The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
4. The Commandant, Assam Rifles Composite Hospital, Shillong, Meghalaya-793001. ... Appellants Vs. Smt. Naresh Kumari ... Respondent Coram: Hon’ble Mr. Justice I.P. Mukerji, Chief Justice Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge Appearance: For the Appellants : Dr. N. Mozika, DSGI with Ms. K. Gurung, Adv. For the Respondent : Ms. P. Cheetri, Adv i) Whether approved for reporting in Law journals etc.: Yes ii) Whether approved for publication Yes in press: For proper public information and transparency, any media reporting this judgment is directed to mention the composition of the bench by name of judges, while reporting this judgment/order. 2025:MLHC:591-DB (Delivered by the Hon’ble, the Chief Justice) Refractive errors prevent the eye from refracting light properly. LASIK is a type of refractive surgery, using laser to treat vision problems like nearsightedness, farsightedness and astigmatism caused by this error. Assam Rifles is a para military force under the Ministry of Home Affairs performing the dual role of maintaining internal security in the North-Eastern Region of our country and guarding the Indo-Myanmar border. On 5th January, 2017, the Ministry of Home Affairs through the Directorate General of Assam Rifles (hereinafter referred to as “the appellant”) published an advertisement for recruitment of staff nurses in the post or rank of Naib Subedar. Eighteen posts were to b…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:MLHC:591-DB
Serial No.01
Daily List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WA No. 50/2024
Date of CAV: 18.06.2025
Date of pronouncement: 09.07.2025
1. Union of India represented by the Secretary to the Government of
India, Ministry of Home Affairs, North Block, New Delhi- 110001.
2. The Director General of Assam Rifles, Mahanideshalaya, (the
Directorate General of Assam Rifles) Shillong, Meghalaya-793011.
3. The Presiding Officer, Laitkor Centre, AR Tech and Tdn Rally 20172018, Mahanideshalaya, (the Directorate General of Assam Rifles)
Shillong, Meghalaya-793011.
4. The Commandant, Assam Rifles Composite Hospital, Shillong,
Meghalaya-793001.
... Appellants
Vs.
Smt. Naresh Kumari
... Respondent
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice I.P. Mukerji, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Appellants
: Dr. N. Mozika, DSGI with
Ms. K. Gurung, Adv.
For the Respondent
: Ms. P. Cheetri, Adv
i)
Whether approved for
reporting in Law journals etc.:
Yes
ii)
Whether approved for publication
Yes
in press:
For proper public information and transparency, any media
reporting this judgment is directed to mention the
composition of the bench by name of judges, while reporting
this judgment/order.
2025:MLHC:591-DB
JUDGMENT
(Delivered by the Hon’ble, the Chief Justice)
Refractive errors prevent the eye from refracting light properly.
LASIK is a type of refractive surgery, using laser to treat vision
problems like nearsightedness, farsightedness and astigmatism caused
by this error.
Assam Rifles is a para military force under the Ministry of Home
Affairs performing the dual role of maintaining internal security in the
North-Eastern Region of our country and guarding the Indo-Myanmar
border.
On 5th January, 2017, the Ministry of Home Affairs through the
Directorate General of Assam Rifles (hereinafter referred to as “the
appellant”) published an advertisement for recruitment of staff nurses in
the post or rank of Naib Subedar.
Eighteen posts were to be filled up. One of such posts was
reserved for persons domiciled in Rajasthan, in accordance with the
policy of the government. The requirements or eligibility criteria as
stated in the advertisement were (a) matriculation or equivalent (b)
diploma in nursing from a recognised council and (c) working
2025:MLHC:591-DB
knowledge of Hindi. The candidate was to be between 18 and 25 years
of age.
The issue involved in the writ petition and in the appeal is this:
The respondent/writ petitioner had qualified in the recruitment
drive of Assam Rifles to fill up the one post of staff nurse from the
Rajasthan quota but was disqualified in the medical examination on the
ground that her vision was defective and had been sought to be
corrected by LASIK surgery. Although her vision after LASIK surgery
met the standards prescribed by the appellants, the very fact that this
deficiency was sought to be corrected by LASIK surgery made her
ineligible for the post.
She preferred the instant writ petition [WP (C) No.410 of 2019Smt. Naresh Kumari v. Union of India & ors].
The writ petition was founded on the following cause of action.
The policy/guidelines for recruitment in Assam Rifles relating to
medical fitness regarding vision was discriminatory between gazetted
officers which included doctors and non-gazetted post of nurses by
prescribing different standards for qualifying in
the medical
examination of vision, although they were similarly situated. Such
2025:MLHC:591-DB
differentiation was unfair, arbitrary and unreasonable which is violative
of Article 14 of the Constitution.
