Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
1 / 30
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
Ct. No.1
Item No.D/L.8
Saikat
Mukherjee
MAT/1651/2026
with
CAN/1/2026
THE STATE OF WEST BENGAL
]… Appellant
Versus
MILAN PRADHAN AND OTHERS
]… Respondents
Appearance:
Mr. Rajdeep Mazumder, A.A.G. with Mr. Ajit Kumar Mishra, A.G.P., Mr. Moyukh
Mukherjee, Mr. Milind Mohul Ghosh, Ms. Sagnika Banerjee, Ms. Rita Das, Mr.
Soumya Raha and Mr. Yuvraj Chatterjee, …..Advocates for the Appellant
Mr. Ayan Bhattacharya, Sr. Adv. with Mr. Sanjay Banerjee, Mr. Zohaib Rauf, Mr.
Ajitesh Pandey, Ms. Sriparna Das, Mr. Sk. Anwar Ali, Mr. Jayanta Narayan Das,
Mr. S. Ghosh, Mr. Prashant Bagchi, Ms. Sumitra Neogi, Mr. Abid Jamal, Mr.
Manojit Bhattacharya, Ms. Anjana Banerjee, Ms. Sarbani Mukhopadhyay, Mr.
Samirul Sardar, Mr. Mrinmoy Bhattacharyya, Mr. Abhi Bhattacharya, Mr. Arka
Chakraborty, Mr. Anish Mukherjee, Mr. Kundan Bharti, Mr. Manish Ojha, Mr.
Asfak Ahammed,
........Advocates for the Respondents
CORAM
:
RAVINDRA V. GHUGE, CJ.
&
OM NARAYAN RAI, J.
DATE
:
25th September, 2026.
2 / 30
ORDER (Per Court)
1.
Considering that all the papers which placed before the learned
Single Judge are before us, we have finally heard the Appeal along with the
Application for stay, by consent of the parties.
2.
By this intra-court Appeal, the State of West Bengal has assailed
an order passed by the Learned Single Judge of this Court dated 24.09.2026, in
Writ Petition no.27141 of 2026, filed by Shri Milan Pradhan vs. The State of
West Bengal and Others.
For the sake of brevity, we are reproducing the said order dated
24.09.2026, hereunder:“1. Matter is heard in presence of learned advocates
representing petitioner and State respondents.
2. Mr. Ayan Bhattacharya, learned Senior Advocate
representing petitioner submits that writ petition was
heard on 22nd September, 2026 when two sets of criminal
prosecutions were considered by this Court in view of
particulars indicated in paragraphs 27 and 28 of the
writ petition.
3. In presence of learned Senior Advocate representing
petitioner and learned Additional Advocate General
representing State respondents it was not surfaced
before this Court that another criminal prosecution
being Khejuri Police Station Case No.45/2007 dated
31st July, 2007 corresponding to G.R. Case No.369/2007
was pending against petitioner. Based on submissions
made on behalf of State respondents, Court proceeded
on the premise that petitioner was in custody on 22nd
September, 2026 in connection with five criminal
3 / 30
prosecutions as stated in paragraph 27 and out of six
criminal prosecutions stated in paragraph 28, it was
found five were not subsisting and in Nandigram Police
Station Case No.156/2007 dated 10th October, 2007
petitioner is not accused.
4. Had pendency of criminal prosecution being Khejuri
Police Station Case No.45/2007 dated 31st July, 2007
been brought to the notice of this Court on
22nd September, 2026, same could have been taken into
consideration
5. On 22nd September, 2026 Court directed the writ
petition to appear in the supplementary list for further
consideration on 12th October, 2026 having found that
apart from five criminal prosecutions as disclosed in
paragraph 27 no other criminal prosecutions are
pending against petitioner. Subsequently, matter was
mentioned on behalf of petitioner on 23rd September,
2026 in view of urgency since petitioner was treated
arrested after 22nd September, 2026 in connection with
Khejuri Police Station Case No.45/2007 dated 31" July,
2007.
6. Mr. Rajdeep Mazumder, learned Additional Advocate
General has placed before this Court order dated 19th
September, 2026 passed in G.R. Case No.369/2007
which is connected to Khejuri Police Station Case
No.45/2007 dated 31st July, 2007 wherefrom it appears
that Investigating Officer prayed for "shown arrest of
the petitioner being accused in view of warrant of arrest
issued against petitioner. It is contended on behalf of
State respondents that production warrant was
subsisting but Court does not find any document
wherefrom it can be concluded that production warrant
in connection with Khejuri Police Station Case
No.45/2007 dated 31st July, 2007 was served upon
petitioner at the material point of time. Therefore,
contention of State respondents regarding execution of
production warrant is negated at this stage.
7. It is also surprising to note herein that aforesaid
criminal prosecution is of 2007 and Investigating
Officer made a prayer for treating petitioner as "shown
arrest" before the court below on 19th September, 2026.
