Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 29.11.2025
Pronounced on: 12.01.2026
+
+
+
+
+
+
W.P.(C) 5945/2017 & CM APPL. 24684/2017
W.P.(C) 6603/2017 & CM APPL. 27367/2017
W.P.(C) 10845/2018 & CM APPL. 42313/2018, CM APPL.
23807/2020, CM APPL. 10435/2021, CM APPL. 30250/2023,
CM APPL. 4573/2025
W.P.(C) 376/2018 & CM APPL. 1581/2018, CM APPL.
23808/2020, CM APPL. 10436/2021, CM APPL. 30416/2023,
CM APPL. 4577/2025
W.P.(C) 13428/2019
W.P.(C) 1708/2020
ELINA DAS & ORS
.....Petitioners
RAJIVE KUMAR SHARMA
.....Petitioner
UNION OF INDIA & ORS
.....Petitioners
YASH MAURYA AND ORS.
.....Petitioners
PRADEEP AND ORS.
.....Petitioners
Through: Mr.Padma Kumar S. and
Mr.Gurpreet Singh, Advs. in
W.P.(C) 5945/2017, W.P.(C)
6603/2017, W.P.(C)13428/2019
and W.P.(C) 1708/2020
Mr.Arun Bhardwaj, Sr. Adv.
with Mr.Vikram Jetly, CGSC,
Ms.Shreya Jetly, Ms.Neha
Mishra, Ms.Muskan Jain and
Mr.Ashu Tiwari, Advs. for UOI
in W.P.(C) 10845/2018 &
W.P.(C) 376/2018
versus
SHIV CHARAN & ORS
.....Respondents
CHARAN SINGH CHAUHAN & ORS
.....Respondents
Through: Mr.A. K. Behera, Sr. Adv. with
Mr.Amarendra P. Singh, Adv.
for Shiv Charan
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 5945/2017 & connected matters
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
Mr.Arun Bhardwaj, Sr. Adv.
with Mr.Vikram Jetly, CGSC,
Ms.Shreya Jetly, Ms.Neha
Mishra, Ms.Muskan Jain and
Mr.Ashu Tiwari, Advs. for UOI
Mr.Padma Kumar S. and
Mr.Gurpreet Singh, Advs. for
private respondents in W.P.(C)
10845/2018
and
W.P.(C)
376/2018
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE NAVIN CHAWLA
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE MADHU JAIN
JUDGMENT
NAVIN CHAWLA, J.
1.
The present batch of writ petitions, W.P.(C) 5945/2017,
W.P.(C) 6603/2017, W.P.(C) 376/2018 and W.P.(C) 13428/2019 have
been filed challenging the Order dated 27.02.2017 passed by the
learned Central Administrative Tribunal, Principal Bench, New
Delhi (hereinafter referred to as, the Tribunal), in O.A. No.
1227/2016, titled Shiv Charan v. Union of India & Ors., whereby
the learned Tribunal had been pleased to dispose of the said O.A.
with the following directions:
“48. In view of the foregoing discussion and
for the reasons stated, we quash the seniority
list dated 09.06.2015. For the purpose of inter
se seniority the DPC promotes from 2006-07
to 2009-10 shall be treated as ad-hoc till the
year 2010-11 when in fulfilment of the
statutory requirement the LDCE was also
held. A list of DPC promotes from 2006-07 to
2010-11 shall be prepared in the same order
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 5945/2017 & connected matters
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
as the settled position of seniority of the
promotes and the same shall be rotated with
the LDCE appointees of 2010-11 for fixation
of inter se seniority in accordance with the
OM dated 07.02.1986. It is an admitted fact
that the respondents have already considered
the approved service of the applicant from the
year 2006 and given the financial benefits and
NFSG as well, by applying rule 4 of the
IBSSR. We have shown that is not the correct
interpretation of the rule 4 in the context of the
rule 3. However, the orders of counting of
approved service the appointees LDCE 2010
from 2006 and granting consequential
financial benefits including NFSG are not
interfered with. OA is disposed of in terms of
the above. No costs.”
2.
W.P.(C) 10845/2018 and W.P.(C) 1708/2020 have been filed,
challenging the Order dated 21.02.2018 passed by the learned
Tribunal in O.A. No. 1399/2016, titled Charan Singh Chauhan v.
Union of India & Ors., whereby the learned Tribunal, following its
order in Shiv Charan (supra), disposed of the said O.A. with the
following directions:
“13. In view of the above discussion, we
dispose of this OA with the following
directions: i) Seniority list dated 15.07.2014 is quashed
and set aside to the extent it pertains to the
applicant. The applicant shall be given
seniority from the year the vacancy against
which he was promoted and shall be; rotated
with the DPC promotees of the same year for
fixation of inter-se seniority in accordance
with OM dated 07.02.1986.
ii) The above exercise may be carried out
within two months from the date of receipt of
certified copy of this order and any
consequential benefits like promotion etc. due
to him per rules may be given effect to within
two months thereafter”
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 5945/2017 & connected matters
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
3.
In W.P.(C) 1708/2020, the petitioners have further challenged
the Order dated 03.09.2019 passed in R.A. 74/2018, titled Pradeep
& Ors. v. Charan Singh Chauhan & Ors., whereby the learned
Tribunal was pleased to dismiss the Review Application seeking
review of the order dated 21.02.2018 passed in the above O.A..
4.
At the outset, we may note that the present batch of petitions
involves similar issues of law and arises from a common bundle of
facts, therefore, it is deemed appropriate to adjudicate them vide this
common judgment.
5.
The dispute concerns the inter se seniority of the Section
Officers (SO) in the Secretariat Cadre of the Intelligence Bureau
(IB), which is governed by Intelligence Bureau Secretariat Service
Rules, 2003 (hereinafter referred to as, ‘IBSSR, 2003’). The IBSSR,
2003 provides that the promotion to the said post shall be made 60%
on basis of promotion and 40% by way of a Limited Departmental
Competitive Examination (LDCE).
6.
For the sake of convenience, reference shall be made to the
facts in W.P.(C) 376/2018, titled Union of India & Ors. v. Shiv
Charan & Ors., and the officers promoted as SO under the
promotional quota shall be referred to as the petitioners, and the
officers promoted under the LDCE quota as the respondents.
FACTUAL MATRIX
7.
The respondent no.1 joined the IB as Personal Assistant (PA)
pursuant to his selection in the Intelligence Bureau Personal
Assistants Grade Examination, 1995, on 12.12.1996.
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 5945/2017 & connected matters
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
8.
At the time of his appointment, the service conditions in the
IB were governed by executive instructions. The IBSSR, 2003 were
promulgated and brought into force with effect from 12.03.2004.
9.
Under the IBSSR, 2003, the next promotional avenue
available to the posts of PA and Assistants is that of Section Officer
(SO). The said post is filled by two methods: 60% vacancies are
filled through the promotional quota and 40% vacancies through the
LDCE conducted by the Union Public Service Commission (UPSC).
PAs and Assistants with 8 years of service are eligible for
consideration against promotional quota, and those with four years
of service are eligible for competing in the LDCE.
10.
