Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
+
Date of Decision: 20.01.2026
W.P.(C) 11617/2015
TWINKLE CHHABRA
Through:
.....Petitioner
Ms. Ritu Negi and Mr. Raman Bahl,
Advs.
versus
STATE BANK OF INDIA AND ANR
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Rajiv Kapur, SC, Mr. Akshit
Kapur and Ms. Riya Sood, Advs. for
SBI.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SACHIN DATTA
SACHIN DATTA, J. (Oral)
1.
The present petition has been filed by the Petitioner seeking directions
to the respondents to pay compensation / damages for the trauma and
harassment caused to the Petitioner due to the alleged negligence and
carelessness of the Respondents in an incident that occurred on 21.04.2015
inside the premises of the Shalimar Bagh Branch of the Respondent No.1
bank / State Bank of India (SBI).
2.
In the present petition, the Petitioner seeks the following reliefs :
“a) Issue a writ of Mandamus and/or other appropriate writ(s)/order(s)
and other appropriate writ(s)/order(s) thereby directing the respondent
no.1 and 2 to pay damages/compensation to the petitioner for the
trauma and harassment caused due to the negligence and carelessness
of the Respondents;
b) Issue a Writ of Mandamus and/or other appropriate writ(s)/order(s)
and other appropriate writ(s)/order(s) thereby directing the respondent
no. 1 and 2 to pay an interest over and above the aforesaid amount at
the rate of 18% per annum from the date of accident till realization
from the respondents; and
c) Pass such other and further order(s) as this Hon'ble Court may deem
Digitally Signed
By:ABHISHEK THAKUR
16:24:00
W.P.(C) 11617/2015
fit and proper under the facts and circumstances of the case.”
3.
The case of the Petitioner is that, while she was present in the
Respondent No.1 bank for opening a savings account on 21.04.2015, a
firearm carried by Respondent No.2, an armed security guard deployed by
Respondent No.1 bank, accidentally discharged, resulting in pellet injuries
to the Petitioner in her thigh muscles. She was immediately taken to Fortis
Hospital, Shalimar Bagh, where she underwent surgical treatment, the cost
of which was covered by the Respondent No.1 bank. The Petitioner was
subsequently discharged from the aforesaid hospital the next day i.e., on
22.04.2015.
4.
On 21.04.2015, an FIR, under Sections 336 and 338 of the Indian
Penal Code, 1860, was registered by the Petitioner against Respondent No.2,
(employee/ security guard of the Respondent No.1 bank) with respect to the
aforesaid incident.
5.
It is further submitted that the incident occurred due to the negligence
of Respondent No.2 in the course of his employment, and that Respondent
No.1 Bank is vicariously liable to compensate for the same.
6.
The Petitioner further contends that despite bearing certain initial
medical expenses, Respondent No.1 bank has failed to consider the
Petitioner’s claim for compensation/ damages on account of (i) loss of
income; (ii) loss of career prospects; (iii) loss of marriage prospects; (iv)
mental agony and trauma etc.
7.
Thereafter, on 14.12.2015, the Petitioner filed the present petition
seeking reliefs as enumerated in para 2 hereinabove.
8.
On 04.03.2016, this Hon’ble Court issued notice in the present matter.
On the same date, a letter dated 11.02.2016 issued by Respondent No.1 bank
Digitally Signed
By:ABHISHEK THAKUR
16:24:00
W.P.(C) 11617/2015
was handed over to the Court. Upon perusal thereof, this Hon’ble Court
directed the Respondent No.1 bank to reimburse all medical expenses
incurred by the Petitioner, whether in the past or in the future, arising out of
the injury suffered by the Petitioner on 21.04.2015.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE PETITIONER
9.
Learned counsel for the Petitioner contends that the present case is a
clear instance of negligence on the part of Respondent No.2, inasmuch as
the incident occurred while Respondent No.2 was on duty at the premises of
Respondent No.1 bank. It is submitted that both the Respondents are jointly
and severally liable for the accident and for payment of compensation to the
Petitioner. It is further contended that the failure of the Respondents to
properly check, service and maintain the firearm issued to Respondent No.2
constitutes gross negligence on their part.
10.
Learned counsel for the Petitioner further submits that as a
consequence of the aforesaid negligence, the Petitioner has suffered serious
and lasting prejudice, inasmuch as she was constrained to give up on her
career prospects of pursuing employment as a teacher and has also suffered
adverse impact on her matrimonial prospects, on account of her inability to
stand for prolonged periods due to the injury sustained.
11.
It is further submitted that the Respondents do not dispute the fact that
the firearm was discharged during the working hours of Respondent No.1
bank, and therefore, according to the Petitioner, the burden does not lie upon
her to establish negligence on the part of the Respondents.
12.
