Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No.02
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
MC (Review Pet.) No.7/2022 in
Review Petition No.1/2023
Date of Order: 09.02.2023
Union of India & anr
Coram:
Vs.
Bina Khongbuh & ors
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sanjib Banerjee, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioners
: Dr. N. Mozika, DSG with
Ms. A. Pradhan, Adv
For the Respondents
: Mr. U.K. Nair, Sr.Adv with
Mr. A.M. Pala, Adv
i) Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii) Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT: (per the Hon’ble, the Chief Justice) (Oral)
In view of the good grounds shown and the importance of the
matter, the delay of about 277 days in seeking review is condoned and the
matter is taken up for immediate consideration. MC (Review Pet.) No.7 of
2022 is disposed of.
2.
The scope of the matter is rather limited. In this review petition,
the Union questions the propriety of a judgment and order of November
29, 2021 passed on a petition under Article 226 of the Constitution in
which an order passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal had been
challenged.
3.
The essence of the matter is as to whether a lecturer at the
College of Nursing run by the North Eastern Indira Gandhi Regional
Institute of Health and Medical Sciences (NEIGRIHMS) would be
entitled to the same grade pay as a vice-principal in a School of Nursing
run under any institution by the Union Ministry of Health and Family
Welfare. By the judgment and order impugned in the writ petition dated
March 15, 2019, it was held that in view of an office memorandum dated
February 10, 2009 issued by the appropriate Union Ministry indicating
the revision of pay scales of teaching nursing personnel in the
Government of India institutions on the basis of the recommendation of
the Sixth Pay Commission, lecturers at the NEIGRIHMS College of
Nursing were entitled to the same grade pay as vice-principals in other
Schools of Nursing run by the Union Ministry. Such position was
accepted by this Court in the judgment and order of November 29, 2021
when this Court refused to interfere with the plausible view taken by
CAT.
4.
A petition for special leave to appeal to the Supreme Court was
carried by the Union against the order of this Court of November 29,
2021. However, before the petition for special leave could be admitted or
rejected, a prayer was made to withdraw the petition for special leave to
appeal with liberty to approach this Court in review. Such liberty was
granted by an order dated April 22, 2022. The present petition has been
filed thereafter. At least another matter, wherein the same grade pay issue
is involved, has remained pending since several adjournments have been
obtained on behalf of the Union before this review petition has been
pursued in right earnest.
5.
To start with, it must be recorded that the scope of review is
rather restricted. The authority that is exercised in course of a review
petition is not akin to either appellate or revisional jurisdiction. Grounds
of review are limited and, essentially, are confined to new or subsequent
discovery of material that may not have been available at the time of the
original hearing despite exercise of due diligence; or, an apparent error
on the face of the record or the like. The particular ground that is pressed
into service here is that a key fact could not be brought to the notice of
this Court at the time that the order of November 29, 2021 was passed.
6.
It must also be observed that the extent of judicial review that
was being exercised in respect of a quasi-judicial order gave limited
scope to this Court while deciding the writ petition in the first place. The
point now sought to be canvassed at the review stage in this Court ought,
ideally, to have been urged before the CAT in the original proceedings. It
was also open to the writ petitioner to press such ground in course of the
original writ petition; but the Union having chosen not to rely on such
point, it has now to be assessed whether the point was available to the
Union at the initial stage for it to be taken into account at this stage,
despite the Union’s failure to urge the same earlier.
7.
For the present purpose, the Union seeks to rely on the essential
qualifications for the post of vice-principal in the NEIGRIHMS College
of Nursing and those for the post of lecturer in the same college. The
argument is of no merit. Indeed, the office memorandum of February 10,
2009 equated the post of vice-principal in a School of Nursing and senior
lecturer in a College of Nursing for the same grade pay to be announced
for both cadres. It was not as if the memorandum of February 10, 2009
equated vice-principals of Colleges of Nursing with lecturers of Colleges
of Nursing. As would be evident from the memorandum, a vice-principal
of a College of Nursing was entitled to a grade pay of Rs.7600 against
the common grade pay indicated in such memorandum for viceprincipals of Schools of Nursing and senior lecturers of Colleges of
Nursing. At any rate it is only a new ground that is sought to be
canvassed and not any new material brought on record. The material on
which the new ground is founded was available even before the CAT.
Since such material was already available, but the ground not asserted,
the petitioner is now estopped from urging the same in review.
8.