Rule 3 of the IBSSR, 2003 provides for preparation of a
Select List for each vacancy year, however, the IBSSR, 2003 do not
contain any express provision for governing the fixation of inter se
seniority between the officers promoted through the Departmental
Promotion Committee (DPC) and those appointed through LDCE.
Therefore, the fixation of seniority is governed by executive
instructions issued by the Department of Personnel and Training
(DoP&T), such as Office Memorandums dated 24.06.1978 and
07.02.1986.
11.
We must herein itself note that, before the learned Tribunal,
the respondent no. 1 herein had submitted that Rule 3 read with Rule
4 of IBSSR, 2003 and the ‘other matters’ specified in Column 5 to
14 of the Schedule to the IBSSR, 2003 would show that as the
‘approved service’ for the LDCE appointees is to be counted from
the 1st day of July of the year of vacancies, the same shall also
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 5945/2017 & connected matters
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
govern seniority. This submission of the respondent no. 1 was,
however, rejected by the learned Tribunal and it was held that the
IBSSR, 2003 do not govern seniority and that the same shall be
determined in terms of the general principles of seniority for Central
Government employees. There is no challenge in these writ petitions
to this finding of the learned Tribunal. We shall therefore, proceed
on the basis that the IBSSR, 2003 do not contain any provision for
determination of the seniority of SOs and that the same is governed
by the various instructions issued by the Central Government in this
regard.
12.
In July 2006, the UPSC issued a notification for conduct of
the LDCE for promotion to the post of SO, for the vacancy year
2005. The examination was conducted in December 2006, however,
declaration of results was delayed due to pendency of W.P.(C) No.
4876/2007, titled The Central Secretariat Stenographers Service
Association & Ors. v. The Central Secretariat Service, Direct
Recruit Assistants Association & Ors., before this Court concerning
the eligibility of Stenographers to appear in the LDCE. Though the
IB was not a party to the said litigation, the results of LDCE-2005
were ultimately declared only in February 2009, and the officers
appointed through LDCE-2005 were assigned seniority from the
year 2009. A seniority list reflecting the said position was issued on
19.03.2010.
13.
LDCEs for the vacancy years 2006-07 to 2009-2010 could not
be conducted within the normal timeframe due to the continued
pendency of the aforesaid writ petition. During this period,
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 5945/2017 & connected matters
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
promotions to the posts of SO through the 60% DPC quota
continued to be effected on a year-to-year basis.
14.
The department claims that on 07.07.2010, with the approval
of the DOP&T, 85 LDCE vacancies were temporarily diverted to
promotional quota as a one-time measure, with the condition that
shortfall in the LDCE quota would be made good at the time of
future vacancies. On 20.08.2010, 69 officers were promoted against
the diverted vacancies, promotion orders were issued and seniority
was also granted to them accordingly.
15.
In the meantime, on 30.07.2010, UPSC inquired about the
LDCE vacancy positions and was informed that 10 vacancies for the
year 2006, 14 vacancies for 2007, and 05 vacancies for 2008 were
available. Thereafter, the UPSC advertised these posts on
20.08.2010; examination was conducted in December 2010; and the
result thereof was declared on 01.10.2011.
16.
Upon appointment, by applying Rules 3 and 4 of the IBSSR,
2003, the officers so appointed were granted ‘approved service’ as
SO with effect from 1st July of the vacancy year against which they
were appointed, and upon completion of four years of approved
service, they were also granted Non-Functional Selection Grade
(NFSG).
17.
On 01.11.2012, the IB circulated directions issued by the
Ministry of Home Affairs (MHA) and the DoP&T, indicating that
seniority of SO appointed through LDCE was to be fixed from the
vacancy year, based on the concept of approved service. In
pursuance thereof, a draft Seniority List dated 01.03.2013 was
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 5945/2017 & connected matters
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
issued, wherein officers appointed through LDCE-2006 were shown
against the vacancy year 2006-07 and were placed above the officers
promoted through the DPC against subsequent vacancy years.
18.
The draft Seniority List dated 01.03.2013 gave rise to
representations
from
officers
promoted
through
the
60%
promotional quota, objecting to the fixation of seniority of LDCE
officers from the vacancy year.
19.
Thereafter, a final Seniority List dated 09.06.2015 was
issued, whereby officers appointed through LDCE were assigned
seniority with reference to the year 2011-12, and officers promoted
earlier through the DPC were placed above them.
20.
Aggrieved by the above Seniority List dated 09.06.2015, Shri
Shiv Charan, that is, the respondent no. 1 herein, an LDCE officer,
filed O.A. No. 1227/2016 before the learned Tribunal, which has
been disposed of by the learned Tribunal with the above quoted
directions.
21.
As a matter of factual background, it is relevant to note that in
WP(C) 10845/2018 and WP(C) 1708/2020, the concerned officers
had appeared in the LDCE conducted in the year 2005–2006 for the
vacancy year 2005; however, their promotion orders were issued
only in the year 2009, during which period promotions through the
DPC continued to be made for subsequent vacancy years. As a
result, the said LDCE appointees came to be placed below the DPC
promotees of the years 2006, 2007 and 2008 in the Seniority List.
The same was challenged by the respondents by way of O.A. No.
1399/2016, which was disposed of by the learned Tribunal vide its
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 5945/2017 & connected matters
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
Order dated 21.02.2018, applying the Order passed in Shiv Charan
(supra) and quashing the Seniority List. Review Applications filed
by promotee officers against the Order dated 21.02.2018, were also
dismissed.
22.
Aggrieved by the Orders dated 27.02.2017 and 21.02.2018,
and the consequential directions affecting seniority, promotions and
service benefits, the Union of India and officers promoted through
the DPC have approached this Court by way of the present writ
petitions under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
RELEVANT PROCEEDINGS IN THE WRIT PETITIONS:
23.
On 25.03.2025, this Court called upon the Union of India to
answer the following queries:
“3. In order to adjudicate the present dispute,
we find it appropriate that an affidavit
disclosing the following facts be filed by the
respondent nos. 2 to 5 in W.P.(C) 5945/2017:
a. how many vacancies were available in the
above post, year wise, between 2005 and
2010;
b. how many personnels were appointed in the
above post, year wise and channel wise,
between 2005 and 2010; and
c. in case, it is admitted that certain personnel
were promoted in excess of the channel quota
for a particular year, the details of such
personnel be also disclosed.
4. It is the case of the petitioner that 85 posts
from the quota of LDCE were diverted to the
promotion quota with the prior approval of the
DoPT and in consultation with the UPSC, on
07.07.2010. The same is disputed by the
learned Senior Counsel appearing for the
respondents. Let another affidavit be filed by
the respondent no. 2-5 in W.P.(C) 5945/2017,
placing on record the order by which the
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 5945/2017 & connected matters
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
diversion had taken place, the approval
received from the DoPT, and the consultation
with the UPSC. In case any personnel have
been appointed against these diverted
vacancies, their particulars, including the date
from which they were granted seniority, be
also disclosed in the affidavit.”
24.
