Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No.01
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
W.A.No.53/2023
Reserved on: 26.02.2024
Pronounced on: 07.03.2024
1. Union of India, represented by the Secretary to the Government of
India Ministry of Health & Family Welfare, New Delhi-110001.
2. North Eastern Indira Gandhi Regional Institute of Health & Medical
Sciences, Mawdiangdiang, Shillong represented by its Director.
3. The Deputy Director (Administration), North Eastern Indira Gandhi
Regional Institute of Health & Medical Sciences, Mawdiangdiang,
Shillong
Vs.
1. Shri Vikas Kumar
2. Shri Rahul Chakraborty
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice S.Vaidyanathan, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W.Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Appellants
:
For the Respondents :
Dr. N. Mozika, DSG with
Ms. A. Pradhan, Adv.
Mr. K.P. Bhattacharjee, Adv.
i)
Whether approved for
reporting in Law journals etc.:
Yes
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes
JUDGMENT
(Made by Hon’ble, the Chief Justice)
The present Writ Appeal has been preferred, challenging the
order 23.06.2023 of the learned Single Judge passed in W.P.(C) No.310
of 2022, in and by which, a direction was issued to the respondents /
appellants herein to provide suitable employment to the Writ Petitioner
in the vacant post of Sanitary Inspector.
2. The case put forth by the Writ Petitioners was that a
notification together with merit list dated 02.06.2022 was published by
the 3rd respondent, whereby the post of Sanitary Inspector was reduced
from 4 to 2 in the General Category, which had resulted in denial of
employment to the Writ Petitioners;
2.1. It was the further case of the Writ Petitioners that initially
there was an advertisement dated 12.10.2007 issued to fill up 6 posts of
Sanitary Inspector on direct recruitment with a ratio of 4 for UR and
two for ST. During the pendency of the advertisement, nearly after a
decade, yet another advertisement was issued to fill up 4 posts of
Sanitary Inspector with a revised ratio of two for UR and 2 for ST,
stating that candidates, who had already applied pursuant to the earlier
advertisement dated 12.10.2007 would be entitled to considered and
they need not apply afresh;
2.2. It was also the case of the Writ Petitioners that based on the
subsequent advertisement, a written test was conducted on 14.03.2021
and a Corrigendum dated 02.08.2021 was issued, stating that the post of
Sanitary Inspectors that was advertised in 2007 would hold good and
the vacancy to be read as 6, i.e. 4 for UR and 2 for ST;
2.3. The case of the Writ Petitioners was that based on the
subsequent advertisement dated 21.08.2017, a merit list was drawn in
which, the Writ Petitioners’ names were shown in Sl.Nos.3 and 4,
whereas their names reflected in Sl.Nos.1 and 2 in the waiting list.
When the Corrigendum was issued restoring the earlier position, the
Writ Petitioners should have been considered;
2.4. The further case of the Writ Petitioners was that though they
had been selected to the post of Sanitary Inspector and the merit list was
also drawn as early as on 25.11.2021, by a Corrigendum / Notification,
again the ration was changed by reducing the post to 4 and the act of the
respondents in the Writ Petition was completely illegal and the
respondents have no authority to keep the Writ Petitioners in the waiting
list, when they realized that the total number of posts was 6, namely, 4
for UR and 2 ST. The petitioners also referred to a judgment of the
Supreme Court in the case of Polyplex Corp. N Ltd. Thru’ Auth.
