The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
9. With the above observations and directions, this writ petition is disposed of”. The only significant issue of the appellants as raised before us appears to be the direction given by the learned Single Judge in favour of the respondent/writ petitioner to give him promotion with retrospective effect. That the respondent/writ petitioner had been wronged, could be a factor which weighed in the mind of the learned Single Judge. It also appears to be based on a broad conspectus of relevant facts which were duly considered by the learned Single Judge. We are, however, of the view that if the respondent/writ petitioner is considered for promotion to the next higher post of Naib Subedar SKT (Engineer), his promotion cannot be given to him with retrospective effect. The wrongdoing, if any, on the part of the concerned authority cannot be compensated in such a manner. At first, it has to be translated into damages and is thereafter required to be quantified by a competent Civil Court. The writ Court, which exercises its high prerogative jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India is not so readily equipped for the purpose of quantification of damages which is required to be awarded in favour of the respondent/writ petitioner on account of wrongdoing, if any, on the part of the concerned authority. We, therefore, modify the impugned judgment and order only to the extent tha…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 03
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WA No. 58 of 2017
Date of order: 01.10.2021
The Union of India & Ors.
Vs.
Kumar Keshab Kalita
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Biswanath Somadder, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) : Mr. R. Debnath, CGC
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. Philemon Nongbri, Adv.
i)
Whether approved for
reporting in Law journals etc.:
Yes/No
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
JUDGMENT: (per the Hon’ble, the Chief Justice) (Oral)
This appeal arises in respect of a judgment and order passed by a
learned Single Judge on 20th May, 2014, in WP(C) 358 of 2010 (Kumar
Keshab Kalita vs. Union of India & others).
The appellants before us are the Union of India, the Director General,
Assam Rifles and two other authorities of Assam Rifles.
By the impugned judgment and order, the learned Single Judge
proceeded to allow the writ petition in part, with certain directions. Before
we proceed to dwell upon the impugned judgment and order, the brief facts
of the instant case are required to be taken note of:The respondent/writ petitioner was enrolled on 21st December, 1985,
as Rifleman General Duty (Rfn/GD) and thereafter, remustered to the
post of Havildar Store Keeper Technical (Engineer) in the month of
August, 1997. The next promotional post of Havildar Store Keeper
Technical (Engineer) is Naib Subedar SKT (Engineer). It is an
admitted case of the parties that as per the Assam Rifles Recruitment
Amendment Rules, 2009, a new recruitment process has been
implemented for promotion from the post of Havildar Store Keeper
Technical (Engineer) to Naib Subedar SKT (Engineer). The post of
Naib Subedar SKT (Engineer) is a cent per cent promotional post, and
the Havildar Store Keeper Technical (Engineer) having minimum
service of 5 (five) years as Havildar Store Keeper Technical
(Engineer) together with a total of 18 (eighteen) years of service and
passed Map Reading Standard II and Technical Trade Test I is eligible
for promotion. It is stated that the respondent/writ petitioner had
successfully completed Map Reading Standard II and also
successfully completed the Technical Trade Test II. It is further case
of the respondent/writ petitioner that inspite of successfully
completed the Technical Trade Test III as early as 2003, he was not
sent for undergoing Technical Trade Test II. It may be pertinent to
mention that for undergoing Technical Trade Test I, the concerned
Havildar Store Keeper Technical (Engineer) should have successfully
completed firstly the Technical Trade Test III and secondly,
Technical Trade Test II. The respondent/writ petitioner had
successfully completed the Technical Trade Test II on 22nd March,
2010, and also completed the Technical Trade Test I on 22nd June,
2010.
It is the further case of the respondent/writ petitioner that he was
denied the opportunity of undergoing Technical Trade Test II while
his juniors had been deputed for undergoing Technical Trade Test I
and as a result, further promotion to the post of Naib Subedar SKT
(Engineer) was denied to him. The respondent/writ petitioner had
filed many representations to the concerned authority for sending him
to undergo Technical Trade Test II and I. In support of this fact, the
respondent/writ petitioner also annexed the copies of the
representations. It is a fact that at the time of holding the DPC on 15th
July, 2009, the respondent/writ petitioner was not eligible for
promotion to the post of Naib Subedar SKT (Engineer).
Before deciding the matter finally, the learned Single Judge called
for filing of affidavits and the stand of the respondents before the writ Court
(being the appellants herein), as spelt out in the impugned judgment and
order, reads thus;
“5. The respondents filed joint affidavit-in-opposition wherein,
had clearly stated that the petitioner was not eligible for promotion
to the pot of Naib Subedar SKT (Engineer) at the time of holding the
DPC on 15.07.2009. The respondents in their affidavit-in-opposition
further stated that the petitioner will be promoted to the next higher
rank of Naib Subedar SKT (Engineer) in his turns subject to
availability of vacancy. This Court vide order dated 18.03.2014
directed the respondents to file additional affidavit mentioning the
particulars of the vacancies in the post of Naib Subedar SKT
(Engineer) arising after the last DPC i.e. 15.07.2009.
