Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
reportable
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WA No. 46 of 2021 with
MC(WA) No. 77 of 2021
1. Dr. Thokchom Chhatrajit Singh, aged about 33 years, S/o
Thokchom Tomba Singh, resident of Kwakeithel Thokchom
Leikai, P.O. & P.S. Imphal and District Imphal West, Manipur795001.
2. Dr. Rajkumar Kamaljit Singh, aged about 38 years, S/o Dr.
Rajkumar Ranjit Singh, resident of Yaiskul Chingakham Leikai,
P.O. & P.S. Imphal and District Imphal west, Manipur-795001.
3. Loukrakpam
Merin Singh,
aged
about
years,
S/o
Loukrakpam Brojendro Singh, resident of Chingamakha
Chongtham Leikai, Singjamei, P.O. & P.S. Singjamei and
District Imphal West, Manipur-795001.
4. Dr. Biraj Shougaijam Rajen Singh resident of Thangmeiband
Kabrabam Leikai, P.O. & P.S. Lamphel and District Imphal
West, Manipur-795001.
5. Anand Jyoti Sanasam, aged about 30 years, S/o Sanasam
Iboyaima Singh, resident of Thoubal Sabaltongba Awang
Leikai, Thoubal, P.O. & P.S. Thoubal and District Thoubal,
Manipur-795138.
6. Pinky Khundrakpam, aged about 32 years, D/o Khundrakpam
Yaima Singh, resident of Sagolband Meino Leirak, P.O. & P.S.
Imphal West and District Imphal West, Manipur-795001.
7. Rosy Kimneithem Haokip, aged about 29 years, D/o
Zamkhokhai Haokip, resident of Spring Village Phaipijang
Spring Villa Langol Housing Complex, P.O. & P.S. Lamphel and
District Imphal West, Manipur-795004.
WA No. 46 of 2021 with
MC(WA) No. 77 of 2021
Page 1
8. Dr. Ningombam Swapana, aged about 42 years, D/o
Ningombam Jitendra Singh, resident of Yaiskul Janmasthan,
P.O. & P.S. Imphal and District Imphal West, Manipur-795001.
9. Thingbaijam Rajkumari Chanu, aged about 32 years, D/o
Thingbaijam Khelemani Khuman, resident of Khabeisoi Sabal
Leikai, P.O. Lamlong, P.S. Porompat and District Imphal East,
Manipur-795010.
…... Appellant/s
In Writ appeal
- Versus 1. Lourembam Iboyaima Singh, aged about 42 years, S/o L.
Ibotombi Singh, resident of Keishamthong Ahanthem Leikai,
P.O.
& P.S. Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur-795001,
Qualification Ph.D. in Linguistic now serving as Asst. Professor
in Manipur Technical University, Takyelpat.
2. Laishram Jimmy, aged about 37 years, S/o Brajendro Singh,
resident of Keishamthong Maning Longjam Leikai, P.O. & P.S.
Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur-795001, Qualification – M.
Tech in Computer Science & Engineering now functioning as
Asstt. Professor in Computer Science & Engineering.
3. Tayenjam Jeneeta, aged about 29 years, D/o T. Rameshwor
Singh, resident of Uripok Khaidem Leikai, P.O. & P.S. Imphal,
Imphal West District, Manipur-795001, Qualification M.Tech in
Engineering – now functioning as Asstt. Professor and H.O.D.
Electrical Engineering Dept.
4. Kosygin Leishangthem, aged about 39 years, S/o raghu
Leishangthem, resident of Thangmeiband Meisnam Leikai, P.O.
& P.S. Lamphel, Imphal West District, Manipur-795001,
Qualification – M. Tech in Earthquake Engineering now
functioning as Asstt. Professor & H.O.D. of Civil Engineering.
5. Asem Nabadavis, aged about 29 years, S/o Dr. Asem
Nabachandra Singh, resident of Khekman Makha Leikai, P.O. &
WA No. 46 of 2021 with
MC(WA) No. 77 of 2021
Page 2
P.S. Thoubal, Thoubal District, Manipur-795138, Qualification –
M.E. in Mechanical Engineering now functioning as Asstt.
Professor & H.O.D. of Department of Mechanical Engineering.
Contesting Respondent/s
in Writ Appeal [Writ Petitioners]
6. The State of Manipur, represented by the Commissioner
Higher/Technical Education, Govt of Manipur, New Secretariat
Complex, Babupara, P.O. & P.S. Imphal, District Imphal West,
Manipur-795001.
7. The Vice-Chancellor, Manipur Technical University, Takyelpat,
Government Polytechnic Campus, Takyelpat, Imphal West
District, Manipur – 795004.
8. The Registrar, Manipur Technical University, Takyelpat,
Government Polytechnic Campus, Takyelpat, District Imphal
West, Manipur-795004.
.....Proforma Respondents
In Writ appeal
B E F O R E
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M. SUNDAR
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE A. GUNESHWAR SHARMA
For the Appellant/s
::
For the respondent/s
::
Date of hearing
Date of Judgment & Order
::
::
Mr. BP. Sahu, Sr. Adv., with Mr. Anjan
Prasad Sahu, Adv.
Mr. A. Romenkumar, Sr. Adv., with
Mr. RK. Banna, Adv., R1-R5.
Mr. Kh. Athouba, G.A,
Mr. Phungyo Zingkhei, Dy. G.A., R6.
Mr. RK. Deepak, Sr. Adv., with
Mr. L. Rajesh, Adv., R7-R8.
11.11.2025 & 12.11.2025
20.11.2025
JUDGMENT & ORDER (CAV)
A. Guneshwar Sharma, J.
[1]
The present third-party appeal has been preferred by 9 (nine)
appellants herein questioning the correctness of the impugned judgment and
WA No. 46 of 2021 with
MC(WA) No. 77 of 2021
Page 3
order dated 20.09.2018 passed by the Ld. Single Bench of this Court in WP(C)
No. 519 of 2018. The writ petition filed by respondent Nos. 1 to 5 herein, was
allowed by setting aside the notification dated 23.05.2018 issued by the
Registrar, Manipur Technical University (hereinafter referred to as ‘MTU’) for
recruitment of teaching and non-teaching staff of the university on regular
basis with respect to the 5 (five) writ petitioners and further, with a direction to
the university to provide regular appointment to the respondent Nos. 1 to 5
herein (writ petitioners) from the date of their initial appointments as Assistant
Professors in MTU on contract basis. Since the appellants herein were not
parties in the writ petition being WP(C) No. 519 of 2018, they approached the
Division Bench of this Court challenging the impugned order dated 20.09.2018
with leave to appeal and application for condonation of delay in filing the thirdparty appeal. The application for condonation of delay in filing the writ appeal,
i.e., MC[WA] No. 36 of 2021 was condoned vide order dated 09.09.2021 and
the leave to appeal was granted vide order dated 06.05.2024 in MC[WA] No.
76 of 2021. No effective order has been passed in the application for stay, i.e.,
MC[WA] No. 77 of 2021.
[2]
Heard Mr. BP. Sahu, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr.
Anjan Prasad Sahu, learned counsel for third-party writ appellants; Mr. A.
Romenkumar, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. RK. Banna, learned
counsel appearing on behalf of respondent Nos. 1 to 5 (writ petitioners); Mr.
Kh. Athouba, learned senior counsel & Govt. Advocate assisted by Mr.
Phungyo Zingkhei, learned Dy. G.A. on behalf of the State respondent No. 6
and Dr. RK. Deepak, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. L. Rajesh,
learned counsel on behalf of respondent Nos. 7 & 8 (MTU).
[3]
The brief fact of the present case is that Manipur Technical
University (MTU) was established pursuant to an ordinance ‘The Manipur
Technical University Ordinance, 2016’ promulgated vide notification dated
23.04.2016 issued by the Governor of Manipur. Later on, the Manipur
Technical University Act, 2016 was passed by the State Assembly and got
assent from the Governor of Manipur on 21.10.2016 and notified in the official
gazette making the date of enforcement retrospectively with effect from
23.04.2016 (the day on which the Ordinance was promulgated). In order to
WA No. 46 of 2021 with
MC(WA) No. 77 of 2021
Page 4
make the university functional at its initial stage, the Registrar of University
issued notification for engagement/appointment of Assistant/Associate
Professors on contract basis vide various notifications dated 20.06.2016,
12.07.2016
and
23.07.2016
for
the
Civil
Engineering,
Mechanical
Engineering, Electrical Engineering, Computer Science Engineering and
Humanities (Communication). In these notifications, posts of Associate
Professor for Physics, Chemistry and Mathematics were also included. The
mode of examination is to be done by way of interview. Vide notification dated
06.07.2016, the Selection Committee recommended Lourembam Iboyaima
Singh (respondent No. 1 herein) as Assistant Professor in Professional
Communication (English); Laishram Jimmy (respondent No. 2) as Assistant
Professor in Computer Science & Engineering. Vide another notification dated
15.07.2016, the Selection Committee recommended four candidates for
various subjects including Kosygin Leishangthem (respondent No. 4 herein)
for the post of Assistant Professor in Civil Engineering and Asem Nabadavis
(respondent No. 5 herein) for the post of Assistant Professor in Mechanical
Engineering and vide another notification dated 29.07.2016, Tayengjam
Jeneeta Devi (respondent No. 3 herein) was recommended for the post of
Assistant Professor in Electrical Engineering. Thereafter, vide order dated
15.07.2016 issued by the Registrar, MTU, Kosygin Leishangthem (respondent
No. 4) was appointed as Assistant Professor in Civil Engineering on contract
basis in MTU for the period of six months. Vide another order dated
15.07.2016 issued by the Registrar, MTU, Asem Nabadavis (respondent No.
