Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
"
!
%
&
#
# !
"$
!
"
'
!
"### $
Digitally signed
by RENUKA
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
%$
&
'
%
(
!
'
)
*
)
!
(
-2-
+
#
%
###$
,
"#
#
!
(
-
!
+
,
#
# "
"
$
$' #
*
!
,
-
$' #
!
,
-
$' #
$' #
)
)
.
-
!
,
-3-
/01 23404056 01 70839 :; 4/3 234040563<' =285;3<
133>06? 45 134 @1093 4/3 A5==56 5<93< 9@439 #
2@1139 :; 4/3
5 $' #
@:5B<
5B<4
@8@:B<@?0 06
# "
2280A@4056
$ @69 " @69 @815 133>06?
23<=011056 45 7083 5:C3A40561 45 4/3 @2280A@4056 70839 :; 4/3
D5<>=@6 B693<
A4
3A4056 $$
"+ 75< 1/5<4 E4/3
! 57 4/3 69B14<0@8
012B431
A4,!
4 01 4/3 A@13 57 4/3 234040563<' =285;3< 4/@4
4/3 <312569364'D5<>=@6 /@9 @22<5@A/39 4/3
@:5B<
5B<4 75< @<<3@<1 57 D@?31 @69 45 134 @1093 4/3 43<=06@4056
5<93<
/3 234040563<' =285;3< /3<306 D@1 90<3A439 45
<30614@43 4/3 <312569364'D5<>=@6 0645 13<F0A3 D04/06
4/<33 =564/1 7<5= 4/3 9@43 57 2B:80A@4056 57 4/3 @D@<9
@69 7B<4/3< 90<3A439 4/@4 4/3 D5<>=@6 D@1 36404839 45
#G 57 4/3 :@A> D@?31 7<5= 4/3 9@43 57 A8@0= 23404056 4088
/01 <30614@43=364
#
#
##%
=285;3< 70839
/01 @D@<9 A@=3 45 :3 2@1139 56
/@8836?06?
4/3
1@09
5 %# # ' ##
@D@<9
234040563<'
D/0A/ A@=3 45 :3
-4-
901=01139 56
4/3 @:5B<
+ #$
#
A5670<=06? 4/3 @D@<9 2@1139 :;
5B<4 9@439 #
#
##%
??<03F39 :; 4/3 1@09
901=011@8 5<93< 234040563<' =285;3< A/@8836?39 4/3 1@=3
:375<3 4/3
$
0F01056
## $ ' #
#+
36A/ 57 4/01
#
306? @??<03F39
<04
223@8
D/0A/ @815 A@=3 45 :3 901=01139 56
A/@8836?39 4/3 1@=3 :375<3 4/3
!
5B<4 06
' # $
5D3F3<
4/3
234040563<' =285;3<
56.:83
23H
5B<4 06
234040563<' =285;3< D@1
654 1BAA3117B8 @69 4/3 1@09 23404056 A@=3 45 :3 901=01139
56 #
#
# $
$
/01 :306? 4/3 14@43 57 @77@0<1
2<373<<39 @6 @2280A@4056 B693<
4/3 D5<>=@6
3A4056 $$
@69 4/3 1@=3 D@1 6B=:3<39 @1
! 57 4/3
2280A@4056
A4
5 $' #
/3 234040563<' =285;3< 909 654 7083 5:C3A4056 45 4/3 1@09
@2280A@4056 @69 4/3 1@=3 D@1 4@>36 @1 654 70839 @69
=@443< 2<5A33939 75< <3A5<906? 57 3F0936A3
$#
$
#+
# $
/3<3@743< 56
4/3 =@443< D@1 251439 75< 3F0936A3
# $ @6 @2280A@4056 D@1 70839 45 <3A@88 4/3 D5<>=@6
D046311 75< 7B<4/3< 3F0936A3 5< A<511 3H@=06@4056 A@=3 45
-5-
:3
<3C3A439
/3
234040563<' =285;3<
70839
4/<33
@2280A@40561 45 <3A@88 <35236 4/3 A@13 45 83@9 3F0936A3 57
4/3 234040563< @69 @815 45 7083 14@43=364 57 5:C3A4056 45 4/3
@2280A@4056 70839 :; 4/3 D5<>=@6 B693<
