Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
23.09.2026
Item No.04
Court No.11
Avijit Mitra
MAT 1677 of 2025
with
I.A. No. CAN 1 of 2025
with
I.A. No. CAN 2 of 2025
Union of India & Ors.
-VersusDineshwar Singh
Mr. Anirban Mitra,
Mrs. Sarda Sha
… for the appellants
Mr. KBS Mahapatra,
Mr. Aditya Shit
….for the respondent
The present appeal has been preferred by the
Union of India and its functionaries challenging a
judgment dated 19th May, 2025 passed by the
learned single Judge in a writ petition being WPA
18137 of 2013 which was preferred by the writ
petitioner, namely, Dineshwar Singh (in short,
Dineshwar) praying for quashing and setting aside
‘the purported proceedings including the purported
Final Order being annexure P-7, Show cause Notice
being annexure P-9, Order of enhance penalty being
annexure P-11, and Appellate Order being annexure
P-14
and
to
reinstate
the
petitioner
with
all
consequential benefits’.
This case has a chequered history. Dineshwar
was roped into a disciplinary proceeding (in short,
DP) initiated through issuance of a chargesheet
vide
memo
dated
9th
September,
2008.
He
participated in the said proceeding and the Enquiry
Officer (in short, EO) submitted an inquiry report
and
forwarded
the
same
to
the
disciplinary
authority (in short, DA) and the DA passed the final
order on 6th June, 2009 imposing a punishment
that ‘the pay of No. 852160079 HC/GD Dineshwar
Singh be reduced by two stages from Rs. 8120/- to
Rs. 7510/- in the time scale of pay for a period of
two years with effect from the date of issue of this
order. It is further directed that No. 852160079
HC/GD Dineshwar Singh will not earn increments of
pay during the period of reduction and that on expiry
of this period, the reduction will have the effect of
postponing his future increments of pay’. Aggrieved
by the same, Dineshwar preferred a statutory
appeal which was disposed of by an order dated
17th August, 2009 enhancing the penalty to the
extent of ‘compulsory retirement from service with all
admissible pensionary benefits’. Challenging the
said order, Dineshwar preferred a writ petition
being W.P. No. 15485 of 2009 which was disposed
of by an order dated 3rd January, 2013 observing,
inter alia, that ‘I do not think the petitioner should be
deprived of the opportunity of lodging an appeal
against the order inflicting on him enhanced penalty.
Hence, I am of the view that the petitioner should be
relegated to the appellate authority for lodging an
appeal under r.46(3) of the rules’. Accepting the said
order, Dineshwar preferred a statutory appeal
which was disposed of by an order dated 23 rd May,
2013 observing, inter alia, that the penalty awarded
by
the
AA
on
17th
August,
is
well
commensurate with the gravity of misconduct.
Challenging the said order, the writ petition being
WPA 18137 of 2013 was filed and the judgment
delivered in the same has been impugned in the
present appeal.
Mr. Mitra, learned advocate appearing for the
appellants submits that Dineshwar being a member
of the Central Armed Force was required to
maintain a very high degree of discipline, decency
and commitment to the force. The conduct of
Dineshwar was found to be unbecoming of a
member of the Force and the charges stood
established against him. Considering the gravity of
the charges, the AA rightly enhanced the penalty.
The learned single Judge ought not to have
substituted its own discretion for that of the
competent authority. Reliance has been placed
upon a judgment delivered in the case of Union of
India & ors. Vs. Diler Singh reported in (2016) 4
S.C.R. 473.
He argues that it is well-settled that Courts
cannot assume the function of the DA and decide
the quantum of punishment. Such authority is
exclusively within the jurisdiction of the competent
appellate authority. The only exception to such
principle would be in those cases were a codelinquent has been awarded a lesser punishment
even
when
the
charges
of
misconduct
were
identical. The learned single Judge glossed over the
said issue and did not return any finding. Reliance
has been placed upon a judgment delivered in the
case of Union of India & ors. Vs. Ex. Constable Ram
Karan, reported in (2022)1 SCC 373.
Mr. Mitra strenuously argues that the question
as to whether there was a scuffle or how it occurred
or
what
precipitated
such
scuffle
is
of
no
consequence when admittedly there was a scuffle
which involved Dineshwar. Considering the gravity
of the charges and the past conduct of Dineshwar,
the AA rightly enhanced the punishment imposed
by the DA. The said order of enhancement did not
suffer from any jurisdictional error warranting
interference of the learned single Judge. In support
of such contention reliance has been placed upon a
judgment delivered by a coordinate Bench of this
Court in an appeal being MAT 2990 of 2024 (Union
of India & Ors. Vs. R. Kasivelu).
