Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
L.P.A. No.491 of 2024
----The Union of India through the secretary, Department of Higher
Education, Ministry of Human Resource Development,
Government of India, New Delhi.
The JS & FA, Department of Higher Education, Ministry of Human
Resource Development, Government of India, Shastri Bhawan,
New Delhi.
The Secretary, Department of Expenditure, Ministry of Finance,
Government of India, EV Branch, New Delhi.
The Chairman, Board of Governors, Indian Institute of Technology
(Indian School of Mines), Dhanbad.
The Director, Indian Institute of Technology (Indian School of
Mines), Dhanbad.
The Registrar, Indian Institute of Technology (Indian School of
Mines), Dhanbad.
University Grants Commission(UGC), through its Secretary, having
its office at Bahadur Shah Zafar Marg, New Delhi.
..........Appellants.
-VersusPrafulla Kumar Behara, son of Late Gajendra Mohan Behara,
resident of Flat No.7091, Tower 6, GH7, Crossing Republik,
Ghaziabad, P.O. Crossing Republik, P.S. Crossing Republik,
District-Ghaziabad, U.P.
........... Respondent
With
L.P.A. No.463 of 2024
----The Union of India through the secretary, Department of Higher
Education, Ministry of Human Resource Development,
Government of India, New Delhi.
The JS & FA, Department of Higher Education, Ministry of Human
Resource Development, Government of India, Shastri Bhawan,
New Delhi.
The Secretary, Department of Expenditure, Ministry of Finance,
Government of India, EV Branch, New Delhi.
The Chairman, Board of Governors, Indian Institute of Technology
(Indian school of mines), Dhanbad
The Director, Indian Institute of Technology (Indian School of
Mines), Dhanbad.
The Registrar, Indian Institute of Technology (Indian School of
Mines), Dhanbad.
University Grants Commission (UGC), through its Secretary,
having its office at Bahadur Shah Zafar Marg, New Delhi.
..........Appellants.
-VersusBhabesh Chandra Sarkar, son of Late Dwija Pada Sarkar, resident
of Quarter No.E-6, Teachers’ Colony, Indian Institute of
Technology (Indian School of Mines), Dhanbad.
........... Respondent
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
With
L.P.A. No.464 of 2024
----The Union of India through the secretary, Department of Higher
Education, Ministry of Human Resource Development,
Government of India, New Delhi.
The JS & FA, Department of Higher Education, Ministry of Human
Resource Development, Government of India, Shastri Bhawan,
New Delhi.
The Secretary, Department of Expenditure, Ministry of Finance,
Government of India, EV Branch, New Delhi.
The Chairman, Board of Governors, Indian Institute of Technology
(Indian school of mines), Dhanbad
The Director, Indian Institute of Technology (Indian School of
Mines), Dhanbad.
The Registrar, Indian Institute of Technology (Indian School of
Mines), Dhanbad.
University Grants Commission (UGC), through its Secretary,
having its office at Bahadur Shah Zafar Marg, New Delhi.
..........Appellants.
-VersusPriya Ranjan Mohanty, son of Late Judhistira Mohanty, resident of
Flat No.33, Teachers’ Enclave, Indian Institute of Technology
(Indian School of Mines), Dhanbad.
........... Respondent
With
L.P.A. No.537 of 2024
----The Union of India through the secretary, Department of Higher
Education, Ministry of Human Resource Development,
Government of India, New Delhi.
The Director, Department of Higher Education, Ministry of Human
Resource Development, Government of India, Shastri Bhawan,
New Delhi.
The Director, Department of Expenditure, Ministry of Finance,
Government of India, EV Branch, New Delhi.
The Chairman, Board of Governors, Indian Institute of Technology
(Indian school of mines), Dhanbad
The Director, Indian Institute of Technology (Indian School of
Mines), Dhanbad.
The Registrar, Indian Institute of Technology (Indian School of
Mines), Dhanbad.
University Grants Commission (UGC), through its Secretary,
having its office at Bahadur Shah Zafar Marg, New Delhi.
..........Appellants.
-Versus-
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
Santosh Kumar Mandal, son of Late Hari Pada Mandal, resident of
L-24, Tulsi Das Colony, Banaras Hindu University, Lanka, Varanasi.
........... Respondent
With
L.P.A. No.267 of 2025
----The Union of India through the secretary, Department of Higher
Education, Ministry of Human Resource Development,
Government of India, New Delhi.
The JS & FA, Department of Higher Education, Ministry of Human
Resource Development, Government of India, Shastri Bhawan,
New Delhi.
The Secretary, Department of Expenditure, Ministry of Finance,
Government of India, EV Branch, New Delhi.
The Chairman, Board of Governors, Indian Institute of Technology
(Indian school of mines), Dhanbad
The Director, Indian Institute of Technology (Indian School of
Mines), Dhanbad.
The Registrar, Indian Institute of Technology (Indian School of
Mines), Dhanbad.
University Grants Commission (UGC), through its Secretary,
having its office at Bahadur Shah Zafar Marg, New Delhi.
..........Appellants.
-VersusSubodh Kumar Maiti, son of Late Muralidhar Maiti, resident of Flat
No.37, Teachers’ Enclave, Indian Institute of Technology (Indian
School of Mines), Dhanbad.
........... Respondent
With
L.P.A. No.268 of 2025
----The Union of India through the secretary, Department of Higher
Education, Ministry of Human Resource Development,
Government of India, New Delhi.
The JS & FA, Department of Higher Education, Ministry of Human
Resource Development, Government of India, Shastri Bhawan,
New Delhi.
The Secretary, Department of Expenditure, Ministry of Finance,
Government of India, EV Branch, New Delhi.
The Chairman, Board of Governors, Indian Institute of Technology
(Indian school of mines), Dhanbad
The Director, Indian Institute of Technology (Indian School of
Mines), Dhanbad.
6.
7.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
1.
2.
The Registrar, Indian Institute of Technology (Indian School of
Mines), Dhanbad.
University Grants Commission (UGC), through its Secretary,
having its office at Bahadur Shah Zafar Marg, New Delhi.
..........Appellants.
