Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 01
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WA No. 23 of 2023
Date of Order: 08.12.2023
Union of India & Ors
Vs.
Shri Gordon Kynsai Nongkynrih
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Hon’ble Mr. Justice B. Bhattacharjee, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s)
:
For the Respondent(s)
:
Dr. N. Mozika, DSGI with
Ms. A. Pradhan, Adv.
Mr. S. Sen, Adv.
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT & ORDER
Per B. Bhattacharjee, J.
This writ appeal seeks to challenge the judgment and order dated
01.12.2022 passed in WP(C) No. 96 of 2022 whereby the writ petition
filed by the respondent herein was disposed of with a direction to the
appellant to consider the case of the writ petitioner for treating his
appointment in a substantive/ permanent capacity.
1.
The fact of the case giving rise to this appeal is that an
advertisement dated 25.02.2010 was issued by the National Institute of
Electronic and Information Technology (NIELIT) formerly known as
Department of Electronics and Accreditation of Computer Course
(DOEACC), inviting application for filling up various sanctioned posts
on regular basis which included 3(three) posts of Scientists/ Engineer „C‟.
The essential qualification for the post of Scientists/ Engineer „C‟ was
prescribed as BE/B.Tech, MSc in relevant fields or recognized equivalent
qualification with not less than 65% marks. The writ petitioner having
requisite qualification of MSc Computer Science, applied for the said
post through proper channel as he was then working in National
Informatic Centre (NIC), Mizoram as a Scientific Officer in a substantive
capacity. The candidature of the writ petitioner was found to be valid and
complete in all respect and he was called for interview. On the conclusion
of the selection process, the writ petitioner was recommended by the
Selection Committee for appointment and his name appeared at Serial
No. 1, whereafter, an offer was made to the writ petitioner for
appointment to the post of Scientist „C‟ on short term basis for a period of
5(five) years. On 19-10-2010, an appointment order was issued and the
writ petitioner joined the post at Aizawl centre and since then he has been
provided with all the regular benefits of pay scale including increment,
revised pay scale, contribution to provident fund, etc. Thereafter, the writ
petitioner was transferred to Itanagar along with the post on 02-05-2011
with two others who were appointed as Scientist „B‟. The writ petitioner
continued working in Itanagar till the month of November 2019 when he
was transferred to Shillong where he is serving till date. The grievance of
the writ petitioner is that inspite of his continuance in service on a regular
pay scale, his service was not regularized in terms of the advertisement
dated 25-02-2010. The other two candidates who applied for the post of
Scientist „B‟ in response to the same advertisement were appointed on
regular
basis.
Feeling
discriminated,
the
writ
petitioner
filed
representations seeking appointment against sanctioned posts from the
date of joining, but the respondents did not take any action. Aggrieved
thereby, the writ petitioner approached this Court by filing writ petition
under Article 226 of the Constitution of India. The writ Court vide
impugned judgment and order dated 01-12-2022 disposed of the writ
petition in the following terms: “ 13. In view of the facts and circumstances of the case, the
respondents are therefore directed to consider the case of the
petitioner for treating his appointment to the post of Scientist „C‟,
NIELIT in a substantive/permanent capacity with effect from
08.10.2010, the date, the petitioner joined, pursuant to the offer of
appointment dated 10.08.2010.”
2.
The Union of India through the Secretary, Department of
Electronics and Information Technology, Ministry of Electronics and
Information Technology along with nine others have assailed the
aforesaid judgment of the writ court in the present appeal.
3.