4 / 30
8. Concerned police authorities are directed not to take
any step against petitioner till 12th October, 2026 in
connection with Khejuri Police Station Case
No.45/2007 dated 31st July, 2007 and petitioner shall
not be treated as arrested in the said criminal
prosecution.
9. In terms of previous order dated 22nd September,
2026 matter shall appear in the supplementary list.”
3.
The original Petitioner preferred the Writ Petition before the
Learned Single Judge on the Appellate Side invoking Article 226 of the
Constitution of India. In the pleadings in the Writ Petition, he disclosed that he
was presently in judicial custody and lodged at Haldia Correctional Home,
Bhabanipur, Purba Medinipur. It was stated in the Petition that because he is a
candidate belonging to a particular political party, he desired an opportunity to
canvass his candidature for a by-election. We are informed that there are two
by-elections scheduled on 6th October, 2026, and the counting of votes is to
commence on 9th October, 2026.
4.
There are several other aspects touching the journey of the original
Petitioner in public life and the political scene in the State of West Bengal,
which are averred at length in his Writ Petition, which are not relevant to be
recorded in our order, considering the issue addressed to us.
5 / 30
5.
The original Petitioner has specifically averred in paragraph
nos.25 to 30 as under:“25. On September 19, 2026, the Petitioner was
produced before the Ld. ACJM, Haldia and was
remanded to judicial custody till October 3, 2026. He is
presently lodged at Haldia Sub-Correctional Home.
26. On September 20, 2026, the said ASI Pradip Kumar
Panda of Nandigram Police Station executed another
purported Warrant of Arrest in connection with
Nandigram PS Case No. 09/07 dated 08.01.2007
(GR-21/07) by showing the Petitioner to be arrested in
connection with the same.
27. The Petitioner has till now been arrested in the
following cases:
Sl.
Case No.
Status of the
Petitioner
Nandigram PS Case No. In Judicial Custody
75/07 dated. 30.04.2007
Nandigram PS Case
In Judicial Custody
No.221/07 dated 15.11.2007
Nandigram
PS
Case In Judicial Custody
No.188/07 dated 08.11.2007
(P-1 gives 18.11.2007)
Khejuri PS Case No. 44/07 In Judicial Custody
dated 30.07.2007
Nandigram PS Case No. In Judicial Custody
09/07 dated 08.01.2007
28 The Petitioner reasonably apprehends that more cases
will be produced one after another and that each will be
used to keep him in custody until the polling is over.
Following are the cases which the Petitioner knows are
pending against him and has not yet shown to have been
arrested in connection with the same:
6 / 30
Sl.
Case No.
Status of the
Petitioner
Nandigram PS Case No.
359/07 dated. 23.11.2007
No arrest shown.
Nandigram PS Case
No.83/07 dated 05.05.2007
No arrest shown.
Nandigram PS Case No. 61/07
dated 04.07.2007
No arrest shown.
Khejuri PS Case No. 54/07
dated 23.03.2007
No arrest shown.
Nandigram PS Case No. 24/07
dated 18.02.2007
No arrest shown.
6. Nandigram PS Case No.
156/07 dated 10.10.2007
No arrest shown.
29. On September 20, 2026, Mr. Bhattacharya sent a
complaint by email to the Director General of Police,
narrating these events. He asked that an FIR be registered
against the SDPO, Nandigram and his subordinates
involved, that disciplinary measures be initiated against
them, and that the CCTV footage of Hotel Hindustan, the
resort, Chandipur Police Station and the route, along
with the relevant station diary and GD entries, be
preserved. No FIR has followed.
A true copy of the complaint, with the
covering email, is annexed hereto and
marked as 'Annexure P-4'.
30. The election timetable leaves no room for delay.
Campaigning ends on October 4, 2026, polling is on
October 6, 2026 and counting on October 9, 2026. The
Petitioner is in custody till October 3, 2026 at the least.
Recording systems in hotels and on the roads overwrite
old footage after a limited period. The records that
matter are held by the very officers who are the subject
of the complaint”
7 / 30
6.
