Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of decision: 17th September, 2026
#
CNR No. DLHC010442232026
+
W.P.(C) 13628/2026, CM APPL. 63646/2026 – STAY & CM
APPL. 63647/2026 – EXMP. FROM FILING CERTIFIED
COPIES
1.
UNION OF INDIA, THROUGH
THE SECRETARY, MINISTRY OF DEFENCE,
SOUTH BLOCK,
DHQ PQ, NEW DELHI-110011
PHONE: +91-88601-89238
E-MAIL: thechambers.srs@gmail.com
...PETITIONER NO. 1
2.
THE CHIEF OF THE ARMY STAFF, THROUGH
INTEGRATED HQ OF MINISTRY OF DEFENCE (ARMY),
SOUTH BLOCK, DHQ PO, NEW DELHI-110011
PHONE: +91-88601-89238
E-MAIL: thechambers.srs@gmail.com
...PETITIONER NO. 2
3.
THE DGAFMS
INTEGRATED HQ OF MINISTRY OF DEFENCE (ARMY)
M-BLOCK, DHQ, PO, NEW DELHI- 110011
PHONE: +91-88601-89238
E-MAIL: thechambers.srs@gmail.com
...PETITIONER NO. 3
Through:
Mr. Satya Ranjan Swain, CGSC
with Mr. Sanskar Gupta with
Mr. Tushar Hazrati, Advocates.
Major Anish Muralidhar, Army.
Versus
Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
16.39
W.P.(C) 13628/2026
COL (TS) SUDEEP ROY,
S/O- LATE HONY FG
OFFICER LN ROY, AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS
R/O-MILITARY DENTAL CENTRE,
C/O- MILITARY HOSPITAL, MORAR CANTT,
GWALIOR (MP)
MOBILE NO. 9999158400, 9205510739
EMAIL ID: kirananilkumar@rediffmail.com
…RESPONDENT
Through:
Appearance not given.
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE NITIN WASUDEO SAMBRE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT SHARMA
JUDGMENT
AMIT SHARMA, J.
1.
The present petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India, 1950, seeks the following prayers:“a. Issue an appropriate Writ or writ in the nature of
Certiorari or directions setting aside the Order dated
06.01.2026 passed by the Hon’ble Armed Forces
Tribunal, Principal Bench, New Delhi in Original
Application No. 606 of 2017 titled “Col (TS) Sudeep
Roy v. Union of India & Ors.” and,
b. Pass other and further order(s) this Hon’ble Court
may deem fit and proper in the interest of justice.”
2.
On 28.11.1991, the respondent was commissioned as a
Lieutenant in the Army Dental Corps (ADC) and was promoted from
time to time, upto the rank of Lieutenant Colonel in May, 2005. When
the respondent became eligible for promotion to the rank of Colonel,
Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
16.39
W.P.(C) 13628/2026
he was considered by the Promotion Board (Medical) No. 3, as a fresh
case, on 22.12.2008. However, he was graded as ‘Not Selected (NS)’
on the grounds of comparative merits. Aggrieved thereby, the
respondent filed a Statutory Complaint dated 02.06.2009 and the same
was rejected by the petitioners vide order dated 25.05.2010, being
devoid of merit. Thereafter, the respondent was again considered by the
Promotion Board (Medical) No. 3 held on 17.12.2009, as a first Review
Case, and on 23.12.2010, as a final Review Case; however, the
respondent was again graded as ‘Non Selected (NS)’, on account of
comparative merits and limited vacancies, and the same was
communicated to the respondent vide letter dated 02.08.2011.
3.
The respondent, again, filed a Statutory Complaint dated
28.02.2014 challenging his non-empanelment to rank of Colonel on the
grounds of bias, subjectivity and inconsistency, and the same was
rejected vide order dated 18.09.2015 passed by the Ministry of
Defence, Govt. of India. Aggrieved thereby, the respondent filed
Original Application No. 606/2017 before the learned Armed Forces
Tribunal, Principal Bench, New Delhi, seeking reconsideration of his
promotion to the rank of Colonel. Vide the impugned order dated
06.01.2026, the learned Armed Forces Tribunal allowed the said
application and directed the petitioners to consider the case of the
respondent afresh for promotion to the rank of Colonel, within a period
of three months. Hence, the petitioners preferred the present petition.
4.
Learned Counsel for the petitioners submitted that the role of the
Armed Forces Tribunal is to check/review the aberrations in the Annual
Confidential Reports (ACRs) and not to rewrite the same. Learned
Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
16.39
W.P.(C) 13628/2026
counsel for the petitioners further drew attention of this Court to the
box grading provided in the ACRs for the years 1998-1999, 1999-2000,
2001-2002 and 2002-2003, to contend that the said box grading
matches well with the pen picture given by the grading Officers and the
same were consistent throughout. It was further submitted that the
grading Officers had duly recorded the reasons while grading the
respondent, and therefore, no interference was called for by the learned
Armed Force Tribunal.
5.