-VersusVirendra Kumar, son of Late Bipin Bihari Lal, resident of Flat
No.G+3 B, Savitri Enclave, Manohar Nagar Housing Colony,
Dhanbad.
........... Respondent
With
L.P.A. No.269 of 2025
----The Union of India through the secretary, Department of Higher
Education, Ministry of Human Resource Development,
Government of India, New Delhi.
The JS & FA, Department of Higher Education, Ministry of Human
Resource Development, Government of India, Shastri Bhawan,
New Delhi.
The Secretary, Department of Expenditure, Ministry of Finance,
Government of India, EV Branch, New Delhi.
The Chairman, Board of Governors, Indian Institute of Technology
(Indian school of mines), Dhanbad
The Director, Indian Institute of Technology (Indian School of
Mines), Dhanbad.
The Registrar, Indian Institute of Technology (Indian School of
Mines), Dhanbad.
University Grants Commission (UGC), through its Secretary,
having its office at Bahadur Shah Zafar Marg, New Delhi.
..........Appellants.
-VersusAlok Kumar Mukhopadhyay, son of Late Amarendranath
Mukhopadhyay, E-5, Teachers’ Colony, Indian Institute of
Technology (Indian School of Mines), Dhanbad.
........... Respondent
With
L.P.A. No.270 of 2025
----The Union of India through the secretary, Department of Higher
Education, Ministry of Human Resource Development,
Government of India, New Delhi.
The JS & FA, Department of Higher Education, Ministry of Human
Resource Development, Government of India, Shastri Bhawan,
New Delhi.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
The Secretary, Department of Expenditure, Ministry of Finance,
Government of India, EV Branch, New Delhi.
The Chairman, Board of Governors, Indian Institute of Technology
(Indian school of mines), Dhanbad
The Director, Indian Institute of Technology (Indian School of
Mines), Dhanbad.
The Registrar, Indian Institute of Technology (Indian School of
Mines), Dhanbad.
University Grants Commission (UGC), through its Secretary,
having its office at Bahadur Shah Zafar Marg, New Delhi.
..........Appellants.
-VersusDipankar Ray, son of Late Debabrate Ray, resident of D/31,
Teachers’ Colony, Indian Institute of Technology (Indian School of
Mines), Dhanbad.
........... Respondent
With
L.P.A. No.271 of 2025
----The Union of India through the secretary, Department of Higher
Education, Ministry of Human Resource Development,
Government of India, New Delhi.
The JS & FA, Department of Higher Education, Ministry of Human
Resource Development, Government of India, Shastri Bhawan,
New Delhi.
The Secretary, Department of Expenditure, Ministry of Finance,
Government of India, EV Branch, New Delhi.
The Chairman, Board of Governors, Indian Institute of Technology
(Indian school of mines), Dhanbad
The Director, Indian Institute of Technology (Indian School of
Mines), Dhanbad.
The Registrar, Indian Institute of Technology (Indian School of
Mines), Dhanbad.
University Grants Commission (UGC), through its Secretary,
having its office at Bahadur Shah Zafar Marg, New Delhi.
..........Appellants.
-Versus-
1.
Chandan Bhar, son of Late Supravat Bhar, resident of Flat No.6,
Teachers’ Colony, Indian Institute of Technology (Indian School of
Mines), Dhanbad. (Deceased).
1(a). Mrs. Suparna Bhar, wife of Late Chandan Bhar, resident of Flat
No.2 E, Block-5, MERLIN Uttara, 94/7K, G.T. Road, Hindmotor,
Hoogly, West Bengal.
1(b). Mr. Chayan Bhar, son of Late Chandan Bhar, Assistant Professor,
NIT Warangal, Department of Electronics and Communications,
NIT Warangal.
........... Respondent
With
L.P.A. No.272 of 2025
----1. The Union of India through the secretary, Department of Higher
Education, Ministry of Human Resource Development,
Government of India, New Delhi.
2. The JS & FA, Department of Higher Education, Ministry of Human
Resource Development, Government of India, Shastri Bhawan,
New Delhi.
3. The Secretary, Department of Expenditure, Ministry of Finance,
Government of India, EV Branch, New Delhi.
4. The Chairman, Board of Governors, Indian Institute of Technology
(Indian school of mines), Dhanbad
5. The Director, Indian Institute of Technology (Indian School of
Mines), Dhanbad.
6. The Registrar, Indian Institute of Technology (Indian School of
Mines), Dhanbad.
7. University Grants Commission (UGC), through its Secretary,
having its office at Bahadur Shah Zafar Marg, New Delhi.
..........Appellants.
-Versus-
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
Kabir Dasgupta, son of Late Shri Mukul Bikash Dasgupta, resident
of Flat No.E/15, Teachers’ Colony, IIT (ISM), Dhanbad.
........... Respondent
With
L.P.A. No.273 of 2025
----The Union of India through the secretary, Department of Higher
Education, Ministry of Human Resource Development,
Government of India, New Delhi.
The JS & FA, Department of Higher Education, Ministry of Human
Resource Development, Government of India, Shastri Bhawan,
New Delhi.
The Secretary, Department of Expenditure, Ministry of Finance,
Government of India, EV Branch, New Delhi.
The Chairman, Board of Governors, Indian Institute of Technology
(Indian school of mines), Dhanbad
The Director, Indian Institute of Technology (Indian School of
Mines), Dhanbad.
The Registrar, Indian Institute of Technology (Indian School of
Mines), Dhanbad.
7.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
1.
2.
3.
University Grants Commission (UGC), through its Secretary,
having its office at Bahadur Shah Zafar Marg, New Delhi.
..........Appellants.
-VersusDurga Charan Panigrahi, son of Late Harihar Panigrahi, resident of
Q. No. Type VI/I, Near Scolomin House, Indian Institute of
Technology (Indian School of Mines), Dhanbad.
........... Respondent
With
L.P.A. No.274 of 2025
----The Union of India through the secretary, Department of Higher
Education, Ministry of Human Resource Development,
Government of India, New Delhi.
The JS & FA, Department of Higher Education, Ministry of Human
Resource Development, Government of India, Shastri Bhawan,
New Delhi.
The Secretary, Department of Expenditure, Ministry of Finance,
Government of India, EV Branch, New Delhi.
