Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 11TH DAY OF MARCH, 2026
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S. G. PANDIT
AND
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE K.V.ARAVIND
WRIT PETITION NO.37850/2025 (S-KSAT)
BETWEEN:
1. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
REP. BY ITS PRINCIPAL SECRETARY
DEPARTMENT OF YOUTH
EMPOWERMENT AND SPORTS
M.S. BUILDING
BANGALORE – 560 001.
2. THE COMMISSIONER
DIRECTORATE OF YOUTH
EMPOWERMENT AND SPORTS
STATE YOUTH CENTRE, YAVANIKA
NRUPATHUNGA ROAD
BENGALURU – 560001.
... PETITIONERS
(BY SRI. VIKAS ROJIPURA, AGA)
AND:
SMT. LAKSHMI DEVI
W/O P NARAYANA
AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS
WORKING AS ATTENDER CUM SWEEPER
GOVERNMENT SPORTS HIGH SCHOOL
VIDYA NAGAR,
BENGALURU NORTH-562157
R/AT GOVERNMENT QUARTERS
VIDYA NAGAR
BENGALURU NORTH–562157.
…RESPONDENT
(BY SRI M.S. BHAGWATH, SENIOR ADV. FOR
SRI K. SATISH, ADV.)
THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLE 226
AND 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO
CALL FOR RECORDS IN APPLICATION NO.4741/2024 ON
THE FILE OF THE KARNATAKA STATE ADMINISTRATIVE
TRIBUNAL, BENGALURU VIDE ANNEXURE-A AND B) ISSUE
A WRIT, ORDER OR DIRECTION TO QUASH THE ORDER
DATED
30.06.2025
IN
APPLICATION
NO.4741/2024
PASSED BY THE KSAT, BENGALURU, VIDE ANNEXURE-A
AND PASS SUCH OTHER ORDERS.
THIS
PETITION
HAVING
BEEN
HEARD
AND
RESERVED FOR ORDER ON 04.02.2026 COMING ON THIS
DAY, S.G.PANDIT J., PRONOUNCED THE FOLLOWING:
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR JUSTICE S.G.PANDIT
and
HON'BLE MR JUSTICE K.V.ARAVIND
CAV ORDER
(PER: HON'BLE MR JUSTICE S.G.PANDIT)
The State Authorities in the Department of Youth
Empowerment and Sports are before this Court under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India questioning the
order dated 30.06.2025 in Application No.4741/2024
passed by the Karnataka State Administrative Tribunal
at Bengaluru (for short, ‘the Tribunal’) whereby the
respondent’s
application
for
a
direction
to
the
petitioners to consider her case for regularization of
her service in the cadre of Attender-cum-Sweeper
with effect from the date she completed ten years of
service with consequential benefits is allowed.
2.
Brief facts of the case are that, it is the
case of the respondent that she was appointed on
consolidated/cumulative pay basis with the Sports
School at Vydyanagar, Bengaluru, as Attender-cum-
Sweeper. The applicant, along with similarly placed
persons
approached
the
Tribunal
in
Application
Nos.1366-1371/1999 with a prayer for regularization
from the date of appointment. The Tribunal disposed
of the same by order dated 26.07.2007, directing the
respondent as well as similarly situated persons to
make individual representations to the authorities
concerned seeking regularization. Accordingly, it is
stated that the respondent is said to have submitted a
presentation
petitioners
and
on
there
the
said
was
no
action
by
the
representation.
In
the
meanwhile, the respondent’s consolidated pay was
enhanced by order dated 20.08.2011 (Annexure-A4).
It is stated that Annexure-A6 dated 28.06.2014,
details of the applicant were sought and the Director,
Youth Services and Sports Department, by letter
dated
21.02.2015,
forwarded
the
details
of
the
respondent and recommended for consideration of
respondent’s case under the Karnataka Daily Wages
Employees' Welfare Act, 2012 (for short, ‘2012 Act’).
Even to that, there was no response and no order was
passed under 2012 Act.
3.
It is stated that one Rajanna, Assistant
Teacher in the same department, approached this
Court in W.P.No.22179/2014 and this Court by order
dated 11.01.2016 directed consideration of his case
for
regularization.
Accordingly,
vide
order
dated
30.06.20174 of the petitioners, services of the said
Rajanna
was
regularized.