In the set up of the above pleadings, the Petitioner had put forth
prayers (a) to (j) below paragraph 36, which read as under:“a) Dispense with the requirement of Rule 26 of the Writ
Rules of this Hon'ble Court as to prior service of a copy
of this petition on the respondents, for the reasons stated
in the petition;
b) Issue a writ in the nature of mandamus commanding
the respondent nos. 1, 2 and 3 to register a First
Information Report on the complaint dated 20.09.2026
of Mr. Subhasish Bhattacharya (Annexure P- 4) and on
the facts stated in this petition, against the Police
Respondents (respondent nos. 4 to 6 and 9 to 12) and
any other police personnel who may be identified, and
to entrust the investigation to an officer not below the
rank of Additional Director General of Police, who shall
not be one of the respondents, to be supervised by a
retired Judge of this Hon'ble Court to be nominated by
this Hon'ble Court and take appropriate disciplinary
and legal action against the delinquent officers;
c) Issue a writ in the nature of mandamus commanding
the respondent nos. 1 to 4 to disclose on affidavit, within
24 hours, the particulars of every criminal case,
whether registered, under investigation or pending trial,
in which the Petitioner is or has been named, giving the
police station, case number and date, sections, GR
number, court and stage, whether any warrant is
outstanding, and whether and when the Petitioner has
been arrested or shown arrested in it;
d) Issue a writ in the nature of mandamus commanding
the Respondents that no coercive step, including arrest,
shown arrest or further arrest, shall be taken against the
Petitioner in any case, till the date of counting of votes
in the bye-election to 210 - Nandigram Assembly
Constituency, being 09.10.2026;
8 / 30
e) Issue a writ in the nature of mandamus commanding
the Respondents that no coercive step, including arrest,
shown arrest, shall be taken against the Petitioner
specifically those mentioned in Paragraph No: 28, till
the date of counting of votes in the bye-election to 210 Nandigram Assembly Constituency, being 09.10.2026;
f) Issue a writ in the nature of mandamus commanding
the Respondents to seize and preserve, the CCTV
footage and the recording devices and storage (DVR,
NVR and cloud) of the following, for the period from
15.00 hours on 18.09.2026 to 24.00 hours on
19.09.2026, together with the station diary, general
diary entries and lock-up records of the police stations
concerned;
(i) Chandipur Police Station and Nandigram Police
Station;
(ii) Hotel Hindustan, Chandipur;
(iii) Mandarmani Royal Beach Resort;
(iv) every other place in which the Petitioner was kept
between his pick-up and his production before the Ld.
ACJM, Haldia;
(v)all traffic cameras, surveillance cameras, ANPR
systems and highway cameras on the route from
Chandipur through Nischinda Crossing to Mandarmani
and onwards to Haldia; and
(vi)the log books and GPS records of the Bolero and the
Scorpio used to carry the Petitioner and Mr.
Bhattacharya, and the booking and guest records of the
hotel and the resort for 18.09.2026;
g) Issue a writ in the nature of mandamus commanding
the Respondents to obtain and preserve, the call detail
records, tower location data and related records of the
official mobile numbers of the Police Respondents
(respondent nos. 4 to 6 and 9 to 12) from the service
providers;
9 / 30
h) Issue a writ in the nature of mandamus commanding
that all material seized or obtained under prayers above
be kept in sealed cover in the custody of the Registrar
General of this Hon'ble Court;
i) Rule Nisi in terms of prayers above;
j) Pass an interim order directing the Respondents that
no coercive step, including arrest, shown arrest or
further arrest, shall be taken against the Petitioner in
any case, till the date of counting of votes in the byeelection to 210-Nandigram Assembly Constituency,
being 09.10.2026;”
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE STATE
7.
The Learned Additional Advocate General for the State of West
Bengal has canvassed that in the said Writ Petition filed under Article 226 of
the Constitution, when the Petitioner had not sought quashing of any of the
several FIRs registered against him for various offences, the Learned Single
Judge had no reason to travel there beyond and pass the impugned order
reproduced above.
8.
He further submits that there are six offences registered against the
original Petitioner punishable under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code. The
investigation was launched in such cases. Suddenly, the erstwhile Government
decided to withdraw all such cases against the original Petitioner, in 2020. This
led to an uproar and WPA(P) 67 of 2021 and WPA (P) 68 of 2021 (PIL Petitions)
10 / 30
were filed before this Court. While dealing with the said PILs, the decision of
the State Government was quashed and set aside by the Division Bench of this
Court, vide judgment dated 10.02.2025 and investigation was directed in all
such cases. The original Petitioner is behind bars, as is conceded in the
pleadings in the Petition and is presently in judicial custody. His bail
applications seeking regular bail are pending before the appropriate
jurisdictional Courts.
9.
It is further submitted that the there was no suppression by the
State Government before the learned Single Judge, inasmuch as, the Petitioner
limited his prayer to the cases mentioned in paragraph 28 of the Writ Petition,
as would be evident from the order dated 22 nd September, 2026. It is also
submitted that the petitioner was aware of the Khejuri Police Station Case no.
45/2007, inasmuch as, the orders of proclamation and attachment had been
passed by the learned Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate Contai, Purba
Medinipur in the said cases. The order of proclamation had been executed by
affixing a copy thereof on the house of the Petitioner.
10.
He points out that the Petitioner’s prayer for bail has been rejected
by the learned Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, vide order dated 23 rd
September, 2026.
11 / 30
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE PETITIONER
11.
The Learned Counsel for the original Petitioner has painstakingly
narrated several factors revolving around the original Petitioner’s public life. It
is further stated that he is contesting an election to the position of Member of
the Legislative Assembly of the State of West Bengal for the first time. He is in
jail and is canvassing for his candidature keeping in view that the polling day
is scheduled on 6th October, 2026.
12.
While opposing the present intra-court Appeal preferred by the
State of West Bengal, he relies on the Judgment delivered by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Ram Kishan Fauji vs. State of Haryana & Ors., (2017) 5
SCC 533, to contend that this intra-court Appeal would not be tenable.
13.