In answer to the above, an Affidavit dated 16.04.2025 was filed
by the Additional Deputy Director, (IB), Ministry of Home Affairs,
stating therein, as under:
“I say that as per IBSSR 2003, notified on
12.3.04, 60% of the posts in the rank of
Section Officer (SO) were to be filled by
promotion & 40% by Limited Departmental
Competitive Examination (LDCE). The total
sanctioned strength of SO was 242 out of
which 145 (60%) posts were earmarked for
Promotion Quota (PQ) & 97 (40%) posts were
earmarked for LDCE quota.
Till vacancy year 2006-07 (April to March),
the vacancy calculation was done post-based.
The vacancies occurring due to attrition in any
mode of recruitment were filled by the same
mode of recruitment only, i.e., vacancy
occurring
due
to
promotion/retirement/voluntarily retirement
etc. of an officer under LDCE quota were
filled by LDCE only and similarly vacancies
occurring in promotion quota (PQ) were filled
by promotion based on seniority only.
The vacancy position in the rank during
vacancy years 2005-06 to 2010-11 are as
under:
Year
Total Vacancies
PQ
LDCE
Vacancies filled
PQ
LDCE
2005-06 (Post-based)
A
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 5945/2017 & connected matters
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
2006-07
10#
A
DoP&T vide OM dt. 19.1.07, introduced vacancy-based method for distribution of
vacancies among different modes of recruitment, as per which all the vacancies
occurring in a year were combined and distributed among different modes of
recruitment as per percentage prescribed in the RRs. Accordingly, all the
vacancies available in the rank of SO till 2007-08 were clubbed together and
bifurcated into PQ and LDCE quota, in terms of RRs, i.e., 60% and 40%
respectively. Total 84 vacancies were available till 2007-08 which were
bifurcated as 50(60%) in PQ and 34(40%) in LDCE quota. Out of these 34
vacancies of LDCE quota, 10 vacancies were allotted to LDCE of 2005-06 and
10 to LDCE of 2006-07, as these vacancies were already notified to the UPSC
for the respective LDCEs vide letters dt. 6.5.05 and 28.6.07 respectively. As such,
remaining 14 vacancies (34-10-10) were available for LDCE 2007-08.
2007-08
(vacancy based)
2008-09
A
14#
2009-10
A
41#
20#
-
2010-11
A
85#
-
~- ,,.--.--~#
A total of 85 vacancies of LDCE quota of the years 2006-07 to 2009-10
(10+14+41+20) remained unfilled for a long time, as UPSC was not
convening the exam for these years. Accordingly, with the approval of
DOP&T dt. 7.7.10, these 85 LDCE quota vacancies were temporarily
diverted to PQ, as a one-time measure with the condition that shortfall in
LDCE quota is made good at the time of future vacancies
A
The details of vacancies filled by LDCE is as appended below.
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 5945/2017 & connected matters
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
Details of LDCE
LDCE year
Vacancies notified
Result year
Vacancies filled
3@(c/f)
@3 vacancies notified for LDCE 2009-10 (in year 2012) were carried forward
unfilled vacancies of year 2007-08 & 2008-09.
I say that in response to the question raised in
paragraph no. 3 c in the order dated
25.03.2025 namely:“c. in case, it is admitted that certain
personnel were promoted in excess of the
channel quota for a particular year, the details
of such personnel be also disclosed".
I say that No personnel were promoted in
excess of the channel quota for a particular
year. I further say that, in the year 2010, 85
LDCE quota posts were diverted to promotion
quota as a one- time exemption to the RR with
the prior approval of the DoP&T. Thereafter,
69 personnel were promoted legitimately
through Supplementary DPC 2010-11.”
25.
Another Affidavit dated 16.04.2025 was filed by the Additional
Deputy Director (IB), in answer to the query raised in Paragraph 4 of
the Order dated 25.03.2025, stating as under:
“4. It is the case of the petitioner that 85
posts from the quota of LDCE were diverted to
the promotion quota with the prior approval of
the DoPT and in consultation with the UPSC,
on 07.07.2010. The same is disputed by the
learned Senior Counsel appearing for the
respondents. Let another affidavit be filed by
the respondent no. 2-5 in W.P.(C) 5945/2017,
placing on record the order by which the
diversion had taken place, the approval
received from the DoPT, and the consultation
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 5945/2017 & connected matters
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
with the UPSC. In case any personnel have
been appointed against these diverted
vacancies, their particulars, including the date
from which they were granted seniority, be
also disclosed in the affidavit.”
I say that as regards diversion of vacancies, it
is submitted that in the year 2010, 85
vacancies of LDCE quota of the years 2006-07
to 2009-10 remained unfilled for a long time,
as UPSC was not convening the exam for these
years due to pending court case of CSS. SO’s
grade LDCE examination by the UPSC could
not be conducted since 2006 due to the
pending of court case filed by the
stenographers of the CSS in Delhi High Court
against the orders of the CAT. The CAT has
ruled that the Stenographers (PAs) are not
eligible to write the examination.
I further say that as such a large number of
vacancies was affecting the functioning of the
department, a proposal (3.9.09) was moved to
the MHA/DOP&T requesting to grant
approval to fill up all the vacancies by 100%
promotion as a one-time exemption to the RRS
and UPSC vide our letters dt.1.12.09, 6.1.10
and 20.4.10 were requested to convene the
exam for IB for filling up these vacancies, as
IB was not a party in the said case.
I further say that UPSC, vide letter dated
13.5.10, informed that the Commission and
DoP&T were under a consultative process to
find a route map for holding SO’s LDCE 2006
onwards in light of Hon’ble Delhi High
Court's interim order 19.3.10, in which it was
mentioned that the exam may be conducted
with the condition that the result of the exam
shall be kept in a sealed cover subject to final
outcome of the Writ Petition WP(C)
4876/2007.A copy of letter dated 13.5.10 of
UPSC is annexed herewith as Annexure R-1.
However, keeping the result in sealed cover
would not help with filling up of vacancies,
which was adversely affecting the functioning
of
the
department.
Subsequently,
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 5945/2017 & connected matters
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
MHA/DOP&T was requested to grant
approval for filling up the vacancies as a onetime measure.
I further say that DoP&T granted approval for
temporary diversion of 85 vacancies of LDCE
quota on 7.7.10 (Vacancy Year 2010-11), as a
one-time measure with the condition that
shortfall in LDCE quota is made good at the
time of future vacancies.
I further say that accordingly, the temporary
diversion of vacancies was done with the
approval of DoP&T and after consultation
with the UPSC.
I further say that out of 85 temporarily
diverted vacancies in the year 2010-11, only
69 were utilized for promotion of Assistants by
convening Supplementary DPC in 2010-11
(held on 6.8.10), as only 69 Assistants were
found eligible.
Subsequently, when UPSC notified LDCE for
2006-07 to 2008-09 on 30.7.10, 16 remaining
vacancies out of 85 diverted vacancies along
with 13 accrued vacancies were notified
(09.08.10) with the approval of the Head of the
Department (DIB) to UPSC for LDCE of the
year [2006-07 (10), 2007-08 (14) & 2008-09
(05)] respectively in order to provide
opportunity for those aspiring to write the
examination (particularly PAs).
