Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:3557-DB
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
W.P (S) No.5864 of 2023
With
W.P (S) No.5823 of 2023
----1. The Union of India through the General Manager, South Eastern
Railway, 11, Garden Reach Kolkata, P.O & P.S- Garden Reach, DistrictKolkata, 700043, State-West Bengal.
2. Chief Personnel Officer, South Eastern Railway, Garden Reach
Kolkata, P.O & P.S- Garden Reach, District-Kolkata, 700043, State-West
Bengal.
3. Senior Divisional Personnel Officer, South Eastern Railway, Ranchi
Division, Post Office Hatia Police Station. Jagarnathpur District- Ranchi,
Jharkhand.
4. Senior Divisional Commercial Manager, South Eastern Railway,
Ranchi Division, Ranchi, Post Office Hatia Police Station Jagarnathpur
District- Ranchi, Jharkhand.
....... …
Petitioners
(in both the cases)
Versus
Sanjeev Kumar Suman Son of Sri Chandeshwar Prasad Resident of
Village-Mokimpur, Post Office- Kotwand Police Station- Chandi DistrictNalanda (Bihar) Presently posted as Chief Commercial Clerk (Goods) at
Hatia, Post Office and Police Station- Hatia, District- Ranchi under Ranchi
Division of South Eastern Railway.
…
…
Respondent [In W.P.(S) No.5864 of 2023]
Sudhir Kumar Son of Bisheshwar Prasad, Resident of village-Dhobi
Bigha, Post Office and Police Station-Ashthawan, District-Nalanda
(Bihar) Presently posted as Chief Commercial Clerk (Goods) at Muri, Post
Office and Police Station-Muri, District-Ranchi under Ranchi Division of
South Eastern Railway.
..... … Respondent [In W.P.(S) No.5823 of 2023]
------CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SUJIT NARAYAN PRASAD
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARUN KUMAR RAI
------For the Petitioners : Mr. Prashant Pallav, ASGI
Ms. Shivani Jaluka, AC to ASGI
Mr. Ravi Prakash, CGC
For the Respondents : Mr. Niladri Shekhar Mukharjee, Advocate
Mrs. Sandhya Singh, Advocate
Dr. Shree Krishana Pandey, Advocate
------
2026:JHHC:3557-DB
Order No.10/Dated:9th February, 2026
Per Sujit Narayan Prasad, J.
1. Both the writ petitions are taken up together for hearing since the
common issues are involved in these writ petitions and these are preferred
against the common order passed by the learned Central Administrative
Tribunal, Patna Bench, Patna (Circuit Bench at Ranchi) [in short, the
learned Tribunal].
2. These writ petitions under Article 226 of the Constitution of India are
directed against the common order dated 19.05.2023 passed in O.A No.
OA/051/00343/2021 and the second one in O.A No. OA/051/00346/2021
by the learned Tribunal whereby and whereunder direction has been given
to grant same pay as Sachin Kumar Gupta and Anurag Kumar to the
respondent-applicants from the date they were promoted as Chief
Commercial Inspector and the order dated 29.04.2021 passed by the
Senior Divisional Commercial Manager, South Eastern Railway, Ranchi
Division, Ranchi has been quashed.
3. The brief facts of the case as per the impugned order and the pleadings
made in the writ petition which require to be enumerated reads as under:
(i)
The Grievance of the applicants(respondents herein) is that
they were selected for the post of Commercial Apprentice,
after due process, pursuant to Centralised Employment
Notice of year 2010 and after training they were appointed
to the post of Chief Commercial Clerk/Commercial
Inspector in year 2015 but are being given GP @ Rs 4200/P.M. whereas some of their junior selected for the same
post of Commercial Apprentice pursuant to similar
Employment Notice of subsequent year and after training
2026:JHHC:3557-DB
were appointed to the post of Chief Commercial
Clerk/Commercial Inspector are being given GP @ Rs
4600/- P.M..
(ii)
The case of the applicants, as is emerging from their
respective OA is that they presently are manning the post
of Chief Commercial Clerk (Goods), that they are selectee
of Batch No2/13 for the post of Commercial Apprentice
and were selected pursuant to Centralised Employment
Notice No. 02/2010 dated 13/2/2010 (Annexure A/1 in OA
No. 343/2021 and offer of appointment dated 07.01.2013
and dated 13.09.2012, respectively for the post of
Commercial Apprentice was given to them and after
recruitment to the post of Commercial Apprentice they
were sent for requisite training.
(iii)
They underwent three years training successfully and on
completion
of
training
were
appointed
as
Chief
Commercial Clerk/Commercial Inspector, in the Pay band
of Rs. 9300-34800+ Grade Pay Rs. 4200/-, vide office
order dated 18.05.2015 (Annexure A/8 in OA No.
343/2021).