The ancillary ground that the Union brings is that there was an
obvious mistake in the office memorandum of February 10, 2009 in that
it referred to senior lecturers but did not refer to lecturers. For such
purpose, the Union refers to the five posts available at the NEIGRIHMS
College of Nursing, namely principal-cum-professor, vice-principal-cumprofessor,
reader/associate
professor,
lecturer
and
tutor/clinical
Instructor. The Union asserts that the post of lecturer in a College of
Nursing was not at all covered by the office memorandum of February
10, 2009 though senior lecturers were indicated therein. The Union
submits that the posts indicated in the office memorandum of February
10, 2009 conformed to those in other schools or colleges of nursing under
the Union Health Ministry and the fact that a different cadre structure
was prevalent at NEIGRIHMS or some of the other Colleges of Nursing
had not been taken into account in issuing such memorandum.
9.
If it were to be accepted that the memorandum of February 10,
2009 had been erroneously issued, there ought to have been a quick
corrigendum thereto. At any rate, upon NEIGRIHMS receiving a copy of
such office memorandum, it would have been expected of NEIGRIHMS
to immediately write to the Ministry to rectify the purported mistake in
the said memorandum. No such measure was taken by NEIGRIHMS
within any reasonable time of the issuance of the said memorandum,
though NEIGRIHMS continued to pay Rs.5400 as grade pay to lecturers
on the basis of the recommendation in such regard by the Sixth Pay
Commission.
10.
It is elementary that a pay commission is tasked with the brief
of making recommendations and it is for the government to ultimately
accept the recommendations, whether to the hilt or to some extent.
Indeed, despite the recommendations of a pay commission providing for
a lower pay scale or grade pay, it is always open to the government or the
relevant employer to indicate a higher pay scale or a higher grade pay.
On the other hand, if, despite the recommendation of a pay commission
being for a higher level, the government seeks to implement a lower
level, unless there is good reason therefor, the same may be amenable to
a challenge. However, when the converse occurs and an employer or the
government seeks to improve on the recommendations made by the pay
commission, no question can be asked. It is entirely the prerogative of the
employer to give a greater benefit to its employees than what may have
been recommended by a pay commission.
11.
It is in such light that the office memorandum of February 10,
2009 must be seen. It is true that the post of lecturer is not indicated in
such office memorandum and the closest to such post is senior lecturer in
a College of Nursing. However, since such memorandum was not sought
to be rectified in any manner or form till the lecturers, who had been
offered a lower grade pay than as indicated in the office memorandum,
moved the CAT, a belated plea of mistake could no longer have been
raised at such stage.
12.
The Union claims that NEIGRIHMS wrote to the relevant
Ministry in or about the year 2016 following a resolution by its governing
body that the grade pay indicated for senior lecturers in the office
memorandum of February 10, 2009 would not apply to lecturers in the
NEIGRIHMS College of Nursing. Two aspects must be referred to in this
context. First, notwithstanding the recommendation as to the grade pay of
lecturers made by the Sixth Pay Commission, when the office
memorandum was issued by the Ministry, NEIGRIHMS had either to
follow such office memorandum or to seek a clarification in such regard.
NEIGRIHMS, on its own, could not have gone back to the
recommendation of the Sixth Pay Commission and, in effect, override the
binding instructions that it received from its governing Ministry by the
office memorandum of February 10, 2009. Secondly, when an authority
in seisin of a recommendation takes a decision pursuant thereto, there is a
presumption that all relevant factors have been taken into account and the
decision has been consciously made. No reason has been indicated as to
how the mistake may have occurred and why the purported mistake did
not receive any attention for a period in excess of seven years before it
was sought to be rectified upon receiving notice from the lecturers that
they may pursue their cause before a quasi-legal forum.
13.
For the reasons aforesaid, neither the judgment under review of
November 29, 2021 nor the order of the CAT of March 15, 2019 calls for
any reconsideration, at least on the specious ground therefor cited in the
present proceedings. Accordingly, Review Petition No.1 of 2023 is
dismissed.
14.
As a footnote, it may be mentioned that a rather impassioned
plea has been made on behalf of the Union for this Court to at least
observe that this judgment or the decision of November 29, 2021 may not
operate as a precedent. It may be said in such connection that judicial
discipline commands that a level of consistency is maintained and the
concept of finality that is of paramount importance has more to do with
consistency rather than correctness. At any rate, at this level and in the
absence of the special power under Article 142 of the Constitution, the
High Court is bound by the doctrine of precedents to not make the
observation that is sought by the Union herein.
15.
There will be no order as to costs.
(W. Diengdoh)
Judge
(Sanjib Banerjee)
Chief Justice
Meghalaya
09.02.2023
“Lam DR-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review