3A4056 $$
! 57
4/3
# " 4/3
@:5B<
A4
5D3F3< :; 5<93< 9@439 #
5B<4 901=01139 @88 4/3 @2280A@40561 06A8B906? 4/3 5:C3A4056
14@43=364 45 :3 4@>36 56 <3A5<9
306? @??<03F39 :; 4/3
1@09 5<93< 4/3 234040563<' =285;3< 01 :375<3 4/01
"
5B<4
3@<639 A5B6138 75< 4/3 234040563<' =285;3<
F3/3=3648; A56436939 4/@4 4/5B?/ 4/3 =@443< :375<3 4/3
56,:83
23H
5B<4 /@1 @44@0639 706@804; 4/3 @2280A@4056
70839 :; 4/3 <312569364'D5<>=@6 B693<
4/3
3A4056 $$
! 57
A4 <3IB0<31 45 :3 5:C3A439 45 @69 93736939 :; 4/3
234040563<' =285;3<
/3
@2280A@40561
70839
:;
4/3
234040563<' =285;3< D3<3 901=01139 :; 4/3 83@<639 @:5B<
5B<4 568; 56 4/3 ?<5B69 4/@4 06
5 5<906@43 :36A/ 57 4/01
4/3<306 <3C3A439 4/3 23404056
5 +"+ 57
#
4/3
5B<4 75< 4/3 <3@156 14@439
36A3 4/3 @:5B<
5B<4 /@1
-6-
<3C3A439 4/3 @2280A@40561 :; <38;06? B256 4/3 1@09 5<93< 57
4/01
5B<4
4 01 A56436939 :; 83@<639 A5B6138 75< 4/3
234040563<' =285;3< 4/@4 07 4/3
=285;3< 01 654 23<=04439
45 7083 5:C3A40561 45 4/3 @2280A@4056 70839 B693<
$$
! 57 4/3
3A4056
A4 @69 654 83@9 041 3F0936A3 4/3<3 D5B89
:3 65 =@43<0@8 56 <3A5<9 45 2<5F3 /01 A@13 @69 314@:801/
4/3 1@=3
3 7B<4/3< A5643691 4/@4 04 D5B89 :3 63A311@<;
75< /0= 45 7083 /01 5:C3A40561 @69 45 83@9 3F0936A3 45 1/5D
@1 45 D/36 4/3 <312569364'D5<>=@6 /@9 C50639 4/3 9B4031
@69 D/36 /3 D@1 @:1364 45 93A093 4/3 A5=2361@4056
@=5B64 4/3 @D@<9 4/3 :@A> D@?31 @69 4/3 @=5B64 9B3
45 :3 2@09
36A3
/3 133>1 45 @885D 4/3 23404056 @69
23<=04 /0= 45 83@9 /01 3F0936A3 :; 70806? 5:C3A40561 45 4/3
@2280A@4056
04 01 4/3 F3/3=364 A564364056 57
83@<639 A5B6138 75< 4/3 <312569364'D5<>=@6 4/@4 4/3
9012B43 01 57 4/3 ;3@<
##
@D@<9 A@=3 45 :3 2@1139 06
-7-
##% @69 04 D@1 IB31405639 :; 4/3
:375<3 4/01
901=01139
5B<4 06 D<04 23404056
=285;3< 06
D/0A/ A@=3 45 :3
/3 1@=3 :306? A/@8836?39 :375<3 4/3
36A/ 57 4/01
##
0F01056
5B<4 04 @815 36939 B2 06 901=011@8
/3
234040563<' =285;3< @815 7@0839 06 1BAA33906? D/36 /3
@22<5@A/39
4/3
56.:83
23H
CB9?=364 57 4/01
5B<4
D5 D<04 234040561 D3<3 70839
3@<803< :375<3 4/01
5B<4
A/@8836?06?
4/3
5B<4 45 <3A@88 4/3 D5<>=@6 75<
3F0936A3 @69 45 83@9 3F0936A3 57 4/3 =285;3< D/0A/ A@=3
45 :3 <3C3A439
/3<375<3 /3 A5643691 4/@4 4/3 F3<; 064364
@69 A569BA4 57 4/3
=285;3< 01 45 2<54<@A4 @69 2<5856? 4/3
2<5A33906?1 45 133 4/@4 4/3 D5<>=@6 01 7<B14<@439 @69
B6@:83 45 36C5; 4/3 7<B041 57 4/3 @D@<9 9312043 /@F06?
