit alleges that she
attempted 14 questions, of which 7 were finally attempted, at the first
terminal in 20 minutes and 53 seconds, and 74 questions on the
second terminal in the following 20 minutes and 13 seconds.
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
68.
The Committee report alleges that Himanshi did not attempt
any question in the last 10 minutes, whereas the rejoinder affidavit
alleges that she did not attempt any question in the last 16 minutes.
69.
Clearly, therefore, at least in the case of Himanshi, there is
manifest non-application of mind.
70.
Further, though it is alleged that the candidates might have been
benefiting from persons seated outside the examination hall, who may
have been operating via a LAN connection, there is no finding of the
existence of any such LAN connection. No person seated outside the
examination hall has been identified, and there is in fact nothing to
indicate, except a bare doubt, that any such person existed.
71.
Apparently aware of this position, it has also been alleged that it
was possible that there may have been remote access software loaded
on the computers to which the candidates were shifted, through which
the paper was being attempted from some remote location. At least in
the case of Himanshi, as the terminal itself has not been identified,
there can be no finding, even tentative, of the existence of any remote
access software on the terminal. Indeed, there is no such finding in
the case of Himanshi anywhere in the report.
72.
Besides, there is no reference of any specific “remote control
software” having been found on the terminal to which Himanshi was
shifted. No person who was operating the terminal from any such
remote location has been identified.
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
As in the case of all other
findings, this, too, remains in the realm of wild speculation.
73.
The report also alleges that the terminal which was originally
used by the candidate, in one or two cases, was later used by other
candidates, thereby demonstrating that the terminal was functioning
properly and that the shifting of the candidate to the other terminal
was mala fide. In the case of Himashi, there is no such finding. There
is not even an observation, in the report of the committee, to the effect
that the terminal which was originally allotted to Himanshi, and from
which she was shifted, was satisfactorily used later by some other
candidate.
74.
We have little doubt in our mind that, if all, or even some of
these circumstances were found to exist in the case of a particular
candidate, the finding of the committee, to the effect that the candidate
had indulged in malpractice or unfair means, may not be susceptible to
interference in judicial review. In the case of Himanshi, the facts are
markedly extreme. The discrepancies and lacunae are too numerous
to ignore. None of the boxes are ticked. None of the factors which
are acknowledged, even in the report of the committee, as being
determinative while deciding that a candidate had indulged in unfair
means, stands satisfied in the case of Himanshi.
75.
Even otherwise, we are of the considered view that the single
factor of the number of questions attempted by Himanshi at the two
terminals from which she undertook the examination, by itself, is not
even treated, by the Committee in its Report, as being by itself
determinative of use of unfair means by a candidate. Indeed, the stand
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
of Himanshi was that the initial terminal allotted to her was defective.
There is no material, on record, in the report of the Committee or
outside it, on the basis of which this assertion can be doubted. The
fact that many such terminals were defective is clear from the demapping of over 44000 candidates, though only 70 cases have been
found to be tainted. If the initial terminal was in fact defective, one
cannot compare the performance of the candidate on that terminal
with the performance of the candidate on a properly working terminal.
The fact that Himanshi was able to attempt the questions to the
terminal to which she was shifted correctly cannot, therefore, be
treated as a factor against her. One cannot be penalised for performing
well.
76.
We reiterate that there is no material to indicate that the
terminal to which Himanshi was shifted was compromised in any
way. The MAC id and the IP address of the terminal, as pleaded in
the rejoinder affidavit, clearly indicate, when compared with
Annexure 5 to the Committee Report, that it was not, in fact,
compromised.
77.
There is nothing to indicate that any candidate was helping
Himanshi from outside the examination hall or that there was any
remote control software installed on the terminal to which she was
shifted. There is nothing to indicate that any other candidates had
worked on the same terminal with similar results, either.
78.
There is also nothing to indicate that the initial terminal allotted
to Himanshi was working satisfactorily.
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
79.
The report of the Committee itself observes that, in the case of
certain candidates, though there was material against them, the
Committee had decided to extend them the benefit of doubt. In the
case of Himanshi, we are of the opinion that she was entitled, in the
face of such circumstances, to be completely exonerated and, at the
very least, to be extended the “benefit of doubt”.
80.
We, therefore, are of the opinion that, in the case of Himanshi,
the finding that she had resorted to unfair means and their consequent
decision to cancel her candidature and debar her from undertaking any
further SSC examination for 7 years, is not sustainable in law or on
facts.
81.
We have, while arriving at our conclusions, kept in mind the
principles laid down by the Supreme Court in the decisions to which
we ourselves have adverted earlier in this judgment.
The Supreme
Court has, no doubt, held that courts must be circumspect in
interfering with the decisions of Committees which examine cases of
unfair means. At the same time, judicial review in such cases is not
irremediably foreclosed. Our decision to hold as we have, is
influenced, to more little extent, by the fact that the very factors
which, according to the Committee in its report, were determinative of
the complicity, or otherwise, of the candidate in adopting unfair
means, do not operate against Himanshi, as there is no finding, with
respect to any of these factors, against her. Even on the basis of the
tests laid down by the Committee in its report, therefore, the finding
that Himanshi had resorted to unfair means is not sustainable.
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
82.
We have already noted that the Tribunal has not, in the
impugned judgment, examined the matter as comprehensively as was
required in the circumstances. We have, therefore, adverted in detail
to the report of the Committee, to satisfy ourselves that a case for
interference is made out.
83.
We, therefore, for the above reasons, are in agreement with the
Tribunal to the extent it holds that the cancellation of the candidature
of Himanshi, and debarring her from undertaking any further SSC
examination for 7 years, was not sustainable on facts or in law.
E.
Conclusion
84.
For the aforesaid reasons, we do not deem this to be a case
meriting interference with the ultimate decision of the Tribunal.
85.
The writ petition is accordingly dismissed, with no order as to
costs.
86.
Resultant orders in the case of Himanshi, in accordance with
law, be passed within a period of four weeks from today.
87.
We make it clear that the present judgment is restricted to
examining the sustainability of the cancellation of candidature and 7
years debarment in the case of Himanshi. As this Court held in its very
first order dated 6 October 2025, this writ petition would be restricted
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
to the case of Himanshi, with liberty granted to the SSC to file
individual writ petitions qua the other petitioners. Such writ petitions
have been filed and they are listed on other dates. The merit of those
petitions would be examined individually.
C. HARI SHANKAR, J.
VINOD KUMAR, J.
SEPTEMBER 24, 2026
AR/dsn
W.P.(C) 15273/2025
KUMAR
16:09:29
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review