The Chairman, Board of Governors, Indian Institute of Technology
(Indian school of mines), Dhanbad
The Director, Indian Institute of Technology (Indian School of
Mines), Dhanbad.
The Registrar, Indian Institute of Technology (Indian School of
Mines), Dhanbad.
University Grants Commission (UGC), through its Secretary,
having its office at Bahadur Shah Zafar Marg, New Delhi.
..........Appellants.
-VersusAkella Satya Venkatesh, son of Late A.S. Murthy, resident of Flat
No.28, E-type quarters, Block-II, Teachers’ Enclave, Indian
Institute of Technology (Indian School of Mines), Dhanbad.
........... Respondent
With
L.P.A. No.275 of 2025
----The Union of India through the secretary, Department of Higher
Education, Ministry of Human Resource Development,
Government of India, New Delhi.
The JS & FA, Department of Higher Education, Ministry of Human
Resource Development, Government of India, Shastri Bhawan,
New Delhi.
The Secretary, Department of Expenditure, Ministry of Finance,
Government of India, EV Branch, New Delhi.
4.
5.
6.
7.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
1.
The Chairman, Board of Governors, Indian Institute of Technology
(Indian school of mines), Dhanbad
The Director, Indian Institute of Technology (Indian School of
Mines), Dhanbad.
The Registrar, Indian Institute of Technology (Indian School of
Mines), Dhanbad.
University Grants Commission (UGC), through its Secretary,
having its office at Bahadur Shah Zafar Marg, New Delhi.
..........Appellants.
-VersusPramod Pathak, son of Late Lallan Jee Pathak, resident of Radha
Nikunja, Kabristan Road, Jorapathak, Dhanbad.
........... Respondent
With
L.P.A. No.276 of 2025
----The Union of India through the secretary, Department of Higher
Education, Ministry of Human Resource Development,
Government of India, New Delhi.
The JS & FA, Department of Higher Education, Ministry of Human
Resource Development, Government of India, Shastri Bhawan,
New Delhi.
The Secretary, Department of Expenditure, Ministry of Finance,
Government of India, EV Branch, New Delhi.
The Chairman, Board of Governors, Indian Institute of Technology
(Indian school of mines), Dhanbad
The Director, Indian Institute of Technology (Indian School of
Mines), Dhanbad.
The Registrar, Indian Institute of Technology (Indian School of
Mines), Dhanbad.
University Grants Commission (UGC), through its Secretary,
having its office at Bahadur Shah Zafar Marg, New Delhi.
..........Appellants.
-VersusDeepanker Asthana, son of Shri D.B. Asthana, Resident of E-3,
Teachers’ Colony, Indian Institute of Technology (Indian School of
Mines), Dhanbad.
........... Respondent
With
L.P.A. No.277 of 2025
----The Union of India through the secretary, Department of Higher
Education, Ministry of Human Resource Development,
Government of India, New Delhi.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
The JS & FA, Department of Higher Education, Ministry of Human
Resource Development, Government of India, Shastri Bhawan,
New Delhi.
The Secretary, Department of Expenditure, Ministry of Finance,
Government of India, EV Branch, New Delhi.
The Chairman, Board of Governors, Indian Institute of Technology
(Indian school of mines), Dhanbad
The Director, Indian Institute of Technology (Indian School of
Mines), Dhanbad.
The Registrar, Indian Institute of Technology (Indian School of
Mines), Dhanbad.
University Grants Commission (UGC), through its secretary, having
its office at Bahadur Shah Zafar Marg, New Delhi.
..........Appellants.
-VersusPhalguni Sen, son of Shri Madan Mohan Sen, resident of 9B, Maple
Street Avenue 2, Renaissance Township, Bardhaman, DistrictPurba Bardhaman.
........... Respondent
With
L.P.A. No.278 of 2025
----The Union of India through the secretary, Department of Higher
Education, Ministry of Human Resource Development,
Government of India, New Delhi.
The JS & FA, Department of Higher Education, Ministry of Human
Resource Development, Government of India, Shastri Bhawan,
New Delhi.
The Secretary, Department of Expenditure, Ministry of Finance,
Government of India, EV Branch, New Delhi.
The Chairman, Board of Governors, Indian Institute of Technology
(Indian school of mines), Dhanbad
The Director, Indian Institute of Technology (Indian School of
Mines), Dhanbad.
The Registrar, Indian Institute of Technology (Indian School of
Mines), Dhanbad.
University Grants Commission (UGC), through its Secretary,
having its office at Bahadur Shah Zafar Marg, New Delhi.
..........Appellants.
-VersusShishir Gupta, son of Late Shyama Charan Gupta, resident of Flat
No.25, Teachers’ Enclave, Indian Institute of Technology (Indian
School of Mines), Dhanbad.
........... Respondent
With
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
L.P.A. No.279 of 2025
----The Union of India through the secretary, Department of Higher
Education, Ministry of Human Resource Development,
Government of India, New Delhi.
The JS & FA, Department of Higher Education, Ministry of Human
Resource Development, Government of India, Shastri Bhawan,
New Delhi.
The Secretary, Department of Expenditure, Ministry of Finance,
Government of India, EV Branch, New Delhi.
The Chairman, Board of Governors, Indian Institute of Technology
(Indian school of mines), Dhanbad
The Director, Indian Institute of Technology (Indian School of
Mines), Dhanbad.
The Registrar, Indian Institute of Technology (Indian School of
Mines), Dhanbad.
University Grants Commission (UGC), through its secretary, having
its office at Bahadur Shah Zafar Marg, New Delhi.
..........Appellants.
-VersusNarayan Rittappa Mandre, son of Late Rittappa Anandappa
Mandre, resident of Flat No.14, Teachers’ Enclave, Indian Institute
of Technology (Indian School of Mines), Dhanbad.
........... Respondent
With
L.P.A. No.280 of 2025
----The Union of India through the secretary, Department of Higher
Education, Ministry of Human Resource Development,
Government of India, New Delhi.
The JS & FA, Department of Higher Education, Ministry of Human
Resource Development, Government of India, Shastri Bhawan,
New Delhi.
The Secretary, Department of Expenditure, Ministry of Finance,
Government of India, EV Branch, New Delhi.