It is also submitted that the Petitioner, till date, continues to undergo
physiotherapy and allied treatment in relation to the injury suffered in the
said incident, and the expenses incurred in that regard ought to be borne by
Digitally Signed
By:ABHISHEK THAKUR
16:24:00
W.P.(C) 11617/2015
Respondents.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENTS
13.
Learned counsel for the Respondents challenges the maintainability of
the present petition and submits that the same involves disputed questions of
fact, including issues of negligence and quantification of damages, which
would require leading of evidence. It is therefore contended that the
Petitioner ought to be relegated to appropriate civil remedies. It is further
submitted that the Petitioner has failed to establish negligence on the part of
the Respondent No.1 bank.
14.
Learned counsel for the Respondents submits that the Respondent
No.1 bank has never refused to bear the medical expenses incurred by the
Petitioner in relation to the said injury. It is further submitted that the
Petitioner was discharged from the hospital in a satisfactory condition, as
reflected from the relevant discharge summary.
15.
It is submitted that the determination of the quantum of compensation
would require adjudication by way of a regular trial before the competent
Civil Court, and that the writ jurisdiction of this Court is not the appropriate
forum for such determination..
FINDINGS
16.
I have considered the rival submissions advanced by respective
counsel for the parties and perused the material placed on record.
17.
At the outset, insofar as the issue of maintainability is concerned, it is
true that ordinarily, disputes relating to negligence and quantification of
damages are relegated to the civil forum. However, it is equally well settled
that in appropriate cases, where the foundational facts are not in serious
dispute and the injury is a result of an admitted incident involving
Digitally Signed
By:ABHISHEK THAKUR
16:24:00
W.P.(C) 11617/2015
instrumentalities of the State, this Court may exercise its jurisdiction under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India to grant compensatory relief,
particularly where the relief is founded on violation of the right to life and
bodily integrity under Article 21.
18.
Reliance in this regard may be placed upon D.K. Basu v. State of
W.B., (1997) 1 SCC 416, whereby the Hon’ble Apex Court observes as
under:
“44. The claim in public law for compensation for unconstitutional
deprivation of fundamental right to life and liberty, the protection of which
is guaranteed under the Constitution, is a claim based on strict liability
and is in addition to the claim available in private law for damages for
tortious acts of the public servants. Public law proceedings serve a
different purpose than the private law proceedings. Award of
compensation for established infringement of the indefeasible rights
guaranteed under Article 21 of the Constitution is a remedy available in
public law since the purpose of public law is not only to civilise public
power but also to assure the citizens that they live under a legal system
wherein their rights and interests shall be protected and preserved. Grant
of compensation in proceedings under Article 32 or Article 226 of the
Constitution of India for the established violation of the fundamental rights
guaranteed under Article 21, is an exercise of the courts under the public
law jurisdiction for penalising the wrongdoer and fixing the liability for
the public wrong on the State which failed in the discharge of its public
duty to protect the fundamental rights of the citizen.
45. The old doctrine of only relegating the aggrieved to the remedies available
in civil law limits the role of the courts too much, as the protector and
custodian of the indefeasible rights of the citizens. The courts have the
obligation to satisfy the social aspirations of the citizens because the
courts and the law are for the people and expected to respond to their
aspirations. A court of law cannot close its consciousness and aliveness to
stark realities. Mere punishment of the offender cannot give much solace
to the family of the victim — civil action for damages is a long drawn and
a cumbersome judicial process. Monetary compensation for redressal by
the court finding the infringement of the indefeasible right to life of the
citizen is, therefore, useful and at time perhaps the only effective remedy to
apply balm to the wounds of the family members of the deceased victim,
who may have been the breadwinner of the family.”
19.
Similarly, in Nilabati Behera v. State of Orissa, (1993) 2 SCC 746,
Digitally Signed
By:ABHISHEK THAKUR
16:24:00
W.P.(C) 11617/2015
the Hon’ble Apex Court observed as under:
34. The public law proceedings serve a different purpose than the private law
proceedings. The relief of monetary compensation, as exemplary damages,
in proceedings under Article 32 by this Court or under Article 226 by the
High Courts, for established infringement of the indefeasible right
guaranteed under Article 21 of the Constitution is a remedy available in
public law and is based on the strict liability for contravention of the
guaranteed basic and indefeasible rights of the citizen. The purpose of
public law is not only to civilize public power but also to assure the citizen
that they live under a legal system which aims to protect their interests and
preserve their rights. Therefore, when the court moulds the relief by
granting “compensation” in proceedings under Article 32 or 226 of the
Constitution seeking enforcement or protection of fundamental rights, it
does so under the public law by way of penalising the wrongdoer and
fixing the liability for the public wrong on the State which has failed in its
public duty to protect the fundamental rights of the citizen. The payment of
compensation in such cases is not to be understood, as it is generally
understood in a civil action for damages under the private law but in the
broader sense of providing relief by an order of making ‘monetary
amends’ under the public law for the wrong done due to breach of public
duty, of not protecting the fundamental rights of the citizen. The
compensation is in the nature of ‘exemplary damages’ awarded against
the wrongdoer for the breach of its public law duty and is independent of
the rights available to the aggrieved party to claim compensation under
the private law in an action based on tort, through a suit instituted in a
court of competent jurisdiction or/and prosecute the offender under the
penal law.