Further I say that the restoration of 69
vacancies of LDCE quota has been initiated in
the year 2023 with the approval of DIB under
intimation to MHA. Till LDCE2024, 20
vacancies [2023=15, 2024=5] have been
restored to LDCE quota. Rest of the vacancies
would be restored in due course.
I further say that, in the year 2010, 85 LDCE
quota posts were diverted to promotion quota
as a one- time exemption to the RRs with the
prior approval of the DoP&T. Thereafter, 69
personnel were promoted legitimately through
Supplementary DPC 2010-11.”
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 5945/2017 & connected matters
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
26.
On the above factual background, submissions were made by
the learned counsels for the parties, which we shall deal herein under.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE LEARNED COUNSELS
FOR THE PETITIONERS
27.
Mr. Arun Bhardwaj, the learned Senior Advocate appearing for
the Union of India, submits that the promotions effected under DPC
for the years 2006 to 2010 were actually based on the quota prescribed
under the IBSSR, 2003 and, therefore, the officers appointed against
their own quota cannot be treated as ad-hoc.
28.
He submits that it was not the case of the respondents (LDCE
officers) that the Department was not informing the UPSC of the
quota for the LDCE or was under-reporting the same. He submits that
in absence of any such allegation or finding, the direction of the
learned Tribunal to treat all officers who had been regularly promoted
against the promotional quota to be treated as ad-hoc, cannot be
sustained. In support, he places reliance on the judgments of the
Supreme Court in G. S. Lamba & Ors. v. Union of India & Ors.,
(1985) 2 SCC 604; B. S. Murthy & Ors. v. A. Ravinder Singh & Ors.,
(2022) 14 SCC 119 and of this Court in Prashant Kumar Sona & Ors.
v. Union of India & Ors., (2024) SCC OnLine Del 4609.
29.
He submits that the DoP&T’s O.M. dated 07.02.1986 does not
bar the regular promotions against the promotional quota, even if the
LDCE quota vacancies have not been reported to the UPSC; it, at best,
restricts the regular promotions only to the extent of the vacancies that
are available within the quota during the relevant
year, and any
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 5945/2017 & connected matters
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
promotion made beyond the same is to be treated as ad-hoc, which is
not the case herein inasmuch as the promotions were effected on
seniority basis only against the 60% promotional quota and no excess
promotions were made during the relevant years.
30.
He submits that the LDCE for the relevant years could not be
held due to pending litigation in W.P.(C) No. 4876/2007 before this
Court concerning
the issue of eligibility of Stenographers for
appearing in the LDCE. The delay, therefore, cannot be attributed to
the Department.
31.
On the issue of diversion of posts, he submits that the diversion
was made with the approval of the DoP&T as the LDCE posts could
not be filled during the relevant years and there was a need to meet the
work requirement of the Department. Against the 85 vacancies that
were temporarily diverted, 69 officers were promoted and were
assigned their respective seniority. He submits that as the diversion
had taken place in accordance with law, no fault can be found in the
same nor can these officers be treated as ad-hoc.
32.
He submits that implementing the direction issued by the
learned Tribunal would amount to giving retrospective seniority to the
respondents/LDCE officers even before they are borne in the cadre;
the same is impermissible in law. In support, he places reliance on the
judgment of the Supreme Court in K. Meghachandra Singh & Ors. v.
Ningam Siro & Ors., (2020) 5 SCC 689.
33.
Mr. Padma Kumar S., the learned Advocate, appearing for
various officers from the promotional quota, while adopting the
submissions of Mr. Bhardwaj, further submits that some of these
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 5945/2017 & connected matters
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
officers could not have given the LDCE as they were already
promoted against the promotional quota. He submits that, therefore,
now to give effect to the Impugned Orders, would result in grave
injustice to them as they would lose their seniority without any fault of
theirs.
34.
He submits that there was no challenge made in the O.A. by the
respondents to the diversion of 85 vacancies from LDCE quota to the
promotional quota and, therefore, the respondents are now estopped
from challenging the same. He submits that once the diversion is
accepted, any promotion made against the same is to be treated as
regular and not ad-hoc.
SUBMISSIONS OF THE LEARNED COUNSELS FOR THE
RESPONDENTS
35.
On the other hand, Mr. A. K. Behera, learned Senior Advocate
appearing for the respondents (LDCE officers), submits that the
Affidavit dated 16.04.2025 filed by the IB shows that officers in
excess of promotional quota had been appointed for the years 2004-05
to 2009-10:
Year
2005-06
40%
vacancy
meant for
LDCE
60% vacancy
meant
for
promotion by
seniority.
2006-07
2007-08
2008-09
Comment of the contesting
respondent/excess promotion
made beyond 60% quota.
Thus, the promotion made is
excess by 14.
Thus, the promotion made is
excess by 25.
Thus, the promotion made is
excess by 34.
Thus, the promotion made is
excess by 53.
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 5945/2017 & connected matters
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
36.
2009-10
2010-11
Thus, the promotion made is
excess by 36.
Thus, the promotion made is
excess by 20.
He submits that even for the years 2006-07, 2007-08 and 2008-
09, the LDCE vacancies reported by the IB to the UPSC were only 10,
14 and 05 respectively; consequently, the corresponding 60%
promotional quota vacancies should, therefore, have been 15, 21 and
08 respectively; however, the Additional Affidavit dated 16.04.2025,
show that 35, 50 and 61 vacancies were shown against the
promotional quota for these respective years. He submits that this
itself shows that the promotions were made in excess of the prescribed
quota and any officer appointed in excess of the quota is to be treated
as ad-hoc in terms of the DoP&T O.M. dated 07.02.1986.
37.
He submits that once the respondents admit that no vacancies
were reported to the UPSC against the 40% quota for the LDCE in the
respective years, in terms of the DoP&T O.M. dated 07.02.1986, the
officers appointed against the other sources, that is, promotional
quota, are to be treated as ad-hoc. He submits that, therefore, no fault
can be found in the learned Tribunal’s direction to treat all officers
appointed during this period under promotional quota as ad-hoc and
thereafter, a Seniority List to be prepared interpolating the officers in
terms of the prescribed quota. In support, he places reliance on the
judgment of the Supreme Court in Pilla Sitaram Patrudu & Ors. v.
Union of India & Ors., (1996) 8 SCC 637.
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 5945/2017 & connected matters
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
38.
He submits that the plea of the IB that the LDCE vacancies
were not reported due to the pendency of the writ petition before this
Court, is also ill-founded inasmuch as the IB was not even a party to
the said litigation. Even otherwise, nothing prevented the IB from
moving an application seeking intervention or impleadment in the said
case. Therefore, the IB cannot be allowed to take advantage of the
pendency of the litigation.
39.