The Chairman, Board of Governors, Indian Institute of Technology
(Indian school of mines), Dhanbad
The Director, Indian Institute of Technology (Indian School of
Mines), Dhanbad.
The Registrar, Indian Institute of Technology (Indian School of
Mines), Dhanbad.
University Grants Commission (UGC), through its Secretary,
having its office at Bahadur Shah Zafar Marg, New Delhi.
..........Appellants.
-VersusPage 10 of 33
Nikkam Suresh, son of Late Nikkam Yeshwanth Rao, resident of
Flat No.26, Teachers’ Enclave, Indian Institute of Technology
(Indian School of Mines), Dhanbad.
........... Respondent
----CORAM :
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJESH SHANKAR
----For the Appellants :
Mr. Prashant Pallav, ASGI
Ms. Leena Mukherjee, C.G.C
For the Respondents:
Mr. Indrajit Sinha, Advocate
Mr. Bibhash Sinha, Advocate
Mr. Ankit Vishal, Advocate
Mr. Kaustav Roy, Advocate
[LPA 537/2024]
----Reserved on 15.09.2026
Pronounced on 29.09.2026
Per: Rajesh Shankar, J.
1.
The present batch of Letters Patent Appeals (except L.P.A No. 537
of 2024) have been filed challenging the common judgment/order
dated 04.01.2024 passed in a batch of writ petitions led by W.P.(S)
No.5777 of 2019 (Kabir Dasgupta & Others Vs. The Union of
India & Others), whereby the learned Single Judge of this court
has allowed the writ petitions filed by the respective writ
petitioners/respondents herein setting aside the decision of the
Board of Governors (BOG) taken in its 11th meeting held on
04.09.2019 by which the recommendation of the Finance
Committee to accept the direction of Ministry of Human Resources
Development
(MHRD),
Government
of
India
regarding
implementation of contributory Provident Fund Scheme in respect
of the writ petitioners was approved.
2.
L.P.A No. 537 of 2024 has been filed against the judgment/order
dated 27.02.2024 passed in W.P.(S) No. 2299 of 2023 whereby
the learned Single Judge of this Court has disposed of the writ
petition filed by the writ petitioner/respondent herein observing
that if the facts/issues involved in the said writ petition are found
to be similar to the facts of the case of Kabir Dasgupta & Others
(Supra), then the matter of the writ petitioner will also be guided
by the observations and directions made in the judgment rendered
in the said case.
Factum of the Case:
3.
The Fourth Pay Commission was constituted by the Central
Government in the year 1983 and the recommendation of the
Commission was implemented by it with respect to its employees
with effect from 01.01.1986.
4.
The Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances and Pensions,
Department of Pension and Pensioners’ Welfare, Government of
India issued Office Memorandum (O.M) dated 01.05.1987
whereby, as per the recommendation of the Fourth Central Pay
Commission, the employees of the Central Government working
under the Contributory Provident Fund Scheme (in short, CPF
Scheme) were deemed to have shifted to the Pension Scheme
unless they specifically opted to continue under CPF Scheme by
30.09.1987.
5.
The Ministry of Human Resource Development, Department of
Education, Government of India issued letter dated 17.06.1987
regarding implementation of the revised pay scales for the
teachers of Central Universities and other institutions maintained
by the University Grants Commission with effect from 01.01.1986,
along with corresponding benefits including retirement benefits.
6.
The erstwhile Indian School of Mines, Dhanbad; now Indian
Institute of Technology (Indian School of Mines), Dhanbad
(hereinafter to be referred as the ‘said Institute’) also issued a
Circular on 19.12.1987 requesting its employees to send their
option if they wished to continue in CPF Scheme, otherwise they
would automatically switch over to General Provident Fund
Scheme (in short ‘GPF Scheme’) with effect from 01.01.1986.
Subsequently, vide notice dated 03.01.1994, it was made clear
that new entrants who had joined after 01.01.1986 would be
entitled only to the GPF Scheme.
7.
In the 128th meeting of the Executive Board of the said Institute
held on 09.09.2005, it was resolved that the employees who had
joined after 01.01.1986 were required to be treated as continuing
under the GPF-cum-Pension Scheme. However, the Director,
MHRD, Government of India declined to concur the said decision
of the Executive Board stating that in view of the categorical
clarification issued by the Ministry of Finance, Government of
India, there was no question of giving any option and those
faculty/staff who were under the CPF Scheme, would continue
under that scheme. It was further stated that there was no
possibility of switching over from CPF to Pension Scheme.
8.
The Indian School of Mines University Teachers’ Association filed
a writ petition, being W.P.(S) No. 2517 of 2009. However, the said
writ petition was dismissed vide order dated 28.03.2014,
observing inter alia that the employees who had consciously
exercised their option to remain under the CPF Scheme, could not
subsequently be permitted to switch over to the GPF-cum-Pension
Scheme.
9.
Aggrieved by the order dated 28.03.2014, the Indian School of
Mines University Teachers’ Association preferred L.P.A. No. 176 of
2014. During the pendency of the said L.P.A., the Executive Board
of the said Institute, in its 172nd Meeting held on 17.05.2016,
decided to constitute a Committee to examine the grievances of
the retired and serving employees of the said Institute. The
Committee, upon consideration of the matter, recommended that
the CPF optees should be permitted to exercise a fresh option for
switching over to the GPF-cum-Pension Scheme, subject to the
approval of the Executive Board/Board of Governors.
10. Pursuant to the recommendations of the Committee, the Board of
Governors approved the same vide its decision dated 28.08.2017
and the said Institute issued office order dated 01.09.2017
implementing the recommendation of the Committee by placing
the respondents in GPF-cum-Pension Scheme with effect from
their respective dates of appointment. GPF account numbers were
allotted to them and their contributions were also transferred to
their respective GPF accounts.
11. Thereafter, the Indian School of Mines University Teachers'
Association withdrew L.P.A. No. 176 of 2014 which was disposed
of as not pressed vide order dated 08.09.2017.
12. The Ministry of Human Resources Development, Government of
India, raised an objection against the decision of the Board of
Governors of the said Institute on the ground that the said decision
had
been
taken
without
consultation
with
the
Ministry.