Signatory vs. Union of India and others, reported in (2014) SCC
Online 5211 in support of their stand. It was submitted by the Writ
Petitioners that one of the selected candidates by name Deepak Kumar
had resigned from the post and the second Writ Petitioner, namely,
Rahul Chakraborty is not interested in the appointment and hence, the
first Writ Petitioner, viz., Vikas Kumar is entitled to be appointed;
3. According to the Appellants herein / respondents in the Writ
Petition, before appointment order was issued, a selection committee
meeting was held on 21.04.2022 and a recommendation was made to
limit the number of post of Sanitary Inspectors to 2 for UR and 2 for
ST, totalling 4 and subsequently, the number of posts had been
enhanced to 6. Though Vikas Kumar / 1st petitioner is ranked at Sl.No.4
in the merit list and 2 in the waiting list, he cannot as a matter of right
demand appointment against the vacancy, which had arisen on account
of resignation of one Deepak Kumar. It was the stand of the Appellants
that once a person had joined the service and resigned, the vacancy has
to be notified and a fresh advertisement needs to be called for. Of
course, it is true that Rahul Chakraborty / 2nd Writ Petitioner is not
interested in joining the post;
3.1. It was the contention of the Appellants that the vacancy,
which has arisen, pursuant to the resignation of a selected candidate,
cannot be filled up with the candidate, who is in the waiting list in the
light of the judgments of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of
State of Punjab vs. Raghbir Chand Sharma, reported in (2002) 1 SCC
113 and Thrissur District Cooperative Bank Limited vs. Delson Davis
P, reported in (2021) 14 SCC 407. Thus, it was contended that the 1st
petitioner, who is alone contesting the matter, is not entitled to any
relief and on that score, the order of the learned Single Judge is liable to
be interfered with.
4. Learned Single Judge, having considered the arguments of
both parties, came to the conclusion that in view of the Corrigendum
dated 02.08.2021, whereby originally notified number of posts, viz., 6
has been restored, all the vacancies have got to be filled up from the
merit list, by applying the principle of reservation. Learned Single
Judge also held that almost 10 years have gone-by from the date of
original advertisement and consequent to the subsequent restoration of
the number of posts to 6, the advertisement dated 12.10.2007 needs to
be adhered to. It was further held that in view of the fact that one post is
lying vacant due to the resignation of one Deepak Kumar and that the
second Writ Petitioner, namely, Rahul Chakraborty has secured
employment somewhere else, the sole Writ Petitioner Vikas Kumar is
entitled to the benefit of earlier notification dated 12.10.2007 and thus,
learned Single Judge had set aside the impugned notification dated
02.06.2022, aggrieved by which, the Appellants are before this Court.
5. Heard the learned counsel on either side and perused the
material documents available on record.
6. On a careful scrutiny of the entire facts and circumstances of
the case, it is apparent that the Government was not certain in
determining the number of posts before issuance of notification for the
post of Sanitary Inspector. It is evident that except confusion and chaos,
nothing could been seen in the process of selection to the post of
Sanitary Inspector, inasmuch as there was an earlier notification dated
12.10.2007 issued to fill up the 6 posts of Sanitary Inspector and
thereafter, there was a reduction in the number of posts from 6 to 4 and
the subsequent restoration of posts to 6. On account of vagueness,
fuzziness, indeterminateness and indefiniteness on the side of the
Government, the candidates much less the petitioners cannot be made
suffer, especially when there was no fault on the part of the Writ
Petitioners. Originally, the advertisement was issued to fill up six posts
of Sanitary Inspector with allocation of ratio, i.e., 4 for UR category and
2 for ST that has to be unilaterally followed. It is true that the vacancy,
which has arisen on account of resignation cannot be taken into account
for the purpose of accommodating Vikas Kumar, as he is the Sole Writ
Petitioner contesting the case as on date and another Writ Petitioner
Rahul Chakraborty had given up his effort in joining the post of
Sanitary Inspector on account of his engagement in some other
employment. At the same time, it cannot be lost sight of the fact that
Vikas Kumar was placed in the merit list at Sl.No.4, but for the
confusion created by the Government, he lost his opportunity albeit he
is meritorious.
