Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 05
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
MC(EP) No. 27 of 2023
In El. Petn. No. 2 of 2023
Shri. Titosstar Well Chyne
Date of Decision: 11.08.2023
Vs.
Shri. Gavin Miguel Mylliem & Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Applicant(s):
Mr. N. Jotendra Singh, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. D. Singha, Adv.
For the Respondent/Opp. Party(s):
Mr. S. Sahay, Adv. with
Ms. S.K. Nongrum, Adv.
Mr. A.M. Pala, Adv.
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
Oral:
1.
The instant Misc. Application has been filed by the Election
Petitioner under Section 141 read with Section 151 of the Code of Civil
Procedure, 1908, and Section 81(3) and Section 87(1) of the
Representation of the People Act, 1951 (hereinafter referred to as RP
Act, 1951), for granting leave to allow the Applicant/Election Petitioner
to furnish attested copies of the Election Petition to the respondents, as
in the main Election Petition No. 2 of 2023, while furnishing copies to
the respondents pursuant to order dated 13.04.2023, photo copies of the
same only was supplied. The respondent No. 1, then on entering
appearance had filed a Misc. Case being MC(EP) No. 19 of 2023,
raising the issue of non-maintainability of the Election Petition on
various grounds, which amongst others, included the non-furnishing of
attested copies of the Election Petition duly signed by the
Applicant/Election Petitioner. As such, by way of the instant
application, leave of this Court has been sought to allow the furnishing
of attested copies of the Election Petition, duly signed by the Election
Petitioner to the respondents.
2.
Mr. N. Jotendra Singh, learned Senior counsel assisted by Mr.
D. Singha, learned counsel for the applicant has submitted that the nonfurnishing of the duly attested copies, was due to inadvertence and is not
intentional. The learned Senior counsel has further submitted that there
should be no impediment in this Court allowing the application,
inasmuch as, the applicant can furnish the attested copies before hearing
of the objection of the respondent No. 1 is taken up. In support of his
contention, the learned Senior counsel has placed reliance on the
judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Anil R. Deshmukh vs.
Onkar N. Wagh & Ors. reported in (1999) 2 SCC 205, wherein it has
been held, that even before arguments were heard on preliminary
objections, as the true copy of the affidavits had been served on the first
respondent and his counsel, there was sufficient compliance of the
provisions of Section 81(3) read with 83(1)(c) of the RP Act, 1951, even
though, the copies served in the first instance on the respondents was
not in conformity with the provisions of the Act. As such, he submits,
the judgment covers the instant case, and thus will overcome the
technical objection that has been raised by the respondent No. 1.
3.
Mr. S. Sahay, learned counsel assisted by Ms. S.K. Nongrum,
learned counsel for the respondent No. 1 has at the outset submitted that,
the application is not maintainable, inasmuch as, Sections 141 and 151
of the Code of Civil Procedure, are inapplicable in the proceedings, as
the same are to be conducted strictly in accordance with the provisions
of RP Act, 1951, which is a self-contained code. It has been further
submitted that, the instant application by the Election Petitioner is an
admission of the fact that, the Election Petition originally filed, is
defective and that the same will be barred by limitation, as only upon
correction of the defects will the Election Petition be compliant with the
statutory requirements. He submits that therefore, the election results
having been declared as far back as on 2nd March, 2023, the 45(fortyfive) days period allowed for preferring the Election Petition had
expired on 17th April, 2023, and as such, the instant application being
filed on 10th July, 2023, is well beyond the period of limitation, and
should be rejected.
4.
It has further been submitted that the application has been filed
to correct the defects only after the application namely Misc. Case No.
19 of 2023, under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC has been filed by the
respondent No. 1. He submits that with the issuance of notice, it is to be
understood that, hearing on the preliminary objections has commenced.