On
the
similar
lines,
respondent requested for consideration of her case for
regularization
by
making
representation
dated
03.01.2024. As there was no action, the respondent
approached
the
Tribunal
in
the
above
stated
application seeking regularization of her services,
stating that she is working as Attender-cum-Sweeper
for more than 29 years and she would be entitled for
regularization.
4.
The Tribunal on consideration of the case of
the respondent and on placing reliance on the latest
decisions of the Hon'ble Apex Court in JAGGO VS.
UNION OF INDIA AND OTHERS1 directed the
petitioners
to
03.01.2024
for
consider
the
regularization
representation
of
services
dated
of
the
respondent as Attender-cum-Sweeper effective from
the date of her completion of 10 years of service with
consequential benefits. Aggrieved by the said order,
the State Authorities are before this Court in this writ
petition.
5.
Heard
learned
Additional
Government
Advocate Sri.Vikas Rojipura for petitioners, learned
senior counsel Sri.M.S.Bhagawath for Sri.K.Sathish,
2024 SCC OnLine SC 3826
learned counsel for the respondent. Perused the entire
writ petition papers.
6.
Learned Additional Government Advocate
Sri.Vikas Rojipura, in addition to the grounds urged in
the memorandum of writ petition, submits that the
respondent would not be entitled for consideration of
her case for regularization since her appointment is
irregular/illegal.
Government
Further,
Advocate
would
learned
submit
Additional
that
the
respondent is not appointed through regular selection
process and the employees who have entered from
back door would not be entitled for regularization.
7.
Learned Additional Government Advocate
would further submit that the respondent would not
fulfill the conditions laid down by the Hon'ble Apex
Court
in
the
case
of
SECRETARY,
STATE
OF
KARNATAKA AND OTHERS Vs. UMADEVI (3) AND
OTHERS2.
Particularly,
Government
Advocate
learned
would
submit
Additional
that
the
respondent is not appointed to a sanctioned post nor
she would possess the qualification required for the
post of Attender-cum-Sweeper. Learned Additional
Government Advocate would place reliance on the
various decisions of the Hon'ble Apex Court contend
that including UMADEVI (supra) to contend that
irregularly and illegally appointed persons would not
be entitled for regularization and also to contend that
the daily wager appointed contrary to law would not
get right to seek regularization. Thus, he would pray
for allowing the writ petition by setting aside the order
passed by the Tribunal.
8.
On the other hand, learned senior counsel
Sri.M.S.Bhagawath for respondent would contend that
the respondent has served more than 29 years in the
(2006) 4 SCC 1
petitioners’ department and she would be entitled for
regularization. Learned senior counsel would submit
that the respondent was appointed to a sanctioned
post by the competent authority and as on the date of
her appointment, there was no qualification prescribed
for the post of Attender-cum-Sweeper. Therefore,
there is no merit in the contention of the learned
Additional Government Advocate and he prays for
rejection of the said contention that the respondent
would
not
fulfill
the
criteria
prescribed
under
UMADEVI (supra). Learned senior counsel in the
matter of regularization, places reliance on the latest
decision of the Hon'ble Apex Court in JAGGO (supra)
and also DHARAM SINGH AND OTHERS vs. STATE
OF U.P. AND ANOTHER3. Thus, he would support the
order passed by the Tribunal and prays for dismissal
of the writ petition.
2025 SCC Online SC 1735
9.
Having
heard
the
learned
counsel
appearing for the parties and on perusal of the entire
writ petition papers, the point which falls for our
consideration is as to,
In the facts and circumstances of the
case, whether the impugned order passed
by the Tribunal warrants interference?
10.
Answer to the above point would be in the
Negative for the following reasons:
The
petitioners
would
not
dispute
the
appointment of the respondent as Attender-cumSweeper
on
06.07.1995
on
the
consolidated/
cumulative pay basis with the Sports School at
Vidyanagar, Bengaluru. The petitioners would also not
dispute the services rendered by the respondent for
more
than
years
and
continuance
of
the
respondent as Attender-cum-Sweeper as on this date.
It is also a fact that the respondent as on the date of
making application before the Tribunal had completed
nearly 29 years and as on this date she has completed
nearly 30 years of service as Attender-cum-Sweeper.
11.