5) was appointed as Assistant Professor in Mechanical Engineering on
contract basis for a period of six months; vide order dated 30.07.2016 issued
by the Vice-Chancellor, MTU, Tayenjam Jeneeta (respondent No. 3) was
appointed as Assistant Professor in Electrical engineering on contract basis
for a period of six months; vide another order dated 08.08.2016 issued by the
Vice-Chancellor, MTU, Lourembam Iboyaima Singh (respondent No. 1) was
appointed as Assistant Professor in Professional Communication (English) on
contract basis; and vide another order dated 08.08.2016 issued by the ViceChancellor, MTU, Laishram Jimmy (respondent No. 2) was appointed as
Assistant Professor in Computer Science and Engineering on contract basis
WA No. 46 of 2021 with
MC(WA) No. 77 of 2021
Page 5
for a period of six months. Vide another order dated 30.12.2016 issued by the
Vice-Chancellor, MTU, the contract appointment of 8 (eight) faculty members
including the respondent Nos. 1 to 5 herein were extended for another period
of six months or till the regularization incumbents join, whichever is earlier, on
the same terms and conditions. It may be noted that vide order dated
15.06.2016, MTU created various post for teaching and non-teaching faculty
including 30 posts of Assistant Professors on regular basis.
[4]
The Registrar of MTU issued a notification dated 23.05.2018 for
recruitment of teaching and non-teaching staff for 10 (ten) categories of posts
for a total of 31 (thirty-one) posts in all. The relevant portion of the
advertisement showing the designation, number of posts, etc. are reproduced
as under:
“NOTICE FOR RECRUITMENT OF TEACHING AND NON TEACHING
STAFF
Imphal, the 23rd May 2018
No. 2/3/2016/MTU: Applications in prescribed form are invited
for recruitment of Teaching faculties and non-teaching staff on regular basis
in Manipur Technical University, Imphal:
A. TEACHING FACULTIES & ASSISTANT LIBRARIAN:
Sl.
Name of the post
Pay Scale
Assistant Professor
Rs. 15,600-
(Civil Engineering)
39,100 + 6000
Group
No.
UR
OBC
ST
SC
of
of
post
post
A
A
A
A
(AGP)
Assistant Professor
Rs. 15,600-
(Mechanical
39,100 + 6000
Engineering)
(AGP)
Assistant Professor
Rs. 15,600-
(Electronics &
39,100 + 6000
Communication
(AGP)
Engineering)
Assistant Professor
Rs. 15,600-
(Computer Science &
39,100 + 6000
Engineering)
(AGP)
WA No. 46 of 2021 with
MC(WA) No. 77 of 2021
Page 6
Assistant Professor
Rs. 15,600-
(Electrical Engineering)
39,100 + 6000
A
A
(AGP)
Assistant Professor
Rs. 15,600-
(Mathematics)
39,100 + 6000
(AGP)
Assistant Professor
Rs. 15,600-
(Physics)
39,100 + 6000
A
A
A
A
(AGP)
Assistant Professor
Rs. 15,600-
(Chemistry)
39,100 + 6000
(AGP)
Assistant Professor
Rs. 15,600-
(Professional
39,100 + 6000
Communication)
(AGP)
Assistant Librarian
Rs. 15,60039,100 + 6000
(AGP)
[5]
It is stated that the petitioners have been working in MTU since
its inception and some of them are working as Head of Department and have
been taking multiple responsibilities in various fields for advancement and
development of the standard of the university and they become backbone of
the university in all aspects. It may be noted that 18 (eighteen) Contract and
Guest Faculty Assistant Professors in MTU made a joint representation dated
22.01.2018 to the Vice-Chancellor, MTU and Registrar, MTU to regularize
their services as they had been part of the university since the very inception
and worked hard to bring the university at that stage and they were functioning
just like regular Assistant Professors. It is stated that the mode of their
appointment of Assistant Professors on contract and guest basis is similar to
the procedure for appointment of Assistant Professor on regular basis. It may
be noted that out of 18 (eighteen) signatories to the representations for
regularization, 5 (five) private respondents (writ petitioners) and appellants
Nos. 1 & 5 were signatories to the representations submitted for
regularisation. However, no decision has been made to the representation till
WA No. 46 of 2021 with
MC(WA) No. 77 of 2021
Page 7
date. In the circumstances, respondent Nos. 1 to 5 herein filed a writ petition,
being WP(C) No. 519 of 2018, before this Court with the prayer for setting
aside the notification dated 23.05.2016 issued by the MTU for appointment of
teaching and non-teaching staff on regular basis with respect to the posts held
by them on contract basis and with a direction to provide regular appointment
from the date of their initial contract appointment and treat the period of
contractual service as the probation period and with consequential relief.
Prayers (c) and (d) are reproduced as:
“(c)
(d)
[6]
to issue writ of certiorari to quash the notification dated
23.05.2018 (annexure – A/8) and to issue a writ in the
nature of mandamus to provide regular appointment order
to the petitioners from the date of their initial appointment
on contract as the contract appointment were made after
following all the procedures for Regular Appointment and
to treat the initial period of two years as probation and to
provide them with consequential benefits.
to pass an interim stay order of the operation of the
Notification dated 23.05.2018 (Annexure – A/8) and to
reserve 5 posts for the petitioners namely Assistant
Professor post of (i) professional Communications; (ii)
Computer Science & Engineering; (iii) Electrical
Engineering; (iv) Mechanical Engineering and Civil
Engineering and allow the petitioners to continue their
contract appointments till they are provided with regular
appointment order with consequential benefits as the
Hon’ble Court seemed appropriate.”
MTU filed counter affidavit to the writ petition inter-alia stating
that:
(i)
regularisation of the petitioners who work only for two
years would amount to violation of Article 309 of the
Constitution and law laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court and there is no provision or legal right to regularize
and absorb the contractual service.
(ii)
the selection of respondent Nos. 1 to 5 on contractual
service was done only by interview and not done in
consonance with the procedure for regular appointment
i.e. 50% weightage on academic record and research
performance, 30% weightage on assessment of domain
WA No. 46 of 2021 with
MC(WA) No. 77 of 2021
Page 8
knowledge and teaching skill and 20% weightage on
interview performance and the contractual engagement
was done for a short period in order to run the newly
established university at the initial stage.
(iii)
In the contract agreement, the respondent Nos. 1 to 5
have
undertaken
that
they
would
not
claim
for
regularisation.
(iv)
the respondent Nos. 1 to 5 (writ petitioners) were engaged
after facing the interview only for the purpose of contract
engagement for limited period and the criteria laid down
under the UGC regulation on minimum qualifications for
appointment of teachers under UGC regulation, 2010 was
not followed.
(v)
after issuance of the impugned notification dated
23.05.2018, a corrigendum dated 11.06.2018 was also
issued stating that UGC regulations on academic record
and research performance – 50%; assessment of domain
knowledge and teaching skill – 30% and interview
performance – 20% would be followed. The notification
was issued in pursuance to the Board of Management 2nd
meeting held on 24.01.2018.
[7]
The respondent Nos. 1 to 5 herein (writ petitioners) also filed
rejoinder affidavit to the counter affidavit filed by the MTU whereby asserting
that regularization of the writ petitioners who are contract Assistant Professors
would not violate the provisions of Article 309 of the Constitution. It is stated
that the Board of Management can frame statute and ordinance for regulating
recruitment and service conditions of the university. However, the university
can adopt the rule framed under Article 309. It is stated that AICTE regulations
stipulates 80% of the posts should be regular and 20% can be filled up on
contract basis and the appointment of the respondent Nos. 1 to 5 is within the
permissible limit of 20% as stipulated in AICTE guidelines. It is also stated that
the undertaking given by the writ petitioners (respondent Nos. 1 to 5) for
contract engagement is vitiated by undue influence as stipulated under
WA No. 46 of 2021 with
MC(WA) No. 77 of 2021
Page 9
Section 16 of the Contract Act and the doctrine of estoppel will not be
applicable against the writ petitioners due to the glaring irregularities
committed by the authority and that too in a concluded contract. The right to
claim regularization cannot be denied on the sole ground of undertaking given
at the time of contract recruitment by the employees not to claim
regularisation.
[8]
Vide a detailed judgment and order dated 20.09.2018, the Ld.
Single Judge allowed the writ petition, i.e., WP(C) No. 519 of 2018 filed by the
respondent Nos. 1 to 5 by setting aside the notification dated 23.05.2018
issued by the Registrar, MTU with respect to 5 (five) writ petitioners
(respondent Nos. 1 to 5 herein) and directed the university to provide regular
appointment to them from the date of their initial appointment. It may be noted
that there was an interim order dated 19.06.2018 passed by the Ld. Single
Judge in WP(C) No. 519 of 2018, thereby staying the notification dated
23.05.2018 with respect to the posts held by the five writ petitioners [R1 to R5
herein] and interim order was extended from time to time and the same
merged with the final judgment dated 20.09.2018. During the course of
hearing, it has been informed that respondent Nos. 1 to 5 applied for regular
appointment in terms of the notification dated 23.05.2018. However, they did
not appear in the final selection test, as they got interim order protecting their
contract service. It is also submitted during the course of hearing that the 9
(nine) writ appellants did not apply for the contract appointment in terms of the
various notification issued in the year 2016.