(iv)
Thereafter on reporting the Division, they vide order dated
04.06.2015 (Annexure A/9 in OA No. 343/2021) were
posted as Chief Commercial Clerk.
(v)
Further averment of applicant is that in subsequent year,
after appointment of applicants, similar Employment
Notice for appointment of Commercial Apprentice (Batch
4/14) was given and after due process of selection & on
2026:JHHC:3557-DB
completion of training said selected candidates, like
applicants
were
appointed
as
Chief
Commercial
Clerk/Commercial Inspector in the Pay band of Rs. 930034800+ Grade Pay Rs. 4200/-and some of them were
posted as Chief Commercial Clerk and some other as
Commercial Inspector. Sachin Kumar Gupta and Anurag
Kumar were posted as Commercial Inspector in December,
2016.
(vi)
Sachin Kumar Gupta and Anurag Kumar who were
appointed subsequent to applicants as Commercial
Apprentice, in Batch of 2014, were appointed as Chief
Commercial Clerk/Commercial Inspector clearing the
same examination and though they are juniors to them but
as of now they are posted as Chief Commercial Inspector
in the Grade Pay of Rs. 4600/- whereas the applicants in
spite of being senior are still in the Grade pay of Rs. 4200/.
(vii) The applicants raising grievance submitted representations
for equal Grade Pay and equal opportunity. They wrote also
to change the cadre, if necessary, to maintain equality in
pay and opportunity, however, when no action was taken
they did file the OA before the Tribunal (OA No.
051/00080/2021 and OA No. /051/00081/2021) and their
OAs were disposed of on 11.02.2021 directing the
respondents(petitioners herein) to treat the OA as their
representation and to take a decision thereon as per law
within three months.
2026:JHHC:3557-DB
(viii) Thereafter separate order, both dated 29.04.2021, rejecting
the representation of the applicants were passed by
respondent no. 4 (writ petitioner no.4) the Senior
Divisional Commercial Manager, stating that Commercial
Apprentices are posted either as Chief Commercial Clerk
or as Commercial Inspector and that cadre of Chief
Commercial Clerk and Commercial Inspector are two
different cadres.
(ix)
Consequently, O.A being OA/051/00343/2021 and O.A
No. OA/051/00346/2021 has been filed by making a case
that Sachin Kumar Gupta and Anurag Kumar are their
juniors, that the post of chief Commercial Clerk and
Commercial Inspector are same in all respects, it is not the
choice of the candidate to be posted as Chief Commercial
Clerk or Commercial Inspector, no choice of the candidate
to accept or not to accept the posting was there and
moreover it is not the fault of the applicants that they were
posted as Chief Commercial Clerk (Goods) and not as
Commercial Inspector.
(x)
Respondents (Writ petitions herein) have filed written
statement wherein it has been submitted that post of Chief
Commercial Clerk and Commercial Inspector are of two
different cadres, having different avenue of promotion and
different strength of cadre. That the post of Chief
Commercial Clerk, in GP 4200, is an intermediate grade of
Commercial Clerk category whereas the post of
Commercial Inspector in GP 4200 is direct recruitment
2026:JHHC:3557-DB
entry grade of such category and as such in both the
categories, i.e. in Chief Commercial Clerk and Commercial
Inspector seniority of the officials are maintained
separately. The respondents have denied that the posts of
Chief Commercial Clerk and Commercial Inspector are
same.
(xi)
The learned Tribunal vide order dated 19.05.2023 after
hearing both the parties has allowed the said O.A. and
accordingly quashed the order dated 29.04.2021 against
which the present petition has been filed.
4.
Thus it is evident that it is the case of the respondent-applicants
that they have been appointed after getting the apprenticeship as Chief
Commercial Clerk under 15% Direct Recruitment quota. The other sets of
employees who have been appointed through Direct Mode as Commercial
Inspector have subsequently been granted promotion to the higher post of
Commercial Inspector, Grade-II in the pay scale of Rs.6500-10500/-.
5.
The respondent-applicants have agitated their grievance that
even though they have been appointed in the year 2013, they are still in
the pay scale of Rs.5500-9000/-, while other sets of employees who have
been appointed as Commercial Inspector, Grade-III in the pay scale of
Rs.5500-9000/- are now getting the pay scale of Rs.6500-10500/-. In
addition, thereto, a prayer has also been made for merger of the cadre of
the Chief Commercial Clerk to that of the Commercial Inspector.
6.
The issue of merger has been discarded by the learned Tribunal
by assigning the reason that the merger is the matter to be looked into by
the establishment since it is the matter of policy decision and, as such, has
refused to pass any positive direction on that.
2026:JHHC:3557-DB
7.
It needs to refer herein that the issue of merger after having been
decided to not come out with the positive direction by the learned
Tribunal, has not been assailed by the respondent-applicants, since, no
writ petition has been filed on their behalf.
8.
The only issue which has been decided by the learned Tribunal
is the issue of parity in the pay scale.
