Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
#
CNR No. DLHC010449502026
+
W.P.(C) 13808/2026, CM APPL. 64644/2026, CM APPL.
64645/2026, CM APPL. 64646/2026 & CM APPL. 64647/2026
UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
.....Petitioners
Through: Mr. Manish Kumar, SPC with
Mr. Rahul Kumar Sharma, GP and Mr.
Kumar Gaurav Adv.
versus
B N CHAWLA
.....Respondent
Through: Mr. Sudarshan Rajan and Mr.
Hitain Bajaj, Advs.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE C. HARI SHANKAR
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NIVEDITA ANIL SHARMA
JUDGMENT (ORAL)
30.09.2026
%
C. HARI SHANKAR, J.
1.
This writ petition assails order dated 24 February 2025 passed
by the Central Administrative Tribunal1 in OA 1133/2019.
2.
The respondent retired from the services of the Controller
General of Accounts2 as Senior Accountant on 30 September 1996.
Vide order dated 15 July 2013, his pension was fixed at ₹ 16,307/- per
“Tribunal” hereinafter
“CGA” hereinafter
W.P.(C) 13808/2026
KUMAR
17:47:35
month. Consequent on implementation of the recommendations of the
Seventh Central Pay Commission, the pension of the respondent was
enhanced to ₹ 42,586/- per month.
3.
Subsequently, however, by Office Orders dated 31 August 2017
and 11 September 2017, the respondent’s pension was reduced from ₹
42,586/- to ₹ 21,150/- per month.
4.
Aggrieved thereby, the respondent issued a legal notice to the
CGA, requesting the CGA to restore his earlier pension.
5.
The CGA, by Office Order dated 16 March 2018, rejected the
respondent’s representation, stating that the revision of his pension
was as per the directions of the Ministry of Personnel, Public
Grievances and Pensions, as a clerical error had been discerned in the
earlier computation of the respondent’ pension. The CGA further
issued a notice dated 22 May 2018, proposing to recover, from the
respondent, the pension allegedly paid to him in excess. This was
followed by a communication dated 26 February 2019 to the Senior
Accounts Officer, CPAO, to direct the Pension Paying Bank Branch to
recover, from the respondent, ₹ 20,67,588/- in instalments at the rate
of one-third of the amount per month till full recovery.
6.
Aggrieved thereby, the respondent approached the Tribunal by
way of OA 1133/2019.
7.
By judgment dated 24 February 2025, the Tribunal has allowed
the respondent’s OA. The decision to refix the respondent’s pension
W.P.(C) 13808/2026
KUMAR
17:47:35
as well as to recover from the respondent the pension allegedly paid in
excess have both been set aside.
8.
Aggrieved thereby, the CGA has approached this Court by
means of the present writ petition.
9.
We have heard Mr. Manish Kumar, learned SPC for the
petitioners and Mr. Sudarshan Rajan, learned Counsel for the
respondent.
10.
Mr. Manish Kumar submits that there is no reasoning, in the
order of the Tribunal, for setting aside the decision to refix the
respondent’s pension.
He submits that the refixation took place
because, at the time of grant of pension, a clerical error had taken
place. As soon as the error was noticed, corrective measures were
taken.
11.
Mr. Manish Kumar submits that, apart from referring to a
judgment of this Court in Director General Civil Aviation v. Iqbal
Singh Vedi3, the Tribunal has provided no independent reason to set
aside the decision to refix the respondent’s pension.
12.
Mr. Manish Kumar submits, however, quite fairly, that he is not
joining issue with the impugned judgment of the Tribunal on the
aspect of recovery.
3 (2017) 239 DLT 210
W.P.(C) 13808/2026
KUMAR
17:47:35
13.
We, therefore, are only required to examine whether the
refixation of the respondent’s pension was in accordance with law.
14.
We are in agreement with Mr. Manish Kumar that there is no
real reasoning provided in the impugned judgment of the Tribunal, in
setting aside the petitioner’s decision to refix the respondent’s
pension. Mr. Manish Kumar submits that, therefore, the matter may
be remanded to the Tribunal to reconsider this aspect.
15.
Remand is not a course of action which should be routinely
adopted. It is settled law that, where the necessary material is before
the Court so as to enable it to meaningfully examine the correctness of
the order under challenge, the Court should decide the matter, rather
than remand it.
16.
In the present case, as Mr. Rajan correctly points out, the
decision of this Court in Iqbal Singh Vedi, especially the paragraphs
extracted by the Tribunal, clearly notes that, where pension is refixed
on account of a clerical error at the time of fixation of the pension, the
refixation has to subscribe to the tenets of Rule 70(1)4 of the Central
Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 19725.
17.
The proviso to Rule 70(1) specifically ordains that, if the
4 70.
Revision of pension after authorization
(1)
Subject to the provisions of Rule 8 and 9, pension once authorized after final assessment
shall not be revised to the disadvantage of the government servant, unless such revision becomes
necessary on account of detection of a clerical error subsequently;
Provided that no revision of pension to the disadvantage of the pensioner shall be ordered
by the Head of Office without the concurrence of the Department of Personnel and Administrative
Reforms if the clerical error is detected after a period of two years from the date of authorization of
pension.
5 “the Pension Rules” hereinafter
W.P.(C) 13808/2026
KUMAR
17:47:35
revision of pension results in monetary disadvantage to the pensioner,
such revision would be require to be preceded by concurrence of the
Department of Personnel and Administrative Reforms6, where the
error is detected two years, or more, after the date of authorisation of
the pension.
18.
In the present case, the pension of the respondent was
authorised on 15 July 2013. The revision orders dated 31 August
2017 and 11 September 2017, which refixed the respondent’s pension
were, therefore, passed more than two years after the pension had been
fixed.
