Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2024:MLHC:741-DB
Serial No.01
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WA No. 48 of 2024
Reserved on: 13.08.2024
Pronounced on: 16.08.2024
1.
Shri. Tikendra Singh
2.
Shri. W.C. Pakyntein
3.
Shri A.A. Sangma
4.
H.B. Passah
5.
Shri. Sravan Sonar
6.
Shri. Benjamin Khyriem
7.
Shri. Mingnan Marak
8.
Shri. R.H. Kharpran
9.
Shri. Nazrul Islam
10.
Shri. T.S. Marwein
11.
Shri. Edencia Pathaw
12.
Smti. Johny M.R. Marak
13.
Shri. Lumlang Kynter
14.
Shri. Elias Lamare
15.
Smti. Music Nongtdu
16.
Shri. Synran Sohtun
17.
Smti. Womra Mukhim
18.
Shri. Sisir Kumar Das Roy
19.
Shri. Robert M. Jyrwa
20.
Smti. Phidiar Kharjana
21.
Smti. Ambrosina Ksing
22.
Shri. Jogodish Momin
2024:MLHC:741-DB
23.
Smti. Phinolis Khyriem
24.
Smti. Maffulda Sohklet
25.
Shri. Phorming Lyngdoh
26.
Smti. Monica Shullai
27.
Smti. Bonsimai Kharmuti
28.
Smti. Litri Shabong
29.
Smti. S. Shangdiar
30.
Shri. Gohen Sangma
31.
Smti. Pilorina Sangma
32.
Shri. Jinathson A Sangma
33.
Smti. Andromery Rodborne
34.
Shri. Peterson Sangma
35.
Shri. Biren Lamin
36.
Shri. Rorence Marak
37.
Shri. Joslin Sangma
38.
Shri. Niralson Marak
39.
Shri. Kallendra Marak
40.
Shri. Stanford Phanwar
41.
Shri.Ruseng Marak
42.
Shri. Blinder Marak
43.
Shri. Supendra R. Marak
44.
Smti. Midil Dkhar
45.
Smti. Rita Ch. Marak
46.
Smti. Hatmon Lyngdoh
47.
Shri. Jrim S. Nongdhar
48.
Smti. Jentilia Sangma
2024:MLHC:741-DB
49.
Shri. Sonaki Kyndiah
50.
Shri. G.D. Koch
51.
Smti. Abrilla B. Marak
52.
Shri. Samuel Reenborne
53.
Smti. Kalpana Momin
54.
Smti. Sujola Marak
55.
Shri. Devaswar Sarkar
56.
Shri. Akramuz Zaman
57.
Shri. A.K. Marbaniang
58.
Shri. Fristhing Marak
59.
Smti. Pdianglin Phanbuh
60.
Smti. Millianda Shylla
61.
Smti. Amy H. Syiem
62.
Smti. Marlyn Kharumlong
63.
Smti. Justina Nongkynrih
64.
Smti. Dorisnora Lyngdoh
65.
Smti. Esther Dkhar
66.
Shri. Bosterwell Marbaniang
67.
Smti. Monica Pohrmen
68.
Shri. Khlainbor B Palle
69.
Smti. Perinda Mukhim
70.
Smti. Mildred Kharmuti
71.
Shri. Sunolsing Sangma
72.
Smti. Geovita Bamon
73.
Shri. A.H. Lyngdoh
74.
Shri. Wilzeng M. Sangma
2024:MLHC:741-DB
75.
Shri. Wanbha Kharumnuid
76.
Shri. Ivanhoe Dkhar
77.
Shri. Wilson Lamare
78.
Shri. Kishan Sonar
79.
Smti. Deborah Betsy Giri
80.
Smti. Pramita Shabong
81.
Smti. Edwa F. Jyrwa
82.
Smti. Miracle Paswet
83.
Smti. Miracle Lyngwa
84.
Smti. Henantha N. Marak
85.
Smti. Rani
86.
Smti. Sirbilis Syiemlieh
87.
Smti. Philomina Nongsiej
88.
Smti. Nasib Bany Nongbet
89.
