Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Date of Decision : 12.03.2026
+
W.P.(C) 3139/2026 CM APPL. 15102/2026 CM APPL. 15103/2026
UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
.....Petitioners
Through: Mr. Kameshwar Nath Mishra, Sr.
Panel counsel with Ms. Vidya Mishra,
Adv.
versus
798106 SGT NARENDRA PRASAD GUPTA RETD .....Respondent
Through: Mr. Banvendra Singh Gandhar, Adv.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V. KAMESWAR RAO
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA
MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA, J. (ORAL)
CM APPL. 15103/2026 (for exemption)
1.
Allowed, subject to just exceptions.
2.
The application is disposed of.
W.P.(C) 3139/2026
1.
This is a writ petition filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India against the order dated 25.09.2024 [‘impugned order’] passed by the
Armed Forces Tribunal, Principal Bench, New Delhi [‘Tribunal’] in Original
Application [‘O.A.’] No. 2961/2023 titled as Ex Sgt Narendra Prasad
Gupta v. Union of India & Ors., wherein the Respondent has been granted
the benefit of the disability element of pension for the disability of Primary
Hypertension assessed at 30% for life, rounded off to 50% for life, from the
date of his discharge from the service.
Signed By:MOHIT
Signing
Date:20.03.2026 19:15
W.P.(C) 3139/2026
2.
The facts giving rise to the present petition are that the Respondent
was discharged from the service on 30.06.2022 under the clause ‘on
fulfilling the condition of his enrolment’.
3.
The Release Medical Board [‘RMB’] held on 28.12.2021 assessed the
disability i.e., Primary Hypertension at 30% for life. The RMB opined that
since the disability is a lifestyle disorder and the onset of the disease was at
the time when the Respondent was serving at peace station i.e., in December
2021 at Vadodara, the aforesaid disability was neither attributable to nor
aggravated [‘NANA’] by the military service.
4.
Respondent’s initial disability pension claim was rejected vide letter
dated 18.10.2022 by holding that the disability was NANA.
5.
Respondent filed O.A. No. 2961 of 2023 before the Tribunal for the
grant of disability element of pension. In the said O.A., the Respondent had
submitted that he will be satisfied if only his claim for Primary Hypertension
is considered for the purpose of grant of disability pension. By the impugned
order, the Tribunal after referring to the judgment of the Supreme Court in
Dharamvir Singh v. Union of India and Ors.1 and Union of India v. Ram
Avtar2 granted the relief of disability pension to the Respondent.
6.
The submission made by the learned counsel for the Petitioners is that
the reliance placed by the Tribunal on the judgment of Dharamvir Singh v.
Union of India and Ors. (supra) is totally misplaced as in the said case the
Supreme Court was concerned with the Entitlement Rules for Casualty
Pensionary Awards, 1982 [‘Entitlement Rules, 1982’], whereas the case of
the Respondent needs to be considered under the Entitlement Rules for
Signed By:MOHIT
Signing
Date:20.03.2026 19:15
2013 (7) SCC 361
2014 SCC Online SC 1761
W.P.(C) 3139/2026
Casualty Pensionary Awards to Armed Forces Personnel, 2008 [‘Entitlement
Rules, 2008’].
6.1.
He contends that the Tribunal has overlooked the Entitlement Rules,
2008, which govern attributability and aggravation and no longer permit a
blanket presumption in favour of the claimant/officer; and since the RMB
has opined the disease to be NANA, the Tribunal could not have presumed a
causal connection between the disease and the service.
6.2.
He states in the facts of this case, Respondent was discharged from
services on 30.06.2022 and therefore, the Respondent would be governed by
Entitlement Rules, 2008.
6.3.
He states that the impugned order incorrectly applies the presumption
available under the repealed Entitlement Rules, 1982, ignoring the amended
regime under Entitlement Rules, 2008, which does not raise a presumption
in favour of the personnel.
6.4.
He states that the Entitlement Rules, 2008, have done away with the
general presumption to be drawn to ascertain the principle of ‘attributable to
or aggravated by military service’.
7.
Having perused the reasons recorded in the opinion of the RMB for
holding NANA, for the reasons recorded hereinafter we are unable to agree
with the submissions made by the learned counsel for the Petitioners that the
Tribunal committed any error in granting relief to this Respondent.
8.
In view of the fact that the Respondent was discharged from service
on 30.06.2022, indeed the claim of disability pension would be governed by
Entitlement Rules, 2008.
9.
Signed By:MOHIT
Signing
Date:20.03.2026 19:15
In another petition, i.e., W.P.(C) 88/2026 titled Union of India v.
W.P.(C) 3139/2026
781466 Ex. SGT Krishna Kumar Dwivedi, decided by this Bench on
06.01.2026, our attention was drawn to the authoritative judgments of the
coordinate Benches of this Court passed in W.P.(C) 3545/2025 titled Union
of India v. Ex. Sub Gawas Anil Madso3 and W.P.(C) 140/2024 titled
Union of India vs. Col. Balbir Singh (Retd.) and other connected
matters4, which have conclusively held that even under Entitlement Rules,
2008 an officer, who suffers from a disease at the time of his release and
applies for disability pension within 15 years from release of service, is
ordinarily entitled to disability pension and he does not have any onus to
prove the said entitlement. The said judgments emphatically hold that even
under the Entitlement Rules, 2008, the onus to prove a causal connection
between the disability and military service is not on the officer but on the
administration. The Entitlement Rules, 2008, however, contemplates that in
the event the Medical Board concludes that the disease, though contracted
during the tenure of military service, was NANA by military service, it
would have to give cogent reasons and identify the cause, other than military
service, to which the ailment or disability can be attributed. The judgments
hold that a bald statement in the report of the Medical Board opining
‘ONSET IN PEACE STATION’ or ‘LIFESTYLE DISORDER’ would not
be sufficient for the military department to deny the claim of disability
pension; and rejected the opinions of the Medical Board. The judgments
hold that the burden to prove the disentitlement of pension therefore remains
on the military department even under the Entitlement Rules, 2008; and
emphasise on the significance of the Medical Board giving specific reasons
Signed By:MOHIT
Signing
Date:20.03.2026 19:15
2025: DHC: 2021-DB
2025: DHC: 5082-DB
W.P.(C) 3139/2026
to justify their opinion for denial of this beneficial provision to the officer.
