Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CRL.O.P.No.5556 of 2026 in Crl.A.SR.No.100849 of 2025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
DATED : 15.07.2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE MR JUSTICE M. NIRMAL KUMAR
CRL.O.P.No.5556 of 2026 in
Crl.A.SR.No.100849 of 2025
The State of Tamil Nadu Rep.by
The Inspector of Police,
CBCID, Metro,
Chennai.
Cr.No.03/2013.
... Petitioner(s)
Vs
1. Kosma
S/o. Arokiyadoss,
No.85/4, New Amaranjipuram,
Thantondiarpeti,
Chennai-81.
2. Sengotuvel
S/o. Kulanthaivel Gownder,
No.27, Cuddalore Main Road,
Puthupettai Post,
Attur Taluk,
Salem District.
3. Sashikumar
No. 5/373, Gandhipuram,
Ammapalayam Post,
Atur Taluk,
Salem District.
... Respondent(s)
__________
Page1 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CRL.O.P.No.5556 of 2026 in Crl.A.SR.No.100849 of 2025
PRAYER: Criminal Original Petition is filed under Section 378(3) of Code of
Criminal Procedure, to grant leave to file an appeal to this Honourable Court
against the acquittal judgment passed in the Learned Metropolitan Magistrate
Special Court for Exclusive Trial of CCB and CBCID Metro Cases, Egmore,
Chennai in C.C.No.2036 of 2017 dated 03.02.2024.
For Petitioner(s):
Ms.Sharada Vivek,
Government Advocate (Criminal Side)
For Respondent(s):
Ms.P.Kritika Kamal for R1 and
Mr.C.P.Palanichamy for R2 & R3
ORDER
This Criminal Original Petition is filed by the State seeking leave to
prefer Criminal Appeal against the judgment of acquittal dated 03.02.2024 in
C.C.No.2036 of 2017 passed by the learned Metropolitan Magistrate, Special
Court for Exclusive Trial of CCB and CBCID Metro Cases, Egmore, Chennai.
2.Case of the prosecution is that in this case, the 1 st respondent was the
Assistant Section Officer in Secretariat, Revenue Department, Government of
Tamil Nadu, the 2nd respondent is the beneficiary of forged G.O.(1D)No.606
dated 31.12.2014 [In short ‘G.O.(1D)No.606’] and the 3rd respondent is the son
of the 2nd respondent. All the three with a common intention joined together
and committed the offence under Sections 204, 465, 467, 468, 471 and 420 r/w
__________
Page2 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CRL.O.P.No.5556 of 2026 in Crl.A.SR.No.100849 of 2025
34 IPC. The above case registered based on the complaint of the Secretary
(Revenue) to Government regarding G.O.(1D)No.606 which was not issued by
the Revenue Department of Tamil Nadu Government. This forged Government
Order issued in favour of the 2nd respondent for handing over the land
measuirng about 0.18.5 hectare in survey No.776 of Thulukkanur Village, Attur
Taluk, Salem District. This forgery came to light when the villagers namely the
Vice President of Thulukkanur Village Panchayat and his friend and Councillor
of Panchayat gave a petition to the Secretary to Revenue Department seeking
cancellation of G.O.(1D)No.606 since the land pertains to the public way
“Pathai Poramboke”. When the defacto complainant verified the authenticity of
the Government Order, it was found that the 2nd respondent already encroached
the Government land for more than 30 years and the land belongs to “Pathai
Poramboke”. Earlier the 2nd respondent gave a petition to Government seeking
transfer of land on lease basis for establishing a factory and the Government
vide G.O.(1D)No.186 dated 17.06.2013 [In short ‘G.O.(1D)No.186’] rejected
the proposal.
However, the 1st respondent in collusion with the other
respondents not despatched G.O.(1D)No.186, on the other hand prepared a
forged Government Order on similar lines with directions to the concern to
transfer patta favouring the 2nd respondent vide G.O.(1D)No.606.
On
verification, it was found that no Government Order in G.O.(1D)No.606 issued.