:336 1BAA33939 06 @88 4/3 75<B=1 <0?/4 B2 45 4/3
23H
56.:83
5B<4
+
5D @4 4/3 14@?3 D/36 4/3 D5<>=@6 01 45 36C5;
4/3 7<B041 57 4/3 @D@<9 @69 D/36 /3 /@1 70839 @6
@2280A@4056 B693<
3A4056 $$
! 57 4/3
A4 4/3 2<31364
@2280A@40561 @<3 70839 568; 45 2<5856? @69 2<54<@A4 4/3
-8-
2<5A33906?1 @69 45 7<B14<@43 4/3 A8@0= 57 4/3 D5<>=@6
A5643691 4/@4 4/3<3 01 65 =3<04 06 4/3 @2280A@4056
@1
9312043
4/3
1B770A0364
5225<4B604;
:306?
?<@6439
234040563<' =285;3< /@1 654 @F@0839 4/3 1@=3
36A3 4/3;
@<3 654 36404839 75< @6; =5<3 836036A;
%
/@F3 /3@<9 4/3 83@<639 A5B6138 75< 4/3
234040563<' =285;3< @69 4/3 83@<639 A5B6138 75< 4/3
<312569364'D5<>=@6
/3
@2280A@4056
<312569364'D5<>=@6 B693<
70839
3A4056 $$
:;
4/3
! 57 4/3
A4
90<3A406? 4/3 234040563<' =285;3< 45 2@; @6 @=5B64 57
1$
%
###' D04/ @88 A5613IB3640@8 :3637041 @856? D04/
0643<314 @4 4/3 <@43 57
G 23< @66B= 56
#+ #
856? D04/ 4/3 1@09 @2280A@4056 =3=5 57 A@8AB8@4056 D@1
@815 70839 :; 4/3 D5<>=@6 56 4/3 F3<; 1@=3 9@43
/3
@2280A@4056
#
# "
56 #
#
A@=3
:3
/3
56.:83
70839
:;
4/3
234040563<
23H
5B<4 93A0939 4/3 =@443<
# $ 2B4406? 4/3 14@=2 57 706@804; 56 4/3 @D@<9
-9-
2@1139 :; 4/3
@:5B<
5B<4
@2280A@4056 2<373<<39 B693<
65 856?3<
04/ <3?@<9 45 4/3
3A4056 $$
! 57 4/3
A4 04 01
06 F03D 57 13F3<@8 A@436@ 57
CB9?=3641 57 4/3
56.:83
23H
5B<4 @1 4/3 1@=3 01 06
4/3 ?B013 57 @6 3H3AB4056 23404056 @1 4/3
D04/ 4/3 @2280A@4056 B693<
3A4056 $$
5B<4 93@806?
! 57 4/3
A4 D088
/@F3 45 80=04 041387 45 4/3 @D@<9 @69 654 3HA339 5< ?5
:3;569 4/3 @D@<9 D04/ <3?@<9 45 4/3 A@8AB8@4056 57 4/3
@=5B64 4/@4 01 45 :3 2@09
#
6 F03D 57 4/3 @2280A@4056 4/@4 01 70839 :; 4/3
D5<>=@6 D04/ <3?@<9 45 <3A5F3<; 57 4/3 @=5B64 2B<1B@64
45 4/3 @D@<9 @6 5225<4B604; D088 /@F3 45 :3 ?0F36 45 4/3
234040563<' =285;3<
2B475<4/
041 1@;
D/34/3<
@6;
@=5B64 01 2@09 5< 932510439 @69 @A>65D839?39 :375<3 4/3
@:5B<
5B<4 75< 4/3 2B<2513 57 A@8AB8@406? 4/3 2@;=364 57
4/3 @=5B64 06 2B<1B@6A3 45 4/3 @D@<9 D/0A/ /@1 @44@0639
706@804;
- 10 -
06A3 4/3 234040563<' =285;3< /@1 654 3F36 70839
5:C3A4056 45 4/3 1@09 @2280A@4056 70839 B693<
! 57 4/3
2@<4031
A4
3A4056 $$
04 D5B89 :3 06 4/3 0643<314 57 :54/ 4/3
=5<3 15
75< 4/3 234040563<' =285;3< 45 7083
5:C3A4056 14@43=364 5< 28@A3 @6; 1BA/ =@43<0@8 45 1/5D
D/@4 01 4/3 @=5B64 4/@4 /@1 :336 2@09'932510439 5<
D04/9<@D6 :; 4/3 D5<>=@6
@D@<9 9531 654 @<013
/3 IB314056 57 <3523606? 4/3
/3<375<3 D/@4 <3=@061 45 :3 1336
06 4/3 @2280A@4056 70839 B693<
3A4056 $$
! 57 4/3
A4 01
D/@4 01 4/3 @=5B64 4/@4 01 2@09 5< 932510439 :; 4/3
234040563<
4 01 A83@< @69 B6@=:0?B5B1 4/@4 4/3 3=285;3<
01 654 <3IB0<39 45 ?5 :3;569 4/3 @D@<9 :; 83@906? @6;
7B<4/3< 3F0936A3 15 @1 45 A564<@90A4 4/3 CB9?=364 @69
@D@<9 2@1139 :; 4/3 <0:B6@8 D/0A/ /@1 @44@0639 706@804;
04 01 <383F@64 45 =364056 4/3 CB9?=364 57 4/3
56.:83
23H
5B<4 06 4/3 A@13 57
!
