Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 33001
]N THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(SPecial Originat Jurisdiction)
THURSDAY, THE FIFTH DAY OF MARCH
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE NAGESH BHEEMAPAKA
WRIT PETITION NO : 37835 OF 2025
Between:
Tushar Prakash Aiwani, S/o.Prakash, Aged about 39 years, Occ Business'
R/o.Palma Building, Apt 'l 103, Al Jaddaf, Dubai' UAE, and presently
R/o.H.No.B-1201, Waterford Co-Op Society, Barfiwala Road, Zalawad Nagar'
Juhu Lane, Yadav Nagar, Andheri West. Mumbai' Maharashtra -400058'
...PETITIONER
AND
The Union of India, rep by its secretary Home Ministry' New Delhi'
The Directorate of Enforcement' Ministry of Finance, Government of lndia'
its Assistant Director-cum-lnvestigation Officer, Hyderabad Zonal
Rep OV
'
Office, f ra Floor, WPShakar Bhavan, Fateh Maidan Road, Hyderabad
500004
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of lhe constitution of lndia praying that in the
be pleased
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may
toissueappropriatewrit,orderordirectionmoreparticularlyoneinthenatureofwrit
Look out
of mandamus declaring the action of the 2nd Respondent in continuing the
Respondent
circular issued against the Petitioner inspite of appearing before the 2nd
andprovidingalltheinformationassoughtforandparticipatingintheinquiryasper
exercise
the summon in ECIR/HYZO t25t2023 as arbitrary, illegal, unjust, colourable
guaranteed
of power and against law and is in violation of the fundamental rights
UnderArticles14,lg(1)(g)and2lottheConstitutionoflndiaandconsequently
the
direct the Respondent No. 2 to recall the Look out Notice issued against
Petitioner in ECIR/HYZO 125t2023 on the file of the 2nd Respondent and
intimate to
the authorities to those whom the same was earlier communicated within a stipulated
time limit perrod.
l.A. NO: 1 OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in supporl of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to direct the
2nd Respondent to consider the request of the Petitioner made through mail
Dt.27-11-2025 and pass appropriate order or orders as this court may deem during
the pendency of the writ petition, pending disposal of the writ petition.
l.A. NO: 1 OF 2026
Petition under Section 15'1 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petitron, the High Court may be pleased to permit the
Petitioner to travel abroad as rs permitted by the learned 'lBth Metropolitan
Magistrate, Girgaon, [,4umbai during the pendency of the present Writ Petition and to
pass appropriate order or orders as this Hon'ble Court may deem fit during the
pendency of the Writ Petition.
Counsel for the Petitioner: Ms. MONICA P.POLE, REP. SRI P.SUBASH
Counsel for the Respondents: SRI V.T.KALYAN, SC FOR CENTRAL GOVT.
The Court made the following: ORDER
III THT HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT
I{YDERABAI)
HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE NAGESH BHEEMAPAI(A
UIRIT PETITION No. 37835 OF 2o.25
os.03.2026
Between:
Tushar Prakash Ajwani
. Petitioner
And
The Union of India,
Rep. by its Secretary,
Home Ministry, New Delhi & another
.
ORDER:
Respondents
Petitioner states that he was born and brought up
in India and his parents are presently residing in the State of
Maharashtra. He pursued his education in India and acquired a
Master of Business Administration degree; thereafter, he
received employment opportunities in the United States of
America, migrated to the United States, and subsequently
acquired citizenship of the United States of America. It is
stated, he is presently employed in Dubai, United Arab
Emirates, and shifted to Dubai for the purpose of his
employment. He runs a business consultancy hrm providing
services to foreign companies and individuals in relation to
payment gatcways, currency conversion, and other allied
professional s('rvices.
1.
1.