In this case, investigation proceeded, documents collected, statement of
witnesses recorded, the respondents 1 and 2 arrested, on their confession,
__________
Page3 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CRL.O.P.No.5556 of 2026 in Crl.A.SR.No.100849 of 2025
materials collected including hard disc, computer, printer and laptop and sent
for forensic analysis. Further, specimen signature and disputed signature and
writings sent to Handwriting Expert who confirmed the forgery committed by
the 1st respondent.
The electronic devices proved the creation of forged
documents. On collecting materials, statement of witnesses and other materials,
charge sheet filed before the trial Court. During trial, PW1 to PW22 examined
and Exs.P1 to P41 marked and MO1 to MO4 produced. On conclusion of trial,
the trial Court dismissed the complaint, acquitted and discharged the
respondents 1 to 3. Against which, the present Criminal Appeal and the petition
for leave grant.
3.Learned Government Advocate (Criminal Side) appearing for the
petitioner submitted that in this case, PW1 is the Secretary to Government,
Revenue Department, Tamil Nadu Secretariat. On receipt of the complaint
from PW3 caused enquiry, verified the documents and files of the Secretariat
and found that the forgery committed and G.O.(1D)No.606 never issued,
thereafter, lodged a detailed complaint with annexure. The petitioner received
the complaint, registered FIR in Crime No.3 of 2015 for offence under Sections
465, 468, 471 & 420 IPC and proceeded with the investigation. PW1 is the
defacto complainant, through whom, Exs.P1 & P2 marked. PW2 is the Joint
Secretary, Revenue Department, Tamil Nadu Secretariat who handed over 500
GB hard disk (MO1), further he produced the service particulars of the 1 st
__________
Page4 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CRL.O.P.No.5556 of 2026 in Crl.A.SR.No.100849 of 2025
respondent, copies of the documents relating to G.O.(1D)No.606 and other
Government Orders and Section Register, Government Order Index Register
and and through PW2 Exs.P3 to P11 marked. PW3 is a villager belongs to the
same village of the 2nd respondent who was holding the post of Vice President
of Thullukanur village who gave a petition to remove encroachment made by
the 1st respondent in Government land “Pathai Poramboke”.
When PW3
enquired Tahsildar, he informed that the Government issued order in G.O.
(1D)No.606 to handover the land to the 2 nd respondent, hence, PW3 filed appeal
to the Government. PW4, a nearby villager holding the post of Panchayat Ward
Member of Thalaivasal Panchayat, gave a petition to remove the encroachment.
PW5, PW6, PW7, PW8, PW9, PW10, PW11 & PW12 are the Deputy Secretary,
Under Secretary, Section Officer, Assistant Section Officer, Office Assistant
and Typist who are posted in the Revenue Department during the relevant time
who all stated that G.O.(1D)No.186 published but the same despatched and kept
on hold by the 1st respondent rejecting the request of the 2 nd respondent to allot
the land on lease. The witnesses confirmed with regard to verification of
Government Order Index Register finding that in the year 2014 only 604
Government Orders passed, indexed and published, but there was no G.O.
(1D)No.606 passed. Further, they produced relevant files pertaining to the case.
PW13 & PW15 are the Village Administrative Officer and Revenue Inspector
in whose presence the confession of the respondents 1 and 2 recorded and the
computer, hard disk, printer, laptop all seized from the 2 nd respondent. PW14
__________
Page5 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CRL.O.P.No.5556 of 2026 in Crl.A.SR.No.100849 of 2025
Deputy Tahsildar, Headquarters, Attur, Salem confirmed that the file with
forged G.O.(1D)No.606 put up to him for processing. PW16 is the Tahsildar,
Attur, who received forged G.O.(1D)No.606 from the Revenue Divisional
Officer. PW17 is the P.A. to the District Collector, Salem who produced the
forged Government Order which received in the Collectorate and other related
documents. PW19 is the Nodal Officer of Vodafone and PW20 is the Deputy
Director, Computer Forensic Division, Chennai. PW21 is the Deputy Director,
Document Division Forensic Science/Handwriting Expert and PW22 is the
Investigating Officer.