He submits therefore, the instant application being filed after the
arguments on the application under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC, has
commenced, the same is clearly not maintainable. Apart from these
contentions, the learned counsel on the point of the petition being barred
by limitation, has relied upon the case of Satya Narain vs. Dhuja Ram
& Ors. (1974) 4 SCC 237. The learned counsel has also sought to
distinguish the case of Anil R. Deshmukh vs. Onkar N. Wagh & Ors.
(supra), which has been relied upon by the applicant, to emphasise the
point that the said judgment does not in any manner authorise or permit
rectification of any defects, which he submits as per the judgment
rendered in Hukumdev Narain Yadav vs. Lalit Narain Mishra (1974) 2
SCC 133, should be done strictly as per the RP Act, 1951. The learned
counsel lastly submits that, the instant Misc. application itself is an
admission of the non-maintainability of Election Petition No. 2 of 2023
itself.
5.
I have heard learned counsels for the parties. The point for
consideration in the present application is whether, an Election Petition
is to be dismissed at the threshold itself due to the non-attestation of the
copies served upon the respondents. Section 81 and 83 of the RP Act,
1951, has stipulated the manner of presentation and also as to the
contents thereof of the Election Petition. Section 81(1)(3) prescribes as
follows.
“81. Presentation of petitions.-…………………………
…………………………………………………………...
…………………………………………………………..
[(3) Every election petition shall be accompanied by as
many copies thereof as there are respondents
mentioned in the petition [***], and every such copy
shall be attested by the petitioner under his own
signature to be a true copy of the petition.]”
6.
On the non-supply of such attested copies, the Election
Petitioner therefore by way of this instant application is seeking to cure
the said defects. As aforenoted, objections to the application have been
raised, on the ground that it is barred by limitation and that the same
cannot be considered, in view of the fact that hearing of Misc. Case 19
of 2023, the Order 7 Rule 11 CPC application filed by the respondent
has since commenced. On the first point, it is not disputed that the
Election Petition was presented before the Registry within the 45(fortyfive) days limitation period, and the same was accepted and registered.
Substantially therefore, the Election Petition was already on board, and
notwithstanding the application for rectification of defects, the same was
available for consideration. The contention therefore, that it was not
complete in all respects and is now sought to be made compliant as per
the RP Act of 1951, by the instant application, which is beyond the
period of 45(forty-five) days, in the considered view of this Court, is
untenable, and the contention is rejected.
7.
On the other aspect, it is noted that though it is correct that an
application under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC filed by the respondent No. 1 is
pending consideration, and had been filed prior to the instant
application, presently however, this Court at this stage, is only to
examine as to whether the preliminary objections had been substantially
heard, before the instant application was filed. In the case of Anil R.
Deshmukh vs. Onkar N. Wagh & Ors. (supra), on this point the
Hon’ble Supreme Court at Para – 17, which is reproduced herein below,
had held as follows.
“17. It is to be noticed that the reference is only
with regard to the applicability of Dr Shipra in
cases like the one which arose before the said
Bench. In the light of the rulings of the
Constitution Bench referred to earlier, we have
our own reservations on the correctness of the
view expressed in Dr Shipra case but it is
unnecessary in the present case to dwell on the
same. As pointed out earlier, Justice
Ramaswamy has confined the ruling to the "fact
situation" in that case. Insofar as the present
case is concerned, there is a distinguishing factor
which makes the ruling in Dr Shipra case
inapplicable. We have already referred to the fact
that even before arguments were heard on the
preliminary objection by the High Court in this
case, the true copies of the affidavits had been
served on the first respondent and his counsel. In
the facts and circumstances of this case, we have
no doubt that there was sufficient compliance of
the provisions of Section 81(3) read with Section
83(1)(c) of the Act even if it could be said that
the copies served in the first instance on the first
respondent were not in conformity with the
provisions of the Act. Unfortunately, this aspect
of the matter has been completely ignored by the
High Court. Hence the order of the High Court
dismissing the election petition in limine is
unsustainable.”
[Emphasis supplied]
8.