Coming to the issue of diversion of the LDCE vacancies, he
submits that Rule 8 of the IBSSR, 2003, permits relaxation only by
passing a specific order giving specific reasons in writing and with
consultation with the UPSC. The petitioners, other than saying that
they had the approval of the DoP&T to relax the rules and divert the
vacancies, have not been able to produce any specific order in this
regard. Even otherwise, on the date of the said approval by the
DoP&T, that is, 07.07.2010, the writ petition that was pending before
this Court and was made a basis for not holding the LCDE, already
stood adjudicated by a Judgment dated 26.05.2010. Therefore, there
was no occasion to divert the vacancies much less to make
appointments thereagainst by Orders dated 20.08.2010. He submits
that these promotions were made after the UPSC had already
requisitioned the vacancy position for the LDCE from the IB on
30.07.2010, and such information was supplied to the UPSC on
09.08.2010. He submits that, therefore, the diversion of vacancies and
promotions made in haste were all mala fide. He places reliance on the
judgments of the Supreme Court in Keshav Chandra Joshi & Ors. v.
Union of India & Ors., (1992) Supp 1 SCC 272; Syed Khalid Rizvi &
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 5945/2017 & connected matters
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
Ors.
v. Union of India & Ors., (1993) Supp 3 SCC 575; M.
Mazruddin Ali & Ors. v. Govt. of A.P. & Ors., (2000) 10 SCC 383;
Bhupendra Nath Hazarika & Anr. v. State of Assam & Ors., (2013) 2
SCC 516; State of Uttaranchal v. Alok Sharma & Ors., (2009) 7 SCC
647; Union of India & Anr. v. Wing Commander R. R. Hingorani,
(1987) 1 SCC 551; UPSC & Ors. v. Praveen Srivastava & Ors.,
(2018) SCC Online SC 3950; and in Praveen Srivastava & Ors. v.
UPSC & Ors., (2017) SCC Online Del 8710.
40.
He further submits that even in the advertisement issued by the
UPSC for LDCE on 28.08.2010, for the recruitment years 2006-07 to
2008-09, the eligibility criteria prescribed was on a year-to-year basis,
clearly showing that the officers were to be appointed against the
vacancies of a particular year and consequentially, be granted seniority
of the particular vacancy year. He submits that the respondents cannot
be denied this benefit on account of defaults of the Department.
41.
He submits that the issue of diversion of post was raised before
the learned Tribunal and the learned Tribunal gave adequate
opportunity to the parties to make submissions on the same.
Therefore, merely because a specific prayer was not made in this
regard in the O.A., would not act as an impediment on the respondents
challenging such diversion, and on the learned Tribunal, adversely
finding against the same. In support, he places reliance on the
judgments of the Supreme Court in J. Ganapatha & Ors. v. N.
Selvarajalou Chetty Trust & Ors., (2025) SCC Online SC 633;
Charanjit Lal Chowdhury v. UOI & Ors., 1950 SCC 833; and, in
State of Kerala v. Kumari T.P. Roshana & Anr., (1979) 1 SCC 572.
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 5945/2017 & connected matters
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
42.
He submits that as far as the reliance of the petitioners on the
judgment of the Supreme Court in K. Meghachandra (supra) is
concerned, the same has been referred to a Larger Bench in
Hariharan v. Harsh Vardhan Singh Rao, (2022) SCC Online SC
1717, wherein the Supreme Court has also directed that all cases in
which occasion for fixing seniority arose prior to 19.11.2019, in the
interregnum, will be governed by the judgment of the Supreme Court
in Union of India & Ors. v. N. R. Parmar & Ors., (2012) 13 SCC
340. He submits that such prospective overruling is also recognised by
the Supreme Court in Managing Director ECIL v. B Karmakar,
(1993) 4 SCC 727.
43.
With regard to the plea of Mr.Padma Kumar S., learned
Advocate, that certain officers could not take the LDCE because they
had already been promoted, the learned Senior Advocate for the
respondents submits that this plea is contrary to the record inasmuch
as not only were these officers allowed to appear in the LDCE, but
were also given an option to have their seniority determined either
under the LDCE or from the promotional quota. He submits that many
of them opted for their seniority to be determined under the LDCE
quota, as would be reflected from the details given in the Additional
Affidavit dated 16.04.2025 filed by the IB.
44.
He submits that therefore, no fault can be found in the
Impugned Orders passed by the learned Tribunal and the present set of
writ petitions deserves to be dismissed.
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 5945/2017 & connected matters
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
ANALYSIS & FINDINGS
45.
We have considered the submissions made by the learned
counsels for the parties.
46.
From the above narration of facts, it is not in dispute that in
terms of the IBSSR, 2003, a quota of 60:40 for promotions:LDCE is
prescribed for the post of SO. It is also not in dispute that the LDCE
for the years 2006-07 to 2008-09 were not held till 2010, while at the
same time, regular promotions were being made against the
promotional quota during these years. Similarly, though for the
vacancy year 2005, LDCE was held in December, 2006, results were
declared only in February, 2009, while in the meantime, officers under
the promotional quota continued to be promoted to the post of SO.
47.
The learned senior counsel for the IB has stated that the
examination for LDCE could not be conducted due to pendency of a
writ petition, being W.P.(C) No. 4876/2007, titled The Central
Secretariat Stenographers Service Association & Ors. v. The Central
Secretariat Service, Direct Recruit Assistants Association & Ors.,
before this Court on the question of eligibility of Stenographers to
participate in such examination. On the other hand, the learned senior
counsel for the respondents/LDCE officers submits that the said
litigation would have had no effect on the conduct of the regular
examination for LDCE inasmuch as the IB was not a party in that
litigation.
48.
In our view, decision of the UPSC not to hold LDCE due to the
pendency of the above referred writ petition and the uncertainty
attached to it, cannot be faulted. We find adequate justification for the
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 5945/2017 & connected matters
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
LDCE examination not being conducted for these years. We are
fortified in our opinion by the fact that while regular promotions were
being made and the LDCE was not being conducted, there was no
challenge made by any officer to the same during the relevant time.
Even in the O.A.(s) filed, it does not appear to be the case of the
respondent that the LDCEs were not being conducted due to some
mala fide or unjustified reasons. In fact, the retrospective seniority
was prayed on basis of the vacancy year against which the LDCE
appointments were being made.
49.
Similarly, the plea of the learned senior counsel for the
respondents that promotions were being made over and above the
promotional quota, cannot be accepted. This is not the basis on which
the O.A.(s) were filed before the learned Tribunal or decided by the
learned Tribunal.
50.
This now brings us to the effect of the situation where
promotions are being made on a regular basis against the promotional
quota, while the LDCE is not being conducted.
51.
The seniority in the above scenario is governed by the DoP&T
O.M. dated 07.02.1986, the relevant portion of which reads as under:
“3. This matter, which was also discussed in
the National Council has been engaging the
attention of the Government for quite some
time and it has been. decided that in future,
while the principle of rotation of quotas will
still be followed for determining the inter-se
seniority of direct recruits and promotees, the
present practice of keeping vacant slots for
being filled up by direct recruits of later years,
thereby giving them unintended seniority over
promotees who are already in position, would
be dispensed with. Thus, if adequate number of
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 5945/2017 & connected matters
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
direct recruits do not become available in any
particular year, rotation of quotas for purpose
of determining seniority would take place only
to the extent of the available direct recruits
and the promotees. In other words, to the
extent direct recruits are not available, the
promotees will be benched together at the
bottom of the seniority list below the last
position upto which it is possible to determine
seniority on the basis of rotation of quotas
with reference to the actual number of direct
recruits who become available. The unfilled
direct recruitment quota vacancies would,
however, be carried forward and added to the
corresponding direct recruitment vacancies of
the next year (and to subsequent years where
necessary) for taking action for direct
recruitment for the total number according to
the usual practice. Thereafter, in that year
while seniority will be determined between
direct recruits and promotees, to the extent of
the number of vacancies for direct recruits and
promotees as determined according to the
quota for that year, the additional direct
recruits selected against the carried forward
vacancies of the previous year would be
placed en-bloc below the last promotee (or
direct recruit as the case may be) in the
seniority list based on the rotation of
vacancies for that year. The same principle
holds good in determining seniority in the
event of carry forward, if any, of direct
recruitment or promotion quota vacancies (as
the case may be) in the subsequent years.
xxx
5.