Smti. S. Ch. Marak
90.
Smti. Kynti Mary Marwein
91.
Smti. Tina Rani
92.
Smti. R. Dkhar
93.
Smti. Dipali Nag
94.
Deovalenty Lyngdoh
95.
(Lt.) Arsent Ch. Marak
...Appellants
- Versus -
1.
State of Meghalaya represented by the Commissioner and
Secretary, Cooperation Department, Govt. of Meghalaya.
2024:MLHC:741-DB
2.
Managing Director, Meghalaya Cooperative Marketing and
Consumer Federation (MECOFED), Lumdiengjri, Shillong.
3.
The Registrar of Co-operative Societies, Govt. of Meghalaya,
Shillong.
...Respondents
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice S. Vaidyanathan, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Mr. Justice B. Bhattacharjee, Judge
Appearance:
For the Appellants
: Mr. A. Khan, Adv.
Mr. S.A. Sheikh, Adv.
For the Respondents : Mr. N.D. Chullai, AAG with
Mr. E.R. Chyne, GA [For R 1&3]
Mr. P. Yobin, Adv. [For R 2]
i)
Whether approved for
reporting in Law journals etc.:
Yes/No
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
JUDGMENT
(Made by Hon’ble, the Chief Justice)
This appeal has been preferred against the judgment and order
dated 08.03.2024, passed by the learned Single Judge in WP(C) No. 317
of 2021, by which the request of the employees for payment of interest
on the delay of payment of gratuity, was negative.
2. It is the case of the Employees/Appellants herein that they
had approached the Controlling Authority under the Payment of
Gratuity Act, 1972 [in short ‘the PG Act’] and after hearing the parties,
2024:MLHC:741-DB
the Controlling Authority ordered gratuity payable to the employees.
Aggrieved by the said order, the employer preferred a review before the
Controlling Authority without filing an appeal and the review was
ordered.
3. In terms of Section 7(7) of the PG Act, the employer should
have preferred an appeal. Unfortunately, the Controlling Authority has
allowed the review and deprived gratuity to the employees. Since the
order was blatantly illegal, the employees have approached this Court
by way of WP(C) [SH] No. 154 of 2012 challenging the order of the
Controlling Authority in reviewing the order-in-original dated
30.07.2010. The writ petition was allowed and the employer was
directed to pay gratuity. The employer was unsuccessful in the intracourt appeal and the matter went up to the Supreme Court. Before the
Supreme Court, the employer had agreed to pay gratuity and the same
was recorded in the order dated 02.04.2018 in SLP (Civil) Diary
No.35923/2017, which is extracted hereinunder:
“Delay in filing the Special Leave Petition is condoned.
Mr. Vijay Hansaria, learned Senior Counsel appearing for
the petitioner states that the petitioner-company shall pay the
amount of gratuity to the persons who have sought Voluntary
Retirement under the Voluntary Retirement Scheme/Golden
Handshake Scheme.
This statement is recorded.
2024:MLHC:741-DB
In respect of leave encashment, notice is issued.
Notice is accepted by Mr. Gaurav Agrawal, learned counsel
for the respondents. He may file reply within three weeks.
Rejoinder affidavit may be filed within a week thereafter.
List immediately thereafter.
The payment of leave encashment shall not be made for a
period of six weeks.
However, the amount of gratuity shall be paid to the
respondents within a period of one month from today.”
4. After the order of the Supreme Court, the employer had paid
gratuity to the employees. Since the payment of interest was not given
by the employer, the employees have demanded interest and they have
approached this Court by way of WP(C) No. 317 of 2021 which was
rejected by the learned Single Judge on the ground that there is no
satisfactory explanation on the delay in filing such petition and also on
the ground of delay and laches, holding that after receipt of money in
the year 2018, the writ petition was filed in 2021. Aggrieved by the
order dated 08.03.2024 passed by the learned Single Judge, the instant
Writ Appeal has been preferred.
