The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
6. With this observation and direction the writ petition is allowed to that extent and stands disposed of.” From a bare perusal of the impugned judgment and order, as quoted above, it appears that the learned Single Judge issued a mandatory direction upon the respondents to release compensation (Disability Pension) for the injury sustained by the writ petitioner during his service for 40% within a month from the date of receipt of a copy of the judgment and order alongwith 6% interest from the date of assessment of injury. The learned Single Judge further directed that in case the concerned respondents authority fails to release the compensation in time, a rate of 12% interest will start from the expiry of one month till realization is completed. While rendering the impugned judgment and order, the learned Single Judge heard the submissions advanced by the learned counsel for the parties and went through Annexure-2 (pages 24 and 25) of the writ petition wherefrom it appears that the injury assessment was done within a year from the date of injury i.e., 15th May, 1996. The learned Single Judge, therefore, was of the view that the respondents should have granted compensation for the injuries suffered by the writ petitioner immediately after the enquiry. The learned Single Judge was further of the view that at this stage, the respondents authority could not take the plea under the um…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 06
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WA No. 3 of 2017 with
MC (WA) No. 3 of 2017
Date of order: 04.02.2021
The Union of India & Ors.
Vs.
No. G/2200782X WO/GD (Retd.)
Min Bahadur Rawal Chhetri
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Biswanath Somadder, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) : Mr. R. Debnath, CGC
For the Respondent(s)
: None
i)
Whether approved for
reporting in Law journals etc.:
Yes/No
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
JUDGMENT: (per the Hon’ble, the Chief Justice) (Oral)
On 28th January, 2021, after going through the records, we had
directed the learned advocate representing the appellants to produce the
Office Memorandum No. 27011/64/2009 – R &W dated 21st November,
2011, which was referred to in the impugned judgment and order dated 16th
November, 2017, rendered by the learned Single Judge. It appears that there
was a typographical mistake in the impugned judgment and order dated 16th
February, 2017. The Office Memorandum should actually read as 21st April,
2011 and not 21st November, 2011, as wrongly recorded by the learned
Single Judge.
The respondent/writ petitioner is not before us. However, the records
reveal that one learned advocate by the name of Mr. S. Banik, had appeared
before the First Court on behalf of the writ petitioner.
The impugned judgment and order dated 16th February, 2017, which
is now assailed before us is reproduced hereinbelow in its entirety:“Heard Mr. S. Banik, learned counsel for the petitioner as well
as Mr. R. Debnath, learned CGC for the respondents.
2.
The brief fact of the petitioner’s case in a nutshell is that:
“By this writ petition, the petitioner is praying for issuing
direction by way of Writ of Mandamus against the
respondent for grant of Disability Pension to the Petitioner
under the Central Civil Services (Extraordinary Pension)
Rules, 1939 as the petitioner being victim of battle
casualty suffered 60% damage to his left leg while
patrolling and Invalid Pension under Rule 38 of CCS
(Pension) Rules, 1972 instead of normal retiring pension
which has been granted as the petitioner is invalidated out
by the Medical Board on the medical grounds due to injury
which was attributable to service and Secondly, for
payment of ex-gratia lump-sum compensation to the
Petitioner as per the Office Memorandum No.
27011/64/2009 – R & W dated 21.11.2011 making
provision for payment of ex-gratia lump-sum
compensation to Central Armed Forces (CAPF) personnel
who sustain injuries and become disabled or
incapacitated on account of causes accepted or
attributable to, or aggravated Government Service”.
3. The learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the
petitioner during his service period sustained bullet injury and
thereafter, the extent of injury was assessed by the Medical
Board of the Assam Rifles who found that the injury sustained
by him was 40% and thereafter, he was placed on ground duty
till his retirement i.e. 01.11.2014. Thereafter, he was allowed to
go for pension with pensionary benefits under Rule 48 of the
CCS (Pension) Rules. The learned counsel further raised
before the Court that, since the petitioner sustained injury
during his service, it amounts to injury suffered contributed to
his service. Since assessment was done and found 40% injury,
the petitioner should be given compensation entitled for the
40% injury he suffered. So, necessary directions may be
issued.
4. On the other hand, the learned CGC submits that it is a fact
that the petitioner has suffered injury and since he has got his
full pensionary benefits at the time of retirement, further
compensation for the injury suffered does not arise as per Rule
6 of the Central Civil Services (Extraordinary Pension) Rules,
1939.
5. After hearing the submissions advanced by the learned
counsel and after going through the Annexure-2 at Page 24 and
25 of the writ petition, it appears that the assessment was done
within a year from the date of injury i.e. 15th May, 1996.