Pctitioncr states that he h:rs been providing
consultancy scrvice s since Novemb er , 20) 2 and is also engaged
in trading acttvities. In the course of his business erctivities, he
was approached by a company namely "Swingtide Trade Pvt'
Ltd." registercd in MumLrai which requested him to facilitate
payment gateways and related communication and IT setups
with various paymcnt platforms including PayTM, PayPal and
PhonePe. His relationship u'ith Su'ingtide Trade Pvt. Ltd was
purely professional in nature and that hc u'as not part and
parcel of thc company, nor was he involveci in its management
or day-to-dal affairs. He had no rolc in the activities o[ the
company a[)art from rcttdering profcssional consultancy
services. It is furthcr contcnded, hc received monies from the
said companv strictlv tovvards professional scrvices rendered by
him.
1.2.
I'etitiont'r statcs that during April, 2023, one of the
Directors of Srn'ingticle Trade Pvt- Ltd. informed that the
company's birnk etcr:ount had been lrozen and requested him to
verily the same. IJpon verification, he n'as inforrned that Cyber
Crime Station, Girgaon, Mumbai had issued instructions
leading to freezing of thc eiccount and that he was required to
J
take up the issue with the Cyber Crime Station. He immediately
visited the Cyber Crime Station, Mumbai and inquired about the
reasons for freeziog of the company's bank account. Petitioner
contends that during such visit, he was questioned regarding
his role in the company, to which he clarihed that he was only a
consultant rendering services and he had been requested by the
Director to verify the freezing of the bank account. He fumished
a-ll the details relating to [he company, including details of its
Directors and other related information, and fully cooperated
with the inquiry.
1.3.
Petitioner states that after two days, he was once
again called to the police stalion and questioned further. He
once again informed the authorities ol all relevant facts and
fully cooperated with the investigation. After questioning and
recording of information, police informed him that they were
placing him under arrest in connection with Crime No. 11 of
2023 wherein he was arrayed as Accused No. 6. He approached
the trial court and oblained bail. Petitioner further states that
he subsequently came to know that another crime bearing No.
lO4 of 2023 had also been registered against certain persons
including himself and that in the said case also, he was granted
bail. When the company's account was frozen, he filed an
Application seeking defreezing of the bank account and that the
learned Judgc grantcd an order defreezing the same. In all the
orders passed by thc learned Judges, it u'as opined that thcre
was no mone tary benefil derived by him in the alleged crimes
and that he had not made any money.
1.4.
11 is contended, petitioner rcccived summons from
the 2"d Respondent dated 14.05.2025 requiring him to appear
on 04.06.2025; hc immediately informed the 2'd Respondent
that he was not available in India on the said date and
requested for another date for appcarance. He thereafter,
received another summon s dated 14 .O8.2O25 directing to
appear on 25.08.2025. It is stated, on 74.O8.2O25, he addressed
a communication to the 2"d Respondent explaining, in detail,
the circumstanccs and his inability to appear on the specif-red
date. He also sought clarification as to wh,r' summons were
being served on l-rim and expressed his rvillingncss to provide all
information sought. He specificall1, requested the 2'd
Responde nt to fttrnish details of the complain t in connection
u,ith whir:h he was summoned and also requestcd a copy of the
ECIR so as to understand the allegations and enable him to
provide necessary information. Till date, he has not been
provided with information regarding the complaint pending with
the 2"0 Respondent.
I
)
1.5.
peLitioner states that he travelled
to India due to a
family medical emergency and also to attend a court hearing
in
connection with an ongoing case. He immediately informed the
office of the 2"d Respondent through e mail dated 15. 11.2025
of
his availability to appear on 17.l l.2O2S, if required. He also
informed the 2"4 Respondent of his intention to return on
la.l l .2025 owing to extremely short leave granted by his
employer in Dubai. In the said e mail, he also expressed
willingness to appear after two weeks, ie. post lg. t l.2O2S,
if
required. However, he did not receive any response, therefore,
proceeded to return to Dubai on 1g.1I.2O25. He was
shocked
and surprised when he was offloaded and not permitted to
board his flight due to I-ook Out Circular issued against
the 2.d Respondent in connection with the
1.6.
him by
.."..