A short order has been passed by the Learned Single Judge. What
has been objected to by the State of West Bengal are the contents of paragraphs
7 and 8 of the impugned order, which have been reproduced herein above.
OUR ANALYSIS AND CONCLUSIONS
14.
It is apparent from the record that the original Petitioner has
invoked Article 226 of the Constitution of India and has not even mentioned,
much less invoked any provision of the Cr.P.C. It is conceded that the original
12 / 30
Petitioner has not sought quashing of any of the FIRs registered against him.
The pending cases are in the backdrop of a Judgment delivered by the Learned
Division Bench of this Court dated 10.02.2025 in the WPA (P) No. 67 of 2021,
thereby setting aside the decision of the State Government in withdrawing all
the cases relating to offences punishable under Section 302 of the IPC and it is
in the light of the said Judgment that the investigation commenced and the
Petitioner is behind bars.
15.
In Ram Kishan Fauji (supra), the Hon’ble Supreme Court holds
that a Letters Patent Appeal, would not be maintainable if the Learned Single
Judge has exercised criminal jurisdiction. In paragraph 18 of the said judgment,
the Hon’ble Supreme Court has concluded that on a plain reading of the
relevant clause of the Letters Patent Appeal, it is manifest that no appeal lies
against the order passed by the Learned Single Judge in exercise of criminal
jurisdiction. The question that needs our consideration is, whether the Learned
Single Judge has exercised criminal jurisdiction.
16.
In paragraph 56, the Hon’ble Supreme Court observed that, ‘the
conception of “criminal jurisdiction” as used in Clause 10 of the Letters Patent
is not to be construed in the narrow sense. It encompasses in its gamut the
inception and the consequence. It is the field in respect of which the jurisdiction
13 / 30
is exercised, is relevant. It confers jurisdiction as regards the subject of
controversy or nature of proceedings and that subject is exercise of jurisdiction
in criminal matters’.
17.
In paragraph 61 thereof, the Hon’ble Supreme Court noted the
facts before it by recording that the Writ Petition was filed under Article 226 of
the Constitution for quashing of the recommendation of the Lokayukta. The
recommendation led to launching of criminal prosecution. FIR was registered
and criminal investigation was initiated. The Learned Single Judge analysed
the report and the ultimate recommendation of the statutory authority, and
thought it seemly to quash the same. After quashing the same, he found that the
FIR had been registered and he annulled the FIR treating the same as a natural
consequence. Thus, the effort of the Writ Petitioner in such case was to avoid
initiation of a criminal proceeding and the final order of the Writ Court was
quashing of the FIR and the subsequent investigation.
18.
In the case in hands, it would be evident from the pleadings as well
as the prayers made in the Writ Petition, that except prayers (a), (b) and (c), all
the other prayers are for issuance of Writs of Mandamus to defer arrest until the
elections conclude. We are conscious of the fact that prayer ‘a’ if granted or
considered would amount to exercise of criminal jurisdiction by the learned
Single Judge since the registration of the FIR would lead to initiation of a
14 / 30
criminal proceeding. However, in the present case, the said aspect has not yet
received consideration of the Learned Single Bench and no order has been
passed in such regard as yet.
19.
As to what would mean exercise of criminal jurisdiction, can be
deduced from the following provisions of the same Letters Patent under clause
15 whereof the present appeal has been filed:-
Criminal Jurisdiction.
22. Ordinary original jurisdiction of the High Court.- And We do
further ordain that the said High Court of Judicature at Fort William in
Bengal shall have ordinary original Criminal jurisdiction within the
local limits of its ordinary original Civil jurisdiction and in respect of all
persons beyond such limits, over whom the said Supreme Court at
Calcutta now has Criminal jurisdiction.
23. Jurisdiction as to persons.- And We do further ordain that the said
High Court of Judicature at Fort William in Bengal in the exercise of its
ordinary original Criminal jurisdiction, shall be empowered to try all
persons brought before it in due course of law.
24. Extraordinary original Criminal jurisdiction.- And We do further
ordain that the said High Court of Judicature at Fort William in Bengal
shall have extra-ordinary original Criminal jurisdiction over all persons
residing in places within the jurisdiction of any Court now subject to the
superintendence of the Sudder Nizamut Adalut at Calcutta, whether
within or without the Bengal Division of the Presidency of Fort William,
and shall have authority to try at its discretion any such persons brought
before it on charges preferred by the Advocate-General, or by any
Magistrate or other Officer specially empowered by the Government in
that behalf.
15 / 30
25. No appeal from High Court exercising original jurisdiction.- And
We do further ordain that there shall be no appeal to the said High Court
of Judicature at the Fort William in Bengal from any sentence or order
passed in any Criminal trial before the Courts of original Criminal
jurisdiction which may be constituted by one or more Judges of the said
High Court. Court may reserve points of law.-But it shall be at the
discretion of any such Court to reserve any point or points of law for the
opinion of the said High Court.