10.
For reference, we also note that the Supreme Court in its recent
judgment in the case of Bijender Singh vs. Union of India5 has reiterated
that it is incumbent upon the Medical Board to furnish reasons for opining
that a disease is NANA and the burden to prove the same is on the Military
Establishment.
The distinction between conclusion and reasons has been succinctly
explained by the Supreme Court in another recent decision of Rajumon
T.M. v. Union of India6 to state that merely stating an opinion/conclusion,
such as ‘CONSTITUTIONAL PERSONALITY DISORDER’ in the RMB
without giving reasons or causative factors to support such an opinion, is an
unreasoned medical opinion. The Supreme Court explained that the said
opinion of the Medical Board was merely a conclusion and would not
qualify as a reasoned opinion for holding the disease/disability to be NANA.
11.
In this background of settled law holding that the onus to prove
disentitlement remains on military establishment and not the officer vis-à-vis
Entitlement Rules, 2008, we have examined the facts of this case and the
RMB.
12.
The Respondent was enrolled in the Indian Air Force on 17.06.2002
and the disease/disability Primary Hypertension was discovered in the year
2021 [after 19 years of service], while he was serving in the Force and
therefore, the disease has indisputably arisen during his military service. The
Respondent was discharged from service on 30.06.2022 on fulfilling the
condition of his enrolment.
Signed By:MOHIT
Signing
Date:20.03.2026 19:15
2025 SCC OnLine SC 895 at paragraphs 45.1, 46 and 47
2025 SCC OnLine SC 1064 at paragraphs 25, 26, 32 and 36
W.P.(C) 3139/2026
13.
The Petitioners have raised the issue of non-entitlement of the
disability element of the pension only on the ground that the Medical Board
has held that the disease is NANA by the military service. The opinion
rendered by the RMB is extracted as under: -
14.
The Petitioners contend that disease is NANA since the RMB records
‘onset of the disease was at a peace station’ and that there was no stress of
the military service; and the disease was due to the lifestyle disorder of the
officer/Respondent.
This precise reason i.e., ‘onset in peace station’ has been specifically
rejected by the coordinate Bench of this Court in Col. Balbir Singh (Retd.)
(supra)7 and Union of India and Others v. Col. Koutharapu Srinivasa
Signed By:MOHIT
Signing
Date:20.03.2026 19:15
At paragraph nos. 66 to 74
W.P.(C) 3139/2026
Retd.8 while granting disability pension to the officer, therein, similarly
suffering from Primary Hypertension, and has been held to be an invalid
ground for denying attributability to the military service. The Division
Bench in the said decision after taking note of Regulation 423(a) of the
Regulations for the Medical Services of the Armed Forces, 2010 held that,
the fact that, the disability occurred in normal peace conditions is immaterial
and by itself is not a sufficient ground for the Medical Board and Military
Establishment to deny attributability as well as disability pension to the
officer.
15.
In Col. Koutharapu Srinivasa Retd. (supra), the Division Bench
held that opinion of the Medical Board merely stating that the disease of
Primary Hypertension is a lifestyle disorder will not prove that the disease
was not attributable to military service. The Court opined that in case the
lifestyle of the officer is the cause of the disease, the medical opinion must
reflect the causative lifestyle factors (i.e., enlist the reasons for such an
opinion).
In the present case as well, the RMB has merely classified the
Respondent’s disease of Primary Hypertension as a lifestyle disorder. The
RMB, however, says nothing about the specific lifestyle factors of the
Respondent, which led to the cause of the disease.
16.
It is now well settled that the Medical Board is obliged to record
cogent reasons and the causative factors which in their opinion led to the
personnel suffering from the said disease. If the Medical Board fails to
identify the causal connection, the presumption is that the disease was
Signed By:MOHIT
Signing
Date:20.03.2026 19:15
2025 SCC OnLine Del 4292 at paragraphs 5 and 16.
W.P.(C) 3139/2026
suffered by the personnel due to the stress and strain arising from the
military service. The statement in the subject RMB that ‘onset was in a
peace area’ is not a legally valid ground for opining NANA.
17.
No other ground has been cited in the RMB report of the Respondent
for holding NANA.
18.
In view of the aforesaid findings, the Petitioners’ challenge to the
grant of disability element of pension to the Respondent, is without any
merits. The Respondent has been rightly held to be entitled to the disability
pension under the Entitlement Rules, 2008 by the Tribunal in the impugned
order.
19.
Additionally, we note that the impugned order is dated 25.09.2024
and the petition has been filed after more than a year, without any
explanation for such a delay. The Petitioner was obliged to comply with the
impugned order of the Tribunal within four months and the same has not
been complied with till date. Keeping in view that the claim of disability
pension is beneficial in nature, we hold that filing of this petition is also
barred by delay and laches.
20.
We therefore find no merit in this petition; the petition is dismissed.
Pending application(s), if any, are disposed of. No costs.
MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA, J
V. KAMESWAR RAO, J
MARCH 12, 2026/AM
Signed By:MOHIT
Signing
Date:20.03.2026 19:15
W.P.(C) 3139/2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review