Consequently, the said Institute, vide Office Order No. 10800
dated 13.02.2018, kept the Office Order dated 01.09.2017 in
abeyance and, thereafter, vide its letter dated 17.04.2018,
referred the matter relating to the conversion of its employees
from the CPF Scheme to the GPF Scheme to the MHRD,
Government of India, for its consideration.
13. The MHRD, Government of India, vide its letter dated 29.07.2019,
informed the said Institute that the issue relating to the conversion
of its employees from the CPF Scheme to the GPF-cum-Pension
Scheme was referred, through the Integrated Finance Division, to
the Department of Expenditure, Ministry of Finance and the said
Department vide letter dated 17.07.2019 clarified that such
conversion, in the case of the employees of autonomous bodies,
was not permissible. Accordingly, the said Institute was directed
to take necessary action in the matter.
14. Thereafter, the Board of Governors of the said Institute in its 11 th
meeting held on 04.09.2019, accepted the directions of the
Ministry of HRD and decided to shift back the concerned
employees from the GPF-cum-Pension Scheme to the Contributory
Provident Fund Scheme. Consequently, the Registrar (Additional
Charge) of the said Institute issued letter dated 03.10.2019
withdrawing the earlier office order dated 01.09.2017 and the
respondents were reverted to the CPF Scheme.
15. Thereafter, the writ petitioners/respondents herein preferred writ
petitions challenging the decision dated 04.09.2019 taken by the
Board of Governors shifting them back to the CPF Scheme. All the
writ petitions (except W.P.(S) No. 2299 of 2023) were allowed by
the
learned
Single
Judge
of
this
Court
vide
common
judgment/order dated 04.01.2024 setting aside the decision dated
04.09.2019 taken by the Board of Governors. It was observed inter
alia that GPF-cum-Pension Scheme was applicable to the writ
petitioners. W.P.(S) No. 2299 of 2023 was also disposed of by the
learned Single Judge of this Court vide order dated 27.02.2024
observing that if the case of the writ petitioner was found to be
similar to the case of Kabir Dasgupta & Others (Supra), then
the matter of the writ petitioner would also be guided by the
observations and directions made in the judgment of the said
case.
Submissions on behalf of the Appellants:
16. Mr. Prashant Pallav, learned A.S.G.I. appearing on behalf of the
appellants submits that the office memorandum dated 01.05.1987
was issued with respect to the employees of the Central
Government and it did not ipso facto apply to the employees of an
autonomous institution such as the erstwhile ISM (now IIT-ISM),
Dhanbad.
The said Institute itself treated the adoption as
necessary and issued notice dated 19.12.1987 inviting its
employees to exercise option of either CPF Scheme or GPF-cumPension Scheme which was extended from time to time, lastly till
22.06.1994.
17. It is also submitted that the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of
State of Rajasthan Vs. A.N Mathur and Ors. reported in
(2014) 13 SCC 531 has held that a university being an
autonomous body but funded by the State, cannot unilaterally take
a decision to give benefits to its employees under a different
scheme without taking the consent of the State government.
18. It is further submitted that the judgment rendered in the case of
A.N. Mathur (Supra.) was based on the interpretation of
Sections 38 and 39 of the Rajasthan Agriculture University Udaipur
Act, 2000. Section 38 of the said Act provides that the university
shall establish a pension and insurance scheme for the benefit of
the teachers, officers, and other employees of the university,
whereas, Section 39 of the said Act stipulates that any change in
the statute must be approved by the Chancellor, who happens to
be the Governor.
19. Learned A.S.G.I. also argues that the statutory provisions of the
Institute of Technology Act, 1961 (in short “Act, 1961”) are
identical to the provisions of the Rajasthan Agriculture University
Udaipur Act, 2000 to the extent of the Act, 1961 also requiring the
statute to be placed before the Visitor, for his approval. The Visitor
in the case of IITs is the Hon’ble President of India. Since the
decision of the Appellant Institute to alter the status of the
beneficiaries of CPF to GPF was not the part of the amended
statute and was also not placed before the Visitor, the same was
invalid in the eye of law.
20. According to the learned A.S.G.I., since the financial burden
pertaining to shift from CPF to GPF-cum-Pension Scheme of the
employees of the said Institute primarily lies on the Union of India,
prior approval ought to have been obtained from MHRD in this
regard.
21. It is further submitted that the respondents themselves
consciously exercised their option to remain under CPF Scheme
and were accordingly treated as CPF beneficiaries for a substantial
period. The lists including the list dated 18.07.1994 issued by the
said Institute mentioned the names of the respondents amongst
the employees covered under CPF Scheme.
22. It is contended that the present case is not one where the
respondents were inadvertently continued under CPF Scheme
without any conscious choice on their part, rather the
contemporaneous records demonstrate that the said Institute had
specifically invited options vide notice dated 19.12.1987 from its
employees for opting CPF/GPF-cum-Pension Scheme and the
respondents consciously opted to remain under the CPF Scheme.
23. It is also urged that the period to exercise such option was
extended by the said Institute from time to time which remained
open up to 22.06.1994. Thus, the employees were afforded
sufficient opportunity to make a conscious choice regarding the
retiral regime under which they desired to continue. Pursuant to
the aforesaid exercise, the said Institute prepared and circulated
lists of employees covered under the CPF Scheme on various dates
i.e., 03.01.1994, 16.03.1994 and 18.07.1994. Significantly, in the
list dated 18.07.1994, the names of 37 employees including the
names of the respondents were mentioned. Thus, their coverage
under CPF Scheme was neither accidental nor merely an internal
accounting entry of the said Institute.
24. According to learned A.S.G.I., the present controversy is
substantially covered by the judgment dated 28.03.2014 rendered
in W.P.(S) No. 2517 of 2009 (Indian School of Mines
University Teachers' Association Vs. The Union of India &
Ors.) wherein the very issue of conversion of the employees of
the said Institute from CPF to GPF-cum-Pension Scheme was
examined and the learned Single Judge specifically noticed that
after adoption of O.M. dated 01.05.1987, options had been invited
by the said Institute even beyond the cut-off date of 30.09.1987
which had consciously been exercised by the aggrieved employees
to remain under the CPF Scheme. The Court held that where an
option had consciously been exercised by the concerned
employees even after the cut-off date fixed by the said Institute
and accepted it, they could not subsequently be allowed to claim
the benefit of deeming fiction so as to migrate to the GPF-cumPension Scheme at a later stage.