26. High Court to review on certificate of the Advocate-General.- And
We do further ordain that, on such point or points of law being so
reserved as aforesaid, or on its being certified by the said AdvocateGeneral that, in his judgment, there is an error in the decision of a point
or points of law decided by the Court ot original Criminal jurisdiction,
or that a point or points of law which has or have been decided by the
said Court should be further considered, the said High Court shall have
full power and authority to review the case, or such part of it as may be
necessary, and finally determine such point or points of law, and
thereupon to alter the sentence passed by the Court of original
jurisdiction, and to pass such judgment and sentence as to the said High
Court shall seem right.
27. Appeal from Criminal Courts in the Provinces.- And We do further
ordain that the said High Court of Judicature at the Fort William in
Bengal shall be a Court of appeal from the Criminal Courts of the Bengal
Division of the Presidency of Fort William, and from all other Courts,
whether within or without the said Bengal Division, from which there is
now an appeal to the Court of Sudder Nizamut Adalut at Calcutta, and
shall exercise appellate jurisdiction in such cases as are subject to appeal
to the said Court of Sudder Nizamut Adalut, by virtue of any laws or
regulations now in force, or shall become subject to appeal in the said
High Court by virtue of such laws or regulations relating to Criminal
Procedure as shall be hereafter made by the Governor-General in
Council.
28. Hearing of referred cases and revision of Criminal trials.- And We
do further ordain that the said High Court of Judicature at lort William
16 / 30
in Bengal shall be a Court of reference and revision from the Criminal
Courts subjret to its appellate jurisdiction, and shall have power to hear
and determine all such cases referred to it by the Session Judges, or by
any other Officers authorized to refer cases to the Sudder Nizamut Adalut,
and to revise all such cases tried by any Officer or Court possessing
Criminal jurisdiction as are now subject to reference to, or revision by,
the said Court of Sudder Nizamut Adalut, whether within or without the
Bengal Division of the Presidency of Fort William, or shall become
subject, to such reference to, or revision by, the said High Court by virtue
of such laws or regulations relating to Criminal Procedure as shall be
hereafter made by the Governor-General in Council.
29. High Court may direct the transfer of a case from one Court to
another.- And We do further ordain that the said High Court shall have
power to direct the transfer of any Criminal case or appeal from any Court
to any other Court of equal or superior jurisdiction, and also to direct the
preliminary investigation or trial of any Criminal case by any Office or
Court otherwise competent to investigate or try it, though such belongs,
in ordinary course, to the jurisdiction of some other Officer or Court.
Criminal Law.
30. Offenders to be punished under Indian Penal Code.- And We do
further ordain that all persons brought for trial before the said High Court
of Judicature at Fort William in Bengal, either in the exercise of its original
judictiou or in the exercise of its jurisdiction as a Court of appeal,
reference, or revision, charged with any offence for which provision is
made by Act No. XLV. of 1860, called the "Indian Penal Code" shall be
liable to punishment under the said Act, and not otherwise, subject
nevertheless to such alterations, modifications, and additions in and to
such Code as may have been or may be prescribed by any acts or
regulations made by the Governor-General in Council.
20.
Evidently, none of the limbs of the aforesaid clauses of the
Letters Patent that define the boundaries of the criminal jurisdiction of this
17 / 30
Court under Letters Patent, have been invoked and none gets attracted in the
facts of the present case. The Single Judge has neither been called upon to
adjudicate upon any point of penal law, nor evaluate any evidence, nor
determine statutory bail conditions nor pass an order that may lead to
initiation of a criminal proceeding nor an order that may lead to termination
thereof.
21.
In the present case, the Writ Petitioner has explicitly chosen not
to invoke the criminal jurisdiction of this Court (Single Judge Bench).
Admittedly, there is no prayer for the quashing of the FIR, no prayer for the
staying of the investigation, and no prayer for statutory bail under the Code
of Criminal Procedure / Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita. Paragraph 32
of the Writ Petition and one of the grounds mentioned in support of the reliefs
claimed in the Writ Petition, read as under :
32. Being aggrieved by and/or dissatisfied with the acts of the Police
Respondents in removing the petitioner from his hotel room without a
memo of arrest, holding him in custody at places and times that no
record shows, and pressing him to withdraw his candidature under
threat of arrest, the Petitioner begs to move this Hon’ble Court in its
extraordinary writ jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution
of India inter alia on the following amongst other, grounds:
XII. FOR THAT protection till the counting is necessary and harms
no one. The cases are nineteen years old. A few weeks more will not
18 / 30
prejudice the prosecution, and the State is free to proceed once the
votes are counted on October 9, 2026. Fresh arrests or shown arrests
in the meantime would carry the Petitioner’s custody past October 3,
2026, through the last days of the campaign and the poll. The
Petitioner asks the Court to only hold the ring. He does not seek
quashing of any case. Bail and the merits of each case are for the
courts concerned.
22.
Thus the sole causa causans for the Writ Petition is the conduct
of the By-Election and the protection of the Writ Petitioner’s statutory right
to contest elections without purported colourable executive indulgence. The
subject matter is, thus, at best as regards the purity of the democratic process,
which is a classic domain of Constitutional Equity and Public Law and no
facet of criminal jurisdiction is involved in it.