At this stage, it would be apposite to refer to the findings given
by the learned Armed Force Tribunal in the impugned order dated
06.01.2026: “The applicant has been graded between 'Outstanding'
to 'Exceptionally Outstanding' by all grading officers
in the ibid CR except by the HTO. The low grading
with a sudden downward moderation by the HTO is
an aberration in the ibid CR. Though, the HTO has
given justification to his low grading, but talks of
events covered from 1998. The CR should be judged
on the period covered under the report and not on
earlier events, hence HTO assessment merits
interference and needs to be expunged. Moreover,
though the HTO has given adverse remarks whilst
justifying his downgrading the profile of the officer,
but the same has not been communicated to the ratee
which is not as per the relevant AO i.e. Special Army
Order SAO 8/S/91. In this regard, Para 72(f) and 73(b)
of the aforesaid SAO under the heading 'PART VIIOBJECTIVITY
IN
REPORTING
AND
COMMUNICATION OF CONTENTS (WHEN
APPLICABLE TO RATEE)' read as under:
“Consistency in report
Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
16.39
W.P.(C) 13628/2026
72. On receipt in De General Medical Services
(DGMS-1A) a CR will be scrutinized for consistency
in reporting. The criteria for the same is defined
below:
(a)
(b)
(c)
xxx
xxx
(d)
(e)
(f) Adverse remarks and guidance for improvement For these to be consistent and acceptable. It will be
essential that the remarks endorsed by the reporting
officer(s) are supported by figurative assessment in
relevant variable of personal qualities and or the
demonstrated performance. In addition, the
assessment of potential should also be in consonance
with the remarks.
73. In case the requirements specified above are
lacking in a CR, the concerned reporting officer will
be querried by Dte General Medical Services
(DGMS-1A), Army HQ. It will there-after be
mandatory upon the reporting officer(s) to provide the
requisite justification. During this process the
following will not be accepted:(a)
xxx
xxx
(b) Exclusion of Adverse remarks or guidance for
improvement to avoid communication to the ratee. In
case reporting officer(s) fails to communicate the
same, the requirement will be executed by Dte
General Medical Service (DGMS-1A)."
The non-communication of the adverse remarks is not
a mere procedural lapse, but is denial of justice to the
officer without giving grounds and an opportunity to
Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
16.39
W.P.(C) 13628/2026
him to put his own point of view. Hence, we consider
it necessary to interfere in the entire assessment of the
HTO in the ibid CR.
20. In view of the above, it is directed that the
following
be
expunged
on
grounds
of
aberration/inconsistency:(a) Entire assessment of IO, RO, FTO & STO in ACR
1998-1999.
(b) Entire assessment of IO, RO, FTO & STO in ACR
1999-2000.
(c) Entire assessment of HTO in ACR 2001-2002.
(d) Entire assessment of HTO in ACR 2002-2003.
21. The respondents are directed to consider the
applicant afresh for promotion to the rank of Col with
the modified profile with the cut-off merit as it existed
whilst considering him for the No. 3 Selection Board
(Medical) on 22.12.2008 (Fresh consideration),
17.12.2009 (1st Review Case) and 23.12.2010 (Final
Review Case). If the applicant is found within merit,
the applicant be notionally promoted to the rank of
Col (Selection Grade) with consequential benefits.
Compliance of the aforesaid directions be made
within three months from the date of receipt of a copy
of this order.
22. With the aforesaid, the O.A. No. 606 of 2017
stands disposed of.
23. Accordingly, all pending miscellaneous
applications also stand closed. There is no order as to
costs.”
6.
The learned Armed Force Tribunal, after considering the
submissions advanced by both the parties, had held that the respondent
had been graded between “outstanding” to “exceptionally outstanding”
Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
16.39
W.P.(C) 13628/2026
by all the grading Officers, except by the HTO, and the same was an
aberration in the CR, as the same pertained to the events covered from
the year 1998. It was further observed that the CR should be judged on
the period covered under the report and not on earlier events, and hence,
the assessment carried out by the HTO needed interference. It was
further observed that the said adverse remarks were not communicated
to the respondent, and the said act was not in consonance with the
Special Army Order SAO 8/S/91. In such an eventuality, the learned
Armed Force Tribunal had directed the petitioners to consider the case
of the respondent afresh, for promotion to the rank of Colonel, and if
found eligible, the respondent be notionally promoted to the rank of
Colonel (Selection Grade) with consequential benefits.
7.
In the considered opinion of this Court, the learned Armed Force
Tribunal had examined the relevant ACRs and the provisions regarding
recording and communication of the remarks, and thereafter, had
returned findings qua aberrations in the assessment of the respondent.
The argument advanced by the learned counsel for the petitioners, that
the learned Armed Force Tribunal had reappreciated the ACRs,
therefore, does not merit acceptance.
8.
A perusal of the impugned order dated 06.01.2026 further shows
that the petitioners were granted three months’ time to comply with the
same; however, the said order has not been complied with till date.
Moreover, the respondent herein, has been superannuated, as stated by
the learned counsel for the petitioners.
9.
In view of the above, this Court finds no illegality, perversity or
Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
16.39
W.P.(C) 13628/2026
jurisdictional error in the impugned order dated 06.01.2026, thereby
warranting interference under Article 226 of the Constitution of India,
1950, and therefore, the same is upheld.
10.
The present petition stands dismissed and disposed of,
accordingly.
11.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
12.
Order be uploaded on the website of this Court, forthwith.
NITIN WASUDEO SAMBRE
(JUDGE)
AMIT SHARMA
(JUDGE)
SEPTEMBER 17, 2026/db
Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
16.39
W.P.(C) 13628/2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review