5. Before going into the merits of the matter, we feel it
appropriate to extract the relevant portions of Section 7(3A) and Section
8 of the PG Act are extracted below:
2024:MLHC:741-DB
“7. Determination of the amount of gratuity:
(1) A person who is eligible for payment of gratuity under
this Act or any person authorised, in writing, to act on his
behalf shall send a written application to the employer,
within such time and in such form, as may be prescribed,
for payment of such gratuity.
(2) As soon as gratuity becomes payable, the employer
shall, whether an application referred to in sub-section (1)
has been made or not, determine the amount of gratuity
and give notice in writing to the person to whom the
gratuity is payable and also to the controlling authority
specifying the amount gratuity so determined.
(3) The employer shall arrange to pay the amount of
gratuity within thirty days from the date it becomes
payable to the person to whom the gratuity is payable.
(3A) If the amount of gratuity payable under sub-section
(3) is not paid by the employer within the period
specified in sub-section (3), the employer shall pay, from
the date on which the gratuity becomes payable to the
date on which it is paid, simple interest at such rate, not
exceeding the rate notified by the Central Government
from time to time for repayment of long term deposits, as
that Government may, by notification specify: Provided
that no such interest shall be payable if the delay in the
payment is due to the fault of the employee and the
employer has obtained permission in writing from the
controlling authority for the delayed payment on this
ground.”
“Notification under Section 7(3-A) of the Payment of
Gratuity Act: S.O. 874--In exercise of the powers
conferred by subsection (3A) of Section 7 of the Payment
of Gratuity Act, 1972 (39 of 1972), the Central
Government hereby specifies ten percent per annum at
the rate of simple interest payable or the time being by
the employer to his employees in cases where the gratuity
is not paid within the specified period. This Notification
shall come into force on the date of its publication in the
2024:MLHC:741-DB
Official Gazette (vide the Gazette of India, Extraordinary,
P.II, Section 3(i) dated 1st October, 1987 at p.2)”
“8. Recovery of gratuity:
If the amount of gratuity payable under this Act is not
paid by the employer, within the prescribed time, to the
person entitled thereto, the controlling authority shall, on
an application made to it in this behalf by the aggrieved
person, issue a certificate for that amount to the Collector,
who shall recover the same, together with compound
interest thereon at such rate as the Central Government
may, by notification, specify,] from the date of expiry of
the prescribed time, as arrears of land revenue and pay
the same to the person entitled thereto:
Provided that the controlling authority shall, before
issuing a certificate under this section, give the employer
a reasonable opportunity of showing cause against the
issue of such certificate:
Provided further that the amount of interest payable under
this section shall, in no case exceed the amount of
gratuity payable under this Act.”
“Notification under Section 8 of the Payment of
Gratuity Act:- S.O.1032(E). - In exercise of the powers
conferred by Section 8 of the Payment of Gratuity Act,
1972 (39 of 1972), the Central Government hereby
specifies 15 per cent per annum as the rate of compound
interest, recoverable by the Collector for the time being,
along with the amount of gratuity and payable to the
person entitled thereto. This notification shall come into
force on the date of its publication in the Official
Gazette.”
6. A reading of Section 7(3A) of the PG Act makes it clear that,
the employer will have to pay interest @ 10% p.a., in case the amount is
not paid within the stipulated time, namely, 30 days. The employees can
2024:MLHC:741-DB
approach the Controlling Authority for determination of the payment of
gratuity payable to them, in case of no response on the application made
by them or after getting a reply from the employer.
7. In the case on hand, the factum of payment of gratuity is
admitted, which had also attained finality. Though it has been contended
by the employer that the employees ought to have approached the
Controlling Authority for the purpose of claiming interest without
prejudice to their rights and according to the employer, there is no need
to pay any interest for the reason that the employees have already given
up their right in claiming interest.
8. We are not inclined to accept the said contention of the
employer for the simple reason that as when there is an admitted fact
with regard to payment of gratuity, there is no need to relegate the
employees to go before the Controlling Authority after a lapse of 20
years, as the gratuity was due as early as in 2004 itself.