With a view to curbing any tendency of
under-reporting/suppressing the vacancies to
be notified to the concerned authorities for
direct recruitment, it is clarified that
promotees will be treated as regular only to
the extent to which direct recruitment
vacancies are reported to the recruiting
authorities on the basis of the quotas
prescribed in the relevant recruitment rules.
Excess promotees, if any, exceeding the share
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 5945/2017 & connected matters
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
falling to the promotion quota based on the
corresponding figure, notified for direct
recruitment would be treated only as ad-hoc
promotees.”
52.
As noted hereinabove, it is the case of the Department that not
only were the promotions being made only against the promotional
quota and not in excess thereof, but also that there was no allegation
of ‘under reporting/suppressing the vacancies’ for the LDCE quota. It
is, therefore, submitted that the excess promotions, if any, cannot be
treated as ad-hoc, as directed by the learned Tribunal. We find merit in
the said submission.
53.
Once it is held that promotions were being made against the
promotional quota and not in excess thereof, the officers so promoted
cannot be treated as ad-hoc only because the officers from the other
stream, that is, LDCE, could not be promoted. They cannot be denied
the benefit of their promotion. In B. S. Murthy (supra), the Supreme
Court held that Paragraph 5 of the O.M. dated 07.02.1986 is meant to
cater to a contingency of under-reporting which results in an unfair
advantage to one stream and allows it to steal a march over the other.
The same cannot be said in the present case inasmuch as, we do not
find that there was a mala fide under-reporting for allowing the
promotee officers to steal a march over the LDCE officers. We may
quote from the judgment as under:
“62. Hence, it is essential to keep in mind
that Para 5, (which has been the basis of the
High Court judgment, to hold that the PRIs
were in excess of their quota) was meant to
cater to a contingency that is of
underreporting direct recruit vacancies to the
Public Service Commission (in this case, the
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 5945/2017 & connected matters
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
SSC) which resulted in an unfair advantage to
promotees who would “steal a march” over
such direct recruits, appointed later. It was in
such contingencies, that is, of under-reporting
vacancies, that the consequence of deeming
promotions to be ad hoc could be resorted to.
If one keeps this perspective in mind, the
correct direction of inquiry, (which in this
Court's opinion was undertaken by CAT) was
to see what were the number of regular
vacancies relative to the quotas, with specific
reference to the vacancy register. This
approach, however, was discredited by the
High Court, which held that the vacancy
register : (A. Ravinder Singh case [A.
Ravinder Singh v. Commr. of Customs &
Central Excise, 2005 SCC OnLine AP 1274] ,
SCC OnLine AP para 26)
“26. … at the most indicates the
vacancy position in DRI/PRI cadre and it is
not intended to confer the benefit of promotion
on in-service candidates more especially when
the promotions are to be effected with
reference to the vacancies indented for DRIs.
Therefore, the observation of the Tribunal that
only in case of detection of underreporting/suppression the bunching process
had to be adopted and in other cases the
vacancies position vis-à-vis the promotion has
to be identified from the vacancy register is
untenable.”
63. As discussed, the materials on record
indicate that promotional vacancies did exist,
at the relevant period. There was a ban on
direct recruitment. The reasons for the ban are
now obscure; but the fact remains that it was
in force for six years (1984-90). During this
period, undoubtedly, no requisitions were
made to the SSC for filling direct recruit
vacancies. However, the linear logic, applied
by the High Court, to conclude that by virtue
of Para 5 of the OM of 1986, the promotions
made during the same period had to be treated
as in excess of the quota, because they were
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 5945/2017 & connected matters
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
not in proportion to the requisitions for direct
recruitment. This view is plainly fallacious,
because it equates executive policy—of not
filling vacancies, due to financial or other
compulsions with deliberate underreporting,
meant to result in unfair advantage to the
PRIs. In the present case, direct recruitment
through the SSC was not resorted to because
of a ban, and not due to under-reporting.
Thus, the contingency visualised in Para 5
never arose. Not only were promotions made
within the quota, and were regular (as they
were preceded by proceedings of the
Departmental Promotion Committee, and
culminated in regularisation, in 1988), there
were in fact regular vacancies, within the
promotee quota.
64. The existence of PRI vacancies is a
matter of objective fact — as can be seen from
the replies to the RTI queries (see footnotes 13
to 15 supra [Ed. : See paras 18 to 20 and
paras 46 and 47, above] ). Those vacancies
fell to the share of PRIs, in terms of the 25%
quota earmarked for them, under statutory
rules. In such circumstances, to say that those
promoted, by resort to DPCs and regularised
later, should be treated as ad hoc promotees,
would be contrary to express rules. In other
words, by giving effect to Para 5 of the 1986
OM, (and treating the promotions as ad hoc
for purposes of inter se seniority), the statutory
rules are virtually given a go-by. It is also
contrary to the stated objective sought to be
achieved by Para 3 of the 1986 OM, which is
to “present practice of keeping vacant slots for
being filled up by direct recruits of later years,
thereby giving them unintended seniority over
promotees who are already in position, would
be dispensed with”. The promotions of the
PRIs before this Court therefore, have to be
treated as regular. This Court is of the
opinion, that the reasoning of the High Court,
in overlooking these aspects, is clearly in
error.”
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 5945/2017 & connected matters
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
54.
In G. S. Lamba (supra), the Supreme Court held that even
where it is assumed that promotions were being made in excess of the
quota, once there is a power to relax the mandatory quota rule, such
appointments made in excess of the quota would not be illegal or
invalid but regular and legal. In the present case, it has been held by us
that the promotional quota was not being exceeded, and even if it was,
the promotions so made cannot be termed as illegal or invalid and
certainly not ad-hoc, thereby denying the benefit of such promotion to
the officers so promoted, including in terms of their seniority.
55.
