The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
4. There is a need to regulate ART clinics and banks by establishing the National Board, the State Boards, the National Registry and the State Registration Authorities for the regulation and supervision of assisted reproductive technology clinics and the assisted reproductive technology banks, for prevention of misuse and for safe and ethical practice of assisted reproductive technology services.” Relevant provisions of Assisted Reproductive Technology (Regulation) Act, 2021 are hereby quoted below:“2(e) “commissioning couple” means an infertile married couple who approach an assisted reproductive technology clinic or assisted reproductive technology bank for obtaining the services authorised of the said clinic or bank; 2(n) “patients” means an individual or couple who comes to any registered assisted reproductive technology clinic for management of infertility; 2(u) “woman” means any woman above the age of twenty-one years who approaches an assisted reproductive technology clinic or assisted reproductive technology bank for obtaining the authorised services of the clinic or bank. 2(2) The expressions “clinics” and “banks” occurring in this Act shall be constructed as “assisted reproductive technology clinics” and “assisted reproductive technology banks”. *** *** 21(g) the clinics shall apply the assisted reproductive technology services,(i) to a woman above the age of twenty-one …
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
09.03.2026
Item No.02
Court No.12
CP
MAT No.1745 of 2025
with
CAN 1 of 2025
Union of India & Anr.
Vs.
Bipul Kumar Sarker & Ors.
Mr. Kumar Jyoti Tiwari, Sr. Advocate
Ms. Anamika Pandey
Ms. Samriddhi Nayak
Mr. Amit Sinha
Mr. Aniruddha Tewari
....for the appellants.
The appellants are aggrieved by the judgment and
order dated May 14, 2024, passed by a learned Single
Judge, by which WPA 12573 of 2024 was disposed of by
directing the concerned clinic, under the provisions of
Assisted
Reproductive
Technology
(Regulation)
Act,
2021, (hereinafter referred to as „the said Act‟), to allow
the respondents to avail of the facility of assisted
reproductive technology services with the sperm/gamete
of the husband, writ petitioner no. 1 and the oocyte of
the writ petitioner no. 2 (wife), as the first choice.
Mr. Tewari, learned senior advocate for the
appellants, submits that the effect of the decision
impugned resulted in diluting the provisions of the
statute, especially the definition of „woman‟ and „couple‟.
He further relies on a decision of the Division Bench of
the Kerala High Court in the matter of Union of India
Vs. Nandini K & Ors. reported in 2025: KER:55330 in
support of his contention that after the promulgation of
the said Act, any attempt at assisted reproductive
services, would be governed solely by the said Act and
the cycle would start afresh under the provisions of the
said Act, if not completed at the earlier stage. Mr. Tewari
relied on the definition of various terms in the Act, in
support
of
his
contention
that
the
statute
was
unambiguous. A literal meaning should have been given
to the provisions. The learned Single Judge should not
have given a purposive interpretation of section 21(g)
thereof.
The writ petition was filed challenging the vires of
Section 21(g) of the said Act. The writ petitioners were
Bangladeshi citizens. The writ petitioners sought to avail
of the treatment for assisted pregnancy.
It has been informed to the court that the writ
petitioners
are
not
in
India.
They
have
left
for
Bangladesh and a baby has been born. The learned
counsel for the writ petitioners
took release from the
matter. The appellants attempted to serve the writ
petitioners but they are not before us.
In the present case, the husband had crossed the
age of 55 years when the writ petition had been filed,
but when the sperm of the husband was collected, he
was below 55 years. The wife was within the age limit to
undergo IVF treatment. The husband did not have any
further function in the process.
The first question raised by appellants was
whether a Bangladeshi national could take advantage of
the said Act. His Lordship considered the issue by
relying on the preamble of the Act and the statement
and objects thereof.
His Lordship came to the conclusion that, the Act
was promulgated to regulate ART services and to protect
affected women and children from exploitation. In the
statement and objects of the subject Bill, it was clarified
by the legislature that India had become a recognized
country where major centres for IVF treatment had been
established and reproductive medical tourism had
become a significant activity. Thus, His Lordship was of
the view that the statement of objects clearly indicated
that none should be deprived of the treatment if they fall
within the parameters of the statute. The Bangladeshi
nationals were not in India to stay, forever, but to avail
of the treatment. The purpose of the Act was to regulate
reproductive medical tourism in India, as it had become
a major centre of the global fertility industry. His
Lordship did not find any provision in the statute which
prohibited
foreigners
from
availing
of
assisted
reproduction. There is no law which prohibits foreign
nationals from availing any medical treatment in India.
Statement of Objects and Reasons behind the
promulgation of the Assisted Reproductive Technology
(Regulation) Act, 2021 are hereby quoted below:“Assisted reproductive technology (ART) has
grown by leaps and bounds in the last few years.