[9]
After pronouncement of judgment dated 20.09.2018 in WP(C)
No. 519 of 2018, the Registrar, MTU issued an order dated 17.12.2018
appointing the nine writ appellants as Assistant Professors on regular basis in
terms of the Notification dated 23.05.2018, as approved by the Board of
Management under Section 26 of Manipur Technical University Act, 2016 in
its meeting held on 15.12.2018. The order dated 17.12.2018 is reproduced as:
ORDERS
Imphal, the 17th December, 2018
No. 2/3/2016-MTU: On the recommendation of the Selection Committee
constituted vide orders of even no. dated 19.11.2018 and 27.11.2018 and
WA No. 46 of 2021 with
MC(WA) No. 77 of 2021
Page 10
approval by the Board of Management under Section 26(f) of Manipur
Technical University Act, 2016 in its meeting held on 15th December 2018, the
following candidates are hereby appointed on Regular basis in the posts
indicated against their names:
Sl.
No.
Name of the Candidate
Name of the
post
Dr. Rajkumar Kamaljit Singh
Aruna Chanu Oinam
Thokchom Chhatrajit Singh
Anand Jyoti Sanasam
Assistant
Professor
Physics
Assistant
Librarian
Assistant
Professor
Dr. Ningombam Swapana
Pinky Khundrakpam
Thingbaijam Rajkumari Chanu
Loukrakpam Merin Singh
Rosy Kimneithem Haokip
Dr. Biraj Shougaijam
Group
of the
post
Category
of the
post
UR
Pay Scale
UR
A
Mathematics
Assistant
Professor
Chemistry
Assistant
Professor
Electronics and
Communication
Engineering
UR
UR
Rs.1560039100+6000
(AGP)
UR
UR
UR
UR
UR
ST
UR
2.
They shall be on probation for a period of 2 (two) years.
3.
This issues with the concurrence of the Finance
Department (PIC), Government of Manipur vide their U.O. No.
69/2016-2017/FD(PIC)
dated
14.06.2016,
349/2016-
2017/FD(PIC) dated 02.12.2016 and the approval of the ViceChancellor, Manipur Technical University.
(Ng. Bhogendra Meitei)
Registrar, Manipur Technical
University”
[10]
It may be noted that the candidate at serial No. 2 i.e. Aruna
Chanu Oinam is appointed as Assistant Librarian and she, being a nonteaching staff, is not related in the present appeal challenging the
regularisation of the respondent Nos. 1 to 5 as Assistant Professors.
[11]
Being aggrieved by the judgment dated 20.09.2018 passed by
the Ld. Single Judge in WP(C) No. 519 of 2018, the MTU preferred a review
petition, being Review Pet. No. 16 of 2018 and the same was dismissed on
WA No. 46 of 2021 with
MC(WA) No. 77 of 2021
Page 11
merit by the Ld. Single Judge vide order dated 18.12.2018. Thereafter, the
MTU also filed an appeal being WA No. 2 of 2019. The respondent Nos. 1 to
5 herein (writ petitioners) also filed contempt case being Cont. Cas(C) No. 378
of 2018. The Commissioner (Hr. & Tech. Edn.), Government of Manipur
prepared a cabinet memorandum by proposing regularization of 5(five)
Assistant Professors on contract basis (respondent Nos. 1 to 5 herein) and 11
(eleven) Assistant Professors on guest basis in MTU and re-designation of
one post of Assistant Professor (Civil Engineering) to the post of Assistant
Professor (Geology). In the cabinet memo, it is mentioned that vide order
dated 20.09.2018, learned Single Judge of this Court in WP(C) No. 519 of
2018 directed the university to give regular appointment to the 5 (five)
Assistant Professors employed on contract basis from the date of their initial
appointment. It is also mentioned that MTU’s review petition, i.e., Review Pet.
No. 16 of 2018 against the direction of the Ld. Single Judge was also
dismissed on 18.12.2018. It is recorded that MTU for academic session (2019
-2020) was working with 25 (twenty five) Assistant Professors comprising of 9
(nine) regular, 5 (five) contract and 11 (eleven) guest and absence of regular
faculty member created situation which would amount to violating the UGC
and AICTE guidelines. The 5 (five) Assistant Professors on contract basis and
11 (eleven) Assistant Professors on guest basis were found qualified as per
the AICTE faculty norms. In the circumstances, it was proposed to regularize
the services of 16 (sixteen) Assistant Professors on contract and guest basis
as one time measure. The Finance Department and Department of Personnel
were not in favour of regularization of contract and guest Assistant Professors.
However, the administrative department proposed to regularize 5 (five)
Assistant Professors engaged on contract wef the date of their initial
appointment in terms of the Court’s order dated 20.09.2018, along with 11
(eleven) Assistant Professors engaged on guest basis from the prospective
date and to re-designate one post of Assistant Professor (Civil Engineering)
out of 6 (six) nos. of sanction post to one post of Assistant Professors
(Geology). The State Cabinet in its meeting held on 11.02.2020 approved the
proposal to regularize the service of 5 (five) Assistant Professors engaged on
contract basis with effect from the date of their joining report (this with respect
WA No. 46 of 2021 with
MC(WA) No. 77 of 2021
Page 12
to respondent Nos. 1 to 5) and 11 Assistant Professors engaged on guest
basis in MTU with immediate/prospective effect.
[12]
In the proceedings of the 10th Meeting of the Board of
Management held on 29.06.2020, the agenda No. 7 was for regularization of
faculties in Manipur Technical University and after due consideration, the
board advised the university to constitute a Verification Committee for
regularizing the service of the 11 (eleven) Assistant Professors on guest basis
and 5 (five) Assistant Professors on contract basis from the date of their
joining. Agenda No. 7 is reproduced as:
“Agenda No. 7 Regularization of faculties in Manipur
Technical University: The Board was apprised that two letters were
received from the Government dated 02.06.2020 and 27.06.2020
conveying decision of the State Cabinet taken on 11.02.2020 for
(i)
Regularization of services of 11 (eleven) Assistant
Professors on Guest basis in Manipur Technical
University.
(ii)
Re-designation of one post of Assistant Professor
(Civil Engineering) out of the 6 (six) nos. of sanction
post to one post of Assistant Professor (Geology).
(iii)
Regularization of services of 5 (five) Assistant
Professors on contract basis with effect from the
date of joining.
After due discussion, the Board advised the University to
constitute a Verification Committee for regularizing the services
of the above mention Assistant professors.
The Verification Committee would comprise of the following
members:
(i)
Prof. Kh. Manglem Singh
Convenor
Registrar (i/c), NIT, Manipur
(ii)
Dr. L. Mahendra Singh
Member
Chairman of COHSEM (Chancellor’s Nominee to BOM)
(iii)
RK. Hemakumar Singh
Member
Principal (i/c), Manipur Institute of Technology.
The Term of Reference of the Verification Committee would be
as follows:
a. Verification of the Certificates of the Assistant
Professors.
b. Checking of the eligibility/qualifications of the
Assistant Professors as per RR for Assistant
Professors in Manipur Technical University along with
requisite qualifications of Teaching Post in Technical
Institutions as per AICTE Norms, 2010.
The Verification Committee is to submit their report by 8th of July,
2020.
WA No. 46 of 2021 with
MC(WA) No. 77 of 2021
Page 13
[13]
In the 11th Meeting of Board of Management of MTU held on
17.08.2020, agenda No. 2 is for regularization of faculties in Manipur
Technical University. Verification Committee report was submitted to the ViceChancellor, MTU on 09.07.2020 and the same was placed before the Board
of Management. After due deliberation and consideration, the Board of
Management approved regularization of services of 5 (five) Assistant
Professors on contract basis from the date of their initial appointment as per
Government letter dated 27.06.2020 and further regularization of 7 (seven)
Assistant Professors on guest basis in pursuance to the decision of the State
Cabinet held on 11.02.2020. As per the approval given by the Board of
Management, respondent Nos. 1 to 5 were appointed as Assistant Professors
on regular basis with effect from their initial date of joining on contract basis
against the posts vide an order dated 17.08.2020 passed by the MTU.
