Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Digitally signed
LAIRENM by
LAIRENMAYUM
AYUM INDRAJEET
INDRAJE SINGH
Date:
ET SINGH 2026.06.18
14:19:11 +05'30'
REPORTABLE
Sl. No.16
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
CRP(CRP.Art.227) No.29 of 2024
1. Thokchom Ongbi Nungshi Devi, aged about 70 years W/O
(L) Th. Ibopishak Singh, a resident of Singjamei Thongam
Leikai, P.O. & P.S. Singjamei, District Imphal West,
Manipur
2. Thokchom Ongbi Memma Devi, aged about 70 years W/O
(L) Th. Nabachandra Singh, a resident of Singjamei
Thongam Leikai, P.O. & P.S. Singjamei, District Imphal
West, Manipur.
…..Petitioners
Versus
Thokchom Ningol Ibempishak Devi D/o Late. Th. Mani
Singh, a resident of Singjamei Thongam Leikai, P.O. &
P.S. Singjamei, Imphal West District, Manipur at present
deceased and represented by her LRs, namely
i)
Moirangthem Dhamendra Singh, aged about 53
yrs. S/o
Late,
Ibempishak
M. Debendra
Devi,
at
Singjamei Thongam
present
Singh
and
residing
at
Leikai, P.O.
& P.S.
Singjamei under Imphal West District of
Manipur.
ii)
Moirangthem Jitendra Singh, aged about 48
years S/o Late, M. Debendra Singh and
Ibempishak
Devi,
at
present
residing
at
Singjamei Thongam
Leikai, P.O.
& P.S.
Singjamei under Imphal West District of
Manipur.
iii)
Moirangthem Ningol Shanti Devi, aged about 51
yrs. D/o
Late, M. Debendra Singh and
Ibempishak Devi W/o Ningthoujam Manisana
Singh, at present residing at Langjing Achouba
Purkhri Mapal, P.O. Langjing & P.S. Patsoi
under Imphal West District of Manipur.
iv)
Sanasam Kananbala Devi, aged about 62 yrs.
D/o Late, S. Biramangol Singh and Ibempishak
Devi W/o Late, Sanasam Jotin @ Bibi Singh, at
present residing at Singjamei Sanasam Leikai,
P.O. & P.S. Singjamei under Imphal West
District Manipur.
…...Respondents
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M. SUNDAR
For revision petitioners
Mr. L. Okendro Singh, Advocate along with
Ms. Merina Thokchom, Advocate.
For respondents
Mr. L.N. Ngamba, Advocate along with Mr.
A. Phulchand Sharma, Advocate.
Date of Judgment & Order
15.06.2026
JUDGEMENT & ORDER
(Oral)
[1]
The following abbreviations/short forms have been used in
this order (for the sake of brevity, convenience and clarity):
Sl.
No.
Abbreviation/Short
Form/other short
references
Full Form/Expansion
1.
CRP
Civil Revision Petition
said Trial Court
Court of Civil Judge (Senior
Division), Imphal West, Manipur
3.
CoD
Condonation of Delay
4.
impugned order
Order dated 05.12.2023 made by
said Trial Court in Judl. Misc. Case
No. 571 of 2022 (Ref: Original Suit
No. 84 of 2015)
5.
Judl. M.C.
Judicial Miscellaneous Case
6.
O.S.
Original Suit
7.
D1
first
defendant
(similar
abbreviation/s are used for other
defendants also with a numeric
change alone,
‘second defendant’ is referred to
as ‘D2’,
‘third defendant’ is referred to as
‘D3’ so on and so forth)
8.
LR
Legal Representative
9.
LRs
Legal Representatives
10.
said suit
O.S. No. 84 of 2015
11.
CPC
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908
12.
Limitation Act
The Limitation Act, 1963 (36 of
1963)
[2]
Captioned CRP has been presented in this Court on
12.08.2024 assailing the impugned order.
