The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
6. In such circumstances, we are of the considered view that no indulgence can be given to the Union of India in view of the settled position of law and on account of the apparent negligence in contesting the present petition.
7. In view of above terms, present petition is dismissed on the ground of delay and laches, so also, the pending miscellaneous application(s), if any. ( G.S. Sandhawalia) Chief Justice February 26, 2026 (KS/ST) ( Bipin Chander Negi) Judge
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
CWP No.17922 of 2025
Date of Decision : 26.02.2026
Union of India and another
…… Petitioners
Versus
Khem Raj Verma and another
…… Respondents
Coram:
The Hon’ble Mr. Justice G.S. Sandhawalia, Chief Justice
The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Bipin Chander Negi, Judge
Whether approved for reporting?1
For the Petitioners
:
For the Respondents :
Mr. Balram Sharma, Deputy Solicitor General of
India.
Mr. Sajeev Bhushan, Senior Advocate with
Mr. Rajesh Kumar, Advocate.
G.S. Sandhawalia, Chief Justice (Oral)
The challenge in the present writ petition is against the order
dated 09.07.2020, passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal
Chandigarh Bench (Circuit Bench) at Shimla, whereby, the order passed
by the present petitioners dated 13.07.2015 rejecting their claim for
regularization was set aside. Directions were issued that once the posts
of MTS are available in the Institution, it cannot be said that the
respondents cannot be adjusted against them and further if they cannot
Whether reporters of Local Papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
not regularized, at least they can be considered against them for fresh
appointment prospectively, while noting the fact that the said employees,
as such, had been working between 1999-2004, on contract basis.
2.
The Union of India, as such, was satisfied with the said order
and chose not to agitate it for all these long years. It was only when
subsequent order dated 07.08.2025 was passed in a miscellaneous
application by noting that earlier order had not been complied with, in
letter and spirit and fresh directions were issued, the present writ petition
has been preferred. In such circumstances, it is only re-iteration of earlier
view, as such, finally inter se the parties.
3.
Therefore, we are of the considered opinion that challenge to
the earlier order, which has become final, at such a belated stage, would
not be maintainable. The second order, as such, was only by way of
execution petition and, therefore, it cannot give the Union of India a fresh
cause of action, as such, to contest their case on merits.
4.
In similar circumstances, present petitioners had also filed
CWP No.6810 of 2025 titled Indian Institute of Advanced Studies vs. Dr.
S.K. Goel and another dated 23.07.2025, wherein, there was a delay of
more than two years in filing the writ petition and we have dismissed the
said writ petition keeping in view the law laid down in CWP No.2522 of
2025, titled Union of India and others vs. Pawna Devi, dated 25.02.2025
that the writ petition filed after a gap of two years from the decision of the
Tribunal would not be liable to be entertained since vested rights, as such,
accrued in favour of the litigant. Relevant portion of the judgment passed
in Pawna Devi’s case (supra) reads as under:“4. We are of the considered opinion that though there is
no period prescribed for filing the writ petitions which
challenge the orders of the Tribunal while invoking the
power under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, but
the Union of India cannot be permitted free play, as such
to challenge the said orders at its own whims and fancies
after a period of over two years in all these set of cases.
The parties to the litigation have developed a vested right
as such after the orders have come in force in their favour
and for the Union of India as such to file these writ
petitions after the delay as mentioned above, cannot as
such be countenanced in the absence of any justifiable
reasons.
5 to 7……..
8. Thus, we can safely hold that there is deliberate
inaction and lack of bonafide by the Union of India which
amounts to gross negligence and the Union of India
cannot take advantage of an order passed by the Hon’ble
Apex Court whereby, the right to challenge the orders of
the Armed Forces Tribunal has been cemented by
noticing that constitutional provisions under Article 226 of
the Constitution of India cannot be curtailed.
9 to 10………
11. In service matters, the Hon’ble Apex Court has time
and again held that the orders passed by the authorities
regarding seniority etc. be challenged within a reasonable
time and reference can be made in the judgment of P.S.
Sadasivcaswamyv. State of Tamil Nadu, AIR 1974 SC
2271, whereby the right has been curtailed of the litigants
to challenge the administrative orders or claim the right to
seniority by filing the writ petitions.
