Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No.01
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WA No. 18/2019 with
MC (WA) No. 36/2019
Date of order: 05.09.2022
The Union of India & ors.
Vs.
Balbir Singh Yadav
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sanjib Banerjee, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Appellants
:
For the Respondent :
Mr. N. Syngkon, Adv with
Ms. L. Phanjom, Adv
Mr. M.L. Nongpiur, Adv with
Mr. S. Syiem, Adv
i)
Whether approved for
reporting in Law journals etc.:
Yes
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
JUDGMENT: (per the Hon’ble, the Chief Justice) (Oral)
The appeal is directed against an order of December 21, 2018 by
which the respondent’s writ petition was allowed and certain benefits
conferred on the respondent that the appellant asserts that the respondent
was not entitled to.
2.
It appears that persons occupying clerical posts in the Assam
Rifles were paid less than similarly positioned persons in the other
Central Armed Police Forces. As a result, persons occupying clerical
posts in Assam Rifles petitioned to this Court for the anomaly to be
removed. By a judgment and order of the Gauhati High Court (from
which this Court was carved out in 2013) the petition was allowed on
August 23, 2012. The operative part of the order dated August 23, 2012
provided as follows:
“14. In the result, this writ petition stands disposed of with the
direction to the respondent No.2, the Director General of Assam
Rifles to take up the matter again with the respondent No. 1, i.e.
the Secretary to the Govt. of India, Ministry of Home Affairs to
bring parity in respect of rank structure and pay of the Assam
Rifles clerical cadre at par with other CPOs by introducing rank
of Assistant Sub-Inspector (Warrant Officer) at the entry grade
w.e.f. 1.1.1986 in the scale of pay of Rs.1320-2040 (revised
Rs.4000-6000) w.e.f. 1.1.1996 or any other date as the authority
or any other date as the authority deem it fit and proper with all
consequential service benefits in the light of the Government of
India, Ministry of Finance resolution dated 20.9.1997
communicated through MHA letter bearing No.2701-02/1/97
PC Cell/Pef-1 dated 10.10.1997. The whole exercise would be
completed within a period of 6 (six) months from the date of
receipt of a certified copy of this judgment and order.”
3.
There is no dispute that the judgment was upheld in appeal by an
order of April 30, 2013. Special leave petitions carried from the appellate
order were taken up by the Supreme Court and the resultant appeals
dismissed by an order of November 17, 2015. Thus, clerical staff in
Assam Rifles became entitled to the same pay and benefits as persons in
clerical posts in the other Central Armed Police Forces.
4.
The writ petitioner in the present case sought to use the order
granting additional benefits to persons occupying clerical posts in Assam
Rifles only by virtue of the fact that the writ petitioner was initially
inducted into Assam Rifles in or about 1987 as a clerk in the Duty
Company of Assam Rifles Training Centre and School.
5.
However, it is the admitted position, as will appear from
paragraphs 3 and 4 of the writ petition, that the writ petitioner was
unsuccessful in the examination conducted at the end of the initial
training period and, as a consequence, the writ petitioner was re-mustered
in the general cadre. It is necessary to notice what has been pleaded in
such regard at paragraphs 3 and 4 of the writ petition:
“3. … The consequence being that the petitioner was
unsuccessful in the said written/typing examination.
“4. That the petitioner states that thereafter, the petitioner was
ordered to undergo basic training of Riflemen (General Duty) on
this very ground that he was unsuccessful in the written exam and
his trade was re-mustered from Lnk (Writer) to Rifleman
(General Duty)…”
6.
There is, no doubt, that a grievance is expressed in the petition
that the writ petitioner was virtually demoted to the post of Rifleman
(General Duty). However, the perceived demotion appears to have been
in the light of the writ petitioner failing to pass the examination for
retaining his position in the clerical cadre. At any rate, the perceived
demotion was in or about the year 1988. The writ petitioner accepted the
alleged demotion, continued to discharge the duties of the post that was
assigned to him and obtained the benefits and perquisites of the post,
including several promotions over a period of more than 20 years.
7.