[3]
Judl. M.C. No. 571 of 2022 was filed in said Trial Court by
wife of deceased D1 & D2 under Section 5 of Limitation Act read with
Section 151 of CPC with a CoD prayer qua 523(five hundred twenty three)
days delay in filing an application to set aside an ex-parte decree dated
25.02.2019 made in said suit (O.S. No. 84 of 2015). This CoD application
was dismissed in and vide impugned order made by said Trial Court.
Aggrieved, ‘wife of D1 as LR and D2’ (‘collectively revision petitioners’ for
the sake of convenience) have presented the captioned CRP in this Court.
Owing to the limited legal perimeter of captioned CRP, it will suffice to write
that O.S. No. 84 of 2015 (said suit) was filed in said Trial Court by one Mrs.
Thokchom Ningol Ibempishak Devi as lone plaintiff inter alia with prayers to
declare proceedings in a mutation case as null and void, for a decree
declaring that plaintiff is absolute owner of suit properties and injunction. To
be noted, lone plaintiff is no more and her 4(four) legal heirs have stepped
into her shoes and they are respondents before this Court.
[4]
In the hearing today, Mr. L. Okendro Singh along with Ms.
Merina Thokchom, learned counsel on record for revision petitioners and Mr.
L.N. Ngamba, learned counsel along with Mr. A. Phulchand Sharma, learned
counsel on record for respondents are before this Court.
[5]
Main CRP was taken up with the consent of both sides and
learned counsel on both sides were heard out in full.
[6]
The afore-referred said suit when filed in said Trial Court had
8(eight) defendants in all. As regards D1, he died pending suit, LR was
brought on record and as already alluded to supra, wife of D1 is revision
petitioner No.1 in captioned CRP.
[7]
Suffice to write that said suit is a legal tussle primarily between
half siblings for the estate of one Mr. Thokchom Mani Singh who had two
wives viz., Th. (O) Ruhini Devi and Th.(O) Ibeton Devi. It is not necessary to
dilate further on facts as captioned CRP arises out of an order in a CoD
application. Post service of suit summons, D1 to D4 & D6 entered appearance
through counsel and filed a common/joint written statement dated 16.02.2016.
Thereafter, the counsel for these defendants had filed a determination
application on 18.08.2018 (Judl. M.C. No.565 of 2018). This determination
application dated 18.08.2018 was dismissed for default on 16.11.2018 without
notice to D1 to D4 & D6. To be noted, there is nothing on record to
demonstrate that notice in this determination application was served on D1 to
D4 & D6. Ultimately, said suit was decreed ex-parte on 25.02.2019.
Thereafter, the lone plaintiff filed a mutation case (Execution) on 17.02.2021
and D1 to D4 as well as D6 came to know about the ex-parte decree only on
26.08.2022 when the revenue officials, pursuant to mutation case, went over
to the suit properties for demarcation. In the CoD application (Judl. M.C.
No.571 2022), there is a specific averment about this in sub-paragraph (iv) of
paragraph 3 and it has been averred that on the very next day i.e., 27.08.2022
D1 to D4 & D6 contacted their counsel but their counsel merely informed them
about the filing of the determination application filed on 18.08.2018.
[8]
To be noted, the plaintiff filed written objections dated
02.02.2023 in the CoD application and while responding to afore-referred subparagraph (iv) of paragraph 3, the plaintiff has merely denied the allegations
and said no determination application has been filed on 18.08.2018.
[9]
In the aforesaid backdrop, said Trial Court in and vide the
impugned order has dismissed the CoD application without going into the
question as to whether D1 to D4 & D6 were put on notice in the determination
application and wandering into Covid period (across the Board) extention of
limitation period. Aggrieved, wife of D1 (LR) and D2 are before this Court.
[10]
This Court now embarks upon setting out discussions and
dispositive reasons.
[11]
As already alluded to supra, the legal perimeter of captioned
CRP is very limited.