Submission of the learned counsel for the writ-petitioners :
9. It has been submitted that parity in the pay scale has been granted by
learned Tribunal even though accepting the fact that both the respondentapplicants and other sets of employees, namely, Sachin Kumar Gupta and
Anurag Kumar are in two different cadres and, as such, they cannot be
equated so far as the pay scale is concerned, but the learned Tribunal, by
way of one-time exercise, has granted the relief by applying the principle
of parity.
10.
Referring the aforesaid fact the learned counsel has assailed the
order of tribunal on the following grounds:
(i)
Once the learned Tribunal has come to the specific finding that both
the respondent-applicants and the another sets of employees,
namely, Sachin Kumar Gupta and Anurag Kumar, have been
appointed in two different cadres, i.e., of the cadre of Chief
Commercial Clerk and Commercial Inspector, Grade-III although
on the same pay scale, but one sets of employees who have been
appointed as Commercial Inspector, Grade-III had been granted
promotion in the higher cadre of Commercial Inspector, Grade-II
in the pay scale of Rs.6500-10500/- which pay scale has been
extended, i.e., the pay scale of Rs.6500-10500/- also to the Chief
2026:JHHC:3557-DB
Commercial Clerk by way of one time exercise which is not
available to the learned Tribunal while exercising its jurisdiction.
(ii)
It has been contended that the learned Tribunal, as a Court
of first instance, while exercising the power is only supposed to
consider the impropriety in the decision, if taken by the appointing
authority, on the issue of arbitrariness, but arbitrariness which is the
core of the Constitution as per provision of Article 14 of the
Constitution of India.
11.
The learned counsel appearing for the writ petitioners has
submitted that the learned Tribunal has, therefore, committed serious error
in granting the pay scale of Rs.6500-10500/- even accepting the fact that
the said pay scale cannot be granted/extended in favour of the employees
working in the cadre of Chief Commercial Clerk.
Submission of the learned Counsel for the respondent/applicant:
12.
Mr. Niladri Shekhar Mukharjee, the learned counsel appearing
for the respondent-applicants has defended the impugned order passed by
the learned Tribunal.
13.
It has been contended that the learned Tribunal has rightly passed
the order as per mandate of the constitution of India in order to rectify the
anomaly in the pay scale in order to maintain the principle of parity
therefore the order impugned requires no interference by this Court.
Analysis: 14.
We have heard the learned counsel for the parties and gone
through the findings recorded by the learned Tribunal in the impugned
order.
15.
It needs to refer herein which we have perused from the order
passed by the learned Tribunal, wherefrom it is evident that the learned
2026:JHHC:3557-DB
Tribunal has not adjudicated the core of the issue, rather by applying the
principle of parity and by way of one time exercise the relief which has
been sought for on behalf of the respondent-applicants, i.e., the pay scale
of Rs.6500-10500/-, which was the pay scale available to the employees
working as the Commercial Inspector, Grade-II, has been granted.
16.
This Court, in the context of the aforesaid consideration, given
by the learned Tribunal is to consider as to whether the learned Tribunal
was having jurisdiction to extend such relief of pay scale of Rs.650010500/- in favour of the respondent-applicants on the ground of
maintaining the principle of parity if such pay scale is not available under
the pay scale earmarked for another cadre and the said pay scale of
Rs.6500-10500/- in the cadre of the respondent-applicants was to the next
hierarchy of the post, i.e., the post of Commercial Superintendent.
17.
This Court, in order to consider the aforesaid issue, is first to
consider the jurisdiction which is to be exercised by the learned Tribunal.
This Court is conscious that the learned Tribunal has been conferred with
the power to exercise its jurisdiction by virtue of amendment as has been
carried out by insertion of a provision by adding Article 323A in the
Constitution.
18.
It is, thus, evident that the power conferred under Article 226 of
the Constitution of India is also to be exercised by the learned Tribunal as
a Court of first instance so far as the employees working under the Central
Government or the other establishment who has been brought under the
purview of the Administrative Tribunal Act, 1985 by issuance of
notification to be issued by the appropriate Government in exercise of
power conferred under section 14(5) of the Administrative Tribunal Act,
1985.
2026:JHHC:3557-DB
19.
The power which is to be exercised under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India is on the basis of the issuance of the writ that is
known as the prerogative writ, i.e., the writ of mandamus, writ of
certiorari, writ of prohibition, writ of quo warranto and writ of habeas
corpus.
20.
We are, herein, concerned with the writ of mandamus, since, no
order was under challenge before the learned Tribunal warranting the
learned Tribunal to come out with the power to exercise for issuance of
writ of certiorari, rather the writ was sought for by issuance of writ of
mandamus/command to rectify the error said to be committed as per the
claim put by the respondent-applicants before the learned Tribunal.
21.