Upon the persons in the clerical posts in Assam Rifles obtaining
substantial benefit by virtue of the order of the Gauhati High Court of
2012 as affirmed in appeal and ultimately upheld by the Supreme Court
in 2015, the writ petitioner carried a petition to this Court complaining
that several other persons who had served for short durations in the
clerical posts had been given the benefit of the order pertaining to clerks
but the writ petitioner had been singled out to be denied the same.
8.
Indeed, paragraph 8 of the writ petition specifically referred to a
list published by Assam Rifles on July 13, 2016 and the writ petitioner
pointed out that the employer had included the names of “Clerks Cadre
Personnel who have put the service even 03 to 10 months.” The writ
petitioner asserted that the personnel named in the relevant list at Serial
Nos. 1 to 5, 11, 73, 86, 224 and 254 were such persons who had served
in the clerical cadre for a short duration. Though it remained unsaid in
the writ petition, the clear insinuation was that such other personnel had
been similarly reduced to general or the like cadre after a short duration,
just like the writ petitioner, but by virtue of the fact that they were initially
appointed in the clerical cadre, the other personnel indicated in the
relevant paragraph of the writ petition had been conferred the additional
benefit that was accorded to all clerks in Assam Rifles following the
decision of the Gauhati High Court of August 23, 2012.
9.
The writ petitioner’s assertion that the several persons in the list
as indicated at paragraph 8 of the writ petition were similarly placed as
the writ petitioner was robustly denied in the affidavit filed by Assam
Rifles. At paragraph 15 of the affidavit filed by Assam Rifles, it was
clearly asserted as follows:
“15. … So far as the case of persons mentioned at serial No 1 to
5, 11, 73, 86, 224 and 254 of DGAR order ibid is concerned, it is
humbly submitted that they have served in the force as clerks
whereas the petitioner has not served as Clerk in the Force.”
10.
Once it was the admitted position, as evident from the petition
itself, that though the writ petitioner may have been recruited in the
clerical post but the writ petitioner was thereafter re-mustered in the
general cadre for the writ petitioner failing to pass the requisite
examination to retain his clerical post, the writ petitioner was disentitled
from claiming any benefit that came with the clerical post. Merely
because the writ petitioner occupied the clerical post for a few months or
even a year before he was assigned to the general cadre would not entitle
the writ petitioner to any of the benefits that persons in clerical posts in
Assam Rifles gained as a virtue of the said judgment of August 23, 2012.
There could have been no other view of the matter.
11.
It, however, appears that the writ court, in the confused manner
in which it recorded the facts made an error in the appreciation of the
facts and, as a consequence, arrived at the wrong conclusion to confer an
undeserving benefit on the writ petitioner. The same would be apparent
from the second page of the order impugned and what is effectively the
third sub-paragraph under paragraph 2 of the order.
12.
In the light of the writ petitioner’s unequivocal acknowledgement
that the writ petitioner was re-mustered in the general cadre as a Rifleman
and continued to serve Assam Rifles in such post and in promoted posts
in the general cadre, the writ petitioner could not have claimed any
benefit granted to members in the clerical service since the writ petitioner
ceased to be in a clerical position after being re-mustered in the general
cadre following the writ petitioner’s failure to pass the examination to be
retained in the clerical post.
13.
Since the writ petitioner has severed all connections to the clerical
post in Assam Rifles in or about the year 1989 and the writ petitioner
continued to serve in the general cadre and gained due promotion by or
about the time his writ petition was instituted, the writ petitioner could
not have sought any benefit in terms of the order dated August 23, 2012.
The writ court fell into error in treating the writ petitioner on the same
footing as others in the Assam Rifles who were recruited in the clerical
posts and continued to serve in the clerical posts without being
subsequently re-mustered or reassigned to any lower cadre for their
failure to meet the minimum requirements of retaining the clerical post.
14.
Accordingly, the judgment and order impugned dated December
21, 2018 stand set aside. As a consequence, WP(C) No. 147 of 2017
instituted by the writ petitioner is dismissed in its entirety.
15.
WA No. 18 of 2019 succeeds.
16.
MC (WA) No.36 of 2019 stands disposed of.
17.
There will be no order as to costs.
(W. Diengdoh)
Judge
(Sanjib Banerjee)
Chief Justice
Meghalaya
05.09.2022
“Lam DR-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review