[12]
This Article 227 Court deems it appropriate to first deal with the
determination application point (first point). At the outset, the contention of
the plaintiff that no determination application was filed on 18.08.2018 cannot
be countenanced and this argument is a non-starter. The reason is, the
impugned order clearly mentions about determination application in
paragraph 10 and paragraph 10 of the impugned order reads as follows:
’10. On perusal of the record of Original suit, it is seen that the
application
made
by
previous
learned
counsel
for
defendant/petitioner was not allowed and hence the reason
submitted by learned counsel that the petitioners did not know
about the ex-parte Judgement because no summons was served
on the petitioners regarding the application made by the previous
counsel of defendant for determination cannot be accepted as
sufficient ground.’
[13]
A careful perusal of paragraph 10 of the impugned order brings
to light that the said Trial Court has not gone into the question raised by D1
to D4 & D6, i.e., the question that they never received notice in the
determination application. In paragraph 10 of the impugned order, said trial
court has merely said that determination application had not been allowed.
This Court ferreted out the details of the determination application (Judl. M.C.
No. 565 of 2018) from E-Courts website of District Courts and scanned
reproduction of e-Court website (as downloaded) is as follows:
Therefore, the basis on which said Trial Court has proceeded
i.e., that the determination application was not allowed is incorrect. In any
event, there is no contra material to demonstrate that D1 to D4 & D6 were put
on notice in the determination application. Therefore, the sequitur is, D1 to D4
& D6 are entitled to contend that they were under the bonafide belief that their
counsel was taking care of their interests and attending to the hearings.
[14]
This takes this Court to the next point (second point) which turns
on Covid period exclusion vide judicial order of Hon’ble Supreme Court dated
10.01.2022 in In Re: cognizance for extension of limitation in Writ
Petition(C) No. 3 of 2020. This point is being gone into as it has been
adverted to in the impugned order but it otherwise has no significance in the
case at hand as the ex-parte decree was made on 25.02.2019 before
15.03.2020 and
the date of knowledge is 26.08.2022 which is after
28.02.2022 as well as 29.05.2022 which is 90(ninety) days post 28.02.2022.
This is extremely relevant as there is no contra material with regard to date of
knowledge particularly when the plaintiff submits that ex-parte decree was set
into motion only on 17.02.2021.
[15]
The third and the last point is a legal issue raised by learned
counsel for respondents. Learned counsel for respondents submitted that
CPC provides for an appeal as against the impugned order and therefore,
CRP under Article 227 ought not to have been filed. It is the specific contention
of the learned counsel for respondents that CPC provides for an appeal
against the impugned order vide Order XLIII Rule 1(d). In the considered view
of this Court, this is plainly incorrect as Order XLIII Rule 1(d) talks about an
order in an application under Order IX Rule 13 CPC (for setting aside ex-parte
decree) and it does not deal with CoD applications/orders.
[16]
Be that as it may, learned counsel for respondents pressed into
service two case laws. The first case law is Virudhunagar Hindu Nadargal
Dharma Paribalana Sabai & ors. v. Tuticorin Educational Society & ors.