The core of the grievance was that the difference in between the
slab of the salary between two sets of employees working in two sets of
cadre, i.e., the Chief Commercial Clerk having the pay scale of
Rs. 5500-9000/- and the Commercial Inspector, Grade-II having the pay
scale of Rs.6500-10500/-.
22.
The post of Chief Commercial Clerk is to be filled up by way of
three modes, i.e., 75% by promotion, 15% plus shortfall against Limited
Departmental Competitive Examination (LDCE) by direct recruitment
(Commercial Apprentice) and 10% from Limited Departmental
Competitive Examination (LDCE).
The next hierarchy of the post of Chief Commercial Clerk is the
Commercial Superintendent in the pay scale of Rs.6500-10500/- which is
to be filled up by way of promotion only from the post of Chief
Commercial Clerk having the pay scale of Rs.5500-9000/-, being the
feeder cadre.
2026:JHHC:3557-DB
23.
While, on the other hand, the post of Commercial Inspector,
Grade-III having the pay scale of Rs.5500-9000/- is to be filled up 15%
plus shortfall against LDCE by Direct Recruitment (Commercial
Apprentice), 10% LDCE and 75% Promotion whereas the next hierarchy
of the post of Commercial Inspector, Grade-III is the Commercial
Inspector, Grade-II in the pay slab of Rs.6500-10500/- to be filled up
totally on the basis of the promotion, i.e., 100% by way of promotion, for
ready reference the scheme of filling up of vacancies as existed on
31.08.2009 in the Railway is reproduced hereunder as:
Scheme for filling up of vacancies as existed on 31.08.2009
Revision of Classification of Posts consequent upon merger of grades
as a result of implementation of VIth Central Pay Commission’s Recommendation
S.
No
.
Category/Existing Scale
Existing mode of
filling up
Existing
Classifica
tion
Pay
Band/Grade
Pay
Remarks
Revised Position
Revised Mode
filling up
TRAFFIC TRANSPORT DEPARTMENT
Assistant Station Master 60%
plus
(ASM)/4500-7000
shortfall against
1)
LDCE by DR.
15%
plus
shortfall agains
General
Selection
by
LDCE;
25%
General
selection
Asstt. Station. Station 100% Prom.
Master/5000-8000
Station Master/5500-9000
Revised
Classification
Selection
(Rectt.
grade)
PB-1/(2800)
60% plus shortfall
against LDCE by DR.
15% plus shortfall
against
General
Selection by LDCE;
25%
General
selection
Rectt/Entry
grade (General
Selection)
Please see
footnotes
1 & 6.
PB2(4200)
75% Prom.
15% plus shortfall
against
LCE
by
DR(Traffic App.)
10%LDCE
suitability with
prescribed
benchmark.
PB2(4600)
100% Prom.
Subsidy with
prescribed
benchmark.
NonSelection
LDCE by
written
Exam
75% Prom.
15%
plus
shortfall against
LDCE
by
DR(Traffic
App.)
10% LDCE
100%
Promotion
NonSelection
Station Supdt./7450-11500
100%
Promotion
NonSelection
Traffic
75% DR;
25% Promotion
Selection
PB-1(1200)
75% DR.
25% Prom.(General
Selection)
Rectt./Entry
grade(General
Selection)
Senior Signaller/4000-6000
100%
Promotion.
NonSelection
PB-1(2400)
100% Promotion
Head Signaller/5000-8000
100%
Promotion.
NonSelection
PB2(4200)
100% Promotion
Inspector of Teleghraph
Traffic/5500-9000
100%
Promotion.
Selection
Non
Selection/Senio
rity-cumsuitability
suitability with
prescribed
benchmark.
Chief
Inspector
of
Telegraph
Traffic/650010500
100%
Promotion.
NonSelection
Dy. Station Supdt./650010500
2)
of
Signaller/3200-
Selection
2026:JHHC:3557-DB
Goods Guard/4500-7000
3)
4)
5)
6)
60% by General
Selection;
15%
plus
shortfall against
Genl Sel by
LDCE; and,
25%
plus
shortfall against
LDCE quota by
DR;
100%
Promotion.
Selection
(Rectt.
Grade)
PB-1(2800)
60% by General
Selection
15% plus shortfall
against Gen Sel by
LDCE; and,
25% plus shortfall
against LDCE quota
by DR.
Rectt/Entry
grade(General
Selection)
Nonselection
PB-2(4200)
100% Promotion
Nonselection/senio
rity-cumsuitability
Suitability with
prescribed
benchmark
Suitability with
prescribed
benchmark
Suitability with
prescribed
benchmark
Sr. Goods
Guard/5000-
Passenger
Guard/5000-
100%
Promotion
Selection
PB-2(4200)
100% Promotion
Sr. Passenger Guard/55009000
100%
Promotion
Nonselection
PB-2(4200)
100% Promotion
Mail/Express Guard/55009000
100%
Promotion
Nonselection
PB-2(4200)
100% Promotion
50% DR.