23.
The case pertains to the invocation of the jurisdiction of a
Court of equity under Article 226 of the Constitution of India and the issue
before the Court was one related to balancing the State’s interest in
governance and the Writ Petitioner’s interest in canvassing his candidature in
the by-election. Such issue did not require the Court to form any opinion,
either on the merits of the criminal case or the truth or falsity of the accusation
levelled against the Writ Petitioner or the weight of evidence, or the
determination of criminal guilt.
19 / 30
24.
The impugned order neither determines any penal liability, nor
speaks about the same even in the passing. The order merely operates as a
temporary, time-bound deferral of state action in exercise of its highly
prerogative Writ Jurisdiction and not criminal jurisdiction. In view of the
above, we do not find that the law laid down in Ram Kishan Fauji (supra)
would render the intra-court Appeal untenable.
25.
Our view is supported by the view of another Division Bench of
this Court in the case of Director General of Police v. Gopal Kumar
Agarwal, reported at 2020 SCC OnLine Cal 755, wherein the issue
pertaining to the maintainability of a Letters Patent Appeal in the light of the
judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Ram Kishan Fauji
(supra, was considered and decided thus:
14. We have carefully considered the submissions made by the
Learned Senior Counsel for the respective parties on the point of
maintainability of these two intra court appeals. The short
question is whether or not the Learned Single Judge passed the
impugned order in exercise of criminal jurisdiction.
15. In the present case, a criminal case was instituted on the
complaint of the writ petitioner (who is the respondent No. 1 in
MAT 318 of 2019 and hereinafter referred to as ‘Gopal’) against
the appellant (hereinafter referred to as ‘Manoj’) in MAT 353, of
20 / 30
2019. Criminal investigation started. Being aggrieved by and
dissatisfied with the manner in which the investigation was
proceeding, Gopal approached the Learned Single Judge by
filing an application under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India praying for change of the investigating agency. According
to him, the investigation was being done in a biased manner to
protect Manoj for the reasons alleged by him in the writ petition.
The Learned Single Judge was of the opinion that there was
substance in Gopal's contention and accordingly directed
substitution of CBI as the Investigating Authority in the place and
stead of CED.
16. In his writ petition, Gopal did not pray for quashing of the
criminal proceedings and naturally so because he is the de-facto
complainant. Nor did Gopal pray for an order for initiation of a
criminal proceeding since the criminal proceeding already stood
initiated. The order of the Learned Single Judge which is
impugned before us neither had the effect of causing initiation of
a criminal proceeding nor had the effect of quashing or
terminating a criminal proceeding. The Learned Judge was of the
view that the investigation was not being conducted in a proper
manner and accordingly directed change of the investigating
agency. This, in our considered opinion, did not amount to
exercise of criminal jurisdiction by the Learned Single Judge.
17. Criminal jurisdiction of the Calcutta High Court has been defined
in Clauses 22 to 29 of the Letters Patent, 1865 which have been
21 / 30
adverted to above. On a careful analysis and consideration of the said
clauses, it cannot be said that the Learned Single Judge passed the
impugned order in exercise of criminal jurisdiction. Further, on the
day the Learned Judge passed the impugned order, His Lordship did
not have determination to hear or decide a case in criminal
jurisdiction. In our opinion, the Learned Judge exercised supervisory
jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India in directing
change of the investigating agency. The criminal investigation was
already in progress. The investigation was not initiated as a result of
the impugned order.
..........................
..........................
22. The facts in the case of Ram Kishan Fauji (supra) are different
from the facts in the present case. In that case the Learned Single
Judge's order had a consequence which was clearly criminal in
nature.The
Learned
Single
Judge
opined
that
the
recommendation of the Lokayukta for registration of FIR against
Ram Kishan Fauji deserved to be quashed and accordingly
quashed the same and also quashed all actions taken pursuant to
such recommendation including the FIR. This led to the
termination of the criminal proceeding. In the present case, the
impugned order of the Learned Single Judge does not have any
such consequence. Neither the impugned order was the reason
for initiation of criminal proceeding nor for termination of any
criminal proceeding. In our view, the Learned Single Judge
merely upheld the civil right of the writ petitioner (Gopal) to have
22 / 30
a fair and impartial investigation conducted in connection with
the alleged unnatural death of his sister, as was claimed by him.