"rrd
Petitioner states that immediately on lg. I 1.2025 at
approximately I l:00 pM, he received e mail from the 2nd
Respondent directing him to be present before the olhce on
20.11.2025. Though he was unaware of the precise reasons for
his summoning, fearing the consequences, he appeared before
the 2"a Respondent on 20.11.2025 and 21.I1.2O25, during
which dates, he provided all the information sought and
answered all questions relating to the activities of Swingtide
Trade Pvt. Ltd. and his professional association with the said
-l-
company. After furnishing information, he was informed that he
should provide anv further information if required, and he
undcrtook to furnish all information in his possession and
assured full participation in the inquiry. He also adclressed e
mail dated 27 .11.2025 elaborating upon thc sequence of events,
his participation in the inquiry, and his intention to cooperate
and requested the 2"d Respondent to lift or cancel the subsisting
Look Out Circular and to grant him permission to travel abroad'
Petitioner states that he informed the 2"d Respondent ol his
pressing cmployment commitments in Dubai ancl his confirmed
travel ticket and hc also handed over thc order passcd by the
learned Judge granting him permission to leave I ndia bet"r'een
t3.O9 .2025 ar.d 31.O7 .2026 for employment purposes
| .7 .
On 29 .1 | .2025, he received email from thc ollicer of
the 2"d Respondent stating that certain additional information
u,as required and directing him to submit the sarne by
Ol .12.2025. According to petitioner, he submi[ted all the
information by e mail dated 01.12-2025- Despitc such
submission the 2"d Respondent has no[ revoked the LOC,
thereby hampering his employment and causing irreparable loss
and grave hardship to him and his famity-
1.8.
Petitioner contends that as per the procedure
governing issuance and review of took Out Circulars, once a
......,....--/2..
I
I
I
I
ii
person appears before the investigating authority and
l
participates in the inquiry, the Originating Agency is required to
,
assess whether such person is likely to evade investigation or
I
I
I
I
t
j
I
I
I
trial by leaving the country. If the assessment reveals that the
person is likely to evade, LOC may be continued; otherwise, the
same must be deleted by informing the Depufy Director, Bureau
of Immigration, New Delhi. An LOC remains in force unless a
deletion request is received from the Originating Agency and
!
i
'
t
i
;
that the Originating Agency is required to periodicaily review the
LOC on a quarterly and annual basis and to submit proposals
for deletion immediately . after the person appears and
i
I
i
I
I
participates in the investigation, if the LOC is not required in its
assessment. Petitioner asserts that the oflicers concerned are
strictly directed to follow the guidelines for opening and
reviewing LOCs and to take appropriate action for deletion when
,
I
I
I
continuation is not warranted.
1.9.
Petitioner contends that fundamental rights in a
democratic setup play a pivotal role and that the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in Maneka Gandhi a. Union of India
;
I
:
,
ii
I
I
I
i
I
I
interpreted the scope of Article 21 ir-r the widest possible
manner. Fundamental rights can be curtailed only by a
procedure established by law. The 2nd Respondent ought to
exercised caution in issuing and continuing a Look Out Circular
and that once a pcrson appears and cooperates in the
investigation, LOC ought to be recalled or revoked' Petitioner
state s that person;rl liberty under Article 21 includes the right
to travel abroad an<i that no person can bc deprived of this right
except in accordance u'ith procedure prescribed b1' lau'
It is
stated, petitioner ha.d already obtained permission from the trial
cor.lrt to travel abroad; despite the same, the 2nd Respondent
has not rccalled the LOC, thereby preventing him from leaving
for his employment. Petitioner states that he is under threat of
losing his cmplolTment, as his employer has issued a
communication directing him io join office or face termination,
and that loss of cmployment would cause irreparable loss and
injury to him and his family which cannot be compensated'
The Znd Respondent filed a detailed counter
contending thal the Directorate of Enforcement is an
2.
investigating agency functioning uncier the Government ol lndia,
Ministry of Finance, and is emporvered to investigate matters
under thr: Prevention of Money Laundering AcL, 2OO2 (PMLA)
and the Foreign Iixchange Management Act, 1999 (FEMA), and
that it is the corlpetent authority to investigate of[ences under
t}'re PMLA and FEMA. Thc 2nd Respondent denies all allegations
made in Lhe writ petition except those specificallv admitted'
2.1.