33.33% Prom.
16.67%
by
LDCE
Selection
PB-1(1900)
Sr. Train Clerk/4000-6000
100%
Promotion
Nonselection
PB-I(24)00)
50% DR;
33.33%
Prom.(General
Selection)
16.67% by LDCE
100% Prom.
Head Tr. Clerk/5000-8000
100%
Promotion
selection
PB-2(4200)
100% Prom.
Chief
Cleark/5500-
100%
Promotion
selection
PB-2(4200)
100% Prom.
Wagon
Movement
Inspector-II/5000-8000
100%
Promotion
selection
PB-2(4200)
Wagon
Movement
Inspector-I/5500-9000
Nonselection
PB-2(4200)
Sr. Wagon Movement
Inspector-II/6500-10500
75% Promotion
15%
plus
shortfall against
LDCE
by
DR(Traffic
Apprentices).
10%LDCE
100%
Promotion
selection
PB-2(4600)
75%
Promotion
(General Selection)
15% plus shortfall
against LDCE by
DR(Traffic
Apprentices)
10% LDCE
75%
Promotion
(General Selection)
15% plus shortfall
against LDCE by
DR(Traffic
Apprentices)
10% LDCE
100% Promotion
Sr. Wagon Movement
Inspector-I/7450-11500
100%
Promotion
Nonselection
PB-2(4600)
Section
Selection
PB-2(4200)
Deputy
Chief
Controller/6500-10500
75% Prom.
15%
plus
shortfall against
LDCE
by
DR(Traffic
Apprentice);
10% LDCE
100%
Promotion
Nonselection
PB-2(4600)
Chief
11500
100%
Promotion
Selection
PB-2(4600)
Selection
Train Clerk/3050-4590
Tr.
Controller/5500-
Controller/7450-
Rectt/Entry
grade(General
Selection)
Nonselection/senio
rity-cumsuitability
Nonselection/senio
rity-cumsuitability
Nonselection/senio
rity-cumsuitability
Rectt/Entry
grade(General
Selection)
Rectt/Entry
grade(General
Selection)
Suitability with
prescribed
benchmark.
75% Prom. (General
Selection)
15% plus shortfall
against LDCE by
DR(Traffic
Apprentices)
10% LDCE
100% Promotion
Rectt/Entry
grade(General
Selection)
PB-1(1900)
50% DR;
33.33% by Prom.;
16.67% by LDCE
Rectt/Entry
grade(General
Selection)
Nonselection
PB-I(2400)
100% Prom.
Nonselection/senio
rity-cumsuitability
selection
PB-2(4200)
100% Prom.
Suitability with
prescribed
benchmark.
COMMERCIAL DEPARTMENT
Ticket Collector/3050-4590
7)
Sr.TC/TTE/4000-6000
Head
TC/Sr.TTE/5000-
50% DR;
33.33%
Prom.;
16.67%
LDCE
100%
Promotion
100%
Promotion
by
by
Passing of
prepromotio
nal
course/tr
aining
consisting
of written
test, will
be
mandator
y in case
of
promotio
n to the
posts in
grade pay
Rs.4200
wherever
mode of
promotio
n
has
been
prescribe
d
as
suitabilit
y
with
prescribe
d
benchma
rk.
Pl.
see
footnote
1.
2026:JHHC:3557-DB
8)
Traveling Ticket Inspector
(TTI)/5500-9000
100%
Promotion
Nonselection
Chief TTI/6500-10500
100%
Promotion
Selection
PB-2(4600)
Commercial
Selection
PB-1(2000)
50% DR;
33.33% by Prom
(General Selection);
16.67% by LDCE
Rectt. Entry
grade(General
Selection)
Sr.Commercial
Clerk/4000-6000
50% DR;
33.33%
Prom.;
16.67%
LDCE
100%
Promotion
Nonselection
PB-1(2800)
100% Prom.
Head
Commercial
Clerk/5000-8000
100%
Promotion
Nonselection
PB-2(4200)
Chief
Commercial
Clerk/5500-9000
75% Prom.
15%
plus
shortfall against
LDCE
by
DR(Comml.
App.);
10% LDCE
100%
Promotion
Selection
75% Prom.
15% plus shortfall
against LDCE by
DR(Comml. App.);
10% LDCE
Nonselection/senio
rity-cumsuitability
Suitability with
prescribed
benchmark.
Selection
PB-2(4600)
100% Promotion.
ECRC-II/4500-7000
25% DR;
75% Promotion
Selection
PB-1(2800)
Rectt/Entry
grade(General
Selection)
ECRC-I/5000-8000
100%
Promotion
Nonselection
PB-2(4200)
25% DR;
75%
Promotion(General
Selection)
100% Promotion.
Reservation
II/5500-9000
Supervisor-
100%
Promotion
Nonselection
Reservation
I/6500-10500
Supervisor-
100%
Promotion
Selection
PB-2(4600)
100% Promotion
Commercial
Inspec.