No point of criminal law was decided by the Learned Single
Judge. The impugned order cannot be said to have been passed
in criminal domain. We are in respectful agreement with the ratio
decidendi of the decisions of the Division Bench of the Gujarat
High Court and the Full Bench of the Delhi High Court which
were approved by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Ram
Kishan Fauji (supra), as mentioned above. Reading the Hon'ble
Supreme Court's decision in the case of Ram Kishan Fauji
(Supra) as a whole, we cannot accept the contention of Learned
Senior Counsel representing Gopal (writ petitioner) that if the
High Court in exercise of power under Article 226 of the
Constitution passes an order which has even the remotest
connection with a criminal case, then the order must be said to
have been passed in exercise of criminal jurisdiction,
notwithstanding that the order by itself does not have any
criminal consequence in the sense that it neither directs initiation
of a criminal proceeding which may have penal consequences for
the accused person, nor it directs quashing or termination of a
criminal proceeding thereby relieving the accused person of
possible penal consequences. In our considered view, the
decision in Ram Kishan Fauji (supra) does not advance the case
of the writ petitioner on the point of maintainability of these
appeals.
23 / 30
23. In this connection it may also be noted that the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in Ram Kishan Fauji (supra) at Paragraph 42 of
the Judgment observed, inter alia, that: “The tenability of intracourt appeal will depend upon the Bench adjudicating the lis as
to how it understands and appreciates the order passed by the
learned Single Judge. There cannot be a straitjacket formula for
the same.” In our understanding, in the facts of the present case,
the Learned Single Judge was exercising civil jurisdiction under
Article 226 of the Constitution and not criminal jurisdiction.
28. For the aforesaid reasons we hold that the present appeals
are maintainable and not barred by Clause 15 of the Letters
Patent, 1865.”
[Emphasis supplied]
26.
It is pertinent to note that the other reason given by the Division
Bench in paragraph 17 of the judgment rendered in Gopal Kumar Agarwal
(supra), to the effect that “His Lordship did not have determination to hear or
decide a case in criminal jurisdiction”, is also relevant for the present purpose.
In this case too, the learned Single Judge did not have determination over
matters pertaining to criminal jurisdiction as the roster therefor was with the
other Learned Judges of this Court. It is well settled that if an order is passed
by a Court without having determination over the matter, such an order would
be void and a nullity in terms of the following observations of the Hon’ble
24 / 30
Supreme Court in the case of Garden Reach Shipbuilders & Engineers Ltd.
v. GRSE Ltd. Workmens Union reported at 2025 SCC OnLine SC 582:
9. In the light of the law laid down by the High Court itself in Sohan
Lal Baid v. State of West Bengal, as approved by a three-Judge Bench
of this Court in State of Rajasthan v. Prakash Chand which has
subsequently been approved by a Constitution Bench in Campaign for
Judicial Accountability and Reforms v. Union of India, as well as Rule
26 (supra), we hold that any order which a bench - comprising of two
judges or a single judge - may choose to make in a case that is not
placed before them/him by the Chief Justice of the High Court or in
accordance with His Lordship's directions, such an order is without
jurisdiction. In other words, an adjudication, beyond allocation, is
void and such adjudication has to be considered a nullity. It needs no
emphasis that the Chief Justice of the High Court, being the primus
inter pares, has been vested with the power and authority to set the
roster, as articulated in Sohan Lal Baid (supra), and such roster is
final and binding on all the ‘Companion Justices’ of the said court.
Plainly, therefore, the order dated March 11, 2024 and the impugned
order are without jurisdiction.
[Emphasis supplied]
27.
A little later, another Division Bench of this Court in the case of
Suparna Kanjilal Chakraborty v. Suvendu Adhikari reported at 2021 SCC
OnLine Cal 4357 answered the question regarding maintainability of a
Letters Patent appeal in the negative, while noticing Gopal Kumar Agarwal
(supra). However, we need not be detained by the decision in Suparna
25 / 30
Kanjilalbe Chakraborty (supra) as the same is clearly distinguishable on
facts.
28.
In the said case, the learned Single Judge, whose order was impugned
before the Division Bench, after referring to the factual details of the various
criminal cases launched against the Writ Petitioner, had summed up the
reliefs prayed for, thus:
“In the factual background above, the petitioner seeks quashing of all
the FIRs. Alternatively, it is submitted that the petitioner has no faith
in the State police any further and sought transfer of such
investigation in the above 6 cases against him to the CBI”
29.
The Division Bench, while dealing with the Appeal made the
following observations in the light of the observations made by the learned
Single Bench:
2.
The Writ Petitioner in WPA 11803 of 2021, i.e. the Writ
petition on which the common order dated 6 September, 2021 of the
Hon'ble Single Bench came to be passed, is the Respondent No. 1
in two of the above noted analogous appeals being MAT 993 of
2021 and MAT 970 of 2021 (respectively MAT-I and MAT-II). The
writ petitioner is a political leader presently owing allegiance to a
political party which is in opposition to the present ruling party of
the State. The writ petitioner originally owed allegiance to the
present ruling party and, inter alia, alleges that upon shifting his
allegiance to the party presently in the opposition, at least six First
Information Reports (FIRs) have been filed against him in four
26 / 30
different police stations of the State. The writ petitioner alleges
victimization and harassment by the State machinery as a
counterblast to the change in his political allegiance. The prayers
in the writ petition are primarily protection from the vexatious
criminal proceedings launched against the Writ petitioner and, in
the alternative, since the writ petition has lost faith in the
impartiality of the State machinery, to transfer investigation of the
FIRs registered against him to the Central Bureau of Investigation
(CBI).