Dr. N. Mozika, learned DSGI appearing for the appellant submits
that the Aizawl centre, which was created in the year 2009, did not adhere
to the recruitment rules of NIELIT (formerly DOEACC) which stipulated
the essential qualification for the post of Scientist „C‟ as 1 st Class
B.E./recognized equivalent qualification with not less than 65% marks; or
M. Tech/M.E./M. Design or Ph.D. (Engg.) and inserted M.Sc. in relevant
field without any basis while issuing the advertisement. He further
submits that the Aizawl centre also ignored the twin instructions
contained in the letter dated 10-12-2009 issued from the headquarters of
DOEACC and published the said advertisement for filling up vacancies
on regular/deputation basis, including permanent absorption instead of
stating that the post were to be filled up temporarily, on short term basis
and would be transferred to Itanagar as and when required. He submits
that the selection committee also miserably erred in recommending the
name of the writ petitioner who had only an M.Sc. degree which is not
equivalent to B.Tech. or M.Tech. and till date, the writ petitioner has not
acquired the requisite qualification. He contends that the advertisement
was issued in violation of the prevalent recruitment rules and the
instruction dated 10-12-2009 and the writ petitioner, as such, cannot
claim regularization of service. Referring to the offer of appointment
dated 10-08-2010, the learned DSGI submits that the appointment was on
short term contract basis for a period of 5(five) years and the writ
petitioner having accepted it, cannot now claim appointment in
substantive/permanent capacity with effect from the date of his joining.
4.
Dr. N. Mozika, the learned DSGI further submits that the decision
of the Gauhati High Court rendered in WP(C)286(AP)/2015 relied on by
the writ petitioner in the present case is misplaced as the writ petitioners
in that case were regularized as they were meeting the eligibility criteria
as per the recruitment rules of DOEACC society at that time for the post
of Scientist „B‟. He submits that the writ petitioner in the present case is
not covered by the aforesaid decision as his educational qualification is
only M.Sc. Computer Science which is not a valid qualification for
Scientist „C‟. He thus submits that the impugned judgment and order
dated 01-12-2022 cannot be sustained in law and facts and the same
requires to be interfered with. He relies on the decision of the Apex Court
reported in (2018) 3 SCC 55, Ashish Kumar v. State of Uttar Pradesh &
Ors. (para-27) to assert that when there is a variance in the advertisement
and in the statutory rules, it is the statutory rules which prevails.
5.
In response, Mr. S. Sen, learned counsel appearing for the
respondent/writ petitioner submits that the essential qualification for the
post of Scientist „C‟ prescribed in the advertisement is not in violation of
the approved recruitment rules of NIELIT (formerly DOEACC) inasmuch
as, M.Sc. in relevant field would mean M.Sc. in any technical discipline
such as Computer Science, which the writ petitioner possesses. He further
submits that the selection process was conducted by a Selection
Committee comprising of experts which after detailed scrutiny of all the
aspects including qualification, recommended the name of the writ
petitioner. There is nothing on record to show that the same
recommendation was ever altered or doubted by any other expert body.
He submits that whether the qualification possessed by the petitioner is
equivalent qualification or not, can only be decided by a committee
comprising of expert and in absence of that, the appellants cannot contend
that the writ petitioner does not possess requisite qualification to deny
him regular appointment. The learned counsel further refers to a letter
dated 08-12-2009 communicating the approval of amendment of Rule 3.1
of Service/Staff Rules of DOEACC Society by the Governing Council of
the Society and submits that the said amendment provided for recruitment
only on regular basis or on deputation basis including permanent
absorption against the sanctioned post by replacing the earlier rule which
provided for appointment on contract or deputation basis for five years.
He contends that the letter dated 10-12-2009, which was issued two days
after the communication of the amendment, is totally contradictory to the
aforesaid amendment in so far as it relates to the instruction for filling up
vacancies on temporary or short- term basis.
6.
Mr. Sen, learned counsel also submits that the writ court has
rightly placed its reliance on the decision of the Gauhati High Court
rendered in WP(C) No. 286(AP)/2015 as it squarely covers the issue of
claim of the writ petitioner for appointment in substantive/permanent
capacity. He submits that the said decision has already been implemented
by the appellants herein and the petitioners therein have been regularized
in the post of Scientist „B‟ from the date of their joining. He submits that
in the above and circumstances, the plea of the appellant raised on the
basis of the stipulation made in the letter dated 10-12-2009 cannot be
maintained at this stage and the writ appeal is liable to be dismissed
forthwith. The learned counsel in support of his argument placed reliance
on the following decisions: -
(1) AIR 1965 SC 491, University of Mysore v. C.D. Govinda
Rao & Anr. (para-12.)
(2) (1986) 3 SCC 156, Central Inland Water Transport
Corporation Ltd. & Anr. v. Brojo Nath Ganguly & Anr. (para96).
(3) (2006) 2 SCC 747, State of Karnataka & Ors. v. C.