9. Mr. P. Yobin, learned counsel for the employer/R2 herein
contended that the application for payment of gratuity had been filed
with a delay of five years and when there was no plea with regard to
payment of interest at any point of time, the claim of the employees
seeking payment of interest is not justified. Learned counsel, in support
2024:MLHC:741-DB
of his contention, has relied upon a judgement of the Madras High
Court dated 28.07.2021 made in the case of The Management of
Jaigopal Garodia Vivekananda Vidyalaya v. R. Poornachandran &
anr passed in W.P.Nos.15871 and 15872 of 2020, in which one of us
(CJ) is a party, wherein, the claim of interest was deprived.
10. Learned counsel for the employees/appellants herein
submitted that gratuity had been directed to be paid in terms of Section
7 and the entire Section is required to be read as a whole and not in
isolation and upon going by a harmonious reading, gratuity has to be
necessarily paid in accordance with the provisions of the PG Act.
11. A reading of the order dated 28.07.2021 of the Madras High
Court in the case of The Management of Jaigopal Garodia
Vivekananda Vidyalaya (supra), would reveal that the order of the
Controlling Authority was challenged and the matter has been remanded
back to the Controlling Authority and the Court has held that the
employees cannot treat the Court as a gambling place to get the benefit.
The issue of laches was considered by the Court and the matter was
remanded to the Controlling Authority in that case. However, the order
of the Madras High Court may not be applicable to the facts of the
present case, more so, in the light of the judgment of the Supreme Court
2024:MLHC:741-DB
in D.D. Tewari v. Uttar Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam Limited reported
in (2014) 8 SCC 894.
12. It is no doubt true that in case there is a delay in filing
application, claiming gratuity, interest can be deprived and in terms of
Section 7 of the PG Act, once the Controlling Authority passed an order,
the employees are entitled to gratuity along with interest. In this case,
the Controlling Authority has reviewed the order filed by the employer,
which, according to the employees, is not sustained.
13. The provisions of Rule 18(5) of the Payment of Gratuity
(Central) Rules, 1972 read as under:
“18. (5) Within 14 days of the receipt of the copy of the
Memorandum of appeal, the opposite party shall submit his
comments of each paragraph of the Memorandum with additional
pleas, if any, to the appellate authority with a copy to the
appellant.”
14. The parties are entitled to raise additional pleas before the
Appellate Authority. In this case, admittedly, both parties have not
approached the Appellate Authority either aggrieved by the original
order of the Controlling Authority or against the order of review and
strangely, the employees have directly invoked Article 226 of the
Constitution of India by filing a petition before this Court. If the
contention of the employer is accepted that the matter may be remanded
2024:MLHC:741-DB
back to the Controlling/Appellate Authority to decide the issue of
payment of interest, it will not serve any purpose for the reason that it
would amount to multiplicity of proceedings one by one before the
Controlling Authority, Appellate Authority, High Court and thereafter
Supreme Court. Ultimately, the employer, after conclusion of
proceedings before all the Forums, will be forced to deposit the interest
amount only in the coffins of the employees and not into the accounts of
the employees, which is not the intent of the welfare legislation.
15. The Apex Court in its judgment reported in (1999) 4 SCC
450 held that when the facts are not in dispute, relegating to an alternate
remedy is not required. Payment of gratuity to the employees is a duty
cast upon the employer provided the Act is applicable. In this case, the
Act is applicable to the employees, which is not disputed by the
employer too. The statutory interest payable automatically follows in
the absence of payment of gratuity by the employer to the employees
within the stipulated time. Gratuity is not a gratis or a bounty, and it has
to be paid to the employees for the services rendered by them in case
they complete more than five years of continuous service in terms of the
PG Act.
2024:MLHC:741-DB
16. In terms of Section 7 (3A), the interest on payment of
gratuity is 10% per annum from the date it become due till it is actually
paid. Section 8 of the PG Act deals with inquiry proceedings and the
rate of interest payment under the said Section is 15%. A combined
reading of Sections 7 and 8 discloses that the maximum interest on
gratuity payable shall not exceed the principal gratuity amount.