India has highest growths in the ART centres and
the number of ART cycles performed every year.
Assisted Reproductive Technology including invitro-fertilisation, has given hope to a multitude of
persons suffering from infertility, but it has also
introduced a plethora of legal, ethical and social
issues.
2. India has over the years become one of the
major centres of this global fertility industry, with
reproductive medical tourism becoming a
significant activity. Clinics in India offer nearly all
the ART services—gamete donation, intrauterine
insemination,
in-vitrofertilisation,
intra
cytoplasmic sperm injection, pre-implantation
genetic diagonistic and gestational surrogacy.
However, in spite of so much activity in India,
there is yet no standardisation of protocols and
reporting is still very inadequate. Furthermore,
there is no law to regulate ART and it is regulated
through guidelines.
3. The need to regulate the Assisted Reproductive
Technology Services is mainly to protect the
affected women and children from exploitation.
The oocyte donor needs to be supported by an
insurance cover. Multiple embryo implantation
needs to be regulated and children born through
ART need to be protected. The cryopreservation of
sperm, oocytes and embryo by the ART Banks
need to be regulated and the proposed legislation
intends to make Pre Genetic Implantation Testing
mandatory for the benefit of the child born
through assisted reproductive technology.
4. There is a need to regulate ART clinics and
banks by establishing the National Board, the
State Boards, the National Registry and the State
Registration Authorities for the regulation and
supervision of assisted reproductive technology
clinics and the assisted reproductive technology
banks, for prevention of misuse and for safe and
ethical
practice
of
assisted
reproductive
technology services.”
Relevant
provisions
of
Assisted
Reproductive
Technology (Regulation) Act, 2021 are hereby quoted
below:“2(e) “commissioning couple” means an infertile
married couple who approach an assisted
reproductive technology clinic or assisted
reproductive technology bank for obtaining the
services authorised of the said clinic or bank;
2(n) “patients” means an individual or couple who
comes to any registered assisted reproductive
technology clinic for management of infertility;
2(u) “woman” means any woman above the age of
twenty-one years who approaches an assisted
reproductive technology clinic or assisted
reproductive technology bank for obtaining the
authorised services of the clinic or bank.
2(2) The expressions “clinics” and “banks”
occurring in this Act shall be constructed as
“assisted reproductive technology clinics” and
“assisted reproductive technology banks”.
***
***
21(g) the clinics shall apply the assisted
reproductive technology services,(i) to a woman above the age of twenty-one years
and below the age of fifty years;
(ii) to a man above the age of twenty-one years
and below the age of fifty-five years.”
His Lordship recorded that the sperm of the
husband was collected before he was 55. Thus, the age
bar would not apply. The concerned clinic, as the
expert, was asked to examine whether the sperm quality
was adequate for reproduction and whether a healthy
baby could be born. The clinic has obviously found that
the sperm quality was upto the standard and continued
with the process, and the child was born.
Mr. Tiwari places reliance on the opinion of the
National Board, justifying the reasons for prescribing
the age limit under Section 21(g) of the Act for ART
services. With regard to prescription of age limit of a
male, the Board opined thus:“Even men sperm quality is also compromised
in above 55 years age, the number of mutations in
the father‟s genome increases that leads to an
increase
in
the
incidence
of
congenital
malformations in offspring. Older paternal age may
be harmful to the offspring‟s health in terms of
genetic mutation and epigenetics.”
Thus, according to the Board also, the sperm
quality of a male above 55 years would be compromised
and the number of mutations in the father‟s genome
would increase, which would lead to an increase in
incidence of congenital malformations of the offspring.
The age limit was specific in the opinion of the Board,
i.e., male above 55 years, which does not apply in this
case as the sperm was collected prior to the man
turning 55.
The learned Single Judge did not consider the
prayer seeking striking down the provisions of Section
21(g)
of
the
said
Act,
on
the
ground
of
unconstitutionalily. The decision of the Kerala High
Court does not apply to the facts of this case.
In this case, as the sperm was collected prior to
the age of 55 of the husband and the wife was within
the age limit, His Lordship was of the view that the
continuation of the IVF treatment would not offend the
law.
Under such circumstances, this appeal is not
entertained. However, the issues raised by Mr. Tiwari
with regard to interpretation of the different provisions
of the statute, involve questions of law which can be
decided in an appropriate case.
Accordingly, the appeal is disposed of without any
orders.
With such disposal of the appeal, CAN 1 of 2025
is also disposed of.
All the parties are directed to act on the basis of
the server copy of this order.
(Shampa Sarkar, J.)
(Ajay Kumar Gupta, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review