Therefore, in my view, the respondent should have granted
compensation for the injury suffered by the petitioner
immediately after the enquiry. I could not understand the reason
that prevented them in releasing the compensation to the
petitioner for the injury he sustained immediately after the
assessment i.e. 15th May, 1996. Therefore, I am of the
considered view that, at this stage they cannot take the plea
under the umbrella of Rule 6 of the Central Civil Services
(Extraordinary Pension) Rules, 1939. Therefore, the
respondent is hereby directed to release the compensation
(Disability Pension) for the injury sustained by the petitioner
during his service for 40% within a month from the date of receipt
of a copy of this judgment and order along with 6% interest from the
date of assessment of injury; and the respondent’s authority should
note that, in case if they fail to release the compensation in time, the
rate of 12% interest will start from the expiry of one month till the
realization is completed.
6. With this observation and direction the writ petition is
allowed to that extent and stands disposed of.”
From a bare perusal of the impugned judgment and order, as quoted
above, it appears that the learned Single Judge issued a mandatory direction
upon the respondents to release compensation (Disability Pension) for the
injury sustained by the writ petitioner during his service for 40% within a
month from the date of receipt of a copy of the judgment and order alongwith
6% interest from the date of assessment of injury. The learned Single Judge
further directed that in case the concerned respondents authority fails to
release the compensation in time, a rate of 12% interest will start from the
expiry of one month till realization is completed.
While rendering the impugned judgment and order, the learned
Single Judge heard the submissions advanced by the learned counsel for the
parties and went through Annexure-2 (pages 24 and 25) of the writ petition
wherefrom it appears that the injury assessment was done within a year from
the date of injury i.e., 15th May, 1996. The learned Single Judge, therefore,
was of the view that the respondents should have granted compensation for
the injuries suffered by the writ petitioner immediately after the enquiry. The
learned Single Judge was further of the view that at this stage, the
respondents authority could not take the plea under the umbrella of Rule 6
of the Central Civil Services (Extraordinary Pension) Rules, 1939. For
convenience, the said Rule 6, is reproduced hereinbelow:“6. No award shall be made in respect of,
(i)
an injury sustained more than five years before the date
of application, or
(ii) death which occurred more than seven years,
(a) after the injury due to violence or accident was
sustained, or
(b) after the Government servant was medically
reported as unfit for duty on account of the disease of which
he died.”
During the course of hearing of the matter, the learned advocate
representing the appellants has drawn our attention to Rule 8 of the Central
Civil Services (Extraordinary Pension) Rules, 1939, which reads as
follows:“8. (1) The percentage of disability due to an injury or injuries
shall be as specified in Schedule-I hereto annexed, or failing that,
as certified by the Medical Authority.
(2)
The percentage of disability due to a disease or diseases
specified in Schedule-I-A, hereto annexed, shall be as certified by
the Medical Authority.
(3)
The extent of disability or functional incapacity shall be
determined in the following manner for purposes of computing the
disability element forming part of benefits–
Percentage of disability assessed by
Medical Board
Percentage to be reckoned
for computation of disability
element
Up to 50
More than 50 and up to 75
More than 75 and up to 100
Provided that the above broadbanding shall not be
applicable to Government servants who are retained in service.”
According to the learned advocate for the appellants, the proviso
under Rule 8, which is reproduced hereinabove, clearly states that the
braodbanding of percentage of disability assessed by the Medical Board
shall not be applicable to Government servants who are retained in service.
In the facts of the instant case, it is the admitted position that the
respondent/writ petitioner was retained in service and was placed on ground
duty till his retirement i.e., 1st November, 2014. This fact has been recorded
by the learned Single Judge in paragraphs 3 of the impugned judgment and
order dated 16th February, 2017, which is set out hereinbefore. The specific
proviso as contained in Rule 8 of the Central Civil Services (Extraordinary
Pension) Rules, 1939, excludes those Government servants who are retained
in service after sustaining injury irrespective of the percentage of disability.
This being the actual position in law, the learned Single Judge ought to have
noticed and considered the proviso under Rule 8 of the Central Civil
Services (Extraordinary Pension) Rules, 1939 and not issued a mandatory
direction upon the respondents to release compensation (Disability Pension)
for the injury sustained by the respondent/writ petitioner during his service
for 40% alongwith further directions for payment of interest as contained in
the impugned judgment and order dated 16th February, 2017.
The impugned judgment and order dated 16th February, 2017,
therefore, is liable to be set aside and is, accordingly, set aside.
The appeal is allowed and the connected miscellaneous application,
being MC (WA) No. 3 of 2017, stands disposed of accordingly.
(H. S. Thangkhiew)
Judge
(Biswanath Somadder)
Chief Justice
Meghalaya
04.02.2021
“Sylvana PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review