The learned judge in his impugned judgment and order dated 15 th
March, 2024 was of the view that there was clear discrimination
“among the sect of persons working in the medical industry namely,
doctors and nurses who are equally responsible for well-being of
patients”. The policy/guidelines giving relaxation to gazetted officers
and denying such concession to nurses “cannot stand in the eye of law”.
The following order was passed:
“(i) The Clause No.67, being discriminatory, arbitrary and
violative of Article 14 of the Constitution of India is interfered
with. A direction is issued to the respondents to include both
Doctors and Nurses in the Guidelines/Tabular Column to be
eligible for appointment, even if they have undergone Lasik
Surgery. To that extent, the Guidelines are quashed;
(ii) Since nearly six years have gone-by, the petitioner shall
undergo another medical examination and if found suitable, she
shall be accommodated in the existing vacancy or in the next
vacancy that may arise;
(iii) It is made clear that without appointing the petitioner as a
Staff Nurse (if medically fit other than Lasik Surgery), no other
nurse shall be appointed.”
From this judgment and order, the Central government appeals
before us.
Dr. N. Mozika, learned Deputy Solicitor General of India
appearing for the appellants made some compelling submissions.
2025:MLHC:591-DB
He said that Assam Rifles was a paramilitary force. It is highly
specialised and its medical requirements very stringent. The said
policy/guidelines, the medical requirements for vision have been made
uniform for posts of a particular grade or type. In this force, a nurse is in
the rank of Naib Subedar. She enjoys this rank along with other
personnel, e.g. a driver, cook, electrician, attendant, tailor, charge
mechanic etc.
Relying on the policy guidelines dated 18th May, 2012 learned
counsel contended that uniformity in visual standards has been
maintained laterally across the posts. In other words, persons of the
same rank have been treated equally. Referring to table-1 of AnnextureI to the said policy and paragraph 67 of Annexure-II with the heading
“Ophthalmic Systemic Examination”, he submitted that direct entry
gazetted officers are permitted to be considered for recruitment even
after having undergone LASIK. Referring to table-3 of Annexure-I, he
said that similarly all subordinate officers which included nurses have
been treated equally making them ineligible for consideration if they
had undergone visual correction of any kind “even by glasses.” Hence,
according to learned counsel, there was no breach of the principle of
2025:MLHC:591-DB
equality. Neither, there was discrimination between any two sections or
groups of personnel or candidates.
The requirement that nurses cannot undergo any vision correction
through glasses or LASIK is a policy perception of the appellants with
which the courts should not interfere. The said policy/guidelines are fair
and reasonable not discriminatory or arbitrary. The learned judge
committed an error by striking down that part of the policy which
disentitled candidates who have to undergo the above corrective
procedure for consideration for selection as nurses, it was further
submitted.
He contended that by the same judgment and order the entire
selection process for nurses had been stalled.
Discussion:
The respondent/writ petitioner underwent medical fitness test
before the appellant’s medical practitioner on 10th May, 2018. It issued
a medical certificate declaring her as unfit with defective distant vision
(<6/12). She asked for review of this declaration.
About the same time, she underwent LASIK surgery.
A further medical examination was conducted on 8 th June, 2018.
A report was made by the Specialist Medical Officer Grade-I (Eye) to
2025:MLHC:591-DB
the effect that the vision of the respondent was <6/6 and 6/6 in the right
eye and there was a “LASIK scar seen in both cornea”.
For that reason, the review medical examination report dated 8 th
June, 2018 declared her unfit, although her vision was within acceptable
standards.
First of all, it has to be made clear that what we are dealing with
are policy/guidelines dated 18th May, 2012 issued by Police-II Division,
Ministry of Home Affairs, Government of India prescribed in visual
standards for recruitment and retention in service of personnel of the
Central Armed Police Force (CAPF) and Assam Rifles (Ars). This
Court is concerned with the application of this policy to Assam Rifles.
Now, this policy is not to be taken as a piece of subordinate
legislation.
The principles of law which the courts follow to adjudicate upon
a policy decision have to be applied here.