The
main
contention
of
the
learned
Additional Government Advocate for petitioners is that
the respondent was not appointed to a sanctioned
post and would not fulfill the criteria laid down by the
Hon'ble Apex Court in UMADEVI (supra). The post of
Attender-cum-Sweeper in sports school is one of the
essential post and as the respondent was continued
for this length of time i.e., more than 30 years, the
petitioners were in need of her service. Having taken
respondents service for these many years, at this
length of time, when the question of regularization
has cropped up, it is not open for the petitioners to
contend that respondent ahs no qualification, that too
a Group-‘D’ post of ‘Attender-cum-Sweeper’.
12.
The Tribunal taking note of the fact that
the respondent has completed more than 29 years
service and respondent has completed 10 years of
continuous service as on 06.07.2005 and taking note
of
the
continuance
of
the
respondent’s
service,
directed regularization. We do not find any error in the
facts and circumstances of the case.
13.
AND
The Hon'ble Apex Court in DHARM SINGH
OTHERS
(supra)
after
noticing
UMADEVI
(supra) and subsequent cases in the matter of
regularization at paragraph 13, 17 and 18, it observed
as follows:
“13. As
we
both Jaggo (Supra)
have
observed
in
and Shripal (Supra),
outsourcing cannot become a convenient shield
to perpetuate precariousness and to sidestep
fair engagement practices where the work is
inherently perennial. The Commission's further
contention that the appellants are not “fulltime” employees but continue only by virtue of
interim orders also does not advance their
case. That interim protection was granted
precisely
because
of
the
long
history
of
engagement and the pendency of the challenge
to the State's refusals. It neither creates rights
that did not exist nor erases entitlements that
may arise upon a proper adjudication of the
legality of those refusals.
17.
necessary
Before
to
concluding,
recall
that
we
the
think
State
it
(here
referring to both the Union and the State
governments) is not a mere market participant
but
a
constitutional
employer.
It
cannot
balance budgets on the backs of those who
perform the most basic and recurring public
functions. Where work recurs day after day
and year after year, the establishment must
reflect that reality in its sanctioned strength
and
engagement
practices.
The
long-term
extraction of regular labour under temporary
labels
corrodes
confidence
in
public
administration and offends the promise of
equal protection. Financial stringency certainly
has a place in public policy, but it is not a
talisman that overrides fairness, reason and
the duty to organise work on lawful lines.
Moreover, it must necessarily be
18.
noted
that
“ad-hocism”
administration
is
thrives
where
The
State
opaque.
Departments must keep and produce accurate
establishment
outsourcing
explain,
registers,
muster
arrangements,
with
evidence,
and
why
rolls
and
they
must
they
prefer
precarious engagement over sanctioned posts
where the work is perennial. If “constraint” is
invoked,
the
record
should
show
what
alternatives were considered, why similarly
placed workers were treated differently, and
how
the
chosen
course
Articles 14, 16 and 21 of
aligns
the Constitution
with
of
India. Sensitivity to the human consequences
of prolonged insecurity is not sentimentality. It
is a constitutional discipline that should inform
every decision affecting those who keep public
offices running.”
14.
A Co-ordinate Bench of this Court in the
case of SRI THYAGARAJU VS. THE STATE OF
KARNATAKA AND ANOTHER4 considering identical
contention
raised
by
the
petitioners/State,
at
paragraphs 21, 22, 23, 24 and 25 has held as follows:
“21. The contention of the State that
the appointment of the petitioner is contrary to
Article 14 and as the appointment of the
petitioner is contrary to Constitutional Scheme,
he would not be entitled for regularization is
untenable and cannot be countenanced. It is
too late in the day after having continued the
petitioner on temporary/daily wage basis for
more than 35 years, the contention that the
appointment of the petitioner is contrary to
Article
and
Constitutional
Scheme,
is
misplaced. It is not open at this length of time
for the State to contend that the petitioner’s
appointment is illegal.
It is for the State to
think and take a decision before appointing a
person on temporary basis.
A person who is
offered
daily
employment
on
wage
or
temporary basis would have no choice in the
days of unemployment and he would be
compelled to accept employment on temporary
W.P.No.3805/2023 DATED 14.07.2025
or daily wage basis due to pressing needs. The
State, after appointing a person on daily wage
or temporary basis, cannot be permitted at this
length
of
service
to
appointment
is
Constitutional
Scheme.
obligation
contend
contrary
that
his
to
Article
or
The
State
has
an
to
comply
Article
Constitutional
Scheme
before
and
making
appointment. Having made appointments even
to say contrary to Article 14 and Constitutional
Scheme, it cannot blame the employee for
accepting such employment, that too after 35
years.