[14]
As respondent Nos. 1 to 5 were regularized vide order dated
17.08.2020 passed by the MTU, the contempt case i.e. Cont. Cas(C) No. 175
of 2018 was closed on 21.08.2020. Thereafter, vide another order dated
28.04.2021, the writ appeal filed by MTU, i.e., WA No. 2 of 2019 challenging
the judgment dated 20.09.2018 in WP(C) No. 519 of 2018 was also dismissed
as infructuous. It has been submitted that no SLP has been preferred against
this order by any of the parties before the Hon’ble Supreme Court. It may be
noted that the 9 (nine) third party appellants herein also filed a writ petition,
being WP(C) No. 344 of 2020, challenging the relevant portion of the
resolution i.e. agenda No. 7(iii) of the Board of Management, MTU meeting
held on 29.06.2020 approving for prospective regularization of the contractual
services of respondent Nos. 1 to 5 herein. It has been challenged mainly on
the ground that the contractual employment cannot be regularized and not to
speak of with retrospective effect. By the retrospective regularization of the
respondent Nos. 1 to 5 with effect from the date of initial contract, the career
of the appellants herein [petitioners in WP(C) No. 344 of 2020] would be
affected in their future service. The prayer in WP(C) No. 344 of 2020 is
reproduced as:
WA No. 46 of 2021 with
MC(WA) No. 77 of 2021
Page 14
“(i)
(ii)
(iii)
[15]
Call for the records of the case and issue rule nisi calling
upon the respondents to show cause as to why the prayer
prayed for by the petitioner shall not be granted. And, after
hearing them make the rule absolute.
issue writ of certiorari and/or any other appropriate
writ/order/direction
to
the
respondents/authorities
concerned by quashing/setting aside the relevant portion
of the resolution (Agenda No. 7(iii) of the Board of
Management of MTU dated 29.06.2020 (Annexure-A/5)
Pass any other appropriate order/direction that this
Hon’ble Court deems fit and just in the interest of justice.”
By a detailed judgment dated 30.12.2020, the Ld. Single Judge
dismissed the writ petition [WP(C) No. 344 of 2020] filed by the 9 (nine)
appellants herein. It was held that the order dated 20.09.2018 passed by the
Ld. Single Judge in WP(C) No. 519 of 2018 attained finality upon the dismissal
of the review petition preferred by the MTU and the agenda No. 7 (iii) of the
Board of Management held on 29.06.2020 was in compliance of the State
Cabinet decision to comply with the direction of this Court in the order dated
20.09.2018. It is further observed that when the order dated 20.09.2018
passed by the Ld. Single Judge in WP(C) no. 519 of 2018, the 9 (nine)
appellants were not in service of MTU as Assistant Professors and no material
was placed how the right of the 9 (nine) appellants would have been affected
and the 9 (nine) appellants herein had a mere apprehension that in
subsequent seniority list, the respondent Nos. 1 to 5 would be senior to them.
The issue of inter-se seniority between the nine appellants herein and
respondent Nos. 1 to 5 herein were not issued before the writ court in WP(C)
No. 519 of 2018. It has been specifically given a finding that the appellants
herein (writ petitioners in WP(C) No. 344 of 2020) were aggrieved by the
retrospective regularization of the respondent Nos. 1 to 5 herein and not by
their regularization as such. In the circumstances, the writ petition was
dismissed being devoid of any merit.
[16]
It is stated at the bar that 9 (nine) appellants herein did not prefer
any review or appeal against the judgment and order dated 30.12.2020
passed by the Ld. Single Judge in WP(C) no. 344 of 2020. Thereafter 9 (nine)
appellants filed the present third-party appeal before the Division Bench with
an application being MC[WA] No. 36 of 2021 for condoning delay in filing
WA No. 46 of 2021 with
MC(WA) No. 77 of 2021
Page 15
appeal along with an application being, MC[WA] No. 76 of 2021, for seeking
leave to file third party appeal. In the writ appeal, the main ground raised interalia on the following grounds that:
(i)
The terms of the engagement on contractual basis was
for a short period and it has been clearly mentioned that
the appointees shall not claimed regularization. The
contract appointment was made before finalization of the
statute and other guidelines for appointment.
(ii)
Since the advertisement for contract appointment in the
year 2016 was purely for a short tenure, many of the
candidates (like the appellants herein) did not apply.
(iii)
The Ld. Single Judge gave contradictory findings about
the applicability of UGC Regulations, 2010 regulating the
appointment of teaching faculty.
(iv)
The Ld. Single Judge failed to appreciate that no statutory
body of the university such as Board of Management and
Academic Council were formed at the time of engagement
of respondent Nos. 1 to 5 on contract basis. The 1st
Meeting of the Board of Management was held on
07.12.2016 and 1st Meeting of the Academic Council held
on 27.05.2017 much after the appointment of respondent
Nos. 1 to 5. It is also stated that as per Section 26(f) of the
MTU Act, it is the prerogative of the Board of Management
to appoint members of the teaching and non-teaching
faculty. The direction in the impugned judgment to
regularize the contractual service of respondent Nos. 1 to
5 from the date of initial appointment will result in gross
injustice to the appellants who are otherwise senior to the
contesting respondents in future for appointment of
important post of Head of Department, Dean of University,
etc.
(v)
In absence of rules/guidelines/statute, teacher can be
appointed only on contract or temporary basis so as to
WA No. 46 of 2021 with
MC(WA) No. 77 of 2021
Page 16
enable the university to run in the beginning and to make
regular appointment after finalization of the rules. The
contract appointment of respondent Nos. 1 to 5 was made
dehors rule just to make the university functional at the
beginning. The judgment of the Ld. Single Judge was not
in consonance with the law settled by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in regard to regularization of contract
appointment and also against the settled law regarding
seniority between the direct recruitment in accordance
with law and contract appointees appointed dehors rules
and regularized subsequently.
[17]
Mr. BP. Sahu, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. Anjan
Prasad Sahu, learned counsel for the third-party writ appellants, submits that
the appellants are compelled to file the present writ appeal with leave to file
3rd party appeal against the impugned judgment dated 20.09.2018 passed by
the Ld. Single Judge in WP(C) No. 519 of 2018 wherein the MTU was directed
to regularize the contract services of the 5 (five) private respondents herein,
i.e., the respondent Nos. 1 to 5 with retrospective effect from the date of their
initial appointment on contract. By doing so, the right of the appellants who
are regularly appointed as Assistant Professors in various subjects in MTU
have been jeopardized and the contract employees are given marched over
them by the direction of the Ld. Single Judge for retrospective regularization.
It is pointed out that the respondent Nos. 1 to 5 have already known from the
very beginning that their appointments as Assistant Professors on contract
basis in MTU is for a short period, that too before the establishment of all the
statutory bodies and for the purpose of starting class at the very initial state.
[18]
Mr. BP. Sahu, learned senior counsel for the appellants, submits
that the Assistant Professors engaged on contract could not claim
regularisation. It is urged that the doctrine of ‘special equity’ will not be
applicable, as the respondent Nos. 1 to 5 worked only for two years. The
decision in the case of Uma Devi: (2006) 4 SCC 1 mandates that the contract
employees should work at least 10 (ten) years for considering regularization
and two years tenure on contractual employment cannot be considered for
WA No. 46 of 2021 with
MC(WA) No. 77 of 2021
Page 17
regularization. It is also submitted that since the initial appointment was on
contractual basis, many of the aspirants did not apply for the same and by
regularizing the right of the aspirants who could have applied if the
advertisement was for regular appointment, have been violated. Mr. BP. Sahu,
learned senior counsel for the appellants, submits the Ld. Single Judge made
contradictory findings with regard to UGC regulations. At one point, it is stated
that the UGC regulations of 2010 was not enforced in MTU whereas in some
part of the impugned orders it is stated that UGC regulations was applicable.
[19]
It is also stated that the appointments of respondent Nos. 1 to 5
on contract basis were dehors rule and the appointment was solely on the
basis of interview. However, UGC Guidelines, 2010 prescribes 50% academic
record, 30% teaching skill and 20% for interview. Since the appointments of
the private respondents were not in terms of the rule applicable, the direction
for regularization from the date of initial appointment on contract is against the
ratio laid down by the constitution bench of the Hon’ble supreme Court in the
case of Uma Devi (supra).
[20]
Mr. BP. Sahu, learned senior counsel for the appellants, has
pointed out that the Ld. Single Judge has misapplied the ratio of the Arjun
Singh & Ors. vs. State of Himachal Pradesh reported as (2015) 5 SCC 713.
In that case, the State Government made requisition to the Himachal Pradesh
Public Service Commission for regular appointment. However, the Public
Service Commission wrongly issued an advertisement for appointment of
contract basis and in the circumstances, as sanctioned and regular posts were
available and the requisition being for regular appointment, it was wrongly
advertised as contractual post. Accordingly, the Court converted the contract
appointment as regular appointment, since regular post was available and the
requisition was for appointment of the regular post. It is pointed out that in the
case in hand, there was no regular post and contract appointment of Assistant
Professors and Associate Professors in MTU was resorted to for the purpose
of initiation of class at the initial stage of the establishment of the new
university. The regular posts were created later on and the mode of
recruitment is also different. It is urged that the ratio of Arjun Singh case
(supra) was wrongly applied in the present case, where there were no regular
WA No. 46 of 2021 with
MC(WA) No. 77 of 2021
Page 18
posts and no requisition for regular appointment. The appointment, from the
very beginning, was meant for contract for a short period till the appointment
of the regular faculty.
[21]
Mr. BP. Sahu, learned senior counsel, has also pointed out that
the Ld. Single Judge has not considered the ratio laid down by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the case of State of State of Maharastra & Ors. vs. Anita
& Ors. reported as (2016) 8 SCC 293 where it was held and observed that
when the Government had taken a policy decision to fill up the post on
contractual basis, the tribunal and High Court ought not to have interfered with
it to hold the appointments were meant permanent in nature. In the case in
hand, the MTU resorted to contract appointment of Assistant Professors and
other employees for starting class at the very early stage as a stop gap
arrangement and till the appointment of regular faculty members and other
staff. The terms of contract especially mentioned for a period of six months
and the employees could not claim regularization. It is submitted that the MTU
never meant the contract appointment to be considered for regularizations and
the Ld. Single Judge was wrong in directing regularizations of the respondent
Nos. 1 to 5 who were appointed as Assistant Professors on contract basis
from the date of their initial appointment. It is emphasised that regularization
of the contract appointment within a period of two years cannot be resorted to
in terms of the decision in Uma Devi case (supra) cited above, not to speak
regularization from the initial date of contractual appointment.