3.
By the order impugned, the Hon'ble Single Bench was
pleased to notice and record the details of the FIRs pleaded in the
writ petition. Upon recording the details, the Hon'ble Single Bench
found the writ petition to be maintainable and, was prima facie
satisfied that in the series of FIRs complained of in the writ petition,
the State machinery acted over-zeal-ously and maliciously. Upon
further recording of reasons for its prima facie satisfaction, the
Hon'ble Single Bench was pleased to observe that the writ
petitioner deserves invocation of his rights under Article 21 of the
Constitution of India for protecting him from implication in false
criminal cases.
[Emphasis supplied]
30.
Thus, in the said case the very basis of the criminal cases were
questioned and the Court had prima facie adjudicated on the same, which led
to exercise of criminal jurisdiction by the learned Single Judge, which is not
27 / 30
the case before us. It was in such background that the learned Division Bench
concluded thus:
A)That the primary reliefs granted by the Hon'ble Single Bench
pertain to the exercise of Criminal Jurisdiction;
B) That the alternate relief of transfer of investigation to the CBI has
not been considered on merits at this stage by the Hon'ble Single
Bench;
C) That the ratio of in re: Ram Kishan Fauji applies apropo the facts
of this case.
D) That the Letters Patent of the High Court at Calcutta hence act
as a bar to filing an intra-Court appeal.
E) That the ratio of in re: Gopal Kumar Agarwal rests on the point
of grant of the relief of transfer of investigation and, such relief being
alternate and not under consideration by the impugned order, is
hence not apropo the present factual scenario.
F) This Court has considered the demurrer on the touchstone of the
nature of the jurisdiction exercised by the Hon'ble Single Bench and,
not on the composition of the Hon'ble Single Bench sitting in Article
226 jurisdiction, by following the law laid down in re: Ram Kishan
Fauji.
31.
We are also cognisant of the fact that a reference as regards
maintainability of a Letters Patent Appeal against an order passed by a
Learned Single Judge in relation to a notice issued under Section 160 of the
Cr.P.C, is pending before a Special Bench of this Court. But then, the question
that has been referred to be decided does not affect the consideration of the
28 / 30
present appeal. To be precise, the question that is pending consideration in
the reference is - “Whether an appeal under Clause 15 of the Letters Patent
is maintainable against an order passed in exercise of the powers conferred
under Article 226 of the Constitution of India in relation to a notice issued
under Section 160 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, to be regarded as an
order passed in exercise of the criminal jurisdiction or depends upon the
nature of the order ultimately passed in a proceeding as indicated in Gopal
Kumar Agarwal and Another (supra)”.
32.
Thus, in the backdrop of the settled position of law, we find from
the pleadings as well as the submissions of the Learned Counsel across the
Bar, that the Petitioner had prayed before the Learned Single Judge that he
should not be treated as being shown to be arrested since he wanted to contest
the election and he was under a threat of withdrawal of his nomination. The
Learned Single Judge expressed ‘surprise’ while noting that the criminal
prosecution was of 2007 and the Investigating Officer had “made a prayer
for treating the petitioner as “shown arrest” before the Court below on
19.09.2026”. Apparently, the learned Single Judge lost sight of the fact that
06 cases punishable under section 302 of the IPC were withdrawn by the State
Government and it was the judgment of the learned Division Bench of this
Court, that quashed the said decision and restored the FIRs.
29 / 30
33.
We fail to understand as to under which provision of the Criminal
Procedure Code or Criminal Jurisprudence, did the Learned Single Judge
exercise an authority to observe that the Petitioner could not be treated as
arrested. In four out of six offences, the Petitioner is already before the
appropriate forum for seeking regular bail. There is no impediment to
approach the appropriate Court for seeking bail in a matter in which he has
been shown to be arrested by tagging the said case with the earlier FIR.
34.
In the light of the above, in a matter wherein there has been no
prayer for bail, there has been no prayer for quashing of the FIR, there has
been no prayer of staying of the investigation which was pressed on
24.09.2026, and in the backdrop of the statement made by the State before
the Learned Single Judge that it is only in five cases that the Petitioner is
arrested and is not to be arrested in any other matter, for the present, there
could be no occasion for the Learned Single Judge to pass the impugned
order. The Petitioner is behind the bars. If he succeeds in law to get bail, in
view that the bail Petitions pending before the appropriate Court, it would be
his right to be set at liberty, if such an order is passed.
30 / 30
35.
In view of the above, this Appeal is allowed. The impugned order
passed by the Learned Single Judge, is quashed and set aside. It be noted that
having regard to the scope of the present intra-court appeal, this order is
restricted to the directions issued by the Learned Single Judge in paragraph 7
and 8 of the impugned order reproduced above.
35.
In view of the disposal of the Appeal, CAN 1 of 2026
stands also disposed off.
(Om Narayan Rai, J.)
(Ravindra V. Ghuge)
Chief Justice
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review