12. The said principle can be kept in mind while deciding
the present cases also. The concept of liberal approach
has to be kept in mind, but the concept of reasonableness
and a total unfettered free play cannot be permitted and
there is a distinction between inordinate delay and delay
of short duration. The fundamental principle before the
Court is to weigh the balance of justice in respect of both
parties and inaction of a party cannot be given the go-by
in the name of a liberal approach and the lack of
bonafide’s which is a relevant factor.
13 to 21… … …
22.
In
State
of
Orissa
SunandaMahakuda(2021)
and
others
versus
SCC
560,
similar
observations came forth from the apex Court while
dismissing a Special Leave Petition which was time
barred and proceedings had been filed after contempt
proceedings had been initiated on the dismissal of the
writ appeal and therefore, the conduct
of the State Government was depreciated while imposing
costs of Rs.25000/-.
23.
Similar was the position in State of Uttar Pradesh
and others versus SabhaNarain and others(2022) 9 SCC
266, which is a three Judge Bench verdict. The relevant
portion reads as under:“4.We have also categorized such kind of cases as
“certificate cases” filed with the only object to obtain
a quietus from the Supreme Court on the ground
that nothing could be done because the highest
Court has dismissed the appeal. The objective is to
complete a mere formality and save the skin of the
officers who may be in default in following the due
process or may have done it deliberately. We have
deprecated such practice and process and we do so
again. We refuse to grant such certificates and if the
Government/public authorities suffer losses, it is time
when concerned officers responsible for the same,
bear the consequences. The irony, emphasized by
us repeatedly, is that no action is ever taken against
the officers and if the Court pushes it, some mild
warning is all that happens.”
24.
In PathapatiSubba Reddy (died) by LRs and others
vs. Special Deputy Collector (LA) 2024 SC OnLine SC
513, it was also held that stale matters cannot be
entertained to defeat the substantial law of limitation and
Statute.
25.
It is not the case of Union of India that there is any
fraud or misrepresentation in the present set of cases,
whereby mainly the legal representatives of the Armed
Forces are seeking redressal of their rights. The State or
the public body can be given some acceptable latitude
keeping in view the law laid down by the Hon’ble Apex
Court in the principle of limitation and though no precise
formula, as such,can be laid down, but we cannot brush
aside the fact that the parties in view of the orders passed
by the Tribunal could have also resorted to getting the
orders executed by filing appropriate remedies and
Tribunal has also granted the benefit of penal interest, if
the payment is not made within the prescribed period.
Inspite of this fact the Union of India chose to sit tight and
chose not to file the writ petitions within a reasonable
period which can be classified as one year and beyond
the same, no indulgence can be granted.
26.
Therefore, the period prior to 18.10.2023 as such
between the date of the decisions ranging from
May/August/November, 2022 cannot be condoned in any
manner and therefore, we are of the considered opinion
that the present writ petitions are liable to be dismissed
on the
grounds of delay and laches as on account of Union of
India
not
having
resorted
to
its
legal
remedies
expeditiously or even having made reasonable effort to
challenge the said orders or even take a decision as such
to challenge the said orders for a period of over one year.
The latitude as such on account of laxity on the
department, in such circumstances cannot be extended.
27.
Without going into the merits of the cases, we are
of the considered opinion that there is a delay of over a
year from passing of the orders and no effort was made
to challenge the order passed by the Tribunal within a
reasonable time, therefore, on account of the opinion
given on 18.09.2023, the Union of India cannot raise the
issue on merits.
28.
Resultantly, there is no other option, but to dismiss
these four writ petitions on account of the principle of
delay and laches and the same are accordingly dismissed
alongwith pending miscellaneous application(s), if any.”
5.
Learned Deputy Solicitor General of India, as such, having
been put to notice of the said events on 19.11.2025, had taken time
seeking necessary instructions, but apparently there is no positive
instruction in favour of the respondents.
Only communication dated
24.02.2026 has been placed on record showing that order directing
framing of charge in the contempt petition of even date of 07.08.2025 is
sought to be challenged before the Apex Court.
6.
In such circumstances, we are of the considered view that no
indulgence can be given to the Union of India in view of the settled
position of law and on account of the apparent negligence in contesting
the present petition.
7.
In view of above terms, present petition is dismissed on the
ground of delay and laches, so also, the pending miscellaneous
application(s), if any.
( G.S. Sandhawalia)
Chief Justice
February 26, 2026 (KS/ST)
( Bipin Chander Negi)
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review