35. This Court and the High Courts, being the protectors of the civil liberties
of the citizen, have not only the power and jurisdiction but also an
obligation to grant relief in exercise of its jurisdiction under Articles 32
and 226 of the Constitution to the victim or the heir of the victim whose
fundamental rights under Article 21 of the Constitution of India are
established to have been flagrantly infringed by calling upon the State to
repair the damage done by its officers to the fundamental rights of the
citizen, notwithstanding the right of the citizen to the remedy by way of a
civil suit or criminal proceedings. The State, of course has the right to be
indemnified by and take such action as may be available to it against the
wrongdoer in accordance with law — through appropriate proceedings.
Of course, relief in exercise of the power under Article 32 or 226 would be
granted only once it is established that there has been an infringement of
the fundamental rights of the citizen and no other form of appropriate
redressal by the court in the facts and circumstances of the case, is
possible. The decisions of this Court in the line of cases starting
with Rudul Sah v. State of Bihar [(1983) 4 SCC 141 : 1983 SCC (Cri) 798
Digitally Signed
By:ABHISHEK THAKUR
16:24:00
W.P.(C) 11617/2015
: (1983) 3 SCR 508] granted monetary relief to the victims for deprivation
of their fundamental rights in proceedings through petitions filed under
Article 32 or 226 of the Constitution of India, notwithstanding the rights
available under the civil law to the aggrieved party where the courts found
that grant of such relief was warranted. It is a sound policy to punish the
wrongdoer and it is in that spirit that the courts have moulded the relief by
granting compensation to the victims in exercise of their writ jurisdiction.
In doing so the courts take into account not only the interest of the
applicant and the respondent but also the interests of the public as a whole
with a view to ensure that public bodies or officials do not act unlawfully
and do perform their public duties properly particularly where the
fundamental right of a citizen under Article 21 is concerned. Law is in the
process of development and the process necessitates developing separate
public law procedures as also public law principles. It may be necessary
to identify the situations to which separate proceedings and principles
apply and the courts have to act firmly but with certain amount of
circumspection and self-restraint, lest proceedings under Article 32 or 226
are misused as a disguised substitute for civil action in private law. Some
of those situations have been identified by this Court in the cases referred
to by Brother Verma, J.”
20.
In the present case, there is no serious dispute with respect to the
occurrence of the incident or the involvement of the employee of
Respondent No.1 bank therein. The injury suffered by the petitioner and the
cause thereof, is thus not a matter requiring elaborate evidentiary
examination, but flows from an admitted factual matrix. The grievance of
the petitioner, therefore, squarely falls within the domain of public law
remedy for breach of the fundamental right under Article 21 of the
Constitution.
21.
Pursuant to the incident which occurred on 21.04.2015, the petitioner
suffered pellet injuries and underwent surgical treatment. The medical
expenses for the same were admittedly borne by Respondent No.1 bank.
22.
The relationship of employer and employee between Respondent
No.1 and Respondent No.2 also stands admitted. Ex-facie, therefore, the
doctrine of vicarious liability would apply, and Respondent No.1 cannot
Digitally Signed
By:ABHISHEK THAKUR
16:24:00
W.P.(C) 11617/2015
escape responsibility for acts committed by Respondent No.2 during the
course of employment.
23.
During the course of hearing, learned counsel for the Petitioner
submits that given the passage of time, and in the light of the glaring facts
and circumstances, this Court may itself assess and award a suitable
monetary amount to the Petitioner.
24.
The petitioner accedes to the suggestion that the Respondent No.1
bank be directed to pay a sum of Rs.5,00,000/- (Rupees Five Lakhs Only) to
the Petitioner as damages.
25.
Learned counsel for the Respondents is unable to refute the factual
version put-forth by the Petitioner and the fact that the Respondent No.1
bank is evidently responsible for the injury inflicted on the Petitioner.
26.
In view of the liability of Respondent No. 1 bank, learned counsel for
the respondents submits that an appropriate and reasonable amount be
awarded as compensation to the Petitioner.
27.
In the circumstances, it is directed that the Respondent No.1 bank
shall pay a sum of Rs.5,00,000/- to the Petitioner as full and final
compensation towards all claims arising out of the incident dated
21.04.2015.
28.
Let the aforesaid amount be paid by the Respondent No.1 bank to the
Petitioner within a period of six weeks from today.
29.
The petition is disposed of in the above terms. Pending applications, if
any, stand disposed of.
SACHIN DATTA, J
JANUARY 20, 2026/ka
Digitally Signed
By:ABHISHEK THAKUR
16:24:00
W.P.(C) 11617/2015
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review