case reported in (2019) 9 SCC 538. To be noted, download from Indian
Kanoon was placed before this Court. In Virudhunagar Hindu Nadargal
case, the factual matrix is that a suit seeking declaration that a notice
convening a General Body meeting is illegal and a permanent injunction was
filed (to be noted, there are other limbs of prayers), along with the suit, an
interlocutory application under Order XXXIX Rules 1 & 2, injunction was taken
out and injunction was granted by Trial Court. As against this injunction order,
D5 in that suit who was third respondent before the Hon’ble Supreme Court
filed a regular appeal under Order XLIII Rule 1(r) of CPC but another
respondent, instead of filing a regular appeal, filed a CRP under Article 227 in
the Madurai Bench of the Madras High Court, the High Court interfered and
set-aside the order of injunction. It is in this backdrop that Hon’ble Supreme
Court made it clear that there is a clear distinction between cases in which
alternative remedy is available under CPC and cases in which alternative
remedy is available under special enactments and it was made clear that
while the former should be construed as near total bar, the latter is clearly a
rule of discretion and is in the realm of self-imposed restriction. In this view of
the matter, it will suffice to write that Virudhunagar Hindu Nadargal case
does not come to the aid of the respondents for two reasons. One reason is,
it is distinguishable on facts as it arose out of an injunction application under
Order XXXIX Rules 1 & 2. The second reason is, Virudhunagar Hindu
Nadargal case is an authority for the proposition that while alternative remedy
qua appeal provision in CPC should be construed as near total bar, alternate
remedy provided under other enactments/special statutes is not an absolute
Rule qua 227 jurisdiction and it is only a rule of discretion which is in the realm
of a self-imposed restriction.
[17]
As regards the second case law, it is Mohamed Ali v. Jaya &
ors. and Indian Kanoon download has been placed before this Court. This is
an order dated 11.07.2022 made by Hon’ble Supreme Court in Civil Appeal
No. 4114 of 2022. Factual matrix in Mohamed Ali is that plaintiff filed a suit
for specific performance qua an agreement to sell pertaining to immovable
property. This specific performance suit was decreed ex-parte by the Trial
Court on 31.10.2012 and as against this ex-parte decree, while one set of
defendants viz., D2 to D4 filed an application to set-aside the decree with an
application for condonation of 2345 days delay, D1 filed a separate application
seeking condonation of 1522 days in filing an application to set-aside the exparte decree. Both the CoD applications were dismissed and while D1 did not
challenge the CoD dismissal order, D2 to D4 assailed the same by way of a
revision under Article 227 but in this revision, the High Court set-aside the
specific performance decree by going into the merits of the matter and
observing that the specific performance decree has been made by the Trial
Court without application of mind (total non-application of mind) and opined
that the Trial Court has not considered the aspect of readiness and willingness
on the part of the plaintiff. It is in this factual matrix that Hon’ble Supreme
Court set-aside the order of the High Court inter alia following Virudhunagar
Hindu Nadargal principle and holding that when there is a specific provision
for appeal vide Section 104(1)(i) read with Order XLIII, Rule 1(r) of CPC, High
Court should not have set-aside the decree for specific performance by going
into merits. In this regard, a very interesting scenario unfurls in the instant
case. The application (Judl. M.C.) for setting aside the ex-parte decree dated
25.02.2019 has been filed with the CoD application seeking condonation of
523 days delay as already alluded to supra. The CoD application has been
numbered as Judl. M.C. No. 571 of 2022 and the impugned order has been
made in the same. Simultaneously, the application for setting-aside the exparte decree has also been numbered and it has been assigned the
sequential/next number i.e., Judl. M.C. No. 572 of 2022. This, in the
considered view of this Court, is plainly incorrect. The procedure is plainly
incorrect. To be noted, before proceeding further it is deemed appropriate to
write that under Article 227, exercising power of superintendence, a High
Court can interfere even when a wrong procedure is adopted by the Trial
Court. It is in this context that this Court deems it appropriate to write that
processing and assigning a number to the Order IX Rule 13 application to set
aside ex-parte decree will arise only on the delay being condoned and
therefore, pending CoD, the Order IX Rule 13 application ought not have been
processed and assigned a number. In any event, in the case at hand, the
impugned order has not been made in Judl. M.C. No. 572 of 2022 (Order IX
Rule 13 application) but the impugned order has been made in Judl. M.C. No.
571 of 2022 (CoD application). Therefore, Mohamed Ali also does not come
to the aid of the respondents. To be noted, this Court is not going into Judl.
M.C. No. 572 of 2022 and it restricts the instant legal drill to impugned order
in Judl. M.C. No. 571 of 2022.