Gr.IV(Marketing/Claims/
Rates/R&D) 5000-8000
Commercial
Inspec.
Gr.III(Marketing/Claims/
Rates/R&D) 5500-9000
100%
Promotion
Selection
PB-2(4200)
15%
plus
shortfall against
LDCE
by
DR(Comml.
App.);
10% LDCE
75% Prom.
100%
Promotion
Nonselection
75% Prom.(General
Selection)
15% plus shortfall
against LDCE by
DR(Comml. App.);
10% LDCE
Suitability with
prescribed
benchmark.
Rectt/Entry
grade(General
Selection)
PB-2(4600)
100% Promotion
100% Promotion
Suitability with
prescribed
benchmark.
100%
Promotion
Nonselection
40% DR.
60% Promotion
Selection
PB-2(4600)
Chief Law Assistant/745011500
100%
Promotion
Nonselection
40% DR.
60%
Promotion.(General
Selection)
Rectt/Entry
grade(General
Selection)
Asstt.Manager
Canteen/3050-4590
50% DR;
50% Promotion
Selection
PB1(1900)
50% DR;
50% Promotion
.(General Selection)
Rectt/Entry
grade(General
Selection)
Clerk/3200-
Commercial Supdt./650010500
9)
10)
Commercial
Inspec.
Gr.II(Marketing/Claims/R
ates/R&D) 6500-10500
Commercial
Inspec.
Gr.I(Marketing/Claims/Ra
tes/R&D) 6500-10500
Law Assistant/6500-10500
11)
12)
24.
Suitability with
prescribed
benchmark.
by
by
selection
Suitability with
prescribed
benchmark.
The claim of the respondent-applicants is that they have been
appointed as the Chief Commercial Clerk under the 15% Direct
Recruitment Quota sometime in the year 2013. Hence, they claimed
themselves to be the senior to that of the other recruits who have been
appointed as Commercial Inspector, Grade-III under 15% Direct
Recruitment quota some time in the year 2015.
Pl
see
footnote
1.
Pl.
see
foot Note
1.
Pl.
see
foot Note
2.
2026:JHHC:3557-DB
25.
The sets of the employees who have been appointed as
Commercial Inspector, Grade-III in the pay slab of Rs.5500-9000/- have
subsequently been promoted to the post of Commercial Inspector, GradeII in the pay scale of Rs.6500-10500/-.
26.
The respondent-applicants have raised the grievance that even
though they have been appointed sometime in the year 2013, but even
then they are still in the pay scale of Rs.5500-9000/-, while the other sets
of the employees who have been appointed as Commercial Inspector,
Grade-III sometime in the year 2015 have now been promoted to the next
higher hierarchy, i.e., the post of Commercial Inspector, Grade-II, in the
pay slab of Rs.6500-10500/-.
27.
They, therefore, have reached to the learned Tribunal for
rectifying the said anomaly as also by making a prayer of merger of the
post of Commercial Clerk and the Commercial Inspector, Grade-III so
that they may also be given the pay scale of Rs.6500-10500/- on being
promoted to the higher post having the pay scale of Rs.6500-10500/-.
28.
But the issue of merger has been decided in negative by holding
in paragraph-24 of the impugned order that the same being the policy
decision, it is none of the business of the Tribunal to pass a positive order
by merging the two cadres i.e., the cadre of Chief Commercial Clerk to
the Commercial Inspector into one cadre.
29.
Admittedly, the said part of the order has not been challenged by
the respondent-applicants by filing another writ petition, meaning
thereby, they have admitted the findings so recorded on the issue of
merger.
30.
The second issue, i.e., extending the pay scale of Rs.6500-
10500/- as had been extended in favour of the employees holding the post
2026:JHHC:3557-DB
of Commercial Inspector, Grade-III on being promoted to the post of
Commercial Inspector, Grade-II which was not made available.
31.
A finding has been recorded, on adjudication, that no parity can
be claimed by the respondent-applicants, since, the respondent-applicants
and Sachin Kumar Gupta and Anurag Kumar the employees holding the
post of Commercial Inspector, Grade-III and subsequently promoted to
the post of Commercial Inspector, Grade-II at the pay scale of Rs.650010500/- cannot be equated as both are having in the two different grades.
But even then, the pay scale has been granted in favour of the respondentapplicants of the pay scale of Rs.6500-10500/-.
32.
It further needs to refer herein that the pay scale of Rs.6500-
10500/- in the cadre of Chief Commercial Clerk is attached to the post of
Commercial Superintendent which is to be filled up, 100% by way of
promotion.
33.