6. The respondents filed joint additional affidavit dated
01.05.2014 wherein, it is stated “that the writ petitioner had acquired
the Qualitative Requirement (QR) for promotion in March 2010 but
could not be promoted to the rank of Naib Subedar/Store Keeper
Technical (Engineer) due to the non-availability of vacancy in the
said rank. That from September, 2011 till date 02 (two) vacancies
had occurred 01 (one) in the unreserved category and 01 (one) in the
reserved category meant for Scheduled Tribe (ST) candidates and 02
(two) Hav/SKT (Engr) viz; Hav/SKT (Engr) Mathai PC from the
unreserved category and Hav/SKT (Engr) L Seimang from
Scheduled Tribe (ST) category had been promoted with effect from
01 September 2011 and 01 November 2011 respectively.” It appears
from the additional affidavit filed by the respondents that there was
only one vacancy in the post of Naib Subedar SKT (Engineer) in the
unreserved category and against that unreserved category one Shri.
Mathai PC i.e. Havildar Store Keeper Technical (Engineer) had
already been promoted”.
The learned Single Judge in the impugned judgment and order at the
very outset observed, inter alia, to the effect that the Court had full sympathy
for the respondent/writ petitioner in the given case but because of hard fact
that he was not eligible at the time of consideration for promotion to the post
of Naib Subedar SKT (Engineer), by the duly constituted DPC held on 15th
July, 2009, the relief sought for in the writ petition could not be granted in
full.
The operative portion of the impugned judgment and order reads as
follows:“7. It is very clear from the inter-se seniority lists of the Havildars
Store Keeper Technical (Engineer), the said Shri. Mathai PC,
Havildar Store Keeper Technical (Engineer) is senior to the
petitioner inasmuch as his seniority position is at Srl.No.11 while the
seniority position of the petitioner is at Srl.No.17. In the additional
affidavit filed by the respondents, it is also stated that for the one
vacancy in the post of Naib Subedar SKT (Engineer), arisen after the
last DPC i.e. 15.07.2009, the petitioner is not in the zone of
consideration. It is very clear in the given case that the petitioner had
been denied for consideration to the next higher post of Naib Subedar
SKT (Engineer) because of the failure on the part of the respondents
to send him to undergo the training for Technical Trade Test I. But
at the same time, the Court cannot direct the respondents to promote
the ineligible persons to the next higher post. In the given case, this
writ petition is disposed of by directing the respondents to consider
the case of the petitioner definitely for promotion to the next higher
post of Naib Subedar SKT (Engineer) as soon as vacancy arises in
the post of Naib Subedar SKT (Engineer).
8. In the peculiar facts and circumstances of this case, if the
petitioner is promoted to the next higher post of Naib Subedar SKT
(Engineer), his promotion should be w.e.f. Shri. Mathai PC, Havildar
Store Keeper Technical (Engineer) was promoted to the post of Naib
Subedar SKT (Engineer).
9. With the above observations and directions, this writ petition is
disposed of”.
The only significant issue of the appellants as raised before us
appears to be the direction given by the learned Single Judge in favour of
the respondent/writ petitioner to give him promotion with retrospective
effect. That the respondent/writ petitioner had been wronged, could be a
factor which weighed in the mind of the learned Single Judge. It also appears
to be based on a broad conspectus of relevant facts which were duly
considered by the learned Single Judge.
We are, however, of the view that if the respondent/writ petitioner is
considered for promotion to the next higher post of Naib Subedar SKT
(Engineer), his promotion cannot be given to him with retrospective effect.
The wrongdoing, if any, on the part of the concerned authority cannot be
compensated in such a manner. At first, it has to be translated into damages
and is thereafter required to be quantified by a competent Civil Court. The
writ Court, which exercises its high prerogative jurisdiction under Article
226 of the Constitution of India is not so readily equipped for the purpose of
quantification of damages which is required to be awarded in favour of the
respondent/writ petitioner on account of wrongdoing, if any, on the part of
the concerned authority.
We, therefore, modify the impugned judgment and order only to the
extent that in the event, the respondent/writ petitioner is promoted to the next
higher post of Naib Subedar SKT (Engineer), he will be at liberty to
approach a competent Civil Court claiming damages against the concerned
authority for its wrongdoing, if any, the fate of which shall be decided
strictly in accordance with law and not based on any observation made
herein. We further observe that in the event, the respondent/writ petitioner
has entered the zone of consideration for the next higher post of Naib
Subedar SKT (Engineer), the concerned authority shall take a decision
thereon, without any further delay, taking into consideration the fact that he
has a judgment and order passed partly in his favour, way back in May, 2014,
i.e., more than seven years ago.
The writ appeal stands disposed of accordingly.
(W. Diengdoh)
Judge
(Biswanath Somadder)
Chief Justice
Meghalaya
01.10.2021
“Sylvana PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review