The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
27. Under the said circumstance, we are of the considered view that the disciplinary proceeding against the writ petitioner was not conducted in due compliance of the principles of natural justice. Since writ petitioner has already retired from service in the year 2022, the learned Single Judge has rightly not remanded the matter to the disciplinary authority to rehear the writ petitioner after serving him the second show cause notice along with copy of the inquiry report.
28. The present Letters Patent Appeal being devoid of merit is, accordingly, dismissed.
29. Pending interlocutory application(s), if any, is also dismissed. (M.S. Sonak, C.J.) (Rajesh Shankar, J.) 30th June, 2026 Rohit Uploaded on 30.06.2026
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:18999-DB
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
L.P.A. No.01 of 2025
----1. The State of Jharkhand.
2.
The Director General of Police, Jharkhand Police Head Quarters,
P.O. & P.S. Dhurwa, District-Ranchi, Jharkhand.
3.
The Deputy Inspector General of Police, Singhbhum (Kolhan)
Range, Chaibasa, P.O. & P.S. Chaibasa, District West Singhbhum.
4.
The Superintendent of Police, Chaibasa, P.O. & P.S. Chaibasa,
District West Singhbhum.
5.
Deputy Superintendent of Police, Chaibasa, P.O. & P.S. Chaibasa,
District West Singhbhum.
..........Appellants.
-VersusUmesh Kumar Singh, son of Late Tarkeshwar Singh, resident of
village-Rupas, Nirpur, P.O. Ramnagar, Karari Kaihhar, P.S.
Athmalgola, Barh, District Patna (Bihar).
........... Respondent
----CORAM :
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJESH SHANKAR
----For the Appellants :
Mr. Kumar Rahul Kamlesh, S.C.-IV
For the Respondents:
----Reserved on 22.06.2026
Pronounced on 30.06.2026
Per: Rajesh Shankar, J.
I.A No.13819 of 2024:
1.
The present interlocutory application has been filed on behalf of
the appellants seeking condonation of delay of 163 days in
instituting the instant appeal.
2.
The reasons assigned in the present interlocutory application is
found sufficient for condoning the aforesaid delay.
3.
Accordingly, the delay of 163 days in instituting the instant appeal
is hereby condoned.
2026:JHHC:18999-DB
4.
I.A. No.13819 of 2024 stands disposed of.
L.P.A. No.01 of 2025:
5.
The present Letters Patent Appeal is directed against the
order/judgment dated 16.05.2024 passed in W.P.(S) No. 6549 of
2012 whereby the learned Single Judge has allowed the said writ
petition filed by the writ petitioner/respondent quashing and
setting aside the order passed by the disciplinary authority vide
Memo No. 2951 dated 31.08.2011 as well as the orders passed by
the appellate and revisional authorities vide Memo No.501 dated
10.05.2012 and Memo No. 289 dated 09.10.2012 respectively. It
has further been directed to extend the consequential benefits to
the writ petitioner upon quashment of the punishment order.
6.
The factual background of the case as stated in the writ petition is
that the writ petitioner had joined the service on 04.08.1989 as
Sub-Inspector (Direct Recruitment). He was posted as the Incharge of Muffasil Police Station, Chaibasa at the relevant point of
time in the year 2010. On 07.05.2010, an F.I.R. being Muffasil P.S.
Case No.45/2010 was lodged under Sections 353, 186, 506,
504/34, 414, 379, 120-B Indian Penal Code and Sections 4 and 5
of the Mines Act.
7.
In the said case, seven trucks were seized by the police. One
Dinesh Kumar (hereinafter referred as the complainant) filed
petition
for
release
of
two
trucks
bearing
registration
nos.JH10G5897 & BR2F3855 and the learned Chief Judicial
Magistrate, Chaibasa sought report from the investigating officer
2026:JHHC:18999-DB
of the case, however, the said report was not submitted in the
court within the stipulated time.
8.