According to Mr. Mitra, Dineshwar on the date of
incident was under the influence of intoxication and
considering
the
gravity
of
the
charges,
the
punishment of compulsory retirement was issued.
The writ Court in the earlier round of litigation by
an order dated 3rd January, 2013 relegated the
issue for consideration of the AA only on the point
as to whether the enhancement was proper. In
strict consonance with such direction, the AA by
the order dated 23rd May, 2013 affirmed the earlier
order dated 17th August, 2009 disclosing the
reasons and upon granting due opportunity of
hearing. The learned single Judge, however, set
aside the said order on the rudiments of a single
observation that the enhancement of punishment to
compulsory
retirement
was
disproportionate.
Surprisingly,
such
observation
is
totally
contradictory to the findings of the learned single
Judge arrived at paragraph nos. 30, 31 and 32 of
the impugned judgment. In paragraph 32 it was
remarked that ‘this Court is aligned with proven
charges against the petitioner and declines to
interfere with the same’. In view of such apparent
inconsistency
and
contradiction,
the
judgment
impugned is not sustainable.
Mr. Mahapatra, learned advocate appearing for
Dineshwar, however, denies and disputes the
contention of Mr. Mitra and drawing our attention
to the provisions of section 8 of the Central
Industrial Security Force Act, 1968 (in short, Act
1968) submits that ‘the article of Charge no. I and II
were not within the jurisdiction of the Disciplinary
Authority’ and that ‘the provision confined in Proviso
to Section 18 of the CISF Act 1968 the allegations
contained in the Article of Charge-III is a nullity in
the eye of law’. The entire proceeding thus suffers
from a jurisdictional error and as such the order
passed in the second statutory appeal was rightly
interfered with and punishment was reduced from
compulsory retirement to stoppage of increment as
directed by the DA.
He contends that the AA by the order dated 23 rd
May, 2013 did not interfere with the order passed
by the AA on 17th August, 2009 though the same
was clearly wrong. In the said conspectus, the
learned single Judge rightly set aside both the
orders dated 17th August, 2009 and 23 rd May 2013
and directed disbursement of all dues and other
statutory reliefs on the basis of the order passed by
the DP on 6th June, 2009. The contents of
paragraph nos. 30, 31 and 32 of the impugned
judgment are the arguments advanced on behalf of
respondents in the writ petition.
He
further
argues
that
the
principles
of
disproportionate punishment are directly invocable
in the facts and circumstances of the case more so
when Dineshwar went outside the NHPC Main Gate
on 19th May, 2008 at about 11.00 hrs after making
entry in the out pass register kept at NHPC Main
Gate Subansiri but such fact was not granted any
weightage by the AA while passing order dated 23 rd
May, 2013.
We have heard the learned advocates appearing
for the respective parties and considered the
materials on record.
In exercise of judicial review, the Court cannot
re-appreciate the evidence on the basis of which the
finding of misconduct has been arrived at. The
Court can interfere only where there has been a
violation of the principles of natural justice or when
the finding of misconduct is not based on some
evidence or when the penalty imposed is shockingly
disproportionate. The judgment impugned in the
present appeal does not disclose any reason as to
why the punishment imposed by the AA by the
order dated 23rd May, 2013 was interfered with. The
final decision taken in paragraph 34 of the
judgment also appears to be contrary to the
findings of the learned single Judge in paragraph
32 of the impugned judgment wherein it has been
remarked inter alia that ‘this Court is aligned with
proven charges against the petitioner and declines to
interfere with the same’.
Indisputably, the judgment impugned in the
present
appeal
has
not
been
challenged
by
Dineshwar and as such the only conclusion that
can be drawn is that Dineshwar is not aggrieved by
the order of punishment as imposed by the DA and
as such at this stage it cannot be argued that the
charges
against
Dineshwar
have
not
been
established.
The discretion exercised by the AA in the order
dated 23rd May, 2013 affirming the findings of the
AA in the earlier order dated 17 th August, 2009
stands supported with reasons. Such decision was
taken upon granting due opportunity of hearing to
Dineshwar and as such the learned single Judge
ought not to have interfered with the same upon
returning findings contrary to the ultimate decision.
The
learned
single
Judge
erred
in
law
in
substituting the punishment imposed by the AA.
For the reasons discussed above, the judgment
dated 19th May, 2025 impugned in the present
appeal is set aside.
The appeal and the connected applications are,
accordingly, disposed of.
There shall, however, be no order as to costs.
Urgent photostat certified copy of this order, if
applied for, be supplied to the parties upon
compliance of all necessary formalities.
(Partha Pratim Roy, J.)
(Tapabrata Chakraborty, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review