It is stated, the genesis of the case lies in FIR No.
598 of 2023 dated 23.03.2023 registered at PS Cyber Crime,
Hyderabad against unknown suspects under Sections 66(C) and
66(D) of the Information Technolog, Act and Sections 419 and
42O of the IPC. The FIR was based on a written complaint by
Mr. Sai Krishna Kumar NV S/o Late N. Bhaskara Rao alleging
that he was cheated in the guise of a "Rate and Review" parttime job offered via Telegram and was defrauded of Rs. 25.48
Iakhs. The 2nd Respondent contends that the police
investigation in the said FIR is still in progress.
2.2.
It is further stated; similar FIRs were registered at
multiple police stations under Sections 66(C) and 66(D) of the
Information Technologu Act and Sections 419 and 42O lPC,
wherein cyber fraudsters induced membdrs of the public by
offering part-time jobs for reviewing and rating websitcs, hotels
and tourist destinations with promises of high returns, collected
huge pre-deposits, and absconded with the lunds. The 2"4
Respondent contends that cyber scam was committed by
unknown fraudsters suspected to bc operating from outside
India in active connivance with various Indian entities and
individuals, some of whom were arrested by PS Cyber Crime in
connection with the scheduled offence. It is further contended
that the masterminds lured the public by claiming association
l0
with Tripadvisor zLnd collected funds in the guise of predeposits.
2.3.
The 2,,(l Respondent states that since the oflences
under Scctions 419 and 42O IPC are scheduled offences under
thc PMLA, an Enfclrcement Case Information Report bearing No'
E;CIRIHYZO 12512023 was recorded on 25.07 .2023 and
investigation under the PMLA was initlated against Prakash
Mtrlchandbhai Pra.iapati, Kumar Jitendra Prajapati, Naimuddin
Wahidudchn Shaik, Gagan Kumar Soni, Parveez alias Guddu,
Shameer Khan, Mohammed Munawar, Shah Sumair, Arul Das
anrl unknorvn otht:rs to identily proceeds of crime generated out
of the cyber frauds and laundered for personal gains.
2.1.
The 2"a Respondent contends that Writ Petition
reflects insecurity'on the part of Petitioner and hc rushed to this
Collrt \r,ithout genuine apprehension. It is stated that summons
were issued lo hin.r undcr Section 5O of the PMLA on 74.O5.2025
and 14.O8.2O25 lbr his examination, but he failed to appear
and, by e mail dated 26.05.2025, informed that he is neilher a
citizen nor rcsident of India, is a citizen of the United States of
America residing in the United Arab Emirates, trnd was unable
to travel to India for appearance on 04.O6.2025. The 2"d
Rcspondcnt further states that even after service of proper
annexures to thc summons dated 14.05.2025 seeking certain
)'
lt
,t
L
-l
J
data and information, Petitioner stated that the summons did
not contain details of thc case for which his presence was
required.
2.5.
The 2"a Respondent contends that considering the
sensitive nature of the investigation and the necessiqr of the
i
Petitioner's examination for tracing proceeds of crime and
II
examining his role under the PMLA, summons dated
i
14 .Oa.2025
were issued requiring his appearance on
25.OA.2O25. He did not respond and, one day prior to the
:
!
I
I
scheduled appearance, by e mail dated 24.Og.2O25, again
expressed inability to travel due to work commitments in UAE.