[22]
Mr. BP. Sahu, learned senior counsel for the appellants, also
relies on the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Jammu
and Kashmir & Ors. v. District Bar Association, Bandipora reported as
(2017) 3 SCC 410, para 11, 12 & 17 which bars regularization of the person
appointed on daily wages and contractual basis without following due process
and the decision was based on the decision of the constitution bench in the
case of Uma Devi (supra). Regarding the locus, it is urged that the petitioners
are very much aggrieved by the retrospective regularization of the respondent
Nos. 1 to 5 by the directions of the Ld. Single Judge in the impugned Judgment
dated 20.09.2018. By this retrospective regularization order issued in the year
2020, the respondent Nos. 1 to 5 have been given seniority upon the
WA No. 46 of 2021 with
MC(WA) No. 77 of 2021
Page 19
appellants who were regularly appointed in the year 2018 after fulfilling all the
requirements and in terms of the Act and applicable rules. It is pointed out that
the writ appellants challenged the Agenda No. 7(iii) with respect to the
decision of the Board of Management for regularization of respondent Nos. 1
to 5 along with others. However, the Ld. Single Judge dismissed the writ
petition being WP(C) No. 344 of 2020 filed by the appellants herein on the
ground that the main and substantive order dated 20.09.2018 passed by the
Ld. Single Judge in WP(C) No. 519 of 2018, attained finality after the dismissal
of the review petition filed by the MTU. It was held that without challenging the
substantive order, the decision of the Board which is in compliance of the
direction in the order dated 20.09.2018, cannot be challenged. In the
circumstances, the present appellants chose to file the present writ appeal
with a leave to file third-party appeal. Since the leave has already been
granted by order dated 06.05.2024 in MC[WA] No. 76 of 2021, the question
of locus does not survive at this stage, as the leave was granted by the
Division Bench of this Court being satisfied that the appellants are aggrieved
parties. In this regard, learned senior counsel for the appellants refers to the
judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of M.S. Jayaraj vs.
Commissioner of Excise, Kerala reported as (2007) 7 SCC 552.
[23]
Mr. BP. Sahu, learned senior counsel for the appellants, further
relies on the following case laws:
(a) Binding nature of UGC Regulations: UGC Regulations are
binding and mandatory nature and any deviation from the
same would render any appointment within the ambit of the
regulations as illegal.
(i)
Annamalai
University
vs.
Secretary
to
Government: (20090 4 SCC 590 (42)
(ii)
State of West Bengal vs. Anindya Sundar Das &
Ors.: (2022) SCC Online SC 1382.
(iii)
Prof. (Dr.) Sreejith PS vs Dr. Rajasree MS & Ors.:
(2022) SCC Online SC 1473
(iv)
Gambirdhan K Gadhvi vs. State of Gujarat: (2022)
5 SCC 179: Where the appointment of the UGC was
WA No. 46 of 2021 with
MC(WA) No. 77 of 2021
Page 20
quashed in a writ of certiorari for not following the UGC
Regulations.
(b) Illegal Selection Committee: UGC Regulations, 2018 stipulate
that appointment of Assistant Professors is to be done by a
duly approved committee and in the case in hand, the
appointment of respondent Nos. 1 to 5 was not by duly
approved Board of Management at the relevant time.
Prof. (Dr.) Sreejith PS vs Dr. Rajasree MS & Ors.: (2022)
SCC Online SC 1473
(c) Illegal selection procedure in violation of UGC norms: Under
the UGC norms, Assistant Professor has to be considered
with API score of 100% weightage consisting of (i) Academic
record and Research Performance (50%), (ii) Assessment of
Domain Knowledge and Teaching Skill (30%) and (iii)
Interview Performance (20%). In case of appointment of the
private respondents, it was 100% by interview which is in
violation of the UGC regulations.
State of Odisha vs. Sulekh Chandra Pradhan: (2022) 7
SCC 482
(d) Initial appointment not made against sanctioned posts:
Where initial appointment was not made on sanctioned post,
no further relief of regularization can be granted.
Bibhuti Shankar Randey vs. State of Madhya Pradesh &
Ors.: (2023) 3 SCC 639: In the present case, the respondent
Nos. 1 to 5 were appointed on contract basis and the same
was not against the sanctioned posts and hence, the direction
for regularization from the date of initial appointment is illegal.
Vibhuti Shankar Randey vs. State of Madhya Pradesh &
Ors.: (2023) 3 SCCA 639.
(e) Courts cannot direct mode/method of recruitment: In
Chandigarh Administration vs. Usha Kheterpal Waie &
Ors.: (2011) 9 SCC 645: It is held that it is for the competent
authority to determine the method of recruitment as long as
WA No. 46 of 2021 with
MC(WA) No. 77 of 2021
Page 21
the method of recruitment is not illegal and the same cannot
be moulded or changed in any form by the Court.
(f) Direction for absorption of respondent Nos. 1 to 5 on regular
basis is against the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
the case of Official Liquidator vs. Dayanand: (2008) 10
SCC 1. There is estoppel against the challenge to the nature
of appointment, once the same is accepted. In the present
case, the private respondents are estopped from challenging
the nature of contract employment and cannot claim
regularization.
(g) State of Maharastra & Ors. vs. Anita & Ors.: (20160 8 SCC
293: It is held that the contractual appointee cannot dispute
the nature of appointment once having accepted the same. In
the case in hand, respondent Nos. 1 to 5 have accepted the
terms of the contractual appointment for a limited period and
that too, barring for regularization, cannot now file the writ
petition that their services be regularized from the initial date
of appointment on contract.
[24]
During the course of hearing, Mr. BP. Sahu, learned senior
counsel for the appellants, fairly concedes that the petitioners are challenging
the only retrospective regularization of respondent Nos. 1 to 5 and they are
not challenging the regularization of 11 Assistant Professors engaged on
guest basis and their prayer is confined to 5 contesting respondents, i.e., the
respondent Nos. 1 to 5 herein, as the retrospective regularization affects their
seniority position and other future rights of considering as Head of Department
and for higher posts. Mr. BP. Sahu, learned senior counsel for the appellants,
submits that the direction of the Ld. Single Judge in the impugned order dated
20.09.2018 directing the university to provide regular appointment to the
respondent Nos. 1 to 5 from the date of their initial appointment be set aside,
as the same in not sustainable in law and fact.
[25]
Further, Mr. BP. Sahu, learned senior counsel for the appellants
urges that as per Section 26(f) of the MTU Act, the appointments have to be
made on the approval of the Board of Management and in the case of
WA No. 46 of 2021 with
MC(WA) No. 77 of 2021
Page 22
respondent Nos. 1 to 5, there is no approval of Board and hence the initial
appointment is dehors the rules. However, the appellants have been
appointed on regular basis on the recommendation of the Board of
Management in terms of Section 26(f) of the Act and the position of the
appellants and respondent Nos. 1 to 5 cannot be equated and the Ld. Single
Judge was wrong in placing them at parity and in fact putting the respondent
Nos. 1 to 5 above the appellants.
[26]
Mr. A. Romenkumar, learned senior counsel for respondent Nos.
1 to 5 (who are the writ petitioners before the Ld. Single Judge), has raised
the question of locus and the maintainability of the present appeal. It is
submitted that the appellants cannot challenge the judgment of the Ld. Single
Judge which directed the MTU to provide regular employment to them from
the date of their initial appointment, as the appellants are not the aggrieved
parties. It is stated that respondent Nos. 1 to 5 were appointed as Assistant
Professor in Communication, Computer Science & Engineering, Electrical
Engineering, Civil Engineering and Mechanical Engineering whereas the
appellants were appointed as Assistant Professors in Mathematics, Physics,
Chemistry, Electronics and the Communication Engineering. It means that the
trades/subjects of respondent Nos. 1 to 5 and those of appellants are different
and hence, they cannot be considered for appointment against the posts held
by the private respondents and they could not have applied in the year 2016
also, even if they were willing to do so. In other words, the appellants are not
an aggrieved parties to the appointment and the regularization of the private
respondents. In this respect, Mr. A. Romenkumar, learned senior counsel for
respondent Nos. 1 to 5, relies on the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court
reported as Umakant Saran v. State of Bihar:(1973) 1 SCC 490 para 10 to
the effect that the writ of certiorari does not lie to challenge appointment at the
instance of persons ‘who was not eligible for consideration for appointment at
the time, had no right to question the appointments since he was not
aggrieved’. Learned senior counsel further refers to the decision of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the case of Shripal Bhati Vs. State of Uttar Pradesh
reported as (2020) 12 SCC 87 para 23 & 25 to the point that a person who is
WA No. 46 of 2021 with
MC(WA) No. 77 of 2021
Page 23
not eligible for appointment is not maintainable against the appointment and
subsequent absorption.