[18]
Though not brought to the notice of this Court by both sides,
this Court ferreted out from the e-Court website the fate of Order IX Rule 13
application i.e., Judl. M.C. No. 572 of 2022. It is seen that Judl. M.C. No. 572
of 2022 has been disposed of as having become infructuous (in website it has
been typed as ‘infectious’ which is obviously a typographical error) owing to
the order made in Judl. M.C. No. 571 of 2022 and this disposal is on
05.12.2023. It is for the revision petitioners to work out remedies either in
accordance with CPC inter alia vide Order XLIII Rule 1(d) (against this
05.12.2023 order) if so advised and so desired or seek review. It is made
clear that if the revision petitioners assail or seek review of 05.12.2023 order
in Judl. M.C. No. 572 of 2022, the same shall be dealt with on its own merits
and in accordance with law by the appellate Court/Court concerned de hors
any observation in this order i.e., untrammeled by observations in this order
except the operative portion (to be set out infra) wherein this Court will be
setting aside the impugned order. This 227 Court, for the sake of specificity,
deems it appropriate to clarify that when this 05.12.2023 order in Judl. M.C.
No. 572 of 2022 is assailed, the disposal order will go as in and vide
05.12.2023 order Judl. M.C. No. 572 of 2022 has been disposed of as having
become infructuous owing to impugned order but this does not mean that
Judl. M.C. No. 572 of 2022 will either stand allowed or dismissed. This will
mean that Judl. M.C. No. 572 of 2022 which is an application under Order IX
Rule 13 CPC has to be heard out afresh on its own merits and in accordance
with law so that said Trial Court can decide whether the afore-referred exparte decree is to be set-aside so that the suit goes for trial/contest or it is
also open to the said Trial Court to dismiss the Order IX Rule 13 application
if the same is warranted on merits. To put it differently, all questions in the
Order IX Rule 13 application are left open for said Trial Court to decide the
same on its own merits and in accordance with law. In this regard, this Court
deems it appropriate to set out a scanned reproduction of order dated
05.12.2023 in Judl. M.C. No. 572 of 2022:
In this regard, it is also made clear that all rights and contentions
of plaintiff are preserved for resisting/opposing challenge/review qua Order
IX Rule 13 order. The ex-parte decree dated 25.02.2019 in O.S. No. 84 of
2015 on the file of said Trial Court will continue to operate and that will be
subject to Order IX Rule 13 application order appeal/review against which
was disposed of on 05.12.2023.
[19]
In the light of the discussions and dispositive reasoning set out
thus far, it is clear that there was a determination application filed by counsel
for D1 to D4 & D6(Judl. M.C. No. 565 of 2018) and that the same came to be
disposed of on 16.11.2018 (dismissed for default). Therefore, the basis of the
impugned order i.e., that determination application was not allowed without
going into the question of whether D1 to D4 & D6 were put on notice is clearly
erroneous. As already alluded to supra there is no contra material to
demonstrate that date of knowledge of D1 to D4 & D6 is only 26.08.2022
when the revenue officials went over to the suit property for demarcation
pursuant to plaintiff launching the ex-parte decree by resorting to mutation.
This means that the delay sought to be condoned i.e., 523 days has been
adequately and sufficiently explained by the protagonists of the CoD
application i.e., revision petitioners before this Court.
[20]
Ergo, the sequitur is, impugned order being Order dated
05.12.2023 made in Judl. M.C. No. 571 of 2022 in O.S. No. 84 of 2015 is setaside/captioned CRP is allowed albeit with preservation of rights and
contentions in the aforesaid manner and with observations as set out supra.
There shall be no order as to costs.
CHIEF JUSTICE
Indrajeet / John Kom
FR/NFR
P.S. I : Upload forthwith.
P.S. II : All concerned will stand bound by web copy uploaded in High Court website
inter-alia as the same is QR coded.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review