Despite receipt of summons on two occasions, petitioner failed
I
to appear and failed to furnish basic details sought. By [e tter
I
I
dated O1.O9.2025 in response to summons dated 14.0g.2025,
petitioner reiterated that he had no house in [ndia, stayed u,ith
his parents in Mumbai during visits, and that the summons did
not disclose details of the case.
2.6.
The 2"d Respondent states thaL pe[itioner was in
India from November 2022 to November 2023 intending to start
a business in consultancy and came into contact with
M/ s Swingtide Trade Pvt. Ltd. to facilitate payment gateivay
services and related IT setup. The 2"d Respondent contends that
in April 2O23, upon freezing of the company's bank account by
Cyber Crime DcllartmenL, Girgaon, Mumbai, petitioner
approached thc Cr ber Crime authorities and was questioned
about his role. Tvvc, days later, hc was arrested and arrayed as
Accused No. 6 in OC No. PW l32O 1323 and was informed that
M/ s Swingtide Trade Pvt. Ltd. had received indirect funds
obtained by fraud. The 2"d Respondent further states that in
September 2023, Petitioner was arrested by Cyber Crime
Department, Pune during investigation of a cyber crime case
ancl was grzrnted biril b]. 6161sp dated 1O.11.2023.
2.7.
ffig 'rna Respondent contends that in view of
petitioner's failurc to appear despite summons and failure to
furnish <:ompletc rcquisite data and information, and
considcring thc gr:rvit1' and nature of the offence, a Look Out
Circular rvas issucrl agarnst him on 12.1O.2025. By e mail dated
15. 1 1.2O25, petitioner informed that he had arrived in Mumbai
for a familv medical emergency and exprcssed rvillingness to
appear on 17.I \.2025 or at a later date two weeks thereafter, as
hc: had bookcd return travel for 7A.11.2025. The 2nd
Respondent cont('nds that Pctitioner did not communicate
telephonicalh, regarding his arrival and attempted to leave India
on the night of 18. I 1.2O25 until he u'as detected on the LOC by
the Bureau of lrnmigration. Upon delection and as per the
parameters of thc LOC, he u,as prevcnted from leaving the
\,Y
ll
country. After receipt of e mail from the Bureau of Immigration,
Respondent informed Petitioner by e mail dated 18. I 1.2O25 to
appear on 20. 1 1.2025 lor examination.
2.A.
The 2"d Respondent contends that considering his
time constraints and in compliance with principles of natural
justice, his deposition was recorded on 2O. I 1.2O25 and
21.11.2025 under Section 50 of the PMLA. During examination,
certain questions relating to his role and involvement were put
to him and he undertook to submit relevant data and
information by 25. 1 1.2025. The 2"d Respondent states that he
failed to submit the undertaken information and tendered lalse
statements. Thereafter, by e mail dated 28.11.2025, Petitioner
requested lifting or revocation of the LOC to enable him to travel
to Dubai. The 2'd Respondent contends that by e mail dated
29.11.2025, he was given another opportunity to submit
pendrng information by 01.12.2025. However, by e mail dated
01.12.2025, he again failed to submit complete data and
information, demonstrating non-cooperation and evasiveness.
2.9.
tt is also stated, petitioner has been charge-sheeted
as Accused No. 6 in FIR No. ll of 2023 dated 10.O4.2O23 of PS
South Cyber, Crime Branch, Mumbai and as Accused No. 1 in
FIR No. lO4 of 2023 dated 1 1.O7.2023 of PS Cyber Crime, Pune
City, Maharashtra, relatable to the scheduled offences. During
t4
investigation, it was revcalcd that both the above FIRs are
intcrlinkecl and connected s'ith the instant case, as multiple
primary and scconrlary laycr bank accounts used for collection
antl layering of procecds of crime were common across the
cases. It is stated that summons were issued to Dilip May'ur
Nikam, Mehul Chhadwa and Anshu Yadav, Director of Mis SBS
Recharge l\t. Ltd., and thcir state ments were recorded. These
statements revealed that Tllshar Prakash Ajwani was arranging
funds through Aditi Parmar and that Dilip Mayur Nikam was
arranging USDT through in termediaries including Spay India,
Quicksun Technologies Pvt. Ltd., SBS Recharge, Mehul
Chhadrva, Paresh Shah, Pintu Singh @ Balvir Singh and others.