It is, thus, evident that the learned Tribunal on the one hand has
declined to pass positive direction on the issue of merger, while on the
other hand, the pay scale attached to the post of Commercial
Superintendent, i.e., the pay scale of Rs.6500-10500/- has been extended
in favour of the respondent-applicants even though they were in the
substantive post of Chief Commercial Clerk without even granting
promotion to the higher post of Commercial Superintendent which is to
be filled up by way of promotion.
34.
The aforesaid fact has been rectified by the learned Tribunal by
way of onetime exercise.
35.
The question is that if the issue revolves around on the issue of
entitlement, can such relief be extended by way of onetime exercise.
2026:JHHC:3557-DB
36.
The answer of this Court is in negative, in view of the fact, that
the provision as contained under Article 226 of the Constitution is to be
exercised as a power to ask the respondent-applicants to remain in their
bound of law and not to exceed their bound of law. If the same is
applicable to the respondent concerned, then how can it be exceeded by
the Court of Law that is the question.
37.
Exercising the power conferred under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India does not mean that the Court having the power under
Article 226 of the Constitution will exceed its jurisdiction even though, as
per the decision taken by the authority, no entitlement is available to the
concerned employees as the fact of the present case is.
38.
The matter would have been different to exercise the power
conferred under Article 226 of the Constitution of India if the issue
touches the issue of parity, meaning thereby, if the violation of Article 14
of the Constitution of India, then certainly the Court having power under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India is to rectify so as to observe the
principle as laid down under Article 14 of the Constitution of India. But
while exercising such power, the Court having jurisdiction under Article
226 of the Constitution is duty bound to threadbare the difference in
between the reasonable classification and the un-classification. If the
difference is based upon the principle of reasonable classification, then
there is no application of Article 14 of the Constitution of India.
39.
While on the other hand, if the difference is based upon
unreasonable classification, then certainly Article 14 will be applicable
and in such situation in order to deal with the issue of hostile
discrimination, it is always available for the writ Court to exercise with
the power conferred under Article 226 of the Constitution of India to
2026:JHHC:3557-DB
rectify the same, reference may be made to the judgment of the Hon’ble
Apex Court rendered in “Western U.P. Electric Power & Supply Co. Ltd.
vs. State of U.P. (1969) 1 SCC 817 while observing that article 14 does
not operate against rational classification, has held as under:
“Article 14 of the Constitution ensures equality among equals : its
aim is to protect persons similarly placed against discriminatory
treatment. It does not however operate against rational
classification. A person setting up a grievance of denial of equal
treatment by law must establish that between persons similarly
circumstanced, some were treated to their prejudice and the
differential treatment had no reasonable relation to the object
sought to be achieved by the law.”
Further, the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of Air India vs.
Nergesh Meerza, (1981) 4 SCC 335 has observed that Article 14 forbids
hostile discrimination but not reasonable classification and Article 14
certainly applies where equals are treated differently without any
reasonable basis.
40.
Adverting to the factual aspect of the present case and as per the
tabular chart produced by the learned counsel appearing for the writ
petitioners, which has been admitted by the learned counsel appearing for
the respondent-applicants that the post of Chief Commercial Clerk having
the pay slab of Rs. 5500-9000/- and the next cadre of the post having the
pay slab of Rs.6500-10500/- is available to the post of Commercial
Superintendent to be filled up by way of promotion 100%. Meaning
thereby, the hierarchy of post of Chief Commercial Clerk is having its
own independent cadre and as having the different cadre it has no nexus
with the cadre of Commercial Inspector, Grade-III.
41.
The learned Tribunal has, however, admitted the aforesaid fact
as would be evident from paragraph-25 of the impugned order regarding
2026:JHHC:3557-DB
the placement of respondent-applicants and other sets of employees,
namely, Sachin Kumar Gupta and Anurag Kumar are in the two different
cadres, but even then the respondent-applicants have been granted relief
of the pay scale and it has been held that the respondent-applicants are
entitled for the pay scale of Rs.6500-10500/-.
42.
This Court is conscious of the jurisdiction conferred under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India which is the power of judicial
review as per the ratio laid down by the Hon’ble Apex Court at paragraph99 in the judgment rendered in the case of “L. Chandra Kumar” (Supra),
relevant paragraph-99 thereof is quoted hereunder as:
"99. In view of the reasoning adopted by us, we hold that clause 2(d)
of Article 323-A and clause 3(d) of Article 323-B, to the extent they
exclude the jurisdiction of the High Courts and the Supreme Court
under Articles 226/227 and 32 of the Constitution, are
unconstitutional. Section 28 of the Act and the "exclusion of
jurisdiction" clauses in all other legislations enacted under the aegis
of Articles 323- A and 323-B would, to the same extent, be
unconstitutional. The jurisdiction conferred upon the High Courts
under Articles 226/227 and upon the Supreme Court under Article
32 of the Constitution is a part of the inviolable basic structure of
our Constitution. While this jurisdiction cannot be ousted, other
courts and Tribunals may perform a supplemental role in
discharging the powers conferred by Articles 226/227 and 32 of the
Constitution. The Tribunals created under Article 323-A and Article
323- B of the Constitution are possessed of the competence to test
the constitutional validity of statutory provisions and rules. All
decisions of these Tribunals will, however, be subject to scrutiny
before a Division Bench of the High Court within whose jurisdiction
the Tribunal concerned falls. The Tribunals will, nevertheless,
continue to act like courts of first instance in respect of the areas of
law for which they have been constituted. It will not, therefore, be
open for litigants to directly approach the High Courts even in cases
where they question the vires of statutory legislations (except where
the legislation which creates the particular Tribunal is challenged)
by overlooking the jurisdiction of the Tribunal concerned. Section
2026:JHHC:3557-DB
5(6) of the Act is valid and constitutional and is to be interpreted in
the manner we have indicated."