4.Learned Government Advocate (Criminal Side) further submitted that
PW19, Nodal Officer confirms that even after retirement of the 1 st respondent,
he had constant touch with the 2 nd respondent. It is the 1 st respondent who
knows the mode of work in issuance of Government Order and purportedly
withheld G.O.(1D)No.186 rejecting the 2nd respondent’s request in allotment of
land, not published the same, and later the file pertaining to G.O.(1D)No.186
stealthily removed and destroyed. Taking advantage of the same, forged G.O.
(1D)No.606 prepared in identical to the language and font of G.O.(1D)No.186,
but in the operative portion, grating permission to the concerned authorities to
pass orders favouring the 2nd respondent. These aspects spoken by the witnesses
from the Secretariat, Tahsildar, Deputy Tahsildar, Block Development Officer,
P.A. to District Collector and other officials in the District who all confirmed
__________
Page6 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CRL.O.P.No.5556 of 2026 in Crl.A.SR.No.100849 of 2025
that forged G.O.(1D)No.606 issued favouring the 2nd respondent.
5.Learned Government Advocate (Criminal Side) further submitted that
the electronic evidence and handwriting expert confirm the forgery and the role
of the accused. The trial Court without property considering and appreciating
the evidence on its own gives a finding that PW8, Successor to the 1 st
respondent confirms that she was on leave from 01.04.2013 to 01.10.2013 when
G.O.(1D)No.186 said to be issued. Hence, for withholding and not sending
G.O.(1D)No.186, PW8 is responsible and not the 1st respondent.
The 1st
respondent retired on 31.07.2015 and the forged G.O.(1D)No.606 issued five
months after her retirement. But the evidence of the witnesses from Secretariat
are categorical that none other than persons from the Secretariat service can
have access and knowledge in issuance of G.O.(1D)No.186 and the purported
G.O.(1D)No.606 on the same subject.
Further, the Handwriting Expert
confirmed that the questioned document confirmed to the standard signature and
writing of the 1st respondent.
Likewise, the Nodal Officer confirms the
telephonic contact between the 1st and 2nd respondent even after her retirement.
The electronic evidence confirms the intrusion using pendrive in the hard disk
which is seized in this case. Further, in the hard disk and computer system
seized from the 2nd respondent’s residents, intrusions recorded similarity in the
language, font in all means found in both G.O.(1D)No.186 and G.O.
(1D)No.606.
__________
Page7 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CRL.O.P.No.5556 of 2026 in Crl.A.SR.No.100849 of 2025
6.Learned Government Advocate (Criminal Side) further submitted the
evidence of the Typist confirms that apart from the 1 st respondent, she and
another Typist have access to the computer but the files are kept in separate
folders and can be accessed only by the concerned officer and staff who have
specific password to gain access. In this case, the Government Order file is in
the file and folder of the 1st respondent. The trial Court gave undue importance
to the side initial in G.O.(1D)No.606 which is a received document signed by
PW14. PW8 Assistant Section Officer admits that signature found in Exs.P5 &
P20 is not signed by her. This case is based on the circumstantial evidence but
the trial Court referred to the evidence of witnesses and considered the charges
compartmental wise in isolation and not in a holistic manner failed to invoke
Section 10 of Indian Evidence Act and renders a judgment that the petitioner
not proved the case. Thus, the judgment of the trial Court is on a wrong
appreciation of the evidence and perverse, hence, needs reconsideration. Hence,
the present petition seeking leave can be allowed and the defence of the
respondent can be considered during final hearing.
7.Per contra, learned counsel for the 1st respondent submitted that in this
case, the forged G.O.(1D)No.606 is dated 31.12.2014. The 1 st respondent was
put in unblemished service and retired on 31.07.2014. For a Government Order
issued five months after the retirement of the 1 st respondent, now she is made to
face the prosecution. The trial Court on the evidence and materials found that
__________
Page8 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CRL.O.P.No.5556 of 2026 in Crl.A.SR.No.100849 of 2025
the charges against the 1st respondent not proved rightly acquitted her. In this
case, PW8 though states that she has not signed in G.O.(1D)No.606, but no
specimen signature of her obtained to find out whether the claim of PW8 is
genuine and acceptable. In this case, the appeal filed only on presumption and
assumption and not as per the evidence available. He further submitted that
PW17, P.A. to District Collector admits that Ex.P20 is a certified copy of G.O.