[27]
On the issue of res-judicata, Mr. A. Romenkumar, learned senior
counsel for respondent Nos. 1 to 5, draws the attention of this Court to the writ
petition, being WP(C) No. 344 of 2020, filed by 9 (nine) appellants herein
against the decision of the Board of Management dated 29.06.2020 Agenda
No. 7(iii) regarding regularization of respondent Nos. 1 to 5 from the date of
their initial appointment. It is pointed out that the decision of the Board of
Management in Agenda No. 7(iii) for regularization of contract appointment of
the respondent Nos. 1 to 5 was in pursuance to the decision of the State
Cabinet held on 11.02.2020 for compliance of the direction of the Ld. Single
Judge in Judgment dated 20.09.2018 in WP(C) No. 519 of 2018 for regular
appointment of the respondent Nos. 1 to 5 from the date of their initial
engagement on contract basis. WP(C) No. 344 of 2020 was dismissed by the
Ld. Single Judge on merit on the ground that the resolution of the Board of
Management of MTU cannot be challenged and the direction in the
substantive order dated 20.09.2018 has attained finality after the dismissal of
the review petition and compliance by the State in terms of the Cabinet
decision. It is pointed out that the appellants herein who were writ petitioners
in WP(C) No. 344 of 2020, did not prefer any review or appeal against the
order dated 30.12.2020 rejecting the same. If this Court sets aside the
judgment dated 20.09.2018 in WP(C) No. 519 of 2018 by allowing the present
appeal, it will amount to impliedly allowing WP(C) No. 344 of 2020 which had
already been rejected without preferring any appeal or review. In this regard,
Mr. A. Romenkumar, learned senior counsel for respondent Nos. 1 to 5, refers
to the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Kaushik CoOperative Building Society vs. N. Parvathamma & Ors. reported as (2017)
13 SCC 138 para 13 where it was laid down the tests for applying the principle
of res judicata:
1) That the litigating parties must be the same;
2) That the subject matter of the suit also must be identical;
WA No. 46 of 2021 with
MC(WA) No. 77 of 2021
Page 24
3) That the matter must be finally decided between the parties
and
4) That the suit must be decided by the Court of competent
jurisdiction.
[28]
It is submitted that in the present case, WP(C) No. 344 of 2020
was filed by the appellants herein against the university and the respondent
Nos. 1 to 5 herein and the writ petition was dismissed. The appellants cannot
file the present appeal challenging the substantive portion of the relief granted
in WP(C) No. 519 of 2018, after the dismissal of WP(C) No. 344 of 2020 has
attained finality. It is stated that granting leave for third party appeal is only for
the purpose of filing of the appeal by the Division Bench of this Court vide
order dated 06.05.2024 in MC[WA] No. 76 of 2021 and the same cannot be
treated as giving the final finding that the appellants are the aggrieved parties.
At most, the order dated 06.05.2024 granting leave can be considered as
prima facie satisfaction of the court as to the point of aggrieved party and the
order granting leave to appeal, cannot be construed as a final decision as to
whether the appellants are aggrieved parties or not and the same is open to
be agitated during the hearing of the appeal on merit.
[29]
Mr. A. Romenkumar, learned senior counsel for respondent Nos.
1 to 5, also relies on the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of
S. Ramachandra Rao vs. S. Nagabhushana Rao reported as 2022 (15)
SCALE 187 para 9.5.1 and 9.5.2 where it is stated that the doctrine of res
judicata is attracted both in separate subsequent proceeding and also at the
different stages of the same proceeding. It was further held that even an
erroneous decision remains binding on the parties to the same litigation
concerning the same issue, if the decision was rendered by the competent
Court. It is pointed out that in the present case, the issue was between the
same party and was decided by the competent Court. Even if the judgment
dated 20.09.2018 which is challenged in the present appeal is presumed to
be erroneous, the principle of res judicata will be attracted. Hence, the present
appeal filed by the appellants is barred by doctrine of res judicata in view of
the dismissal of WP(C) No. 344 of 2020 vide order dated 30.12.20220.
WA No. 46 of 2021 with
MC(WA) No. 77 of 2021
Page 25
[30]
Another point of maintainability of the writ appeal is the issue of
infringement of future right of the appellants. Mr. A. Romenkumar, learned
senior counsel refers to the case of Niolofar Insaf vs. State of M.P. reported
as (1991) 4 SCC 279 para 12, wherein Hon’ble Supreme Court held that the
validity of order of transfer cannot be challenged by 3rd party on the ground
that the same would affect his right at the future point of time and in
subsequent event. It is urged that the only ground for filing the present appeal,
as evident from the ground of appeal especially (O) in the memo of appeal, is
that the right of the appellant for consideration of promotion and posting as
Head of Department, Dean and higher post would be affected by retrospective
regularizations of respondent Nos. 1 to 5 and by placing them in seniority
above the appellants.
[31]
Mr. A. Romenkumar, learned senior counsel, submits that the
writ petition/appeal is not maintainable on the assumption of perceived and
imaginary injury at the future point of time. It is pointed out that consideration
for appointment as Head of Department, Dean and other posts has no nexus
with the regularization of the respondent Nos. 1 to 5. The appointments to the
higher post are to be considered as per the relevant rules. On merit, it is
submitted that there are two types of contract appointments (i) without
following due process of rules and (ii) by following all the requisite procedures.
It is pointed out that in Manipur Technical University Act, 2016, Section 9
stipulates that the university is strictly to adhere to the rules and regulations,
norms and standards, procedures and guidelines, etc. of the AICTE in respect
of establishment and maintenance and others, such rules and regulations,
guidelines of UGC from time to time. It is pointed out that AICTE guidelines
prescribe that minimum 80% of the faculty should be regular full time and the
remanent may be adjunct faculty resource person from university. It is pointed
out that vide order dated 15.06.2016, for MTU 50 number of regular posts of
teaching faculty including 30 posts of Assistant Professors, 16 posts of
Associate Professors and 4 posts of Professors were created along with nonteaching posts including the posts of Vice-Chancellor, Registrar, Controller of
Examination, etc.
WA No. 46 of 2021 with
MC(WA) No. 77 of 2021
Page 26
[32]
Mr. A. Romenkumar, learned senior counsel, has pointed out
that 80% of 30 posts turns out to be 24 posts. It is pointed out that 30 posts of
Assistant Professors created vide order dated 15.06.2020 and as per AICTE
norms 80%, i.e., 24 posts are to be filled up on regular basis and the remaining
20%, i.e., 6 (six) posts can be appointed on contract basis. The initial
appointment of respondent Nos. 1 to 5 along with another is as per the AICTE
norms of 20% appointments on contract basis against the sanctioned 30 posts
of Assistant Professors in MTU. It is also pointed out that the initial
appointment of respondent Nos. 1 to 5 was against the sanctioned posts
created on 15.06.2020 and respondent Nos. 1 to 5 and another were
appointed against 6 (six) posts earmarked for appointment on contract basis
in terms of the AICTE norms vide various orders issued by MTU in the year
2016 in order to facilitate to start the classes in the initial stage. Since the rule
was not framed at that time, the university made an arrangement of following
the applicable guidelines and the advertisement for contract appointment was
widely published in newspapers and electronic media and the appointment on
the basis of the interview along with consideration of the academic and other
qualifications of the candidates applied for. It is pointed out that the procedure
adopted in the appointment of respondent Nos. 1 to 5 on contract basis and
that of the appointment on the appellants herein on regular basis are similar.
[33]
Mr. A. Romenkumar, learned senior counsel, has referred to the
notification dated 23.05.2018 issued by the MTU calling for appointment of 30
faculty members on regular basis specifying that the mode of selection will be
interview. It is submitted that the substantial procedural for appointment of
respondent Nos. 1 to 5 on contract basis in the year 2016 and the process for
appointment of appellants on regular basis in the year 2018 are similar, i.e.,
both are on the basis of interview. It is further submitted that the appointment
of respondent Nos. 1 to 5 is through open advertisement by conducting of the
selection procedure by an expert body. On the recommendation by the
selection committee, the contract appointment of the private respondents was
made upon after following due process. Even if the posts were created, the
regular appointment could not be made in absence of the codified rules.
However, the appointment made in 2016 in terms of the MTU Ordinance, 2016
WA No. 46 of 2021 with
MC(WA) No. 77 of 2021
Page 27
on contract basis, has all the trappings of the regular appointment. Anything
done under the Ordinance has been protected by Section 54 of MTU Act.
[34]
Mr. A. Romenkumar, learned senior counsel, relies on the
decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Union Public Service
Commission v. Girish Jayantilal Baghela reported as (2006) 2 SCC 482
para 12, that any regular appointment made on the post under the State or
Union without issuing advertisement and inviting application from the eligible
candidate and without holding proper selection would violate the principle
guarantee under Article 16 of the Constitution. It is submitted that in the case
in hand, all the procedures of a regular appointment have been followed and
such contract appointment of respondent Nos. 1 to 5 is only in the name, but
in essence, the same is a regular appointment and there is no illegality in
directing appointment of respondent Nos. 1 to 5 on regular basis from the date
of their initial appointment on contract.
[35]
Mr. A. Romenkumar, learned senior counsel, refers to the
decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of State of Bihar v.