2.1O.
11 is also stated, Whals App chat screenshots of
gr()ups comprising Petitioncr, Mayur Diiip Nikam and Aditi
Prrrmar revealecl tir:rt Aditi Parmar shared crypto wallet details
for receiving USDT against transfer of online funds into bank
accounts shared b_v Petitioner and Diiip Mayur Nikam. It is
contended that scveral bank account details and contact
nurmbcrs o[ suspcc[s were found in the mobile phone of the
Pctitioner seized by PS C.yber Crime, Pune City, and that
investigation is still in progress as numerous bank accounts are
. involved and connccted rvith the instant case involving victims
across India \ rh() \\'erc chcated through lake tour and travel
7t5
promotion links and whose funds were converted into USDT and
layered further.
2.1| .
The 2"d Respondent states that examination of the
above persons revealed that M/s SBS Recharge Pvt. Ltd. alone
had received proceeds of crime exceeding Rs. 15 Crores from
multiple primary and secondary layer bank accounts and
handed over cash to others for conversion into USDT and
transfer to crypto wallets shared by Aditi Parmar to Tushar
Prakash Ajwani and Mayur Dilip Nikam. Petitioner is part of a
chain wherein proceeds of crime were converted into USDT in
lieu of commission and that being a citiznn of the United States,
there exists every possibility that he may leave India and it
would be difhcult to secure his presence before the Court for fair
trial. There is a strong possibility that Petitioner may not appear
before the Directorate, thereby hampering ongoing investigation
and actions rclating to attachment of proceeds of crime and
prosecution of persons involved in money laundering.
2.12.
The 2"d Respondent furttrer states that Petitioner
failed to provide details of his associates including Amit Sahani,
Aditi Parmar and others involved in collection and conversion of
proceeds of crime into cash or USDT, and that his examination
regarding receipt of commission and matters relating to charge
sheets fiIed by PS South Cyber Crime Branch, Mumbai and PS
l6
Cyher Crime , Pune City is still pcnding. [t is also contended that
the Petitioner continued to remain part of a Whats App group
\.ith Aditi Pannar :rnd Dilip Mayr-rr Nikam even after freezing of
bank accounts shared by Dilip Ma1'ur Nikam lor receipt of funds
from Adrti Parmar for conversion into USDT. In view of the
above, it is conterrded, the Look Out Circular issued against
Pel.itioner ought not to be revoked and prays that no relief be
granted until his complete examination is concluded or until
final conclusion of the case, rvhichevcr is later.
Heard Ms. Monica P. Pole, learned counsel
3.
representir-rg Sri P. Subash, lehrned counsel for petitioner and
Sri V.T. Kalyan. Iearned Standing Counsel for Central
G()vernment.
4.
From thc matcrial on record, it is to be noticed, the
Enforcemcnt Case lnformation Report bearing No.
E.CIR/HYZOl25/2023 dated 25.07.2O23 arises out of FIR No.
598 of 2023 dated 23.03.2023 registered at PS Cyber Crime,
Hyderabad, based on allegations of cyber fraud involving
cheating to thc tunc of Rs. 25.48 lakhs in the guise of "Rate and
Re
view" part-l ime employment oflers circulatcd through
Telegram- 'l'he offences ini,oked under Scctions 419 and 42O IPC
are undisputecllv scheduled olfences under the Prevention of
Mone5, Laundering Act, 2OO2. Once a scheduled offence is
1'7
registered and material discloses generation of proceeds of
crime, the Directorate of Enforcement is statutorily empowered
to register an ECIR and initiate investigation under the
provisions o[ the PM LA. The authority of the Directorate in this
regard is traceable to statute and is not in dispute.