(1D)No.606, based on the certified copy, the handwriting expert report obtained
is of no consequence. In support of her submissions, learned counsel relied on
the decision of the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of C.Kamalakannan v. State
of Tamil Nadu rep. by Inspector of Police, C.B.C.I.D., Chennai reported in
2025 LiveLaw (SC) 287. She further submitted that hard disk/MO1 produced
through Ex.P3 Mahazar by PW2 on 08.12.2015. The 1st respondent retired on
31.07.2014, the computer was still in usage in Department.
Who are the
persons used it and how some intrusions made, there is no conclusive evidence.
PW20/Computer Forensic Expert confirms that he is unable to find out whether
the files uploaded or extracted from the hard disk with the available pendrive.
Both Expert Evidence does not conclusively hold the 1 st respondent is
responsible for creating forged documents. Considering all these aspects, the
trial Court rightly acquitted the 1st respondent. Hence, the leave petition is
liable to be dismissed.
__________
Page9 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CRL.O.P.No.5556 of 2026 in Crl.A.SR.No.100849 of 2025
8.Learned counsel for the respondents 2 and 3 submitted that in this case,
the 2nd respondent arrested and PW13 and PW15 are the witnesses for arrest and
confession. PW13 confirms that he does not know what is written in the
confession statement and he only signed. PW13 is none other than the Village
Administrative Officer.
PW13 and PW15.
There are contradictions between the evidence of
PW20, Deputy Director, Computer Forensic Division
confirms that intrusion in the hard disk of the computer and the usage of printer
is on a later date after G.O.(1D)No.606 issued.
G.O.(1D)No.606 already
available in the Office of PW14, Deputy Tahsildar who confirms that he
processed the file based on G.O.(1D)No.606 which was received in his office
on 20.01.2015. Thus, the seizure of the electronic device clearly confirms that
the respondents 2 and 3 falsely implicated. As regards the 3 rd respondent,
grandson of 2nd respondent, his laptop seized to show that the laptop used for
creating forged document but the electronic evidence confirms that the hard
disk in laptop does not contain any files pertaining to G.O.(1D)No.606. The 2 nd
respondent is in the possession of disputed property for more than 30 years.
Earlier the Panchayat passed a resolution in his favour and his application to the
Commissioner, Land Reforms, Revenue Secretary and others considered, all
gave favourable notings and in the Secretariat and amount of Rs.13 lakhs fixed
as lease to the 2nd respondent.
For political reasons, the recommendation
overturned and now projected that since 2 nd respondent being the beneficiary,
hence, created false documents. The trial Court considering all these aspects
__________
Page10 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CRL.O.P.No.5556 of 2026 in Crl.A.SR.No.100849 of 2025
rightly dismissed the complaint and acquitted the respondents 2 and 3. Hence,
the leave petition is liable to be dismissed.
9.Considering the submissions and on perusal of the materials, it is seen
that the defacto complainant is none other than the Secretary, Revenue
Department, Government of Tamil Nadu, who lodged the complaint along with
eight annexures which are marked as Exs.P1 & P2. The complaint is with
regard to G.O.(1D)No.186. Though it was issued, but not despatched. The
request of the 2nd respondent seeking lease of “Pathai Poramboke” land rejected,
but with identical narration, purported G.O.(1D)No.606 accepting the 2nd
respondent’s request and directed the authorities to issue orders favouring the
2nd respondent.
Prior to it, the defacto complainant had verified with the
Commissioner of Land Reforms and District Collector, Salem got explanation
for both Gos.
Secretariat.