25. In the case of Rajasthan Agriculture University, Bikaner v.
State of Rajasthan & Others reported in (2013) 12 SCC
610, as relied upon by the learned A.S.G.I., the employees were
given options to opt for a particular scheme which had to be
exercised by 03.01.1992. The concerned employee contended that
he had not exercised his option by the cut-off date but had chosen
to adopt the CPF scheme after the cut-off date, which was
accepted by the university. The employee later on contended that,
since he had furnished the option beyond the cut-off date, the
same was non-est in the eye of law, and he should be granted the
benefit under the GPF scheme.
26. In the said case, the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India negating the
contentions raised by the concerned employee held that he was a
reasonably literate person and should have acknowledged the
consequences of his conscious choice when he had opted for the
C.P.F. Scheme even after lapse of the period prescribed in the
notification. The learned A.S.G.I. asserts that the facts governing
the instant case are identical to the case of Rajasthan
Agriculture University, Bikaner (Supra) as the employees of
the said Institute had consciously chosen to adopt the CPF scheme
and now they cannot be allowed to switch over to the GPF scheme
after more than 30 years.
27. It is submitted that earlier the present issue was raised by the
Indian School of Mines University Teachers’ Association by filing
writ petition being W.P.(S) No.2517 of 2019 and the judgment
dated 28.03.2014 passed by the learned single judge of this Court
is significant on the question of institutional competence. It was
observed in the said case that ISM, Dhanbad was a centrally
funded technical institution receiving yearly Grant-in-Aid from
MHRD, Government of India and the pensionary expenditure of its
retired employees was met from such Grant-in-Aid. It was further
observed that though the said Institute might have a claim of
being an autonomous organisation, it was dependent upon
financial assistance of the Central Government to meet its
expenditure, including payment of pension. Therefore, the
decision of the Executive Board dated 09.09.2005 permitting the
concerned CPF optees to switch over to GPF-cum-Pension Scheme
could not be said to be a final word in the matter.
28. The
same
principle
applies
with
greater
force
to
the
subsequent recommendations and the office orders issued in the
year 2017. Merely because the said Institute again resolved to
place certain employees under GPF-cum-Pension Scheme, it could
not override the policy decision of MHRD and the Department of
Expenditure, Government
of India, particularly
when
the
financial liability was ultimately to be borne by the Union of India.
29. It is further argued that the learned single Judge has put much
reliance on the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court rendered
in the case of University of Delhi Vs. Shashi Kiran & Ors.
reported in 2022 SCC OnLine SC 594 while passing the
impugned order dated 04.01.2024. However, the learned single
Judge has failed to appreciate that the factual matrix of the said
case was entirely different from the case in hand. The said case
was in relation to the retirement benefits of the employees of the
University of Delhi and as such the rights of the employees in that
case were required to be examined in the context of the statutory
regime peculiar to the University of Delhi. However, in the present
case, the erstwhile ISM was an autonomous institution governed
by its own Rules, Regulations and administrative decisions, and
the question whether Central Government instructions, including
the O.M. dated 01.05.1987 was applicable to its employees
depended upon their adoption and implementation by the
competent institutional and governmental authorities. Therefore,
the broad observation made in the case of Shashi Kiran
(Supra.) that the general rule after 01.01.1986 was pension/GPF
and CPF was an exception, cannot be read as laying down an
absolute proposition with respect to any autonomous institution
that its every employee appointed after 01.01.1986 automatically
became beneficiary of GPF-cum-Pension Scheme irrespective of
the scheme actually adopted by the institution.
30. It is contended that the respondents were not merely shown as
CPF beneficiaries by unilateral action of the employer, rather the
record indicated a positive and conscious exercise of option on
their part to remain under the CPF Scheme and they continued
under the said regime for a substantial period.
31. It is finally argued that the judgement of Sakshi Kiran (Supra.)
is not applicable in the present batch of appeals. In the case of
Sakshi Kiran (Supra.), the concerned employees had not
exercised their option to continue under CPF Scheme, whereas in
the present appeals, the respondents had consciously exercised
the option to continue under CPF Scheme.
Submissions made on behalf of the Respondents:
32. Mr. Indrajit Sinha, learned counsel for the respondents submits
that the respondents have been erroneously treated as employees
having the option to remain under the CPF Scheme, despite they
being appointed in the said Institute after 01.01.1986 and
therefore, were to be governed by the GPF-cum-Pension Scheme.
33. It is further submitted that office memorandum dated 01.05.1987
was issued for change over of the Central Government employees
from the CPF Scheme to the GPF-cum-Pension Scheme in the light
of implementing the recommendations of the Fourth Central Pay
Commission and the same was applicable only with respect to
those employees who were already in service on 01.01.1986.
34. It is also submitted that the Registrar of the said Institute, vide
notice dated 03.01.1994, had categorically recorded that new
entrants, after 01.01.1986 would be entitled only for the GPF
Scheme.
35. It is further submitted that the Executive Board of the said Institute
in its 128th meeting held on 09.09.2005 acknowledged the mistake
committed by the said Institute in requiring the employees who
had been appointed after 01.01.1986 to exercise an option and
resolved that such employees were required to be treated under
the GPF-cum-Pension Scheme.
36. It is submitted that the MHRD, Government of India disagreed with
the said decision of the Board which was communicated vide its
letter dated 16.11.2005 and thereafter the issue was again
examined by the said Institute through the committee headed by
Prof. D.P. Singh. The Committee submitted its recommendation on
28.08.2017 specifically mentioning that the employees who had
joined the said Institute after 01.01.1986 should have been placed
under the GPF-cum-Pension Scheme. Pursuant thereto, the
Registrar of the said Institute issued office order dated 01.09.2017
whereby the respondents and other similarly situated employees
who were appointed or re-appointed on or after 01.01.1986 but
placed under CPF Scheme, were deemed to have been placed in
GPF-cum-Pension Scheme with effect from their date of
appointment.