Upendra Narayan Singh reported as (2009) 5 SCC 65 para 31 to the point
that any public employer is due bound to notify the vacancies in newspaper,
having wide circulation, announcement in radio and television and
consideration of eligible candidates who have applied pursuant to such
advertisement. In the present case also, the six vacancies were advertised
and on the basis of the recommendation of the Selection Committee and after
examining the candidates who had applied, the six candidates including five
private respondents herein were shortlisted and were accordingly appointed
on contract basis. Reliance is made on the decision of the Ld. Single Judge
of this Court in the case of Manovwer Ali v. State of Manipur reported as
(2017) 4 NJE 466 para 53 where it was observed in para 53 that regular
appointment would mean appointment by following the procedure laid down
in the recruitment rules, and if not especially mentioned in the rules, it would
require advertisement of the vacancies and the consideration of the claim of
the eligible candidates required under Article 16 of the Constitution. Reference
is also made to the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Siraj
Ahmad vs. State of U.P. reported as (2019) 17 SCALE 626 para 14 where
WA No. 46 of 2021 with
MC(WA) No. 77 of 2021
Page 28
the persons appointed possess the prescribed minimum qualifications and are
working against the sanctioned post but having selected without undergoing
the process of open competitive selection, such appointments are considered
to be irregular. It is submitted that irregular appointment can be regularised as
held in Uma Devi case (supra).
[36]
Mr. A. Romenkumar, learned senior counsel, submits that in the
case in hand, all the procedures of the regular appointment have been
followed and as such, the contract appointment of the respondent Nos. 1 to 5
is in essence a regular appointment. Further, reliance has also placed in the
decision of Arjun Singh v. State of Himachal Pradesh reported as (2015)
15 SCC 713 where it was held that when the regular posts are available, the
appointment of contractual basis is held to be unfair and Court directed the
person appointed on contract basis be regularized from the date of initial
appointment.
[37]
Mr. A. Romenkumar, learned senior counsel, has pointed out
that the Ld. Single Judge has extensively relied on the Arjun Singh principle
while allowing the writ petition filed by respondent Nos. 1 to 5 thereby directing
the regularization of their services from the date of initial appointment, as they
have satisfied all the eligible criteria. In the case of Somesh Thapliyal & Anr.
v. Vice-Chancellor, H.N.B Garhwal University reported as 2021 (10)
SCALE 213, it was held that once the candidates have gone through the
process of selection provided under the scheme of the Act regardless of the
fact that whether the post is temporary or permanent in nature, at least their
appointment is substantive in character and could be made permanent as and
when the post is permanently sanctioned by the competent authority.
[38]
Mr. A. Romenkumar, learned senior counsel, submits that in the
present case, 30 posts of Assistant Professors were created in MTU vide order
dated 15.06.2016 and as per AICTE 20%, i.e., 6 posts can be filled up on
contract engagement or otherwise. Since respondent Nos. 1 to 5 gone through
the process prescribed for regular appointment, their contract appointment
against the sanctioned posts on regular basis can be regularized. He also
refers to the following case laws:
WA No. 46 of 2021 with
MC(WA) No. 77 of 2021
Page 29
(a) Shanker Raju v. Union of India reported as (2011) 2 SCC
132 para 10: It was held that the settled principle of law for a
long time should not be unsettled. If the present appeal is
allowed, the settled proposition of law will be unsettled.
(b) Md. Abdul Helim Khan v. State of Manipur reported as
2022 SCC ON LINE MANI 229: The Ld. Single Judge of this
Court held that there should be finality of judgment of the
Court and the settled proposition of law should not be settled
lightly.
(c) Office of the Lokayokta v. Thokchom Kaminimohon
reported as 2022 2 MNLJ 107 para 19: The Ld. Single Bench
of this Court held that the initial appointment of incumbent
against the sanctioned post due to administrative exigency is
only an irregular appointment and not an illegal as laid down
in Uma Devi (supra) and the same can be regularized.
(d) Vivek Kaisth v. Sate of Himachal Pradesh reported as
(2024) 2 SCC 269 para 44: invoking the doctrine of ‘special
equity’, a person who has been working as judge on excess
appointment
but
otherwise
eligible
and
without
any
favouritism, nepotism or due to any extraneous condition for
a period of 10 years was regularized.
[39]
Mr. A. Romenkumar, learned senior counsel submits that in the
present case also respondent Nos. 1 to 5 were appointed following the due
process on their own merit and there is no allegation of nepotism or any other
extraneous consideration and the direction for their regularization by the Ld.
Single Judge can be upheld by invoking the doctrine of ‘special equity’.
Similarly, in the case of Gujarat State Dy. Executive Engineers’
Association v. State of Gujarat reported as 1994 SUPP 2 SCC 591 para 11:
The appointment of persons who have been working for 5 (five) years was
protected as there was no substantial illegality in their appointment.
[40]
Mr. A. Romenkumar, learned senior counsel, refers to the
decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Kalyani Mathivanan v.
K V Jeyaraj & Ors. reported as (2015) 6 SCC 363 para 62.4 which held that
WA No. 46 of 2021 with
MC(WA) No. 77 of 2021
Page 30
UGC, 2010 regulations are directory for the universities, colleges and higher
education and institutions under the purview of State legislature. However, as
held in para 62.3, UGC, 2010 regulations are mandatory to teacher and other
academic staff in all the Central Universities and Colleges. In short, UGC,
2010 regulations are directory for university and higher education institution
under the purview of the State and the State has to adopt to implement the
scheme. Hence UGC, 2010 regulations are partly mandatory for central
university and partly directory for State university. Mr. A. Romenkumar,
learned senior counsel, has pointed out that the submissions of the appellants
of violating UGC guidelines, 2010 is without any basis in view of this judgment
and the UGC guidelines was adopted as late in the year 2019 as submitted
by learned counsel for the State Government.
[41]
Mr. A. Romenkumar, learned senior counsel for respondent Nos.
1 to 5 (who are writ petitioners before the Ld. Single Judge), sums up his
submission as:
(i) The appellants have no locus to challenge the
appointment and regularization of the respondent Nos.
1 to 5. The subjects/trades of 9 (nine) appellants are
different from the subjects of the five private
respondents and the appellants could not have applied
for the posts against which respondent Nos. 1 to 5
were appointed on contract basis in the year 2016.
(ii) The appellants are not the aggrieved parties and
hence, no writ of certiorari or appeal praying similar
prayer will lie at the instance of the persons who are
aggrieved parties. The regularization of respondent
Nos. 1 to 5 does not affect the right of the appellants
as both the appellants are respondent Nos. 1 to 5
belonged to different trades and subjects and nothing
is common except for being employees of the MTU.
(iii) The present appeal is barred by the principle of res
judicata as the appellants have not preferred any
review/appeal against the rejection of the writ petition
WA No. 46 of 2021 with
MC(WA) No. 77 of 2021
Page 31
being WA No. 344 of 2020 filed by them praying for the
similar relief.
(iv) The appointment of respondent Nos. 1 to 5 on contract
basis is against the regular sanctioned posts created
on 15.06.2016 and in terms of AICTE norms by
allowing 20% appointment on non-regular basis.
(v) Even if the appointment of respondent Nos. 1 to 5 is in
form contract basis, their appointment in essence is on
regular basis and by following all the prescribed
procedures. The appointment of respondent Nos. 1 to
5 was in terms of the provisions of MTU Ordinance,
2016 and Section 54 of the MTU Act, 2016 protects all
the acts done under the Ordinance.
(vi) At most, the initial appointment of respondent Nos. 1
to 5 can be considered (for the sake of argument but
not admitting) as irregular appointment and hence, the
same can be regularized by the authority or at the
instance of the Court. The respondent Nos. 1 to 5 have
special equity in their favour having contributed to the
growth of the university from the very day of its
inception. Till now, some of them have been conferred
the responsibility of the Head of Department. These
persons are behind formulation of the Statute and
Ordinance of the MTU and they have been performing
multi-tasking assignments as given to them by the
university authority from time to time. It is prayed that
the writ appeal be dismissed being devoid of merit.
[42]
Mr. Kh. Athouba, learned senior counsel & G.A., submits that the
respondent Nos. 1 to 5 were appointed in the year 2016 on contract basis to
facilitate for starting of classes in the initial stage. He also supports the
submissions of Mr. A. Romenkumar, learned senior counsel for respondent
Nos. 1 to 5, to the point that the present appeal is barred by the principle of
res judicata, as the appellants herein who had filed WP(C) No. 344 of 2020
WA No. 46 of 2021 with
MC(WA) No. 77 of 2021
Page 32
praying for similar relief never challenged the rejection of the writ petition. If
the present appeal is allowed, it would amount to allowing the dismissed writ
petition without challenging the same. It is submitted that since the direction
of the Ld. Single Judge in the judgment dated 20.09.2018 in WP(C) No. 519
of 2018 has already been complied by the university on the instruction of the
State Government in order to fill up the vacancies, the writ appeal does not
have any merit and does not warrant any indulgence from this Hon’ble Court.
[43]
Mr. RK. Deepak, learned senior counsel, fairly submits that
before the Ld. Single Judge, the MTU opposed the prayer for regularization of
respondent Nos. 1 to 5 on the ground that their appointment was on contract
basis for a limited period and with a condition barring any request for
regularization. However, on the advice of the State Cabinet and as per the
direction of learned Single Judge, the Board of Management of MTU has
taken a conscious decision on regularizing the contract services of the
petitioners from the date of their initial appointment along with others. The
main consideration for regularization is in order to fill up the vacancy existed
in the university and the same was done with the approval of the Board of
Management which is the highest decision-making body of the university. At
this stage, the prayer in writ appeal may not be opened, as it will unsettle the
settled proposition of law.