4/01
" #$
5B<4 06 4/3 A@13 57 % & '
/3
5 5<906@43
(
)
36A/ 57
*
- 11 -
+
,%- ,
IB314056
# .$
/@1
93A0939
4/01
25<4056 57 D/0A/ 01 3H4<@A439 /3<306 :385D )
!" #!!
&
!$ !# #! %
&
'
##
(
)
&
*
#
F3<;
! #! , '
+
&
&
.
'
/
(
#! , 0
$
6 F03D 57 4/3 @2280A@4056 /@F06? :336 70839 @69
4/3 @:5B<
5B<4 D5B89 /@F3 45 2@11 @6 5<93< 56 4/3 1@09
@2280A@4056
4/3 1@=3 D088 /@F3 45 :3 @9F3<439 45 D04/
<3?@<9 45 4/3 @=5B64 4/@4 01 2@09 5< 45 :3 2@09 :; 4/3
234040563<' =285;3< 45 4/3 D5<>=@6 75< D/0A/ 4/01
5B<4 01
57 4/3 5206056 4/@4 4/3 =@443< <3IB0<31 45 :3 <3=04439 45
4/3 @:5B<
5B<4 :; 134406? @1093 4/3 5<93< 2@1139 :; 4/3
- 12 -
@:5B<
5B<4 23<=04406? 4/3 234040563<' =285;3< 45 7083
5:C3A40561 @69 @6; A@8AB8@40561 @1 45 4/3 2@;=364 15
=@93 5< 932510439 5< <3A30F39 07 @6; :; 4/3 D5<>=@6
"
AA5<906?8;
2@11 4/3 75885D06?)
/3 D<04 23404056 01
/3 A5==56 5<93< 9@439 #
4/3
@:5B<
@69 " 06
5B<4
/
# " 2@1139 :;
@8@:B<@?0 56
2280A@4056
5 $' #
F093
$
663HB<3
01 /3<3:; 134 @1093
34040563<' =285;3< 01 23<=04439 45 7083 4/3
5:C3A4056
14@43=364
5 $' #
70839 B693<
4/3
3A4056 $$
2280A@4056
! 57 4/3
@69 28@A3 @88 1BA/ =@43<0@8 :375<3 4/3
A4
@:5B<
5B<4 75< 04 45 A5=3 45 @ A56A8B1056 56 4/3
2@;=364 07 @6; =@93 5< 9B3 45 :3 2@09 45 4/3
<312569364'D5<>=@6
- 13 -
0F
6 F03D 57 4/3 7@A4 4/@4 4/3 69B14<0@8
D@1 57 4/3 ;3@<
##
012B43
4/3 =@443< /@F06?
@44@0639 706@804; D04/ <3?@<9 45 4/3 @D@<9 06 4/3
;3@<
# $ :375<3 4/3
@:5B<
5B<4
1/@88
56.:83
93A093
23H
5B<4 4/3
4/3
=@443<
3H2390405B18; D04/06 @6 5B43< 80=04 57 4/<33
=564/1 7<5= 4/3 9@43 57 <3A3024 57 A52; 57 4/3
5<93<
F
4 01 =@93 A83@< 4/@4 4/3 1A523 57 4/3
@:5B<
5B<4 06 93A0906? 4/3 @2280A@4056 70839 B693<
3A4056 $$
! 57 4/3
A4 01 80=0439 @69 04
A@6654 ?5 :3;569 D/@4 01 2<5F0939 B693< 4/3
A4 5< ?5 :3;569 4/3 @D@<9 2@1139 D/0A/ /@1
@44@0639 706@804;
'
)
5)
5) "
!)*
!
#
"
(
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review