37. It is further argued that the position of the respondents was
further strengthened by the communication dated 26.02.2018
wherein the said Institute acknowledged that the employees who
had joined on or after 01.01.1986 could only be placed under the
GPF-cum-Pension Scheme and that their placement under CPF had
occurred due to the mistake of the Institute.
38. It is submitted that the issue raised in instant L.P.A. is no more res
integra as the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in the case of
Shashi Kiran (Supra.) has already interpreted the office
memorandum dated 01.05.1987 holding that the employees
joining the service after 01.01.1986 would always be under GPF
Scheme.
39. It is also submitted that the learned Division Bench of this Court
in the case of Kendriya Vidyalaya Sangathan Vs. Sh. Bhrigu
Nandan Sharma, W.P.(S) No. 6520 of 2025 while relying
upon the law laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Shashi
Kiran (Supra) has held that the benefit of switch-over to GPFcum-Pension Scheme may be granted notwithstanding that the
employees had earlier opted to remain under the CPF Scheme.
Such switch over cannot be denied merely on the ground of delay
and laches. The benefit may be extended even when the employee
had not exercised any option at all. It is also permissible where
the employee failed to exercise the option within the prescribed
cut-off date. Even an employee who had specifically opted to
remain under the CPF Scheme may, in appropriate circumstances,
seek subsequent switch-over to the Pension Scheme. The decisive
consideration is that the Pension Scheme constitutes a more
beneficial outcome for the employees. The original choice
exercised by an employee does not, in any circumstance, create
an absolute bar against seeking the more beneficial pensionary
benefits. Denial of more advantageous pensionary benefits to one
class of employees may result in discriminatory treatment. The
rationale is founded on the beneficial and welfare- oriented nature
of the scheme permitting such switch-over.
40. It is contended that the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of
Krishna Rai Vs. Banaras Hindu University reported in
(2022) 8 SCC 713 has held that the principle of estoppel cannot
override the law. The manual duly approved by the Executive
Council will prevail over any such principle of estoppel or
acquiescence.
41. Mr. Kaustav Roy, learned counsel for the respondent-Santosh
Kumar Mandal in one of the appeals being L.P.A No. 537 of 2024,
submits that the said respondent was appointed as Technical
Assistant in the said Institute vide letter dated 04.07.1987 and
joined the service on 24.07.1987. Though, he was not provided
any option, yet was erroneously placed under CPF Scheme.
42. It is further submitted that earlier the said Institute was a deemed
Central University/autonomous institution and later on came to be
known as IIT (ISM) possessing institutional authority to examine
and decide the service-status issue. Moreover, receipt of grants
does not, by itself, make every administrative decision of an
autonomous institution dependent upon approval of the Central
Government. In any event, the funding department of the
Government is not supposed to disregard a duly taken decision
without any such statutory authority.
43. It
is
also
contended
that
after
implementation
of
the
recommendation of the Fourth Pay Commission, there was no CPF
Scheme available at all for the officers/employees who were
appointed after the cut-off date 01.01.1986.
Findings of the Court:
44. Heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the
materials available on record.
45. The issue that falls for consideration of this Court is as to whether
under the present facts and circumstance of the case, the
respondents are entitled to avail the benefits of GPF-cum-pension
Scheme?
46. Thrust of the argument of the learned A.S.G.I. appearing for the
appellants is that the respondents voluntarily opted for CPF
Scheme and once the option was exercised, the same could not
be changed.
47. Undisputedly, all the respondents had joined the said Institute
after implementation of the recommendation of the Fourth Pay
Commission with effect from 01.01.1986. In the case of Sakshi
Kiran (Supra.), the Hon’ble Supreme Court had an occasion to
interpret the notification dated 01.05.1987 issued by the
Department of Pension and Pensioners’ Welfare, Government of
India. In the said case, Their Lordships while interpreting the
intent of the notification dated 01.05.1987, held that normally the
employees were covered under the GPF Scheme and the CPF
Scheme was an exception for those employees who had opted it.
It was specifically held that the employees joining service after
01.01.1986 were always covered under the GPF Scheme.
48. The learned A.S.G.I. has endeavoured to distinguish the case of
Sakshi Kiran (Supra.) primarily on the basis of factual context
of the present case. He submits that earlier the said Institute was
an autonomous body having its own statutory framework and
institutional structure. As such, it was thought appropriate to seek
option from the respondents who then opted for CPF Scheme. We
are not convinced with the said argument of the learned A.S.G.I.
in view of the fact that office memorandum dated 01.05.1987 was
in toto adopted by the said Institute vide circular dated 19.12.1987
by offering the same option to its employees as was mentioned in
the office memorandum dated 01.05.1987. Importantly, the said
Institute itself accepted that it had committed mistake by seeking
options from the respondents who had joined the service after
01.01.1986.
49. We have also perused the judgment of the co-ordinate Bench
rendered in the case of Kendriya Vidyalaya Sangathan
through its Commissioner Vs. Sh. Bhrigu Nandan Sharma
(W.P.(S) No. 6520 of 2025). In the said case, the learned
Bench held that the decision for switching over to the GPF Scheme
from CPF Scheme was a welfare measure and as such the GPFcum-Pension Scheme being more beneficial, was admissible even
to those employees who originally opted to remain in the CPF
Scheme, especially because denying the better and/or more
lucrative benefit by way of pension to one set of employees would
per se be discriminatory.
50. There was no question of giving option to the respondents who
had joined the said Institute after 01.01.1986. The said Institute
was itself at fault in asking options from the respondents. The said
mistake was subsequently admitted by the Institute and on
03.01.1994, it issued a letter stating that the new entrants, after
01.01.1986 would be entitled to only GPF scheme. The
respondents cannot be made to suffer due to the mistake
committed by the said Institute in asking option from the
respondents to opt for C.P.F. Scheme.
51. We have perused the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court
rendered in the case of Krishna Rai (Dead) through Legal
Representatives and Others Vs. Banaras Hindu University
through Registrar and Others reported in (2022) 8 SCC
713 as has been relied upon by Mr. Indrajit Sinha. In the said
case, Their Lordships have held that the principle of estoppel
cannot override the law. Their Lordships have also referred the
earlier judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court rendered in the
case of Tata Chemicals Ltd. Vs. Commissioner of Customs
(Preventive), Jamnagar reported in (2015) 11 SCC 628
wherein it was held that if the law requires something to be done
in a particular manner, then it must be done in that manner, and
if it is not done in that manner, then it would have no existence in
the eye of law.