22.
Learned
Additional
Government
Advocate places reliance on the decision in
UPENDRA SINGH (supra) to contend that a
daily wager who is appointed contrary to law is
not entitled for regularization. The decision in
UPENDRA SINGH (supra) places reliance on
the decision of the Hon'ble Apex Court in
UMADEVI (3) (supra). Paragraph 53 of the
UMADEVI
(3)
(supra)
provides
for
regularization of a daily/temporary employee
on certain circumstances, if he fulfills the
conditions
laid
down
therein.
Since
the
petitioner herein fulfills the criteria laid down
for regularization in UMADEVI (3) (supra),
the decision of the Hon'ble Apex Court in
UPENDRA SINGH (supra) would not be an
impediment
to
consider
the
case
of
the
petitioner for regularization. Moreover, based
on the facts, we have come to the conclusion
that the petitioner was appointed to a vacant
post of Hawaldar, as indicated in the order of
appointment dated 27.12.1984 (Annexure-A8).
23.
The Hon'ble Apex Court in the case
of STATE OF KARNATAKA AND OTHERS VS.
M.L.KESARI AND OTHERS5 explained its
earlier decision in UMADEVI (3) (supra), at
paragraphs 7, 8 and 11, which we reproduce
as follows:
“7. It is evident from the above that
there is an exception to the general
principles
against
“regularisation”
enunciated in Umadevi (3) [(2006) 4 SCC
1], if the following conditions are fulfilled:
(i) The employee concerned should
have worked for 10 years or more in duly
(2010) 9 SCC 247
sanctioned post without the benefit or
protection of the interim order of any
court or tribunal. In other words, the
State Government or its instrumentality
should have employed the employee and
continued him in service voluntarily and
continuously for more than ten years.
(ii) The appointment of such employee
should not be illegal, even if irregular.
Where the appointments are not made or
continued against sanctioned posts or
where
the
possess
persons
the
appointed
prescribed
do
not
minimum
qualifications, the appointments will be
considered to be illegal. But where the
person
employed
possessed
the
prescribed qualifications and was working
against sanctioned posts, but had been
selected without undergoing the process
of
open
competitive
appointments
are
selection,
considered
such
to
be
irregular.
8. Umadevi (3) [(2006) 4 SCC 1]
casts a duty upon the Government or
instrumentality concerned, to take steps
to
regularise
the
services
of
those
irregularly appointed employees who had
served for more than ten years without
the benefit or protection of any interim
orders of courts or tribunals, as a onetime
measure. Umadevi
(3) [(2006)
SCC
1]
such
directed
that
one-time
measure must be set in motion within six
months from the date of its decision
(rendered on 10-4-2006).
11.The
direction
object
behind
para
in
the
said
of Umadevi
(3) [(2006) 4 SCC 1] is twofold. First is to
ensure that those who have put in more
than
ten
years
of
continuous
service
without the protection of any interim
orders of courts or tribunals, before the
date of decision in Umadevi (3) [(2006) 4
SCC 1] was rendered, are considered for
regularisation in view of their long service.
Second
that
the
departments/instrumentalities
do
not
perpetuate
of
employing
daily-wage/ad
hoc/casual
persons
basis
is
on
for
to
the
long
ensure
practice
periods
and
then
periodically regularise them on the ground
that they have served for more than ten
years, thereby defeating the constitutional
or
statutory
provisions
relating
to
recruitment and appointment. The true
effect of the direction is that all persons
who have worked for more than ten years
as on 10-4-2006 [the date of decision
in Umadevi (3) [(2006) 4 SCC 1] ] without
the protection of any interim order of any
court
or
tribunal,
in
vacant
posts,
possessing the requisite qualification, are
entitled
to
be
considered
for
regularisation. The fact that the employer
has
not
undertaken
such
exercise
of
regularisation within six months of the
decision in Umadevi (3) [(2006) 4 SCC 1]
or that such exercise was undertaken only
in regard to
a
limited few, will
not
disentitle such employees, the right to be
considered for regularisation in terms of
the
above
directions
in Umadevi
(3) [(2006) 4 SCC 1] as a one-time
measure.”
24.
In the case of JAGGO VS. UNION
OF INDIA AND OTHERS6, the Hon'ble Apex
Court was considering the regularization of
part
time/contractual
employee
and
at
paragraphs 10, 12, 13, 14, 21 and 26, the
Hon'ble Apex Court has observed as follows:
“10.