According to the complainant, he met the Officer-in-Charge/writpetitioner, who
told
the
complainant
to
satisfy
the Investigating Officer of the case for sending the report to the
court. The complainant gave Rs.4,500/- to the Investigating
Officer, however, the report was not sent. The investigating officer
demanded Rs. 10,000/- for sending the report which was refused
by the complainant and he asked back Rs.4,500/- from the
Investigating Officer, however, the Investigating Officer neither
sent the report to the court nor returned the said amount.
9.
Thereafter, the complainant made a written complaint to the
Superintendent of Police, West Singhbhum, Chaibasa whereupon
an inquiry was conducted by the Deputy Superintendent of Police,
West Singhbhum, Chaibasa submitting a report with respect to
allegation of the complainant against the writ petitioner as true.
Thereafter, a departmental proceeding was initiated against the
writ petitioner and a memo of charge was issued to him alleging
that the investigating officer had demanded Rs.10,000/- from the
complainant with the consent of the writ petitioner.
10. The Sub-Divisional Police Officer, Chakradharpur was appointed as
the conducting/inquiry officer who issued show cause notices to
the writ petitioner on different dates, however, he did not
participate in the inquiry. Finally, the inquiry officer submitted the
inquiry report on 12.08.2011 finding the charges against the writ
petitioner
proved.
The
disciplinary
authority
i.e.,
the
2026:JHHC:18999-DB
Superintendent of Police, West Singhbhum, Chaibasa agreed with
the finding of the inquiry officer and passed the order of
punishment as contained in Memo No.2951 dated 31.08.2011
withholding one annual increment of the writ petitioner equivalent
to two black marks. It was further ordered that the writ petitioner
was not to be paid any additional amount except the subsistence
allowance during the suspension period.
11. The writ petitioner preferred appeal on 28.02.2012 before the
Deputy Inspector General of Police, Singhbhum, (Kolhan) Range,
Chaibasa, however, the same was dismissed vide order dated
10.05.2012. Thereafter, the petitioner preferred revision before
the Director General-cum-Inspector
General
of Police
on
21.05.2012, which was also dismissed on 09.10.2012.
12. Being aggrieved, the writ petitioner filed a writ petition being
W.P.(S) No.6549 of 2012 which has been allowed by the learned
Single Judge of this Court vide impugned order dated 16.05.2024
observing that mandatory second show cause notice along with
the copy of inquiry repot was not served to the writ petitioner
before inflicting the penalty.
13. The learned counsel for the appellants submits that the learned
Single Judge has failed to appreciate that the inquiry officer had
provided ample opportunities to the writ petitioner for submitting
his reply against the charges framed, however, he deliberately and
intentionally did not respond to the same.
2026:JHHC:18999-DB
14. It is submitted that there are no procedural lapses in conducting
the departmental proceeding, rather the same has been done
strictly in accordance with law.
15. It is further submitted that co-delinquent namely Manohar Jharian
Minz (Investigating Officer) had confessed his guilt before the
Superintendent of Police, West Singhbhum, Chaibasa and had also
supported the charges levelled against the writ petitioner.
16. It is also contended that since the writ petitioner himself did not
choose to participate in the inquiry conducted by the inquiry
officer, no prejudice can be said to have caused to him by not
serving the second show cause notice.
17. Heard the learned counsel for the appellants and perused the
materials available on record.
18. It is an undisputed fact that the second show cause notice along
with copy of the inquiry report was not served to the writ petitioner
before imposing major penalty upon him.
19. Thrust of the argument of the learned counsel for the appellants
is that there was no need to serve second show cause notice along
with copy of the inquiry report to the writ petitioner since he did
not choose to participate in the inquiry proceeding despite
issuance of repeated notices to him. It is further contended that a
departmental proceeding does not vitiate on mere ground of not
serving a copy of the inquiry report to the delinquent employee
unless it is shown as to what prejudice has been caused to him by
the said non-service on the part of the employer.