17. In this case, by way of filing writ petition, the employees
have sought for payment of interest and in any event, the rate of interest
payable under Section 7 (3A) or under Section 8, shall not be over and
above the principal amount of gratuity as stated supra. The employees
have been deprived gratuity in the year 2004 after they were made to
leave the respondents under the Golden Handshake Scheme and their
retiral benefits were paid only after 15 years in the year 2018.
18. It is pertinent to mention here that the demand of gratuity
together with interest is a statutory right, which cannot be deprived to
employees. The interest shall be payable along with the principal, in
case of delay by the employer as mentioned earlier. In this case, as there
is a delay in payment of gratuity, the employees are entitled to the rate
of interest as applicable in terms of Section 7 (3A), more so, second
proviso to Section 8 of the PG Act. In terms of Section 14 of the PG
2024:MLHC:741-DB
Act, payment of gratuity along with interest cannot be taken away by
means of an agreement or instrument. It is no doubt true in the present
case on hand, the employees have not demanded interest either before
the Single Judge or up to the Supreme Court. Of course, the Supreme
Court ordered payment of gratuity. Since the Supreme Court had not
asserted about the interest on payment of gratuity, the employees cannot
be deprived in agitating the relief for interest, as the question of
acquiescence may not be applicable, when there is a statutory duty cast
upon the employer to pay the amount.
19. The Constitution Bench in a decision reported in (2002) 2
SCC 244: Jaipur Zila Sahakari Bhoomi Vikas Bank Ltd. vs. Ram
Gopal Sharma, at paragraph 13 held that no provision in the enactment
can be made redundant and each provision is meant for a specific
purpose. For ready reference, paragraph 13 is extracted below:
“13. … It is well-settled rule of interpretation that no part of
statute shall be construed as unnecessary or superfluous. The
proviso cannot be diluted or disobeyed by an employer. He
cannot disobey the mandatory provision … The interpretation of
statute must be such that it should advance the legislative intent
and serve the purpose for which it is made rather than to
frustrate it. …”
20. If the employees are deprived of gratuity, it runs counter to
the Constitution judgment and the Legislation itself. Of course, for the
2024:MLHC:741-DB
delay in claiming interest, more so after receiving the amount in 2018
and agitating the claim in 2021, we are of the view that the employees
will have to be deprived interest to some extent, but not in its entirety.
Otherwise, after the period of destruction of records by the employer,
who has to maintain records for a particular period, the employees may
approach the Authority for redressal. He/she may not have worked or
worked for a required number of days, it would be difficult for the
employer to prove his case. Taking note of the judgment of the Supreme
Court in Krishna District Co-operative Marketing Society Limited,
Vijayawada v. N.V. Purnachandra Rao & ors reported in (1987) 4 SCC
99, there shall be an amendment to PG Act prescribing the maximum
time limit for claiming interest on gratuity. For the sake of convenience,
the relevant passage of the said judgment is extracted hereunder:
“11. We may incidentally observe that the Central Act itself
should be suitably amended making it possible for an individual
workman to seek redress in an appropriate forum regarding
illegal termination of service which may take the form of
dismissal, discharge, retrenchment etc. or modification of
punishment imposed in a domestic enquiry. An amendment of
the Central Act introducing such provisions will make the law
simpler and also will reduce the delay in the adjudication of
industrial disputes. Many learned authors of books on industrial
law have also been urging for such an amendment. The State Act
in the instant case has to some extent met the above demand by
2024:MLHC:741-DB
enacting section 41 providing for a machinery for settling
disputes arising out of termination of service which can be
resorted to by an individual workman. In this connection we
have one more suggestion to make. The nation remembers
with gratitude the services rendered by the former Labour
Appellate Tribunal which was manned by some of our eminent
Judges by evolving great legal principles in the field of labour
law, in particular with regard to domestic enquiry, bonus,
gratuity, fair wages, industrial adjudication etc. The Industrial
Disputes (Appellate Tribunal) Act, 1950 which provided for an
all-India appellate body with powers to hear appeals against the
orders and awards of Industrial Tribunals and Labour Courts in
India was repealed in haste. If it had continued by now the
labour jurisprudence would have developed perhaps on much
more satisfactory lines than what it is today. There is a great
need today to revive and to bring into existence an all- India
Labour Appellate Tribunal with powers to hear appeals against
the decisions of all Labour Courts, Industrial Tribunals and even
of authorities constituted under several labour laws enacted by
the States so that a body of uniform and sound principles of
Labour law may be evolved for the benefit of both industry and
labour throughout India. Such an appellate authority can become
a very efficient body on account of specialisation. There is a
demand for the revival of such an appellate body even from
some workers’ organisations. This suggestion is worth
considering. All this we are saying because we sincerely feel
that the Central Act passed forty years ago needs a second look
and requires a comprehensive amendment.”