[44]
We have perused the material on record, considered the rival
submissions made at the bar and the case laws cited by the parties. From the
submissions made by the learned counsel for the parties, the following points
for determination are involved in the present appeal for adjudication:
I. Whether the writ appellants are ‘aggrieved parties’ so as to
maintain the third-party appeal?
II. Whether the writ appeal is barred by the principle of ‘res-
judicata’, as the writ petition WP(C) No. 344 of 2020 filed by the
appellants for the same cause has already been dismissed and
attained finality?
WA No. 46 of 2021 with
MC(WA) No. 77 of 2021
Page 33
III.
Whether the respondent Nos.1 to 5 have been appointed
as Assistant Professors on contract basis in Manipur Technical
University against sanctioned posts after duly following the
prescribed procedure?
[45]
On the question of the appellants being ‘aggrieved parties’ so as
to entitle them to file the present third-party appeal against the impugned
judgment dated 20.09.2018 passed by the learned Single Judge in WP(C) No.
519 of 2018, the answer lies in whether the appellants can apply and are
eligible for appointment to the posts against which the private respondents
were appointed as Assistant Professors on contract basis in the year 2016.
Before answering this question, it will be relevant to refers to the parties and
the subjects against which they have been appointed on contract and regular
basis. The same will be evident from the following tables:
A. Respondent Nos. 1 to 5 appointed on Contract basis in 2016:
Sl. No.
Name
Subject
Lourembam Iboyaima Singh R1
Communication (English)
Laishram Jimmy R2
Computer
Science
Engineering
Tayenjam Jeneeta R3
Electrical Engineering
Kosygin Leishangthem R4
Civil Engineering
Asem Nabadavis R5
Mechanical Engineering
&
B. Appellant Nos. 1 to 9 appointed on Regular basis in 2018:
Sl. No.
Name
Subject
Dr. Thokchom Chhatrajit Singh A1
Mathematics
Dr. Rajkumar Kamaljit Singh A2
Physics
WA No. 46 of 2021 with
MC(WA) No. 77 of 2021
Page 34
Loukrakpam Merin Singh A3
Electronic &
Communication
Engineering
Dr. Biraj Shougaijam A4
Electronic &
Communication
Engineering
Anand Jyoti Sanasam A5
Mathematics
Pinky Khundrakpam A6
Electronic &
Communication
Engineering
Rosy Kimneithem Haokip A7
Electronic &
Communication
Engineering
Dr. Ningombam Swapana A8
Chemistry
Thingbaijam Rajkumari Chanu A9
Electronic &
Communication
Engineering
From the above tables, it is seen that the five private respondents
were appointed as Assistant Professors on contract basis in the year 2016 in
Communication (English), Computer Science & Engineering, Electrical
Engineering, Civil Engineering and Mechanical Engineering; while the nine
appellants were appointed as Assistant Professors on regular basis in the year
2018 in the subjects/trades of Mathematics, Physics, Electronic &
Communication Engineering and Chemistry. It is evident that there is no
commonality in the subjects/trades qua the private respondents and the
appellants. In other words, the appellants could not apply and appear qua the
notifications issued in the year 2016 for appointment of Assistant Professors
on contract basis. Accordingly, they do not and should not have any grievance
in the appointment, regularization and other service conditions of the private
respondents. We are in agreement with the submission of Mr. A.
Romenkumar, learned senior counsel that the appellants cannot be
considered as ‘aggrieved parties’ so as to challenge the judgment directing
WA No. 46 of 2021 with
MC(WA) No. 77 of 2021
Page 35
regularization of the private respondents from the date of initial appointment
on contract basis. It will also be relevant to point out that the impugned order
directing regularization of the five private respondents was passed on
20.09.2018 and the appellants were appointed on regular basis on
17.12.2018. In other words, the appellants were not in the service of MTU on
the date of passing of the impugned order of regularisation. By stretch of any
imagination, the appellants cannot claim that their rights including that of
further promotion, etc. has been affected by the impugned order. The
subsequent order of regularization from the initial date of appointment on
17.08.2020 issued by MTU after following prescribed procedure, is in
compliance of the impugned order dated 20.09.2018. The issuance of order
of regularization on 17.08.2020 does not improve the case of the appellants.
While granting third-party leave to appeal, this Court was of the prima facie
opinion in favour of the appellants being ‘aggrieved parties’ and the said status
is to be examined at the time of final hearing and decision.
[46]
It is held in the case of Gopabandhu Biswal v. Krishna
Chandra Mohanty: (1998) 4 SCC 447 @ Para 13 that ‘only persons who are
directly and immediately affected by the impugned order can be considered
as ‘parties aggrieved’. Hon’ble Supreme Court also held in the case of Anand
Sharadchandra Oka v. Universities of Mumbai: (2008) 5 SCC 217 that if a
person claiming relief is not eligible as per requirement, then he cannot be
said to be a ‘person aggrieved’ regarding election or the selection of other
persons. As per the above decisions, it is settled law that only ‘aggrieved party’
can challenge the appointment or otherwise of other persons.
[47]
From the above narrated facts and case laws, it is crystal clear
that the subjects of the private respondents and those of the appellants are
different. In other words, the appellants are not eligible for consideration for
appointment against the posts held by the private respondents since 2016.
Since the appellants are not eligible for consideration for the contract
appointment in the year 2016, they cannot be termed as ‘aggrieved parties’
and they cannot challenge the impugned judgment dated 20.09.2018 directing
MTU to provide regular employment to the private respondents from the initial
date of appointment on contract basis. In view of the ratios mentioned supra,
WA No. 46 of 2021 with
MC(WA) No. 77 of 2021
Page 36
grant of leave for third-party appeal is not a conclusive finding on the status
as regards ‘aggrieved parties’ and the third-party leave to appeal has been
granted on prima facie satisfaction, subject to examination in the main
proceeding. In the circumstances, we are of the view that the appellants are
not ‘aggrieved parties’, notwithstanding the grant of third-party leave to appeal
by this Court.
[48]
Next issue is the question of res-judicata. It is an admitted fact
that the direction in the impugned order dated 20.09.2018 in WP(C) No. 519
of 2018 for retrospective regularization of the private respondents, has already
attained finality upon implementation of the same by MTU on the advice of
State government. Before filing of the present appeal, the appellants herein
challenged the resolution of the Board of Management of Agenda 7(iii) of its
meeting held on 29.06.2020 for regularization of the five private respondents
from date of initial appointment on contract along with others by way of writ
petition being WP(C) No. 344 of 2020 and the same was rejected on merit. It
is further admitted that the appellants have not challenged the dismissal of
WP(C) No. 344 of 2020 before the Division Bench in appeal nor was any SLP
filed before the Hon’ble Supreme Court. Instead of challenging the dismissal
order of WP(C) No. 344 of 2020, the appellants preferred the present thirdparty appeal against the original impugned order dated 20.09.2018 in WP(C)
No. 519 of 2018. The parties in WP(C) No. 344 of 2020 and WA No. 46 of
2021 are similar. If the writ appeal is allowed, it will amount to indirectly
allowing WP(C) No. 344 of 2020 which has already been dismissed. We are
in agreement with Mr. A. Romenkumar, learned senior counsel for the private
respondents that the principle of res-judicata will set in and the present appeal
will be barred by the principle settled in the case of Kaushik Co-operative
Building Society (supra).
[49]
On the question whether the private respondents were appointed
against sanctioned posts, it has already been noted above that MTU created
50 posts of teaching faculty including 30 posts of Assistant Professors vide
order dated 15.06.2016. As per AICTE norms, 80% of faculty should be on
regular basis and remaining 20% can be engaged on contract or otherwise.
The 6 (six) posts advertised by MTU in the year 2016 for appointment of
WA No. 46 of 2021 with
MC(WA) No. 77 of 2021
Page 37
Assistant Professors on contract basis is 20% of 30 posts. The mode of
appointment is after open advertisement and assessment of candidates on
the basis of interview and other credentials. In short, the appointment of the
five private respondents along with another in 2016 on contract basis is
against the sanctioned posts by following due process as applicable at that
time. The mode of appointment was on contract basis because of the fact of
non-constitution of various statutory bodies of MTU and codified procedure
was not in place in the early stage, i.e., at the relevant time (2016). It may be
noted that the regularization order dated 17.08.2020 was issued by MTU as
approved by the Board of Management on the advice of the State Government
and in compliance of the direction of learned Single Judge. In view of decision
in Arjun Singh (supra), the direction for regular appointment of the private
respondents with effect from the date of initial appointment does not suffer
from any impediment or infirmity necessitating the need to interfere.
[50]
In view of the discussions above, the writ appeal fails and the
same is dismissed. Consequently, MC[WA] No. 77 of 2021, the application for
stay of impugned order, is also dismissed. No cost.
JUDGE
CHIEF JUSTICE
FR/NFR
Kh. Joshua Maring
Digitally signed
KH.
by KH. JOSHUA
JOSHUA MARING
Date: 2025.11.20
MARING 14:21:19 +05'30'
WA No. 46 of 2021 with
MC(WA) No. 77 of 2021
Page 38
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review