The most ordinary principles which would be applicable are that
normally, policy decisions are the result of specialised enquiry which
the government makes with regard to a subject-matter, conducted by
experts in the field. Normally, the courts would not interfere in those
policy matters. It is said that a government policy matter is not to be
2025:MLHC:591-DB
interfered with by the courts. This legal principle cannot be treated as
absolute. When it comes to dealing with an issue so as to evolve a
policy decision, specialised expert opinion on it concerning the same,
technical matters, the financial and economic impact, requirements of
the population etc. are involved. The executive is the best judge of its
efficacy. The court should refrain from evaluating and adjudging the
policy decision.
Any policy is required to be inconformity with the Constitution
and the laws. When the court finds that a particular policy is violative of
the Constitution or the law or is arbitrary, most unreasonable, in abuse
of power or discriminatory of a section of population or has been made
with mala fide intent, it has the power to strike it down or strike down a
part of it.
In the above policy guidelines, there are provided visual
standards for various categories of personnel which are divided into
tables 1-5 in Annexure-I thereof. Annexure-II deals with ophthalmic
systemic examination.
Paragraph 67 of the second Annexure dealing with refractive
surgeries lays down that candidates who have undergone LASIK
surgery may be considered fit for recruitment in the post of direct entry
2025:MLHC:591-DB
gazetted officers. Higher ranking officers are usually by direct
recruitment which is gazetted.
In table-1 of Annexure-I direct entry gazetted officers whose age
of entry is between 20 to 30 years, LASIK surgery for correction of
eyesight is permitted subject to some conditions in the policy.
What is an issue in the writ and in this appeal is the stipulation in
table-3 of Annexure-I with regard to subordinate officers whose
induction is between the age of 18 and 35. The type of vision which is
prescribed is N6 and N9 for better eye and worse eye respectively for
near vision and 6/6 and 6/9 for better eye and worse eye respectively for
distant vision. Then comes the controversial prescription: “visual
correction of any kind is not permitted even by glasses.” This simply
means that those who have undergone LASIK surgery to achieve the
vision standard prescribed would be disqualified.
Now, in Assam Rifles newly recruited nurses are also ranked as
subordinate officers. In case of other officers whose services are akin to
those in the armed forces, such a stipulation regarding eyesight or vision
might be tenable and reasonable. Why this kind of a stipulation is
enforced against nurses whose nature and type of work could not be
2025:MLHC:591-DB
affected at all by refractive surgery or by glasses provided their vision
on clinical examination is adequate for the type of work they do?
I have carefully perused the tables appended as annexures to the
said policy. As observed earlier, for direct entry gazetted officers, a
visual standard is prescribed which could be arrived at by undergoing a
LASIK surgery. The same policy has been made applicable to other
gazetted officers particularised in table-2, e.g. medical officers, dentists,
veterinary officers, engineers and so on. However, for subordinate
officers visual standards as provided in table-3 have been prescribed. In
this category nurses are also included.
I have not gone into the reasonableness of this policy as
applicable to the other posts in table-3 but I am firmly of the view that
prescribing this vision standard for nurses is wholly improper,
absolutely unreasonable and discriminatory. I fail to see how the quality
of vision required by nurses be different from those prescribed for direct
entry gazetted officers like doctors, dentists, veterinary officers and
engineers in tables 1 and 2. Nurses are more or less similarly situated as
the above medical personnel and therefore, the standard mentioned in
table-1 and table-2 should apply to them.
2025:MLHC:591-DB
The argument of Dr. Mozika is completely flawed and not
accepted by me. As rightly observed by the learned single judge that
whereas doctors who are direct entry officers have been exempted from
disqualification on the ground of having undergone laser, nurses being
paramedics have been disqualified if they have undertaken the same
medical procedure.
In my opinion, this kind of differentiation in requirement in the
personnel in the same rank is wholly arbitrary and unreasonable. I see
no reason why a nurse having undergone refractive surgery could be
disqualified when directly recruited doctors are not. The basis of
classification of nurses is grossly erroneous. Independent attention
should have been given to this medical condition when its application to
nurses was being considered. We are not concerned with the entire
policy. It is not under challenge. I only hold that the requirements of
table-3 with regard to subordinate officers shall be disapplied in case of
nurses and that paragraph 67 above would apply also to nurses.
This appeal is dismissed. The impugned judgment and order
dated 15th March, 2024 is affirmed with the modification that the
2025:MLHC:591-DB
respondent/writ petitioner’s eye examination report shall be revised by
the appellants, according to the findings above and she be selected to
the post of Nurse (Naib Subedar) in the Rajasthan vacancy immediately.
All other posts advertised may also be filled up in accordance with law.
(W. Diengdoh)
Judge
(I.P. Mukerji)
Chief Justice
LIZ KHARBHIH
Date: 2025.07.09 02:16:59 IST
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review