In Prashant Kumar Sona (supra), dealing with almost identical
facts, this Court held that non-holding of the LDCE would only show
that the quota rule has broken-down, however, this would neither
denude the officers promoted against their quota of the benefit of such
promotion for seniority nor give a right to the LDCE officers to claim
a retrospective seniority by operation of the quota rule. We quote from
the judgment as under:
“34. Even though this plea of the petitioners
appears to be attractive on the first blush, on
applying the same to the factual matrix of the
present case, we are of the view that the
petitioner’s claim for grant of retrospective
seniority has to be rejected. Even if the
petitioners and other beneficiaries of LDCE
were not at fault for deferment of the LDCE
for five years, the fact remains that during this
entire period of five years when the LDCE
exam was on hold, promotions to the post of
SOs were being regularly made. We are,
therefore, of the view that as held by the Apex
Court in G.S. Lamba (supra), in the present
case as well on account of the LDCE not being
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 5945/2017 & connected matters
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
held for almost five years, the quota rule had
as a matter of fact broken down. Merely
because the quota rule had broken down due
to unavoidable factors, cannot change the
position that the said rule like in the case of
G.S. Lamba (supra), had broken down.
Consequently, the rota rule could not have
been applied to grant retrospective seniority to
LDCEs appointed as SOs only in the year
2011. It would, therefore, be highly unjust to
the promotees, if the SOs appointed/promoted
through LDCE in 2011, like the petitioners,
are accorded seniority over them. We cannot
lose sight of the fact that while the promotees
had been working as SOs since 2006 onwards,
the petitioners and other employees recruited
through LDCE joined the post of SO only in
2011 and were admitted, during the period
between 2006 and 2011, working on the junior
posts of Assistant Grade II or lower.”
56.
In Suraj Prakash Gupta v. State of J&K & Ors., (2000) 7 SCC
561, on which much reliance has been placed by the learned senior
counsel for the respondents, the Court had held that there was lethargy
of the State and total inaction on its part in not asking the Service
Commission to make direct recruitment. The Court held that delay on
the part of the Government appeared to be motivated for the purpose
of blocking the quota of the direct recruits and giving a part of it to the
promotees. The Court held that the Rules therein gave power to relax
the same where suitable candidates are not available. The Court held
that such non availability of the candidates cannot be inferred and
therefore, there was no breakdown of the quota rule. The said
judgment cannot have application in the facts of the present writ
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 5945/2017 & connected matters
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
petitions as we do not find any mala fide in the department in not
holding the LDCE.
57.
Coming to the issue of diversion, we may, at the outset, note
that though the same was never put in challenge before the learned
Tribunal, the learned Tribunal, however, considered the same and held
that no regular appointment could have been made against these
diverted posts. We quote from the Impugned Order as under:
“27. In the reply filed by the private
respondents it has been averred that, with the
concurrence of MHA and DOPT, 85 vacancies
were diverted from LDCE quota to promotion
quota in the year 2010 on an undertaking that
the same will be restored to LDCE quota later.
There is no document or even averment to
show that such a diversion was in relaxation of
the rules by exercising power under rule
8(Power to relax) of the IBSSR. It goes without
saying that if such relaxation were granted
there would be no need to restore the LDCE
quota. The context indicates that it was only a
measure to temporarily fill up the vacancies by
promotion. The approval of MHA and DOPT,
as has been averred, was for temporary
diversion. No regular appointment could have
been made against temporarily diverted post
which had to be restored to the original quota
subsequently”
58.
Rule 8 of the IBSSR-2003 vests with the Central Government a
power to relax any of the provisions of the said Rules. It reads as
under:
“8. Powers to relax - Where the Central
Government is of the opinion that it is
necessary or expedient so to do, may, by
order, for reasons to be recorded in writing
and in consultation with the Union Public
Service Commission, relax any of the
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 5945/2017 & connected matters
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
provisions of these rules with respect to any
class or category of person.”
59.
The only document sought to be relied upon by the petitioners
as a relaxation to the Rules and for diversion of the posts, is the
following Noting of the DoP&T:
“Department of Personnel & Training
Estt. (RR) Division
MHA have submitted the proposal relating to
diversion of vacancies earmarked for Limited
Departmental
Competitive
Examination
(LDCE) in Section Officer Grade in IB to
promotion quota. The RRs for the post of
Section Officer prescribe the method of
recruitment 60% by promotion, 40% through
LDCE, Assistants with 8 years services are
eligible for promotion. For LDCE regular
Assistants/Stenographer Grade II/Personal
Assistant (IB) with not less than 4 years are
included In the field of consideration. It is
indicated that due to non-holding of LDCE by
UPSC the vacancies under this category have
remained unfilled which is adversely affecting
the functioning of IB. As per the
communication dated 13.5.10 from UPSC, it is
seen that the Commission and DOPT are
under a consultative process to find a route
map for holding LDCE from 2006 onwards.
2.
The proposal for diversion of vacancies
from LDCE to promotion
quota may not be in order for the reasons
indicated in para 6 of p. 7/N.However,
considering the functional difficulties arising
due to a large number of vacancies in the SO
Grade, we may, as a one time measure, agree
for temporary diversion of 85 vacancies of
SOs from LDCE quota to promotion quota
with the condition that the shortfall In the
LDCE quota is made good at the time of future
vacancies. Alternatively, the vacancies may be
filled up on ad hoc basis.”
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 5945/2017 & connected matters
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
60.
The Department, treating the above to be an approval of the
DoP&T for the diversion of 85 vacancies of SO(s) from LDCE quota
to promotional quota, has filled up 69 of such posts on 20.08.2010,
that is, prior to the promotion being granted to the respondents/LDCE
officers in 2011, thereby making such officers senior to the
respondents/LDCE officers.
61.
The learned senior counsel for the respondents is correct in his
submission that no specific order of such diversion of vacancies has
been placed on record before the learned Tribunal or before this Court
by the Department.
62.
The above-quoted Noting of the DoP&T would show that a
proposal has been mooted for the diversion of the vacancies, giving
reason for the same as the inability to hold LDCE for the year 2006
onwards resulting in functional difficulties due to a large number of
vacancies in the SO Grade. The said reasons were accepted by the
DoP&T and the proposal was granted approval with the condition that
such diversion shall be temporary and shall have to be made good at
the time of future vacancies. Therefore, it is to be assumed that the
proposal to relax the quota rule had been granted due approval by the
DoP&T. However, the Department has not placed on record any
specific order whereby it has exercised the power to relax the rules
and to formally divert the LDCE vacancies to the promotional quota.
63.
In terms of Rule 8 of the IBSSR-2003, there is a requirement
for a specific order giving reasons ‘in writing’ and in consultation with
the UPSC to relax the rules. Neither have we been shown a specific
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 5945/2017 & connected matters
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
order giving reasons for the diversion of vacancies, nor has it has been
shown to us that there was any consultation with the UPSC or that its
approval was taken before making the diversion of the posts.
64.
Even the Note of the DoP&T, which has been sought to be
relied upon by the Department, shows that there was an alternative of
the vacancies to be filled up on ad-hoc basis. We must herein also note
that the judgment in writ petition pending before this Court, which
was the reason for not holding the LDCE, had been reserved on
15.05.2010 and was pronounced on 26.05.2010. The impediment for
holding the LDCE was, therefore, no longer in existence when the
above-quoted Note of the DoP&T was made. The UPSC, in fact, on
30.07.2010, had requisitioned from the IB the number of vacancies for
the LDCE quota for the years 2006 to 2008. By that time, the
promotions had yet not been made by the IB. In fact, they were not
made even when the information about the LDCE quota for these
years was sent by the IB to the UPSC. On 20.08.2010, when the
promotion orders were issued, in fact, the UPSC had also advertised
the examination for filling up the vacancies of the LDCE quota.