Lalitha.(para 29)
(4) (2019) 15 SCC 59, Sridip Chatterjee v. Gopa Chakraborty
& Ors. (para-14)
7.
The submissions advanced by the respective parties have been
carefully considered. It appears that the contentions of the appellants
before this Court in the present writ appeal is exactly the same which
were raised before the writ court. The writ court has elaborately dealt
with those contentions and recorded a detailed finding which is
reproduced below: “10. Before dealing with the point of the qualification criteria, as raised by the
respondents, the other conditions of appointment between the writ petitioner
herein, and the writ petitioners in WP(C) No. 286 of 2015, are exactly on the
same footing, as the entire recruitment of the appointees was through the same
selection process emanating from the same advertisement dated 25.02.2010.
The judgment of the Gauhati High Court, in this respect has great persuasive
value, as the question of the irrationality and arbitrary action of the
respondents in discriminating between the appointees, has been discussed in
great detail, and a finding arrived at, that such action was totally unfair, while
allowing the writ petitions. In this context, it would be apposite to quote 2
paragraphs, which are relevant namely Para – 10 and 11 of the said judgment.
“10. As per the earlier Rule 3.1 of Service/Staff Rules of DOEACC
Society, all appointments will be made either on contract or on
deputation basis for a period of 5 years as against the sanction posts
on graded scale of pay. On completion of said period, the contract
can be further be extended based on performance. The said Rule was
amended subsequently vide Annexure – 4 whereby it is provided that
“all appointments will be made either by the direct recruitment on
regular basis or on deputation basis including permanent absorption
against the sanctioned posts.” It is to be noted that after this
amendment, the authorities has advertised for recruitment to the
several posts including the posts of ScientistB (of the petitioners) for
filling up of various posts on regular/deputation basis including
permanent
absorption
basis,
dated
25.02.2010.
From
the
communication of the respondent authority vide Annexure – 5B, dated
12.05.2010, it appears that the authorities has intimated the member
of the selection committee that they are intending to recruit Scientist
B and C on regular basis. Thereafter, the selection Committee
recommended the selection of both the petitioners and petitioner No.
2 secured the 2nd position in the select list whereas the petitioner No.
1 secured 6 th position in the select list and one K.H. RekaDevi stood
3rd position and another V. Khiangte secured 1st position. But while
issuing appointment order to present two petitioners, they were
appointed for short term Contract basis for 5 years whereas the other
two above named persons Serial No. 1 & 3 has been appointed on
regular basis on the same scale of pay. Such an affair on the part of
the respondents is wholly contrary to their own advertisement. As has
been mentioned above, as per the amended Rules, no appointment
can be made on contract basis. It is apparent that the authority has
not only flouted the norms and Rules and has arbitrarily used the
power of discretion while appointing the present two petitioners. As
has been discussed above, the respondent authorities is a State as per
the Article 12 of the Constitution of India and as such they are bound
to carry transparency in the matter of selection and appointment
strictly according to the Rules, which has not been adhered to by the
respondent authority. Although, discretion always not a subject of
criticism but such discretion should be exercised only on the sound
principle of reasonableness which is not found in the given case. The
respondent authority has extremely failed to disclose anything as to
the reason of deviating from their own Rules and procedure and as
about the reasons for exercising such discretion. 11. It is pertinent to
note here all the selected candidates stood at par with each other and
there is no opinion of the selection committee whatsoever that such
persons should be categorized while at the time of appointment, as
has been done by the respondent authorities. Without going any
further, it can be held that decision of the respondent authority is
vitiated by arbitrariness and beyond the test of reasonableness and
liable to be interfered into.”
11. Thus it is seen that the judgment of the Gauhati High Court has
covered this aspect, after examining the entire gament and actions of the
respondents, with regard to the writ petitioners in WP(C) No. 286 of
2015, who are exactly on the same footing as the petitioners, which this
Court notes and adopts the said finding.