5.
Section 5O of the PMLA confers power upon the
authorized ollicer to summon any person whose attendance is
considered necessary to give evidence or produce records during
the course of investigation. Proceedings under Section 5O are
deemed to be judicial proceedings within the meaning of
Sections 193 and 228 of thc IPC. Therefore, summons issued
under Section 5O carry statutory force and cannot be treated as
mere administrative communications. The record reflects that
summons wcre issued to Petitioner on 14.05.2025 requiring his
appearance on 04.06.2025 and again on 14.08.2025, requiring
his appearance on 25.08.2025. lt is an admitted position that
Petitioner did not appear pursuant to the said summons.
Though he expressed inability to travel on account of his
residence in the United Arab Emirates and his status as a
citizen of the United States of America, the fact remains that the
investigating authority was deprived of his examination at the
relevant time. Issuance of t-ok Out Circular on 12.10.2025 was
preceded by such non-appearance.
1t{
Pctitioner arrived InCia on 15.11.2025 and
6.
t:ommunicated by e mail expressing u,illingness to appear either
on
7. 1 L2O25 or tr"r'o r.r,eeks thercafter. Ho'"l,ever, he attempted
to depart India on 18.11.2025 w'ithout securing conltrmation
from the investigating authority regarding rescheduling of his
examination. Upon detection pursuant to the LOC by the
Bureau of Immigration, he was pre vented from leaving the
country. Thereafter, he rvas examined on 2O.1 1.2O25 and
21.11.2025 under Section 50 of the PMLA.
The principal issue for consideration is whether
7.
continuation of [,ook Out Circu lar alter his examination on
20.17.2025 and !) 1.11.2025 is arbitrary, illegal, or violative of
Articles t+, 19(1)(g) ar-rd 21 of the Constitution of India.
8.
Thc countcr discloses lhat during examination,
petitioner undertook to furnish certain information and data by
25.11.2025. It is specil-rcally avcrred that he failed to furnish
the undertaken information and that the material supptied
subsequentlv on O 1. 12.2025 u,as incomplete. It is further
averred that his examination in relation to ccrtain associates,
including persons allegedll, involved in conversion of proceeds of
crime into USDT, and in relaLion to charge sheets hled in FIR
No. 11 ot 2023 datcd 10.O4.2023 of pS South Cyber, Crime
,.?
l9
-
Branch, Mumbai and FIR No. 1O4 of 2023 dated I 1.O7.2023 of
PS Cyber Crime, Pune City, is still pending.
9.
The material placed by Respondents also indicates
that the investigation concerns interlinked FIRs, multiple
primary and secondary layer bank accounts, and alleged
conversion of proceeds of crime exceeding Rs. 15 Crores into
USDT crypto currency. Statements of other persons recorded
under investigation allegedly implicate Petitioner in arranging
funds through Aditi Parmar and in sharing bank accounts for
receipt of online funds which were thereafter converted into
crypto assets. Whether these .allegations ultimately result in
prosecution or conviction is not a matter for determination at
this stage. However, for the limited purpose of assessing
justil-rcation for continuation of an LOC, the Court must
consider whether there exists prima facie material warranting
further examination and securing of presence.
10.
The guidelines governing look Out Circulars
contemplate that the Originating Agency must assess whether
the subject is likely to evade investigation or trial. Such
assessment is essentially factual in nature and involves
evaluation of conduct, past compliance, gravity of offence, and
possibility of non-availability. Judicial review of such
t0
assessment is limited to examining '*'hether the decision is
arbitrar,r,, mala fide, or u'ithout material basis
Ll.
In the present casc, Petitioner did not respond to
two surlmons issued in May and August 2025. He attempted to
depart lndia on 18. I ),.2025 prior to securing conllrmation
regarding his examination. He is admittedly, a citizen of the
United Statcs of America residing in the United Arab Emirates.