Having
given
careful
consideration to the submissions advanced
and the material on record, we find that
the appellants' long and uninterrupted
service, for periods extending well beyond
ten years, cannot be brushed aside merely
by labelling their initial appointments as
part-time or contractual. The essence of
their employment must be considered in
the light of their sustained contribution,
the integral nature of their work, and the
fact that no evidence suggests their entry
was through any illegal or surreptitious
route.
12. Despite being labelled as “parttime workers,” the appellants performed
these essential tasks on a daily and
continuous basis over extensive periods,
2024 SCC OnLine SC 3826
ranging from over a decade to nearly two
decades.
Their
engagement
was
not
sporadic or temporary in nature; instead,
it was recurrent, regular, and akin to the
responsibilities typically associated with
sanctioned
posts.
Moreover,
the
respondents did not engage any other
personnel
for
appellants'
these
tenure,
tasks
during
the
underscoring
the
indispensable nature of their work.
13. The claim by the respondents
that these were not regular posts lacks
merit, as the nature of the work performed
by
the
appellants
was
perennial
and
fundamental to the functioning of the
offices. The recurring nature of these
duties necessitates their classification as
regular posts, irrespective of how their
initial engagements were labelled. It is
also
noteworthy
that
subsequent
outsourcing of these same tasks to private
agencies after the appellants' termination
demonstrates the inherent need for these
services. This act of outsourcing, which
effectively replaced one set of workers
with another, further underscores that the
work in question was neither temporary
nor occasional.
14. The abrupt termination of the
appellants' services, following dismissal of
their
Original
Application
before
the
Tribunal, was arbitrary and devoid of any
justification.
The
termination
letters,
issued without prior notice or explanation,
violated fundamental principles of natural
justice. It is a settled principle of law that
even contractual employees are entitled to
a fair hearing before any adverse action is
taken
against
them,
particularly
when
their service records are unblemished. In
this case, the appellants were given no
opportunity to be heard, nor were they
provided any reasons for their dismissal,
which followed nearly two decades of
dedicated service.
21. The High Court placed undue
emphasis
on
the
initial
label
of
the
appellants'
engagements
and
the
outsourcing
decision
after
their
taken
dismissal. Courts must look beyond the
surface labels and consider the realities of
employment:
continuous,
long-term
service, indispensable duties, and absence
of any mala fide or illegalities in their
appointments.
In
that
light,
refusing
regularization simply because their original
terms
did
because
not
an
explicitly
outsourcing
state
so,
policy
or
was
belatedly introduced, would be contrary to
principles of fairness and equity.
26. While
the
judgment
in Uma
Devi (supra) sought to curtail the practice
of
backdoor
entries
appointments
adhered
principles,
it
is
principles
are
often
and
to
ensure
constitutional
regrettable
that
its
misinterpreted
or
misapplied to deny legitimate claims of
long-serving employees. This judgment
aimed to distinguish between “illegal” and
“irregular” appointments. It categorically
held
that
employees
in
irregular
appointments, who were engaged in duly
sanctioned
posts
and
had
served
continuously for more than ten years,
should be considered for regularization as
a
one-time
measure.
However,
the
laudable intent of the judgment is being
subverted when institutions rely on its
dicta to indiscriminately reject the claims
of employees, even in cases where their
appointments are not illegal, but merely
lack adherence to procedural formalities.
Government departments often cite the
judgment in Uma Devi (supra) to argue
that no vested right to regularization
exists
for
overlooking
temporary
the
acknowledgment
employees,
judgment's
explicit
of
where
cases
regularization is appropriate. This selective
application distorts the judgment's spirit
and purpose, effectively weaponizing it
against employees who have rendered
indispensable services over decades.”
25.
petitioner
In the case on hand also, the
is
continued
on
daily
wage/temporary basis for nearly 35 years.
After
extracting
regular
work
from
the
petitioner, the action of the respondents in
rejecting
the
petitioner’s
request
for
regularization at this length of time is wholly
arbitrary,
unreasonable
and
unfair
and
opposed to Article 21 of the Constitution of
India.
The above decision of the Co-ordinate Bench would
aptly apply to the facts of the present case also.
15.
We do not find any merit in the writ
petition. Accordingly, writ petition stands rejected.
Sd/(S.G.PANDIT)
JUDGE
Sd/(K.V.ARAVIND)
JUDGE
NC
CT: bms
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review