12. On the question of qualifications, though arguments have been
raised, and materials sought to be shown, that the petitioner did not meet
the prescribed requirements, and further that the advertisement had been
issued in violation of the directions of NIELIT (formerly DOEACC), in
the considered view of the Court, it is too late in the day, for the
respondents to raise such objections. This is in view of the fact, that the
advertisement had been issued as far back as in February, 2010, and a
selection process, which had been conducted thereafter, had found the
candidature of the writ petitioner to meet the requirements. The selection
no doubt, being conducted by a duly constituted selection committee, an
expert body, had found the petitioner suitable for appointment, and it
follows that the qualification of the writ petitioner, had therefore been
found to be equivalent and suitable, to be recommended for
appointment. The respondents therefore, cannot at this stage, take a
stance that the petitioner did not meet the educational qualification
criteria and that the appointment was never meant to be regular. No
fault, negligence or suppression can be attributed in any manner to the
writ petitioner, and in fact, he had given up a regular post in the NIC to
join the respondent organization, in the secure hope that he was applying
for a regular post, as was advertised. The respondents therefore, are
estopped from taking an alternate stance, in disowning their
advertisement to deny the writ petitioner the benefit of regular status or
for consideration thereof.”
8.
The appellants have failed to point out any infirmity or illegality
in the aforesaid finding recorded by the writ court. We also do not see
any apparent reason to disagree with the above finding or to adopt any
different view other than what has been expressed by the writ court.
9.
Moreover, it appears from the materials on record that pursuant to
the advertisement, a selection committee comprising of as many as 6(six)
experts from various departments, was constituted by the respondent to
conduct the recruitment process. The selection committee after thorough
scrutiny of all aspects including educational qualification of each and
every candidate recommended the name of the selected candidates for the
post of Scientist „C‟ wherein the name of the writ petitioner appeared at
serial No.1. Nothing has been brought to our notice to establish that the
recommendation of the selection committee, in so far as it relates to the
candidature of the writ petitioner, stood interfered with or doubted at any
point of time by any other committee or authority of the appellants. No
material has been placed before us by the appellants to support its stand
on the insufficiency of qualification of the writ petitioner. There is also
nothing on record to show that M.Sc. Computer Science is held to be not
equivalent qualification for the post of Scientist „C‟. In absence of any
such material, it is not possible for this Court to hold that the writ
petitioner does not possess the requisite qualification. The proposition of
law laid down in the case of Ashish Kumar (supra) relied on by the
appellants cannot be applied here to hold that there exists a variance in
the advertisement and the related recruitment rules.
10.
It is an admitted fact that pursuant to the appointment of the writ
petitioner in the post of Scientist „C‟, he has been continuing in the
department on the strength of various extension orders beyond the initial
period of five years. The appellants never sought to terminate or remove
the writ petitioner from service for want of requisite qualification. The
only objection taken by the appellants appears to be against the claim of
regularization of the service of the writ petitioner and not against his
continuation on temporary basis. There is nothing on record to show that
the prescribed qualification for contractual appointment and regular
appointment are different from each other. If the appellants seriously
contends that the writ petitioner lacks in educational qualification, his
service should not have been extended from time to time. Thus, the
objection of the appellants to the claim of the writ petitioner seems to be
in defiance of any logic and cannot be accepted.
11.
In addition, it is noticed that a period of more than 13(thirteen)
years have lapsed from the date of advertisement and appointment of the
writ petitioner, but no action has been taken by the department either to
recall or cancel the recommendation made in favour of the writ petitioner.
It appears that no corrigendum or clarification was also issued at any
point of time to rectify or alter the stipulations made in the advertisement.
Inspite of all these, even if it assumed at this stage that the appointment of
the writ petitioner was proper, the writ petitioner cannot be made to suffer
on account of failure of the appellants in view of the fact that the writ
petitioner had given up a regular post in the NIC to join the present post
of Scientist „C‟.
12.
Since this Court is not inclined to interfere with the impugned
judgment and order dated 01-12-2022 passed in WP(C) No. 96 of 2022,
the analysis of the citations relied on by the learned counsel for the
respondent/ writ petitioner is deemed not necessary.
13.
In view of the discussions made above, there is no merit in the
present appeal and it is accordingly dismissed.
14.
There will be no order as to costs.
(B. Bhattacharjee)
Judge
(W. Diengdoh)
Judge
Meghalaya
08.12.2023
“ N. Swer, Stenographer, Gr-II ”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review