21. The Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 did not have a specific
time limit for the workman to question the non-employment. Section 2A
of the Act of 1947 was amended on 15.10.2010 prescribing the
2024:MLHC:741-DB
maximum time limit of three years. As held by the Supreme Court, we
are making only the suggestion and not giving any directions that there
should be an amendment.
22. Hence, this Court is of the view that instead of paying
interest at the rate of 10% per annum or 15% per annum in terms of the
second proviso to Section 8, we restrict the rate of interest to 6% per
annum, which means the employees will be entitled to 6% of interest on
the principal amount payable by the employer to them.
23. The Apex Court, in a decision reported in (1993) 3 SCC
214: Central Cooperative Consumers’ Store Ltd. vs. Labour Court,
categorically held that the employer will have to pay the amount
initially and thereafter can recover the amount from the officers, who
are responsible for non-payment of gratuity with interest and the
observation reads as follows:
“5. Public money has been wasted due to adamant behavior not
only of the officer who terminated the services but also due to
cantankerous attitude adopted by those responsible for pursuing
the litigation before one or the other authority. They have
literally persecuted her. Despite unequal strength the oppositeparty has managed to survive. We are informed that the
opposite-party has been reinstated. This was put forward as bona
fide conduct of petitioner to persuade us to modify the order in
respect of back wages. Facts speak otherwise. Working life or
opposite-party has been lost in this tortious painful litigation of
more than twenty years. That for such thoughtless acts of its
2024:MLHC:741-DB
officers the petitioner-society has to suffer and pay an amount
exceeding three lakhs is indeed pitiable. But considering the
agony and suffering of the opposite-party that amount cannot be
a proper recompense. We, therefore, dismiss this petition as
devoid of any merit and direct the petitioner to comply with the
directions of the High Court within the time granted by it. We
however leave it open to the society to replenish itself and
recover the amount of back wages paid by it to the oppositeparty from the personal salary of the officers of the society who
have been responsible for this endless litigation including the
officer who was responsible for terminating the services of the
opposite-party. We may clarify that the permission given shall
have nothing to do with the direction to pay the respondent her
back wages. Step if any to recover the amount shall be taken
only after payment is made to the opposite-party as directed by
the High Court.”
24. Admittedly, in the present case, there is a delay in claiming
interest and there was no plea seeking interest in the earlier round of
litigation. As stated earlier, gratuity is not a gratis or bounty, but a duty
cast upon the employer to pay the same to the employees. The monetary
value of 2004 has drastically come down in 2024. Hence, we are of the
view that in the present set of facts, the interest on gratuity at the rate of
6% per annum on the entire principal amount shall be paid to the
employees by the employer within a period of four months from the
date of receipt of a copy of this judgment. It is made clear that if the
amount is not paid within the time stipulated supra, the respondents
shall at first pay the interest amount and thereafter, recover the interest
2024:MLHC:741-DB
portion (that was paid beyond the specified time supra) from the officers
concerned, who are responsible to comply with the orders of this Court
in respect of disbursement of amount in time.
25. Accordingly, with the above observations and directions, WA
No. 48 of 2024 is disposed of.
(B. Bhattacharjee)
Judge
(S. Vaidyanathan)
Chief Justice
PRE-DELIVERY JUDGMENT IN
WA No.48 of 2024
LIZ KHARBHIH
Date: 2024.08.16 17:50:17 IST
Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review