PW2 produced the files and documents available in the
PW3 & PW4 sent revision petition and the resolution of the
panchayat all sent to the respondent Police. Thereafter, the respondent Police
registered FIR in Crime No.3 of 2015 for offence under Sections 465, 468, 471
and 420 IPC. PW1 Secretary to Government. PW2 Joint Secretary to Revenue
Department. PW5 Deputy Secretary. PW6 & PW7 Under Secretaries. PW8
Section Officer. PW9 & PW10 Assistant Section Officers.
PW11 Office
Assistant. PW12 Typist, Revenue Department. PW3 and PW4 Vice President
of Village Panchayat and Ward Member who raised objection and questioned
__________
Page11 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CRL.O.P.No.5556 of 2026 in Crl.A.SR.No.100849 of 2025
issuance of G.O.(1D)No.606. PW13 and PW15 Village Administrative Officer
and the Revenue Inspector in whose presence the respondents 1 and 2 arrested,
confession recorded and material objects seized.
PW14 Deputy Tahsildar,
Headquarters Attur, Salem. PW16 Tahsildar, Attur. PW17 Personal Assistant
to District Collector, Salem all confirm the representation by the 2 nd respondent
and receipt of G.O.(1D)No.606. PW18 Block Development Officer produced
the resolutions passed in the Village Panchayat. PW19, Nodal Officer produced
the call detail records, it is seen that the respondents 1 and 2 were in contact on
8th, 9th and 22nd September and 12th October, 2014, after the retirement of the 1 st
respondent.
Further, PW20, Deputy Director, Computer Forensic Division
examined MO1 to MO4 and gave report. PW21, Deputy Director, Document
Division Forensic Science/Handwriting Expert confirms the signature and
writings in G.O.(1D)No.606 forged. PW22 is the Investigating Officer.
10.On analysing the evidence of witnesses and documents, it is seen that
G.O.(1D)No.186 dealt by the 1st respondent when she served as Assistant
Section Officer. Though this Government Order issued rejecting the claim of
the 2nd respondent, but not despatched and later during internal enquiry, it is
found that the original file pertaining to G.O.(1D)No.186 found destroyed.
Subsequently similar G.O.(1D)No.606 on the same subject issued, the narration
and sequencing in both Government Orders are identical but for the resultant.
As per G.O.(1D)No.606, the 2nd respondent was not given right to the public
__________
Page12 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CRL.O.P.No.5556 of 2026 in Crl.A.SR.No.100849 of 2025
pathway classified as “Pathai Poramboke” and guideline fixed. Further, this
G.O.(1D)No.606 said to have been issued in concurrence from the Rural and
Revenue Department and Finance Department with reference number. The
language and release of the Government Orders is in the knowledge of the
Secretariat staffs alone.
11.The production of forged G.O.(1D)No.606 and claiming right by the
2nd respondent confirmed by the evidence of PW3, Vice President of Tullukanur
Village and PW4, Panchayat Ward Member. PW7, Under Secretary, Revenue
Department confirms missing of file pertaining to G.O.(1D)No.186.
PW8,
Section Officer, Revenue Department confirms that she has not signed G.O.
(1D)No.606 and the signature is a forged one. PW9, Assistant Section Officer,
Revenue Department confirms that in the year 2014, Government Orders up to
604 alone issued and there is nothing in the Government Order Index Register
to show there was issuance of G.O.(1D)No.606. Further, in the Index Register,
there was only 30,000 postal numbers but in
G.O.(1D)No.606, the postal
number is shown as 40,000. An enquiry with the Finance Department confirms
that the postal number never crossed 30,000, but G.O.(1D)No.606, file number
is shown as 49,457. Thus, G.O.(1D)No.606 not circulated and issued after
getting concurrence from the Rural Development Department and Finance
Department, all found to be forged and a forged official document with
Government emblem purported with authority created and using forged
__________
Page13 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CRL.O.P.No.5556 of 2026 in Crl.A.SR.No.100849 of 2025
document knowingly the 2nd respondent attempted to grab the Government
property.
12.PW10, Assistant Section Officer, Revenue Department confirms that it
was the 1st respondent who was Assistant Section Officer during the relevant
period. PW11 confirms that G.O.(1D)No.186 not despatched on 17.06.2013.