52. Thus, mere on the ground that the respondents had opted for CPF
Scheme, they cannot be deprived of the GPF-cum-Pension Scheme
as the action of the said Institute asking option from the
respondents was itself erroneous.
53. One of the arguments advanced by the learned A.S.G.I. is that,
before taking any decision to provide an opportunity to the
respondents to switch over from the CPF Scheme to the GPF
Scheme, the said Institute was required to obtain the prior
approval of the Central Government, as the implementation of
such a decision would have entailed a financial burden on the
Central Government.
54. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Sakshi Kiran (Supra.)
held that when the scheme for switching to the GPF Scheme from
CPF Scheme was framed and sought to be implemented, the
authorities concerned must have considered the entire magnitude
such as, the numbers of employees and the likelihood of financial
impact on the management after giving pensionary benefits to
those employees. It was further held that when the office
memorandum dated 01.05.1987 was issued, the authorities were
conscious of the possibility that all the employees might come over
to GPF Scheme and keeping that eventuality in the backdrop, the
fund was constituted arranging all the affairs.
55. Thus, the appellants cannot take a plea of financial burden to
reject the claim of the respondents. Moreover, by allowing the
respondents to switch over to the GPF-cum-Pension Scheme from
CPF Scheme, the said Institute merely corrected its mistake which
was apparent and no such prejudice has been caused to the
Central Government by the said decision.
56. Even if it is accepted that the prior approval of the Central
Government was required to be taken, the same can at best be
said to be a procedural irregularity. Even otherwise, as observed
hereinabove that the respondents were entitled to avail the GPFcum-Pension Scheme and were wrongly asked to opt for CPF
Scheme, the subsequent decision of the said Institute to allow the
respondents to switch over to GPF Scheme from CPF Scheme was
completely valid and legal.
57. It is well settled principle of law that a decision otherwise valid
cannot be vitiated on the sole ground of procedural irregularity
unless that irregularity has caused a fundamental "failure of
justice" or material prejudice to the affected party. A procedure is
merely the handmaid of justice designed to facilitate fair play,
rather than to obstruct or enslave substantive law. The Courts
have always prioritized the ultimate correctness and core fairness
of
a
decision
over
strict
hyper
technical
adherence
to
administrative formality.
58. The judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court rendered in the case
of A.N. Mathur (Supra.) as has been relied upon by the learned
A.S.G.I. is not applicable in the facts and circumstance of the
present case. In the case in hand, by giving option to the
respondents to switch over to the GPF Scheme, the said Institute
merely corrected its mistake and did not provide any additional
benefit to the respondents.
59. Though the appellants have not been able to sufficient to explain
the reason behind seeking options for choosing CPF Scheme from
the respondents who had joined in service after 01.01.1986,
learned A.S.G.I. has tried to justify it by submitting that the said
Institute being an autonomous body decided to seek options from
the respondents to opt for the CPF Scheme and the respondents
consciously opted the said scheme as well as continued under the
said scheme for a substantial period of time and, therefore, at this
stage they should not be allowed to switch over to the GPF scheme
that too when the office memorandum dated 01.05.1987 had
specifically mentioned that the option once exercised would be
final.
60. We do not find any substance in the said argument of the learned
A.S.G.I. in view of the fact that once the initial decision of the said
Institute to ask for option from the respondents was itself
erroneous, it is immaterial as to for which scheme the respondents
opted for and for how long they continued in the opted scheme.
There is a well-known principle that once the infrastructure
collapses, the superstructure is bound to collapse. One cannot
have a building without the plinth.
61. The judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court rendered in the case
of Rajasthan Agriculture University, Bikaner (Supra.) as
has been relied upon by the learned A.S.G.I. is also not applicable
in the facts and circumstance of the present case. The said
judgment was rendered under particular facts and circumstance of
that case. In the said case, the respondent/employee had not
exercised his option for CPF Scheme within the prescribed period
provided in the notification dated 17.08.1991 and he was deemed
to have opted for pension scheme as per the deeming fiction
incorporated in the said notification. The prescribed period, the
respondent/employee opted for CPF Scheme and the appellantUniversity accepted his request. After the appellant having retired
from service, claimed that since he had not exercised his option
within the prescribed period, he was entitled to be considered
under the Pension Scheme. The matter having travelled to the
Hon’ble Supreme Court, Their Lordships held that the employee
wanted to take undue advantage of the favour done to him by the
appellant-University which could not be permitted. Had the
employee not exercised his option at all, he would have surely
been treated to have accepted the Pension Scheme, but as he had
given his option late, which had been graciously accepted by the
appellant-University,
it
could
not
be
said
that
respondent/employee should have been treated to have accepted
the Pension Scheme.
62. In the case in hand, giving option to the respondents was itself an
erroneous decision of the said Institute. It is a settled law that an
illegal decision or an order that is void ab initio can ordinarily be
challenged, ignored, or set aside at any stage, because a true
illegality or lack of fundamental jurisdiction cannot be cured by
passage of time.
63. For the reasons as aforesaid, we do not find any infirmity in the
impugned orders dated 04.01.2024 and 27.02.2024 passed by the
different Single Benches of this Court.
64. The present appeals are disposed of with the following directions:i.
The appellants are directed to treat the respondents
under the GPF-cum-Pension Scheme.
ii.
The respondents who have retired from service and
have still not been paid benefits of CPF Scheme, will get
pension and other retiral benefits under GPF-cumPension Scheme.
iii.
The respondents who have retired and have already
been given benefits of CPF Scheme, will get pension
under GPF Scheme only when they refund the
government contribution made towards the CPF
Scheme in favour of the ISM, Dhanbad.
65. Pending interlocutory application(s), if any, is also disposed of.
(M.S. Sonak, C.J.)
29th September, 2026
A.F.R.
Rohit
Uploaded on 29.09.2026
(Rajesh Shankar, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review