2026:JHHC:18999-DB
20. To appreciate the said contention of the learned counsel for the
appellants, it would be profitable to refer herein the judgment of
the Hon’ble Supreme Court rendered in the case of Managing
Director, ECIL & Others Vs. B. Karunakar & Others
reported in (1993) 4 SCC 727 wherein it has been held that
non-supply of a copy of the report of the inquiry officer to the
employee facing a disciplinary proceeding, amounts to denial of
natural justice. However, in the later part of the judgment, it has
been observed that the factual issue of prejudice caused to the
employee on account of non-furnishing of a copy of the inquiry
report has to be considered in the facts of each case. It has been
also observed that where furnishing of the inquiry report does not
make any difference to the ultimate outcome of the matter, it
would be a perversion of justice to allow the employee concerned
to resume his duties and to get all consequential benefits.
21. Now, the question falls for consideration of this Court is as to
whether any prejudice was caused to the writ petitioner by not
serving a copy of the inquiry report to him?
22. It is evident from the inquiry report that not a single witness was
examined or cross-examined before the inquiry officer to prove the
charges against the writ petitioner. Even the complainant was not
examined during the inquiry proceeding and the petitioner was
found guilty by the inquiry officer only relying upon the documents
produced before him.
23. In the case of Roop Singh Negi Vs. Punjab National Bank
and Others reported in (2009) 2 SCC 570, the fact was that
2026:JHHC:18999-DB
the management had only tendered the documents on which they
had relied upon without examining witnesses to prove the said
documents. The Hon’ble Apex Court has held that a departmental
proceeding is a quasi-judicial proceeding and the inquiry officer
performs a quasi-judicial function. The charges levelled against the
delinquent officer must be found to have been proved. The inquiry
officer has a duty to arrive at a finding upon taking into
consideration the materials brought on record by the parties.
Moreover, the purported evidence collected during investigation of
a criminal case by the investigating officer against all the accused
by itself cannot be treated to be evidence in the disciplinary
proceeding.
24. We are of the considered view that though the writ petitioner failed
to attend the inquiry proceeding, the inquiry officer was duty
bound to examine at least the complainant on the basis of whose
complaint, the departmental proceeding was initiated against the
writ petitioner. Thus, non-examination of the complainant during
the departmental proceeding is an inexcusable lapse and has
certainly caused serious prejudice to the writ petitioner.
25. The purpose of furnishing a copy of the inquiry report to the
delinquent employee is not a mere formality, it is rather aimed to
provide him an opportunity to meet the reasoning given in the said
report and to controvert the conclusion reached by the inquiry
officer. Unless the copy of the inquiry report is supplied to the
delinquent, he would not be in a position to know as to whether
the finding recorded by the inquiry officer is supported by any
2026:JHHC:18999-DB
material or is based with no evidence. Had the writ petitioner been
given an opportunity to respond to the inquiry report, he could
have raised the issue before the disciplinary authority regarding
serious lapses committed by the inquiry officer. The denial of
supply of the copy of inquiry report, therefore, has caused a grave
prejudice to the writ petitioner.
26. Thus, we do not find any substance in the contention of the
appellants that no prejudice has been caused to the writ petitioner
by not serving him the second show cause notice along with copy
of the inquiry report.
27. Under the said circumstance, we are of the considered view that
the disciplinary proceeding against the writ petitioner was not
conducted in due compliance of the principles of natural justice.
Since writ petitioner has already retired from service in the year
2022, the learned Single Judge has rightly not remanded the
matter to the disciplinary authority to rehear the writ petitioner
after serving him the second show cause notice along with copy
of the inquiry report.
28. The present Letters Patent Appeal being devoid of merit is,
accordingly, dismissed.
29. Pending interlocutory application(s), if any, is also dismissed.
(M.S. Sonak, C.J.)
(Rajesh Shankar, J.)
30th June, 2026
A.F.R.
Rohit
Uploaded on 30.06.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review