7. At this stage, learned DSG for the appellants stated that after
expiry of the period of waiting list, vacancies that had arisen
subsequently cannot be filled up from the list. It is pertinent to state here
that out of the candidates, who had participated in the selection, only
two persons, namely, Writ Petitioners, out of whom 1st Petitioner alone
is contesting the case, have knocked at the doors of this Court and
admittedly, the name of Vikas Kumar also finds place at Sl. No. 2 in the
waiting list and 4 in the merit list. Therefore, Vikas Kumar is eligible to
be accommodated in the post, by extending the benefit of earlier
notification / advertisement dated 12.10.2007 and as Rahul Chakraborty
is not interested in pursuing the matter, his case need not be considered
at this stage. It is made clear that the vacancy that had caused on
account of resignation has to be considered afresh and only after proper
advertisement, the same needs to be filled up.
8. We direct the appellants to issue fresh advertisement and fill
up the vacancies lying vacant as on 31.12.2023 in accordance with law
and the whole exercise of identifying vacancies and filling up the same
shall be completed on or before 30.04.2024. It is made clear that the
relief is granted only to Vikas Kumar and since much water has flown,
no other person can knock at the doors of this Court, seeking the same
relief based on the advertisement dated 12.10.2007 at this distant point
of time. It is reiterated that in case any attempt is made to get the benefit
of this judgment by others who wake up from slumber now, the case
that may be filed by them can be dismissed on account of laches.
9. In fine, finding no merits and substance in the argument
advanced by the Appellants, in our considered opinion, the order of the
learned Single Judge does not warrant any interference by this Court.
Accordingly, W.A.No. 53 of 2023 is dismissed as devoid of merits, with
a direction to the Appellants to give the benefit of the order of learned
Single Judge to the 1st Writ Petitioner / Vikas Kumar within a period of
six months from the date of receipt of a copy of this judgment.
10. Before parting with this judgment, we emphasize that future
vacancies should be identified well in advance and all attempts to be
made to fill up those vacancies, in view of the fact that every employer /
State is aware about the vacancies that may fall vacant on account of
attainment of superannuation of employees every year. As per the
dictum laid down by the Apex Court in the case of Malik Mazhar
Sultan and Others vs. U.P.Public Service Commission and Others,
reported in (2006) 9 SCC 507, timely determination of vacancies and
appointments are mandatory in order to avoid frustration in the mind of
unemployed youths and backlog of vacancies. For the sake of
convenience, the relevant paragraphs are extracted below:
“18. The Rules postulate the timely determination of
vacancies and timely appointments. The non-filling of
vacancies for long not only results in the avoidable litigation
but also results in creeping of frustration in the candidates.
Further, non-filling of vacancies for long time, deprives the
people of the services of the Judicial Officers. This is one of
the reasons of huge pendency of cases in the courts.
19. It is absolutely necessary to evolve a mechanism to
speedily determine and fill vacancies of Judges at all levels.
For this purpose, timely steps are required to be taken for
determination of vacancies, issue of advertisement, conducting
examinations, interviews, declaration of the final results and
issue of orders of appointments. For all these and other steps,
if any, it is necessary to provide for fixed time schedule so that
system works automatically and there is no delay in filling up
of vacancies. The dates for taking these steps can be provided
for on the pattern similar to filling of vacancies in some other
services or filling of seats for admission in medical colleges.
The schedule appended to the Regulations governing medical
admissions sets out a time schedule for every step to be strictly
adhered to every year. The exception can be provided for
where sufficient number of vacancies do not occur in a given
year. The adherence to strict time schedule can ensure timely
filling of vacancies. All State Governments, Union Territories
and/or High Courts are directed to provide for time schedule
for the aforesaid purposes so that every year vacancies that
may occur are timely filled. All State Governments, Union
Territories and High Courts are directed to file within three
months details of the time schedule so fixed and date from
which time schedule so fixed would be operational.”
(W. Diengdoh)
Judge
(S. Vaidyanathan)
Chief Justice
Meghalaya
07.03.2024
“Sylvana PS”/”ar”
PRE-DELIVERY JUDGMENT IN
W.A.No.53 of 2023
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review