He is charge-sheetecl as Accused No. 6 in FIR No. 11 of 2023
and as Accused No. 1 in FIR No. lO4 of 2023. His examination
under Section 50 of the PMLA is stated to be incomplete, with
pending queries relating to associates and alleged receipt of
commission in connection with conversion of procceds of crime
into USDT.
12.
In
t.hese circumstances, the
apprchension
expressed byr Respondent that there exists a possibility of
Pe
titioner leaving India and not being readily available for
further investigation cannot be said to be unfounded or
irrational. The decision to continue LOC is thus supported by
materiaI considerations and cannot be characterized as
arbitrary. The reliance placed by Petitioner on the judqment in
Maneka Gandhi u. Union of India is duly noted. There can be
no dispute that the right to travel abroad forms part of personal
libcrt-v under Articlc 21. Howeve r, the said right is noL absolute.
2t
It is subject to procedure established by law. The PMLA is a
special legislation enacted to combat the menace of money
laundering and confers statutory powers upon the Directorate of
Enforcement to investigate oflences relating to proceeds of
crime. When investigation is pending and presence of a person
is considered necessary, reasonable restrictions imposed in
accordalce with statutory procedure cannot be held per se
violative of Article 2 1 .
13.
The permission granted by the trial Court
permitting travel between 13.09 .2025 and 3l .O7 .2026 rn
connection with other criminal proceedings does not
automatically bind the Directorate of Enforcement in respect of
proceedings under the PMLA. Each authority acts within the
scope of its statutory mandate. Mere existence of a travel
permission in one proceeding does not extinguish powers of
another statutory authorit5r where independent investigation is
pending.
14.
The scope of interference under Article 226 does not
extend to substituting the subjective satisfaction of the
investigating agency with that of the Court, particularly in
matters involving assessment of flight risk and necessity of
securing presence during investigation. The Court does not sit
in appeal over investigative discretion unless it is shown that
the action is vitiated bv mala fides, manifest arbitrariness, or
abscnce oI j urisd iction.
15.
In the present case, no maLerial is placed before
this Court lo establish mala fides or colourable exercise of
po\ rcr. Thc L()C . was issued after non-compliance with
summons. Its continuation is justihed on the ground of
incomplete examination, gravity of alleged offences involving
large-scalc cyber fraud and money laundering, interlinked FIRs,
ancl Petitioner's foreign citizenship and residence abroad. The
procedure adoptecl cannot be said to be unknown to law or
dehors statulory authority. This Court is therefore, satisfied
lhat thc action of the 2nd Respondent in continuing the Look
Or-r
t Circular is base d on relevant matcrial and a rational nexus
with the ob..lcct of securing presence of the Petitioner for ongoing
investigation. No violation of Articles l+, l9(1)(g) or 21 is made
olrt in the facts of thc case.
1(r.
For the foregoing reasons, this Court holds that
Pt'Litioncr failed to establish any arbitrariness, illegality, or
constitutional infirmity in the continuation of the Look Out
Circuiar issued on 12.1O.2025. Thc impugned action is
trzrr:eablc to statutory power under the Prevention of Money
Laurndering Act,'2OO2 and is supported by matenal on record.
:,
.
The Writ Petition is accordingly dismissed. No order
as to costs.
18.
Pending miscellaneous applications, i[ any, shall
stand closed.
/
-P. PONNA KRISHNA
ISTANT REGIST
//TRUE COPY//
SECTION OFFICER
To,
1. One CC to SRI P.SUBASH, Advocate [OPUC]
2. One CC to SRI V T KALYAN, SC FOR CENTRAL GOW. [OPUCI
3. Two CD Copies
BSR
BS
w
HIGH COURT
DATED: 0510312026
ORDER
tU
l. tiiE S 14 ,(:
WP.No.37835 of 2025
\
,)
2 J
c-.1
illq 207
I
i ,./,
+
t, t ]..l L.l cO *
DISMISSING THE WRIT PETITION,
WITHOUT COSTS
)h
t.): \ii
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review