PW12 confirms that the computer used by the 1st respondent. He further
confirms PW12/Typist, and one Kumaravel/Typist though they used the same
computer, but the folder was under the exclusive control of the concerned
officer secured with password and only the concerned officer can have access to
it. Except for carrying out the typing work, PW12 and Kumaravel had no
access to the folder and files.
13.PW14 Deputy Tahsildar who made side initial in G.O.(1D)No.606
confirms receipt of the Govenment Order. Further, G.O.(1D)No.606 received
in the Tahsildar Office on 21.01.2015. PW16 Tahsildar confirmed receipt of
G.O.(1D)No.606 and the objections raised by PW3 and PW4. PW17, Personal
Assistant to District Collector, Salem confirms the receipt of G.O.(1D)No.606.
The evidence of these witnesses confirmed that the forged G.O.(1D)No.606
reached the concerned officers in Salem, Attur to facilitate allotment of “Pathai
Poramboke” land in favour of the 2nd respondent. On the other hand, G.O.
(1D)No.186, which rejects the 2nd respondent’s claim, not despatched by the 1 st
__________
Page14 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CRL.O.P.No.5556 of 2026 in Crl.A.SR.No.100849 of 2025
respondent.
14.In this case, the forgery of document proved by PW21/Handwriting
Expert through Ex.P32. PW20/Computer Forensic Expert produced the report
Ex.P40 confirming similarity and identity of the words and font in G.O.
(1D)No.606 and G.O.(1D)No.186. Further, it also confirms the files which
intruded using pendrive in MO1, MO2 and MO3. MO1 produced by PW2
which is from the Secretariat and MO2 to MO4 seized from the residents of the
2nd respondent. This seizure confirmed by PW13 and PW15. Further, the Call
Detail Records is additional link for the common design.
15.The trial Court wrongly appreciated the evidence of the witnesses by
breaking it into parts, failing to consider that the public documents had been
forged and that the persons holding positions having access to important vital
facts and secured documents, created forged Government Orders. The trial
Court further failed to consider the evidence in the background of Sections 8
and 10 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, instead considered each instance as
solitary one which is not proper. Further, the trial Court failed to consider that
it is a circumstantial evidence, wherein the offence orchestrated and executed in
a well-planned manner by taking advantage of the 1st respondent's position and
access to the Government files. The 1st respondent had exclusive knowledge of
rejection of allotment of “Pathai Poramboke” to the 2 nd respondent, thereafter,
__________
Page15 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CRL.O.P.No.5556 of 2026 in Crl.A.SR.No.100849 of 2025
by gaining access to the vital documents and electronic devices, created forged
G.O.(1D) No.606 and the 2nd respondent is the beneficiary.
16.As regards the 3rd respondent/grandson of 2nd respondent, his laptop
seized to connect and show that the laptop used for the purpose of creating
forged document. But the electronic evidence confirms that the hard disk in
laptop does not find any files pertaining to the forged G.O.(1D)No.606. The
Investigating Officer admits that there is no evidence against the 3 rd respondent.
Hence, this Court is not inclined to grant leave to prefer appeal against the 3 rd
respondent.
17.In view of the above, this Court finds the finding of the trial Court is
perverse and needs to be re-considered. Hence, this Court grants leave to the
petitioner to prefer appeal against the judgment of acquittal dated 03.02.2024 in
C.C.No.2036 of 2017 passed by the learned Metropolitan Magistrate, Special
Court for Exclusive Trial of CCB and CBCID Metro Cases, Egmore, Chennai in
so far as the respondents 1 and 2 are concerned.
18.In the result, this Criminal Original Petition is Partly-Allowed.
15.07.2026
vv2
__________
Page16 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CRL.O.P.No.5556 of 2026 in Crl.A.SR.No.100849 of 2025
M.NIRMAL KUMAR, J.
vv2
CRL.O.P.No.5556 of 2026 in
Crl.A.SR.No.100849 of 2025
15.07.2026
__________
Page17 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review