In the instant case, the respondent No. 1 had filed Misc. Case
No. 19 of 2023, under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC on 14.06.2023, and the
matter then appeared on 11.07.2023. On this date, the Election
Petitioner then filed the instant Misc. Case, seeking leave to furnish
attested copies before the commencement of hearing of the objection
application under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC. The order dated 11.07.2023,
being relevant is reproduced herein below.
Serial No. 03
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
MC (EP) No. 27 of 2023 in
El. Pet. No. 2 of 2023
Date of Order: 11.07.2023
Shri Titosstar Well Chyne
Coram:
Vs. Shri Gavin Miguel Mylliem & Ors.
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner(s)/Applicant(s): Mr. D. Singha, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. S. Sahay, Adv. with
Ms. S.K. Nongrum, Adv. (For R 1)
This is an application filed by the election petitioner under
Section 141 read with Section 151 of the CPC for granting leave to
allow the applicant/election petitioner to furnish attested copies of
the Election Petition, duly signed by the applicant/election
petitioner before the commencement of hearing of the objection
application under Order 7 Rule 11 of the CPC, filed by the returned
candidate (respondent No. 1), which has been registered as Misc.
Case No. 19 of 2023.
Mr. S. Sahay, learned counsel for the returned candidate
(respondent No. 1) submits that a short reply is necessary to the
instant Misc. Case, and prays for 2(two) weeks’ time to file the
same.
Prayer is allowed.
It is also noted that the election petitioner has filed reply to
the Order 7 Rule 11 application.
List this matter on 27.07.2023.
JUDGE
Meghalaya
11.07.2023
“V. Lyndem-PS”
9.
From the facts as they pertain on that date, and as given in the
order dated 11.07.2023 quoted above, the preliminary objection was yet
to be taken up for consideration or arguments by this Court, and as such
therefore, the above quoted judgment will squarely apply to the instant
case, inasmuch as, leave has been sought to furnish the attested copies
before Misc. Case No. 19 of 2023, will be taken up.
10.
Another authority of relevance is the judgment in the case of
G.M. Siddeshwar vs. Prasanna Kumar (2013) 4 SCC 776, wherein the
Hon’ble Supreme Court has in Paragraphs – 39 and 52, which are
reproduced herein below, held that although non-compliance with the
provisions of Section 83 of the RP Act, 1951, is a curable defect, yet
there must be substantial compliance with the provisions thereof. This
judgment will therefore undoubtedly apply to the instant case, inasmuch
as, substantial compliance is on record and the only defect was that,
attested copies had not been furnished to the respondents.
“39. Undoubtedly, Section 86 of the Act makes no reference
to Section 83 thereof and so, prima facie, an election petition
cannot be summarily dismissed under Section 86 of the Act
for non-compliance with the provisions of Section 83 thereof.
This was briefly adverted to in Hardwari Lal v. Kanwal Singh
but that was in the context of dismissal of the election petition
under the provisions of CPC. The contention urged in
Hardwari Lal was to the effect that since Section 83 of the
Act does not find a mention in Section 86 thereof, an election
petition could not be summarily dismissed for noncompliance with Section 83. A three-Judge Bench of this
Court held that since an election petition is required to be
tried as nearly as possible in accordance with the procedure
applicable under CPC to the trial of suits, an election petition
could nevertheless be dismissed if it did not disclose a cause
of action.
52. The principles emerging from these decisions are that
although non-compliance with the provisions of Section 83 of
the Act is a curable defect, yet there must be substantial
compliance with the provisions thereof. However, if there is
total and complete non-compliance with the provisions
of Section 83 of the Act, then the petition cannot be described
as an election petition and may be dismissed at the
threshold.”
11.
As the defect therefore, being mere technical in nature, it
cannot be held to be fatal to the main Election Petition, and as observed
earlier, as there is substantial compliance with Section 83 of the RP Act,
1951, the technical defect is therefore curable.
12.
Accordingly, in view of these discussions and observations
made herein above, the instant Misc. Application is allowed and is
accordingly disposed of.
Judge
Meghalaya
11.08.2023
“D.Thabah-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review