43.
The power of judicial review has been deliberated by the Hon'ble
Apex Court, which is to be considered while exercising the said power
only to the extent that if any order is being passed found to be having error
on the face of the order or without jurisdiction or suffers from perversity.
The error apparent on the face of the order means that if the order appears
on its face having with error, then only the power of judicial review is to
be exercised.
44.
The Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of West Bengal Central
School Service Commission vs. Abdul Halim, (2019) 18 SCC 39, has
held at paragraph-30 that the power of judicial review must be exercised
by the Court after determining that the impugned is vitiated by an error
apparent on the face of 2026:JHHC:2418-DB the record and not the same
has been established by a process of reasoning. Paragraph-30 of the
aforesaid judgment is being referred as under:
"30. In exercise of its power of judicial review, the Court is to see
whether the decision impugned is vitiated by an apparent error of law.
The test to determine whether a decision is vitiated by error apparent
on the face of the record is whether the error is self-evident on the face
of the record or whether the error requires examination or argument to
establish it. If an error has to be established by a process of reasoning,
on points where there may reasonably be two opinions, it cannot be said
to be an error on the face of the record, as held by this Court
in Satyanarayan Laxminarayan Hegde v. Millikarjun Bhavanappa
Tirumale
[Satyanarayan
Laxminarayan
Hegde v.
Millikarjun
Bhavanappa Tirumale, AIR 1960 SC 137] . ---."
45.
In the case of T.C. Basappa vs. T. Nagappa and Anr., (1955) 1
SCR 250, their Lordship have held that the patent error in a decision can
2026:JHHC:3557-DB
be corrected by writ of certiorari, when it is manifested by the error
apparent on the face of the proceedings. The relevant portion of the
aforesaid judgment is quoted hereunder:
"11. ... An error in the decision or determination itself may also be
amenable to a writ of certiorari but it must be a manifest error apparent
on the face of the proceedings e.g. when it is based on clear ignorance
or disregard of the provisions of law. In other words, it is a patent error
which can be corrected by certiorari but not a mere wrong decision.
...."
46.
This Court has considered the impugned order passed by the
learned Tribunal on the touch stone of the ratio laid down by the Hon’ble
Apex Court at paragraph-99 in the case of “L. Chandra Kumar” (supra)
and as per the discussions made hereinabove, is of the view that the
findings so recorded by the learned Tribunal is well versed but the
conclusion which has been arrived holding the respondent-applicants
entitled the pay scale of Rs.6500-10500/- is totally contrary to the
aforesaid findings based upon the consideration made by the learned
Tribunal.
47.
This Court, therefore, is of the view that the power which has
been exercised by the learned Tribunal, by way of onetime exercise,
putting the respondent-applicants in the pay scale of Rs.6500-10500/- is
held to be exceeding the jurisdiction by the learned Tribunal.
48.
The law is well settled that if any order is passed exceeding the
jurisdiction, it is nullity in the eyes of law. Reference may be made to the
judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court rendered in Balvant N. Viswamitra
v. Yadav Sadashiv Mule reported in (2004) 8 SCC 706.
“..Where a court lacks inherent jurisdiction in passing a decree or
making an order, a decree or order passed by such court would be
without jurisdiction, non est and void ab initio. A defect of
jurisdiction of the court goes to the root of the matter and strikes
2026:JHHC:3557-DB
at the very authority of the court to pass a decree or make an order.
Such defect has always been treated as basic and fundamental and
a decree or order passed by a court or an authority having no
jurisdiction is a nullity. Validity of such decree or order can be
challenged at any stage, even in execution or collateral
proceedings.”
49.
Considering the aforesaid facts, the part of the order by which
the direction has been given by the tribunal holding the respondentapplicants entitled to the pay scale of Rs.6500-10500/- is hereby quashed
and set aside.
50.
In the result, these writs petitions stand allowed.
51.
Pending I.As, if any, stands allowed.
(Sujit Narayan Prasad, J.)
(Arun Kumar Rai, J.)
Dated:09.02.2026
Sudhir
A.F.R.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review