19.
The proviso to Rule 70(1) was, therefore, required to be
complied with.
20.
We may also invoke, in this context, the oft-quoted truism that
where the law requires an act to be done in a particular manner, that
act has to be done in that manner alone or not done at all, for which
there is wealth of authority, starting from Taylor v. Taylor7 and
reiterated, subsequently, by the Privy Council in Nazir Ahmed v. The
King Emperor8
and by the Supreme Court in a whole line of
decisions, of which the most often-cited is State of Uttar Pradesh v.
Singhara Singh9.
21.
Mr. Manish Kumar has drawn our attention to a noting of the
“DPAR” hereinafter
7 LR 1Ch426
8 AIR 1936 PC 253
9 AIR 1964 SC 358
W.P.(C) 13808/2026
KUMAR
17:47:35
DPAR which, according to him, would qualify as grant of the
requisite authorisation under the concurrence as required by the
proviso to Rule 70(1)(A) of the Pension Rules. We may reproduce the
noting, in extenso, thus:
“Department of Pension & Pensioners' Welfare
Desk (A)
*****
Reference notes of Office of CGA, Deptt of Expenditure on pre
page:
Office of CGA, Deptt. of Expenditure on this file, has
referred the matter for this Department's concurrence to recover the
excess amount of arrears/pension paid to Shri B.N. Chawla,
Retired Sr. Accountant for the period from 01.01.2006 to
30.07.2017 on account of wrong fixation of the pension due to a
clerical evor while revising his pension w.e.f. 01.01.2006 vide
CPAO authority dated 15.07.2013.
2.
As per the note @P.1 & 2, Shri B.N. Chawla retired from
Govt. service w.e.f. 30.09.1996 while working as a Sr. Account in
the pay scale of Rs 5500-175-9000/-. His basic pay was Rs 6375/at the time of retirement and accordingly his basic pension was
fixed to Rs 3120/- w.e.f. 01.10.1996. His basic pension was to be
revised to Rs. 7215/-PM w.e.f. 01.01.2006 in the pay band of Rs,
9300-34800 with Grade Pay of Rs 4200/- in terms of DoPPW OM
dated 28.01.2013, however the to some error, his pension got fixed
to Rs. 16307/- vide CPAO authority dated 15.07.2013. The bank
paid the arrears for the period from 01.01.2006 to 31 07.2016 to
Shri Chawla in the month of July, 2016.
3.
Further, while revising his pension as per the 7th CPC, it
was found that his basic pension was to be fixed to Rs. 721-5/(instead of Rs. 16307; w.e.f. 01.01.2006 and accordingly his
pension as per 7th CPC was revised to Rs.1,150 as per para 1.12 of
the guidelines (Rule 70 of CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972) available
on Pensioners Portal of DoPPW.
4.
In the meantime, in implementation of 7th CPC
recommendations, the bank itself revised his pension to Rs. 41,909
(taking his basic pension as Rs.16307 in to account) by multiplying
by a factor of 2.57.
5.
The pension of Shri Chawla was revised vide CPAO
W.P.(C) 13808/2026
KUMAR
17:47:35
authority dated 31.08.2017 on implementation of 7th CPC. On
receiving the revised authority, the bank fixed his basic pension to
Rs 21,150 w.e.f. October, 2017. Aggrieved, Shri Chawla sent a
legal notice to restore his pension. On which, the department issued
a Speaking order clarifying the position (Flag/A).
6.
The department has submitted that wrong fixation of
pension of Shri Chawla w.e.f.01.01.2006 vide CPAO authority
dated 15.07.2013 was owing to a clerical error and payment of
arrears on account of this was made by the bank in July, 2016. The
7th CPC revision authority was issued on 31.08.2017 implemented
by the bank in October, 2017 i.e. with in two
implementation/enhancement of pension. Now department has
referred the file for this department's concurrence on the recovery
of the excess amount paid to Shri Chawia.
7.
It is observed that the department has already
revised/reduced the pension of Shri Chawla in exercise of the
power available to the administrative department under Rule 70 of
CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972. The department may take an
appropriate administrative decision on the question of making
recovery of overpayment of pension on account of wrong
fixation/revision of pension during 6th CPC. They may keep in
view the rule position in Rule 70(2) and 70(3) as also DoPTs OM
No. 18/03/2015-Estt.(Pay.I) dated 02.03.2016.
Submitted for approval please.
Sd/(Prashant Gupta)
SO/09.04.2018”
22.
We are unable to accept Mr. Manish Kumar’s submission for
two reasons.
23.
In the first place, the noting is dated 9 April 2018, which was a
full five years after the decision to refix the respondent’s pension had
been taken. Quite obviously, therefore, this noting cannot constitute
concurrence for the decision of refixation of the pensioner.
24.
Secondly, the noting itself indicates that the concurrence of the
W.P.(C) 13808/2026
KUMAR
17:47:35
DPAR was sought only on the aspect of recovery consequent on
refixation, which itself had taken place without obtaining any
concurrence from the DPAR.
25.
The aforesaid noting cannot, therefore, come to the rescue of
the petitioner.
26.
In that view of the matter, we find no error in the ultimate
decision of the Tribunal to set aside the orders dated 31 August 2017
and 11 September 2017 refixing the respondent’s pension.
27.
The writ petition is, therefore, devoid of merits and is
accordingly dismissed with no orders as to costs.
C. HARI SHANKAR, J
NIVEDITA ANIL SHARMA, J
SEPTEMBER 30, 2026/AR
W.P.(C) 13808/2026
KUMAR
17:47:35
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review