65.
In the above facts, the decision of the IB to appoint officers
against the diverted LDCE vacancies cannot be accepted. The officers
promoted against such diverted vacancies, therefore, are to be treated
as ad-hoc for the purposes of determining their seniority.
66.
In Syed Khalid Rizvi (supra), the Supreme Court while
interpreting almost an identical rule to that of Rule 8 of the IBSSR,
2003, held that it would require an express order in writing and
invoking a fiction of deeming relaxation would emasculate the
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 5945/2017 & connected matters
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
operation of the rules and regulations and be fraught with grave
imbalances and chain reactions. We quote from the judgment as
under:
“33. Rule 3 of the Residuary Rules provides
the power to relax rules and regulations in
certain cases — where the Central
Government is satisfied that the operation of
— (i) any rule made or deemed to have been
made under the Act, or (ii) any regulation
made under any such rule, regulating the
conditions of service of persons appointed to
an All India Service “causes undue hardship
in any particular case”, it may, by order,
dispense with or relax the requirements of that
rule or regulation, as the case may be, to such
an extent and subject to such exceptions and
conditions as it may consider necessary for
dealing with the case in a “just and equitable
manner”. Rule 3 empowers the Central
Government to relieve undue hardship caused
due to unforeseen or unmerited circumstances.
The Central Government must be satisfied that
the operation of the rule or regulation brought
about undue hardship to an officer. The
condition precedent, therefore, is that there
should be an appointment to the service in
accordance with rules and by operation of the
rule, undue hardship has been caused, that too
in an individual case. The Central Government
on its satisfaction of those conditions, have
been empowered to relieve such undue
hardship by exercising the power to relax the
condition. It is already held that conditions of
recruitment and conditions of service are
distinct and the latter is preceded by an
appointment according to Rules. The former
cannot be relaxed. The latter too must be in
writing that too with the consultation of UPSC.
In Mohapatra [(1969) 2 SCC 149 : (1970) 1
SCR 255] and Khanna [(1972) 1 SCC 784 :
(1972) 3 SCR 548] this Court held that
approval by the Central Government and
UPSC are mandatory. In A.K. Chowdhury
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 5945/2017 & connected matters
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
case [(1975) 4 SCC 7 : 1975 SCC (L&S) 192 :
(1975) 3 SCR 878] it was held that
requirement of Rule 3(3)(b) of Seniority Rules
is mandatory. In Amrik Singh case [(1980) 3
SCC 393 : 1980 SCC (L&S) 415 : (1980) 3
SCR 485] an express order in writing under
Rule 3 of Residuary Rules is mandatory. In
this case neither any representation to relax
the rules was made nor any order in writing in
this behalf was expressly passed by the
Central Government. The fiction of deeming
relaxation would emasculate the operation of
the Rules and Regulations and be fraught with
grave imbalances and chain reaction. It is,
therefore, difficult to accept the contention
that there would be deemed relaxation of the
Rules and Regulations.”
67.
In M. Mazruddin Ali (supra), the Supreme Court again
emphasised the need for a specific order for relaxation of the rules to
operate.
68.
In view of the above, it must be held that the power to relax
the IBSSR, 2003, was not properly exercised by the Central
Government and the 69 officers promoted thereagainst, therefore,
are to be treated as only ad-hoc and are not entitled to claim any
seniority based thereon. They would need to be adjusted against the
future vacancies of the post of SO against their respective quotas for
the purposes of determination of their seniority.
69.
This now brings us to the additional submission of Mr.Padma
Kumar S., learned Advocate, that certain officers were not allowed
to take the LDCE as they had been promoted against the diverted
vacancies. He has given a specific example of one, Ms. Manjula
Devi. The said submission has been rebutted by the learned senior
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 5945/2017 & connected matters
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
counsel for the respondents by contending that Ms. Manjula Devi
had applied and had been issued an admit card for the LDCE
examination. He submitted that there were other similarly placed
candidates who had appeared for the LDCE and though they had
been granted promotion against the diverted vacancies, on their
selection in the LDCE, were given an option whether they would
like to continue on the promoted post in the promotional quota or be
assigned seniority under the LDCE quota. These officers opted for
LDCE quota seniority as would be evident from the Additional
Affidavit filed by the Department.
70.
From the Additional Affidavit dated 16.04.2025, filed by the
IB, it would be evident that certain officers, though were promoted
against the diverted vacancies, opted for their seniority to be
determined as an LDCE candidate on successfully appearing in the
LDCE. This negates the submission of Mr. Padma Kumar S.,
learned Advocate, that such officers were not allowed to participate
in the LDCE as they had already been promoted against the diverted
vacancies. In any case, once we have held that the diversion of the
vacancies was not in accordance with the Rules, such officers who
were promoted against these diverted vacancies cannot claim
seniority.
71.
In view of the above, we dispose of this batch of writ petitions
by holding as under:
a)
The Impugned Orders of the learned Tribunal insofar as they
hold that the promotions made to the post of SO against the
promotional vacancies for the years 2005 to 2010 shall be treated as
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 5945/2017 & connected matters
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
ad-hoc, cannot be sustained. These promotions, having been made
against the vacancies of the promotional quota, are treated as regular,
giving the seniority benefits to such officers;
b)
The alleged diversion of 85 vacancies from the LDCE quota to
the promotional quota was not in accordance with the IBSSR, 2003,
and, therefore, cannot be sustained. The promotion of 69 officers
made against the alleged diverted vacancies would, therefore, be
treated as ad-hoc, not vesting such officers with any seniority benefit.
These officers will gain their seniority only on their turn by applying
the respective quota in terms of the IBSSR, 2003;
c)
Certain officers who were promoted against the alleged diverted
vacancies, however, on their selection in the LDCE, had opted for
their seniority to be determined in the LDCE. These officers would,
therefore, retain their seniority under the LDCE quota. In case any
other officer who was promoted under the diverted vacancies and in
spite of successfully clearing the LDCE chose for the seniority to be
determined under the promotional quota, would be given another
option to seek seniority according to his/her rank in the LDCE;
d)
The officers who were promoted under the LDCE would gain
their seniority only from the date of their promotion and not from the
year(s) of their vacancy;
e)
In case any officer claims that he/she was not allowed to appear
in the LDCE having
been promoted against the alleged diverted
vacancies, he/she can raise this grievance with the Department, which
shall consider the same in accordance with the law and pass a
reasoned order thereon within a period of four weeks of receipt of
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 5945/2017 & connected matters
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
such representation;
f)
A fresh Seniority List on basis of our above directions for the
posts of SO shall be prepared by the Department within a period of
eight weeks. It shall, however, be open to the officers to challenge the
same, if they are aggrieved thereby, in accordance with law.
72.
With the above directions, the writ petitions along with the
pending applications are disposed of.
73.
There shall be no order as to costs.
NAVIN CHAWLA, J.
MADHU JAIN, J.
JANUARY 12, 2026/sg/pb
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) 5945/2017 & connected matters
By:REYMON VASHIST
17:42:36
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review